Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Page No.# 1/8
GAHC010290302023
undefined
THE GAUHATI HIGH COURT
(HIGH COURT OF ASSAM, NAGALAND, MIZORAM AND ARUNACHAL PRADESH)
Case No. : WP(C)/7510/2023
NIRMAL DAS
S/O- LATE AKHIL DAS,
R/O- DHING TOWN, WARD NO. 6,
P.S.- DHING, P.O.- DHING,
DIST.- NAGAON, PIN- 782123,
ASSAM.
VERSUS
THE STATE OF ASSAM AND 6 ORS
REPRESENTED BY THE SECRETARY TO THE GOVERNMENT OF ASSAM,
MUNICIPAL ADMINISTRATION DEPARTMENT,
DISPUR, GUWAHATI-6.
2:DHING MUNICIPAL BOARD
REPRESENTED BY THE CHAIRMAN/ CHAIRPERSON
DHING
P.O.- DHING
DIST.- NAGAON
PIN- 782123
ASSAM.
3:THE VICE CHAIRMAN
DHING MUNICIPAL BOARD
DHING
P.O.- DHING
DIST.- NAGAON
PIN- 782123
ASSAM.
4:THE EXECUTIVE OFFICER
Page No.# 2/8
DHING MUNICIPAL BOARD
DHING
P.O.- DHING
DIST.- NAGAON
PIN- 782123
ASSAM.
5:THE DISTRICT COMMISSIONER
NAGAON DISTRICT
ASSAM
PIN- 782001.
6:THE ADDITIONAL DEPUTY COMMISSIONER
I/C URBAN AFFAIRS
NAGAON DISTRICT
ASSAM
PIN- 782001.
7:MD. MAHEBUDDIN HAZARIKA
S/O- SAMSUR ALI HAZARIKA
R/O- SONARI GAON
DHING
DIST.- NAGAON
PIN- 782123
ASSAM
Advocate for the Petitioner : MR. JYOTIRMOY ROY, B SAHA,MR B P SARMAH,MR D
DAS,MR. C CHAKRAVARTY,MR. R HAZARIKA,MR. S SARMA
Advocate for the Respondent : GA, ASSAM, MR. B CHAKRABORTY(R7),MR K L GUPTA (r-4)
BEFORE
HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE SANJAY KUMAR MEDHI
ORDER
06.08.2026
The instant petition under Article 226 of the Constitution of India has been
filed seeking the following relief:-
Page No.# 3/8
“ In the premises aforesaid, it is therefore, humbly prayed that Your Lordship
may be pleased to issue a rule calling upon the Respondents to show cause as
to why a writ in the nature of Certiorari to set aside the impugned letter vide
No. DMB.234/2022-23/471 dated 29.11.2023 issued by the Executive Officer,
Dhing Municipal Board, Nagaon, Assam (Annexure No.7) thereby cancelled the
Bheti allotment order of the Petitioner vide No. DMB/36/2023-24/0865 dated
19.09.2023 and also pleased to issue a rule calling upon the Respondents to
show cause as to why a writ in the nature of Mandamus shall not be issued
thereby directing the Respondents more particularly Respondent No.2 to 4 to
consider the case of the Petitioner by upholding the Bheti allotment order of the
Petitioner vide No. DMB/36/2023-24/0865 dated 19.09.2023; and upon
consideration of the cause or causes being shown and after hearing the parties
be pleased to make the rule absolute and/or to pass such order or order(s) as
Your Lordship may deem fit and proper. In the interim, pending disposal of the
instant writ petition, Your Lordship would be pleased to stay of the operation of
the impugned cancellation letter vide No. DMB.234/2022-23/471 dated
29.11.2023 issued by the Executive Officer, Dhing Municipal Board, Nagaon,
Assam (Annexure No. 7) and further pleased to direct the Respondent No. 2 to
4 not to allot to Bheti No. 55/1 to Respondent No.7 and/or not to create any
third party right and/or pass any such order or order(s) as Your Lordship may
deem fit and proper in the interest of justice.
And for this act of kindness the Petitioner as in duty bound shall ever pray.”
2.
The facts projected in brief are that the petitioner is having a shop at Bheti
No. 55 of Dhing Bazar, Ward No. 6 which was duly allotted to him. He had
applied for a Bheti in the 1 st floor of the newly constructed RCC building vide
application dated 18.08.2023 and accordingly, he was allowed to deposit an
amount of Rs.30,288/- for such allotment and the allotment order dated
Page No.# 4/8
19.09.2023 was issued in his favour. The petitioner started the construction and
claims to have spent a considerable amount whereafter suddenly, the Executive
Officer, Dhing Municipal Market had issued the impugned letter dated
29.11.2023 cancelling the allotment by stating that due to server error, the Bheti
was wrongly allotted to the petitioner. It is this action which is the subject
matter of challenge in the present writ petition.
3.
I have heard Shri J. Roy, learned Senior Counsel assisted by Shri C.
Chakraborty. I have also heard Shri K. L. Gupta, learned counsel for the Dhing
Municipal Board and Shri B. Chakraborty, learned counsel for the respondent no.
7. Ms. U. Das, learned State Counsel is present for the State respondent.
4.
Shri Roy, the learned Senior Counsel for the petitioner has submitted that
while the allotment was made to the petitioner of the Bheti No. 55/1 on
19.09.2023, all verifications were made whereafter the petitioner had also
started constructions. He has submitted that the cancellation has been done on
extraneous factors to favour the respondent no. 7. He has submitted that
though materials have been placed to show that the allotment was previously
made in favour of the respondent no. 7, such allotment appears to be of the
year 2016 and the very fact that no construction was made for all this period
would show that such allotment did not practically take place. He has also
submitted that the from the date of allotment on 19.09.2023 till the date of
cancellation i.e. 29.11.2023 more than 2 months had passed in which period,
the petitioner had also made constructions which were done openly and even
whereafter not action was taken and suddenly, after more than 2 months, the
impugned action has been taken. He has submitted that though an agreement
has been shown to be made by the Dhing Municipal Board with the respondent
no. 7, such agreement was for a period of 1 year with a renewable clause and
Page No.# 5/8
there was no renewal. He has submitted that under Clause 18 of the said
agreement, if no renewal is done within 3 years, such allotment would be
cancelled and by the application of the legal fiction, the allotment if done with
the respondent no. 7, stood cancelled.
5.
By drawing the attention of the affidavit-in-opposition of the respondent no.
7, the learned Senior Counsel for the petitioner has submitted that only on
03.06.2023, the permission has been given to the respondent no. 7 to make the
constructions which gives an impression that the papers have been
manufactured. The learned Senior Counsel accordingly submits that the
impugned order of cancellation is liable to be interfered with.
6.
Per contra, Shri Gupta, the learned counsel appearing for the contesting
Dhing Municipal Board has submitted that affidavit-in-opposition has been filed
on 20.04.2026. He has submitted that on 19.09.2023 due to server error, Bheti
55/1 was allotted to the petitioner. He has submitted that when the said mistake
was detected, the communication dated 29.11.2023 has been issued cancelling
the same and requesting the petitioner to take refund of the allotment amount.
He has submitted that the Bheti No. 55/1 was allotted to the respondent no. 7
in the year 2016 and only due to server error, the Bheti was wrongly allotted to
the petitioner.
7.
When this matter was taken up for consideration on the earlier occasion
i.e. 28.07.2026, this Court had directed Shri Gupta, the learned counsel to
obtain the record which he has accordingly done.
8.
On the aspect that no construction was made by the respondent no. 7 in
this period from 2016-2023, the learned counsel for the Board has submitted
that permission was not granted for various reasons and therefore the
Page No.# 6/8
construction by the respondent no. 7 could not be done. He has also clarified
that though the agreement of his client with the respondent no. 7 dated
13.10.2016 was not renewed as a matter of fact, he had been paying the rents
on time and there is no default. He has also submitted that the petitioner
himself is allotted the ground floor of the same building in connection with
which there is an agreement which is also not renewed and not registered.
9.
The learned counsel for the Board accordingly submits that the impugned
order dated 29.11.2023 does not suffer from any legal infirmity and accordingly
this writ petition is liable to be dismissed.
10. Supporting the decision making process, Shri B. Chakraborty, learned
counsel for the respondent no. 7 has submitted that it is clear that the
arrangement made with the petitioner on 19.09.2023 was a result of an
inadvertent mistake. He has submitted that as a matter of fact, no allotment
order as such has been able to be placed before this Court and the
communication relied upon is only a receipt of the amount. He has also
submitted that the Bheti 55/1 was duly allotted to his client in the year 2016
followed by an agreement and all up-to-date payments have been made. He has
submitted that as permission was granted to his client only on 03.06.2023, the
construction could not be done in between. However, in the meantime, the
present dispute had arisen. He has also questioned the authority of the
petitioner to make construction without any permission.
11. The rejoinder submission has been made by Shri Chakraborty, learned
counsel for the petitioner who has submitted that the aspect of non-registration
or non renewal of the agreement of his client with the Dhing Municipal Board
has not been pleaded in the affidavit and therefore cannot be raised. He has
also submitted that though no allotment order as such has been served upon
Page No.# 7/8
him, it is not in dispute that the communication dated 19.09.2023, though is in
the form of a receipt will clearly show that allotment was indeed made with his
client for the Bheti 55/1.
12.
The rival submissions have been duly considered and the materials placed
before this Court including the original register and file of the Dhing Municipal
Board have been carefully examined.
13.
The challenge to the cancellation order dated 29.11.2023 has passed on
the basis that the Bheti in question (55/1) was allotted to the petitioner on
19.09.2023. Though there has been some resistance made on behalf of the
respondents that the document relied by the petitioner is not an allotment order,
this Court is of the opinion that the said document, though is in the form of a
receipt would show that the allotment was indeed made in the name of the
petitioner on 19.09.2023. Under those circumstances, it is required to examine
as to whether the cancellation order is legally tenable and justified or not.
14.
The specific defence taken by the respondents which is also reflected in
the documents is that the Bheti 55/1 was already allotted to the respondent no.
7 in the year 2016. The petitioner has however contested the aforesaid aspect
by stating that such defence is a manufactured one as from 2016 onwards there
was no construction made by the respondent no. 7. The said aspect being
within the realm of disputed questions of fact, this Court vide the earlier order
dated 28.07.2026 had directed the learned counsel for the Board to produce the
original documents which has accordingly been produced. To dispel and remove
any doubts on this issue, the said records have been duly examined. The
register which has been produced in original however clearly reflects that Bheti
No. 55/1 was indeed allotted to the respondent no. 7. The aspect that the
respondent no. 7 has not made construction over the land would not make any
Page No.# 8/8
difference to such allotment as the allotment, as such, has not been cancelled.
It is also the pleaded case of the respondents that the respondent no. 7 has
been making up-to-date payments to the Board for the Bheti allotted and it is
also the case of the respondent no. 7 that lack of permission to make
construction was only the reason not to have any construction done. It is on
record that such permission has been granted only on 03.06.2023 and
immediately thereafter, the allotment to the petitioner was made by 19.09.2023
which has been said to be because on a server error. Though it may be argued
that vide the allotment order dated 19.09.2023, a right has accrued upon the
petitioner, taking into consideration that when such allotment was clearly made
by server error and the Bheti was already allotted to the respondent no. 7 way
back in the year 2016 which is fortified by the records, this Court is of the
opinion that the impugned order dated 29.11.2023 cannot be faulted with.
15. The petitioner would however be entitled to have the refund of the entire
money deposited by him. The petitioner may also make appropriate application
for reimbursement of the expenditure incurred for the construction and if the
same is done, it is required to be considered by the Board and disposed of by a
speaking order.
16. The writ petition is accordingly disposed of.
17.
The original records including the register are handed over back to Shri
Gupta, learned counsel for the Board.
JUDGE
Comparing Assistant
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review