The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
10. The decision of V.N. Patil (supra) relied on by the learned GA at paragraph 23 lays down that it is not necessary that in every case, it is required to record elaborate reason. However, the proposition laid down therein cannot be interpreted to say that no valid reason is required to be recorded. In the present matter, the foundation for recall, as is indicated in the application for recall, does not even remotely make out a case that such recalling is necessary for just decision of the case or to arrive at the truth. The reasons recorded by the Trial Court in allowing the application for recall also do not specify the requirement of recalling, as to whether for some clarification or for any new evidence needed by the court. While advancement of justice remains the prime object of law, recall cannot be allowed on mere asking or reasons related to convenience. Mere observation that the recall was necessary for a just decision is not enough unless there is tangible reason to show how just decision would suffer without recall. The application filed by the prosecution is totally silent in this regard. 2024:MLHC:649
11. In view of the above, the impugned order dated 23.05.2023 passed in Sessions Case No. 57 of 2021 by the Sessions Judge, East Jaintia Hills District, Khliehriat, cannot be sustained in law and the same is set aside and quashed.
12. The Revision Petition stands allowed. Judge Meghalaya
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
2024:MLHC:649
Serial No. 09
Regular List
HIGH COURT OF MEGHALAYA
AT SHILLONG
Crl. Rev. P. No. 18 of 2023
Date of Hearing : 22.07.2024
Date of Decision: 22.07.2024
Shri Nisal Lamurong
S/o. Shri K. Chyrmang,
R/o. Kremmyrsiang Village,
East Jaintia Hills District,
Meghalaya.
Vs.
1. State of Meghalaya
Rep. by the Secretary,
Department of Home and
Police, Shillong, Meghalaya.
2. The Superintendent of
Police, East Jaintia Hills
District, Khliehriat,
Meghalaya.
…. Petitioner
….. Respondents.
Coram:
Hon’ble Mr. B. Bhattacharjee, Judge
Appearance:
For the Petitioner/Appellant(s)
:
Mrs. R. Dutta, Legal Aid Counsel.
For the Respondent(s)
:
Mr. R. Gurung, GA,
Mr. K.P. Bhattacharjee, GA.
i)
Whether approved for reporting in
Law journals etc.:
ii)
Whether approved for publication
in press:
JUDGMENT
Yes/No
Yes/No
2024:MLHC:649
1.
This revision petition under Section 397/401 read with Section 482
Cr.PC has been filed assailing the order dated 23.05.2023 passed by the
District and Sessions Judge, East Jaintia Hills District, Khliehriat, in
Session Case No. 51 of 2021 by which the application under Section 311
CrPC filed by the prosecution for recalling and re-examination of PW-1,
the complainant, was allowed.
2.
The brief fact of the case is that the petitioner is facing trial in
Sessions Case No. 57 of 2021 under Section 326/302 IPC which was
charge sheeted on the basis of an FIR dated 12.12.2014 filed by the PW1. The learned Trial Court had taken cognizance of the matter and framed
charge under Section 326/302 IPC against the petitioner. On 03.03.2022,
PW-1 was examined, both in chief and cross, and was discharged
thereafter. Subsequently, around five prosecution witnesses were also
examined. On 17.04.2023, the prosecution filed an application under
Section 311 Cr.PC for recalling and re examination of the PW-1. After
hearing the parties, the learned Trial Court vide order dated 23.05.2023
allowed the application. The petitioner being aggrieved, has filed this
revision petition challenging the order dated 23.05.2023.
3.
Ms. R. Dutta, learned Legal Aid Counsel appearing for the
petitioner submits that the learned Trial Court has passed the impugned
order without adhering to the basic requirement of law as mandated by
the provision of Section 311 Cr.PC. She submits that passing of order on
a petition for recall is not an empty formality and a witness cannot be
recalled as a matter of course without assigning any valid reason. The
learned counsel submits that the application filed by the prosecution did
2024:MLHC:649
not disclose any reason as to what necessitated the recalling of PW-1. She
contends that even the impugned order did not specify any justified or
valid reason for recalling the said witness. The learned counsel submits
that as par the established norms of law, it is mandatory for a court to
record and ascertain the essentiality of the person sought to be recalled
for re-examination before allowing the prayer. In support of her
contention, the learned counsel places reliance on a decision of the Apex
Court reported in Rajaram Prasad Yadav Vs. State of Bihar and Anr.
(2013) 14 SSC 461 (Para 14) and submits that the impugned order does
not show that the Trial Court has recorded any valid reason for allowing
the application filed by the prosecution and hence the same is liable to be
interfered by this Court.
4.
Mr. R. Gurung, learned GA appearing for the State, on the other
hand supports the impugned order and submits that the Trial Court in its
wisdom found it essential to recall the PW-1 for re-examination on the
basis of the facts and circumstances of the case. He submits that it is not
required for a Trial Court to record elaborate reason in every case
concerning recalling of witness. He contends that the Trial Court in its
order dated 23.05.2023 has held that some essential facts is required to be
extracted from the PW-1 to enable the Court to reach at a just decision of
the case and in such a situation, it cannot be said that the impugned order
suffers from any illegality or infirmity requiring interference by this
Court. The learned GA places reliance on the decision of the Apex Court
reported in V.N. Patil Vs. K. Niranjan Kumra and Ors. (2021) 3 SSC 661,
(para-23) and submits that the present revision petition is devoid of merit
2024:MLHC:649
and be dismissed.
5.
Heard learned counsel for the parties and perused the materials
available on record.
6.
The record reveals that the evidence of the PW-1 was recorded
before the Trial Court on 03.03.2022 and after examination-in-chief and
cross examination, the witness was discharged. Thereafter, another five
prosecution witnesses were examined which includes the Investigating
Officer of the case, examined as the PW-6. The application of recalling of
PW-1 was filed by the prosecution on 17.04.2023. The only reason for
recalling of the witness as stated at para 1 of the said application is
reproduced below: “ 1.The prosecution would like to file the instant application for
recalling and re-examine the below mentioned prosecution witness
who is the complainant in the instant case as her evidence appears
to be essential for the prosecution case.”
Apart from the above, no other ground is made out in the application. It is
not stated therein whether the recalling and the re-examination of the PW1 is required for explaining the matter referred to in cross-examination or
for introducing a new matter in relation to the fact of the case.
7.
Section 138 of the Indian Evidence Act, 1972 sets out the order of
examination of witnesses in a trial. It also contains provisions for
direction of re-examination of witness for explanation of matters referred
to in cross-examination and for introduction of new matter with
permission of the court. Hence, it is essential for a court to mention for
2024:MLHC:649
what purpose a witness is sought to be recalled, whether for clarification
of matters referred to in cross-examination or for introduction of new
matter, or for both purposes. A witness cannot be recalled for the purpose
of putting repetitive question in order to seek improvement of evidence
which is already a part of record. In the instant matter, the learned Trial
Court has not recorded any such reason while allowing the application for
recalling filed by the prosecution.
8.
A bare perusal of the impugned order reveals that the learned Trial
Court has passed the order on the basis of the statement of the
complainant under Section 161 Cr.PC and also the confession statement
of the accused. The statement of the complainant under Section 161
Cr.PC was available on record when the PW-1 was examined by the Trial
Court on 03.03.2022. It is nowhere recorded that some of the facts,
essential for the just and proper decision of the case, has not been
extracted from PW-1. That apart, there is nothing on record to show that
the PW-1 had played any part in the recording of the confessional
statement of the accused in the matter. Thus, merely because there exists
a confessional statement of the accused in the matter, it cannot be a
ground for recalling the PW-1.
9.
The decision of Rajaram Prasad Yadav (supra) at para 14
stipulates that when recalling and re-examining of any person already
examined is concerned, the court must necessarily consider and ensure
that such recall and re-examination of any person, appears in the view of
the court to be essential for the just decision of the case. Therefore, the
paramount requirement is just decision and for that purpose, the
2024:MLHC:649
essentiality of a person to be recalled and re-examined has to be
ascertained. In the present case, it appears that the learned Trial Court has
passed the impugned order without recording any finding to ascertain the
essentiality of the person ordered to be recalled. The application for
recalling did not mention about occurrence of any error in the recording
of evidence of the PW-1. In such a situation, there is every likelihood that
the petitioner will be highly prejudiced in the event the PW-1 is examined
afresh in the guise of re-examination by the prosecution on the basis of
the impugned order.
10.
The decision of V.N. Patil (supra) relied on by the learned GA at
paragraph 23 lays down that it is not necessary that in every case, it is
required to record elaborate reason. However, the proposition laid down
therein cannot be interpreted to say that no valid reason is required to be
recorded. In the present matter, the foundation for recall, as is indicated in
the application for recall, does not even remotely make out a case that
such recalling is necessary for just decision of the case or to arrive at the
truth. The reasons recorded by the Trial Court in allowing the application
for recall also do not specify the requirement of recalling, as to whether
for some clarification or for any new evidence needed by the court. While
advancement of justice remains the prime object of law, recall cannot be
allowed on mere asking or reasons related to convenience. Mere
observation that the recall was necessary for a just decision is not enough
unless there is tangible reason to show how just decision would suffer
without recall. The application filed by the prosecution is totally silent in
this regard.
2024:MLHC:649
11.
In view of the above, the impugned order dated 23.05.2023 passed
in Sessions Case No. 57 of 2021 by the Sessions Judge, East Jaintia Hills
District, Khliehriat, cannot be sustained in law and the same is set aside
and quashed.
12.
The Revision Petition stands allowed.
Judge
Meghalaya
22.07.2024
“N. Swer, Stenographer Gr II. ”
NATHANIEL SWER
Date: 2024.07.22 16:34:04 IST
Powered by TCPDF (www.tcpdf.org)
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review