Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Page No.# 1/15
GAHC010262022025
undefined
THE GAUHATI HIGH COURT
(HIGH COURT OF ASSAM, NAGALAND, MIZORAM AND ARUNACHAL PRADESH)
Case No. : WP(C)/6892/2025
NIRMALI MEDHI
W/O. KRISHNA KANTA KALITA, RESIDENT OF VILL., P.O. AND P.S.
MILANPUR, DIST. NALBARI, ASSAM
VERSUS
THE STATE OF ASSAM AND 6 ORS
REPRESENTED BY THE SECRETARY, DEPARTMENT OF SCHOOL
EDUCATION, ASSAM, DISPUR, GHY-06.
2:THE COMMISSIONER AND SECRETARY
FINANCE DEPARTMENT
GOVT. OF ASSAM
DISPUR
GUWAHATI-06.
3:THE ACCOUNTANT GENERAL (A AND E)
ASSAM
MAIDAMGAON
BELTOLA
GUWAHATI-06.
4:THE DIRECTOR OF SECONDARY EDUCATION
ASSAM
KAHILIPARA
GUWAHATI-19.
5:THE DIRECTOR OF PENSION
ASSAM
HOUSEFED COMPLEX
DISPUR
GUWAHATI-06.
Page No.# 2/15
6:THE INSPECTOR OF SCHOOLS
NALBARI DISTRICT CIRCLE
NALBARI
ASSAM
PIN- 781337
7:THE HEADMASTER OF KATARA HIGH SCHOOL
NALBARI
P.O. CHENGNOI
DIST. NALBARI
ASSAM
PIN- 781337
Advocate for the Petitioner
: MR. M KHAN, MR A K DAS,MS J AKTAR
Advocate for the Respondent : GA, ASSAM, MR. S K MEDHI(SC,AG (A AND E)),SC, AG,SC,
FINANCE,SC, SEC. EDU.
BEFORE
HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE SOUMITRA SAIKIA
JUDGMENT
·
Date on which Judgment was reserved
:
·
Date of Pronouncement of Judgment
: 11.08.2026
· Whether the pronouncement is of
the Operative Part of the Judgment
· Whether the full Judgment has been
Pronounced
Open Court Dictation
:
No
:
Yes
JUDGMENT AND ORDER
Heard Mr. M Khan, leaned counsel for the petitioner. Also heard Ms. M Das,
learned counsel appearing on behalf of Mr. SK Medhi, learned counsel for the
respondent no.3, Ms. RM Barooah, learned counsel for the respondent no.2 and
Page No.# 3/15
Ms. D Mushahary, learned counsel for the respondents no. 1, 4 & 6.
2.
This writ petition is filed by the petitioner, seeking a direction to the
respondents for release of the monthly pension of the petitioner with effect from
01-05-2022 and other retirement benefits, after regularising her service period
from 08-04-1998 to 11-12-2005 or taking into account the service period prior
to the regularisation of her services for the purposes of pension within a
particular time frame. Further prayer is made for release of her arrear salary for
the period February 2005 to 11-12-2005 with appropriate rate of interest.
3.
The petitioner was appointed temporarily as an Assistant Teacher to
graduate post on ad-hoc basis in Baithalangso High Secondary School in Karbi
Anglong district for a period of 4 (four) months with graduate scale of pay
against a valid sanction post created by the Government by the letter
No.ESS.7/78/2/1-A dated 26-02-1978. Accordingly, she joined in her service with
effect from 08-04-1988 and has received a monthly pay and allowances as
admissible in law. It is contended on behalf of the petitioner that although she
was temporarily appointed for a period of 4 (four) months, she was allowed to
continue in her services in the same vacant post.
4.
Thereafter, by an order dated 27-01-2005 issued by the Director of
Secondary Education, the petitioner was transferred and posted at Katara High
Page No.# 4/15
School, Katara in the district of Nalbari. There, the petitioner submitted her
joining report to the Headmaster of the said school on 04-02-2005 after her
release from the earlier place of posting, namely, Baithalangso High Secondary
School in Karbi Anglong. However, the Headmaster did not permit her to join in
the said school and consequently, did not accept the joining letter submitted by
the petitioner.
5.
The petitioner thereafter submitted application before the Director of
Secondary Education on 07-03-2005 seeking intervention in the said matter. The
Director of Secondary Education, by communication dated 02-05-2005 to the
Inspector of Schools, NDC, Nalbari, issued instructions to take steps to
implement the transfer order dated 27-01-2005.
6.
In spite of such instructions being issued to the Headmaster of Katara High
School, Katara, the petitioner was not allowed to join. Being thus situated, the
petitioner approached this Court by filing WP(C) No. 7188/ 2005. This writ
petition came to be disposed of on 18-11-2005, providing that the petitioner be
allowed to sign in the attendance register, take her classes and perform her
normal duties and also be paid her salary.
7.
Before disposal of WP(C) No. 7188/ 2005 by the order dated 18-11-2005,
the petitioner's joining report submitted on 04-02-2005 was accepted on 01-11-
Page No.# 5/15
2005 by the Headmaster of Katara High School, Nalbari. Thereafter, the
petitioner was transferred at Rajkadamtol, Balika Vidyapith High School by order
dated 08-12-2005. The petitioner joined in the said school on 12-12-2005 and
received her salary from 12-12-2005 to 28-02-2007. However, she did not
receive her salary from February, 2005 to 11-12-2005. The petitioner thereafter
was again attached to the Nalbari Girls High School by order dated 24-10-2007
under the orders passed by the Inspector of Schools, Nalbari. She accordingly
joined in the said school on 26-10-2007. However, she was not paid her salary
from the date of joining in the school. It is the grievance of the petitioner that
she did not receive her salary from 01-02-2005 to 12-12-2005 and from 01-032007 to 31-12-2010, i.e. the period of her service in Nalbari Girls High School.
8.
Thereafter, the petitioner due to her medical illness availed medical leave
from 01-01-2011 to 30-05-2011 after submitting her prayer dated 31-12-2010
to the Headmaster of Nalbari Girls High School and as also to the Inspector of
Schools. Thereafter, when the petitioner came back to rejoin in her place of
posting, after the expiry of her medical leave, the Headmaster of Nalbari Girls
High School did not permit her to sign the attendance register.
9.
After approaching various authorities and no relief being granted to the
petitioner, she approached this Court again by filing WP(C) No.6477 of 2016
Page No.# 6/15
seeking a direction from the Court for regularisation of her services and to pay
her regular salary as well as arrear salary. This Court thereafter disposed off the
writ petition by the order dated 25-11-2019, with the following directions:
“……
5. The plea that the petitioner had not been allowed to sign the attendance register,
cannot be said to be mere pretence for not attending class in the school, which fact, this Court
had taken cognizance of, as reflected in the above order. In this regard, this Court has also
noted the process initiated by the State authorities as indicated in the letter dated 05.02.2009
issued by the Under Secretary to the Government of Assam to the Director of Secondary
Education seeking clarification on various issues as mentioned in the said letter regarding
adjustment of the service of the petitioner. From the above what transpires is that the
petitioner was appointed, though may be under a transfer vacancy, but she had rendered a
long period of service and the Government had already initiated certain process for
considering adjustment of her service.
6. Accordingly, this Court is of the view that it would be appropriate that the exercise for
regularization/ adjustment of the petitioner’s service already initiated in the year 2009 in
terms of the communication dated 05.02.2009 be concluded and appropriate decision be taken
as regards the regularization of the service of the petitioner as a Graduate Teacher
considering the long service rendered by her since the year 1988. It will be unfair on the part
of the State Authorities at this period of time to deny regularisation/adjustment of the
petitioner’s service on the ground of lack of proper appointment at the initial stage. If the
petitioner had been allowed to work for such a long period of time since 1988, which is also
borne by records, the authorities can sympathetically consider the case of the petitioner and
pass appropriate order for regularization/ adjustment of her service against a regular vacancy
in terms of the process already initiated, keeping also in mind the judgment of the Hon’ble
Supreme Court in Uma Devi (Supra).
The aforesaid exercise will be undertaken as expeditiously as possible preferably within
a period of 3 (three) months from the date of receipt of a certified copy of this order and if the
Page No.# 7/15
service of the petitioner is regularized/adjusted, consequential benefits along with senior scale
of pay also be given to her as per law.
7. With the above observations and directions, the writ petition stands disposed of.”
10.
Pursuant to the disposal, several communications were exchanged
between the various authorities in the Government and the matter was duly
examined.
11.
On a report submitted by the Director of Secondary Education, by the
order dated 18.06.2024 issued by the Inspector of Schools, NDC, Nalbari, the
service of the petitioner was finally regularised with effect from 12-12-2005 to
31-12-2010 against the post created vide Govt. No.ESS.172/77/164 dated
17.10.1977
and
permanently
retained
vide
No.GMSC.28/84/345
dated
20.02.1992 of the Katara High School and the earlier incumbent having been
promoted on 20-08-2002. The said order clearly indicated that this order of
regularisation was issued in compliance to the order dated 25/11/2019 passed
in WP(C) No. 6477 of 2016.
12.
It is the claim of the petitioner that her past services have not been
counted towards the grant of pension as the petitioner was regularised with
effect from 12-12-2005. It is contended on behalf of the petitioner that the
respondents have not taken any steps for release of her pension pursuant to the
petitioner superannuating on 30-04-2022.
Page No.# 8/15
13.
Learned counsel for the petitioner in support of his contention has placed
reliance on the following judgments:
(i)
Dharam Singh & Ors vs. State of UP & Anr.
reported in 2025 INSC 998
(ii)
Prem Singh vs. State of UP and Others.
reported in (2019) 10 SCC 516
(iii)
Rajkaran singh & Ors. vs. Union of India and Ors
reported in 2024 INSC 621
14.
Pressing these judgments into service learned counsel for the petitioner
submitted before the court that the services rendered by the petitioner either
temporary or ad-hoc basis is required to be counted towards her pensionary
benefits. Referring to the judgement rendered by this Court in WP(C) No. 1517
of 2023 it is submitted that the Judgment and Order dated 13.05.2024 passed
in this writ petition squarely covers the case of the writ petitioner and a similar
order is required to be issued whereby, the respondents therein were directed to
consider the period of services of the petitioner therein rendered on an ad-hoc
basis towards payment of pension.
15.
The respondents have contested the matter by filing their affidavit-in-
opposition.
16.
The respondents in their affidavit stated that since the petitioner was
regularised on 18-06-2024 with effect from 12-12-2005 to 31-12-2010, she is
Page No.# 9/15
not entitled for pension under the Assam Services (Pension) Rules, 1969.
However, she is entitled to the new defined contributory pension scheme, which
is applicable to all new entrants joining the government service on or after 0102-2005.
17.
Learned Counsel for the parties have been heard and pleadings on record
have been carefully perused.
18.
The petitioner prayer in the present writ petition is directed against the
respondents for release of monthly pension with effect from 01.05.2022 and
other retirement benefits after regularizing her service period from 08.04.1988
to 11.12.2005. Although it does not appear from the averment made in the writ
petition, however, during the submissions made by the learned counsel for the
petitioner it is clear that the primary grievance of the writ petitioner is non-grant
of pensionary benefits to the petitioner under the Assam Services (Pension)
Rules, 1969. There is no wrangle at the Bar that the petitioner was regularized
vide the order dated 18.06.2024 with effect from with effect from 12-12-2005 to
31-12-2010 against the vacant post created and retained in the Katara High
School, Nalbari. This order has been accepted by the petitioner. No challenge is
made by the petitioner in the earlier proceedings before the Court or in the
present proceedings. The effect of this order is that the petitioner was
Page No.# 10/15
regularized with the effect from the period mentioned i.e. 12-12-2005 to 31-122010. The petitioner, therefore, was regularized after the enforcement of the
new contributory pension scheme which came to be implemented with effect
from 01.02.2005. As per the new pension scheme, all new employees appointed
or regularized after the enforcement of the new defined contributory pension
scheme are governed by the said pension scheme and not by the erstwhile
Assam (Services) Pension Rules, 1969. Therefore, when the petitioner is
accepted her regularization order dated 18-06-2024 and the period of services
was regularised with effect from 12-12-2005 to 31-12-2010 which is admittedly
after the New Defined Contribution Pension Rules, 2005, the petitioner be
entitled to payment under the said New Pension Scheme of 2005. The attempt
made by the learned counsel for the petitioner to interfere with the order dated
25.11.2019 passed by the Coordinate Bench in WP(C) NO.6477/2016 that the
regularization of the writ petitioner was pursuant to the direction being issued in
the said matter and therefore, the services rendered by her ad-hoc capacity was
required to be considered towards payment of pension and therefore, that
period of pension ought to have been calculated from the period that the
petitioner had rendered her services from 08-04-1998 to 11-12-2005 and if that
be so then she would be covered under the Assam Services (Pension) Rules,
1969. This submission appears to be fallicious, inasmuch as, a careful reading of
Page No.# 11/15
the order dated 25.11.2019 in WP(C) No.6477/2016 reveals that the Coordinate
Bench had directed to sympathetically consider the case of the petitioner for
regularization or adjustment of her services. There was no finding by the
Coordinate Bench that the petitioner ought to have been regularized with effect
from the date she had rendered her services. There was no finding by the
Coordinate Bench that the petitioner ought to have been regularized with effect
from the date she had rendered her services.
19.
Under such circumstances, it cannot be said that there was specific
direction by the Coordinate Bench against the respondents requiring the
petitioner to be regularized with effect from the date she had rendered her adhoc services. Be that as it may, finally the service of the petitioner was
regularized by the order date 18.06.2024 with effect from 12-12-2005 to 31-122010 and this order was not under challenge in any proceedings and the
petitioner has accepted this order. Therefore, the petitioner services having
been rendered in the ad-hoc capacity prior to the period which was regularized
cannot be a ground for the respondents to grant her pension under the Assam
Services (Pension) Rules, 1969. The petitioner having been regularized
subsequent to the introduction of the New Defined Contribution Pension
Scheme, 2005 which was brought into effect from 01.02.2005 and the period of
service rendered by the petitioner with effect from 12-12-2005 to 31-12-2010,
Page No.# 12/15
under such circumstances, the petitioner cannot stake her claim for being
granted the pension under the Assam Services (Pension) Rules, 1969. The
judgments pressed into service by the learned counsel for the petitioner relate
to counting of services rendered for long years on ad-hoc basis or contract basis
which must be taken into account for regularizing the services of an employee.
The judgment of this Court rendered in WP(C) No.1517/2023 by order dated
13.05.2024 is entirely on different facts and circumstances. From the recital of
the order it appears that the petitioner therein was considered for grant of
pension presumably under the old pension rules and notwithstanding his
regularisation under the New Pension Rules, however, his pension was not
granted because of short fall of the mandatory period of service required under
Rule 31 of the Assam Services (Pension) Rules, 1969. It was under these
circumstances that the services rendered by the petitioner under the ad-hoc or
temporary capacity to be considered to cover up the short fall of the services
required for grant of pension which is 10 years pursuant to regularization. Under
these circumstances, the respondents were directed to consider the services
rendered by the petitioner therein in ad-hoc capacity, so that, the pension
proposal can be processed and his claims need not be rejected on account of
short fall of the services required. The facts as discussed in the present writ
petition are different from the facts and circumstances which were urged before
Page No.# 13/15
the Court in WP(C) No.1517/2023.
20.
Accordingly, the decision as pressed into service as rendered in WP(C)
No.1517/2023 by order dated 13-05-2024 is not applicable in the facts and
circumstances of the present proceedings.
21.
There was acquiescence on the part of the petitioner as she had accepted
the regularisation order regularizing her services with effect from 12-12-2005 to
31-12-2010. In this regard, reference may be made to the judgment rendered
by the Apex Court in Union of India vs. N Murugesan reported in (2022) 2 SCC
25, the relevant paragraphs of which are extracted herein below:
25. Acquiescence would mean a tacit or passive acceptance. It is implied and
reluctant consent to an act. In other words, such an action would qualify a passive
assent. Thus, when acquiescence takes place, it presupposes knowledge against a
particular act. From the knowledge comes passive acceptance, therefore instead of
taking any action against any alleged refusal to perform the original contract, despite
adequate knowledge of its terms, and instead being allowed to continue by
consciously ignoring it and thereafter proceeding further, acquiescence does take
place. As a consequence, it reintroduces a new implied agreement between the
parties.
20. The principles governing delay, laches, and acquiescence are overlapping
and interconnected on many occasions. However, they have their distinct characters
and distinct elements. One can say that delay is the genus to which laches and
acquiescence are species. Similarly, laches might be called a genus to a species by
name acquiescence. However, there may be a case where acquiescence is involved,
but not laches. These principles are common law principles, and perhaps one could
Page No.# 14/15
identify that these principles find place in various statutes which restrict the period of
limitation and create non-consideration of condonation in certain circumstances. They
are bound to be applied by way of practice requiring prudence of the court than of a
strict application of law. The underlying principle governing these concepts would be
one of estoppel. The question of prejudice is also an important issue to be taken note
of by the court.
21. The word “laches” is derived from the French language meaning
“remissness and slackness”. It thus involves unreasonable delay or negligence in
pursuing a claim involving an equitable relief while causing prejudice to the other
party. It is neglect on the part of a party to do an act which law requires while
asserting a right, and therefore, must stand in the way of the party getting relief or
remedy.
22. Two essential factors to be seen are the length of the delay and the nature
of acts done during the interval. As stated, it would also involve acquiescence on the
part of the party approaching the court apart from the change in position in the
interregnum. Therefore, it would be unjustifiable for a Court of Equity to confer a
remedy on a party who knocks its doors when his acts would indicate a waiver of
such a right. By his conduct, he has put the other party in a particular position, and
therefore, it would be unreasonable to facilitate a challenge before the court. Thus, a
man responsible for his conduct on equity is not expected to be allowed to avail a
remedy.
22. The ratio of this judgment will be applicable in the present case. The
petitioner had sufficient opportunity to assail the order of regularisation, at least
to the extent that the said order did not reckon the entire period of service
rendered by her in an ad hoc capacity for the purpose of regularisation. No
explanation has been put forward by the petitioner as to why the petitioner did
not assail or challenge the inaction of the respondents in not taking into account
Page No.# 15/15
the temporary services rendered by the petitioner for regularization.
23.
In view of the discussion above, there is no merit in the writ petition.
Accordingly, the writ petition stands dismissed. No order as to cost. Interim
order, if any, stands vacated.
Pending Interlocutory Application, if any, also stands dismissed.
JUDGE
Comparing Assistant
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review