The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
20. I have gone through the entire materials available on record. It appears to the court that, the applicant has not made out grounds to show that, she is a necessary or - 10 NC: 2026:KHC:5354 WP No. 39583 of 2025 HC-KAR proper party to the suit and in her absence no effective decree can be passed. On the other hand, the plaintiff has established that, she is not the necessary party to the suit. The intention of applicant clearly shows that, she has filed the present application in this case to delay the proceedings and to cause hardship to the plaintiff. Under such circumstances, this court is of the considered opinion that, the application filed by the applicant liable to be rejected. Accordingly, I answer point No.1 in the Negative.
21. Point No.2: In view of the reasons given on Point No.1, 1 proceed to pass the following: The application filed by the applicant by name Nikhat Afreen W/o Shaik Ziyaulla Under Order 1 rule 10(2) R/W Section 151 of C.P.C-IA No.IV, is hereby rejected. Under the facts and circumstances of the case, no order as to costs.
3. As can be seen from the material on record and the impugned order passed by the trial Court, the trial Court has come to the correct conclusion that in the light of the judgment of the Apex Court in Kasturi vs E. M. Perumal reported AIR 2005 SC 2813 and followed by this Court in the case of Narayan Reddy vs. Manjunath reported AIR 2016 KAR 1, the petitioner who claims an independent right over the suit schedule property and was undisputedly not a party to the agreement sought to be enforced by the plaintiff against the defendant was neither a proper nor necessary party to the suit - 11 NC: 2026:KHC:5354 WP No. 39583 of 2025 HC-KAR especially when the petitioner had already instituted a separate suit in O.S. No.23/2023 ventilating her grievances. It is needless to state that any judgment, decree, order, compromise etc. passed/to be passed in O.S. No.18/2021 would not be binding upon the petitioner nor affect her right, title, interest and possession over the suit schedule property nor cause prejudice to her rights and contentions in O.S. No.23/2023 filed by her. Under these circumstances, I am of the view that the impugned order passed by the trial Court rejecting I.A. No.4 cannot be said to suffer from any illegality or infirmity warranting interference by this Court in the exercise of its jurisdiction under Article 227 of the Constitution of India as held in Radhey Shyam and O…
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
-1NC: 2026:KHC:5354
WP No. 39583 of 2025
HC-KAR
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA AT BENGALURU
DATED THIS THE 30TH DAY OF JANUARY, 2026
BEFORE
THE HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE S.R.KRISHNA KUMAR
WRIT PETITION NO. 39583 OF 2025 (GM-CPC)
BETWEEN:
NIKHAT AFREEM
W/O SHAIK ZIYAULLA
D/O MOHAMMED RIYAZ,
AGED ABOUT 27 YEARS,
R/O SHANTHI NAGARA,
PAVAGAA TOWN,
NOW R/O N.18-293, PARAGI ROAD
HINDUPUR TOWN, SATHYA SAI DISTRICT,
ANDRA PRADESH - 515 201.
…PETITIONER
(BY SRI. N.S. BHAT, ADVOCATE)
Digitally signed
by
SHARADAVANI
B
Location: High
Court of
Karnataka
AND:
1.
NARASIMHA REDDY
S/O V.NAGABHUSHAN REDDY,
AGED ABOUT 47YEARS
R/AT REDDY COLONY,
PAVAGADA TOWN,
PAVAGADA TALUK,
TUMKUR DISTRICT - 561 202.
2.
MOHAMMED RIYAZ
S/O MOHAMMED FAZLULLA,
AGED ABOUT 57 YEARS,
CLASS I P.W.D. CONTRACTOR,
-2NC: 2026:KHC:5354
WP No. 39583 of 2025
HC-KAR
R/AT NEAR M.A.G. BUILDINGS,
TUMKUR ROAD,
PAVAGADA TOWN AND
PAVAGADA TALUK - 561 202.
…RESPONDENTS
THIS WP IS FILED UNDER ARTICLE 227 OF THE
CONSTITUTION OF INDIA PRAYING TO QUASH AN IMPUGNED
ORDER DATED 17-11-2025 ON I.A.NO.4 INO.S.NO.18/2021
PASSED BY THE COURT OF SENIOR CIVIL JUDGE AND JMFC, AT
PAVAGADA AS PER ANNEXURE-E AND CONSEQUENTLY TO
ALLOW I.A. NO.4 UNDER ORDER 1 RULE 10(2) R/W SECTION
151 OF CPC IN O.S.NO.18/2021 AS PRAYED FOR BY THE
PETITIONER AS PER ANNEXURE-C AND ETC.,
THIS PETITION, COMING ON FOR PRELIMINARY
HEARING, THIS DAY, ORDER WAS MADE THEREIN AS UNDER:
CORAM: HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE S.R.KRISHNA KUMAR
ORAL ORDER
This petition by the impleading applicant in I.A. No. 4
filed in O.S.No.18/2021 is directed against the impugned order
dated 17.11.2025, whereby the said application filed by the
petitioner -impleading applicant under I.A.No.4 under Order I
Rule 10(2) CPC seeking impleadment as defendant No.2 in the
suit was dismissed by the trial Court.
2.
A perusal of the material on record will indicate that
the first respondent - Narasimha Reddy instituted suit in O.S.
-3NC: 2026:KHC:5354
WP No. 39583 of 2025
HC-KAR
No.18/2021 against second respondent - defendant for specific
performance and other reliefs in relation to the suit schedule
immovable property. The petitioner who is none other than the
daughter of the sole defendant, Mohamad Riyaz, filed the
instant application inter area contending that the said Mohamad
Riyaz had gifted the suit schedule property in her favour as
long back as on 10.04.2016 and that she had already filed a
suit against both plaintiff and defendant which is pending in OS
No.23/2023 before the trial Court for declaration, permanent
injunction and other reliefs in relation to the very same suit
schedule property. The said impleadment application filed by
the petitioner having been opposed by the respondents, the
trial Court proceeded to pass the impugned order rejecting the
impleadment application by holding as under ORDER ON I.A No.IV
The applicant has filed an application Under Order 1 rule
10(2) R/W Section 151 of C.P.C-IA No.IV and sought to
implead her as defendant No.2, in this suit.
2. In support of the above I.A, the applicant has filed
affidavit and stated that, the plaintiff has filed this suit
against the defendant for Specific performance of
agreement of sale dated 01-12-2017. Her father
Mohammed Riaz, the defendant had executed a Gift deed
dated 10-04-2016 with respect to suit schedule property
measuring 0.25.04.00 guntas in Sy No.15/1A6 of
Pavagada village. Since the date of Gift, she has been in
-4NC: 2026:KHC:5354
WP No. 39583 of 2025
HC-KAR
possession and enjoyment of the suit property. Her father
had executed a registered agreement of sale dated 0112-2017 infavour of plaintiff with respect to suit property,
without her knowledge and consent. The said agreement
of sale is not binding on her right and share in the suit
property. She came to know about the said fact recently
and 12 and permanent injunction, which is pending for
consideration before SEA Suit in O.S.No.23/2023 against
the defendant for Declaration the. Pri Civil Judge and
JMFC, Pavagada. She is the lawful owner and in
possession of the suit schedule property. She has got
right and merits in the case, hence, she is necessary
party to the present proceedings. If the application is
allowed, no hardship would be caused to the plaintiff. On
the other hand, if the application is rejected, it would
cause much hardship to him. On the said grounds, he
prayed to allow the application.
3. On the other hand, the plaintiff has filed objection to
the application denying all the allegations made in the
affidavit annexed to it. It is contended that, the applicant
claiming
right
and
possession
under
fabricated
unregistered gift deed dated 10-04-2016, subsequent to
execution of registered agreement of sale dated 01-122007 in his favour. The said gift deed has been created by
applicant colluding with defendant for wrongful gain. On
the basis of gift deed she has filed suit in O.S.No.23/2023
against the defendant for Declaration and permanent
injunction, which is pending for consideration before the
Prl Civil Judge and JMFC, Pavagada. She has obtained an
ex-parte ad-interim temporary Injunction against her
father defendant suppressing the materials facts. She will
not get any right based on the alleged Gift deed with
respect to suit property. The said gift deed came to be
created after filing the present suit and after passing an
order of injunction. The applicant and entire family having
knowledge about the agreement of sale and filing of this
suit. In order to avoid the plaintiff from getting the relief,
they have colluded with each other and created Gift deed.
The present suit is for specific performance of contract
and the applicant who is not party to the agreement is not
the necessary party to the suit. The dispute in the suit is
only between him and defendant and the scope of suit
cannot be widened permitting the applicant as a party. He
intends to enter the suit only to create hurdles in drawing
-5NC: 2026:KHC:5354
WP No. 39583 of 2025
HC-KAR
decree and thereby make or mend the plaintiff to his
vices. If the application is rejected, nothing will be caused
to the applicant. On the said grounds, the plaintiff prayed
to reject the application.
4. Now the points that arise for my consideration are:
1) Whether the applicant is a necessary or proper
party to the suit to resolve the real controversy
between the parties?
2) What order?
5. Heard the arguments of learned counsel for the
applicant and plaintiff.
6. Perused the I.A and entire materials available on
record.
7. My finding to the above points are:
Point No.1: In the Negative
Point No.2: As per the final order
for the following:
REASONS
8. Point No.1: This is a suit filed by the plaintiff against
the defendant for the relief of Specific performance of
contract and such other reliefs. It is the case of plaintiff
that, defendant being the owner of suit schedule property
had executed a registered agreement of sale dated 0112-2017 in his favour with respect to suit schedule
property. Subsequent to execution of agreement sale, he
did not com forward to execute the sale deed by
producing E-sketch. Hence, he has filed the present suit
for enforcement of agreement of sale.
9. On the other hand, defendant filed written statement
denying the allegations made in the plaint. It is the
contention of defendant that, in view of non-settlement
among the brothers and cancellation of durasth effected
after partition dated 12-11-2017, he could not get E-
-6NC: 2026:KHC:5354
WP No. 39583 of 2025
HC-KAR
sketch and its beyond his control. The consideration
amount of Rs14,50,000/- mentioned in the agreement of
sale is on a lower side having regard to market value of
year 2017-18.
10. The learned counsel for the applicant has filed written
argument reiterating the contentions taken in the affidavit
of IA and further contended that, applicant filed
application for impleading her as her father had executed
Gift deed dated 10-04-2016. The plaintiff filed suit with
respect to property which is in her possession and
enjoyment and without proper title and possession, the
suit is not maintainable. The alleged agreement is
subsequent to execution of Gift deed. The said agreement
executed without her knowledge and consent. Hence, she
is the necessary party to the suit. As per the mohamadan
law gift: Hiba with respect to movable and immovable
property is acceptable. In the present case, the Gift deed
is executed without any exchange and same was accepted
Section 129 TP act is not applicable. That the declaration
of Gift. Send this Hiba according to Mohamadan law and
provisions of Section 129 TP act is not applicable. That
the declaration acceptance and delivery of possession
which are ingredients of Gift under mohamadan law have
been fulfilled. On the basis of Gift, the property was
already transferred into the name of applicant. After
coming to know about the agreement of sale, she had
filed a suit in O.S.No.23/2023 against the defendant
before the Prl Civil judge and JMFC, Pavagada which is
pending for consideration.
11. It is argued that, as per the law laid down in the
decision reported in ILR 2000 KAR 1534 in the case
between G.M.Mujjer Ahamad and another V/s Mohammed
Zafrulla, oral Gift under mohamadan law is permissible.
The applicant is the owner and in possession and
enjoyment of the suit property, hence, she is the
necessary party to the suit to avoid multiplicity of
proceedings. On the said grounds, the learned counsel
sought to allow the application as sought for.
12. On the other hand, the learned counsel for the
plaintiff has submitted his argument reiterating the
contentions taken in the objection filed to the application.
It is argued that, the applicant claiming right and
-7NC: 2026:KHC:5354
WP No. 39583 of 2025
HC-KAR
possession under fabricated unregistered gift deed dated
10-04-2016, subsequent to execution of registered
agreement of sale dated 01-12-2007 in favour of plaintiff.
The said gift deed has been created by applicant colluding
with defendant for wrongful gain. On the basis of gift
deed she has filed suit in O.S.No.23/2023 against the
defendant for Declaration and permanent injunction,
which is pending for consideration before the Prl Civil
Judge and JMFC, Pavagada. She will not get any right
based on the alleged Gift deed with respect to suit
property. In order to avoid the plaintiff from getting the
relief, they have colluded with each other and created Gift
deed. The present suit is for specific performance of
contract and the applicant who is not party to the
agreement is not the necessary party to the suit.
13. It is argued that, the dispute in the suit is only
between him and defendant and the scope of suit cannot
be widened permitting the applicant as a party. In
support of his contention, the learned counsel relied on
decision reported in AIR 2016 KAR 1 in the case between
Sri. Narayana reddy V/s Sri.Manjunath and others and
submitted that, in view of the law laid down in the said
decision a stranger to the contract are not necessary
parties. The intention of applicant is only to create hurdles
in drawing decree and thereby make or mend the plaintiff
to his vices. If the application is rejected, nothing will be
caused to the applicant. On the said grounds, the learned
counsel for the plaintiff prayed to reject the application.
14. Admittedly, the relief sought in this suit is for Specific
performance of agreement of sale on a specific cause of
action occurred to the plaintiff. The purpose of plaintiff to
file the present suit is to enforce the agreement of sale
executed by defendant in his favour. It is the contention
of applicant that, she is the daughter of defendant and he
had executed gift deed in her favour with respect to suit
property on 10-04-2016. She has got right over the suit
property, in which the plaintiff claiming his right under
agreement of sale. It is an admitted fact that, she had
already filed suit against the plaintiff and defendant in
O.S.No.23/2023 for declaration and permanent injunction
which is pending for consideration.
-8NC: 2026:KHC:5354
WP No. 39583 of 2025
HC-KAR
15. It is not the case of applicant that, she got the right
subsequent to agreement to sale or suit. According to
her, she had got right even prior to execution of
agreement to sell. She is not the party to the suit and
there is no contract between the plaintiff and applicant.
The sale transaction under registered agreement of sale is
only between the plaintiff and defendant. The applicant
alleging that, her father had executed Gift deed and
subsequently executed agreement of sale infavour of
plaintiff without her knowledge and consent. It is
pertinent to note, the defendant herein became the silent
spectator by doing all these. It prima-facie shows that,
the applicant filed this application at the instance of
defendant.
16. I have gone though the decision which relied on by
the learned counsel for the plaintiff reported in AIR 2016
KAR 1 in the case between Sri. Narayana reddy V/s
Sri.Manjunath. In the said judgment, the Hon'ble High
court held that, " in a suit for Specific performance of
contract, the dispute being between the vendor and the
agreement holder, the question of deciding the tile and
possession of the parties interested cannot be gone into.
The respondents No.3 to 6 being the strangers to the
contract who are claiming their rights over the suit
schedule property as legal heirs of deceased Khashi
Nanjundappa are not necessary parties to the present
suit. If they have any rights in the suit schedule property,
it would be open for them to assert their rights either by
way of 2 Independent suit or by taking recourse to the
relevant provisions of CPC, if available to them to obstruct
the execution, in a suit for Specific performance of
contract, the question involved is very limited, which
cannot be enlarged to adjudicate the rights of the parties,
i.e., respondents No.3 to 6 said to be the legal heirs of
deceased Kashi Nanjundappa, changing the character of
the suit is not permissible".
17. Wherein the said judgment Hon'ble High court also
referred the decision of Hon'ble Supreme court reported
in AIR 2005 SC 2813 in the case between Kasturi V/s
lyyamperumal and others. Wherein the Hon'ble Supreme
court held that, " It is well settled that in a suit for
Specific performance of contract for sale that the lis
between the appellant and the respondent No.2 and 3
-9NC: 2026:KHC:5354
WP No. 39583 of 2025
HC-KAR
shall only be gone into and it is also not open to the court
to decide whether the respondent Nos. 1 and 4 to 11
have acquired any title and possession of the contracted
property as that would not germane for decision in the
suit for Specific performance of contract for sale that is to
say in a suit for Specific performance of contract for sale
the controversy to be decided raised by the appellant
against the respondent No.2 and 3 can only be
adjudicated upon, and in such a lis the court cannot
decide the question of title and possession of the
respondent Nos.1 and 4 to 11 relating to the contracted
property"
18. In the case on hand, the registered agreement of sale
with respect to suit property taken place only between the
plaintiff and defendant and the applicant is stranger to
the said contract. Apart from that, the applicant had
already filed suit in O.S.No.23/2023 against the
defendant and plaintiff herein for Declaration and
permanent injunction, which is pending for consideration
before the Prl Civil Judge and JMFC, Pavagada. In view of
the law laid down in the aforesaid decisions by the
Hon'ble Supreme court and also Hon'ble High court, in a
suit for Specific performance of contract for sale that the
lis between the plaintiff and defendant shall only be gone
into and it is not open to the court to decide whether the
applicant has acquired any title and possession of the suit
schedule contracted property.
19 The controversy to be decided raised by the plaintiff
against the defendant can only be adjudicated. The court
cannot decide the question of title and possession of the
property sold under agreement of sale. Therefore, the
applicant who is claiming her right under the alleged Gift
deed is not a necessary or proper party to the suit. If at
all, the applicant has any grievance against the plaintiff
and defendant, she has to exhaust the remedy in another
suit which is pending for consideration. So for as the issue
involved in the present case is concerned, her presence is
not necessary. She neither necessary nor proper party to
the present suit.
20. I have gone through the entire materials available on
record. It appears to the court that, the applicant has not
made out grounds to show that, she is a necessary or
- 10 NC: 2026:KHC:5354
WP No. 39583 of 2025
HC-KAR
proper party to the suit and in her absence no effective
decree can be passed. On the other hand, the plaintiff has
established that, she is not the necessary party to the
suit. The intention of applicant clearly shows that, she has
filed the present application in this case to delay the
proceedings and to cause hardship to the plaintiff. Under
such circumstances, this court is of the considered opinion
that, the
application filed by the applicant liable to be rejected.
Accordingly, I answer point No.1 in the Negative.
21. Point No.2: In view of the reasons given on Point
No.1, 1 proceed to pass the following:
ORDER
The application filed by the applicant by name
Nikhat Afreen W/o Shaik Ziyaulla Under Order 1 rule
10(2) R/W Section 151 of C.P.C-IA No.IV, is hereby
rejected.
Under the facts and circumstances of the case, no
order as to costs.
3.
As can be seen from the material on record and the
impugned order passed by the trial Court, the trial Court has
come to the correct conclusion that in the light of the judgment
of the Apex Court in Kasturi vs E. M. Perumal reported AIR
2005 SC 2813 and followed by this Court in the case of
Narayan Reddy vs. Manjunath reported AIR 2016 KAR 1,
the petitioner who claims an independent right over the suit
schedule property and was undisputedly not a party to the
agreement sought to be enforced by the plaintiff against the
defendant was neither a proper nor necessary party to the suit
- 11 NC: 2026:KHC:5354
WP No. 39583 of 2025
HC-KAR
especially when the petitioner had already instituted a separate
suit in O.S. No.23/2023 ventilating her grievances. It is
needless
to
state
that
any
judgment,
decree,
order,
compromise etc. passed/to be passed in O.S. No.18/2021
would not be binding upon the petitioner nor affect her right,
title, interest and possession over the suit schedule property
nor cause prejudice to her rights and contentions in O.S.
No.23/2023 filed by her. Under these circumstances, I am of
the view that the impugned order passed by the trial Court
rejecting I.A. No.4 cannot be said to suffer from any illegality
or infirmity warranting interference by this Court in the exercise
of its jurisdiction under Article 227 of the Constitution of India
as held in Radhey Shyam and Ors v Chhabi Nath and Ors –
(2015)
SCC
423;
K.P.
Natarajan
and
Ors.
vs.
Muthalammal and Ors – AIR 2021 SC 344; and Mohd. Ali
v V. Jaya – (2022) 10 SCC 477. Accordingly, the following ORDER
(i)
The
petition
is
hereby
disposed
of
without interfering with the impugned order dated
17.11.2025 passed in O.S.No.18/2021.
- 12 NC: 2026:KHC:5354
WP No. 39583 of 2025
HC-KAR
(ii) It is made clear that any judgment,
decree,
order,
compromise
etc.
passed/to
be
passed in O.S. No.18/2021 shall not be binding
upon the petitioner nor affect her right, title,
interest and possession over the suit schedule
property nor cause prejudice to her rights and
contentions in O.S. No.23/2023 filed by her.
Sd/(S.R.KRISHNA KUMAR)
JUDGE
YKL
List No.: 2 Sl No.: 13
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review