Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
AGARTALA
MAC App. No.22 of 2024
New India Assurance Company Ltd.,
Agartala Division,
4, Mantribari Road,
P.S. West Agartala,
District- West Tripura,
Pin- 799001.
Represented by its Divisional Manager.
(Insurer of motor bike bearing No.TR-03-H-5725)
….Appellant.
Versus
1.
Sri Sankar Saha,
S/o. Late Monmohan Saha.
2.
Smti. Basana Saha,
W/o. Sri Sankar Saha.
Both are resident of No.1 Sukanta Colony,
Rangkang, Amarpur, P.S. Birganj,
District- Gomati Tripura,
Pin- 799101
…….Respondent Claimants.
3.
Sri Abhijit Datta,
S/o. Sri Himangshu Bikas Datta,
Resident of Nabadiganta Lane,
Joynagar, Agartala,
P.S. West Agartala,
District- West Tripura,
Pin- 799001.
(Present owner of the vehicle No.TR-01-AE-1621,
Tipper).
4.
Sri Utpal Deb,
S/o. Late Gopal Deb,
Resident of Majlishpur,
Mohanpur, Agartala,
P.S. Ranir Bazar,
District- West Tripura,
Pin- 799035.
(Previous owner of the vehicle No.TR-01-AE-1621,
Tipper).
.….Respondent Owners.
5.
Sri Ashim Das,
S/o. Sri Adhir Ch. Das,
Resident of Bilthai, Dharmanagar,
P.S. Panisagar,
District- North Tripura,
Pin- 799260.
(Driver of the vehicle No.TR-01-AE-1621, Tipper).
….Respondent Driver
6.
Sriram General Insurance Co. Ltd.,
BR Arcade, 3rd Floor,
21, Janapath, Opp. of Hotel Priya Palace,
Ulubari, P.S. Paltanbazar,
Guwahati, Assam.
(Insurer of the vehicle No.TR-01-AE-1621, Tipper).
.…Respondent Insurer
For Appellant(s)
:
Mr. G. S. Das, Adv,
Mr. K. Deb, Adv.
For Respondent(s)
:
Mr. S. Bhattacharjee, Adv,
Mr. K. De, Adv.
Date of Hearing
:
02.09.2024
Date of delivery of
Judgment and Order :
Whether fit for
Reporting
:
05.09.2024
NO
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE BISWAJIT PALIT
Judgment & Order
This appeal is preferred under Section 173 of M.V.
Act challenging the judgment and award dated 27.09.2023
delivered by Learned Motor Accident Claims Tribunal No.2,
Gomati Judicial District, Udaipur in connection with case
No.T.S.(MAC) 10 of 2022. By the said judgment and award,
Learned
Tribunal
below
has
fastened
the
liability
of
compensation upon both the Insurance Companies jointly in
equal share i.e. the present appellant and also the respondent
No.6, Sriram General Insurance Company Limited.
02.
Heard Learned Counsel, Mr. G. S. Das for the
appellant Insurance Company and also heard Learned Counsel
Mr. K. De for the respondent Insurer No.6, Sriram General
Insurance Company Limited and also heard Learned Counsel,
Mr. S. Bhattacharjee for the respondent-claimants.
03.
In course of hearing of argument Learned Counsel
for the appellant drawn the attention of this Court that in this
case, the present appellant has only challenged the mode of
payment of compensation by the Tribunal. According to
Learned Counsel, the offending tipper vehicle was insured with
respondent No.6, i.e. the Sriram General Insurance Company
Limited, but the Learned Tribunal below fastened the liability of
compensation upon the appellant and also upon the said
respondent No.6 equally, but the motor bike insured with the
appellant was in no way responsible for the alleged accident on
the alleged day of accident.
Learned Counsel for the appellant first of all drawn
the attention of the Court referring page No.8 of the claim
petition
wherein,
mentioned
that
in
on
column
the
No.20,
alleged
day
it
the
was
specifically
deceased
was
proceeding towards Amarpur from his house at Sukanta Colony
by riding his motor bike bearing No.TR-03-H-5725 and while
he reached at Rangkang near Kawamara Samatatal mouth on
the way of Amarpur to Nutanbazar Road that time the driver of
offending vehicle bearing No.TR-01-AE-1621 (Tipper) was
proceeding towards Nutanbazar from Amarpur reached at
Rangkang near Kawamara Samatatal mouth without giving any
signal of indicator and dashed the said motor bike rash and
negligently. Learned Counsel for the appellant further drawn
the attention of this Court the examination-in-chief in affidavit
of the witness Smt. Basana Saha wherein in para No.4, she
specifically stated that on 29.01.2020 at about 01.30 p.m. her
son, Litan Saha was proceeding towards Amarpur from his
house at Sukanta Colony by riding his motor bike bearing
No.TR-03-H-5725 and while reaching towards at Rangkang
near Kawamara Samatatal mouth on the way of Amarpur to
Nutanbazar Road under Birganj Police Station, Amarpur that
time the driver of the offending vehicle bearing No.TR-01-AE1621
(Tipper) was proceeding towards Natunbazar from
Amarpur reached at Rangkang near Kawamara Smatatal mouth
without giving any signal of indicator dashed against the motor
bike rash and negligently.
Learned Counsel further submitted that in the
charge
sheet
which
was
relied
upon
by
the
claimant-
petitioners, it was specifically stated that the I.O. after
completion of investigation being prima facie satisfied laid
charge sheet against the driver of tipper truck bearing No.TR-
01-AE-1621 namely Ashim Das. Learned Counsel further
submitted that the Learned Tribunal below at the time of
determining of the claim-petition framed the following issues:
(I) Whether Litan Saha, S/o Sri Sankar
Saha died in a road traffic accident on
29-01-2020 at about 1.30 PM at
Rangkhang near Kawamara under PSBirganj due to the rash and negligent
driving by the driver of the Tipper
bearing No. TR-01AE-1621 (Tipper)?
(II) Are the claimant-petitioners entitled
to be compensated under the Motor
Vehicles Act, 1988? If so, to what extent
and who shall be liable to pay such
compensation?
Referring the same, Learned Counsel submitted that
upon the pleadings of the parties Learned Tribunal below
proceeded to determine as to whether the offending tipper
vehicle was responsible or not for the alleged accident on that
day and in para No.12 of the judgment, the Learned Tribunal
below came to the observation that on the alleged day the
accident occurred due to rash and negligent driving by the
driver of vehicle No.TR-01-AE-1621 (Tipper) in deciding issue
No.1. But surprisingly, at the time of delivery of judgment
Learned
Tribunal
fastened
the
liability
of
payment
of
compensation upon both the Insurance Companies, i.e. the
present
appellant
and
respondent
No.6,
Sriram
General
Insurance Company Limited for which Learned Counsel for the
appellant drawn the attention of the Court for interference of
the judgment and award and to modify the judgment to the
extent that the entire compensation would be borne by the
respondent No.6 who was insurer of the offending tipper truck
on the day of accident.
04.
Per contra, Learned Counsel, Mr. K. De representing
the respondent No.6, Sriram General Insurance Company
Limited submitted that from the judgment it transpires that the
accident occurred due to head and collision between both the
vehicles,
for
which,
Learned
Tribunal
below
rightly
and
reasonably delivered the judgment fixing liability of payment of
compensation upon both the Insurance Companies.
At the time of hearing of argument Learned Counsel
for the respondent-claimants submitted that the referring
claimants have nothing to say on the award of the Learned
Tribunal below and urged before the Court to pass appropriate
order considering the materials on record.
05.
I have heard arguments of both the sides and gone
through the judgment of the Learned Tribunal below. For the
sake of convenience, I would like to refer herein below the
relevant portion of the judgment and award of the Learned
Tribunal below as mentioned in para No.16 and 17 which are
as follows:
“16. In the result, it is hereby ordered
that the claimant petitioners are entitled
to get compensation of ₹12,09,600/- +
₹15,000/- + ₹40,000/- + ₹15,000/- =
₹12,79,600/(Rupees
twelve
lacs
seventy nine thousand six hundred) only.
The OP No.4 i.e. New Indian Assurance
Company Ltd., the insurer of the
motorbike bearing registration No. TR-
03H-5725 and the OP No.5 i.e. Sriram
General Insurance Co. Ltd., the insurer of
the
offending
vehicle
bearing
Registration No. TR-01AE-1621 (Tipper)
are directed to make the payment of
compensation
to
the
claimantpetitioners jointly and in equal manner
within 30 (thirty) days from today along
with interest thereon @ 6% per annum
from the date of fling of claim petition,
i.e.,
from
25.02.2022
till
payment/realization of the same.
17. Out of the said amount the claimantpetitioner No.1 & 2 be paid ₹3,00,000/each and the rest amount of ₹6,79,600/in equal manner should be kept in fxed
deposit in their respective accounts in
any Nationalized Bank for the period of
5(fve) years. In the case in which
investment in long term in the nature of
fxed deposit is made on condition that
the Bank will not permit any loan or
advance on the Fixed Deposit and
interest on the amount invested is paid
monthly directly to the claimants or their
legal heir(s), as the case may be. Further
the claimant-petitioners are also granted
liberty to apply for withdrawal in case of
an emergency. To facilitate the payment
of amount of the claimant-petitioners
and the fxed deposit amount on
maturity, the claimantpetitioners at the
appropriate time shall fle photo copy of
their Bank Pass Book in their names
containing photograph, account number,
IFSC number and the RTGS number duly
certifed by the Banker and a copy of
Passport
Size
photographs
before
making payment so as to enable this
Tribunal to transfer the amounts directly
to their Bank Account.”
From the aforesaid paras, it appears that in para
No.16 the Learned Tribunal below has fastened the liability of
payment of compensation amounting to Rs.12,79,600/- in
equal share upon both the Insurance Companies with 6%
interest from the date of filing the claim-petition till realization.
06.
Learned Counsel for the Sriram General Insurance
Company Limited in course of hearing of argument only drawn
the attention of the Court that there was head on collision
between both the offending tipper truck and the motor bike for
which the Learned Tribunal below rightly fastened the liability
of
payment
of
compensation
upon
both
the
Insurance
Companies. But on perusal of the claim-petition, evidence on
record, specifically the examination-in-chief in affidavit of one
of the claimants and also after going through the observation
of Learned Tribunal below in para No.12 in deciding issue No.1
and also after going through the charge sheet laid by the I.O.
which was relied upon by the claimant petitioner, it appears
that in all the places the entire allegation was levelled against
the driver of the offending tipper truck but Learned Tribunal
below in the concluding part of the judgment without any basis
came
to
the
observation
that
both
the
vehicles
were
responsible for the alleged accident. It was the admitted
position that the deceased rider of the bike was also the owner
of the bike and the same was duly insured at the time of
accident with the appellant. But before the Learned Tribunal
below, there was no such evidence on record that the motor
bike was also responsible for the alleged accident on the
alleged day and since the claimant-petitioner and the charge
sheet of I.O. specifically supported the story of the claimantpetitioner that the accident occurred due to rash and negligent
driving of the driver of tipper truck, so, it was surprising as to
how the Learned Tribunal below came to the observation that
both the vehicles were responsible for the accident.
07.
Furthermore, before the Learned Tribunal below in
the written statement, there were no assertions by the
respondent No.6 i.e. the Sriram General Insurance Company
Limited that the accident occurred due to rash and negligent
driving of the driver and rider of both the vehicles. Even no
such evidence was adduced on behalf of the said Insurance
Company and also by the other contesting parties. Thus, after
going through the judgment of the Learned Tribunal below and
also after going through the record of the Learned Tribunal
below, it appears that Learned Tribunal below at the time of
delivery of judgment through misconception of fact fastened
the liability of payment of compensation upon both the
Insurance Companies for which the interference of the Court is
required and in the opinion of this Court, since there was clear
evidence on record regarding the rash and negligent driving by
the driver of the offending tipper truck which caused the
accident on the alleged day. So, the entire amount of
compensation as determined by the Learned Tribunal below
shall be borne by the respondent No.6 i.e. the Sriram General
Insurance Company Limited.
08.
In the result, the appeal filed by the appellant is
partly allowed with the modification that the entire amount of
compensation amounting to Rs.12,79,600/- shall be borne by
the
respondent
No.6
i.e.
the
Sriram
General
Insurance
Company Limited and the appellant Insurance Company is thus
exonerated from the liability of 50% amount of award to the
claimants as per judgment. The entire award as ordered by the
Tribunal shall be borne by the respondent No.6, Sriram General
Insurance Company of this appeal and the Insurance Company
is asked to deposit the said amount to the Learned Tribunal
below within a period o six (06) weeks from the date of
delivery of the judgment.
09.
A copy of this judgment be given free of cost to
Learned Counsel for the appellant and also to the Learned
Counsel for the respondent No.6, i.e. Sriram General Insurance
Company Limited for information and compliance.
Send down the LCR along with a copy of the
judgment.
Pending application(s), if any, also stands disposed
of.
JUDGE
MOUMITA
DATTA
Purnita
MOUMITA DATTA
Date: 2024.09.06 15:39:14
+05'30'
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review