The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
05. 12.2022 containing the grounds of detention, there is no recording of the circumstances under which the detention order could not be furnished within the stipulated period of 5 days and as such, the detention order is liable to be set aside on this ground alone. He also submits that the State Government took 12 days in disposal of the representation submitted by the detenu and the same is not explained. The Central Government is yet to pass any order with regard to the representation submitted by the detenu. For violation of all the statutory requirements, Mr. Shashibhushan, learned senior counsel, prays for setting aside of the detention order and the said detenu be set at liberty or release the detenu from detention. [11] Mr. Th. Vashum, learned G.A. for the State respondents, submits that the representation dated 29.12.2022 was forwarded by the IG (Prisons) vide letter dated 30.12.2022 and was received on 02.01.2023. On Page 5
05. 01.2023, para-wise comment was called from DGP, Manipur and the same was furnished on 06.01.2023. After considering the view of the Advisory Board and the para-wise comment, the State Government rejected the representation dated 29.12.2022 on 11.01.2023. He submits that there is no inordinate delay on the part of the State Government. He further submits that the grounds of detention was furnished within the outer limit of 15 days and as such, there is no violation of the mandatory provisions. [12] Mr. Kaminikumar, learned for the Central Government, submits that he has no specific instruction in this matter and this Court may pass appropriate order. [13] Considering the submissions of the learned counsel for both the parties at bar and on perusal of the documents on record, it is seen that the grounds of detention was furnished on 05.12.2022 i.e. 10 days after the detention order dated 25.11.2022. It is the mandate of Section 3(3) of the PIT-ND & PS Act that ordinarily, grounds of detention should be furnished within 5 days and in exceptional cases and for the reasons to be recorded in writing, the same may be furnished within 15 days from the date of detention. In the present case, there is no recording of such reasons for not furnishing the grounds of detention within the stipulated period of 5 days. As such, the State Government cannot claim the benefit of the outer limit of…
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
IN THE HIGH COURT OF MANIPUR
AT IMPHAL
W.P. (Cril.) No. 39 of 2023
Mrs. Nienglalchawi, aged about 26 years, W/o Solensei Haokip,
resident of B. Vengnom Village, P.O. & P.S. Churachandpur, District:
Churachandpur, Manipur-795135.
…... Petitioner/s
- Versus 1. The State of Manipur represented by the Special Secretary
(Home), Government of Manipur, Manipur Secretariat, South
Block, P.O. & P.S. Imphal, District: Imphal West, Manipur795001.
2. The Union of India represented by Secretary (Finance),
Government of India, Ministry of Finance, North Block, New
Delhi-110001.
3. The Superintendent, Manipur Central Jail, Imphal, P.O. & P.S.
Imphal, District: Imphal West, Manipur-795001.
........Respondent/s
B E F O R E
HON’BLE THE ACTING CHIEF JUSTICE M.V. MURALIDARAN
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE A. GUNESHWAR SHARMA
For the petitioner
:: Mr. L. Shashibhushan, Sr. Advocate
For the respondents
:: Mr. Th. Vashum, G.A. for the State and Mr.
S. Kaminikumar, CGC for the Union of
India.
Date of Order
:: 27.03.2023
Page 1
O R D E R (ORAL)
A. Guneshwar Sharma, J.
[1]
The detenu, namely Mr. Solensei Haokip, was arrested on
09.05.2022
in
connection
with
FIR No.
17(5)2022 KPI
PS u/s
21(c)/29/60(3) NDPS Act. From his possession 212 Shop cases containing
suspected Heroin No. 4 weighing 2.131 Kgs. was recovered and he was
remanded to police custody and later on to judicial custody. Vide order
dated 15.11.2022 in Cril.Misc.Case No. 63 of 2022, the Ld. Special Judge
(ND & PS), Senapati rejected the application under Section 167(2) Cr.P.C.
read with Section 37 of ND & PS Act on the ground that extending the
period for completing the investigation under Section 36 (A)(4) of ND & PS
Act was disposed of on 09.11.2022.
[2]
Vide order dated 25.11.2022, the Special Secretary (Home),
Government of Manipur issued the detention order to the detenu under
Section 3(1) of the Prevention of Illicit Traffic in Narcotic Drugs and
Psychotropic Substances Act (PIT-ND & PS Act), 1988 for effectively
preventing him from further involvement in illicit trafficking of narcotic drugs
and psychotropic substances for a period of three months until further
orders.
[3]
Vide letter dated 05.12.2022, the Special Secretary (Home),
Government of Manipur furnished the grounds of detention to the detenu
wherein it was stated that 2.131 Kgs. of Heroin No. 4 was seized from him
and the co-accused. It was stated that the detenu filed Cril.Misc.Case No.
Page 2
63 of 2022 and he was likely to be released on bail. It was stated that the
extension of time under Section 36 (A)(4) of ND & PS Act was required to
be modified and releasing the accused on bail on expiry of 180 days would
hamper the progress of investigation and as an alternative measure,
preventive detention order was passed. However, there is no explanation
for not furnishing the grounds of detention to the detenu within 5 days of
detention as under Section 3(3) of the PIT-ND & PS Act.
[4]
Vide
letter
dated
29.12.2022
addressed
to
the
Superintendent, Manipur Central Jail, Sajiwa, the detenu submitted 2 (two)
similar representations all dated 29.12.2022 to the Chief Secretary,
Government of Manipur and to the Deputy Secretary (PIT-ND & PS),
Ministry of Finance, Department of Revenue, Government of India, New
Delhi for revocation of the detention order dated 25.11.2022 on the ground
that no recovery was made from him, he was wrongly implicated and the
default bail was already rejected on 15.11.2022 and no reason for likely to
be released on bail was mentioned. It was prayed that a copy of the
representation be sent to the Advisory Board and to the Deputy Secretary
(PIT-ND & PS), Ministry of Finance, Department of Revenue, Government
of India, New Delhi.
[5]
Vide order dated 11.01.2023, the Commissioner (Home),
Government of Manipur rejected the representation submitted by the
detenu as being devoid of merit. Vide order dated 27.01.2023, the
Commissioner (Home), Government of Manipur confirmed the detention
Page 3
order dated 25.11.2022 and fixed the period of detention for 12 months
from the date of detention.
[6]
The detention order was challenged mainly on the ground
that:
(i)
Non-application of mind while passing the detention
order;
(ii)
Delay in disposal of the representation by the State
Government; and
(iii)
Furnishing the grounds of detention beyond 5 days in
violation of under Section 3 (3) of the PIT-ND & PS Act.
[7]
The State Government filed counter affidavit and it was stated
that the detenu and co-accused were habitual drug offender and from their
possession, Heroin No. 4 of 2.131 Kgs (of commercial quantity) was
recovered. Further, it was stated that they were indulging in illicit trafficking
of drugs thereby earning illegal profit and as an alternative measure,
preventive detention was taken. It was also stated that the representation
dated 29.12.2022 forwarded by IG (Prisons) was received on 02.01.2023.
[8]
The Central Government did not file any reply.
[9]
Heard Mr. L. Shashibhushan, learned senior counsel for the
petitioner, Mr. Th. Vashum, learned G.A. for the State respondents and Mr.
S. Kaminikumar, learned CGC for the Union of India.
Page 4
[10]
Mr. L. Shashibhushan, learned senior counsel for the
petitioner, submits that on 05.12.2022, the grounds of detention was
furnished to the detenu with respect to the detention order dated
25.11.2022, i.e. after expiry of 10 days from the date of detention. The
learned senior counsel draws the attention of this Court to the provision of
Section 3(3) of the PIT-ND & PS Act. He further submits that the grounds
of detention ought to be furnished within 5 days in ordinary case and in
exceptional circumstances and for the reasons to be recorded within 15
days from the date of detention. He points that in the letter dated
05.12.2022 containing the grounds of detention, there is no recording of
the circumstances under which the detention order could not be furnished
within the stipulated period of 5 days and as such, the detention order is
liable to be set aside on this ground alone. He also submits that the State
Government took 12 days in disposal of the representation submitted by
the detenu and the same is not explained. The Central Government is yet
to pass any order with regard to the representation submitted by the
detenu.
For
violation
of
all
the
statutory
requirements,
Mr.
L.
Shashibhushan, learned senior counsel, prays for setting aside of the
detention order and the said detenu be set at liberty or release the detenu
from detention.
[11]
Mr. Th. Vashum, learned G.A. for the State respondents,
submits that the representation dated 29.12.2022 was forwarded by the IG
(Prisons) vide letter dated 30.12.2022 and was received on 02.01.2023. On
Page 5
05.01.2023, para-wise comment was called from DGP, Manipur and the
same was furnished on 06.01.2023. After considering the view of the
Advisory Board and the para-wise comment, the State Government
rejected the representation dated 29.12.2022 on 11.01.2023. He submits
that there is no inordinate delay on the part of the State Government. He
further submits that the grounds of detention was furnished within the outer
limit of 15 days and as such, there is no violation of the mandatory
provisions.
[12]
Mr.
S.
Kaminikumar,
learned
CGC
for
the
Central
Government, submits that he has no specific instruction in this matter and
this Court may pass appropriate order.
[13]
Considering the submissions of the learned counsel for both
the parties at bar and on perusal of the documents on record, it is seen that
the grounds of detention was furnished on 05.12.2022 i.e. 10 days after the
detention order dated 25.11.2022. It is the mandate of Section 3(3) of the
PIT-ND & PS Act that ordinarily, grounds of detention should be furnished
within 5 days and in exceptional cases and for the reasons to be recorded
in writing, the same may be furnished within 15 days from the date of
detention. In the present case, there is no recording of such reasons for not
furnishing the grounds of detention within the stipulated period of 5 days.
As such, the State Government cannot claim the benefit of the outer limit of
15 days as an exceptional case, when no reason has been recorded in this
regard. The detention order is bad on this ground alone. However, we do
Page 6
not find any undue delay in disposal of the representation of the detenu by
the State Government and 13 days time taken in disposing of the
representation has been explained properly by the State Government. On
the other hand, the Central Government is yet to pass any order on the
representation submitted by the detenu even after 88 days from the date of
receiving of the representation. There is no explanation in this regard and
the detention order is liable to be set aside on this ground also. In the case
of Rajammal v. State of T.N. reported in (1999) 1 SCC 417: 1999 SCC
(Cri) 93, at page 421 and Sarabjeet Singh Mokha v. The District
Magistrate, Jabalpur reported as MANU/SC/1011/2021, the Hon’ble
Supreme Court held that non-disposal and/or delay in disposal of the
representation of the detenu vitiates the detention order.
[14]
Accordingly, the detention order dated 25.11.2022 and
confirmation order dated 27.01.2023 are set aside for delay in furnishing
grounds of detention and non-disposal of the representation by the Central
Government. The detenu, namely Solensei Haokip, be released from
detention forthwith, if not required in any other case.
[15]
Accordingly, writ petition is allowed. No cost.
JUDGE
ACTING CHIEF JUSTICE
FR/NFR
joshua
KH. JOSHUA KH. JOSHUA MARING
Date: 2023.05.03
MARING
10:57:08 +05'30'
Page 7
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review