Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
[2026:RJ-JP:993-DB]
HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE FOR RAJASTHAN
BENCH AT JAIPUR
D.B. Civil Contempt Petition No. 1135/2024
In
D.B. Civil Writ Petition (PIL) No. 4716/2022
1.
Nekiram S/o Nemichand, R/o Nuniya Gothda Tehsil
Chidawa District Jhunjhunu
2.
Ranveersingh S/o Bhagwanaram, R/o Nuniya Gothda
Tehsil Chidawa District Jhunjhunu
3.
Balveer S/o Narayanram, R/o Ajeetpura Tehsil Chidawa
District Jhunjhunu
4.
Jan Kalyan Samiti, Mandrela, Tehsil Chidawa District
Jhunjhunu Through Mantri Rishi Sharma.
----Petitioners
Versus
1.
Shri Sudhanshu Pant,
Secretariat, Jaipur
Chief
Secretary
Rajasthan,
2.
Shri Ramawtar Meena, District Collector Jhunjhunu
3.
Shri Naresh Soni, Upkhand Adhikari Chidawa
4.
Shri Kamaldeep Puniya, Tehsildar Chidawa
5.
State of Rajasthan through Chief Secretary Rajasthan
Secretariat, Jaipur
----Respondents
For Petitioner(s)
:
Mr. Ved Pal Shastri
For Respondent(s)
:
Mr. G.S. Gill, AAG with
Ms. Shikha Sharma for State
Mr. Anoop Pareek,
Mr. Kshitiz Sharma,
Mr. Mohit Balwada,
Mr. Sunil Shekhawat for applicants
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE SUDESH BANSAL
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE SANDEEP TANEJA
Order
08/01/2026
REPORTABLE
1.
In the main Contempt Petition, petitioners alleged non-
compliance of the judgment/ final order dated 23.05.2022 passed
in D.B. Civil Writ Petition (PIL) No. 4716/2022, but after
(2 of 16)
[2026:RJ-JP:993-DB]
[CCP-1135/2024]
submission of reply to the Contempt Petition and Additional
Affidavit showing compliance, in the rejoinder, petitioners stated
non-compliance of the orders dated 04.12.2023 and 10.03.2025
as well and prayed to ensure compliance of such orders.
2.
During
course
of
Contempt
Petition,
misc.
application
(1/2025) was filed by few applicants seeking impleadment, stating
inter alia, that applicants are not encroachers over the pasture
land, yet in the guise of seeking compliance of order dated
23.05.2022, for removal of encroachment over pasture land, their
authorized construction and possession is being sought to be
removed. This application was decided vide interim order dated
03.11.2025 and applicants were allowed to assist the Court as
intervenors.
3.
Another misc. application (2/2025) has been filed by and on
behalf of 22 applicants, stating inter alia, that they have filed S.B.
Civil Writ Petition No. 13399/2023 and S.B. Civil Writ Petition No.
11728/2023, challenging the eviction order and in such writ
petitions, interim stay order is operating in their favour and writ
petitions are pending, yet petitioners are trying to create pressure
upon the respondents-authorities to demolish their construction
and dispossess them from residential houses, hence, applicants be
allowed to be impleaded and heard in the present contempt
proceedings. This application is pending and has also been heard.
4.
Heard learned counsels for respective parties and perused
the record.
5.
It appears that petitioners filed D.B. Civil Writ Petition (PIL)
No. 4716/2022 raising a grievance that despite passing an eviction
order dated 04.08.2021 by the Tehsildar in exercise of powers
[2026:RJ-JP:993-DB]
(3 of 16)
[CCP-1135/2024]
under Section 91 of the Rajasthan Land Revenue Act, 1956
(hereinafter referred to as “the Act of 1956”), order has not been
executed and encroachments from pasture and Government land
have not been removed. In the writ petition, encroachment over
the pasture land situated at Village Ajitpura having Survey Nos.
177, 184, 215, 245, 257, 388/188, 395/283, 396/284 and at
Village Nunia Gothda, having Survey Nos. 11, 13, 159, 187 and
280 and encroachment over the land of Gair Mumkin Kabristan
recorded in Revenue Record under Survey Nos. 24, 28, 35,
404/29 and 405/30 situated at Village Nunia Gothda, which is
stated to be used as pasture land since Muslims left for Pakistan,
were alleged.
6.
It appears that the Hon’ble Division Bench of this Court,
disposed of the Writ Petition (PIL) vide judgment/ final order dated
23.05.2022 with observation that if the order of eviction passed
by the Tehsildar under Section 91 of the Act of 1956, has attained
finality and has not been challenged and none of the persons
affected has taken recourse to remedy of appeal and there is no
interim order, it goes without saying that the order is required to
be executed in accordance with Scheme of the Act.
7.
A bare perusal of the judgment/ order dated 23.05.2022
goes to show that the order only talks about that if the eviction
order has attained finality or no interim order operates against the
eviction order, same is required to be executed in accordance with
Scheme of the Act of 1956. The manner and procedure to execute
the eviction order passed by the Tehsildar, in exercise of powers
under Section 91 of the Act of 1956, is itself envisaged under
Section 91 and for aid, the State Government has promulgated
[2026:RJ-JP:993-DB]
(4 of 16)
[CCP-1135/2024]
Rajasthan Land Revenue (Eviction of Trespassers) Rules, 1975 in
exercise of the powers conferred by Clause (xliv) of Sub Section
(2) of Section 261. For ready reference, Section 91 of the Act is
being reproduced hereunder:“91. Unauthorised occupation of Land - (1) Any person
who occupies or continues to occupy any land without lawful
monthly shall be regarded as a trespasser and may be summarily
evicted there from by the Tehsildar at any time of his motion or
upon the application of a local authority at whose disposal such
land has been placed, and any crop standing, or any building or
other construction erected. or anything deposited on such land
shall, if not removed with in such reasonable time as the
Tehsildar may from time to time fix for the purpose, be liable to
be forfeited to the State and to be disposed of [in the case of any
such crop, in the manner he thinks fit and in other cases] as the
Collector may direct:
Provided that the Tehsildar may in lieu of ordering the
forfeiture of any such building or other construction, order the
demolition of the whole or any part thereof.
[(2) Such trespasser shall further be liable to pay, for 'each
agricultural year during the whole or any part where of has been
in such unauthorized occupation of the land, a penalty which may
extend to fifty times the annual rent, or assessment, as the case
may be, for the first act of trespass. In the case of each
subsequent ad of trespass, he shall by the order of Tehsildar, be
liable to commitment to civic person for a term which may
extend to three months and to pay penalty to the extent as
aforesaid. The amount of such penalty shall be recovered as an
arrear of land revenue, and]
[(3) Where the trespasser ordered to be committed to civil prison
under subsection (2) satisfies the Tehsildar by whom he is
ordered to be committed to civil prison that he intends to present
an appeal, the Tehsildar shall order that such trespasser be
released on his own bond for such periods will afford him
sufficient time present the appeal and obtain stay order from the
Appellate Court and such order shall so long as he is so released
on bond be deemed to be suspended]
(4) In any of the following cases, namely.(i) where the trespasser does neither vacate the land not
make appearance in response to the notice issue under
sub-section (3), or
(ii) where in response to such notice, the trespasser does
not vacate the land and makes appearance but(a) does not show any such cause, or
(b) makes any representation which is rejected after
such inquiry and hearing as may be necessary in the
circumstances of the case, the Tehsildar shall, unless, in
the case covered by clause (ii) the trespasser under-takes
to vacate the land within a week's time- and vacates it
whine such time order the removal of the trespasser from
[2026:RJ-JP:993-DB]
(5 of 16)
[CCP-1135/2024]
such land and shall remove or depute any person, to
remove him therefrom and take possession thereof; and if
the Tehsildar or the person so deputed is opposed or
limpeded in taking possession of such land, the Tehsildar
shall apply to a Magistrate having jurisdiction and such
Magistrate shall enforce the surrender of the land to the
Tehsildar.
(5) Notwithstanding anything contained in the foregoing subsections, the Tehsildar may, in case any such land belongs to the
category specified in clause (ii) of the proviso to Section 97, sell
it, with the approval of the Sub-Divisional Officer, to the
trespasser upon payment by him of the premium therefor at the
rate fixed under Section 96 and applicable to such land in
addition to the assessment and penalty recoverable from him
under sub-section (2) in respect of the whole period of unlawful
occupation
[(6) Notwithstanding anything contained in sub-section (2) (a) whoever occupies any land without lawful
authority or, having occupied such land before corning into
force of the Rajasthan Land Revenue (Amendment) Act,
1992, fails to remove such occupation within fifteen days
from the date of service of a notice in writing calling upon
him to do so by the Tehsildar shall, on conviction, be
punished with simple imprisonment which shall not be less
than one month but which may extend to three years and
with fine which may extend to twenty thousand rupees; and
(b) whoever, being an employee of the State
Government specifically entrusted by an order of the
Collector in writing with the duty to stop or prevent an
offence punishable under this sub-section willfully or
knowingly neglects or deliberately omits to stop of prevent
such offence, shall, on conviction, be punished with simple
imprisonment for a term which may extend to one month or
with fine which may extend to one thousand rupees or with
both :
Provided that, in the case of an offence under clause (a),
the court may for any adequate or special reason to be
mentioned in the judgment impose a sentence of imprisonment
for a term of less than one month :
Provided also that no investigation of an offence under
clause (a) of this sub section shall be made by an officer below
the rank of a Deputy Superintendent of Police :
Provided further that no court shall take cognizance of an
offence under clause (b) except with the previous sanction of the
Collector.
Explanation - For the purpose of this sub-section, "Land" means
(i) a pasture land as defined in the Rajasthan Tenancy Act, 1955
(Act No. 3 of 1955); and
(ii) land redefined in sub-clauses (iii) and (iv) of clause Ca) of
Section 103 including land appurtenant to a public well, Nadi,
Johad and Talab.]”
[2026:RJ-JP:993-DB]
8.
(6 of 16)
[CCP-1135/2024]
It is noteworthy that prior to filing of the present Contempt
Petition, petitioners had preferred D.B. Civil Contempt Petition No.
927/2022, pleading non-compliance of the judgment/ final order
dated 23.05.2022 and their previous Contempt Petition has been
dismissed vide order dated 11.03.2024 with finding that at this
stage, no case is made out for wilful disobedience by respondents
of the order dated 23.05.2022, for initiating the contempt
proceedings, however, petitioners were granted liberty to avail
remedies in accordance with law for redressal of surviving
grievance, after conclusion of the proceedings challenging the
eviction order.
9.
It is further noteworthy that the counsel for petitioners
admits and does not dispute that the eviction order dated
04.08.2021, passed by the Tehsildar has been challenged by
private persons, by means of filing various writ petitions being
S.B. Civil Writ Petition No. 9608/2023, 11728/2023, 13399/2023
and 11914/2023 and proceedings on such writ petition, have not
been concluded as much as interim stay order(s) for not
demolishing the residential houses, are also operating and writ
petitions are pending for adjudication/ consideration before the
learned Single Judge of this High Court.
10.
The contention of counsel for petitioners is that at least the
respondents-authorities should comply with and execute the
eviction order for removing the encroachment from the other part
of pasture lands, leaving the area of residential houses on which
interim stay order(s) passed by the learned Single Judge in Writ
Petition are operating. Further contention of learned counsel for
petitioners is that, at the time of dismissing the previous
(7 of 16)
[2026:RJ-JP:993-DB]
[CCP-1135/2024]
Contempt Petition vide order dated 11.03.2024, the Court was
under impression that an another stay order of maintaining status
quo dated 27.07.2023 passed by the Sub Divisional Officer,
Chirawa is also operating over the lands in question whereas
indeed such stay order has been vacated and the Revenue Suit
itself has been rejected by the SDO, Chirawa vide judgment dated
26.07.2024 under Order 7 Rule 11 CPC. Hence, now, there is no
hurdle
in
executing
the
eviction
order,
for
removal
of
encroachment other than residential houses against which interim
stay order passed by learned Single Judge is still operating.
11.
Learned
counsel
pointed
out
that
during
course
of
proceedings of previous Contempt Petition, an order dated
04.12.2023 was passed by the Coordinate Bench of this High
Court whereunder directions were issued to respondents to take
necessary steps against the encroachers in terms of final order
dated 23.05.2022, if they are holding land beyond the area,
stayed by the learned Single Judge. For ready reference, the
portion of order dated 04.12.2023, Para No. 6 and 7 reads as
under:“6. Further, prayer has been made that as per the
interim order granted by learned Single Judge, the
same only pertains to the residential area whereas, the
land, much beyond the residential area, is under
encroachment by several persons against which
necessary steps have not been taken.
7.
In view of the submissions made, it is expected
from the respondents to take necessary steps in terms
of the directions issued by the Division Bench and the
encroachers, if they are holding land beyond the area
stayed by learned Single Judge, they shall be dealt
appropriately in terms of the directions issued by this
Court.”
[2026:RJ-JP:993-DB]
12.
(8 of 16)
[CCP-1135/2024]
Learned counsel for petitioners have further pointed out that
in the present contempt proceedings vide interim order dated
26.09.2025, respondents were granted opportunity to submit
report in compliance of the order dated 04.12.2023 and though
pursuant thereto, an Additional Affidavit dated 14.10.2025 has
been filed by the Sub Divisional
Officer, Chirawa showing
compliance of the eviction order/ directions of this Court, but that
affidavit contains incorrect and incomplete averments and indeed
only wired fencing have been removed, crops from the pasture
land have not been removed and further, shops of Budhram and
Mahendra Goswami which are in fact located in pasture land, but
has wrongly been shown in their Khatedari; another encroacher
Ram Singh has again started construction of his house after
demolition by respondents and the entire encroachment from the
pasture land has not been removed. Hence, contention of counsel
for petitioners is that the respondents-authorities are guilty of
non-compliance of the directions issued by this Court vide orders
dated 23.05.2022 and 04.12.2023 and 26.09.2025 and as such
they are liable to be punished for committing Contempt of Court.
In support thereof, counsel for petitioners has placed reliance
on the judgment, delivered by the Full Bench of the Rajasthan
High Court in case of Jaiwant Rao & Ors. Vs. State of
Rajasthan [AIR 1961 (Raj.) 250].
13.
Per contra, learned Additional Advocate General, appearing
for and on behalf of respondents- contemnors, humbly submits
that the weapon of initiating contempt proceedings could not be
used for execution of a decree or implementation of an order and
the Court should not invoke the contempt jurisdiction where
[2026:RJ-JP:993-DB]
(9 of 16)
[CCP-1135/2024]
alternative remedies are available to secure the execution of
orders/ directions of which non-compliance have been alleged.
14.
His further submission is that the entire encroachment
except demolition/ removal of the residential houses, have been
removed and compliance report in form of Additional Affidavit by
the then SDO, Chirawa, Naresh Soni has been placed on record
pursuant to the order dated 26.09.2025, hence, there is no
disobedience on the part of respondents-State Authorities either of
final order dated 23.05.2022 or of order dated 04.12.2023, what
to say of deliberate and willful disobedience of such orders. His
further submission is that the respondent-authorities have high
regards for the Majesty of law and orders/ directions passed by
the Hon’ble Courts and have always strived to ensure true and
faithful compliance of the orders/ directions passed by the Hon’ble
Court, however, even if any action of the respondents-authorities
is found to be in contradiction to the final order dated 23.05.2022
or the other orders, same is not willful and deliberate and the
same is bonafide, in good faith and in discharge of their official
duties and respondents tender their unconditional apology for the
same. The prayer of learned Additional Additional General is that
initiation of the contempt proceedings, second time, for execution
of the eviction order is ex facie misuse of the process of law, more
so when the previous Contempt Petition of petitioners has already
been dismissed on merits, therefore, petitioners be saddled with
suitable cost, while dismissing their present second Contempt
Petition.
15.
We have gone through the compliance report. In the
compliance report, reference of registering a PLPC Case No.
[2026:RJ-JP:993-DB]
(10 of 16)
[CCP-1135/2024]
51/2022 in the present matter, has been given and it has been
mentioned that in the meeting dated 30.12.2022, directions were
issued to the concerned
Authorities to ensure
removal
of
encroachments from the Government land. It has further been
mentioned that on the report of Patwari Halka, proceedings under
Section 91 of the Act of 1956 were initiated against as many as
149 encroachers and eviction orders dated 04.08.2021 and
10.09.2021 were passed by the Tehsildar, Chirawa. It has been
disclosed that out of 149 encroachers, 114 encroachers have filed
writ petitions before the learned Single Bench of the Rajasthan
High Court, challenging the eviction orders and interim orders
restraining the respondents from demolishing the residential
houses have been passed in such writ petitions, which are stated
to be pending. Encroachments from 8038 Sq. Meter area out of
total area of encroachment 11412 Sq. Meter have completely been
removed. The details of name of encroachers and area of removal
of their encroachment have been indicated in the compliance
report and it has specifically been mentioned that only demolition
of the residential houses have not been made on account of
interim orders granted by the Hon’ble Single Bench, albeit,
encroachments from the non-residential area have been removed.
16.
It is worthy to notice that in the rejoinder, petitioners
submitted that construction of shop of Uppradhan, godown of
Budhram and shop of Mahendra have not been removed. In the
compliance report, specific reply/ explanation to such factual
matrix has been given, pointing out that shop of Sube Singh,
father of Uppradhan, has been removed; some portion of shop of
Budhram was identified as encroachment, which has been
[2026:RJ-JP:993-DB]
(11 of 16)
[CCP-1135/2024]
removed. It has been stated that shop of Mahendra is located in
his khatedari land. For non-removal of encroachment of Rajendra,
it has been stated that his bada is constructed in his own
khatedari land. We find that in view of submission of the
compliance report and considering the details of facts of making
compliance, it is not a case of flouting the order(s) & direction of
this court. Compliance report may not be misconstrued as
execution of eviction order. Hence, compliance report is accepted
and same is taken on record.
17.
During course of arguments, we asked the counsel for
petitioners about the scheme of execution of eviction order(s)
passed by the Tehsildar in exercise of jurisdiction under Section 91
of the Act of 1956 and in reply, counsel for petitioners does not
dispute that the procedure of execution of the eviction order is
provided in Section 91 itself, which is complete code in itself, in
respect of ensuring removal of the unauthorized occupation from
the pasture land/ Government land appurtenant to a public Well,
Nadi, Johar and Talab.
18.
It is apposite to refer the celebrated judgment of the Hon’ble
Supreme Court delivered in case of R.N. Dey & Ors. Vs.
Bhagyabati Pramanik & Ors. [(2000) 4 SCC 400], which has
been followed by the Supreme Court recently in case of Urban
Infrastructure Real Estate Fund Vs. Dharmesh S. Jain &
Anr. [(2022) 6 SCC 662], while affirming the proposition of law,
the Supreme Court held and observed as under:“This Court in the case of R.N. Dey V. Bhagyabati
Pramanik (2000) 4 SCC 400 held that the weapon of
initiating contempt proceedings could not be used for
execution of a decree or implementation of an order.
That is, a court should not invoke contempt
jurisdiction, where alternate remedies are available to
(12 of 16)
[2026:RJ-JP:993-DB]
[CCP-1135/2024]
secure the terms of an order. We are mindful of the
fact that contempt proceedings should not be of the
nature of ‘execution proceedings in disguise.”
19.
We are mindful that the purpose of contempt jurisdiction is
to uphold the Majesty of the Courts of law and indeed. Contempt
is a matter, between the Court passing the order, of which
contempt
is
alleged
and
the
contemnor;
questions
as
to
executability of such order is a question which concerns the
parties
inter se. The power of Court to invoke contempt
jurisdiction, does not, in any manner, adjudicate the rights of
parties inter se. In the contempt proceedings, the Court does not
adjudicate upon any claim between litigating parties. It is a matter
between the Court and the contemnor and third parties cannot
intervene. It is exercised in a summary manner in aid of the
administration of justice and to uphold Majesty of law and dignity
of the Courts.
20.
It is an established principle of law that to hold a person
guilty of civil contempt, willful disobedience is an indispensable
requirement. The Hon’ble Supreme Court, after sailing through
plethora
of
judgments
recently
in
case
of
Balwantbhai
Somabhai Bhandari v. Hiralal Somabhai Contractor [(2023)
17 SCC 545], opined that the expression or word “Willful” means
act or omission, which is done voluntarily or intentionally and with
the specific intent to do something which the law forbids or with
the specific intent to fail to do something the law requires to be
done, that is to say that bad purpose either to disobey or to
disregard the law, which signifies deliberate action done with evil
intent or with a bad motive or purpose.
(13 of 16)
[2026:RJ-JP:993-DB]
21.
[CCP-1135/2024]
We have noticed that even though Additional Affidavit
submitted by the SDO, Chirawa as compliance report, has been
countered by the petitioners giving out name of few private
persons whose encroachment on the pasture land has not been
removed, but according to respondents-contemnors, the area of
residential houses has not been disturbed on account of operating
the interim stay order in favour of persons, who have challenged
the eviction orders before the learned Single Judge. We are of the
considered opinion that while dealing with the Contempt Petition,
the Court is not expected to conduct a roving inquiry and go
beyond the scope of judgment/ order, which is alleged to be
violated. Further, this principle should be applied with more
sincerity, particularly, when disputed questions of facts are
involved. The factual dispute, in respect of removal/ non-removal
of the encroachment over the pasture land, existing herein, is
indeed a complex question of fact, which need not be and cannot
be adjudicated in the contempt proceedings. It is open for the
petitioners or aggrieved person to pursue even that aspect in
execution proceedings or such other proceedings as may be
permissible in law.
22.
As far as initiation of contempt proceedings against the
respondent-State Authorities is concerned, that too by means of a
second contempt after dismissal of the first Contempt Petition on
merits vide order dated 11.03.2024, which has attained finality.
We find that same is not proper and rather, this is not a fit case to
initiate
and
proceed
contempt
proceedings
against
the
respondents for ensuring execution of eviction order, which fell
within the mandate of Section 91 of the Act of 1956. We deem it
[2026:RJ-JP:993-DB]
(14 of 16)
[CCP-1135/2024]
appropriate to refer findings recorded by the Hon’ble Supreme
Court recently in case of Dr. U.N. Bora Vs. Assam Roller Floor
Mills Association [(2022) 1 SCC 101], in Para No. 9, ad infra:“9. We do not wish to reiterate the aforesaid settled
principle of law except by quoting the reasoned decision of
this Court in Hukum Chand Deswal v. Satish Raj Deswal,
2020 SCC Online SC 438 wherein the celebrated judgment
in Ram Kishan v. Tarun Bajaj, (2014) 16 SCC 204, has
been quoted. The following paragraphs would govern the
aforesaid principle:
“20. At the outset, we must advert to the
contours delineated by this court for initiating civil
contempt action in Ram Kishan vs. Tarun Bajaj & Ors.
In paragraphs 11, 12 and 15 of the reported decision,
this Court noted thus:
‘11. The contempt jurisdiction conferred
on to the law courts power to punish an
offender
for
his
wilful
disobedience/contumacious
conduct
or
obstruction to the majesty of law, for the
reason that respect and authority commanded
by the courts of law are the greatest guarantee
to an ordinary citizen that his rights shall be
protected and the entire democratic fabric of
the society will crumble down if the respect of
the judiciary is undermined. Undoubtedly, the
contempt jurisdiction is a powerful weapon in
the hands of the courts of law but that by itself
operates as a string of caution and unless,
thus, otherwise satisfied beyond reasonable
doubt, it would neither be fair nor reasonable
for the law courts to exercise jurisdiction under
the Act. The proceedings are quasi criminal in
nature, and therefore, standard of proof
required in these proceedings is beyond all
reasonable doubt. It would rather be hazardous
to impose sentence for contempt on the
authorities in exercise of the contempt
jurisdiction on mere probabilities. ”
23.
As far as reference of judgment of Full Bench of Rajasthan
High Court, delivered in case of Jaiwant Rao (supra), counsel for
petitioners have drawn attention of this Court to the following
judicial precedent, which is emphasized therein:“It is a well recognised and salutary rule of
practice that a single Judge is bound by the decision of a
Bench of two or more judges and a Division Bench is
bound by the decision of another Division Bench and he
cannot ignore or disregard the earlier decision, unless
(15 of 16)
[2026:RJ-JP:993-DB]
[CCP-1135/2024]
such decision has been overrules by a Full Bench or the
Supreme Court. Subordinate Courts are bound by the
decisions of the High Court and if single Judges make
pronouncements inconsistent with those of a Division
Bench in disregard of the rules of judicial precedents,
they would create confusion in the minds of the
subordinate judiciary. The salutary important of
respecting judicial precedents which foster judicial
traditions and help to provide a safe guide in a morass
of confusion cannot be over emphasized.”
24.
In the present contempt proceedings that there is no issue at
all
of
not
following
the
judicial
precedent
as
enunciated
hereinabove, rather the issue is in respect of disobedience of the
judgment/ final order dated 23.05.2022 and other orders dated
04.12.2023 and 10.03.2025. The first Contempt Petition initiated
by and on behalf of petitioners has already been dismissed on
merits with observation that no wilful disobedience of judgment/
final
order
23.05.2022
was
noticed.
Interim
order
dated
04.12.2023 was also taken into consideration while dismissing first
Contempt
Petition.
proceedings,
is
This
not
Court,
in
this
second
reconsidering/reviewing
contempt
the
finding/
observations made by the Coordinate Bench while dismissing the
first Contempt Petition. In addition, this Court too does not find
any disobedience of order dated 04.12.2023, passed during
proceedings of first Contempt Petition, rather the compliance of
this
order
as
per
the
order
dated
10.03.2025
passed
in
furtherance to the directions dated 04.12.2023, has already been
submitted. Thus, reliance placed by the counsel for petitioners on
the judicial precedent enunciated above, is misplaced and does
not render any assistance to the Court in the present contempt
proceedings.
[2026:RJ-JP:993-DB]
25.
(16 of 16)
[CCP-1135/2024]
Thus, in our considered opinion, the present contempt
proceedings have been pursued by the petitioners, arbitrarily and
in utter misuse of contempt jurisdiction of the High Court and in
the guise of alleging disobedience of the orders passed by this
Court, petitioners virtually asked for execution of the eviction
order, which is executable as per the prescribed manner and
procedure mandated under Section 91 of the Act of 1956.
26.
We find this second contempt petition is malafide and filed in
utter misuse of process of law, and same is hereby dismissed with
cost, which is quantified to Rs. 1 Lakh payable by the petitioners
jointly in the state exchequer for use of maintenance of pasture
and public lands.
27.
Notices of contempt issued against respondents stand
discharged.
28.
In view of dismissal of Contempt Petition, misc. application
(2/2025) for impleadment, has rendered infructuous, hence, same
stands disposed of, accordingly.
29.
Any other pending application(s), if any, also stand disposed
of.
(SANDEEP TANEJA),J
NITIN /42
(SUDESH BANSAL),J
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review