Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Page No.# 1/9
GAHC010259162017
2026:GAU-AS:11766
THE GAUHATI HIGH COURT
(HIGH COURT OF ASSAM, NAGALAND, MIZORAM AND ARUNACHAL PRADESH)
Case No. : WP(C)/3723/2017
NOBIN KUMAR CHAKMA
S/O JAGADISH CHAKMA R/O FLAT NO. 2, 2ND FLOOR, RASHMI ENCLAVE,
SATGAON ROAD, PATHARQUARY, GUWAHATI
VERSUS
THE UNION OF INDIA and 4 ORS.
REP. BY THE HOME SECRETARY, MINISTRY OF HOME AFFAIRS, NORTH
BLOCK, NEW DELHI-110001.
2:THE DIRECTOR GENERAL OF THE CRPF
AN ORGANISATION UNDER THE MINISTRY OF HOME AFFAIRS
HEADQUARTER AT NEW DELHI.
3:THE IGP
DEPARTMENTAL REHABILITATION BOARD OF BIHAR SECTOR- 2015
PATNA
4:THE COMMANDANT
11BN
CENTRAL RESERVE POLICE FORCE
LATEHAR
JHARKAND.
5:THE DEPUTY POLICE INSPECTOR
GROUP CENTRE
9TH MILE
AMERIGOG
GUWAHATI -23
Page No.# 2/9
Advocate for the Petitioner : MR.S K MEDHI, P HAZARIKA,MR P BHARDWAJ,MR.A
DAS,MR.R BAISHYA,MR.S R RABHA
Advocate for the Respondent : C.G.C., ASSTT.S.G.I.,MR.K K PARASAR(R- 1 to 5)
BEFORE
HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE KAUSHIK GOSWAMI
ORDER
18.08.2026
Heard Mr. P Bhardwaj, learned counsel for the petitioner. Also heard Mr. K K
Parashar, learned CGC for the respondents.
2.
By way of this petition under Article 226 of the Constitution of India, the
petitioner is assailing the impugned order of termination dated 04.05.2017 issued by
the Commandant, 11th Battalion, CRPF, Latehar, Jharkhand, whereby the service of
the petitioner as Constable (GD) in the CRPF came to be terminated.
3.
The brief facts of the case are that pursuant to the selection process for
appointment to the post of Constable (GD) in the CRPF, the petitioner submitted his
candidature and participated in the selection process, including the written
examination and interview. He was also medically examined and, thereafter, was duly
appointed as Constable (GD) in the CRPF on 22.11.2014. The petitioner joined the
11th Battalion of the CRPF at Guwahati and was thereafter sent to Latur in the State
of Maharashtra for undergoing training for a period of one year. Upon completion of
his training, the petitioner was posted at F/11 BN, Central Reserve Police Force,
located at Block Colony, Latehar, Jharkhand.
While serving at the aforesaid place of posting, the petitioner was served with a
show-cause notice dated 05.04.2017, whereby he was called upon to show cause as
to why his services should not be terminated on the ground that he had been
Page No.# 3/9
detected to be suffering from colour blindness. The petitioner submitted his reply on
03.05.2017. However, on the very next day, i.e. 04.05.2017, the respondents issued
the impugned order terminating his services. Aggrieved thereby, the present writ
petition has been filed.
4.
Mr. Bharadwaj, learned counsel appearing for the petitioner, submits that the
petitioner, having been detected to be colour blind only after he had already served for
almost two years since his appointment, ought not to have been boarded out from
service. According to the learned counsel, the petitioner could have been retained and
his services utilised against some other post where colour blindness would not
constitute an impediment in the nature of duties required to be performed. It is
contended that termination of the petitioner’s service, without exploring such an
alternative, is unjustified.
5.
Per contra, Mr. K. K. Parashar, learned CGC appearing for the respondents,
submits that, at present, not a single post in the CRPF can be treated as a noncombatant post. It is submitted that even personnel performing ordinary functions are
mandatorily required to undergo arms training so that, in the event of any emergency,
they can be called upon to perform combatant duties. He further submits that under
the policy guidelines dated 27.02.2013 issued by the Ministry of Home Affairs, colour
blindness is a mandatory disqualification for recruitment as well as retention in the
CRPF in respect of personnel recruited after the said policy came into force. The
petitioner, having been appointed subsequent thereto and having himself furnished an
undertaking agreeing to be boarded out if found to be colour blind at any stage of his
service career, cannot now seek to challenge the consequence prescribed under the
said policy.
6.
I have given my thoughtful consideration to the submissions advanced by the
learned counsel for the parties and have also perused the materials available on
record.
Page No.# 4/9
7.
It appears that the Government of India, Ministry of Home Affairs, by order
dated 27.02.2013, issued new policy guidelines on recruitment/retention in respect of
personnel of the Central Armed Police Forces (CAPFs) and Assam Rifles (AR) having
defective vision, including colour blindness.
8.
The aforesaid policy guidelines read as under:
“F.No.I-45024/1/2008-Pers.II
Government of India / Bharat Sarkar
Ministry of Home Affairs / Grih Mantralaya (Police-II Division)
North Block, New Delhi - 01
Dated, the 27th Feb. 2013
ORDER
Subject: New Policy Guidelines on recruitment/ retention in respect of Central
Armed Police Forces (CAPFs) and Assam Rifles (ARs) personnel having defective
vision including colour blindness- regarding.
The standing policy of the Government is that only persons who are fully fit in
all respects i.e. in SHAPE-I are to be recruited to the CAPFs and ARs. It is and
has always been the standing policy of the Government that if any member of
the CAPFS & AR is declared permanently unfit while in service, he is boarded
out from service. The reasons for this are very clear. The personnel of the CAPFs
& AR are issued with lethal weapons and are expected to use lethal force
against insurgents and terrorists. If any of the personnel of the CAPFS & AR is
not fully fit, he will either not be able to protect himself or his colleagues in a
battle with insurgents/terrorists. groups or he will run the risk of killing
innocent people especially if his eyesight is weak and he cannot distinguish
between uniform etc. The policy of boarding out personnel who had been
declared unfit applies to all types of unfitness whether it be unfitness in
physical parameters or in any other SHAPE component and that is how it
should have remained. However, in the years 1991, 1997, 2002, 2008, 2011
and 2012, various orders were issued saying that those who had been
recruited prior to a particular date and were found to be colour blind at a later
stage, would not be boarded out while those recruited after the date would be
boarded out. This marked a departure / an exception from the standing policy
and this departure/ exception was not in the public interest- these departures
were also bad in law because no policy could apply retrospectively. For the
Page No.# 5/9
above reasons, it has been decided as follows:i)
The circular/orders/instructions issued by the Ministry of Home Affairs or
by any of the Central Armed Police Force (CAPF) & Assam Rifle (AR) vide
communication No.R.II-31/91-EC-II dated 16.5.1991, No. R.II-31/97-EC-II dated
12.6.1997, No.1-45020/52/2001-Pers-II dated 17.5.2002, No.I-45024/1/2008Pers-II dated 29.10.2008, No.45024/1/2008-Pers-II dated 11.3.2011 and
No.45024/1/2008-Pers-II dated 08.12.2011 are withdrawn with immediate
effect. Further, any reference to the colour blindness especially Para- 5 & 6
including those for the gazetted officers contained in New Visual Standard
Policy No.I-45024/1/2008-Pers-II dated 18.5.2012 also stands withdrawn with
immediate effect.
(ii)
Any person who has defective vision or is colour blind will not be
recruited future. If any person is wrongly recruited despite having defect in
vision or despite being color blind he will be promptly removed from service as
soon as the defect is noticed. The Doctor who declared him fit will be proceeded
against in Departmental Proceeding for major penalty The person who was
wrongly recruited will not allowed to continue to take advantage of this wrong
act, and the Govt. cannot be bound by the wrong act of any of its functionaries.
(iii)
It is however clarified that the present directions will only apply
prospectively Those personnel recruited earlier and thereafter found to be colour
blind will not be boarded out on account of color blindness. But it is reiterated
that any person recruited herein after, if found colour blind even after
recruitment shall promptly be boarded out of service. Keeping in view the
direction of the Hon'ble High Court and in the public interest, the services of the
colour blind personnel recruited prior to 18.05.2012 would be utilized for the
jobs where public safety issues are not involved. Some of the posts/cadres
identified for such personnel by CAPFs are enlisted in the Annexure-I.
(iv) As the Color Blindness is a congenital disease, to obviate the induction of
colour blind personnel in CAPFs & Assam Rifles by error by manipulation in any
of the future recruitments, an undertaking shall be taken from all the selected
candidates at the time of joining that if any stage of their service career, if they
are found to be colour blind they will be boarded out as per the SHAPE Policy on
vogue.
9.
This issues with the approval of Union Home Secretary.”
A perusal of the aforesaid policy guidelines makes it clear that a person having
defective vision or colour blindness is not eligible for recruitment in the CAPFs and
Assam Rifles. The policy further provides that where a person is wrongly recruited
Page No.# 6/9
despite having such defect, he is to be promptly removed from service as soon as the
defect is noticed. The policy also specifically draws a distinction between personnel
recruited prior to the policy and those recruited thereafter. In respect of personnel
recruited after the policy came into force, it is expressly provided that if they are
found to be colour blind even after recruitment, they shall promptly be boarded out
from service.
10.
It is not in dispute that the petitioner was appointed on 22.11.2014, i.e. after
the aforesaid policy guidelines dated 27.02.2013 had come into force. At the time of
his joining, the petitioner furnished an undertaking in terms of the aforesaid policy
guidelines. The undertaking reads as under:
“UNDERTAKING
As per new policy guidelines issued vide MHA order No.F.No.I-45024/1/2008Pers-II dated 27/02/2013, I hereby undertake that if at any stage of my service
career, I am found to be colour blind, I will be boarded out as per the shape
policy in vogue.
Date: 22/11/2014
Nobin Kar Chakma
Signature of Govt. servant
F/No. 145/32849 Rank CT/90
Name Nobin kumar Chakma”
11.
Thus, the petitioner had, at the time of his joining service, expressly undertaken
to abide by the consequence prescribed under the policy in the event of his being
found to be colour blind at any stage of his service career. The undertaking is
categorical and leaves no ambiguity as to the consequence which the petitioner had
agreed to accept.
12.
It appears from the records that subsequently, in the year 2016, the petitioner
was detected to be suffering from colour blindness. The said fact is not disputed by
the learned counsel appearing for the petitioner.
Page No.# 7/9
13.
It is also significant that the policy guidelines dated 27.02.2013 have not been
challenged in the present proceeding. Consequently, the validity of the policy is not an
issue before this Court. The question that arises for consideration is whether, in the
admitted factual circumstances, the respondents were justified in applying the
consequence prescribed under the said policy to the petitioner.
14.
As noticed hereinabove, the petitioner was appointed after the policy guidelines
dated 27.02.2013 had come into force. Therefore, his case is squarely governed by the
said policy. The policy expressly provides that any person recruited thereafter, if found
to be colour blind even after recruitment, shall promptly be boarded out from service.
The petitioner’s appointment in the year 2014, therefore, cannot be considered
independently of the aforesaid policy. More importantly, the petitioner had furnished a
specific undertaking accepting the said condition at the time of his joining.
15.
The fact that the petitioner had already undergone training and had rendered
service for some period before the defect was detected cannot, by itself, create a right
in his favour to continue in service contrary to the governing policy. The policy itself
contemplates a situation where colour blindness may be detected after recruitment
and specifically prescribes the consequence in such a situation. Therefore, mere
passage of time between the date of appointment and the date of detection of colour
blindness does not take the petitioner outside the ambit of the policy.
16.
The submission of the learned counsel for the petitioner that the petitioner
ought to have been accommodated in some other post also requires consideration.
The policy guidelines dated 27.02.2013 contemplate utilisation of colour blind
personnel recruited prior to 18.05.2012 in jobs where public safety issues are not
involved. However, that provision is specifically confined to personnel recruited prior to
the said date. The petitioner, admittedly, was recruited in the year 2014 and therefore
does not fall within the category of personnel to whom such alternative utilisation is
contemplated under the policy.
Page No.# 8/9
17.
Nevertheless, in terms of this Court’s order dated 13.02.2025, Mr. K. K.
Parashar, learned CGC, was directed to obtain instructions from the department as to
whether the services of the petitioner could be utilised in any other post where colour
blindness would not constitute an impediment in the discharge of the duties attached
to such post. Pursuant thereto, the learned CGC has placed the departmental
instructions before the Court by way of an affidavit dated 23.05.2025.
The specific stand of the respondents is that, at present, not a single post in the
CRPF can be treated as a non-combatant post. It has been stated that even personnel
serving in ordinary functional posts are mandatorily required to undergo arms training
so that, in an emergency, they may be called upon to perform combatant duties.
According to the respondents, therefore, all posts in the CRPF carry operational
requirements which make colour blindness an impediment in the discharge of the
duties attached to such posts.
In the absence of any material placed before this Court to demonstrate that an
alternative post exists in the CRPF against which the petitioner can legitimately be
retained notwithstanding the applicable policy, this Court cannot direct the
respondents to create or identify a post for the petitioner contrary to the policy
governing his service.
18.
It is also necessary to bear in mind that the CRPF is an armed force
entrusted with duties which involve, inter alia, the use of arms and deployment in
situations requiring combatant functions. The policy decision of the competent
authority prescribing visual standards for recruitment and retention in such forces
cannot ordinarily be interfered with by this Court in exercise of its jurisdiction under
Article 226 of the Constitution, particularly when the petitioner has not challenged the
policy itself and has expressly undertaken to abide by its consequences.
19.
Viewed from the aforesaid perspective, the impugned order dated 04.05.2017
cannot be said to suffer from any infirmity warranting interference by this Court. The
Page No.# 9/9
petitioner was recruited after the policy guidelines dated 27.02.2013 came into force;
he was subsequently detected to be colour blind; he had expressly undertaken that if
found to be colour blind at any stage of his service career, he would be boarded out in
accordance with the SHAPE Policy and the respondents have also placed before the
Court their position that there is no alternative non-combatant post in the CRPF in
which the petitioner can be retained.
20.
In view of the foregoing discussion, no case is made out for interference with
the impugned order dated 04.05.2017.
Accordingly, the instant writ petition, being devoid of merit, stands dismissed.
21.
There shall be no order as to costs.
JUDGE
Comparing Assistant
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review