Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Serial No. 01
Supplementary List
HIGH COURT OF MEGHALAYA
AT SHILLONG
WP(C) No. 316 of 2022
Date of Decision: 17.08.2023
Shri. Ngaitlang Dhar Vs. Employees State Insurance Corporation (ESIC)
Coram:
Hon’ble Mr. Justice W. Diengdoh, Judge
Appearance:
For the Petitioner/Appellant(s)
: Mr. S. Deb, Adv.
For the Respondent(s)
: Ms. W.B. Khongjee, Adv.
i)
Whether approved for reporting in
Law journals etc.:
ii)
Whether approved for publication
in press:
Yes/No
Yes/No
JUDGMENT AND ORDER
1.
This is a petition under Article 226 of the Constitution of India with
a prayer for issuance of a writ in the nature of Mandamus and/or Certiorari
or any other appropriate Writ, Order and direction preferred by the
petitioner herein.
2.
Heard Mr. S. Deb, learned counsel for the petitioner who has
submitted that the petitioner is a well-respected and reputed businessman of
Meghalaya who has provided employment to numerous individuals through
his various businesses.
3.
The petitioner was, however, surprised to receive copy of
communication
dated
30.11.2021
being
No:43000064460000704/
11182021419/617/419 issued by the Authorised Officer, ESI Corporation
Regional Office, Guwahati addressed to the Recovery Officer, ESI
Corporation, Guwahati for recovery of contribution under section 45C to
45-I of the Employees’ State Insurance (ESI) Act, 1948 amounting to ₹
69,719/- plus interest @ of 12% p.a. with effect from 21.07.2012. The
petitioner was addressed as Proprietor/Principal Employer of M/s N Dhar
Construction.
4.
Again, vide communication No. 43000064460000704/RRC dated
17.08.2022 the Recovery Officer ESIC, NE Region has issued Prohibitory
Order to the Branch Manager, State Bank of India, Laitumkhrah (Shillong)
Branch prohibiting operation of Account No. 20011865907 operated by the
petitioner, again, addressed as Proprietor/Principal Employer/Director of
M/s N Dhar Construction. The petitioner has then addressed a letter dated
22.08.2022 to the Authorised Officer, ESIC, Regional Office, Guwahati
informing him that there is no such establishment/factory by the name of
M/s N Dhar Construction nor is he the Principal Employer as alleged. It
was also clarified that there is no such workshop of the petitioner located at
Mawblei, Opp. Syiem Workshop, Shillong.
5.
The learned counsel has also submitted that having failed to receive
any response to the letter dated 22.08.2022 the petitioner has caused a legal
notice dated 24.08.2022 to be issued upon the Recovery Officer, ESIC NE
Region, Guwahati. The same also being addressed to the Branch Manager,
SBI Laitumkhrah (Shillong) Branch, with a request to withdraw/recall the
impugned order dated 17.08.2022.
6.
The learned counsel has further submitted that the petitioner not
being the Principal Employer of the said M/s N Dhar Construction, he is
not liable for any claim for recovery of contribution under the ESI Act. In
extension, the provision of section 75(2)(a) of the ESI Act, 1948 being the
powers of the Employees’ Insurance Court to adjudicate as regard recovery
of contribution from the Principal Employer, the same may not be
applicable to the petitioner.
7.
Again, it is submitted that there is no basis or evidence whatsoever
for the respondent/Corporation to prove any fact from the alleged
inspection conducted at Mawblei, when on some baseless and unverified
information received from one Smti. Durka Dhar who is an illiterate person
and who has no knowledge of the business of the petitioner, the said
recovery proceedings was initiated. It is reiterated that there is no
establishment belonging to the petitioner under the banner of M/s N Dhar
Construction at Mawblei, Shillong.
8.
On the legal aspect, the learned counsel has submitted that though
there is no definition of the word ‘establishment’ under the said Act of
1948, section 2(12) defines ‘factory’ to mean any premises including the
precincts thereof whereon ten or more persons are employed or were
employed on any day of the preceding twelve months. Here again, there is
no record to show that there are ten or more persons employed with M/s N
Dhar Construction at Mawblei Shillong, therefore, the impugned order is
entirely unfounded, misconstrued and not tenable in law. The same is liable
to be interfered with by this Court and to be quashed accordingly.
9.
Ms. W.B. Khongjee, learned counsel for the respondents No. 1, 2
and 3/ESIC has submitted that the process of recovery initiated under
section 45A of the ESI Act was for the failure of the petitioner to furnish a
Declaration of Registration in Form-01 as required under Regulation 10-h
of the ESI (General) Regulation, 1950 following which, a Social Security
Officer (SSO) visited the unit at Mawblei on 24.04.2012 for the purpose of
survey. The SSO met Smti. Durka Dhar who introduced herself as the
Workshop Manager and has also verbally furnished the information as
regard the name and address of the Principal Employer and the nature of
business but has failed to produce basic records such as attendance register,
salary register, etc. On the basis of the recommendation made by the SSO,
the ESI Act was extended to M/s N Dhar Construction.
10.
The learned counsel has further submitted that since the petitioner
who is the Principal Employer has failed to comply with the relevant
provisions of the ESI Act notice dated 17.07.2015 was issued to determine
the contribution due for the period April 2012 to May 2015. On the
employer failing to respond to the said notice, another opportunity to be
heard on 07.05.2019 was afforded to the employer but having failed to do
so, accordingly an order under section 45A of the ESI Act was passed on
10.04.2019 and on no appeal being preferred against such order, the matter
was then referred to the Recovery Office vide Form C-19 dated 30.11.2021
to recover the dues.
11.
If the petitioner is aggrieved by the action of the respondent/ESIC on
the issuance of the impugned order dated 30.11.2021, he should have
sought relief from the Employees’ Insurance Court as provided under
section 75 of the said ESI Act, submits the learned counsel. By failing to do
so, the petitioner is precluded from approaching this Court with this instant
petition.
12.
In support of this contention, the learned counsel has referred to the
case of Khasrul Islam v. Union of India & 5 Ors. wherein in WP(C)/
981/2022 vide order dated 16.02.2022 the Hon’ble Gauhati High Court
dealing with a case under the ESI Act has observed that there is a statutory
remedy provided under section 75 of the ESI Act, 1948 available to the
petitioner to agitate against a notice of demand therefore, the court has
directed the petitioner therein to approach the Employees’ Insurance Court
in that regard. Similarly, in the case M/s Assam Railway Employees CoOperative Association Ltd. v. The Employees State Insurance Corporation
& 2 Ors., the Hon’ble Gauhati High Court vide order dated 24.08.2018 has,
under
the
facts
and
circumstances
of
the
case
directed
the
petitioner/Association to approach the Employees’ Insurance Court as
provided under section 75 of the ESI Act.
13.
In another case before the High Court of Tripura, the Hon’ble High
Court vide order dated 11.05.2018 in WP(C) No. 476/2014 in a case where
the petitioner was served with a show cause notice for non-compliance of
the provisions of the Employees’ State Insurance Act, 1948, has declined to
exercise its inherent jurisdiction under Article 226 of the Constitution and
has considered it appropriate for the petitioner to approach the competent
court under section 75 of the said ESI Act.
14.
In response to this, the petitioner has submitted that the case laws
relied upon by the respondent/ESIC are not applicable to the case in hand
inasmuch as the petitioner has denied the existence of any such
establishment wherein, he is said to be the Principal Employer of the same
and as such, taking recourse to the provision of section 75 of the ESI Act is
not the option available to the petitioner.
15.
This Court has taken note of the respective stand of the parties, the
respondent No. 4/Branch Manager, State Bank of India, Laitumkhrah
(Shillong) Branch, not having participated in these proceedings the matter
shall proceed exparte against the said respondent.
16.
Without going into the merits of the case of the parties as noted
hereinabove, what is apparent is that the petitioner at the outset has
outrightly denied being the Principal Employer or the Proprietor of M/s N
Dhar Construction. In the absence of any evidence as to the existence of
such an establishment at Mawblei, Shillong which was the place where the
alleged inspection and survey by the said SSO has taken place, the fact that
no records of any employees, not to say of ten employees or more being
employed by the said establishment is available would only lead this Court
to believe that the basic dispute would be an issue of facts.
17.
It is well settled that this Court more often than not, would not in
judicial review go into disputed question of facts between the parties,
though as observed in very exceptional or rare cases facts could be gone
into. However, in this case, the initial resistance of the petitioner is that he
is not the Principal Employer of M/s N Dhar Construction. This being the
case, the provision of section 75 of the ESI Act would also not be
applicable, since the provision speaks of adjudication of dispute by the
Employees’ Insurance Court as regard dispute which arises, inter alia,
involving the Principal Employer and the Corporation or between a
Principal Employer and an Immediate Employer, therefore, if the status of
a Principal Employer cannot be attached to the petitioner herein, the
purview of section 75 is excluded from its operation to the case of the
petitioner in this regard.
18.
The question then would arise as to how to determine the issue of
whether the petitioner is the Principal Employer of M/s N Dhar
Construction. The simple answer will lie in this, that is, that the only
competent court to decide this issue would be the civil court.
19.
This being the case, the prayer of the petitioner cannot be decided in
this lis and the parties are at liberty to approach the competent civil court
for redressal of their dispute.
20.
Accordingly, the prayer made in this petition cannot be accepted.
The same is hereby rejected.
21.
Petition disposed of. No costs.
Judge
Meghalaya
17.08.2023
“Tiprilynti–PS”
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review