The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
19. NV,J CRP_3311_2025 It is well settled that when new pleadings are raised in a written statement, the petitioner acquires the right to file a rejoinder. Such a rejoinder does not alter the original pleadings set out in the plaint, nor does it change the nature of the suit; it simply explains or clarifies the new facts introduced by the defendant. In light of this settled legal position, the order passed by the learned Trial Court is liable to be set aside.
20. In the result, civil revision petition is allowed, and the order passed by the Additional Civil Judge (Senior Division), Ongole in I.A.No.326 of 2025 in O.S.No.66 of 2019 dated 24.10.2025 is hereby set-aside.
21. Consequently, miscellaneous applications pending if any, shall stand closed. No costs. Dated: 07.05.2026 NV,J CRP_3311_2025 THE HON’BLE SRI JUSTICE VENKATESWARLU NIMMAGADDA CIVIL REVISION PETITION No.3311 OF 2025 Dated: 07.05.2026 W
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
THE HON’BLE SRI JUSTICE VENKATESWARLU NIMMAGADDA
CIVIL REVISION PETITION No.3311 OF 2025
ORDER:
1.
This civil revision petition under Article 227 of the Constitution
of India is filed challenging the order passed by the Additional Civil
Judge (Senior Division), Ongole in I.A.No.326 of 2025 in O.S.No.66 of
2019 dated 24.10.2025.
2.
The brief facts of the case are that, I.A. No.326 of 2025 was
filed by the petitioner/plaintiff before the Court below under Order VIII
Rule 9 C.P.C, 1908 with a prayer to receive the rejoinder along with
plan annexed to the petition to disclose the suit schedule property
and its annexed properties.
3.
Upon considering submissions of both the counsel, the Trial
Court framed a point for determination of an issue as to “whether the
petition is merit acceptance to receive the Rejoinder along with the
Plan to disclose the suit schedule property and its annexed
properties” and held that there are no merits in the interlocutory
application, as such, dismissed I.A.No.326 of 2025. Aggrieved
thereby, the present civil revision petition is filed.
4.
NV,J
CRP_3311_2025
During the course of hearing, Sri M.R.S. Srinivas, learned
counsel for the petitioner, submitted that the filing of the plan and
rejoinder is solely for the effective adjudication of the suit. He also
contended that receiving the plan and rejoinder would not cause any
prejudice to the respondent, particularly as the trial in the suit has not
yet commenced, and that such documents would aid in providing
greater clarity for proper disposal of the matter. It is further submitted
that filing of the rejoinder and plan has become necessary in light of
the pleadings set out in the written statement filed by the defendant. It
is argued that a rejoinder is warranted where the defendant
introduces new material facts requiring clarification and rebuttal by
the plaintiff. It is a well-settled principle of law that a rejoinder must
not introduce a completely new cause of action or alter the original
claim. In the present case, the rejoinder and the plan filed by the
petitioner are intended only to provide further clarification to assist the
Court in effectively resolving the disputes between the parties. In
support of his contention, learned counsel for the petitioner placed
reliance on the judgment of this Hon’ble Court in Pulivarthi Venkata
Seshagiri Rao vs. Babburi Venkata Swamy1 and on the strength of
2020 (6) ALD 242 (AP)
NV,J
CRP_3311_2025
the principle laid down in the above judgment, learned counsel would
contend that allowing of rejoinder would not in any way prejudice the
case of respondents as tenability or otherwise of statements set out in
rejoinder would be considered in suit. Learned counsel also submits
that such a finding is erroneous, arbitrary, and unsustainable in law,
and is therefore liable to be set aside.
5.
Sri S. Siva Rama Krishna Prasad, learned counsel for the
respondent, filed a counter-affidavit denying the averments made in
the petition. He contended that neither the plaint schedule nor the
rejoinder schedule boundaries filed by the plaintiff indicates northern
boundary of the defendant’s property as a 20-feet road. He further
argued that the plan filed by the plaintiff, as well as the defendant’s
document of the year 2000 and the link document of the year 1988,
clearly depict a 20-feet road on the southern side of the defendant’s
property. In such circumstances, the plaintiff has no right to contends,
based on the very same documents, that no road exists on the
northern side of the defendant’s property, and has deliberately
omitted the said road adjacent to the defendant’s property. Therefore,
the petitioner is not entitled to seek any relief from this Court for
receiving a rejoinder and plan under Order VIII Rule 9 CPC. Moreover,
NV,J
CRP_3311_2025
it is submitted that neither the plaintiff nor his settlor was ever in
possession of the plaint schedule property at any point in time, as
evidenced
by
the
documents
filed
by
the
plaintiff
himself.
Consequently, the additional documents in the form of a rejoinder and
plan cannot be used to the advantage of the petitioner.
6.
Learned counsel for the respondent further submitted that
several documents filed by the petitioner clearly establish the
existence of a road for the past 45 years. It is stated that the vendor
of the defendant, as well as the vendor of the owner of the eastern
boundary schedule property, acquired their respective properties in
the year 1981. Even at that time, the schedule properties were
described as open plots, and a 20-feet road was shown on the
northern side of the defendant’s property. However, in the present
rejoinder and accompanying plan filed by the petitioner, the northern
boundary of the suit schedule property is not shown as a 20-feet road.
It is therefore contended that the petitioner did not approach the Court
with clean hands, hence plaintiff is not entitled to any relief.
Additionally, it is reiterated that neither the plaintiff nor his settlor was
ever in possession of the plaint schedule property, as evident from
NV,J
CRP_3311_2025
the petitioner’s own documents. Hence, the present civil revision
petition is liable to be dismissed.
7.
Heard Sri M.R.S. Srinivas, learned counsel for the petitioner,
Sri S. Siva Rama Krishna Prasad, learned counsel for the respondent
and perused the material available on record.
8.
In order to appreciate the aforesaid contentions, it is
appropriate to refer to Order VIII Rules 8 & 9 C.P.C:
Order VIII Rule 8 New Ground of defence
"Any ground of defence which has arisen after the
institution of the suit or the presentation of a written
statement claiming a set-off or counter - claim may be
raised by the defendant or plaintiff, as the case may be, in
his written statement."
Order VIII Rule 9 Subsequent pleadings
Subsequent pleadings.—No pleading subsequent to the
written statement of a defendant other than by way of
defence to set-off or counter-claim shall be presented
except by the leave of the Court and upon such terms as
the Court thinks fit; but the Court may at any time require a
written statement or additional written statement from any
of the parties and fix a time of not more than thirty days for
presenting the same.”
9.
NV,J
CRP_3311_2025
A close reading of the aforesaid provisions makes it abundantly
clear that the scope of Order 8, Rule 9 CPC is much wider than Rule
8. Order 8, Rule 8 CPC (which deals with new ground of 7 defence)
permits either party to the suit to raise only a new ground of defence,
which has arisen subsequent to the filing of the suit or filing of the
written statement (as the case may be) claiming set-off or
counterclaim. Whereas, Order 8, Rule 9 CPC not only permits filing of
subsequent pleadings, as a matter right, in cases where the
defendant sets up a counter-claim or pleads set-off in his written
statement, but also in other cases with the leave of the Court. Thus,
under Order 8, Rule 9 CPC a plaintiff can file a rejoinder with the
leave of the Court even in cases where the defendant has not
pleaded set-off or a counter-claim. This position is now well settled.
10.
In another Judgment in Malgireddy Venkata Ramana vs.
Thippana Narsi Reddy2, another learned single Judge of this Court
while dealing with Order VIII Rule 9 of Code of Civil Procedure held
as follows :-
2010 (3) ALD 82
NV,J
CRP_3311_2025
“12. The primary object of subsequent pleading is to supply
what has been omitted inadvertently or unintentionally or to
deny or clarify the facts stated in the pleadings of the
opposite party. In the rejoinder the plaintiff can be permitted
to
explain
the
additional
facts,
which
have
been
incorporated in the written statement to explain the
additional facts, which have been incorporated in the written
statement………..”
11.
.The primary object of subsequent pleading is to supply what
has been omitted inadvertently or unintentionally or to deny or clarify
the facts stated in the pleadings of the opposite party, that in the
rejoinder, the plaintiff can be permitted to explain the additional facts,
which have been incorporated in the written statement. In view of the
consistent view taken by this Court in the above referred Judgments,
the contention of learned counsel for the respondents deserves to be
rejected.
12.
It is settled law that under Order VIII Rule 9 of C.P.C, 1908 the
plaintiff can be permitted to file rejoinder to explain the additional facts
which had been incorporated in the written statement even though the
same were not mentioned in the application seeking leave.
13.
NV,J
CRP_3311_2025
In this regard, it is trite to refer to the Judgment of a learned
single Judge of this Court in Aloor Subrahmanyam v. Suthram
Prabhakar3 wherein it was held that:
“9. Order VIII Rule 9 CPC deals with subsequent
pleadings. It has imposed bar on the parties filing
pleadings subsequent to the filing of the written
statement other than by way of defence to set-off or
counter- claim, except by the leave of the Court. This
provision per se does not stipulate any limitations on
the power of the Court to allow the parties to file
subsequent pleadings. However, the Courts have
interpreted this provision by reading certain limitations
into the same, obviously to ensure that the scope of
the proceedings is not unduly enlarged and the suit
proceedings are not dragged on in the guise of filing
subsequent pleadings.
10. In Shikharchand Jain (3 supra), the Supreme Court
broadly indicated three parameters on which leave for
filing subsequent pleadings can be granted. They are:
(1) the relief claimed originally by reason of
subsequent change has become inappropriate; or
(2) where it is necessary to take notice of changed
circumstances in order to shorten the litigation; or
(3) to do complete justice between the parties.
14. In Sardar Darshan Singh (2 supra), this Court
has held that while permitting subsequent pleadings,
the plaintiff cannot be permitted to raise inconsistent
pleas or alter the cause of action.
15. In Malgireddy Venkata Ramana (1 supra), this
Court held that the primary object of subsequent
pleading is to supply what has been omitted
2012(3) ALD 202
NV,J
CRP_3311_2025
inadvertently or unintentionally or to deny or clarify the
facts stated in the pleadings of the opposite party, that
in the rejoinder the plaintiff can be permitted to explain
the additional facts, which have been incorporated in
the written statement and that the application under
Order VIII Rule 9 CPC cannot be treated as one under
Order VI Rule 17 CPC as both are contextually
different.
16. In the opinion of this Court, the legislature has
designedly omitted to lay down any guidelines
restricting the scope of the Courts to specific instances
while granting leave for filing subsequent pleadings.
From this itself, the legislative intention can be
gathered to the effect that unless the Court forms an
opinion that the application for leave is filed for
reasons, such as procrastinating the suit proceedings
or to widen the scope of the suit or change the nature
and character of the suit proceedings, the applications
shall ordinarily be allowed. By permitting such
subsequent pleadings, the Courts can avoid multiplicity
of proceedings. That approach will also help the Court
to comprehensively and effectually decide all the
questions arising in the case with reference to the
complete information furnished by the parties through
their original as well as subsequent pleadings.
14. Viewed from this angle, the provision of Order VIII
Rule 9 needs to be construed in a manner which would
ordinarily permit the party to file subsequent pleadings
rather than scuttling their right to do so. A caveat is,
however, entered that in the guise of such applications,
the parties cannot be permitted to indulge in filing
frivolous and vexatious petitions even where the need
for filing subsequent pleadings does not exist. It is
eventually for the Courts to make a delicate balance
between the expediency of permitting subsequent
pleadings and discouraging the frivolous and merit less
applications.”
17.
NV,J
CRP_3311_2025
On perusal of the judgments extracted above and on perusal of
the object of necessity as contemplated under Order VIII Rule 9
C.P.C, 1908 this Court is of the considered view that the trial Court
ought to have allowed the application filed by the petitioner/plaintiff
seeking leave to file rejoinder. Further, allowing of a rejoinder, in the
facts and circumstances of the case, would not in any way prejudice
the case of the respondents as the tenability or otherwise of the
statements/matters set out in the rejoinder would be considered in the
suit. Therefore, the order of the learned trial Judge in view of the legal
position deserves to be interfered with, in exercise of powers under
Article 227 of the Constitution of India.
18.
The rejoinder and plaint submitted by the petitioner is only an
explanation to the new pleadings putforth by the respondent through
his written statement. It is the right of the petitioner by way of new
pleadings or contentions in the written statement by the defendant
either by way of rebuttal or clarification. Under Order VIII Rule 9 of the
CPC, the plaintiff is entitled to file a rejoinder, and this provision
envisages the petitioner’s right to do so.
19.
NV,J
CRP_3311_2025
It is well settled that when new pleadings are raised in a written
statement, the petitioner acquires the right to file a rejoinder. Such a
rejoinder does not alter the original pleadings set out in the plaint, nor
does it change the nature of the suit; it simply explains or clarifies the
new facts introduced by the defendant. In light of this settled legal
position, the order passed by the learned Trial Court is liable to be set
aside.
20.
In the result, civil revision petition is allowed, and the order
passed by the Additional Civil Judge (Senior Division), Ongole in
I.A.No.326 of 2025 in O.S.No.66 of 2019 dated 24.10.2025 is hereby
set-aside.
21.
Consequently, miscellaneous applications pending if any, shall
stand closed. No costs.
______________________________________
JUSTICE VENKATESWARLU NIMMAGADDA
Dated: 07.05.2026
SP
NV,J
CRP_3311_2025
THE HON’BLE SRI JUSTICE VENKATESWARLU NIMMAGADDA
CIVIL REVISION PETITION No.3311 OF 2025
Dated: 07.05.2026
W
SP
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review