Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
WBCHCA0477882026
Item Nos.1 & 2
Ct. No.1
RP
IN THE HIGH COURT AT CALCUTTA
CONSTITUTIONAL WRIT JURISDICTION
APPELLATE SIDE
WP.CT 212 of 2026
1) UNION OF INDIA through the Secretary, Ministry of
Communication and IT, Department of Posts, Dak Bhawan
New Delhi-110001.
2) THE DIRECTOR GENERAL, Department of Posts,
Dak Bhawan, New Delhi-110001.
3) THE CHIEF POSTMASTER GENERAL, WB Circle,
Yogayog Bhawan, C.R. Avenue, Kolkata-700012.
4) THE POSTMASTER GENERAL, South Bengal Region,
Office of the Chief Postmaster General, WB Circle,
Yogayog Bhawan, Kolkata-700012.
5) THE POSTMASTER GENERAL, South Bengal Region,
Yogayog Bhawan, C.R. Avenue, Kolkata-700012.
6) THE POSTMASTER GENERAL, North Bengal & Sikkim
Region Siliguri, District: Darjeeling, PIN-734001.
7) THE DIRECTOR OF POSTAL SERVICE (HQ),
Office of the Chief Postmaster General, WB Circle,
Yogayog Bhawan, Kolkata-700012.
versus
1) SUSANTA PAUL CHOUDHURY,
]…. PETITIONERS
son of Late Durga Pada Paul Choudhury, aged about 62 years
Ex-Pa (SBCO) Kolkata GPO, residing at Orchid Enclave-16,
Sarat Bose Road, Subhas Nagar, Kolkata-700065.
2) AJIT KUMAR ROY
son of Late Dhirendra Nath Ray, aged about 62 years,
Ex-Pa (SBCO) Park Street HPO, residing at Block-B,
Flat No.3A, Balaka Green Apartment, Sardarpara, Kaikhali,
Kolkata-700052.
3) DAKSHINESWAR MAJHI,
son of Late Prahalad Majhi, aged about 62 years,
Ex-Pa (SBCO), Asansol HPO, residing at Village & PO-Sankar,
District: Purulia, PIN-742101.
4) SHYAMAPADA KARMAKAR
son of Late Amar Ch. Karmakar, aged about 62 years,
Ex-Pa/SBCO, Durgapur HPO, residing at Village-Shaklara,
PO-Amarkanan, District-Bankura, PIN-722155.
5) SAMIR KUMAR DAS-II
son of late Sisir Ranjan Das, aged about 62 years,
Ex-Pa/SBCO, Bankura HPO, residing at Village-Nabapally
P.O. Kenduadihi, District-Bankura, PIN-722101.
6) RANJIT KUMAR BAIDYA
son of Late Jatindra Nath Baidya, aged about 67 years,
Ex-Pa/SBCO, Diamond Harbour HPO, residing at Village-Kanpur,
P.O.Hatugang, District: South 24 Parganas, PIN-743331.
] ..RESPONDENTS
With
WP.CT 553 of 2005
UNION OF INDIA & ORS.
]..PETITIONERS
VS.
RANJIT KUSUM CHOUDHURY & ORS.
]..RESPONDENTS
Appearance:
Mr. Pinaki Ranjan Chakraborty
Ms. Amrita Pandey
Mr. Kalyan Sarkar
…..Advocates for Petitioners
…..Advocate for Respondents
CORAM: RAVINDRA VITHALRAO GHUGE,
CHIEF JUSTICE
&
OM NARAYAN RAI, J.
Date: 07.10.2026
Judgment (Per Ravindra V Ghuge, CJ)
1.
Rule. Rule made returnable forthwith and heard finally by
the consent of the parties.
2.
The Petitioners before us are the Union of India and the
Department of Posts. Respondents before us are six Employees, who are
Original Applicants before the Learned Central Administrative Tribunal,
Kolkata bench, in OA 350/334/2019, which was decided by the impugned
order dated 01.04.2026.
3.
The Petitioners have put forth prayer Clause 18(a) as under:-
“a.
Issue a writ/order/direction and/or to set aside and/or quash the
order dated 01.04.2026 passed in O.A. 350/334/2019 (Susanta Paul
Choudhury & Ors. vs. Union of India & Ors.) passed by the Learned
Central Administrative Tribunal, Kolkata Bench”
4.
We find that this case rests purely on facts, which are
summarised as under:a)
The Applicants were working on the post of Lower Division
Clerk/Upper Division Clerk, which was subsequently nomenclatured as
Postal Assistants and formed a separate category introduced by the
Department of Posts.
b)
The said department introduced a Time Bound One Promotion
scheme (in short ‘TBOP’) on 30.11.1983. According to the said scheme,
an employee was entitled to receive an increment to the next higher scale
by way of one TBOP non-functional promotion after completion of 16
years of service as LDC/UDC or Postal Assistant/UDC, taken together.
c)
Subsequently, the Department of Posts introduced a Biennial Cadre
Review (in short, ‘BCR’) Scheme with effect from 11.10.1991. This
scheme was applicable to those, who were already covered by TBOP and
after completing a total of 26 years, meaning 10 years after receiving
TBOP. The rise in the pay scale was also prescribed. For clarity, the
TBOP higher scale was Rs.1400-2300 and the BCR Pay Scale was an
enhancement to Rs.1600-2660.
d)
The benefits of both these schemes were not co-related to or
dependent upon the Seniority-Juniority of any Employee. The benefits
were available only on completion of 16 years and further 10 years in
service.
5.
It is, thus, apparent from the above details of the scheme that
both these schemes have nothing to do with seniority or juniority of any
person. In short, even if a candidate was junior most in the hierarchy, but
on completion of 16 years, would be eligible for the TBOP benefit,
notwithstanding his juniority. Similarly after the said candidate put in 10
more years, post receiving TBOP scheme benefits, he would be entitled to
the next higher pay scale under the BCR Scheme.
BACKGROUND HISTORY OF THIS CASE
6.
The reasons leading to the delivery of the impugned
judgement are based upon orders passed earlier by the Tribunal and this
Court.
7.
There were two employees, namely, Smt. Uma Biswas and
Smt. Aruna Banerjee, who were granted benefits of BCR Scheme after
completing 26 years in service, by putting together their earlier service
with another government department. These two candidates were not
arrayed as Respondents before the Tribunal. Smt. Uma Biswas was also
an LDC and later an UDC, who entered the Postal Department on transfer
under a scheme from the Telecom Department. Rule 38 of the ‘Postal
Manual Volume IV’, admittedly permits such inter-department transfer,
subject to the condition that the person voluntarily seeking such a transfer
would be relegated to the junior most level in the seniority list amongst
the Employees falling in the same category like LDC or UDC. Similarly
is the case of Smt. Aruna Banerjee.
8.
Smt. Uma Biswas and Smt. Aruna Banerjee, after completing
16 years, were held to be eligible for the TBOP Scheme. It is pertinent to
note, inasmuch as, it is nobody’s case, much less a disputed case, that
under Rule 38 of Postal Manual Volume 4, a candidate seeking transfer
for personal convenience from one department to another department of
Government of India, was only to lose his/her seniority after joining the
other department. Such a candidate was not liable to lose his number of
years of service put in with the erstwhile Government of India
Department.
In short, neither Smt. Uma Biswas, nor Smt. Aruna Banerjee were liable
to lose their number of years put in with the Telecom Department. When
the Rules do not prescribe such loss in number of years of employment, as
if the transferred candidate is to start as a fresher, by no interpretation can
such a conclusion be drawn that these candidates would stand to loss their
earlier tenure of employment in the Telecom Department.
Even the
Tribunal did not draw this conclusion.
OUR ANALYSIS AND CONCLUSIONS
9.
Having considered the submissions of the learned Counsel
for the respective sides at length and on perusing the record available
before us threadbare, in the light of the judgments cited, we find that
following factors were lost sight of by the Tribunal and were also not
taken into account by a Co-ordinate bench of this Court, in the order cited
before us :a)
TBOP and BCR Scheme were ‘tenure centric’, meaning depended
upon the time when a candidate completed 16 years of service to be
eligible for TBOP benefits and a further tenure of 10 years for being
eligible for BCR benefits.
b)
TBOP and BCR were ‘not seniority centric’, meaning that even if
a candidate was last in the seniority list, but was eligible for the benefit of
TBOP after completing 16 years and BCR after completing 10 further
years, there was no embargo or impediment for grant of such benefits to
such a candidate.
c)
On transfer of a candidate from one Government of India
Department to the other Government of India Department, by virtue of
Rule 38 of the Postal Manual Volume IV, he/she would not lose his
number of years put in service in the earlier Government of India
Department.
d)
It is undisputed that Smt. Uma Biswas and Smt. Aruna Banerjee
had completed 16 years and further 10 years and had became eligible for
TOBP and BCR scheme benefit.
e)
The only reason for the Original Applicants to approach the
Tribunal was that they propagated the theory of juniority/seniority and
complained that because Smt. Uma Biswas and Smt. Aruna Banerjee were
junior to the Applicants after their transfer from the Telecom Department
to the Postal Department, and had got the benefits of TBOP and BCR
Scheme, these Applicants should be paid the same pay scales on the
principle of ‘stepping-up’.
The Tribunal was impressed by the
contentions of the Applicants that TBOP/BCR Scheme was interlinked
with the juniority/seniority of employees.
10.
The Learned Advocate for the Applicants have relied upon an
order passed by a Co-ordinate bench of this Court on 23.08.2025 in
WPCT 553 of 2005. We have called for the file in WPCT 553 of 2005 by
orders dated 30.09.2026 and 01.10.2026, since we wanted to go through
the said order. We find that the details of the said case have not been
narrated in the said order, which is a short order. The law laid down by
the Hon’ble Supreme Court vide its Judgment dated 09.10.2002 in Union
of India & Ors. vs. Leelamma Jacob & Ors., (2003) 12 SCC 280, was
referred to. But the Department had sought time to implement the order of
the Tribunal dated 16.08.2004 passed in OA 1148 of 2003. Hence, the
Petition was disposed off. As such, it is apparent that the said Petition was
disposed off by a consenting order dated 23.08.2005.
11.
In view of the order passed by the Tribunal, the Department
approached the Hon’ble Supreme Court by filing SLP No.18019 of 2006
and the Hon’ble Supreme Court dismissed the SLP vide order dated
13.09.2010, recording that the order of the Tribunal/High Court would not
be treated as a precedent for any other purpose. Moreover, we noticed
from the said proceedings that the Union of India volunteered to
implement the order of the Tribunal and the Writ Petition was disposed off
by this Court which makes it a consenting order.
12.
This brings us to the Judgment delivered by the Hon’ble
Supreme Court in Leelamma Jacob (supra) which is heavily relied upon
by Original Applicants before us. Having perused the judgment, we find
that the Hon’ble Supreme Court dealt with the determination of seniority
and length of service for the purpose of promotion from basic Grade-1 to
the next Grade-2 under the Statutory Rules, based on the departmental
examination held in 1981.
13.
While dealing with the said case the Hon’ble Supreme Court
noted that the benefit under the BCR would entitle the candidate to the
higher basic grade, after he/she had continued in regular service for 26
years and would have been entitled to promotion.
By virtue of
OTBP/BCR scheme, approval/fixation of the pay scale was made by
taking into account that the candidate was eligible for the OTBP/BCR
Scheme.
14.
The complaining candidates before the Hon’ble Supreme
Court had contended that the beneficiaries of the BCR scheme, though
junior to them in Grade-II, were promoted to Grade-III at higher scale of
pay. The Hon’ble Supreme Court concluded that the BCR scheme, by
virtue of which seniority attained by the Respondents on being promoted
in 1981, was taken away, which was violative of the existing rules and
was liable to be set aside. In the present case before us, no seniority has
been changed by extending the monetary benefits to Smt. Biswas and Smt.
Banerjee.
15.
It is, thus apparent that the facts in Leelamma Jacob (supra)
are completely distinguishable and different from the facts before us. The
Applicants before the Tribunal complained that because Smt. Uma Biswas
and Smt. Aruna Banerjee were given the benefits of BCR after completing
26 years, though those Applicants may not have completed 26 years when
those two candidates logged 26 years, they should be held entitled for the
benefits of BCR even before completing 26 years, by applying the
‘stepping-up’ principle.
16.
For ready reference, we are reproducing the chart which was
reproduced by the Union of India in its written statement/reply before the
Tribunal, as under:SL
NO.
NAME
DATE
ENTRY
LDC
1.
Dakhineswar Majhi
20.09.1982
LDC
20.09.98
2.
Samir Kumar Das
27.12.1982
LDC
27.12.98
3.
Shyamapada Karmakar
27.12.1982
LDC
27.12.98
4.
Ajit Kumar Roy
07.08.1981
LDC
07.08.97
5.
Susanta Paul Chowdhury
08.08.1981
LDC
08.08.97
6.
Ranjit Kumar Baidya
20.10.1978
LDC
20.10.94
7.
Uma Biswas
27.06.1973 as LDC
telephone
operator
in
Telecom
Department/
Transferred
under rule 38 on
01.11.83
as
LDC in the
Deptt.
01.08.91
17.
OF DESIGNATION POSITION IN REMARKS
AS PRIOR TO 1991 THE GR. LIST
CORRECTED
UPTO
01.07.2007
In view of the above chart, it is apparent that Smt. Uma
Biswas had joined as a Telephone Operator on 27.06.1973. Amongst
those Applicants before the Tribunal, Ranjit Kumar Baidya had joined on
20.10.1978. The other five had joined in 1981 and 1982. Smt. Uma
Biswas was an LDC. These six applicants were also LDC. Smt. Uma
Biswas became eligible for the TBOP benefit on 1.8.1991. The other six
Applicants became eligible for TBOP scheme on the dates mentioned in
the above reproduced chart, in 1994, 1997 and 1998.
However, the
peculiar twist in this case is that the Union of India granted TBOP benefit
to these Applicants prematurely, because of some orders passed by the
Tribunal in other matters, concluding on the principle of stepping-up,
oblivious of the fact that such a comparison could not have been made.
18.
Now, the question before us is as to whether those Applicants
who have received extra payments equivalent to the benefits of TBOP and
BCR, prematurely, should be subjected to recovery. The admitted position
is that the Original Applicants were already paid the benefit of BCR,
prematurely. Consequently, their pay scale went up to Rs.1600-2660,
which is the maximum available at the stroke of completing 26 years in
employment. It appears from the record that these Applicants got the
benefit of BCR even before they were eligible for the benefit of TBOP,
meaning thereby that they received the monetary benefits prior to
completing even 16 years.
19.
What surprises us is that the Learned Tribunal has blindly
followed the earlier orders passed by the earlier Bench of the Tribunal,
without even going into the details of the case. The fact situation which
we have discussed in the foregoing paragraphs, should have been
considered and discussed by the Tribunal. Be that as it may, having not so
done, we have done the exercise and we find that those Applicants should
not have been given the benefits when they were not eligible under the
said two schemes, rather, they have already received the benefits
prematurely even before completing 16/26 years. It is under fortuitous
circumstances that they received such benefits.
20.
Apparently,
Applicants
are
labouring
under
the
misconception that TBOP and BCR Schemes were related to seniority of a
candidate, much to the contrary. The scheme itself indicates that there is
no issue of seniority involved, save and except, that a candidate
completing 16 years was eligible for getting the benefits of the TBOP
Scheme and on completing further 10 years in continuity, for receiving the
BCR Scheme benefits.
21.
The Learned Advocate for the Petitioners has relied on an
order dated 08.07.2014 passed by another co-ordinate Bench of this Court
in the WPCT 104 of 2014 (Union of India & Ors. vs. Rabindra Nath
Modak & Ors.). Even in the said order, the case canvassed before this
Court was about getting the benefits of the scheme based on the seniority
aspect. It is quite unusual that the Union of India did not point out to our
co-ordinate Bench dealing with Rabindra Nath Modak (supra), that the
benefits of TBOP and BCR schemes were related to completing 16 years
and 26 years as LDC, and had nothing to do with the inter-se seniority
amongst the candidates. As such, the said order in Rabindra Nath Modak
(supra) is clearly distinguishable on facts, which have been discussed by
us in this Judgment.
22.
In view of the above, this Petition is partly allowed. The
Impugned Judgment and the Order of the Tribunal dated 01.04.2026
passed in OA No.350/334/2019, is quashed and set aside.
23.
However, we need to consider that the Original Applicants,
incorrectly and inadvertently have been granted the maximum benefits
available on completion of 26 years, even before completing 16 years in
employment, under fortuitous circumstances.
The money has already
been paid to them. They were not at fault in orchestrating such payment.
There is no allegation of fraud or involvement of these Applicants in
facilitating premature payment of TBOP and BCR benefits, at the stroke
of completing 16 years or even there before, as the case may be.
Therefore, we are deem it appropriate to rely upon the law laid down by
the Hon’ble Supreme Court in Syed Abdul Qadir vs. State of Bihar,
(2009) 3 SCC 475 and the State of Punjab & Ors. vs. Rafique Masih
(White Washer), (2015) 4 SCC 334, and we direct the Petitioners not to
recover those amount from any of these Applicants.
Since all these
Applicants have now superannuated and they have received the maximum
benefits and have also completed 26 years in employment, no further
action is required to be initiated by the Petitioners. We are, therefore,
giving a quietus to this matter.
24.
Rule is made partly absolute in above terms.
25.
Pending Civil Application, if any, would not survive and
stands disposed off.
(OM NARAYAN RAI, J.)
(RAVINDRA V. GHUGE)
Chief Justice
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review