Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
2026:CGHC:24532
Digitally
VISHAKHA signed by
BEOHAR
VISHAKHA
BEOHAR
NAFR
HIGH COURT OF CHHATTISGARH AT BILASPUR
Reserved for orders on : 06.05.2026
Order passed on : 18.06.2026
WPC No. 6594 of 2025
1 - Niteen Kumar Singh S/o Dil Kumar Singh Aged About 27 Years R/o
Pradhanpara Darima, District- Surguja Chhattisgarh,
2 - Sahil Kari S/o R.K. Xalxo Aged About 28 Years R/o Kanchan Ganga,
Phase-2, Near Mobile Tower Danganiya, Raipur, District- Raipur
Chhattisgarh,
3 - Chandra Prakash Ravi S/o Manoj Kumar Ravi Aged About 27 Years
R/o House No.2/169, Mahua Para, Fundurdihari Ambikapur, DistrictSurguja Chhattisgarh.
4 - Sakshi Kanwar D/o Man Singh Kanwar Aged About 25 Years R/o 2D, 2nd D Type Hospital Sector Ward No.6, Dallirajhara PostDallirajhara District- Balod, Chhattisgarh,
... Petitioner(s)
versus
1 - State Of Chhattisgarh Through- The Secretary, Department Of
Health And Family Welfare And Medical Education Mahanadi Bhawan
Mantralaya, Atal Nagar Nava Raipur District Raipur Chhattisgarh,
2 - The Director Directorate Of Health And Family Welfare Government
Of Chhattisgarh, Raipur, District- Raipur Chhattisgarh,
3 - The Director Directorate Of Medical Education Dks Bhawan Parisar
Raipur, District- Raipur Chhattisgarh
4 - The Registrar Chhattisgarh Medical Council Raipur District- Raipur
Chhattisgarh,
5 - Vice Chancellor Pt. Deendayal Upadhyay Memorial Health Science
And Ayush University Of Chhattisgarh, Raipur, District- Raipur
Chhattisgarh,
6 - Dean Chhattisgarh Instutute Of Medical Sciences (Cims) Bilaspur,
District- Bilaspur Chhattisgarh
... Respondent(s)
(Cause-title is taken from Case Information System)
For Petitioners
:
Mr. Ashutosh Mishra, Advocate
For State
:
Mr. Soumitra Kesharwani, Panel Lawyer
For Resp. No. 4 :
Mr. Komal Prasad Sahu, Advocate holding
brief on behalf of Dr. Sudeep Agrawal,
Advocate
For Resp. No. 5 :
Mr. Sumit Verma, Advocate
(Single Bench)
Hon'ble Shri Justice Amitendra Kishore Prasad
CAV Order
1.
The present writ petition has been filed by the petitioners, who
completed their MBBS Course from Chhattisgarh Institute of
Medical Sciences in the year 2024 and thereafter successfully
completed their compulsory rotating medical internship in May,
2025. At the time of admission, the petitioners had executed a
bond undertaking to serve under the Government Medical Service
for a period of two years in accordance with the applicable
admission rules. It is the specific grievance of the petitioners that
despite the categorical stipulation contained in Rule 10, Sub-Rule
VI of the Chhattisgarh Medical, Dental and Physiotherapy Under
Graduate
Admission
Rules,
2025,
which
mandates
that
appointment orders are required to be issued by the State
authorities within a period of six months from completion of the
course, failing which the bond obligation automatically stands
cancelled,
the
respondent
authorities
neither
issued
any
appointment orders within the prescribed period nor granted the
mandatory No Objection Certificate (NOC) to the petitioners,
despite repeated representations and requests made in this
regard. It has further been averred that instead of adhering to the
statutory mandate and recognizing the automatic extinguishment
of the bond obligations upon expiry of the stipulated period, the
respondents proceeded to issue notice dated 08.12.2025 initiating
counselling for compulsory two-year Government service in
respect of students whose MBBS course and internship period fell
within the year 2025. According to the petitioners, since they had
already completed their MBBS course earlier and had completed
their compulsory rotating internship in May, 2025, and as no
appointment orders had been issued within the period prescribed
under the Rules, their bond obligations had already stood
cancelled by operation of law. However, despite such legal
position, the respondents failed to issue the requisite NOC in
favour of the petitioners, thereby depriving them of pursuing
higher studies and other professional opportunities. Being
aggrieved by the arbitrary inaction on the part of the respondents,
non-compliance of the statutory provisions, and the consequential
infringement of their fundamental rights guaranteed under Articles
14, 19(1)(g), and 21 of the Constitution of India, the petitioners
have approached this Court seeking appropriate directions for
issuance of NOC, acknowledgment of automatic cancellation of
the bond, and grant of following reliefs :
“10.1.Issue an appropriate writ, order or
direction commanding the respondent
authorities to forthwith issue the No
Objection Certificate (NOC) in favour of
the petitioners as mandated under Rule
10, Sub-Rule VI of the Chhattisgarh
Medical,
Dental
Under
Graduate
and
Physiotherapy
Admission
Rules,
2025;
10.2.Issue a writ of mandamus directing
the respondents to pass necessary
orders acknowledging the automatic
cancellation of the bond executed by
the petitioners at the time of their
admission in the MBBS Course, in
terms
of
the
statutory
provision
contained in Rule 10, Sub-Rule VI;
10.3. Issue an appropriate writ, order or
direction commanding the respondent
authorities particularly to respondent
No.5 university to Confer Degree to the
petitioners herein;
10.4. Grant any other relief/reliefs which
this Hon'ble Court may deem fit, just
and
proper
under
the
facts
and
circumstances of the case;”
2.
The facts, as pleaded in the present petition, reveal that the
petitioners were bona fide students of Chhattisgarh Institute of
Medical Sciences, Bilaspur, and pursued the M.B.B.S. Course
during the academic session 2019–2024. After successfully
completing the prescribed academic curriculum, clinical training,
and examinations conducted in accordance with the governing
medical education regulations, the petitioners completed their
MBBS Course in the year 2024 and thereafter became eligible to
undergo compulsory rotating medical internship as mandated
under the applicable regulations framed by the National Medical
Commission. In pursuance thereof, the petitioners underwent
compulsory rotating medical internship in terms of the National
Medical Commission (Compulsory Rotating Medical Internship)
Regulations, 2021, for the period commencing from May, 2024 to
May, 2025 at the affiliated hospitals and institutions attached with
Chhattisgarh Institute of Medical Sciences, Bilaspur. Upon
successful completion of the internship training, Internship
Completion Certificates were issued by the Dean of the institution
certifying completion of internship by the petitioners. Prior to
admission into the MBBS Course, the petitioners, along with other
similarly situated students, were required to execute a compulsory
service bond as a condition precedent for admission into the
Government medical institution. Under the terms and conditions of
the said bond, the petitioners undertook to serve under the
Government Medical Service for a period of two years after
completion of the MBBS Course and internship, subject to
issuance of appointment orders by the competent authorities
within the stipulated period prescribed under the governing rules.
Execution of the said bond was mandatory in nature and formed
an integral condition of admission imposed by the respondent
authorities. Despite successful completion of the MBBS Course in
the year 2024 and completion of compulsory internship in May,
2025, no appointment orders were issued in favour of the
petitioners within the time prescribed under the applicable rules.
Neither any posting order nor any communication regarding
Government service was issued by the respondent authorities
within six months from completion of the MBBS Course.
Simultaneously, the respondent authorities also failed to issue the
requisite No Objection Certificate (NOC), despite repeated
requests made by the petitioners for the same. Aggrieved by the
inaction and indifference on the part of the respondent authorities,
the petitioners submitted several representations before the
competent authorities requesting issuance of appointment orders
in accordance with the bond conditions and the applicable
statutory rules. Despite repeated representations and personal
approaches made by the petitioners, no action was taken by the
authorities and no appointment orders were issued. Upon expiry
of the statutory period of six months prescribed under the
governing Rules, the petitioners submitted further representations
requesting issuance of a No Objection Certificate (NOC) and
formal acknowledgment regarding cancellation of the bond
executed at the time of admission. The petitioners specifically
pointed out that in view of the applicable statutory provisions, the
bond obligations had already stood extinguished by operation of
law owing to failure on the part of the Government to issue
appointment orders within the prescribed period. However, the
respondent authorities neither considered nor decided the said
representations and continued to withhold issuance of the NOC
and bond cancellation order without any justification. Rule 10,
Sub-Rule
VI
Physiotherapy
of
the
Under
Chhattisgarh
Graduate
Medical,
Admission
Dental
and
Rules,
specifically provides that after completion of the MBBS Course,
the Government through the Medical Education Department is
required to issue appointment orders to such graduate doctors
within a period of six months, failing which the bond furnished by
the candidate shall automatically stand cancelled. Thus, by
operation of the statutory rule itself, the bond obligations
undertaken by the petitioners automatically ceased to exist upon
failure of the respondents to issue appointment orders within the
stipulated period. Despite the clear statutory mandate, the
requests made by the petitioners for issuance of NOC and
acknowledgment of cancellation of bond were arbitrarily ignored
by the respondent authorities. Subsequently, in complete
disregard of the aforesaid statutory provisions, the respondent
authorities issued a notice dated 08.12.2025 initiating counselling
for compulsory two-year Government service in respect of
students who had completed the MBBS Course during the year
2025. The issuance of the said notice clearly demonstrated
arbitrary and discriminatory action on the part of the respondent
authorities, particularly when the petitioners’ bond obligations had
already stood automatically cancelled by operation of law due to
non-issuance of appointment orders within the prescribed period.
Aggrieved by the persistent inaction and arbitrary conduct of the
respondent authorities, and by failure to issue the mandatory No
Objection Certificate despite automatic cancellation of the bond
obligations under Rule 10, Sub-Rule VI of the Chhattisgarh
Medical, Dental and Physiotherapy Under Graduate Admission
Rules, 2025, the petitioners have preferred the present writ
petition seeking issuance of appropriate writ, order, or direction
commanding the respondents to issue the requisite No Objection
Certificate, acknowledge cancellation of the bond obligations, and
grant consequential reliefs in favour of the petitioners.
3.
Learned counsel appearing for the petitioners submits that the
action as well as continued inaction on the part of the respondent
authorities is wholly arbitrary, unreasonable, and violative of
Article 14 of the Constitution of India. It is contended that the
entire controversy in the present case is squarely governed by
Rule 10, Sub-Rule VI of the Chhattisgarh Medical, Dental and
Physiotherapy Under Graduate Admission Rules, 2025, which
unequivocally mandates that after completion of the MBBS
Course,
the
Government
through
the
Medical
Education
Department is required to issue appointment orders to such
graduate doctors within a period of six months, failing which the
bond furnished by the candidate shall automatically stand
cancelled. Learned counsel submits that the petitioners completed
their MBBS Course in the year 2024 and thereafter completed
their compulsory rotating internship in May, 2025, yet no
appointment orders were issued to them within the statutory
period prescribed under the Rules. Consequently, by operation of
law itself, the bonds executed by the petitioners at the time of
admission stood automatically cancelled and extinguished.
Despite the clear statutory mandate, the respondent authorities
have continued to act as though the bond obligations are still
subsisting, which is ex facie illegal and unsustainable in law.
Learned counsel further submits that at the time of admission into
Chhattisgarh
Institute
of
Medical
Sciences,
Bilaspur,
the
petitioners were compelled to execute compulsory service bonds
requiring them to render two years of Government service in rural
areas upon completion of the MBBS Course and internship. It is
submitted that under the applicable Rules, the bond amount was
fixed at Rs. 25,00,000/- for unreserved category students and Rs.
20,00,000/- for reserved category students. Learned counsel
draws attention of this Court towards Rule 11 of the Rules of
2025, which provides that in the event a candidate fails to appear
in the third round of counselling for compulsory Government
service or declines to serve, such candidate would be liable to
deposit the aforesaid bond amount. However, it is argued that the
liability contemplated under Rule 11 can arise only when the State
first fulfills its own statutory obligation under Rule 10(6) by issuing
appointment orders within the prescribed period of six months.
Since the respondents themselves failed to comply with the
mandatory requirement of issuing appointment orders within the
stipulated period, they cannot subsequently compel the petitioners
to participate in counselling or threaten recovery of the bond
amount. Learned counsel for the petitioners further submits that
the respondents have acted contrary to the doctrine of legitimate
expectation. According to learned counsel, the petitioners had
executed the compulsory service bonds only on the legitimate
assurance and expectation that the State Government would act
in accordance with the governing statutory framework and issue
appointment orders within the period prescribed under Rule 10(6).
It is submitted that after compelling the petitioners to execute
bonds containing severe financial consequences, the respondents
failed to discharge their reciprocal statutory obligations and
thereafter attempted to impose liability upon the petitioners for no
fault attributable to them. Such arbitrary conduct on the part of the
State authorities, according to learned counsel, strikes at the very
root of fairness in administrative action and is therefore violative of
Article 14 of the Constitution of India. It is further contended that
despite repeated representations submitted by the petitioners
requesting issuance of appointment orders, the respondent
authorities neither responded to the said representations nor took
any decision thereupon. Even after expiry of the statutory period
of six months, when the petitioners approached the authorities
seeking issuance of No Objection Certificates (NOC) and
acknowledgment regarding cancellation of bond obligations, the
respondents maintained complete silence and failed to consider
the legitimate grievances raised by the petitioners. Learned
counsel submits that such conduct on the part of the authorities
clearly demonstrates administrative apathy, non-application of
mind, and arbitrary exercise of power. The failure of the
respondents to either decide the representations or communicate
any reason for withholding issuance of NOC has rendered the
impugned inaction wholly illegal and unsustainable in law.
Learned counsel further submits that the impugned notice dated
08.12.2025,
whereby
counselling
for
compulsory
two-year
Government service has been initiated, is wholly without
jurisdiction and directly contrary to Rule 10, Sub-Rule VI of the
Rules of 2025. It is argued that once the statutory period of six
months expired without issuance of appointment orders, the bond
obligations automatically stood cancelled by operation of law, and
therefore the respondents ceased to have any authority to compel
the petitioners to participate in counselling or render compulsory
Government service. The impugned notice, according to learned
counsel, amounts to an impermissible attempt on the part of the
respondents to revive obligations which had already stood
extinguished under the statutory Rules. Such action is nothing but
a colourable exercise of power undertaken in complete disregard
of the mandatory statutory provisions governing the field.
Learned counsel also submits that the petitioners, having
completed their MBBS Course and compulsory internship, are
fully qualified medical graduates entitled to pursue higher studies,
private employment, or any other professional opportunities
available to them in accordance with law. However, due to
arbitrary withholding of the No Objection Certificate and nonrecognition of cancellation of the bond obligations, the petitioners
have been prevented from pursuing their professional careers and
academic advancement. It is argued that such arbitrary restriction
imposed by the respondents directly infringes the petitioners’
fundamental rights guaranteed under Articles 19(1)(g) and 21 of
the Constitution of India, which encompass the right to practice a
profession of one’s choice and the right to livelihood and dignity.
Learned counsel submits that the petitioners cannot be made to
suffer indefinitely on account of the administrative failures and
inaction attributable solely to the respondent authorities.
It is
further argued that no prejudice whatsoever would be caused to
the State Government if the reliefs sought by the petitioners are
granted, particularly when the statutory Rules themselves provide
for automatic cancellation of the bond in the event of failure to
issue appointment orders within six months. Once the bond
obligations ceased to exist by operation of law, the respondents
lost all authority to enforce the same or to compel the petitioners
either to participate in counselling or to deposit the bond amount.
Learned counsel submits that the State cannot be permitted to
take advantage of its own wrong by first failing to comply with the
mandatory statutory provisions and thereafter seeking to enforce
punitive conditions against the petitioners.
In support of the
aforesaid submissions, learned counsel for the petitioners has
placed reliance upon the order dated 16.06.2023 passed by this
Court in WPC No. 5469 of 2021, Doctors Rakhi Pandey vs
State of Chhattisgarh and others, wherein similar issues relating
to compulsory service bond obligations were considered by this
Court. Reliance has also been placed upon the judgment dated
22.01.2024, rendered by the High Court of Madhya Pradesh in
WP No. 1594 of 2024, Doctors Manisha Agrawal vs State of
Madhya Pradesh and others along with connected matters,
wherein the Court, while interpreting similar bond conditions and
statutory provisions, granted relief in favour of the petitioners
therein. On the strength of the aforesaid judgments, learned
counsel submits that the present writ petition deserves to be
allowed and the respondents be directed to issue No Objection
Certificates and formally acknowledge cancellation of the bond
obligations in favour of the petitioners.
4.
Per contra, learned State counsel vehemently opposes the
submissions advanced on behalf of the petitioners and submits
that the present writ petition is wholly misconceived, devoid of
merit, and liable to be dismissed at the threshold. Learned State
counsel submits that the petitioners have failed to demonstrate
existence of any enforceable legal right warranting interference by
this Court in exercise of jurisdiction under Article 226 of the
Constitution of India. According to the State, the petitioners are
seeking to evade and avoid the contractual and statutory
obligations voluntarily undertaken by them at the time of
admission into the MBBS Course, after having availed the benefit
of admission under the State quota in Government medical
institutions. Learned State counsel submits that the petitioners
were admitted into the MBBS Course at Chhattisgarh Institute of
Medical Sciences, Bilaspur in the year 2019 and, at the time of
their admission, the governing field was occupied by the
Chhattisgarh Medical, Dental and Physiotherapy Under Graduate
Admission Rules, 2018. It is submitted that under Rule 10(A) of
the Rules, 2018, every candidate admitted to Government
Medical Colleges was mandatorily required to execute a bond
undertaking that after successful completion of the MBBS Course
and internship, such candidate would serve under the State
Government as a Medical Officer in Government Health Centres
or Government Medical Colleges for a period of two years.
Learned State counsel submits that the petitioners voluntarily
executed the bonds without any protest or objection and accepted
all terms and conditions contained therein. The amount of the
bond was fixed at Rs. 25,00,000/- for unreserved category
candidates and Rs. 20,00,000/- for reserved category candidates.
Having accepted admission and all consequential benefits flowing
therefrom, the petitioners cannot now be permitted to challenge or
avoid the very conditions on the basis of which such admission
was granted. Learned State counsel further submits that the very
object and purpose behind incorporating the bond condition in the
Admission Rules was to ensure availability of qualified medical
practitioners in rural and remote areas of the State, particularly in
Government Primary Health Centres, Community Health Centres,
and Government Medical Colleges facing acute shortage of
doctors. It is argued that the policy underlying the bond condition
is a welfare-oriented measure intended to strengthen public
healthcare infrastructure and provide medical services to rural
populations. According to learned counsel, the State never
intended to create unnecessary restrictions upon the professional
advancement of medical graduates, but the bond condition was
incorporated
solely
to
ensure
that
doctors
educated
in
Government institutions at subsidized cost render public service
for a limited duration in return.
Learned State counsel further
submits that the reliance placed by the petitioners upon Rule 10,
Sub-Rule
VI
of
the
Chhattisgarh
Medical,
Dental
and
Physiotherapy Under Graduate Admission Rules, 2025 is
misconceived and deserves rejection. It is argued that the
expression “completion of MBBS Course” cannot be interpreted in
isolation and necessarily includes successful completion of
compulsory rotating medical internship as prescribed under the
norms of the National Medical Commission. In this regard, learned
State counsel has referred to the Frequently Asked Questions
relating to Competency Based Medical Education (CBME)
curriculum and communication dated 01.08.2023 issued by the
Undergraduate Medical Education Board of the National Medical
Commission, wherein it has been clarified that the MBBS Course
consists of four and a half academic years followed by one year
compulsory rotating internship. It is therefore contended that the
MBBS Course can be said to have been completed only upon
successful completion of internship.
Learned State counsel
submits that in the present case, the petitioners completed their
internships between 21.05.2025 and 03.06.2025 and immediately
thereafter the Dean of Chhattisgarh Institute of Medical Sciences,
Bilaspur vide communication dated 18.06.2025 forwarded the
names of the petitioners to the Commissioner, Medical Education
for issuance of appointment orders. Acting promptly thereupon,
the
Commissioner,
Medical
Education
vide
letter
dated
10.09.2025 forwarded the cases of the petitioners to the State
Government for issuance of appointment orders. Thereafter, the
Directorate of Health Services initiated the counselling process by
issuing notice dated 08.12.2025 inviting all eligible candidates,
including the petitioners, to participate in online counselling
scheduled between 09.12.2025 to 12.12.2025 for allotment of
postings under compulsory Government service. It is contended
that the entire process was undertaken expeditiously and strictly
in accordance with the governing Rules and procedure prescribed
by the State Government. Learned State counsel further submits
that the petitioners themselves participated in the counselling
proceedings without raising any objection whatsoever in relation
to the bond conditions or alleged automatic cancellation thereof.
After conclusion of the counselling process, appointment orders
dated 24.12.2025 were issued in favour of the petitioners posting
them at various Community Health Centres and Primary Health
Centres situated in districts Bijapur and Narayanpur for rendering
services under the compulsory service bond. It is contended that
once the petitioners voluntarily participated in the counselling
process and accepted the process of allotment, they are estopped
from turning around and challenging the same at a subsequent
stage. Learned counsel submits that the doctrine of approbation
and reprobation squarely applies in the present case and the
petitioners cannot be permitted to simultaneously accept the
benefits of admission under the Rules while rejecting the
obligations flowing therefrom. Learned State counsel further
argues that the doctrine of election clearly prohibits a party from
accepting and rejecting the same instrument at different stages
according to convenience. It is submitted that the petitioners, after
securing admission in Government medical colleges under the
State quota and executing the bonds voluntarily, cannot now seek
exemption from the very service obligations undertaken by them.
The petitioners cannot be permitted to approbate and reprobate
simultaneously by taking advantage of the admission process
while refusing to discharge their reciprocal obligations towards the
State. It is further contended by learned State counsel that despite
issuance of appointment orders dated 24.12.2025, the petitioners
deliberately failed to join at their respective places of posting in
Community Health Centres and Primary Health Centres situated
in Bijapur and Narayanpur districts. Such conduct, according to
the State, constitutes a clear violation of the bond conditions as
well as Rule 10(A) of the Rules, 2018. Consequently, the
petitioners
became
liable
to
pay
the
bond
amount
of
Rs.25,00,000/- in case of unreserved category candidates and
Rs.20,00,000/- in case of reserved category candidates. Learned
counsel submits that under the applicable Rules, the said amount
is recoverable as arrears of land revenue and unless the
petitioners deposit the requisite amount, they are not entitled to
issuance of No Objection Certificate (NOC).
Learned State
counsel further submits that the impugned counselling notice
dated 08.12.2025 and consequential appointment orders dated
24.12.2025 were issued strictly in accordance with the Rules
governing the field and after following due process. Significantly,
the petitioners have not challenged the appointment order dated
24.12.2025 in the present writ petition. In absence of challenge to
the said appointment orders, the petitioners cannot seek a
declaration that their bonds stood automatically cancelled.
Learned counsel submits that the respondents have acted strictly
within the four corners of law and there is no arbitrariness,
illegality, mala fide, or violation of constitutional rights as alleged
by the petitioners. Lastly, learned State counsel submits that the
relief sought by the petitioners, if granted, would defeat the very
object of compulsory rural service policy framed by the State
Government for strengthening healthcare facilities in rural and
tribal areas of the State. It is therefore prayed that the writ petition
being devoid of merit, substance, and any enforceable legal right
deserves to be dismissed.
5.
Learned counsel appearing for respondent No. 4, Chhattisgarh
Medical Council, supports submission made by learned State
counsel and submits that the role of the Medical Council is limited
only to registration and regulatory functions in accordance with
the applicable statutory provisions and the Council has no
authority in matters relating to execution, enforcement, or
cancellation of service bonds executed by MBBS students with
the State Government. It is submitted that issuance of
appointment orders, No Objection Certificates (NOC), and
enforcement of compulsory Government service conditions fall
exclusively within the domain of the State Government and
Medical Education Department.
6.
Learned counsel appearing for respondent No. 5, Pt. Deendayal
Upadhyay Memorial Health Sciences and Ayush University of
Chhattisgarh, also adopts submission advanced on behalf of
learned State counsel and also submits that the University
functions merely as the affiliating and degree-granting authority
and has no independent role in relation to compulsory
Government service bonds or issuance of appointment orders. It
is further submitted that the University acts upon communications
and directions issued by the competent authorities of the State
Government and Medical Education Department, and therefore no
cause of action survives against respondent No. 5 in the present
proceedings.
7.
Having heard learned counsel for the parties at considerable
length and after carefully considering the entire material available
on record, this Court finds that the controversy involved in the
present writ petition lies within a narrow compass and primarily
revolves around interpretation and applicability of Rule 10(6) of
the Chhattisgarh Medical, Dental and Physiotherapy Under
Graduate Admission Rules, 2025.
8.
Learned counsel appearing for respondents No. 4 and 5 have
supported the stand taken by the State Government and have
contended that since the petitioners failed to join at their
respective places of posting pursuant to the appointment orders
issued by the respondent authorities, they have violated the terms
and conditions of the compulsory service bonds executed by them
at the time of admission into the MBBS Course. It has been
submitted that in view of such violation, the petitioners are liable
to deposit the prescribed penalty amount under the governing
Rules and unless and until the said amount is deposited, no No
Objection Certificate (NOC) can be issued in their favour.
According to the respondents, the petitioners, after having availed
admission in Government medical colleges under the State quota
and after having voluntarily executed the bonds without protest,
cannot now seek to evade the obligations arising therefrom. It has
thus been urged that the writ petition is devoid of merit and
deserves dismissal at the threshold.
9.
The central question which arises for consideration before this
Court is whether the petitioners, who admittedly completed their
MBBS Course and compulsory rotating internship within the
period mentioned in the petition, are liable to deposit the penalty
amount contemplated under the Rules despite failure of the
respondent authorities to issue appointment orders within the
statutory period of six months. Consequentially, this Court is also
required to determine whether the respondents are justified in
withholding issuance of No Objection Certificates (NOC) in favour
of the petitioners and whether the appointment orders issued
subsequent to expiry of the prescribed statutory period can be
enforced against them.
10.
In order to appreciate the rival contentions raised by the parties,
this Court deems it appropriate to first advert to the relevant
statutory framework governing the field. Rule 10 of the
Chhattisgarh Medical, Dental and Physiotherapy Under Graduate
Admission Rules, 2025 deals with execution of compulsory
service bonds by candidates admitted to Government medical
colleges. Rule 10(1), Rule 10(2), Rule 10(3), Rule 10(6), Rule
10(7), and Rule 10(10) are of particular relevance for adjudication
of the present dispute and are quoted hereunder :
“10. Bond for candidates taking
admission in MBBS course to serve
under the State Government (i) It shall be compulsory for a student
admitted
to
MBBS
course
of
Government Medical Colleges, that
after successful completion of the under
graduation course, he shall work as a
Medical Officer in Government Health
Centre or Government Medical College
as
Junior
Registrar/Demonstrator
/Junior Resident for a period of one
year as directed by the Government.
This shall not be compulsory for other
courses (BDS, BPT).
(ii) Bond to work under the Government
(Format Schedule V) At the time of
admission a candidate shall have to
furnish a bond in the prescribed form
that he/she agrees to the provisions of
Rule 10(1) and that in case he/she opts
not to work under the Government
he/she will deposit the bond amount as
prescribed in Rule 10(3). Only after
he/she has deposited the full amount
due will be issued a No Objection
Certificate as prescribed.
(iii) The amount of the bond will be Rs.
25,00,000/- (Rs. Twenty lakhs only for
unreserved category candidates) and
the amount of the bond will be Rs.
20,00,000/- (Rs. Twenty lakhs only) for
reserved category students.
xxx
xxx
xxx
(vi) After completion of MBBS course,
within a period of six months, CG
Government,
Department
will
Medical
Education
issue
appointment
order to such graduate doctors, failing
which the bond filled by the candidate
will be deemed to be automatically
cancelled.
(vii) After fulfilling the service period
condition as per rule 10 (1) or after all
dues have been deposited as per rule
10 (3) or after obtaining a bank
guarantee from the candidate for the
balance period, as the case may be
(depending on the option exercised by
the candidate), the Commissioner shall
issue a No Objection Certificate to the
candidate.
xxx
xxx
xxx
(x) Penalty for not complying with rule
10 (1) If a candidate opts to serve
under the Government and is found
guilty of not complying with rule 10(1),
the entire amount of the bond as
mentioned in rule 10 (iii) shall be
recovered
from
arrears
land
of
the
candidate
revenue
by
as
the
appointing office under sub-rule (vi)
above. Such candidate shall not be
granted No Objection Certificate as
mentioned in rule 10(vii) until the entire
amount due is recovered.”
11.
A conjoint reading of the aforesaid provisions demonstrates that
while the Rules obligate students admitted in Government medical
institutions to render compulsory Government service for a period
of two years after completion of MBBS Course and internship, the
Rules simultaneously cast a corresponding statutory obligation
upon the State Government to issue appointment orders to such
graduate doctors within a period of six months from completion of
the course and internship. Most significantly, Rule 10(6)
unequivocally stipulates that if appointment orders are not issued
within the prescribed period of six months, the bond furnished by
the candidate shall automatically stand cancelled. Thus, the Rules
not only impose obligations upon students but also prescribe
corresponding duties upon the State authorities, together with
consequences for non-compliance thereof.
12.
From perusal of the pleadings and documents brought on record,
certain facts emerge as undisputed. It is not disputed that the
petitioners were admitted into the MBBS Course at Chhattisgarh
Institute of Medical Sciences during the academic session 2019–
2024. It is further not disputed that after successful completion of
the MBBS Course, the petitioners underwent compulsory rotating
medical internship in accordance with the Regulations framed by
the National Medical Commission and completed the same
between 21.05.2025 and 03.06.2025 respectively. It is also not
disputed that the Dean of the institution communicated completion
of internship and eligibility of the petitioners for appointment to the
competent authorities vide communication dated 18.06.2025.
Therefore, the factual position regarding successful completion of
MBBS
Course
and
internship
by
the
conclusively established from the records.
petitioners
stands
13.
The records further reveal that despite completion of internship
and communication thereof by the Dean of the institution, no
appointment orders were issued in favour of the petitioners within
the statutory period prescribed under Rule 10(6) of the Rules of
2025. It further transpires that till issuance of notice dated
08.12.2025, no counselling proceedings were initiated by the
respondents and no posting orders were issued to the petitioners
for compulsory Government service. The petitioners, on the
contrary, repeatedly approached the authorities by submitting
representations requesting issuance of appointment orders in
terms of the Rules so that they could discharge the obligations
contemplated under the bond. However, despite repeated
representations, no decision was taken by the respondents within
the prescribed statutory period. The materials placed on record
unmistakably demonstrate that the delay in issuance of
appointment orders is solely attributable to the respondent
authorities and not to any conduct on the part of the petitioners.
14.
This Court also finds substance in the grievance raised by the
petitioners that even after expiry of the statutory period of six
months, the respondent authorities failed to take any decision on
their request for issuance of No Objection Certificates and
acknowledgment regarding cancellation of the bond obligations.
Instead of complying with the statutory consequences flowing
from Rule 10(6), the respondents sought to initiate counselling
proceedings vide notice dated 08.12.2025 and thereafter issued
appointment orders dated 24.12.2025 posting the petitioners in
various Community Health Centres and Primary Health Centres
situated in districts Bijapur and Narayanpur.
15.
The chronology of events clearly reveals that the respondents
attempted to enforce the bond obligations only after expiry of the
period prescribed under the Rules and after the statutory
consequences under Rule 10(6) had already come into operation.
At this stage, it would be apposite to examine the language
employed in Rule 10(6) of the Rules of 2025. The Rule specifically
provides that after completion of MBBS Course and internship,
appointment orders are required to be issued by the Chhattisgarh
Medical Education Department within six months, “failing which
the bond filled by the candidate will be deemed to be
automatically cancelled.”
16.
The phraseology employed in the Rule leaves no room for
ambiguity. The legislature, in its wisdom, has consciously used the
expression “shall” while prescribing the obligation upon the State
Government and further employed the phrase “deemed to be
automatically cancelled” for prescribing the consequence of failure
to comply with such obligation. The legal effect of a deeming
provision is well settled in law.
17.
Once the contingency contemplated under the Rule occurs, the
consequence provided therein follows automatically without
requiring any further adjudication or formal declaration. Thus,
once six months elapsed from the date of completion of MBBS
Course and internship without issuance of appointment orders,
the bonds executed by the petitioners stood extinguished by
operation of law itself. The cancellation contemplated under Rule
10(6) is automatic, self-operative, and mandatory in nature. The
respondents,
therefore,
ceased
to
possess
any
authority
thereafter either to compel the petitioners to participate in
counselling proceedings or to enforce the terms of a bond which
had already stood cancelled by statutory fiction. Any subsequent
action undertaken by the respondents after expiry of the statutory
period cannot revive an obligation which had already ceased to
exist under the Rules governing the field.
18.
The submission advanced by the respondents that the petitioners
voluntarily participated in the counselling process and are
therefore estopped from seeking relief before this Court also does
not merit acceptance. The records clearly reveal that the
petitioners had consistently represented before the authorities
seeking appointment within the prescribed period and had
thereafter sought issuance of NOC upon expiry of the statutory
period. Participation in counselling proceedings initiated belatedly
by the respondents after expiry of six months cannot operate as
waiver of a statutory right accrued in favour of the petitioners
under Rule 10(6).
19.
It is trite law that there can be no estoppel against a statute. Once
the statute itself declares that the bond shall stand automatically
cancelled upon non-issuance of appointment orders within six
months, such statutory consequence cannot be nullified merely
because the petitioners participated in counselling proceedings
initiated after expiry of the prescribed period. Equally untenable is
the contention of the respondents that the petitioners are liable to
deposit penalty amount for failure to join pursuant to appointment
orders dated 24.12.2025.
20.
In the considered opinion of this Court, once the bond obligations
themselves stood extinguished prior to issuance of the said
appointment orders, the consequential appointment orders
become unenforceable and incapable of creating any binding
legal obligation upon the petitioners. The very foundation for
imposition of penalty under the Rules is existence of a valid and
subsisting bond obligation. Once the bond stood automatically
cancelled by operation of Rule 10(6), the respondents lost
authority to invoke penal consequences against the petitioners.
Therefore, the insistence of the respondents upon payment of
Rs.25,00,000/- in case of unreserved category candidates and
Rs.20,00,000/- in case of reserved category candidates is wholly
arbitrary, illegal, and contrary to the statutory framework
governing the field.
21.
This Court also cannot lose sight of the fact that the petitioners
are young medical graduates who have successfully completed
rigorous academic and internship requirements under the
regulatory framework of the National Medical Commission. The
arbitrary withholding of No Objection Certificates and continued
insistence upon non-existent bond obligations directly impedes
their right to pursue higher education, employment opportunities,
and professional advancement. The respondents, after failing to
discharge their own statutory obligations within the prescribed
timeline, cannot be permitted to prejudice the professional careers
of the petitioners by relying upon obligations which have already
stood extinguished by operation of law. Such action on the part of
the respondents is clearly arbitrary and violative of Articles 14,
19(1)(g), and 21 of the Constitution of India.
22.
This Court is fortified in the aforesaid view by the order dated
16.06.2023 passed by this Court in Doctors Rakhi Pandey vs
State of Chhattisgarh and others, wherein similar issues
relating to compulsory service bond obligations were considered.
This Court also finds support from the judgment dated
22.01.2024 rendered by the High Court of Madhya Pradesh in
Doctors Manisha Agrawal vs State of Madhya Pradesh and
others along with connected matters, wherein while interpreting
analogous statutory provisions, it was held that once the State
authorities fail to issue appointment orders within the prescribed
period, the bond obligations automatically stand cancelled and
cannot thereafter be enforced against the candidates.
23.
Accordingly, in light of the foregoing discussions and considering
the mandatory provisions contained in Rule 10(6) of the
Chhattisgarh Medical, Dental and Physiotherapy Under Graduate
Admission Rules, 2025, this Court has no hesitation in holding
that since the respondents failed to issue appointment orders to
the petitioners within a period of six months from the date of
completion of MBBS Course and internship, the bonds executed
by the petitioners stood automatically cancelled by operation of
law. Consequently, the appointment orders dated 24.12.2025
issued in favour of the petitioners after expiry of the statutory
period of six months are held to be unenforceable and of no legal
consequence. The same shall not bind the petitioners in any
manner whatsoever.
24.
It is further held that the petitioners cannot be compelled either to
join at the places of posting pursuant to the said appointment
orders or to participate in counselling proceedings initiated vide
notice dated 08.12.2025. The petitioners shall not be liable to
deposit any penalty amount of Rs.25,00,000/- in respect of
unreserved category candidates or Rs.20,00,000/- in respect of
reserved category candidates pursuant to the bonds executed by
them at the time of admission.
25.
The respondents are directed to forthwith issue No Objection
Certificates (NOC) in favour of the petitioners without insisting
upon payment of any bond amount or penalty. Respondent No. 5,
Pt. Deendayal Upadhyay Memorial Health Sciences and Ayush
University of Chhattisgarh, is further directed to confer MBBS
Degrees upon the petitioners, if not already conferred, in
accordance with law and without insisting upon production of any
NOC relating to compulsory service bond obligations.
26.
With the aforesaid observations and directions, the writ petition
stands allowed.
No order as to costs.
Sd/-
Sd/(Amitendra Kishore Prasad)
Judge
Shayna / Vishakha
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review