Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Digitally signed
by RAMESH
KUMAR VATTI
Date: 2026.07.01
15:22:39 +0530
2026:CGHC:26079
AFR
HIGH COURT OF CHHATTISGARH AT BILASPUR
WPS No. 9383 of 2022
* - Nitish Sharma S/o Late Radheshyam Sharma, aged about 23 years R/o 1st
BNCAF Line, Ward No. 60, Katulbod, Durg, District Durg, Chhattisgarh
... Petitioner
Versus
1 - State of Chhattisgarh, Through Secretary, Department of Home Affairs,
Mahanadi Bhawan, Atal Nagar, Nava Raipur, District Raipur, Chhattisgarh
2 – Director General of Police, PHQ, near Mantralaya, Sector 19, Atal NagarNava Raipur, Chhattisgarh 492001
3 – Inspector General of Police, Chhattisgarh Armed Force, North Range,
Sarguja, District Sarguja, Chhattisgarh
4 – Commandant 12th Battalion, Chhattisgarh Armed Force, Ramnujganj,
District Balrampur, Chhattisgarh
... Respondents
For Petitioner
:
Mr. A.V. Shridhar, Advocate
For Respondents/State
:
Mr. Anmol Sharma, Panel Lawyer
Hon’ble Shri Justice Rakesh Mohan Pandey
Order on Board
25/06/2026
1.
The petitioner has filed this petition challenging the amendment
inserted to Policy of compassionate appointment dated 29.08.2016 and
subsequent order passed by the respondent No. 4 dated 14.07.2021.
2.
The facts, in brief, are that Radheshyam Sharma was posted on the
post of Head Constable (GD) under the respondent No. 4, who died in
harness on 27.04.2021. His date of retirement was 30.04.2021. The
petitioner herein moved an application for grant of compassionate
appointment before the respondent authorities and same has been
rejected by the respondent No. 4 vide order dated 14.07.2021 on the
ground that one of the dependents of deceased-government servant is
already in government service and therefore, according to the
provisions of Clause 6(A) of Policy for compassionate appointment,
the the application of the petitioner cannot be considered. The
petitioner has challenged the amendment inserted to Clause 6(A)
dated 29.08.2016, which states that if one of the dependents of the
deceased-government servant is already in government service, any
other member would not be entitled for consideration.
3.
Mr. A.V. Shridhar, learned counsel appearing for the petitioner would
submit that elder son of the deceased-government servant is working
on the post of Constable (GD) and residing separately along with his
wife and children. He would submit that he has been living separately
prior to date of death of his father and he never financially assisted the
deceased-government servant or his family. It is argued that the
amendment inserted on 29.08.2016 defeats the very purpose for grant
of compassionate appointment, particularly in cases where other
members of the family are residing separately. He would refer definition
of ‘Family’ given in Black’s Law Dictionary, 8 th Edition, which reads as
under:1. A group of persons connected by blood, by affinity or
by law esp. within two or three generations.
2. A group consisting of parents and their children.
3. A group of persons who live together and have a
shared commitment to a domestic relationship. See
RELATIVE. – amilial, adj.
Mr. A.V.Shridhar would argue that the family of the deceasedgovernment servant and family of his elder son namely Hemant
Sharma were and are residing separately and they are nucleus family,
therefore, the bar contained in Clause 6(A) of the Policy is arbitrary,
discriminatory and violative of Articles 14, 16 and 21 of the Constitution
of India. It is also contended that the respondent authorities ought to
have conducted an enquiry before rejecting the claim with regard to
compassionate appointment. He would pray to quash the newly added
Clause
6(A)
of
Policy
for
compassionate
appointment
dated
29.08.2016 and subsequent order of rejection of petitioner’s claim
dated 14.07.2021.
4.
On the other hand, Mr. Anmol Sharma, learned Panel Lawyer
appearing for the State/respondents would oppose. Mr. Anmol Sharma
would submit that the courts should not interfere with the soundness
and wisdom of the policy. He would contend that the compassionate
appointment cannot be claimed as matter of right. The object and
purpose of the compassionate appointment is the immediacy of the
financial crisis occurred as a result of death of breadwinner. It is also
contend that if in the family there is already a member who is employed
then it cannot be presumed that family is not able to meet the financial
crisis. He would submit that appointment on the ground of compassion
is an exception and cannot be made as a rule and relaxation in
aforesaid pre-conditions would open a floodgate of appointments on
compassionate grounds. Mr. Anmol Sharma would further contend that
the elder brother of the petitioner is already in government service and
therefore his claim has rightly been rejected. He would refer the
judgment passed by the Full Bench of this Court in WA No. 236 of
2022 in the matter of State of Chhattisgarh & Ors. Vs. Umesh
Thakur dated 21.06.2023 wherein validity of Clause 6(A) has already
been examined. He would submit that the Hon’ble Full Bench held that
the High Court under Article 226 of the Constitution of India would not
direct to hold an enquiry qua dependency/financial support by one of
the family members of the deceased Government servant, who is
already in Government service to the other family member of the
deceased and any such direction would amount to rephrasing /
rewording of the terms of applicable scheme. He would submit that this
writ petition deserves to be dismissed.
5.
I have heard learned counsel for the parties and perused the
documents.
6.
The petitioner has challenged Clause 6(A) of Policy for compassionate
appointment dated 29.08.2016 and an order of rejection dated
14.07.2021 on 02 grounds : (i) definition of the family has been
extended by Policy maker while including a dependent member of the
deceased- government servant, who is government servant and
residing separately and (ii) no enquiry was conducted as to whether
such an employee is providing any financial assistance to other
members of the family or not. It is not case of petitioner that he had
abandoned his parents prior to date of demise of his father or
immediately after getting job on the post of Constable (GD). The word
‘Family’ includes parents, wife and children. The elder son of the
government servant was member of family and even after death of
deceased- government servant, he cannot be precluded from such
definition. It is true that after marriage, Hemant Sharma was residing
separately alongwith his wife and children, but on that ground alone, it
cannot be ruled out that he
was not part of family of deceased-
government servant Radheshyam Sharma. Further this plea was never
taken prior rejection of application moved by the petitioner herein for
grant of compassionate appointment and, therefore, I am of the view
that the amendment inserted in the Policy dated 29.08.2016 is valid.
7.
The Hon’ble Supreme Court in the matter of General Manager
(D&PB) and Others Vs. Kunti Tiwary and Another reported in (2004)
7 SCC 271 while dealing with issue to determine financial condition of
family held in paragraph- 7, as under:“7.
In adoption of this principle, an office
memorandum was circulated to all banks on 7-81996 emphasising that the observations of this
Court would have to be complied with. The Indian
Banks’ Association also adopted the directive of this
Court in Umesh Kumar Nagpal case1 in the
Scheme which was proposed for appointment of
heirs of deceased employees. In that proposal it
was recommended that in order to determine the
financial condition of the family the following
amounts would have to be taken into account:
(a) Family pension.
(b) Gratuity amount received.
(c) Employee’s/employer’s contribution to provident
fund.
(d) Any compensation paid by the Bank or its Welfare
Fund.
(e) Proceeds of LIC policy and other investments of
the deceased employee.
(f) Income of family from other sources.
(g) Employment of other family members.
(h) Size of the family and liabilities, if any, etc.”
The Hon’ble Supreme Court included income from employment
of other family members as income of the family alongwith other
amounts admissible to said family.
8.
In the matter Umesh Thakur (supra) following question was framed
by the Hon’ble Full Court of this Court:“When any dependent family member of deceased
employee is already in Government service, in that
circumstance whether any other member of the
family would be deprived for employment on
compassionate ground, without consideration of
dependency
of
family
on
such
Government
employee?”
And it was answered in following terms:
In State of Himachal Pradesh and another Vs. Parkash
Chand, (2019) 4 SCC 285, their Lordships of the Supreme Court
have
held
that
compassionate
direction
to
consider
application
appointment
of
dependents
of
for
deceased
employee dehors policy is impermissible, and observed as
under:“9.
The High Court has observed that the State
should
consider
cases
for
appointment
on
compassionate basis by dealing with the applications
submitted by sons, or as the case may be, daughters of
deceased government employees, even though, one
member of the family is engaged in the service of the
Government or an autonomous Board or Corporation.
This direction of the judgment of the High Court virtually
amounts to a mandamus to the State Government to
disregard the terms which have been stipulated in Para
5(c) of its Policy dated 18-1-1990. The Policy contains a
limited exception which is available only to a widow of a
deceased
employee
who
seeks
compassionate
appointment even though one of the children of the
deceased employee is gainfully employed with the
State. The basis for this exception is to deal with cases
where the widow is not being supported financially by
her children.
10.
In the exercise of judicial review under Article 226
of the Constitution, it was not open to the High Court to
rewrite the terms of the Policy. It is well settled that
compassionate appointment is not a matter of right, but
must be governed by the terms on which the State lays
down the policy of offering employment assistance to a
member of the family of a deceased government
employee. [Umesh Kumar Nagpal v. State of Haryana 2,
SBI v. Kunti Tiwary6 , Punjab National Bank v. Ashwini
Kumar Teneja7, SBI v. Somvir Singh3, Mumtaz Yunus
Mulani v. State of Maharashtra8, Union of India v.
Shashank Goswami9, SBI v. Surya Narain Tripathi10 and
Canara Bank v. M. Mahesh Kumar11 .]
11. For the above reasons, we are of the view that the
judgment of the High Court is unsustainable. The High
Court has virtually rewritten the terms of the Policy and
has issued a direction to the State to consider
applications which do not fulfill the terms of the Policy.
This is impermissible.”
9.
It is categorically held that this Court under Article 226 of the
Constitution of India would not direct for holding enquiry qua
dependency/financial support by one of the family members of the
deceased- government servant who is already in Government service
to the other family members of the deceased-government servant and
such attempt would not amount to rephrasing / rewording of the terms
of the policy for compassionate appointment. Thus, no order can be
issued to conduct an enquiry to find out as to whether such an
employee is providing any financial assistance to other member of the
family or not. The object of compassionate appointment is to provide
immediate financial assistance to the family of the deceased employee
which has been left without means of livelihood, but where the family
receives sufficient terminal benefits and one of the members of the
family is already in government service, claim for grant of
compassionate
appointment
cannot
be
considered.
The
compassionate appointment is non-merit based exception designed
solely to help surviving dependent of deceased- government servant. It
is not a vested hereditarily right, but a targeted relief measure.
10. Taking into consideration the above-discussed facts and the law laid
down by the Hon’ble Supreme Court and Hon’ble Full Bench of this
Court, I do not find any good ground to interfere with the Policy for
compassionate appointment dated 29.08.2016 and order passed by
respondent No. 4 dated 14.07.2021.
11. Accordingly, this writ petition fails and is hereby dismissed.
Sd/(Rakesh Mohan Pandey)
Judge
vatti
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review