Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
[ 3168 ]
I
IN THE HIGH COURT FOR THE STATE OF TELANGANA
AT HYDERABAD
TUESDAY, THE TWENTIETH DAY OF JANUARY
TWO THOUSAND AND TWENTY SIX
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE SRI JUSTICE K.LAKSHMAN
CIVIL REVISION PETITION NO: 4303 AND 4313 OF 2025
CRP NO: 4303 OF 2025
Petition under Article 227 of lhe Constitution of lndia aggrieved by the
order dated 1OlOgl2O25 in LA. No. 498 oI 2024 in A.S.No.8 of 2022 on the file of
the Court of the Principal District and Session Judge-Cum-Famity Court,
Medchal-Malkajgiri District, Malkajgiri at Kushaiguda.
Between:
Nimma lt/ohan Reddy, S/o. lla Reddy, aged about 58 years, Occ- Business,
Rl/o. Plot No. 8, NCL Enclave, Pet-Basheerabad, Medchal-lvlalkajgiri District
...PETITIONER/RESPONDENT No. 2
AND
1.
M. Janardhan Reddy, S/o. Yadi Reddy, Aged about 60 years, Rl/o. Plot No.
21, Jupiter Colony, Thirumalgiri, Secunderabad.
...RESPONDENTS/RESPONDENT No. 1
2.
Faiz Ahmed, S/o- Osman Ahmed, Aged 63 Years, Occ- Retd. Govt.
Employee,
J. Irfan Ahmed (Died), (Vide. LRs Respondent No.4-B )
4. Atiya Sulthana, D/o. lrfan Ahmed
5. Mohammed Adnan Ahemed Mughni, S/o. lrfan Ahmed
6. Zara Fatima Asna, D/o. lrfan Ahmed
7. Mohammed Farhan Ahemed Multani S/o. lrfan Ahmed
8. Mohammed Azan Ahmed Burhani, S/ o. lrfan Ahmed
All F/ o. H. No. 20-4-335, Osman College, Kiwath, Hyderabad
...RESPONDENTS/APPELLANTS
lA NO: 'l OF 2025
Petition under Section 151 CPC praying that in the circumstances stated
in the affidavit filed in support of the petition, the High Court may be pleased to
stay all further proceedings in E.P. No. 249 of 2022 on the file of the Principal
Senior Civil Judge, Medhchal-Malkajgiri District at Malkaigiri.
CIVIL REVISION PETITION NO: 4313 OF 2025
Petition under Article 227 of the Constitution of lndia aggrieved by the
order dated 1010912025 in l.A. No. 497 of 2024 in A.S.No.8 of 2022 on the file of
the Court of the Principal District and Session Judge-Cum-Family Court,
Medchal-Malkajgiri District, Malkajgiri at Kushaiguda.
Between:
Nimma Mohan Redd v , S/o. lla Reddy, aged about 58 years, Occ- Business,
Rl/o. Plot No. 8, NCL E nclave, Pet-Basheerabad, Medchal-Malkajgiri District
..PETITIONER/RESPONDENT No. 2
AND
M. Janardhan Reddy, S/o. Yadi Reddy, Aged about 60 years, Rl/o. Plot No,
21, Jupiter Colony, Thirumalgiri, Secunderabad.
...RESPONDENTS/RESPONDENT No. 1
Faiz Ahmed, S/ o. Osman Ahmed, Aged 63 Years, Occ- Retd. Govt.
Employee,
J
lrfan Ahmed (Died), (Vide. LRs Respondent No.4-B )
Atiya Sulthana, D/o. lrfan Ahmed
Mohammed Adnan Ahemed Mughni, S/o. lrfan Ahmed
Zara F atima Asna, D/o. lrfan Ahmed
Mohammed Farhan Ahemed Multani S/o. lrfan Ahmed
Mohammed Azan Ahmed Burhani, S/ o. lrfan Ahmed
All Fi/ o. H. No. 20-4-335, Osman College, Kiwath, Hyderabad
...RESPONDENTS/APPELLANTS
lA NO: 1 OF 2025
Petition under Section 151 CPC praying that in the circumstances stated
in the affidavit filed in support of the petition, the High Court may be pleased to
suspend the operation of the Judgment and Decree dated 31 .12.2018 in O.S.
No. 769 of 2010 on the file of the Principle Senior Civil Judge, Ranga Reddy
District at L.B. Nagar.
I
I
Counsel forthe Petitioner: Sri K. Suyodh Reddy
Counsel for the Respondent No. 'l: Sri Kondaparthy Kiran Kumar
The Court made the following: COMMON ORDER
HIGH COURT FOR THE STATE OF TELANGANA
AT HYDERABAD
HoN'BLE SRI JUSTICE K. LAKSHMAN
CML REVISION PETITION NOs.4303 and .1313 OF 2025
Befs ccn
......Petitioner
Nimma Mohan Reddy,
and
M. Janardhan Reddy and others
......Rcspondents
This Court delivered the following:-
COMMON OIIDER
Lis involved in these revisions and the parties are one and
the same. Therefore, the same were heard together and decided by
way ol this common order:-
2. Heard Mr'. C.Damodar Reddy, learned Senior Counsel
representing Sri K.Suyodh Reddy, learned counsel for the
petitioner and Sri Kondaparthy Kiran Kumar, Ieamed counsel
appearing for l" respondent. Respondent Nos.2, 4 to 8 are only
formal parlies.
3. These two revisions are filed under Article 227 of the
Constitution of India assailing the common order dated 10.09.2025
:
\
)
passed in I.A.Nos.497 and 498 of 2024 in A.S.No.S of 2022 passed
by the learned Principal District Judge, Medchal - Malkajgiri
District at Malkajgiri.
LTNDISPtiTED FACTS:-
4. l" respondent herein has filed a suit vide O.S.No.769 ol
2010 against the petitioner herein, respondent Nos.2 and 3 herein
lor perpetual injunction
ln
respect of thc agricultural land
admeasuring Ac.2.24 guntas ln Sy.No.573, Ac.2.16 guntas ln
Sy.No.574 in total Ac.5.00 guntas situated at Old Atwal Village,
Alwal Municipality, Malkaigiri Mandal, Ranga Reddy District.
The same was decreed on 31.12.2018 by the leamed Principal
Senior Civil Judge at L.B.N4agar, Ranga Reddy District.
5. Defendant Nos.2 and 3 prefcred an appeal vide A.S.No.8
of 2022 challenging the said judgrnent and decree dated 31.12.2018
in O.S.No.769 of 2010. Det'endant Nos.2 and 3 filed two
interlocutory applications under Order 4l Rule 33 read with
Section 151 of CPC to suspend the operation of said judgment and
decree dated 3l.12.2018 and under Order 4 I Rule 5 of CPC to stay
all further proceedings in E.P.No.249 ol 2022 in the said appeal
\
J
t
and the said applications were dismissed. Defendant Nos.2 and 3
did not take any steps challenging the said order and the same
attained finaliry. Flowever, A.S.No.8 of 2022 pending and it is
posted to 04.02.2024 for hearing.
6. The petitioner herein /Defendant.No. I did not prefer any
appeal challenging the saidjudgment and'decree dated 31.10.2018
in O.S.No.769 of 2010. However, he has fited a suit vidc
O.S.No.34 of 2023 seeking d&laration that the said judgrnent and
decree dated 31.12.2018 in O.S.No.769 of 2010 is not binding on
him. In the said suit, he has filed I.A.No.238 of 2023 seeking
suspension of the operation of said judgment and decree dated
31.12.2018 in O.S.No.769 of 2010. Learned Principal District
Judge, Medchal - Malkajgiri District granted interim injunction
order dated 24.02.2023. Subsequently, the said I.A.No.238 ol
2023 was disrnissed on 09.10.2023. Aggrieved by the said order.
the petitioner herein/Defendant No. I has preferred CMA No.6l3 ol
2023 and the same is pending. Thereafter, the petitioner
herein/Defendant No. I i-iied two applications vide I.A.No.497 ol
2024 under Order 4l Rule 33 read with Section 15l of CpC to
I
\
suspend the operation of said judgment and decree dated
3 I . 12.20 18 and I.A.No.49 8 ol 2025 under Order 4 1 Rule 5 of CPC
to stay all further proceedings in 8.P.No.249 of 2022 in the said
appeal and the said applications were dismissed vide common
order dated 10.09.2025. Chatlenging the said order, the petitioner
filed the present revisions;
7. 1't respondent/D.Hr. filed E.P.No.249 of 2022 against
J.Drs. seeking execution ol the sah judgment and decree dated
3 I .12.20 18. It is pending.
8. The petitioner/Def-endant No.1 fited the aforesaid
I.A.Nos.497 and 498 of 2024 contending as follows:t.
1't respondent/plaintiff obtained the said judgment and
decree dated 31.12.2008 in O.S.No.769 of 2010 by
playing fraud on the Court.
It.
1" respondenVplaintiff himsell in the capacity of the
agreement of sale - cum - General Power of Attorney
holder, has executed a registered sale deed and
thereby alienated
an
extent of Ac.0.20 guntas ln
favour of Smt. Tadipalty Rajani, under registered sale
l
deed bearing document No.3 193 of 2009, dated
06.07.2009.
l
Possession has been delivered to the said Tadipally
Raj ani
iv. The said sale deed was executed before filing
O.S.No.769 of 2010. Therefore, the judgment and
decree dated 3 I . 12.2008 in O.S.No.769 of 20 l0
cannot be executed.
Thus, 1" respondent/plaintiff filed the aforesaid suit
suppressing the said fact and obtained said judgment
and decree dated3l.12.2008 by playing fraud.
vi. l'' respondent/p laintiff claimed litle over the suit
schedule property basing on agreement ol sale - cum
GPA bearing document No.278l of 2007 dated
16.06.2007 and recitals of the said document
contemplates that respondent No. I /plaintiff claimed
title over tl.re suit schedule property basing on ROR
proceedings dated 09.01.1996. The same were under
challenge before this Court in W.P.No.l7539 ol 2010
wherein, vide order dated 1 8. I 1 .2013, this Court gave
a clear finding that the said proceedings dated
09.01.1996 are not in existence.
vll.
This Court, vide order dated 28.04.2023, suspended
the pattadar passbooks issued in favour ol respondent
No. liplaintiff.
\/t1l.
The extent claimed by the l'1 respondent/plaintiff is
contradictory to the agrtelnent of salc - cum GPA.
tx.
On coming to know about the said fi'aud, the petitioner
herein has already filed a suit O.S.No.34 of 2023
seeking declaration that the said judgment and decree
is not binding on him.
x
He has also filed I.A.No.238 of 2023 in the said suit
seeking suspension of the operation of the said
judgment and decree dated 31.12.20i8. Leamed
Principal District Judge, Medchal Malkajgiri District,
granted interim injunction vide order dated
24.02.2023, subsequently, tl.re said I.A.No.238 o12023
was dismissed vide order dated 09. 10.2023
l
Aggrieved by the said order, he has preferred CMA
No.6
l3 ol 2023 and the same is pending. I
i1
respondent/plaintiff filed E.A.No.l64 of 2019 rn
8..P.No.249 of 2022 seeking police aid.
xll
During the cross-examination, respondent No. 1/
plaintifl has admitted that he has sold the land
I
admeasuring Ac.0.20 guntas, which is part of suit
schedule property in O.S.No.769 of 2010.
x l.
'Ihus, the judgment and decree dated 31.12.2018 in
O.S.No.769 ol20l0 is liable to be set aside and all the
lunher proceedings in E.P.No.249 of 2022 are liable
to be stayed.
9. l'' respondent/plaintitT tlled counter opposing the said
applications contending :-
i. The petitioner herein/Defendant No. I being the
respondent in the appeal vide A.S.No.8 of 2022
pref-erred by the Defendant Nos.2 and 3, cannot seek
stay of operation of judgment and decree dated
3 I . I 2.20 18 which has become final against him.
I
't
ii. There are no interirn orders in A.S.No.8 of 2022.
Itl.
He did not prefer any appeal challenging the said
judgment and decree dated 31.12.2008 in O.S.No.769
of 20 10.
iv. He cannot pursue parallel remedies i.e. filing
O.S.No.34 <ti 2023 and LA.No.338 of 2023 and the
present applications.
The petitioner did ho? enter into witness box rn
O.S.No.769 of 2010. He has not preferred any appeal
challenging the said judgment and decree and it
attained finality in respect of petitioner/Defendant
No. l.
vi. He cannot take plea of lraud in the present
interlocutory applications.
I
0. Thus, l't respondent/plaintiff/Decree Holder sought to
disr.niss both the applications.
. Vide impugned order dated l0 .09.2025, learned
appellate Cout dismissed both the applications holding that the
petitioner herein did not prefer any appeal challenging the
\^l
.\
judgment and decree dated,31.12.2008 in O.S.No.769 of 2010 and
thus, he is not aggrieved by the same, he cannot plead fraud in the
present applications. Therefore, the said applications filed by him
are not maintainable.
12. Challenging the said common order dated 10.09.2025,
the petitioner filed the present revisions. *.'
13. Sri C. Darnodar Reddy, learned Senior counse[ for the
petitioner and Sri Kondapaghy Kiran Kumar, leamed counsel
appearing for respondent, made their submissions extensively.
14. Learned Senior Counsel appearing for the petitioner
placed reliance on the principle laid down by the Apex Court in
Chandramohan Ramchandra Patil vs. Bapu Koyappa Patil
(Dead ) through L.Rs.r, Azgar Barid (Dead) by L.Rs. vs.
Mazamb2, Eastern Coalfields Ltd. Vs. Rabindra Kumaf,
S.P.Chengalvaraya Naidu vs. Jagannatha, United tndia
Insurance Ltd. vs. Rajenrlra Singhs, Ram Kumar vs, State of
' AIn zoo3 sc t7s+
'atR zo22 sc t3o+
'Civit.Appgt No.2'1-94 of 2022 paragraph No. t3
" r99.r ( l) scc I
(2ooo) 3 scc 581
'>.
\-r
l0
\
UP6 K.D.Sharma vs. Steel Authority of India Ltd.7, State of
Orissa vs. Fakir Charan Sethis, Vijay Syal vs. State of Punjabe,
Chairman - cum - M.D. Coal India Ltd. Vs. Ananta Sahato,
Rama Chandra Singh vs. Savitri Devilr, Erstwhite High Court of
Andhra Pradesh in Fatima Fouzla vs. Walashan Prince
n4oazzam Jah Bahadu#, this Court in K.Anjaiah vs. The Asst.
Commissioner of Proh.& Exciser3.
15. Sri Kondapafthy Kiran Kumar, learned counsel for the
l"
respondent, placed reliance on the principle laid down by Division
Bench of High Court of Himachal Pradesh at Shimla in Pratap
Singh Verma vs. State of H.P.ra.
16. The aforesaid rival contentions would reveal that the
petitioner hercin is Defendant No. I in O.S.No.769 of 2010. t't
respondent/ ptaintiff has filed the said sdit against the petitioner
herein and Defendant Nos.2 and 3 seeking perpetual injunction in
respect of the suit schedule property to restrain the delendants from
u
AIR 2022 sc 4705
't (2008) l2 scc 481
eln 20l5 sc :e6
'(zoo:) g scc aot
'o lzo t t; s scc t+z
" (2003) 8 scc atg
"t1 AIR 1989 AP 315
tzt
zozl
rl 20161tyt6
SCC Online HP 672
1l
interfering with his possession over the suit schedule property
Admittedly, the petitioner herein did not enter into witness box.
Ultimately. learned Princ ipal,, Senior Civil Judge, at L.B.Nagar,
Ranga Redd1, I)istrict decreed the said suit on 3 I . 12.2008
Admittedly, the petitioner herein did not prefer any appeal
challenging the said judgment and decrecil Defendant Nos.2 and 3
pref-en'ed an appeal vide A.S.No.tl ol 2022 challenging the said
.iudgrnent and decree dated-31.12.2008, they have also filed
interlocutory applications seeking suspension of the operation of
the said .iudgment and decree and also to stay all further
proceedings in 8.P.No.249 of 2022, the same were dismissed. They
did not take any steps challenging the said order. Thus, the said
order attained tinatity.
17. tt is relevant to note that the petitioner herein/Defendant
No.
I has filed a suit vide o.S.No.848 ol 2019 (O.S.No.2030 of
2022) against the lo respondent/plaintiff seeking perpetual
injunction. He also filed an application vide I.A.No.369 of 2019
for temporary injunction, pending disposal of the suit. Vide order
dated 18.12.2020, leamed Additional Senior Civil Judge, Ranga
\
Reddy District, initially granted interim injunction and later
modified it as status quo on contest. Chatlenging the said order
dated 18. I 2.2020, the petitioner hercin/Defendant No. 1 filed appeal
vide CMA No.2 ol202l . The same is pending.
18. lt is also not in dispute that during the pendency ofthe
said appeal vide CMA l.io.2 of 2021 and the suit vide O.S.No.2030
ol 2022, the petitioner herein has filed a suit vide O.S.No.34 of
2023 against l" respondent hereiri/ptaintiff, T.V.Vijaya Saradhi,
Smt. T.Vahini Vedatam and Tadipally Rajani, to declare
Agreemenl - cum (leneral Power o1'Attomey bearing document
No.278 I of 2007, sale deed bearing document Nos.2l93 of 2009,
5726 of 2019 and 5737 of 2019 and Judgment and decree dated
3 I .12.2018 in O.S.No.769 ol20l0 as null and void and not binding
on him and also tbr perpetual injunction
lll respect of land
admeasuring Ac.3.24 guntas in Sy.No.5'l3/AA/1, Ac.5.00 guntas in
Sy.No.573 and 574 situated at Old Alwat Municipality. He has also
filed two applications vide I.A.Nos.237 and 238 of 2023 in
O.S.No.34 of 2023 seeking temporary injunction against 1"
respondent herein from alienating the suit schedule property and
-7
l3
for suspension of operation of judgment and decree dated
31.12.2008 in O.S.No.769 of 2010 respectively. The learned
Principal District and Sessions Judge, Medchal Malkajgiri,
dismissed both the applications vide common order dated
09.10.2023. Feeling aggrieved by the said order, the petitioner
herein has also preferred an appeal vide CMA No.613 of 2023 and
the same is pending.
19. 'l'hereafter, the petigioner herein has filed the aforesaid
two applications vide I.A.Nos.497 and 498 ol-2024 in A.S.No.8 of
2022 seeking stay of all lurther proceedings in E.P.No.249 of 2022
and suspend the operation of judgment and decree dated
31.12.2018 in O.S.No.769 of 2010.
20.'l-hus, the petitioner herein is pursuing parallel remedies
in O.S.No.34 of 2023 and also in I.A.Nos.497 and 498 of 2024 in
A.S.No.S of 2022
21. Adnlittedty. he has not preferred any appeal challenging
the judgment and decree dated 31.12.2018 in O.S.No.769 of 2010.
Only Defendant Nos.2 and 3 preferred an appeal vide A.S.No.8 of
2022. In the said appeal, they have also t'lled two interlocutory
l4
applications seeking suspension of the said judgment and decree
and to stay all further proceedings in E.P.No.249 of 2022 and the
same were dismissed.
22. As discussed supra, I.A. Nos. 237 and 238 of 2023 filed
by the petitioner herein / Delendant No. I in O.S.No.34 of 2023
were dismissed by the trial Court on 09.10.2023. Thereafter, the
petitioner herein has tlled the aftrresaid two applications vide I.A.
Nos.497 and 498 oI'2024 in A.S.No.8 of 2022. Thus, the petitioner
herein is pursuing parallel remcdies. He has filed the aforesaid two
interlocutory applications on dismissal of Interlocutory
Applications filed by him in O.S.No.34 of 2023 and during
pendency of CMA No.6l3 of 2023. [t is an abuse of process of
Court. Therefore, the petitioner is not entitled for any relief. On
consideration of the said aspects only, leamed trial Court dismissed
both the applications vide irnpugned common order dated
10.09.2025.
23. With regard to the contention ol the learned Senior
Counsel that 1't respondent/plaintif?Decree Holder obtained the
said judgment and decree dated 31.12.2008 in O.S.No.769 of 2010
I
--7
l5
by playing flaud, the petitioner herein cannot plead fraud without
preferring an appeal challenging the said judgment and decree.
I
llowever, he has also filed a suit O.S.No.34 of 2023 to declare the
said judgment and decree dated 31.12.2008 is not binding on him.
I
He has to raise all these contentions in O.S.No.3 4 ol 2023 and he is
a party in A.S.No.8 of 2022 and he can supplement contentions of
D.2 and D.3 before the appellate Court in the said appeal. He
cannot pursue parallel remeciies. It is an abuse of process of law.
Upon consideration of the said aspects only, learned trial Court
dismissed both the applications vide I.A.Nos.497 and 498 of 2024
filed by the petitioner herein. It is a reasoned order and well
fbunded. [t does not require interference by this Court in the
present revrslons.
24. The petitioner placed reliance on catena of .iudgments of
the Apex Court and other High Courts, but the facts of said cases
are diflerent from the facts olthe case on hand.
25. In view of the aforesaid discussion, both the Civil
Revision Petitions are liable to be dismissed and are dismissed.
i
l6
('
..,,.,"1r.i1i1[:ffi.ej:*eous
petitions. if any, pending in these
Sd/. A.H.S- GOWRI SHANKAR
ASSISTANT REGISTRA
//TRUE COPY//
SECTION OFFICER
To
1. The Principal District and Session Judge-Cum-Family Court, MedchalMalkajgiri District, Malkajgiri at Kushaiguda.
2. One CC to Sd K. Suyodh Reddy, Advocate [OPUC]
3. One CC to Sri Kondaparthy Kiran Kumar, Advocate [OPUC]
4. Two CD Copies
VH,6A
I
I
w
I
HIGH COURT
DATED: 2010112026
,
o
,/',9
l,o
o
I
\
ORDER
*
CRP.No.4303 of 2025
AND
CRP.No.4313 of 2025
DISMISSING BOTH CRP'S
@
oU
I HE s l4
0 2 rr8 2fl26
*
z
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review