Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
IN THE HIGH COURT OF ORISSA AT CUTTACK
W.P.(C) No.41695 of 2023
In the matter of an application under Article 226 and
227 of the Constitution of India, 1950.
………………
Niranjan Khatua
Petitioner
….
-versus….
State of Odisha & Others
For Petitioner
:
For Opp. Parties :
Opposite Parties
M/s. B. Routray, Sr. Adv.
along with
Mr. S. Sekhar, J. Biswal,
A.K. Das and M. Panda, Adv.
M/s. P.K. Panda,
Addl. Standing Counsel
PRESENT:
THE HONBLE MR.JUSTICE BIRAJA PRASANNA SATAPATHY
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------Date of Hearing:15.04.2026 and Date of Judgment:15.04.2026
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------Biraja Prasanna Satapathy, J.
1.
This matter is taken up through Hybrid Mode.
2.
Pursuant to order dt.12.03.2026, learned Addl.
Standing Counsel produced the instruction so provided
by
the
Excise
Directorate,
Odisha
vide
letter
// 2 //
dt.13.04.2026 with service of copy on the learned
counsel appearing for the Petitioner. The same be kept
on record.
3. Heard learned counsel appearing for the parties.
4. The present Writ Petition has been filed inter alia
with the following prayer:
It is therefore, most humbly prayed that this Hon'ble
Court be graciously pleased to:
i) Admit the writ application.
ii) Call for the record.
iii) Issue rule nisi calling upon the Opp. parties more
particularly opposite party No. 2 to show cause as to
why the office order No.11499 dtd.03.11.2023
Annexure-10 shall not be quashed.
iv) If the Opp. Parties more particularly Opp. party
No.2 fails to show cause or show insufficient cause
issue a writ in the nature of certiorari or any other
writ/ writs, order/
orders, direction/ directions by quashing the office
order No.11499 dtd.03.11.2023 Annexure-10.
v) Issue a writ in the nature of mandamus or any
other writ/writs, direction/directions directing the
Opp. Parties more particularly Opp. Party No.2 & 3 to
reinstate the present petitioner along with all
consequential service benefit within a time period to
be stipulated by this Hon'ble Court.
vi)
And/or
pass
any
other
order/orders,
direction/directions as this Hon'ble Court deems fit
and proper for the ends of justice.
And for the said act of kindness, the petitioner as in
duty bound shall ever pray.
// 3 //
5.
It is contended that Petitioner was appointed as
an Excise Constable and posted to the Office of
Superintendent of Excise, Cuttack where he joined on
22.07.2009.
promoted
While
so
continuing,
Petitioner
was
to the rank of ASI, Excise vide order
dt.21.8.2022. However, while so continuing as an ASI of
Excise, a show-cause was issued to the Petitioner by
Opp. Party No.4 on 15.07.2023 under Anexure-3, with
regard to a complaint received that the Petitioner was
consuming liquor with another person in Foreign Liquor
ON-Shop.
5.1.
It is contended that Petitioner though submitted
his reply under Annexure-5, but Petitioner was placed
under suspension vide Office Order dt.19.07.2023 under
Annexure-6.
initiated
vide
Not only that, a proceeding was also
Memorandum
dt.07.09.2023
under
Annexure-7, in terms of the provisions contained under
Rule-16 of the OCS (CCA ) Rules, 1962.
5.2.
It is contended that Petitioner after receipt of the
Memorandum dt.07.09.2023 under Annexure-7, made an
// 4 //
application with a request to provide him the documents
so that he can file his written Statement of defence on
12.09.2023
under
Annexure-8.
However,
without
providing the documents so applied for, vide order
dt.19.10.2023
under
Annexure-9,
Opp.
Party
No.3
appointed the Inquiry Officer to conduct the inquiry.
5.3.
It is contended that while the matter stood thus,
the impugned order dt.03.11.2023 under Anexure-10 was
passed, wherein Petitioner was dismissed from his
services and such an order was passed by Opp. Party
No.2, in exercise of the powers conferred under Article
311(2)(b) of the Constitution of India.
Article 311(2) of the Constitution of India reads as
follows:
311. (2) No such person as aforesaid shall be
dismissed or removed or reduced in rank except after
an inquiry in which he has been informed of the charges
against hi m and given a reasonable opportunity of
being heard in respect of those charges;
Provided that where it is proposed after such inquiry, to
impose upon him any such penalty, such penalty may
be imposed on the basis of the evidence adduced during
such inquiry and it shall not be necessary to give such
person any opportunity of making representation on the
penalty proposed:
// 5 //
Provided further that this clause shall not apply—
(a) where a person is dismissed or removed or reduced
in rank on the ground of conduct which has led to hi s
conviction on a criminal charge; or
(b) where the authority empowered to dismiss or
remove a person or to reduce him in rank is satisfied
that for some reason, to be recorded by that authority in
writing, it is not reasonably practicable to hold such
inquiry; or
(c) where the President or the Governor, as the case
may be, is satisfied that in the interest of the security of
the State, it is not expedient to hold such inquiry.
5.4.
Learned Sr.Counsel appearing for the Petitioner
while
assailing
the
impugned
order,
vehemently
contended that since while exercising the power under
Article 311(2)(b) of the Constitution of India, no reason
was assigned as to why it is not practicable on the part of
the authority to dispense with the inquiry, the impugned
order is not sustainable in the eye of law.
5.5.
In support of his submission, reliance was placed
to a Constitution Bench decision of
the Apex Court in
the case of Union of India and Another Vs. Tulsiram
Patel. Hon’ble Apex Court in Para-133 & 138 of the said
decision has held as follows:
133. The second condition necessary for the valid
application of clause (b) of the second proviso is that the
disciplinary authority should record in writing its reason
for its satisfaction that it was not reasonably practicable
// 6 //
to hold the Inquiry contemplated by Article 311(2). This is
a Constitutional obligation and if such reason is not
recorded in writing, the order dispensing with the inquiry
and the order of penalty following thereupon would both
be vold and unconstitutional.
138. Where a government servant is dismissed,
removed or reduced in rank by applying clause (b) or an
analogous provision of the service rules and the
approaches either the High Court under Article 226 or
this Court under Article 32, the court will interfere on
grounds well established in law for the exercise of
power
of judicial
review in matters where
administrative discretion is exercised. It will consider
whether clause (b) or an analogous provision in the
service rules was properly applied or not....
Xxx
5.6
xxx
xxx
Similarly, reliance was placed to a recent decision
of the Hon’ble Apex Court in the case of Manohar Lal Vs.
Commissioner of Police and Others. Hon’ble Apex
Court in the said decision in Paragraphs-40,41 & 42 has
held as follows:
40. On overall analysis of the intent of Article 311(2), it is
vivid that an employee holding a post in Union or State ought
not to be dismissed or removed by an authority subordinate
to the one by which he was appointed. It is further specified
that a person shall be dismissed or removed or reduced in
rank after an inquiry supplying the charges if any against
him and giving a reasonable opportunity of being heard in
respect of those charges. The applicability of the said clause
is restricted in a situation wherein his conduct led to his
conviction of criminal charges or where the authority
empowered who dismissed, removed or reduced in rank
records reason in writing upon satisfaction that it is not
'reasonably practicable to hold an enquiry against him. In
addition, where such power has been exercised by the
President or the Governor it may be in the interest of security
of the State or if not expedient to hold such an enquiry, then
exceptional power under clause (c) of second proviso to Article
311 ought to be exercised.
// 7 //
41. In case such a decision invoking the extraordinary power
is taken by the competent authority in light of the judgment
Tulsiram Patel (Supra) within the parameter as discussed,
the scope of judicial review is available to the Constitutional
Courts wherein the reasons as assigned for satisfaction of
the authority must be reasonable, valid, Justified and in
writing. In addition, the satisfaction as recorded must be the
objective satisfaction on the basis of material brought on
record which ordinarily the disciplinary authority may take
as a prudent person. Otherwise, dispensing with the enquiry
is not permissible in law. In the present case, Section 21 of
the 1978 Act confers power of punishment and Section 22
prescribes the procedure for awarding such punishment. The
procedure as contemplated has been elaborated under the
1980 Rules. In the present case, in our view, the power
exercised by the authority is completely without application
of mind, thus, the question of recording of satisfaction as
affirmed by the appellate authority, the CAT and the High
Court does not arise. Therefore, we can hold that the order
dispensing with the regular procedure of inquiry is arbitrary
and consequently the order of dismissal of the appellant is
liable to be quashed and the orders of the CAT and the High
Court affirming the said dismissal order stand set aside.
42. In light of the above discussion, the irresistible conclusion
is to set aside the order passed by the CAT and the High
Court and to quash the order of dismissal passed by the DCP
and confirmed by the appellate authority. In consequence,
the appellant shall forthwith be reinstated with continuity of
service. He shall be entitled for all consequential benefits
notionally. Since, the appellant is found involved in a criminal
case, therefore, in the facts of the case, back wages from the
date of dismissal till reinstatement are restricted to 50%.
5.7.
Making
all
these
submissions,
and
placing
reliance on the aforesaid two decisions, learned Sr.
Counsel appearing for the Petitioner contended that since
while exercising the power conferred under Article 311
(2)(b) of the Constitution of India , no reason has been
assigned as to why it is not practicable on the part of
// 8 //
Opp. Party No.2 to dispense with the inquiry, the
impugned order requires interference of this Court.
6.
Learned Addl. Standing Counsel on the other
hand while supporting the impugned order, when made
his submission basing on the counter affidavit so filed by
Opp. Party No.2, this Court passed the following order on
12.03.2026.
“1. This matter is taken up through hybrid mode.
2. Heard learned counsel appearing for the Parties.
3. While reiterating the view expressed by this Court
in order did.22.01.2026, learned Sr. Counsel
appearing for the Petitioner made further contention
contending inter alia that since in the impugned order
while exercising the power under Art. 311(2)(b) of the
Constitution of India, no reason has been assigned
as to why no enquiry is possible, the impugned order
is not sustainable in the eye of law
4. In support of his submission, learned Sr. Counsel
appearing for the Petitioner relied on a decision of
this Court in the case of Dharanidhar Behera Vs.
State of Odisha & Ors. (W.P.C.(OAC) No. 4133 of
2013).
5. Learned Addl. Standing Counsel is directed to
obtain instruction with regard to the order passed on
22.01.2026 and so also the stand taken that no
reason has been assigned by Opp. Party No.2 while
exercising the power under Article 311(2)(b) of the
Constitution of India.
6. As requested, list this matter on 7thApril, 2026.”
7.
Pursuant to the aforesaid order, instruction was
provided by the Excise Directorate and basing on the
// 9 //
instruction, learned Addl Standing contended that Opp.
party No.2 being the competent authority, in view of the
resolution issued by the Government in the Excise
Department on 08.06.2023
is competent to pass the
impugned order in question.
7.1.
It is further contended that
in the impugned
order so passed by Opp. Party No.2 under Annexure-10,
since it has been clearly indicated that it is not
practicable to hold
the inquiry against the Petitioner,
that amounts to compliance the provision contained
under Article 311(2)(b) of the Constitution of India. It is
contended that since while passing the impugned order,
Opp. Party No.2 came to a conclusion that it is not
practicable on his part to hold the inquiry, no illegality or
irregularity can be found with the impugned order.
8.
Having heard learned counsel appearing for the
parties and considering the submission made, this Court
finds that Petitioner while continuing as an ASI, Excise in
the establishment of Opp. Party No.4,a show cause was
issued to him vide letter dt.15.07.2023 under AnnexurePage 9 of 13
// 10 //
3.
Thereafter, Petitioner was placed under suspension
even after receipt of the reply to the show-cause, vide
order
dt.19.07.2023
subsequently,
a
under
proceeding
Annexure-6
was
initiated
and
vide
Memorandum dt.07.09.2023 under Annexure-7.
8.1.
Even though as found from Annexure-7, the
proceeding was initiated under Rule-16 of the OCS (CC &
A) Rules, 1962, but while appointing the Inquiry Officer
as well as Marshalling Officer vide order dt.19.10.2023,
Opp. Party No.3 being the Disciplinary Authority reflected
the proceeding to have been initiated under Rule-15 of
the Rules.
8.2.
It is also found that Petitioner though made an
application to provide him the documents vide letter
dt.12.09.2023 under Annexure-8, but prior to providing
him the documents, the Inquiry Officer and Marshalling
Officer were appointed vide order dt.19.10.2023 under
Annexur-9. Thereafter, the impugned order was passed
by Opp. Party No.2 on 03.11.2023
under Annexure-9
whereby Petitioner was dismissed from his services and
// 11 //
such an order was passed in exercise of power under
Article -311 (2)(b) of the Constitution of India.
8.3.
This Court after going through the provisions
contained under Article 311 (2)(b) of the Constitution of
India and the decisions as cited supra, is of the view that
since while exercising such power, no reason has been
assigned as to why it is not practicable on the part of
Opp. Party No.2
to hold
an inquiry.
Since no such
reason has been assigned save and except the stand that
it is not practicable to hold the inquiry, it is the view of
this Court that stipulation contained under Article
311(2)(b) of the Constitution of India has not been
complied with.
8.4.
In view of the aforesaid analysis, this Court is
inclined to quash the impugned order dt.03.11.2023.
While quashing order dt.03.11.2023 under Annexure-10,
this Court permits Opp. Party No.3 to proceed with the
proceeding
so
initiated
against
the
Petitioner
vide
Memorandum dt.07.09.2023 in accordance with law.
This Court also permits Opp. Party No.3 to issue a
// 12 //
corrigendum by holding that the proceeding has been
initiated under Rule 15 instead of Rule 16 of the Rules.
8.5.
This Court further directs Opp. Party No.3 to
provide the documents so required for the purpose of
filing of written statement of defence to the Petitioner
within a period of 4(four) weeks hence.
On being
provided with the documents, Petitioner be allowed
4(four) weeks time to file his written statement of defence.
On such filing of the written statement of defence, the
Inquiry Officer and the Marshalling Officer so appointed
vide order under Annexure-9
may continue with the
inquiry , if available at present, or else Opp. Party No.3
shall appoint a fresh Inquiry Officer and Marshalling
Officer for the purpose of inquiry with passing of a fresh
order.
This Court permits Opp. Party No.3 to proceed
with the proceeding in accordance with law and in which
case this Court expresses no opinion and conclude the
same as expeditiously as possible preferably within a
period of 8(eight) months from the date of receipt of the
written statement of defence.
// 13 //
8.6.
However, since by the time Petitioner was so
terminated vide the impugned order, he was under
suspension as per order dt.19.07.2023 under Annexure6, this Court directs Opp. Party No.2 to allow the
Petitioner to continue under suspension and pay the
subsistence allowance as due and admissible for the
period Petitioner remained out of employment and future
subsistence allowance till conclusion of the proceeding.
8.7.
This Court further directs Opp. Party No.2 to
conclude the proceeding as expeditiously as possible
preferably by the end of this year.
9.
The Writ Petition accordingly stands disposed of
with the aforesaid observation and direction.
(Biraja Prasanna Satapathy)
Judge
Orissa High Court, Cuttack
Dated the 15th April, 2026 /Sangita
Digitally Signed
Signed by: SANGITA PATRA
Reason: authentication of order
Location: high court of orissa, cuttack
Date: 23-Apr-2026 17:06:42
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review