Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
IN THE HIGH COURT AT CALCUTTA
CIVIL REVISIONAL JURISDICTION
APPELLATE SIDE
PRESENT:
THE HON’BLE DR. JUSTICE AJOY KUMAR MUKHERJEE
C.O. 3907 of 2024
Nisha Shah
Vs.
Madhuri Chandra & Ors.
For the Petitioner
:
Mr. Souvik Sen
Heard on
:
12.12.2025
Judgment on
:
27.01.2026
Dr. Ajoy Kumar Mukherjee, J.
1.
Petitioner herein has assailed the order dated 7th August, 2024 passed
by the Civil Judge (Senior Division) 9th court Alipore in Ejectment Suit no.
58 of 2022.
2.
The principal opposite parties(OP) herein as landlords filed aforesaid
Ejectment suit no. 58 of 2022 with a prayer for recovery of khas possession
and consequential reliefs. The defendant/petitioners appeared in the suit
after receiving summons and filed two applications under section 7(1) and
7(2) of the West Bengal Premises Tenancy Act, 1997 (in short Act of 1997).
Plaintiffs /OP herein filed written objection against said application. Upon
contested hearing learned Court below was pleased to dispose of said two
applications by an order dated 17.08.2023, with the observation that the
challans filed by the defendants portrays that they have paid the rent of the
suit premises on and from the month of November, 2011 to October, 2022
before the Rent controller, except the month of May to July 2012. He further
observed that the challans in connection with the deposit of monthly rent for
the months of March, 2017 to November 2022 was made in the name of a
dead person. He also observed that challans in support of payment of rent
for the month May 2012 to July 2012
were never submitted and the
defendants submitted Carbon copy of General Diary which reflect that the
said challans are missing.
3.
Based on the submissions made by the parties the court below further
held that defendant failed to submit valid document in support of payment
of rent for the months of September to October 2011, May to July, 2012 and
March 2017 to November, 2022 and thereby calculated that the arrear rent
for the aforesaid 68 months @ Rs. 9550/- per month is Rs. 6,97,150/-.
However, the Court held that since the defendants have stated that they
have made payment before the Rent controller in the name of dead person,
being the original land lord for the period from March, 2017 till November,
2022 they were directed to withdraw such amount from Rent Controller and
to deposit the same afresh before the court, so that the plaintiff can avail the
same.
He further held that since the defendants are required to make
payment of rent for the month of September, 2011 to October 2011 and May
2012 to July 2012 and also from January 2023 to August, 2023, so they
were directed to make payment of Rs. 1,24,150/- along with interest within
one month of the date of the passing of the order without fail and they were
further directed to make payment of the current rent from the month of
September, 2023 within 7th of each succeeding month. Be it mentioned that
aforesaid order was not challenged by either of the parties and it is also
admitted position that the rate of rent in connection with suit premises is of
Rs. 9550/- per month.
4.
Since aforesaid payment
was not done within one month from the
date of passing of the order, in full satisfaction, the plaintiff opposite parties
filed an application under section 7(3) of the Act of 1997 with prayer for
striking out defence against delivery of possession. The petitioners herein
filed written objection and they also filed an application under section 151 of
the Code of Civil Procedure for passing necessary order to withdraw the
deposited amount of Rs. 6,49,400/- from the office of the Rent Controller.
5.
Thereafter the court below had taken up the aforesaid applications
filed by plaintiff and defendants and by the impugned order came to a
finding that the defendants in order to show that in compliance to order
dated 17th August, 2023 they deposited the rent with the plaintiff, they have
filed one challan dated 7th October, 2023, with their written objection and
from the said challan, it appears that the defendant paid rent for the month
of May to July, 2012 along with interest in the credit of plaintiff and beside
that defendants did not make any payment towards arrear due. In respect of
petitioners/defendants prayer for direction upon Rent Controller for
withdrawing and depositing the amount, he observed that the Rent
Controller has already reported that they do not have any such record in the
office, regarding any payment made by the defendants and no information in
that connection regarding the deposit of rent in the office of the Rent
Controller is available and therefore inclined to pass any direction and came
to a conclusion that the defendants have made deliberate default in
complying the aforesaid order dated 17th August, 2023 passed by the court
under section 7(2) of the Act of 1997 and therefore he allowed the plaintiffs
prayer to strike out the defendants defence against delivery of the
possession of the tenanted premises.
6.
Being aggrieved by the aforesaid order learned counsel for the
petitioner submits that she made an application on 31.08.2023 for
withdrawal of the amount of Rs. 6,49,400/- but the Rent Controller had not
made any response to that Application. She also made application under RTI
Act before the Rent Controller but she was not properly informed by the
office of the rent controller and since she was eagerly waiting for the positive
information, she could not comply the order dated 17.08.2023 without
having any malafide intention. However, finding no alternative she deposited
rent for the month of May to July 2012, before the court below on
07.10.2023, which is beyond the stipulated time frame by the Court. In this
context her further submissions is that it was never the intention of the
petitioner not to deposit the rent for the aforesaid three months but for the
aforesaid reasons few days delay caused. In this context referring 7(2) of the
Act of 1997 her counsel submits that under the proviso clause to section 7
(2), it is clear that having regard to the circumstances of the case an
extension of time may be granted by the Civil Judge only once and the
period of such extension shall not exceed two months. Therefore, if the
statue is construed liberally then
it appears that the defendants/tenant
deposited the rent in compliance with the order after 20 days from the
stipulated date which is well within two months, though it is true that she
had not filed any formal application for extension of period. In this context
she further submits that being a litigant she was never advised to file an
application for extension before the court below before depositing the rent
beyond time, instead she was advised to file aforesaid application under
section 151 of CPC on 20.09.2023. Accordingly her submission before the
Court is that due to said fault/mistake made on the part of petitioners for
not filing of the said extension application within one month from the order
dated 17.08.2023, it does not give rise to pass the impugned order not to
provide the benefit to protect the defence of the tenant as per the spirit of
the statute. The court below ought to have considered that it is not a case,
where petitioner/tenant failed to comply the order granting special
protection for another two months, in as much as tenant under the
compelling circumstances could not comply earlier order dated 17.08.2023
and therefore the order impugned is liable to be set aside.
7.
Mr. Ghosh Learned Counsel appearing on behalf of the opposite party
raised vehement objection against the submission made by the petitioners
and contended that court below made specific direction by the order dated
17.08.2023 to make the payment within one month of the date of the
passing of the order without fail and also to make payment of current rent.
Non compliance of any part of the aforesaid order, it brings the tenants to
the mischief of subsection (3) of section 7 of the Act of 1997. He further
submits that the defendants admittedly did not make the Application for
extension and as such the extension cannot be granted under sub section
(2) of section 7 and therefore the court below was justified in striking out the
defence against delivery of possession and for which the order impugned
does not call for interference.
8.
I have considered the submissions made by the parties.
9.
From the submissions and also from the document available in the
record and on perusal of the impugned order it is clear that though defence
contention is that he paid rent to the land lord for the month of September,
and October, 2011 but the land lord did not give him any rent receipt.
Thereafter he did not make payment for the said two months and even he
did not make payment for the said two months while filed his application
under section 7 (1) and 7(2) of the Act but he has deposited the same only
on 13.09.2023 i.e. after one year two months of receipt of summons of the
suit, because he received summon admittedly on 16.11.2022. Secondly by
the impugned order dated 17.08.2023, though court below directed the
defendant to pay rent for September, 2011 to October, 2011 and May 2012
to July
2012 with interest within one month without fail but defendant
failed to make such deposit of rent for the month of May to July 2012 wihtin
one month and also did not make any prayer for extension of time and
thereafter he deposited the same only on 7th October, 2012. Thirdly, as
regards payment of current rent the impugned order portrays that defendant
paid rent for the month of November, 2023 in the month of January, 2024
inspite of specific direction about payment of current rent by 7th of each
succeeding month. Fourthly, court below specifically observed in the
impugned order that in respect of alleged deposit of rent in the name of dead
person before the Rent Controller from March, 2017 to November, 2022, the
RTI office in reply submitted that they do not have any such record in the
office regarding any payment made by defendant and defendant also failed
to file any document in support of valid payment of rent for the said months.
Therefore in compliance with order dated 17.08.2023, defendant neither had
withdrawn rents for the said 69 months (approximately) nor paid the rent
for the said months along with interest till date.
10.
Now so far as the first issue is concerned regarding the defence
contention that inspite of payment of rent the plaintiff land lord opposite
party did not grant any receipt for the month of September and October
2011 the tenant, had specific penal remedy under section 32 of the Act of
1997 which specifically provides as follows:Penalty for refusal by landlord to grant receipt for rent paid.---If the
landlord refuses to deliver to the tenant a receipt for any rent paid by the
tenant, the Controller shall, on application made in this behalf by the tenant
within two months from the date of payment and after hearing the landlord, by
order, direct the landlord to pay to the tenant, by way of damages, such sum,
not exceeding three times the amount of rent paid by the tenant, as the
Controller may determine, and the cost of application, and shall issue a
certificate to the tenant in respect of the rent paid.
11.
It is not the case of the tenant/defendant that he had taken any such
measure. Furthermore section 21 of the Act of 1997 prescribes remedy
where land lord refuses to accept rent for a particular month or months.
Here defendant has nothing to show that he had taken recourse either
under section 32 or under section 21, when land lord allegedly on receiving
rent did not grant any rent receipt. Therefore, when defendant received
summon on 16.11.2022, he was duty bound to deposit rent for September,
and October, 2011 within one month from 16.11.2012. Here though
defendant had taken the plea that court below by the order dated
17.08.2023 permitted him to deposit said rent within one month which he
duly complied and in the absence of any challenge against said order by
either party, it had attained its finality, but I am not agreeable with such
argument for the reason that in this context the law has been laid down by
the Apex Court in Bijay Kumar Singh and Ors. Vs.
Amit Kumar
Chamariya and another reported in (2019) 10 SCC 660 and para 21 of
the said judgment runs as follows:21. Sub-section (3) provides for consequences of non-payment of rent
i.e. striking off the defence against the delivery of the possession and to
proceed with the hearing of the suit. Such provision is materially
different from sub-sections (2-A) and (2-B) which was being examined
by this Court in B.P. Khemka [B.P. Khemka (P) Ltd. v. Birendra Kumar
Bhowmick, (1987) 2 SCC 407] . Sub-sections (2-A) and (2-B) of Section
17 of the 1956 Act confer unfettered power on the court to extend the
period of deposit of rent, which is circumscribed by the proviso to
Section 7(2) and sub-section (3) of Section 7 of the Act. Therefore, the
provisions of sub-section (2) are mandatory and required to be
scrupulously followed by the tenant, if the tenant has to avoid the
eviction on account of non-payment of arrears of rent under Section 6 of
the Act. There is an outer limit for extension of time to deposit of arrears
of rent in terms of the proviso to sub-section (2) of Section 7 of the Act.
The consequences flowing from non-deposit of rent are contemplated
under sub-section (3) of Section 7 of the Act. Therefore, if the tenant fails
to deposit admitted arrears of rent within one month of receipt of
summons or within one month of appearance without summons and
also fails to make an application for determination of the disputed
amount of rate of rent and the period of arrears and the subsequent
non-payment on determining of the arrears of rent, will entail the
eviction of the tenant. Section 7 of the Act provides for a complete
mechanism for avoiding eviction on the ground of arrears of rent,
provided that the tenant takes steps as contemplated under sub-section
(2) of Section 7 of the Act and deposits the arrears of rent on
determination of the disputed amount. The deposit of rent along with an
application for determination of dispute is a precondition to avoid
eviction on the ground of non-payment of arrears of rent. In view thereof,
tenant will not be able to take recourse to Section 5 of the Limitation Act
as it is not an application alone which is required to be filed by the
tenant but the tenant has to deposit admitted arrears of rent as well.
12.
Thereafter in Debasish Paul and another Vs. Amal Boral, 2023
Live Law SC 919 Supreme Court reiterated the same view and observed in
para 16 that the reasoning in Bijay Kumar Singh’s Case (Supra) cannot be
doubted. Moreover
the requirement for a tenant is not only to file an
application under section 7 but he is also required to deposit the admitted
arrears of rent as well, which has certainly not been done. It is true that
said judgment was passed in 2019 but in view of the judgment passed by
the Apex Court reported in (2007) 3 SCC 557, (P.V. George & Others Vs.
State of Kerala & Others) it can be said that the aforesaid law laid down
by the Apex Court in Bijay Kumar Singh Case (Supra) is retrospective in
operation as the law in this context was laid down by the Court. Therefore
even though Trial court erroneously allowed defendant/tenant to deposit
rent for the month of September, to October, 2011 at a later date, but the
tenant is not entitled to get such protection as there cannot be estoppel
against the law laid down by the Apex court
13.
Secondly defendant pleaded in support of non deposit of rent for the
month of May to July 2012 is that challan in support of such deposit for the
said month is missing. However, fact remains that even in compliance with
the order dated 17.08.2023, the defendant did not make such payment
within one month as stipulated. No prayer for extension has also been
sought for within stipulated one month. Learned counsel for the defendant
has raised a lame excuse that the defendant was not advised to make such
prayer and that the provision of law is to be liberally construed which
provides extension of time for two months for first default but here again I
am not agreeable to aforesaid contention made by the petitioner as the
context of the instant case is different.
14.
Petitioner has already defaulted in payment of rent for the month of
September to October, 2011 as well as defaulted also in paying current rent
for the month of November, 2023 within time and above all there is nothing
to show that he has made any valid deposit of rent from march 2017 to
November, 2022.
15.
In Golam Vs Hazi reported in 62 CWN 858 it was held that even if
there is a violation in respect of a single deposit or in the deposit of any
disputed amount as required under sub section (1) it attracts sub section
(3).
16.
In Smt. Bina Devi Binay Vs. Ramesh Kumar Gupta reported in
(2015) 3 SCC Cal 384 where all the previous judgments were referred and
the court observed in para 19 that the word extension must relate to the
date fixed by the original order under sub section (2) of section 7 and the
only conclusion that can be arrived at with regard to proviso (2) sub section
2 of section 7 of the Act of 1997, that an application for extension of time to
deposit the arrear rent within the period fixed by the original order passed
by the court below must be made on or before the date of expiry of the
original time limit fixed by the Civil Judge.
17.
In this context it is also to be mentioned that in view of the judgment
of the Apex Court in Nasiruddin and others Vs. Sita Ram Agarwal
reported in (2003) 2 SCC 577 the word “shall” used in the said provision
though ordinarily imperative in nature but where the statue does not
provides extension of time, the court cannot extend time nor condone the
delay.
18.
In addition to that though defendant has taken a plea without having
any document that he deposited rent for about 69 months from March,
2017 to November, 2022 before the Rent Controller but such deposit even if
taken to be truly made, has been made admittedly in the name of a
deceased person. In this context plaintiff’s specific case is that by a letter
dated 26.12.2018 they informed the defendants that original land lord died
which they had acknowledged by giving reply. Defendants in their written
objection against plaintiffs application under section 7(3) have merely made
a denial which stands as oath Vs. oath. Section 22 (2) of the Act of 1997
specifically states that if wilfully or negligently tenant makes false
statement, the deposit made by him cannot be said to be a valid deposit.
Therefore, even if any such deposit is made by defendant that must be
invalid deposit, for which court below by the aforesaid order dated
17.08.2023 directed that even if deposit is made in the name of a dead
landlord, it is to be withdrawn and to be deposited before the Court below
within one month without fail. Defendant here also did not comply the said
order and had taken a plea that Rent controller did not make cooperation for
such withdrawal. Though as indicated above that in reply to petitioners RTI
application the concerned office replied that no such record in support of
defendants aforesaid deposit of rent is available in
the office. Therefore,
even if it is assumed that there was any alleged non co-operation by
controller, defendant could have complied the aforesaid order dated
17.08.2023 by depositing said amount of rent on protest within one month
with leave to withdraw if subsequently excess payment of rent for any month
is detected, so as to avoid eviction on the ground of non payment of arrear
rent and /or to save herself from defence to be struck off against delivery of
possession for default in payment of rent. But she has not taken any step
and till date defendant has nothing to show that he made such deposit of
rent for the aforesaid 69 months validly and therefore the court rightly held
that the defendants have made deliberate default in complying the order
dated 17th August, 2023 passed by the same court while disposing his
application under section 7(2) of the Act of 1997 and therefore, the
circumstances attracts invocation of his power under section 7(3) of the Act.
19.
Last but not the least, it is settled law that High Courts under Article
227 of the constitution of India have little scope to interfere with the order of
the courts below as a matter of routine. Here the trial court has arrived at a
conclusion assigning reason and the court below has not committed any
grave injustice nor exceeded its jurisdiction in passing the order impugned.
If the power under supervisory jurisdiction is used where it is not proper to
exercise, it will become counter productive and such power may lose its
vitality. Since there is nothing to show that the order impugned passed by
the court below is either illegal or irrational or suffering from procedural
impropriety, I find nothing to interfere with the order impugned.
20.
CO 3907 of 2024 thus stands dismissed.
Urgent photostat certified copy of this order, if applied for, be supplied to the
parties, on priority basis on compliance of all usual formalities.
(Dr. AJOY KUMAR MUKHERJEE, J.)
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review