The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
12. As per Order VIII Rule 9 CPC, it is evident that once the matter is posted for trial, the petitioner, without adducing any evidence, cannot seek amendment of the boundaries of the plaint schedule property, as such, the prayer is contrary to the object of the said provision and lacks merit. Therefore, the Civil Revision Petition is devoid of merits and is liable to be dismissed. In view of the reasons NV,J CRP_3301_2025 stated above, the order passed by the Court below does not warrant any interference of this Court.
13. In the result, civil revision petition is dismissed. No costs.
14. Consequently, miscellaneous applications pending if any, shall stand closed. No costs. Dated: 07.05.2026 NV,J CRP_3301_2025 THE HON’BLE SRI JUSTICE VENKATESWARLU NIMMAGADDA CIVIL REVISION PETITION No.3301 OF 2025 Dated: 07.05.2026 W
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
THE HON’BLE SRI JUSTICE VENKATESWARLU NIMMAGADDA
CIVIL REVISION PETITION No.3301 OF 2025
ORDER:
1.
This civil revision petition under Article 227 of the Constitution
of India is filed challenging the order passed by the Additional Civil
Judge (Senior Division), Ongole in I.A.No.447 of 2024 in O.S.No.66 of
2019 dated 12.08.2025.
2.
The brief facts of the case are that, I.A. No.447 of 2024 was
filed by the petitioner/plaintiff before the Court below under Order VI
Rule 17 C.P.C with a prayer to amend the schedule as per the
consequential amendments memo annexed to the petition i.e. to add
the measurements on all four sides to the boundaries with regard to
the suit schedule property.
3.
It was contended by the petitioner/plaintiff that he filed suit
against the respondent to declare the petitioner as absolute owner of
the suit schedule property and to deliver possession of the same to
him under due process of law. Counsel for the petitioner verified the
schedule and found mistake that the measurements for all four
boundaries were not added/shown, as he filed the suit for declaration
NV,J
CRP_3301_2025
and for delivery of possession with regard to the suit schedule
property and as such, it is necessary to show the measurements on
all four boundaries with regard to the suit schedule property. To show
the measurements, on all four sides, the amendment of the schedule
is very much necessary. If the schedule is amended by adding the
measurements on all four sides of four boundaries in the schedule, no
prejudice would be caused to the other side as well as pleadings in
the plaint would not be altered.
4.
Before the Trial Court, the respondent/defendant filed counter
affidavit denying all averments made in the petition. It was contended
that the proposed amendments mentioned in the memo of
consequential amendments is vexed and inconsistent with the
existing schedule. If the proposed amendments are allowed, it
creates a lot of confusion not only to the plaintiff himself but also to
the defendant and the Court as well. Therefore, such vexed
amendment cannot be permitted and sought for dismissal of
I.A.No.447 of 2024.
5.
NV,J
CRP_3301_2025
Upon considering submissions of both the counsel, the Trial
Court framed point for determination of issue as to “whether the
petition merits acceptance to amend the schedule as per the
consequential amendments memo annexed to the petition” and held
that there are no merits in the interlocutory application, as such,
dismissed I.A.No.447 of 2024. Aggrieved thereby, the present civil
revision petition is filed.
6.
During hearing, Sri M.R.S. Srinivas, learned counsel for the
petitioner submits that, During the hearing, M.R.S. Srinivas, learned
counsel for the petitioner, contended that the court below failed to
appreciate the object of Order VIII Rule 9 CPC, which permits the
filing of a rejoinder to clarify the averments in the plaint or to respond
to the written statement. He submitted that the petitioner had filed
I.A. No. 447 of 2024 seeking amendment of the suit schedule in terms
of the consequential amendment memo annexed to the petition,
specifically to incorporate measurements on all four sides of the
property in addition to its boundaries. Learned counsel further argued
that the petitioner is entitled to seek such an amendment at any stage
prior to the commencement of trial. In the present case, no trial has
NV,J
CRP_3301_2025
commenced and no evidence has been adduced by the petitioner;
therefore, the application for amendment ought to have been allowed
and granting leave by the court below. He also submits that the
proposed amendment does not alter the nature of the suit or
introduce a new cause of action, but merely clarifies the description of
the suit schedule property. Hence, in the absence of any change in
the scope or nature of the suit, the amendment should have been
permitted. Learned counsel further contended that, in light of the
registered Settlement Deed dated 26.05.2005 executed in favour of
the petitioner, and the omission relating to the registered rectification
deeds dated 06.02.2008 and 16.07.2016, the filing of a rejoinder falls
squarely within the ambit of Order VIII Rule 9 CPC. He argued that
the petitioner has the right to seek amendment of the schedule
property under Order VI Rule 17 CPC, and such a request cannot be
denied. However, the Court below, without assigning proper reasons,
dismissed the application on the ground that the suit was filed in 2019
and that the interlocutory application was intended to delay the
proceedings. Learned counsel submits that such a finding is
erroneous, arbitrary, and unsustainable in law, and is therefore liable
to be set aside.
7.
NV,J
CRP_3301_2025
Sri S. Siva Rama Krishna Prasad, learned counsel for the
respondent, filed a counter affidavit denying the averments made in
the petition. He contended that a perusal of the affidavit and the
documents filed in support of the petition, including the rectification
deeds allegedly omitted from the plaint description, shows that the
issue of amendment does not arise. In the absence of any denial with
regard to southern boundary or allegation of encroachment by the
defendant upon the petitioner’s property, the boundaries and its
measurements to the schedule property are of no relevance. He
submits that, it is not the case of the petitioner that the respondent is
not the owner of the land forming the southern boundary of the plaint
schedule property. As there is no allegation of encroachment or
overlapping, the mere mention of the respondent is the southern
boundary holder does not require any amendment, even if
rectification deeds were omitted. He further submitted that the Trial
Court rightly addressed the petitioner’s claim, noting that although the
suit was filed in 2019, the petitioner failed to adduce any evidence
despite the matter being posted for trial long back. Instead, the
petitioner filed multiple applications one after the other, only to
protract the litigation to amend the boundaries of the plaint schedule
NV,J
CRP_3301_2025
property. Therefore, even under Order VI Rule 17 CPC and Order VIII
Rule 9 CPC, filing the present petition after a lapse of six years, when
the matter is already set for trial, is contrary to the object of these
provisions and appears to be an attempt to prolong the proceedings
without adducing evidence as the plaintiff in the suit.
8.
Heard Sri M.R.S. Srinivas, learned counsel for the petitioner,
Sri S. Siva Rama Krishna Prasad, learned counsel for the respondent
and perused the material available on record.
9.
I.A. No. 447 of 2024 has been filed under Order VI Rule 17
CPC read with Section 151 CPC seeking amendment of the plaint
schedule property in terms of the consequential amendments set out
in the memo annexed to the petition. However, such amendment
does not appear to be necessary, as there is no claim against the
respondent, nor is there any allegation that the respondent has
encroached upon or occupied any portion of the suit schedule
property. In the absence of any such allegation or claim of title by the
respondent, the property as originally described in the plaint remains
unaffected and intact.
10.
NV,J
CRP_3301_2025
It is well-settled law that amendment of the plaint schedule,
including its boundaries, lies within the discretion of the Court. The
Court below, upon due consideration of the facts, circumstances, and
pleadings of the petitioner, has rightly held as follows:
“As per the plaint schedule, the property of the defendant is
shown on the Southern side and in the plaint averments
also it is claimed that the defendant has got property to the
South of the suit property. It is never the specific case of the
plaintiff in the plaint or in the petition that the plaint schedule
is the property encroached by the defendant. Further, a
perusal of the plaint schedule makes it clear that, as per the
schedule the defendant has got property to the Southern
side of the said property. Further, the plaint schedule is not
matching with any of the items in the schedule in the suit
document i.e. Settlement Deed dated 26.05.2005. When
there are no such details mentioned either in the plaint or in
the suit document, in view of the humble opinion of this
Court, the plaintiff cannot be permitted show such specific
measurements in the plaint schedule now by way of
amendments and it is for the plaintiff to show the specific
reasons along with the documents showing the mentioning
of such specific measurements for him to mention and claim
such measurements. The reasons mentioned in the petition
are not sufficient to permit him to amend the plaint. Merely
because the suit is filed for declaration and delivery of
NV,J
CRP_3301_2025
possession of suit schedule property, the plaintiff cannot be
permitted to amend the plaint schedule to mention the
measurements as per will and wish as no proper reasons
have been mentioned and no document relevant to that
effect is produced.”
11.
On perusal of the reasons assigned and the explanation
furnished by the Court below, it appears that there is no necessity to
amend the boundaries of the plaint schedule property. The contention
of the learned counsel for the respondent that, despite the matter
being posted for trial after a lapse of six years from the date of
institution of the suit, and without adducing any evidence, the
petitioner has been filing applications one after another to protract the
proceedings and delay the trial, appears to be valid and reasonable in
light of the facts and circumstances as set out above.
12.
As per Order VIII Rule 9 CPC, it is evident that once the matter
is posted for trial, the petitioner, without adducing any evidence,
cannot seek amendment of the boundaries of the plaint schedule
property, as such, the prayer is contrary to the object of the said
provision and lacks merit. Therefore, the Civil Revision Petition is
devoid of merits and is liable to be dismissed. In view of the reasons
NV,J
CRP_3301_2025
stated above, the order passed by the Court below does not warrant
any interference of this Court.
13.
In the result, civil revision petition is dismissed. No costs.
14.
Consequently, miscellaneous applications pending if any, shall
stand closed. No costs.
______________________________________
JUSTICE VENKATESWARLU NIMMAGADDA
Dated: 07.05.2026
SP
NV,J
CRP_3301_2025
THE HON’BLE SRI JUSTICE VENKATESWARLU NIMMAGADDA
CIVIL REVISION PETITION No.3301 OF 2025
Dated: 07.05.2026
W
SP
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review