Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
ANURADHA
TIWARI
2026:CGHC:3487-DB
Digitally
signed by
ANURADHA
TIWARI
Date:
2026.01.22
13:23:52
+0530
NAFR
HIGH COURT OF CHHATTISGARH AT BILASPUR
WA No. 47 of 2026
Netram Kashyap S/o Pran Nath Aged About 42 Years R/o Ward No. 12,
Chorbhatti, Tahsil Pamgarh, District Janjgir-Champa Chhattisgarh
... Appellant
versus
1 - State of Chhattisgarh Through Its Secretary, Department of
Panchayat And Rural Development, Mahanadi Bhawan, Mantralaya,
Atal Nagar, Nava Raipur, District - Raipur Chhattisgarh
2 - The Collector District Janjgir-Champa Chhattisgarh
3 - Sub-Divisional Officer (R) Pamgarh, District Janjgir-Champa
Chhattisgarh
4 - Janki Prasad Kashyap S/o Keshav Prasad Aged About 70 Years R/o
Ward No. 12, Chorbhatti, Tahsil Pamgarh, District Janjgir-Champa
Chhattisgarh
5 - Lakshmi Prasad S/o Rajaram Aged About 40 Years R/o Ward No.
10, Chorbhatti, Tahsil Pamgarh, District Janjgir-Champa Chhattisgarh
6 - Naresh Kashyap S/o Baldev Prasad Aged About 35 Years R/o Ward
No.
18,
Chorbhatti,
Tahsil
Pamgarh,
District
Janjgir-Champa
Chhattisgarh
7 - Puniram Kashyap S/o Chaitram Aged About 40 Years R/o Ward No.
11, Chorbhatti, Tahsil Pamgarh, District Janjgir-Champa Chhattisgarh
8 - Sanat Patel S/o Ramfal Patel Aged About 40 Years R/o Ward No. 17,
Chorbhatti, Tahsil Pamgarh, District Janjgir-Champa Chhattisgarh
9 - Presiding Officer Raghuraj Singh Chandel R/o Village Taraud, Tahsil
Akaltara, District Janjgir-Champa Chhattisgarh
10 - Returning Officer, Shri Mahendra Lahre Tahsildar, Pamgarh, District
Janjgir-Champa Chhattisgarh
... Respondents
(Cause-title taken from Case Information System)
For Appellant
: Mr. Prafull N. Bharat, learned Senior Advocate
assisted by Mr. Shivang Dubey, Advocate
For Respondent-State : Mr. Prasun Kumar Bhaduri, Deputy Advocate
General
For Respondent No.4 : Mr. Chandresh Shrivastava, Advocate
Hon'ble Shri Ramesh Sinha, Chief Justice
Hon'ble Shri Ravindra Kumar Agrawal, Judge
Judgment on Board
Per Ramesh Sinha, Chief Justice
21.01.2026
1.
Heard Mr. Prafull N. Bharat, learned Senior Counsel assisted by
Mr. Shivang Dubey, learned counsel for the appellant as well as
Mr. Prasun Kumar Bhaduri, learned Deputy Advocate General,
appearing for the State and Mr. Chandresh Shrivastava, learned
counsel appearing for respondent No.4.
2.
By way of this writ appeal, appellant has prayed for following
relief(s):“The humble Appellant most respectfully prays
that this Hon'ble Court may kindly be pleased to
issue appropriate writ(s), order(s), direction(s):
To set-aside directions passed in the impugned
order dated 08.12.2025 directing "Matter is
remitted back to respondent No.3/Prescribed
Authority -cum- Sub Divisional Officer to pass
order afresh following due process of law,
providing opportunity of hearing to other nonapplicants also to lead evidence if they so desire
and
opportunity
Proceedings
of
of
hearing
election
to
petition
all
parties.
may
be
concluded following due process of law within a
further period of 3 months from the date of
appearance of the parties before it.”
3.
The present intra Court appeal has been filed against the order
dated 08.12.2025 passed by the learned Single Judge in WPC
No.2698/2025 (Netram Kashyap v. State of Chhattisgarh and
others), whereby the writ petition filed by the appellant/writ
petitioner has been allowed.
4.
Brief facts projected before the learned Single Judge are that the
appellant/writ petitioner, along with respondent Nos. 4 to 8,
contested the election for the post of Sarpanch of Gram
Panchayat Chorbhatti, Tahsil Pamgarh, District Janjgir-Champa,
Chhattisgarh. Polling for the said election was held on
23.02.2025, and the counting of votes was also conducted on the
same date. Upon conclusion of the counting process, as per the
declaration made by the Election Authority, the appellant/writ
petitioner secured 489 votes, whereas respondent No. 4 (election
petitioner) secured 451 votes. Consequently, the appellant/writ
petitioner was declared as the returned candidate and a certificate
of election was issued in his favour on 25.02.2025.
5.
Thereafter, respondent No. 4 filed an election petition under
Section 122 of the Chhattisgarh Panchayat Raj Adhiniyam, 1993,
alleging that the votes secured by the appellant/writ petitioner and
respondent No. 6 were interchanged, resulting in an erroneous
declaration of the appellant/writ petitioner as having secured the
highest number of votes. In the election petition, a prayer was
made for recounting of votes of Booth No. 79, for declaring the
election of the appellant/writ petitioner (non-applicant No. 1
therein) as illegal and void, for cancellation of his election, and for
declaring the election petitioner as the duly elected candidate.
The appellant/writ petitioner filed his reply to the election petition,
denying the allegations made therein. Respondent Nos. 5, 6, 8
and 9 also submitted their respective replies.
6.
The Election Tribunal, by an order, directed recounting of votes.
The said order was assailed by the appellant/writ petitioner by
filing WPC No. 1975 of 2025, contending that the order for
recounting had been passed without adhering to the mandatory
procedure prescribed under Rule 11 of the Chhattisgarh
Panchayats
(Election
Petitions,
Corrupt
Practices
and
Disqualification for Membership) Rules, 1995 (hereinafter referred
to as “the Rules of 1995”). The writ petition was allowed, the order
dated 16.04.2025 was quashed, and the matter was remitted back
to the Election Tribunal to decide the election petition afresh in
accordance with law.
7.
After receipt of the matter on remand, the Election Tribunal
framed the issues, fixed the case for recording of evidence of the
parties, and thereafter passed the impugned order, which was the
subject matter of challenge before the learned Single Judge by
filing WPC No.2698/2025, which was allowed by the learned
Single Judge vide order dated 08.12.2025.
8.
Feeling aggrieved by the order dated 08.12.2025 passed in WPC
No.2698/2025, the present appeal has been filed by the
appellant/writ petitioner.
9.
Learned Senior Counsel for the appellant/writ petitioner submits
that the impugned order passed by the learned Single Judge is
unsustainable both on facts and in law. It is contended that an
order of remand cannot be made casually or mechanically,
particularly when such remand has the effect of enabling the
contesting party to fill up lacunae left in its case before the learned
Election Tribunal. In the present matter, the appellant had raised a
specific objection in the rejoinder that remanding the case would
allow respondent No. 4 to improve and supplement his election
petition, yet the learned Single Judge failed to consider the said
objection. It is further submitted that there was no pleading
whatsoever, either in the writ petition or in the replies filed by the
respondents, alleging that the Election Tribunal had failed to
record evidence or had denied proper opportunity of hearing to
any of the parties. Despite this, the learned Single Judge
proceeded to develop an entirely new case by holding that parties
should be afforded further opportunity to lead evidence, which
was never the case of any of the litigating parties. Such an
approach, it is urged, amounts to an error apparent on the face of
the record, as the Court cannot travel beyond the pleadings and
build a case for the parties.
10.
Learned Senior Counsel further submits that respondent No.
3/Prescribed Authority-cum-Sub Divisional Officer, in its reply
before the Court, has categorically stated that no illegality was
committed while passing the impugned order. The reply clearly
demonstrates that, pursuant to the earlier remand in WPC
No.1975/2025, the Election Tribunal framed issues, fixed the
matter for evidence, recorded examination-in-chief and crossexamination of witnesses of both sides on multiple dates, and
thereafter fixed the case for final arguments. The order sheets
and proceedings unmistakably show that ample and sufficient
opportunity to lead evidence and to be heard was afforded to all
parties, and written submissions were also filed in addition to oral
arguments. It is submitted that, in fact, the Election Tribunal
conducted a full-fledged trial on two separate occasions before
passing the impugned order dated 26.05.2025. Despite such
exhaustive proceedings, the learned Single Judge failed to
consider that the Tribunal had already granted complete
opportunity to the parties and yet had not adhered to the
mandatory
procedure
prescribed
under
Rule
of
the
Chhattisgarh Panchayats (Election Petitions, Corrupt Practices
and Disqualification for Membership) Rules, 1995.
11.
Learned Senior Counsel submits that the respondents/nonapplicants had denied the contents of Form 17 relied upon by
respondent No. 4, and even the Presiding Officer (respondent No.
9) had appeared before the Election Tribunal and specifically
denied the correctness of the counting slip alleged by respondent
No. 4. Further, in the writ proceedings, the Office of the Advocate
General had accepted notice on behalf of respondent Nos. 9 and
10, yet they consciously chose not to file any reply. Having
forfeited their right to contest, it was wholly erroneous on the part
of the learned Single Judge to grant them yet another opportunity
to lead evidence upon remand. It is also submitted that a serious
jurisdictional issue regarding the maintainability of the election
petition was specifically raised by the appellant. Without
adjudicating this preliminary issue, the matter could not have been
remanded. The Election Tribunal, instead of deciding the issue of
maintainability, repeatedly directed recounting of votes, first by
order dated 16.04.2025 and again by order dated 26.05.2025,
despite the earlier order having been set aside by this Court. This
conduct, according to learned Senior Counsel, clearly reflects a
pre-determined and biased approach against the appellant.
12.
Learned Senior Counsel further submits that the learned Single
Judge erred in permitting adducing of additional evidence upon
remand, which would result in a fresh trial and allow the
respondents to set up an entirely new case, contrary to settled
principles of election law. It is pointed out that respondent No. 4
never sought recounting before the Presiding Officer at the time of
counting of votes, nor raised any objection during the counting
process, and failed to produce any contemporaneous or certified
documentary evidence in support of his allegations. It is also
contended that there is a clear non-compliance of Section 80 of
the Chhattisgarh Panchayat Nirvachan Niyam, 1995. Rule 80(5)
categorically bars any application for recounting after declaration
of results. In the present case, the election result was declared on
23.02.2025, whereas the application for recounting was filed on
27.03.2025, i.e., after 32 days, rendering the prayer for recounting
legally impermissible.
13.
Learned Senior Counsel submits that the impugned order of the
Election Tribunal is a non-speaking order passed in haste, without
proper application of mind, and is detrimental to the democratic
mandate. The right to seek recounting is not an inherent right and
cannot be exercised casually. Recounting, if at all permissible,
can only be incidental to the final relief contemplated under Rule 6
of the Rules of 1995 at the conclusion of trial. The relief sought by
respondent No. 4 does not fall within the ambit of Rule 6, thereby
rendering the election petition itself not maintainable and raising a
serious jurisdictional bar. It is submitted that once maintainability
becomes a jurisdictional issue, the Court is duty-bound to decide
it at the threshold, as held by the Supreme Court in B.Y.
Narasimha Prasad v. M. Veerappa (2008) 9 SCC 372 and
Magadh Sugar & Energy Ltd. v. State of Bihar (2021 SCC
OnLine SC 801). Reliance is also placed on Nadakeruppa (Dead)
by LRs v. Pillamma (Dead) by LRs, wherein the Supreme Court
has categorically held that an order of remand cannot be passed
as a matter of course, particularly when parties have already led
oral and documentary evidence, and that the appellate court must
endeavor to decide the matter on merits. On these grounds,
learned Senior Counsel submits that the impugned order of
remand passed by the learned Single Judge is legally
unsustainable and liable to be set aside.
14.
On the other hand, learned State counsel opposes the
submissions advanced on behalf of the appellant/writ petitioner
and submits that the learned Single Judge has consciously
safeguarded the interest of the appellant/writ petitioner while
passing the impugned order. It is contended that the learned
Single Judge has taken due care of the objections raised by the
appellant and has specifically dealt with the same in paragraphs 9
to 11 of the impugned order.
15.
Learned State counsel would further submit that the direction of
remand has not been issued in a casual or mechanical manner,
but only to ensure strict compliance with the mandatory procedure
prescribed under Rule 11 of the Chhattisgarh Panchayats
(Election Petitions, Corrupt Practices and Disqualification for
Membership) Rules, 1995. According to learned State counsel,
the remand was ordered only with a view to cure the procedural
irregularities and to ensure that the Election Tribunal adjudicates
the election dispute in accordance with law, and not to permit any
party to fill up lacunae in its case. It is further submitted that the
learned Single Judge has neither expressed any opinion on the
merits of the controversy nor prejudged the rights of the parties.
The impugned order, it is urged, merely restores the matter to the
Election Tribunal with appropriate safeguards so that the
proceedings are conducted afresh in conformity with the statutory
mandate, after granting opportunity to all concerned, thereby
upholding the principles of natural justice.
16.
Learned State counsel, therefore, submits that no case for
interference in writ appeal is made out and that the appeal
deserves to be dismissed.
17.
Learned counsel for respondent No. 4 submits that respondent
No. 4 has also preferred an independent writ appeal assailing the
same impugned order passed by the learned Single Judge.
18.
We have heard learned counsel for the parties at length and have
carefully considered the rival submissions advanced on their
behalf as also the impugned order.
19.
After appreciating the submissions of learned counsel for the
parties as also the materials on record, the learned Single Judge,
while relying upon the decisions rendered by the Hon’ble
Supreme Court in Arikala Narasa Reddy v. Venkata Ram
Reddy Reddygari and another, (2014) 5 SCC 312 and
Secretary and Curator, Victoria Memorial Hall v. Howrah
Ganatantrik Nagrik Samity and others, (2010) 3 SCC 732, has
passed the impugned order in following terms:“11. Perusal of the order sheet would show that
on 08.05.2025, election petitioner had made
statement that he do not want to give further
evidence. Order sheet dated 13.05.2025 would
show that non-applicant No.1 submitted affidavit
under Order 18 Rule 4 CPC as examination-inchief of non-applicant No.1/election petitioner.
Returned
candidate
Omprakash
and
Netram
Ramnarayan
Kashyap,
were
cross-
examined on 16.05.2025 and have closed
evidence. Election Tribunal thereafter had fixed
the case for argument.
12. Though in election petition there is specific
pleading that in the ‘counting slip’, Presiding
Officer of Booth No.79 while preparing counting
slip has recorded that returned candidate secured
85 votes, Naresh/non-applicant No.3 secured 157
votes and in the election results, number of votes
have been erroneously mentioned by Presiding
Officer, the Election Tribunal has not fixed the
case for recording of evidence of other nonapplicants. No notice has been issued to nonapplicants No.6 and 7 against whom allegations
were made, overlooking the fact that non-
applicant No.6 has submitted his reply.
13. True it is that order to be passed by Election
Tribunal/Authority should contain reasons by
discussing the evidence which is not appearing in
this case. Hon’ble Supreme Court in case of
Arikala Narasa Reddy Vs. Venkata Ram Reddy
Reddygari and Anr. (2014) 5 SCC 312 ,has
observed thus:
“14. Before the court permits the recounting,
the following conditions must be satisfied:
(i) The court must be satisfied that a prima facie
case is established;
(ii) The material facts and full particulars have
been pleaded stating the irregularities in
counting of votes;
(iii) A roving and fishing inquiry should not be
directed by way of an order to re-count the
votes;
(iv) An opportunity should be given to file
objection; and (v) Secrecy of the ballot should
be guarded.”
14. In case of Secretary and Curator, Victoria
Memorial Hall Vs. Howrah Ganatantrik Nagrik
Samity and Ors. (2010) 3 SCC 732, Hon’ble
Supreme Court has observed thus:
“40. It is a settled legal proposition that not only
administrative but also judicial order must be
supported by reasons, recorded in it. Thus,
while deciding an issue, the Court is bound to
give reasons for its conclusion. It is the duty
and obligation on the part of the Court to record
reasons while disposing of the case. The
hallmark of an order and exercise of judicial
power by a judicial forum is to disclose its
reasons by itself and giving of reasons has
always been insisted upon as one of the
fundamentals of sound administration justice delivery system, to make known that there had
been proper and due application of mind to the
issue before the Court and also as an essential
requisite of principles of natural justice. "The
giving of reasons for a decision is an essential
attribute of judicial and judicious disposal of a
matter before Courts, and which is the only
indication to know about the manner and
quality of exercise undertaken, as also the fact
that the Court concerned had really applied its
mind." [Vide State of Orissa Vs. Dhaniram
Luhar and State of Rajasthan Vs. Sohan Lal &
Ors.]
41.
Reason
is
the
heartbeat
of
every
conclusion. It introduces clarity in an order and
without the same, it becomes lifeless. Reasons
substitute subjectivity by objectivity. Absence of
reasons
renders
indefensible/unsustainable
the
order
particularly
when
the order is subject to further challenge before
a higher forum. [Vide Raj Kishore Jha Vs. State
of Bihar & Ors. AIR 2003 SC 4664; Vishnu Dev
Sharma Vs. State of Uttar Pradesh & Ors.
(2008) 3 SCC 172; Steel Authority of India Ltd.
Vs. Sales Tax Officer, Rourkela I Circle & Ors.
(2008) 9 SCC 407; State of Uttaranchal & Anr.
Vs. Sunil Kumar Singh Negi AIR 2008 SC
2026; U.P.S.R.T.C. Vs. Jagdish Prasad Gupta
AIR 2009 SC 2328; Ram Phal Vs. State of
Haryana & Ors. (2009) 3 SCC 258; Mohammed
Yusuf Vs. Faij Mohammad & Ors. (2009) 3
SCC 513; and State of Himachal Pradesh Vs.
Sada Ram & Anr. (2009) 4 SCC 422].
42. Thus, it is evident that the recording of
reasons is principle of natural justice and every
judicial order must be supported by reasons
recorded in writing. It ensures transparency and
fairness in decision making. The person who is
adversely affected may know, as why his
application has been rejected.”
15. In view of the aforementioned decisions of
Hon’ble Supreme Court, it is apparent that before
passing of order of re-counting of votes, Election
Tribunal should be satisfied that prima facie case
is made out and all material facts and particulars
have been pleaded stating irregularities
in
counting of votes by providing opportunity to all
parties to lead evidence and further that order to
be passed must be supported by reason.
16. From perusal of the order sheets, it is clearly
appearing that case was not fixed for recording of
evidence of other non-applicants who submitted
reply to election petition and further from
impugned order, it is not reflecting that Election
Tribunal has discussed the evidence and has
assigned cogent reason for directing re-counting
of votes.
17. Perusal of the pleadings made in the election
petition would show that election petitioner in
election petition has pleaded material facts,
provided full particulars in support of the case,
further, have examined witnesses supporting the
pleadings and therefore election petitioner cannot
be put at fault when he pleaded material facts and
provided full particulars on which his case is
based, but the Prescribed Authority failed to
record satisfaction and have not followed due
procedure for fixing of case for recording of
evidence of witness/witnesses of other nonapplicants.
18. In the aforementioned facts of case and
discussions made as also decisions of Hon’ble
Supreme Court, I am of the view that order dated
26.05.2025 Annexure P-1 passed by Prescribed
Authority/Election Tribunal directing re-counting of
votes is not sustainable in the eye of law and it is
accordingly set aside. Matter is remitted back to
respondent No.3/Prescribed Authority -cum- Sub
Divisional Officer to pass order afresh following
due process of law, providing opportunity of
hearing to other non-applicants also to lead
evidence if they so desire and opportunity of
hearing to all parties. Proceedings of election
petition may be concluded following due process
of law within a further period of 3 months from the
date of appearance of the parties before it.
Parties are directed to appear before the Election
Tribunal on 23rd December 2025.
19. Writ petition is accordingly allowed to the
extent and in the manner indicated above.
20. Original Record of election petition which is
placed before this Court for perusal by learned
counsel for the State be returned back.”
20.
From a conjoint reading of paragraphs 11 to 18 of the impugned
order, it is manifest that the learned Single Judge has recorded
clear findings to the effect that, although some evidence had been
recorded, the Election Tribunal failed to extend opportunity to all
necessary parties, particularly other non-applicants against whom
allegations were specifically made in the election petition.
21.
The learned Single Judge has also noticed that the impugned
order of the Election Tribunal directing recounting of votes does
not disclose proper reasons nor demonstrates the recording of
requisite satisfaction before ordering recounting, which is a
mandatory requirement under the law governing election disputes.
22.
The principles enunciated by the Hon’ble Supreme Court in
Arikala Narasa Reddy (supra) and Secretary and Curator,
Victoria Memorial Hall (supra) have been correctly appreciated
and applied by the learned Single Judge. The impugned order
clearly reflects that the remand has been ordered to ensure
compliance with the mandatory procedure, to safeguard the
principles of natural justice, and to ensure that any eventual
decision of the Election Tribunal is reasoned, legally sustainable,
and capable of withstanding judicial scrutiny.
23.
We are unable to accept the contention advanced on behalf of the
appellant that the remand would permit respondent No. 4 to fill up
lacunae in his case. The directions contained in the impugned
order neither permit improvement of pleadings nor grant liberty to
travel beyond the scope of the election petition. On the contrary,
the remand has been ordered only to ensure that all parties who
are already on record and against whom allegations have been
levelled are afforded an opportunity of hearing and that the
Election Tribunal records its satisfaction in accordance with law
before passing any order having serious civil consequences, such
as recounting of votes.
24.
The submission regarding jurisdictional issues and maintainability
of the election petition has also been adequately taken care of by
the learned Single Judge by setting aside the order of recounting
itself and remitting the matter for fresh consideration in
accordance with law. All contentions raised by the appellant,
including maintainability and jurisdiction, remain open to be urged
before the Election Tribunal, which is duty bound to adjudicate the
same in accordance with law while deciding the election petition
afresh.
25.
We also find no merit in the argument that the learned Single
Judge has pre-judged the controversy or expressed any opinion
on the merits of the election dispute. The impugned order is
carefully worded and confined strictly to procedural infirmities and
non-compliance of mandatory requirements. The learned Single
Judge has consciously refrained from making any observations
which may prejudice either party before the Election Tribunal.
26.
In an election dispute, the democratic mandate and sanctity of the
electoral process are of paramount importance. Directions
ensuring adherence to statutory procedure, opportunity of hearing
to all concerned, and passing of reasoned orders cannot be
faulted with. The remand in the present case subserves these
very objectives and does not call for interference in intra-court
appellate jurisdiction.
27.
In view of the foregoing discussion, we are of the considered
opinion that the order dated 08.12.2025 passed by the learned
Single Judge does not suffer from any perversity, illegality, or
jurisdictional error warranting interference by this Court. The writ
appeal, being devoid of merit, deserves to be dismissed.
28.
Accordingly, the writ appeal is dismissed. No order as to costs.
29.
The Election Tribunal shall proceed in terms of the directions
issued by the learned Single Judge and conclude the election
petition expeditiously, strictly in accordance with law.
Sd/(Ravindra Kumar Agrawal)
Judge
Anu
Sd/(Ramesh Sinha)
Chief Justice
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review