Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
WP(C) NO. 25049 OF 2024
2025:KER:12030
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KERALA AT ERNAKULAM
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE ANIL K.NARENDRAN
&
THE HONOURABLE MR.JUSTICE MURALEE KRISHNA S.
THURSDAY, THE 13th DAY OF FEBRUARY 2025 / 24TH MAGHA, 1946
WP(C) NO. 25049 OF 2024
PETITIONER:
NITHA.A.B., AGED 34 YEARS,
W/o ARUN, THIRUVATHIRA, VANCHIYOOR.P.O.,
ALAMCODE, CHIRAYINKEEZHU, ATTINGAL,
THIRUVANANTHAPURAM, PIN - 695102
BY ADV A.S.SHAMMY RAJ
RESPONDENTS:
KERALA DEVASWOM RECRUITMENT BOARD,
II FLOOR, DEVASWOM BUILDINGS, OPP.AYURVEDA
COLLEGE, M.G.ROAD, THIRUVANANTHAPURAM,
REPRESENTED BY ITS SECRETARY, PIN - 695001
THE SECRETARY,
KERALA DEVASWOM RECRUITMENT BOARD,
DEVASWOM RECRUITMENT BOARD OFFICE,
AYURVEDA COLLEGE JUNCTION,
THIRUVANANTHAPURAM, PIN - 695001
TRAVANCORE DEVASWOM BOARD,
TRAVANCORE DEVASWOM BOARD HEADQUARTERS,
NANTHANCODE, KAWDIAR POST, THIRUVANANTHAPURAM,
REPRESENTED BY ITS SECRETARY, PIN - 695003
ADDL.R4 ARUN G.S., ASWATHY, MATHIRA.P.O.,
KOTTARAKKARA, KOLLAM, PIN 691536
WP(C) NO. 25049 OF 2024
2025:KER:12030
ADDL.R5 JISHNU NAMPOOTHIRI.P.J.,
PUNNOOR MADOM, 590, KAREELAKULANGARA P.O.,
KARTHIKAPPALLY, ALAPPUZHA, PIN - 690572.
ADDL.R6 GOKUL P., CHANDRA, MADATHIL LANE,
K.P.10/115, GSSNRA 187, NCC ROAD,
AMBALAMUKKU P.O., THIRUVANANTHAPURAM, PIN-695005
ADDL.R7 VAISHAKH VARMA R., MANIKKUNNIL KOICKEL,
MATHILBHAGOM, THIRUVALLA P.O., PATHANAMTHITTA,
PIN - 689101.
ADDL.R8 BIJEESH C.B., CHENGOTTUKUNNU HOUSE, VIII,
KARTHIKKULAM P.O., MANANTHAVADY, WAYANAD,
PIN - 670646
ADDL.R9 ATHUL MOHAN, KITCHU BHAVAN, ARKANNOOR P.O.,
KOTTARAKKARA, KOLLAM, PIN - 691533.
ADDL.R10 UMESH B., KIZHAKKATHIL VEEDU, 10-836,
PULLIKONAM, KACHANI, KARAKULAM P.O.,
THIRUVANANTHAPURAM, PIN - 695564
ADDL.R11 ASWATHI KRISHNAN P.P.,
PAYYADA PADIKKAL, KOOTTANAD P.O., PATTAMBI,
PALAKKAD, PIN - 679533
ADDL.R12 ANEKHA KRISHNAN V.,
KRISHNAKRIPA HOUSE, MUTTIL P.O., VYTHIRI,
WAYANAD, PIN - 673122
ADDL.R13 APARNA T.V.,
RAJINALAYAM HOUSE, BLATHUR, KALLIAD P.O.,
THALIPPARAMBA, KANNUR, PIN - 670593
ADDL.R14 ANNETA L., SWATHI, ARA E41, T.C.20/1884(7),
THAMALAM P.O., THIRUVANANTHAPURAM, PIN - 695012
*ADDL.R4 TO ADDL.R14 ARE IMPLEADED AS PER ORDER
DATED 29.07.2024 IN I.A.4/2024 IN WPC 25049/2024.
BY ADV. G.BIJU, SC FOR TRAVANCORE DEVASWOM BOARD
SRI. V.V. NANDAGOPAL NAMBIAR, SC, KERALA DEVASWOM
RECRUITMENT BOARD
KISHORE D
WP(C) NO. 25049 OF 2024
2025:KER:12030
MEERA GOPINATH(K/001803/1999.)
R.MURALEEKRISHNAN (MALAKKARA)(K/000583/2008)
THIS WRIT PETITION (CIVIL) HAVING COME UP FOR ADMISSION
ON 13.02.2025, THE COURT ON THE SAME DAY DELIVERED THE
FOLLOWING:
WP(C) NO. 25049 OF 2024
2025:KER:12030
JUDGMENT
Anil K. Narendran, J.
The petitioner, who submitted an application pursuant to
Ext.P4 notification dated 11.10.2023 issued by the 1st respondent
Kerala Devaswom Recruitment Board, for the post of Public
Relations Officer in the 3rd respondent Travancore Devaswom
Board, has filed this writ petition under Article 226 of the
Constitution of India, seeking a writ of certiorari to quash Ext.P7
select list dated 02.07.2024 published by the 1st respondent
Recruitment Board. The petitioner has also sought for a writ of
mandamus commanding respondents 1 and 2 to conduct interview
of the candidates afresh, in the presence of an Advocate
Commissioner to be appointed by this Court.
2.
Going by the averments in the writ petition, the
petitioner applied for the post of Public Relations Officer in the 3rd
respondent Devaswom Board. The 1st respondent Recruitment
Board conducted a written test and interview on 18.02.2024 and
27.06.2024, respectively. The petitioner acquired the highest
mark in the written test. But in order to avoid ladies coming to the
said post, the interview board has given the least mark to the
WP(C) NO. 25049 OF 2024
petitioner.
None
of
the
academic
2025:KER:12030
credentials
or
previous
experiences of the petitioner were considered. Even though the
petitioner answered all the questions asked in the interview, the
interview board purposefully granted the least mark to her solely
for avoiding a lady being placed in the top rank.
3.
On 12.07.2024, when this writ petition came up for
consideration before a learned Single Judge, it was submitted that
identical cases are posted before the Division Bench dealing with
Devaswom matters. Therefore, by the order dated 12.07.2024,
this writ petition was directed to be listed before the Division
Bench, after obtaining the orders of the Hon'ble the Chief Justice.
Thereafter, after obtaining necessary orders, the writ petition is
listed before the Division Bench on 18.07.2024.
4.
On 19.07.2024, the learned counsel for the petitioner
sought time to file an application to amend the writ petition.
Thereafter, the petitioner filed I.A.Nos.1, 2 and 3 of 2024 seeking
various interim reliefs. I.A.Nos.1 and 2 of 2024 were filed on
18.07.2024 and I.A.No.3 of 2024 was filed on 20.07.2024.
Thereafter, the petitioner filed I.A.No.4 of 2024 on 20.07.2024
seeking an order to amend the writ petition, as stated in that
WP(C) NO. 25049 OF 2024
interlocutory
application.
By
the
2025:KER:12030
order
dated
29.07.2024,
I.A.Nos.1 and 2 of 2024 were closed and I.A.No.3 of 2024 was
dismissed as not pressed. I.A.No.4 of 2024 filed by the petitioner
seeking an order to implead the candidates, who are included in
Ext.P7 select list, as additional respondents 4 to 14, and to amend
the writ petition as stated in that interlocutory application, was
allowed. The learned Standing Counsel for Devaswom Recruitment
Board took notice for respondents 1 and 2 and the learned
Standing Counsel for the Devaswom Board for the 3rd respondent.
Urgent notice by speed post was ordered to additional respondents
4 to 14.
5.
The 4th respondent has filed a counter affidavit dated
23.08.2024, opposing the reliefs sought for in the writ petition,
producing therewith Exts.R4(a) to R4(h) documents. Paragraphs
6 to 9 of that counter affidavit read thus;
“6. It is submitted that this respondent is having vast experience
in public relations. The 4th respondent has worked as a Journalist
as Reporter/Sub Editor in Mathrubhumi News Channel and as a
Sub Editor in the Information Public Relations Department,
Government of Kerala. A true copy of the Certificate of Experience
dated 8.12.2022 issued by the Manager-HR & Administration,
Mathrubhumi News Channel to the 4th respondent is produced
herewith and marked as Exhibit R4(c). The 4th respondent has
WP(C) NO. 25049 OF 2024
2025:KER:12030
also worked as a Sub Editor in the Information Public Relations
Department for the period from 1.2.2022 to 31.1.2023 and from
21.3.2023 to 20.1.2024. A true copy of the Certificate of
Experience dated 20.1.2024 issued by the Information Officer,
Information Public Relations Department to the 4th respondent for
the period 1.2.2022 to 31.2.2023 is produced herewith and
marked as Exhibit R4(d). A true copy of the Certificate of
Experience dated 20.1.2024 issued by the Information Officer,
Information Public Relations Department to the 4th respondent for
the period 21.3.2023 to 20.1.2024 is produced herewith and
marked as Exhibit R4(e).
7. It is submitted that Exhibits R4(c) to R4(d) are only experience
certificates to prove that the 4th respondent is having vast
experience in the field of Journalism and the same is not a part
of the essential qualification prescribed in the notification. At the
time when the 4th respondent applied for the post, he was working
as a Sub Editor in the Information Public Relations Department
and Exhibits R4(d) and R4(e) Certificates are obtained are on
20.1.2024, that is before the interview.
8. It is submitted that the 4th respondent has secured 67 marks
in the written test and he was awarded 7 marks in the interview,
taking into consideration the credentials and experience of this
respondent. Accordingly, this respondent has secured 74 marks
and was placed as rank No.1 in Exhibit P7 ranked list.
9. It is submitted that this respondent was advised on 9.7.2024
and the appointment order was issued by the Devaswom
Commissioner to the 4th respondent on 15.7.2024. A true copy of
the Advice Letter dated 9.7.2024 issued by the 2nd respondent to
the 4th respondent is produced herewith and marked as Exhibit
R4(f).
A
true
copy
of
the
Memo
of
Appointment
ROC.NO.52/12/EST-A dated 15.7.2024 issued by the Devaswom
Commissioner-in-charge to the 4th respondent is produced
WP(C) NO. 25049 OF 2024
2025:KER:12030
herewith and marked as Exhibit R4(g). The 4th respondent joined
the service on 18.7.2024. A true copy of the Proceedings No. ROC
No.9321/24/Est-1 dated 25.7.2024 issued by the Secretary,
Travancore Devaswom Board is produced herewith and marked
as Exhibit R4(h).”
6.
The
learned
Standing
Counsel
for
Devaswom
Recruitment Board has filed a counter affidavit dated 30.10.2024,
on behalf of respondents 1 and 2. Paragraphs 3 and 4 of that
counter affidavit read thus;
“3. The 3rd respondent Travancore Devaswom Board as per letter
dated 02.09.2023 reported one vacancy of PRO to 1st respondent
Kerala Devaswom
Recruitment Board ('KDRB'
herein).
1st
respondent issued notification for the PRO post as category No.
11/2023 on 11.10.2023 with last date of notification as
09.11.2023. The qualifications for the said post are as follows:
(i)
Degree
from
any
recognized
university
(ii)
PG diploma in Public Relations/Journalism OR its
equivalent qualification.
Written
test
was
conducted
on
18.02.2024
at
Thiruvananthapuram. Short List (No. 07/2024) was published on
09.04.2024 on the basis of the written test. A total of 13 persons
are included in the Short List. After publishing the Short List, their
certificates were verified on 02.05.2024 and rejected the
application of one candidate as he was found not qualified to
apply. Interview was held on 27.06.2024 for all the 12 candidates
included in the Short List. The interview was conducted by KDRB
as per the provisions of Rule 7 of the Kerala Devaswom
Recruitment
Board
Rules,
2015.
Subject
expert
and
representative of TDB were also there in the Interview Board.
Ranked List was published on 02.07.2024 (Exhibit P7 in writ
WP(C) NO. 25049 OF 2024
2025:KER:12030
petition) and advice memo was issued to the 1st rank holder on
09.07.2024. Exhibit P7 ranked list was prepared on the basis of
written test and interview by the Board including experts. The
interview board give marks to each candidate after assessing the
performance of every candidate appeared before them. The
marks of the written examination was not be revealed before the
interview board.
4. The allegation of the applicant that as she is a lady, the
interview board has purposefully given the least mark to her is
only her assumption. There is no discrimination from the part of
the Board which is clear from the ranked list itself that the second
highest mark of '6' awarded is to a lady named Aswathy Krishnan
P.P along Jishnu Namboothiri P.J. It may be seen that in Ext. P7,
the first person in the supplementary rank list of Hindu Scheduled
caste, OBC, Hindu Nadar are ladies. Hence the allegation of the
petitioner is not legally tenable. There is no gender discrimination
on the part of the Interview Board. The Interview Board gave
marks to applicant after assessing the performance of the
applicant. Exhibit P7 is the first ranked list issued by this
respondent in the post of PRO of Travancore Devaswom Board.
As per Rule 3(2) of the Kerala Devaswom Recruitment Board
Rules, 2015, the reservation and rotation as provided in Rules 14
to 17 of the Part II Kerala State and Subordinate Services Rules,
1958, shall mutatis mutandis apply. As per Rule 14 of Kerala State
and Subordinate Service Rules, the first vacancy shall be filled up
from open competition. Hence the allegation of the writ petitioner
that she is entitled to get the appointment under reservation
category is not legally maintainable.”
7.
The learned Standing Counsel for the Devaswom Board
has filed a counter affidavit dated 14.01.2025 on behalf of the 3rd
respondent Board. Paragraphs 4 to 6 of that counter affidavit read
WP(C) NO. 25049 OF 2024
2025:KER:12030
thus:
“4. It is submitted that the Travancore Devaswom Board
published Travancore Devaswom Board Officers' and Servants'
Service Rules, 2022 on 20-06-2022. As per the above Rule, the
appointment of Public Relations Officer is by direct recruitment
from a select list prepared and approved by the Kerala Devaswom
Recruitment Board. The qualification prescribed for the post of
Public Relations Officer is (i) any degree from a recognised
University and (ii) P.G Diploma in Public Relations/ Journalism or
its equivalent.
5. The Travancore Devaswom Board reported the vacancy of
Public Relations Officer to the Kerala Devaswom Recruitment
Board on 02-09-2023. The respondents 1 & 2 conducted a
selection
process
and
published
Exhibit-P7
rank
list
on
02.07.2024. The second respondent advised the 4th respondent,
who is the first rank holder for appointment to the post.
Accordingly, the Devaswom Commissioner issued appointment
order,
ROC.NO.52/12/EST-A
dated
15-07-2024
to
the
4th
respondent. The fourth respondent joined service on 18-07-2024
FN.
6. The petitioner challenges the selection process questioning the
award of marks by the interview Board. It is submitted that the
marks awarded in an interview will be on the basis of the
performance of the candidate in the interview. Moreover it is the
settled legal proposition that reassessment of the merits of
individual candidates is legally impermissible in exercise of the
power of judicial review under Art.226 of the Constitution of India.
M.V Thimmaiah Vs Union Public Service Commission [2008(2)
SCC 119] & Baidyanath Yadav Vs Aditya Narayan Rov [2020(16)
SCC 799].”
8.
Heard the learned counsel for the petitioner, the
WP(C) NO. 25049 OF 2024
2025:KER:12030
learned Standing Counsel for Kerala Devaswom Recruitment
Board for respondents 1 and 2, the learned Standing Counsel for
Travancore Devaswom Board for the 3rd respondent and also the
learned counsel for the 4th respondent.
9.
The issue that arises for consideration in this writ
petition is as to whether any interference is warranted on Ext.P7
select list prepared by the 1st respondent Kerala Devaswom
Recruitment Board, for recruitment to the post of Public Relations
Officer in the 3rd respondent Travancore Devaswom Board.
10.
The learned counsel for the petitioner would contend
that Ext.P7 select list is one prepared by giving a go-by to the
merit of the individual candidates. Such a procedure has been
adopted only to deny the petitioner, who secured the maximum
mark in the written test, appointment as Public Relations Officer
in Travancore Devaswom Board. Based on the pleadings on record,
the learned counsel for the petitioner would contend that the
petitioner has been discriminated for the reason that she is a lady.
According to the learned counsel, the duties and responsibilities of
Public Relations Officer require the presence of that officer at
Sabarimala Sannidhanam, when Sabarimala Sree Dharma Sastha
WP(C) NO. 25049 OF 2024
2025:KER:12030
Temple remains open during Mandala-Makaravilakku festival
seasons.
11.
On the other hand, the learned Standing Counsel for
the Devaswom Recruitment Board and the learned Standing
Counsel for the Devaswom Board and also the learned counsel for
the additional 4th respondent would contend that no interference
of this Court under Article 226 of the Constitution of India is
warranted in the assessment of merit of the individual candidates
by the interview board of the Devaswom Recruitment Board, which
has culminated in the preparation of Ext.P7 select list.
12.
The specific stand taken in the counter affidavit filed on
behalf of respondents 1 and 2 is that the allegation contained in
the writ petition that the petitioner being a lady, the interview
board purposely gave least mark to her is only her assumption.
There is no discrimination from the side of the Recruitment Board,
as evident from Ext.P7 select list, in which the petitioner secured
the second highest mark, i.e., 6 marks. In addition to that, the
first person in the supplementary list for Hindu Scheduled Caste,
OBC and Hindu Nadar are lady candidates. The interview board
gave marks to the applicant after assessing her performance.
WP(C) NO. 25049 OF 2024
2025:KER:12030
Since Ext.P7 select list is the first select list prepared by the
Devaswom Recruitment Board for the post of Public Relations
Officer in the 3rd respondent Devaswom Board, in view of the
provisions contained in Rule 3(2) of the Kerala Devaswom
Recruitment Board Rules, 2015, read with Rules 14 to 17 of Part
II Kerala State & Subordinate Service Rules, 1958, the first
vacancy shall be filled up from open competition. Accordingly, the
additional 4th respondent, who is Rank No.1 in Ext.P7 select list,
was advised for appointment as Public Relations Officer in
Travancore Devaswom Board.
13.
As rightly contended by the learned Standing Counsel
for the Devaswom Recruitment, the learned Standing Counsel for
the Devaswom Board and also the learned counsel for the
additional 4th respondent, reassessment of merits of individual
candidates is legally impermissible in exercise of the power of
judicial review under Article 226 of the Constitution of India, in the
absence of violation of statutory rules, bias, mala fides or
arbitrariness in the selection process, as held by the Apex Court
in M.V.Thimmaiah v. Union Public Service Commission
[(2008) 2 SCC 119] and Baidyanath Yadav v. Aditya
WP(C) NO. 25049 OF 2024
2025:KER:12030
Narayan Roy [(2020) 16 SCC 799]. It is not within the domain
of this Court, exercising the power of judicial review, to enter into
the merits of a selection process, except cases in which there are
proven allegations of violation of statutory rules, inherent
arbitrariness, etc. In exercise of the power of judicial review, this
Court cannot step into the shoes of the selection committee or
assume appellate role to examine whether the marks awarded by
the selection committee in the viva voce are excessive or not
corresponding to the performance of the respective candidates.
14.
In such circumstances, we find no reason to interfere
with Ext.P7 select list prepared by the 1st respondent Devaswom
Recruitment Board for the post of Public Relations Officer in the
3rd respondent Devaswom Board. The petitioner is not entitled to
any of the reliefs sought for in this writ petition.
In the result, the writ petition fails and the same is
accordingly dismissed.
Sd/ANIL K. NARENDRAN, JUDGE
Sd/MURALEE KRISHNA S., JUDGE
DMR/-
WP(C) NO. 25049 OF 2024
2025:KER:12030
APPENDIX OF WP(C) 25049/2024
PETITIONER'S EXHIBITS
Exhibit P1
TRUE COPY OF THE B.A. DEGREE CERTIFICATE
OF THE PETITIONER (REGISTER
NO.9270/MARCH 2010) DATED 18.10.2010,
ISSUED TO THE PETITIONER BY THE
UNIVERSITY OF KERALA
Exhibit P2
TRUE COPY OF THE RANK CERTIFICATE
(REGISTER NO.9270) DATED 26.3.2011
ISSUED TO THE PETITIONER BY THE KANNUR
UNIVERSITY
Exhibit P3
TRUE COPY OF THE M.A. DEGREE CERTIFICATE
DATED 9.1.2024 ISSUED TO THE PETITIONER
BY THE KANNUR UNIVERSITY
Exhibit P4
TRUE COPY OF THE NOTIFICATION
NO.97/R1/2023/K.D.R.B. DATED 11.10.2023
ISSUED BY THE 2ND RESPONDENT
Exhibit P5
TRUE COPY OF THE ONLINE APPLICATION
NO.100079 FILED BY THE PETITIONER BEFORE
THE 1ST RESPONDENT
Exhibit P6
TRUE COPY OF THE CALL LETTER (FILE
NO.1944/R12023/KDRB) DATED 13.6.2024,
ISSUED BY THE 2ND RESPONDENT
Exhibit P7
TRUE COPY OF THE RANK LIST NO.06/2024
DATED 2.7.2024 PUBLISHED BY THE 2ND
RESPONDENT
Exhibit P8
TRUE COPY OF THE EXPERIENCE CERTIFICATE
DATED 6.12.2021 ISSUED BY THE JOINT
DIRECTOR OF THE ALL INDIA RADIO,
THIRUVANANTHAPURAM TO THE PETITIONER
Exhibit P9
TRUE COPY OF THE EXPERIENCE CERTIFICATE
NO.22/PR/2024/I&PRD DATED 19.4.2024
ISSUED BY THE DEPUTY DIRECTOR,
INFORMATION AND PUBLIC RELATIONS
WP(C) NO. 25049 OF 2024
2025:KER:12030
DEPARTMENT TO THE PETITIONER
Exhibit P10
TRUE COPY OF THE EXPERIENCE CERTIFICATE
DATED 6.5.2024 ISSUED TO THE PETITIONER
BY THE ADDITIONAL DIRECTOR GENERAL,
MINISTRY OF INFORMATION & BROADCASTING
RESPONDENTS' EXHIBITS
Exhibit R4(a)
TRUE COPY OF THE DEGREE CERTIFICATE
DATED 5.8.2013 ISSUED TO THE 4TH
RESPONDENT BY THE KERALA UNIVERSITY
Exhibit R4(b)
TRUE COPY OF THE POST GRADUATE DEGREE
CERTIFICATE DATED 30.8.2019 ISSUED TO
THE 4TH RESPONDENT BY THE MAHATMA
UNIVERSITY
Exhibit R4(c)
TRUE COPY OF THE CERTIFICATE OF
EXPERIENCE DATED 8.12.2022 ISSUED BY THE
MANAGER-HR AND ADMINISTRATION,
MATHRUBHUMI NEWS CHANNEL TO THE 4TH
RESPONDENT
Exhibit R4(d)
TRUE COPY OF THE CERTIFICATE OF
EXPERIENCE DATED 20.1.2024 ISSUED BY THE
INFORMATION OFFICER, INFORMATION PUBLIC
RELATIONS DEPARTMENT TO THE 4TH
RESPONDENT FOR THE PERIOD 1.2.2022 TO
31.2.2023
Exhibit R4(e)
TRUE COPY OF THE CERTIFICATE OF
EXPERIENCE DATED 20.1.2024 ISSUED BY THE
INFORMATION OFFICER, INFORMATION PUBLIC
RELATIONS DEPARTMENT TO THE 4TH
RESPONDENT FOR THE PERIOD 21.3.2023 TO
20.1.2024
Exhibit R4(f)
TRUE COPY OF THE ADVICE LETTER DATED
9.7.2024 ISSUED BY THE 2ND RESPONDENT TO
THE 4TH RESPONDENT
Exhibit R4(g)
TRUE COPY OF THE MEMO OF APPOINTMENT
ROC.NO.52/12/EST-A DATED 15.7.2024
ISSUED BY THE DEVASWOM COMMISSIONER-IN-
WP(C) NO. 25049 OF 2024
2025:KER:12030
CHARGE TO THE 4TH RESPONDENT
Exhibit R4(h)
TRUE COPY OF THE PROCEEDINGS NO. ROC
NO.9321/24/EST-I DATED 25.7.2024 ISSUED
BY THE SECRETARY, TRAVANCORE DEVASWOM
BOARD
// TRUE COPY //
P.A. TO JUDGE
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review