Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
2026:CGHC:11111
NAFR
HIGH COURT OF CHHATTISGARH AT BILASPUR
ORDER RESERVED ON 04.02.2026
ORDER DELIVERED ON 03.03.2026
ORDER UPLOADED ON 03.03.2026
MCRC No. 10445 of 2025
1 - Nitesh Purohit S/o Bhanu Shankar Purohit Aged About 52 Years R/o
B-1, Mukta Sadan, In Front Of Goyal Nursing Home Samta Colony,
District- Raipur Chhattisgarh,
... Applicant(s)
versus
1 - State Of Chhattisgarh Through ACB/ EOw, District- Raipur
Chhattisgarh,
... Respondent(s)
For Applicant(s)
:
Shri Manoj Paranjape, Senior Counsel
assisted by Shri Gagan Tiwari, Advocate
For Respondent/State
:
Shri Praveen Das, Addl. Advocate General
assisted by Shri Krishna Gopal Yadav, GA
(Hon’ble Shri Justice Arvind Kumar Verma)
C A V Order
The instant application is preferred by the applicant seeking grant
of regular bail in connection with FIR No. 04/2024 registered at Police
Station EOW/ACB, Raipur, pertaining to offences punishable under
Sections 420, 467, 468, 471 and 120B IPC as well as Sections 7 and
12 of the Prevention of Corruption Act, 1988. Bail application filed
before the learned Special Judge (Prevention of Corruption Act), Raipur
came to be rejected vide order dated 10.12.2025, which order is
impugned herein.
BRIEF FACTS OF THE CASE
2.
The prosecution case, in nutshell, revolves around an alleged
liquor scam in Chhattisgarh unearthed during Income Tax search and
seizure operations conducted in February-March 2020 at multiple
premises linked to liquor trade entities and associated individuals. The
documents and digital records allegedly recovered therein purportedly
revealed irregular financial transactions and systemic manipulations in
State liquor procurement, distribution, licensing, and sales processes,
pointing to an organized syndicate influencing official mechanisms.
Statements of sundry persons recorded by Income Tax authorities lent
further credence to these inferences, precipitating deeper scrutiny. On
18.11.2022, the Directorate of Enforcement registered ECIR under
PMLA, treating the proceeds as arising from scheduled offences.
Pursuant thereto, communication under Section 66 PMLA was
addressed to EOW/ACB, Raipur, culminating in FIR No. 04/2024 dated
07.01.2024 under Sections 420, 467, 468, 471, 120B IPC and Sections
7 & 12 PC Act, 1988, arraying public servants and private players in the
liquor business.
3.
The conspiracy envisaged illicit gains through: (i) commissions
extracted from suppliers for liquor supply/sale clearances; (ii) off-therecord liquor sales via government outlets abetted by multi-level
manipulations; and (iii) annual payoffs securing seamless distillery
operations. The generated funds were allegedly laundered via a web of
intermediaries involving transit, storage, and disbursement through
sundry premises. Voluminous documents, financial trails, witness
statements, and digital evidence were garnered. Initial Final Report was
filed before Special Court (PC Act), Raipur, followed by successive
supplementary charge-sheets implicating more accused; the applicant
featured in the sixth such report dated 24.11.2025.
4.
The applicant stands indicted for abetting principal accused in
syndicate operations, with his/family premises allegedly leveraged for
fund handling/transport linked to excise irregularities, alongside
business entities under his umbrella facilitating syndicate logistics.
Summoned and arrested on 19.09.2025, he was charge-sheeted inter
alia. Prosecution posits concert with co-accused in a broader
conspiracy yielding illicit excise profits, backed by extensive witness
examinations and documentary matrix, to be substantiated at trial.
SUBMISSION OF THE COUNSEL FOR THE APPLICANT
5.
Shri Paranjape, learned Senior counsel for the applicant submits
that the instant bail application merits gracious consideration in light of
triple test enshrined in bail jurisprudence, duly satisfied herein. No
further Investigative Utility Probe qua the applicant stands concluded
with filing of 6th
Supplementary Final Report dated 24.11.2025. No
custodial remand remains warranted, rendering continued incarceration
otiose and punitive. There is no discrete role or overt act stands
attributed to the applicant in charge-sheet or materials garnered. The
association, if any, remains vicarious and inferential, insufficient to
justify pre-trial deprivation of liberty. He has placed his reliance in the
matter of State of Kerala v. Raneef, (2011) 1 SCC 784).
6.
Learned Sr. counsel for the applicant submits that the applicant
has been in judicial custody since 19.09.2025 and investigation qua
him
stands
substantially
completed,
culminating
in
filing
of
supplementary charge sheet. The Investigation, insofar as the present
applicant is concerned, stands completed and the investigating agency
has already filed the 6th Supplementary Final Report dated 24.11.2025
before the learned Special Judge (Prevention of Corruption Act),
Raipur. Thus, the applicant is no longer required for custodial
interrogation and continued detention serves no investigative purpose.
The trial Court rejected the bail application primarily on the gravity of
allegations without properly appreciating absence of specific role
attributed to the applicant, completion of investigation, documentary
nature of evidence, parity with co-accused already enlarged on bail,
prolonged and uncertain timeline of trial. It is therefore submitted that
seriousness of accusation alone cannot justify indefinite incarceration
pending trial.
7.
It has been contended that the constitutional courts retain power
to grant bail despite statutory rigours. As has been held by the
Supreme Court in Union of India v. K.A. Najeeb (2021) 3 SCC 713,
stating that
Statutory restrictions… do not oust the ability of
constitutional courts to grant bail on grounds of violation of Part III of
the Constitution… Where there is no likelihood of trial being completed
within reasonable time, courts may grant bail.”
8.
The allegations against the applicant are general and omnibus in
nature and do not attribute any specific overt act or transaction showing
direct handling or personal receipt of alleged illegal funds. No recovery
of cash, incriminating documents or financial instruments has been
effected from the applicant despite allegations of large scale cash
movement.
9.
It is next submitted that the applicant’s name appears in the FIR
without assigning any specific overt act. Even in the supplementary
charge-sheet, allegations remain broad and inferential in nature. No
direct recovery of illegal proceeds has been made from the applicant
and no material demonstrates applicant’s personal handling or receipt
of alleged illegal funds. The entire case of the prosecution is based on
documentary evidence, financial records and statements already
recorded. All the documents and electronic material relied upon stand
seized and are in custody of the prosecution. Therefore, there is no
possibility of tampering with evidence.
10.
It is contended that the applicant has throughout cooperated with
investigating agencies. He appeared before authorities whenever
summoned and complied with directions of Courts and had never
attempted to evade investigation or abscond. The arrest took place
when he appeared before the agency pursuant to notice, demonstrating
his bona fides. The prosecution case involves large number of accused
persons, voluminous documentary record, several hundreds of
witnesses and the charges are yet to be framed. The trial in such
complex economic matters ordinarily takes several years and continued
detention would therefore amount to punishment prior to conviction.
11.
Next contention of the learned Senior Counsel for the applicant is
that several co-accused persons, including those alleged to have
played more significant roles, have already been granted bail by
competent courts. The persons allegedly involved in core operational
and financial aspects of the case are already on bail. Therefore, denial
of bail to the applicant alone would violate the principle of parity. The
applicant has no criminal antecedents. He is a permanent resident and
engaged in lawful business activities. There is no possibility of
absconding or fleeing from justice.
12.
Prosecution witnesses are largely official or formal witnesses and
the evidence is documentary in nature. Hence, apprehension of
influencing witnesses is illusory. It is settled law that an accused is
presumed innocent until proven guilty. The pre-trial detention should not
become punitive. He submits that the liberty guaranteed under Article
21 of the Constitution mandates that detention pending trial must be
justified by compelling circumstances, which are absent here. He
contended that the applicant has remained in custody since September
2025 and trial involving enormous documentary and oral evidence will
take years and further has placed reliance in the matter of Manish
Sisodia v. Directorate of Enforcement (2024) SCC OnLine SC 920,
which is as under:
“Bail is not to be withheld as a punishment…
It appears that the trial courts and the High
Courts attempt to play safe in matters of
grant of bail… Bail is a rule and refusal is an
exception… It is high time that the trial courts
and the High Courts recognize the principle
that bail is rule and jail is exception.”
13.
Similarly, authority has been placed in the matter of Manish
Sisodia Vs. CBI, 2023 SCC OnLine SC 1393 wherein it was observed
that prolonged incarceration is violation of Article 21. In yet another
decision of the Supreme Court, ie. Javed Gulam Nabi Shaikh Vs,.
State of Maharashtra, (2024) 9 SCC 813, it has been held that
“Seriousness of the offence cannot justify denial of bail where trial is
unlikely to conclude within reasonable time.”
14.
The allegations attributed to the present applicant are broad,
omnibus and lacking in material particulars. Even according to the
prosecution narrative, the applicant is stated to have been “involved in
arrangements and movement of funds”, yet no specific transaction is
disclosed, no particular date, time or place is mentioned, no amount is
attributed, no recipient or beneficiary is identified, no circumstance
demonstrating active participation is established. Such generalized
allegations cannot constitute prima facie proof of involvement in
offences of conspiracy,cheating or corruption.
15.
In bail jurisprudence, vague assertions cannot justify continued
incarceration in absence of concrete material linking the accused to the
criminal acts. The allegations attributed to the applicant are sweeping
and general in nature, without identification of any specific transaction,
role performed, amount handled, beneficiary involved or direct
participation. Bail stage requires existence of prima facie material, not
mere suspicion or association. It is settled that detailed examination of
evidence is impermissible at the stage of bail. He has placed his
reliance in the matter of
Niranjan Singh & Anr. v. Prabhakar
Rajaram Kharote & Ors.(1980) 2 SCC 559, wherein it has been held
as under:
“Detailed examination of the evidence and
elaborate documentation of the merits
should be avoided while passing orders on
bail applications… To be satisfied about a
prima facie case is needed but it is not the
same as an exhaustive exploration of the
merits.”
16.
It is next contended that the applicant has been suffering from
chronic schizophrenia for nearly three decades, requiring continuous
psychiatric supervision, medication and periodic clinical evaluation.
Medical records and treatment documents issued by treating
psychiatrists have already been placed on record.
Adequate
psychiatric treatment is not available within jail conditions, and
incarceration has seriously impacted applicant’s mental stability and
safety. Thus, continued custody poses grave risk to his health and
personal well-being. He further submits that trial in the present case,
involving numerous accused persons, voluminous records, and
hundreds of witnesses, is unlikely to conclude within reasonable time.
17.
Reliance is placed upon Manish Sisodia v. Directorate of
Enforcement, 2024 SCC OnLine SC 920, wherein the Apex Court
reiterated:
“Bail is not to be withheld as punishment…
bail is rule and refusal an exception.”
18.
Reliance is also placed on Javed Gulam Nabi Shaikh v. State
of Maharashtra, (2024) 9 SCC 813, wherein it was held that prolonged
incarceration without likelihood of early trial violates constitutional
liberty.
19.
Further reliance is placed on Union of India v. K.A. Najeeb,
(2021) 3 SCC 713, wherein the Supreme Court has held that:
“Statutory
rigours
cannot
fetter
constitutional courts from granting bail
where trial is unlikely to conclude within
reasonable time.”
20.
Bail is therefore warranted not merely on legal grounds but also
on humanitarian considerations, ensuring access to proper medical
care under supervision of family and medical professionals. A
substantial portion of prosecution allegations is sought to be supported
by alleged WhatsApp chats.
Reliance placed by prosecution upon
Whatsapp chats and digital material is legally questionable at this
stage, as seizure, custody chain and certification requirements under
law are disputed issues to be tested during trial. It is contended that at
the stage of bail, the Courts are not expected to conduct a detailed
examination of evidence. Reliance is placed on Niranjan Singh Vs.
Prabhakar Rajaram Kharote (1980) 2 SCC 559, wherein the Apex
Court has observed that :
“Detailed examination of the evidence and
elaborate documentation of the merits
should be avoided while passing orders on
bail applications…”
21.
Further reliance is placed on P. Chidambaram v. CBI, (2020) 13
SCC 337, wherein it was held:
“At the stage of granting bail, elaborate
examination of evidence and detailed
reasons touching upon merits of the case
should be avoided…”
22.
However the mobile devices were not seized by the investigating
agency, no proper custody chain has been demonstrated, no forensic
extraction report has been produced, chats are stated to have been
sourced from Income Tax authorities without authentication and no
certification under Section 65B of the Evidence Act has been produced.
23.
In
absence
of
lawful
seizure,
forensic
verification,
and
certification, such electronic material cannot presently be treated as
legally
admissible
evidence.
Selective
reproduction
of
alleged
messages without establishing source, integrity, and authenticity
renders such material unreliable. In absence of legally admissible
electronic
evidence,
allegations
against
the
applicant
remain
unsubstantiated.
24.
It is significant that no incriminating material whatsoever has
been recovered from the applicant. No unaccounted currency,
documents, diaries, banking instruments, digital records or valuables
have been seized from him. If the prosecution theory of large-scale
movement of funds through the applicant were true, at least some
traceable recovery would have surfaced. The total absence of recovery
demolishes the prosecution’s attempt to link the applicant with alleged
financial transactions. Mere association or familial linkage with other
accused persons cannot constitute criminal liability. Even if prosecution
allegations are assumed at face value, essential ingredients of offences
alleged are not satisfied. There is no material to show the dishonest
inducement, forgery or fabrication of records, personal benefit derived
by applicant, criminal intent or participation. The allegations are
restricted to alleged harbouring or facilitating movement of funds
without demonstrating culpable intent.
25.
Consequently, prima facie ingredients of offences under Sections
420, 467, 468 IPC and Section 12 of the Prevention of Corruption Act
are not made out. The prosecution seeks to project disputed materials
as conclusive proof, whereas at bail stage courts are only required to
see existence of prima facie case without entering into merits. He has
placed reliance in the matter of P. Chidambaram v. Central Bureau
of Investigation, (2020) 13 SCC 337 wherein it has been observed
that
“At the stage of granting bail, elaborate
examination of evidence and detailed
reasons touching upon the merits of the
case should be avoided as the same may
prejudice the accused.”
26.
Pre-trial incarceration ought not degenerate into punitive
detention, a consistent exposition of the Apex Court jurisprudence. The
applicant has extended full cooperation throughout, poses no flight risk,
faces exclusively documentary evidence, and confronts a concluded
investigation. Continued custody is, thus, ex facie unjustified and liable
to be discountenanced. The allegations remain nebulous and bereft of
specificity; no recoveries implicate the applicant; electronic evidence is
inherently suspect; mens rea stands unestablished; incarceration
duration impugns Article 21 safeguards; trial commencement looms
indefinitely; and settled precepts mandate a liberal bail dispensation.
27.
In view of the settled juridical postulates and unimpeachable
facts canvassed, the applicant justly merits enlargement on bail.
SUBMISSIONS ON BEHALF OF THE RESPONDENT/STATE
28.
Learned State counsel submits that the allegations pertain to a
large-scale organized criminal conspiracy involving manipulation of the
State
liquor
trade,
illegal
commission
collection,
diversion
of
government revenue, and systematic generation and distribution of
proceeds of crime running into thousands of crores.
29.
The present applicant is not a peripheral or casual participant but
has emerged during investigation as a trusted custodian and
operational facilitator of tainted cash forming a crucial link in the
conspiracy. Considering the magnitude, organized structure, and
continuing investigation into financial trails, the present case stands in a
category where grant of bail would seriously prejudice ongoing
investigation.
30.
The investigation initiated on the basis of inputs received from
the Enforcement Directorate revealed existence of a structured
syndicate involving influential individuals, officials and private actors
who manipulated liquor procurement, distribution and licensing
processes within the State. The conspiracy resulted in generation of
illegal proceeds through collection of illegal commission from liquor
suppliers, sale of unaccounted liquor through State-run outlets using
fake holograms,
extraction of illegal gratification from distilleries to
permit business operations, diversion of lawful State revenue. These
acts caused enormous financial loss to the State exchequer and
enriched the conspirators.
31.
He contended that the investigation reveals that the syndicate,
led by co-accused Anwar Dhebar and others, generated and
distributed large amounts of illegal cash through controlled channels.
The present applicant, being a close and trusted associate of key
conspirators, was entrusted with custody, storage and distribution of
tainted funds. Cash was routinely brought in bags by associates and
shifted into premises linked with the applicant, including Hotel Giriraj,
from where onward distribution was undertaken. The applicant, along
with his son, facilitated safe storage and subsequent delivery of illegal
cash at designated locations as per instructions received from
syndicate leaders. Investigation further discloses that co-accused
persons used the applicant’s premises as a safe-house for movement
and concealment of proceeds of crime. Statements of co-accused and
other witnesses corroborate that tainted money was kept at premises
controlled by the applicant.
32.
The technical analysis of digital material including WhatsApp
communications establishes coded instructions relating to delivery and
disbursement of illegal funds. Chats contain coded references to
recipients, amounts and delivery points, demonstrating structured
financial operations and the ledger-type digital entries and date-wise
payment charts correlate with communications showing organized cash
distribution mechanisms. The entries reveal repeated large-value
payments routed through channels linked with the applicant. Such
digital correlation establishes prima facie involvement of the applicant
in custody and movement of illegal funds.
33.
It is contended that the investigation so far reveals that illegal
commissions and revenue diversion arising out of liquor operations
have resulted in generation of proceeds exceeding several thousand
crores. Consolidated analysis indicates illegal commission from country
liquor operations amounting to thousands of crores, illegal commissions
in foreign liquor operations,
illegal gains arising from misuse of
licensing framework and cumulative financial impact exceeding ₹3,000
crores and investigation suggesting further escalation. Such magnitude
places the offence among the gravest economic crimes affecting public
revenue.
34.
He submits that the investigation is multi-layered and continuing
to trace beneficiary chains, money trails and investments. Multiple
supplementary charge-sheets have already been filed and investigation
continues regarding additional aspects.
Mere filing of charge-sheet
against some accused does not conclude investigation in such complex
economic crimes. Further tracing of assets, proceeds of crime, and
financial linkages is ongoing.
35.
The applicant occupies a position enabling influence over
persons connected with cash handling and delivery mechanisms.
Material witnesses include persons directly connected with financial
movement and operational execution and therefore the release of the
applicant poses grave risk of influencing or intimidating witnesses and
tampering with documentary and digital evidence. The applicant also
possesses capability to obstruct financial tracing by altering asset
structures or frustrating attachment proceedings. In connected
proceedings arising from the same conspiracy, this Court has recorded
categorical findings regarding organized criminal activities and
likelihood of influence over witnesses. The observations made therein
regarding involvement of accused persons carry persuasive value and
reinforce seriousness of allegations.
36.
He submits that the economic offences involving diversion of
public revenue and organized corruption strike at the economic
foundation of governance. The Courts have repeatedly recognized that
economic crimes require serious consideration at bail stage owing to
their societal impact. The present offence involves systematic siphoning
of State revenue through manipulation of public systems. Defence
claims regarding absence of recovery or alleged infirmities in electronic
evidence are matters for trial and cannot dilute prima facie findings at
bail stage. Health grounds raised by the applicant can be adequately
addressed within custodial medical framework. Alleged cooperation
during investigation does not mitigate gravity of involvement and
investigation remains ongoing, the financial trails remain under
examination. Witnesses are yet to be examined therefore the release of
applicant would adversely affect investigation and trial.
37.
The applicant is prima facie a key facilitator in custody and
movement of proceeds of crime and the offence involves enormous
public revenue loss. He submits that the investigation remains
incomplete and possibility of influence and tampering exists. Therefore,
grant of bail at this stage would seriously prejudice investigation and
trial. In view of the facts and circumstances stated hereinabove, it is
respectfully prayed that this Court may be pleased to reject the bail
application filed by the applicant in the interest of justice.
FINDINGS AND CONCLUSION
38.
After hearing arguments from the learned counsel for both sides,
reviewed the case file meticulously, in essence.
39.
The present application necessitates examination of competing
considerations,
seriousness
of
allegations
on
one
hand
and
constitutional protection of personal liberty on the other within the
settled framework governing grant of bail.
40.
While the seriousness of allegations cannot be understated, the
scope of consideration at the stage of bail is limited and does not
involve a detailed appreciation of evidence which is the domain of trial.
I. Principles Governing Grant of Bail
41.
The law governing bail is well settled. The Apex Court has
consistently held that grant or refusal of bail must be governed by
judicial discretion exercised on settled parameters balancing individual
liberty with societal interest. In State of Rajasthan v. Balchand (1977)
4 SCC 308, the Apex Court laid down the foundational principle that
“bail is the rule and jail is the exception.”
42.
This principle was reiterated and elaborated in Gudikanti
Narasimhulu v. Public Prosecutor (1978) 1 SCC 240, wherein the
Court emphasized that deprivation of liberty pending trial must be
justified by compelling reasons and cannot be mechanical.
43.
Similarly, in Sanjay Chandra v. CBI (2012) 1 SCC 40, dealing
with economic offences involving large financial implications, the Apex
Court observed that seriousness of allegation alone cannot justify
prolonged pre-trial incarceration, particularly when investigation is
complete and trial is likely to take considerable time. The Court
observed that detention pending trial should not assume punitive
character.
44.
Further, in Dataram Singh v. State of Uttar Pradesh (2018) 3
SCC 22, it was reiterated that grant of bail is a general rule and refusal
an exception, and presumption of innocence continues until conviction.
45.
Likewise, in P. Chidambaram v. Directorate of Enforcement
(2020) 13 SCC 791, the Apex Court held that gravity of offence is an
important factor, but it cannot be the sole ground to deny bail when the
triple test — flight risk, possibility of tampering with evidence, and
likelihood of influencing witnesses is satisfied. Thus, judicial approach
must balance societal interest and personal liberty without pre-judging
guilt.
II. Completion of Investigation and Evidentiary Nature of Material
46.
In the instant case, the investigation has advanced considerably,
culminating in the filing of charge-sheets. The prosecution's narrative
hinges predominantly on documentary, digital, and financial evidence,
all of which has been meticulously gathered and safeguarded. No
compelling necessity for the applicant's custodial interrogation is
demonstrated at this juncture. Where the evidence is inherently
documentary and securely held, prolonged detention serves no
substantive investigative purpose.The Supreme Court in Sanjay
Chandra (supra) held that once the prosecution relies on documentary
evidence already in the investigating agency's possession, extended
detention ceases to be justified.
III. Parity with Co-Accused
48.
A substantial and weighty circumstance pressed into service by
the applicant is that several co-accused, including those alleged to be
the principal architects and beneficiaries of the purported conspiracy,
have already been enlarged on bail by competent courts. It is not in
dispute that in the present case multiple co-accused stand released on
bail, both by this Hon’ble Court and by the Hon’ble Supreme Court. The
principle of parity, therefore, squarely arises for consideration and
cannot be lightly disregarded while adjudicating the present application.
The co-accused Sanjay Mishra and Manish Mishra in MCRC
No. 7093 of 2025 (order dated 23.09.2025); Vijay Bhatia in MCRC
No. 5601 of 2025 (order dated 25.09.2025); Sunil Dutt in MCRC No.
188 of 2025 (order dated 12.03.2025); Abhishek Singh in MCRC No.
7790 of 2025 (order dated 11.11.2025); Chaitanya Baghel in MCRC
No. 8224 of 2025; Atul Singh in MCRC No. 8857 of 2025 (order
dated 13.01.2026); and Mukesh Manchanda in MCRC No. 8849 of
2025 (order dated 23.09.2025).
49.
Further, the Apex Court has also enlarged several co-accused on
bail, namely: Arvind Singh in SLP (Crl.) No. 2608 of 2025 (order
dated 19.05.2025); Amit Singh in SLP (Crl.) No. 2545 of 2025 (order
dated 19.05.2025); Deepak Duary in SLP (Crl.) No. 298 of 2025
(order dated 07.03.2025); Anurag Dwivedi in SLP (Crl.) No. 18386 of
2024 (order dated 07.03.2025); and Arunpati Tripathi in SLP (Crl.)
No. 14466 of 2024 (order dated 07.03.2025).
50.
Thus, persons alleged to have played major roles in the alleged
scheme already stand enlarged on bail. In comparison, the role
ascribed to the present applicant does not, at this stage, emerge as
graver than those co-accused already enlarged on bail. Absent
distinguishing
circumstances
warranting
differential
treatment,
continued detention of the applicant would offend the settled principle of
parity. Accordingly, parity with released co-accused constitutes a
compelling circumstance tilting the balance in favour of enlargement,
subject to safeguards ensuring fair trial and unhindered investigation.
51.
It is not disputed that the applicant's name does not figure in the
original
FIR,
surfacing
solely
during
investigation.
While
this
circumstance alone does not absolve liability, it retains material
relevance in the bail calculus. No direct recovery stands attributed to
the applicant. The prosecution's case pivots principally on digital
communications and financial analysis—evidence documentary in
character, secure against dissipation irrespective of custody.
52.
In Niranjan Singh v. Prabhakar Rajaram Kharote, (1980) 2
SCC 559, the Apex Court cautioned that the bail stage must not
degenerate into a mini-trial; courts are to assess only broad
probabilities, eschewing detailed evidence scrutiny.
53.
The applicant has endured incarceration for a considerable
duration, a factor that acquires heightened significance in the bail
matrix under Section 439 CrPC. Given the multiplicity of accused,
voluminous documentary evidence, and inherent complexity of
unraveling financial transactions, the prospect of early trial conclusion
appears remote and unrealistic. In Sanjay Chandra v. CBI, (2012) 1
SCC 40, the Apex Court has emphatically held that undertrial detention
cannot
metamorphose
into
punitive
incarceration
where
trial
prolongation is foreseeable; liberty cannot be sacrificed at the altar of
investigatory or prosecutorial delays.
54.
Under Article 21 of the Constitution, personal liberty stands
enshrined as a fundamental right—pending trial incarceration must
remain strictly commensurate with necessity, not morph into de facto
punishment preceding conviction (Maneka Gandhi v. Union of India,
(1978) 1 SCC 248; Hussainara Khatoon v. Home Secretary, State of
Bihar, (1980) 1 SCC 81).
55.
This Court, therefore, cannot countenance prolonged custody as
a substitute for trial expedition; such an approach would erode the
foundational principle that "bail is the rule, jail the exception" (State of
Rajasthan v. Balchand, (1977) 4 SCC 308).
Period Of Custody And likely Delay In Trial
56.
The State voices apprehension that the applicant's enlargement
may precipitate witness influence or investigatory interference.
However, no specific overt act or tangible material has been adduced
demonstrating the applicant's attempts to tamper while in custody. Such
generalized apprehensions stand adequately neutralized through
imposition
of
stringent
bail
conditions—ensuring
unwavering
cooperation, prohibiting evidence interference, and mandating regular
reporting. The Supreme Court in P. Chidambaram v. Directorate of
Enforcement, (2020) 13 SCC 227, expressly recognized that
meticulously
tailored
bail
conditions
can
effectively
safeguard
prosecutorial interests without necessitating prolonged incarceration.
Balancing Gravity and Liberty
57.
Economic offences, though grave with widespread societal
ramifications, cannot ipso facto eclipse the constitutional safeguard of
personal liberty under Article 21. The Apex Court in Sanjay Chandra v.
CBI, (2012) 1 SCC 40, authoritatively clarified that offence gravity alone
cannot justify bail denial post substantial investigation completion and
evidence securing—bail remains rule, not exception. Balancing
allegation gravity against investigation culmination, co-accused parity,
absent recovery, FIR omission, and protracted custody, the applicant's
continued detention appears neither necessary nor proportionate at this
stage.
58.
In the absence of any material placed on record demonstrating
that the role attributed to the present applicant is graver, exceptional, or
distinguishable from that of co-accused persons who have already
been enlarged on bail, selective continuation of their custody would
amount to discriminatory treatment, contrary to settled principles
governing grant of bail. Liberty cannot be curtailed on the basis of
selective application of criminal process, particularly when persons
alleged to be principal conspirators, facilitators, or beneficiaries of the
same transaction have already been granted liberty by competent
courts. Judicial discretion must operate uniformly and cannot result in
unequal treatment among similarly placed accused persons.
59.
This Court is also mindful of the well-settled legal position that
pre-trial incarceration is not punitive in nature and detention must be
justified by compelling considerations such as likelihood of absconding,
tampering with evidence, or influencing witnesses. No such exceptional
or compelling circumstances have been demonstrated against the
present applicants so as to warrant their continued confinement.
60.
More importantly, investigation qua the present applicant stands
completed and charge-sheet has already been filed before the trial
Court. The prosecution case now substantially rests upon documentary
and electronic evidence already secured and forming part of the record.
Therefore, continued custody of the applicant does not appear
necessary for purposes of investigation.
61.
Without entering into the merits of the allegations and confining
consideration strictly to the question of bail, this Court is of the
considered opinion that no compelling or justifiable reason survives at
this stage for further curtailment of the applicants’ personal liberty. The
ends of justice would be sufficiently safeguarded by enlarging the
applicant on bail, subject to appropriate conditions ensuring his
presence during trial and preventing interference with the course of
justice.
62.
In view of the totality of circumstances elucidated hereinabove
encompassing substantial investigation completion, predominantly
documentary evidence, co-accused parity, FIR omission, absent
recovery, protracted custody, trial delays, neutralized tampering
apprehensions, and offence gravity appropriately balanced, this Court
is of the considered opinion that the applicant merits enlargement on
bail. The application is allowed. The applicant shall be released
forthwith, subject to furnishing personal bond and surety to the
satisfaction of the Trial Court, alongside strict compliance with the
conditions delineated hereafter.
63.
Accordingly, continued incarceration of the applicant at this stage
is not warranted. It is directed that the Applicant shall be released on
bail upon furnishing a personal bond in the sum of ₹1,00,000/- (Rupees
One Lakh only) along with two local sureties of the like amount to the
satisfaction of the learned Trial Court, subject to the following
conditions:
(i) he shall surrender his passport, if any, before
the Trial Court;
(b) the applicant must cooperate with the
investigation and the trial proceedings;
(c) he shall not directly or indirectly make any
inducement, threat or promise to any person
acquainted with the facts of the case;
(d)
he shall commit no offence whatsoever
during the period he is on bail; and
(e) in case of change of residential address
and/or mobile number, the same shall be
intimated to the Court concerned by way of an
affidavit.
(f) any stringent conditions as may be imposed
by the trial court.
Sd/(Arvind Kumar Verma)
Judge
SUGUNA
DUBEY
Digitally signed
by SUGUNA
DUBEY
Date:
2026.03.03
17:32:05
+0530
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review