Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
APHC010199
272017
IN THE HIGH COURT OF ANDHRA PRADESH
AT AMARAVATI
Bench Sr.No:-157
[3584]
MOTOR ACCIDENT CIVIL MISCELLANEOUS
APPEAL Nos: 48 AND 2724 OF 2017
MACMA No.48 of 2017:
United India Insurance Co. Ltd., Kadapa Dist.
...Appellant
Vs.
Neelam Supriya, Kadapa Dist and 2 Others
...Respondent(s)
**********
Advocate for Appellant:
Mr.SRINIVASA RAO VUTLA
Advocate for Respondents:
Mr.M S P KAMARAJU (not
appeared)
****
MACMA No.2724 of 2017:
Neelam Supriya and 2 Others
...Appellant(s)
Vs.
V Chandra Sekhar Reddy and Anr.
...Respondent(s)
**********
Advocate for Appellants:
Mr.M S P KAMARAJU (not
appeared)
Advocate for Respondent No.2:
Mr.SRINIVASA RAO VUTLA,
***
CORAM : THE CHIEF JUSTICE LISA GILL
SRI JUSTICE CHALLA GUNARANJAN
DATE
: 30th June 2026
COMMON JUDGMENT: (per Hon’ble Sri Justice Challa Gunaranjan)
Both these appeals - one preferred by Insurer and the other by
claimants- arise out of the very same award, dated 08.08.2016, in
HCJ & CGR, J.
M.A.C.M.A. Nos.48 & 2724 of 2017
M.V.O.P.No.315 of 2015, passed by the Chairman, Motor Accident
Claims Tribunal-cum-IV Additional District Judge, Kadapa, (for short,
“the Tribunal”), and the same are heard together and disposed of by
this common judgment.
2.
For the sake of convenience, the parties hereinafter are
referred to as they were arrayed in the M.V.O.P. before the Tribunal.
3.
M.A.C.M.A. No.48 of 2017 is preferred by insurer and whereas
M.A.C.M.A.No.2724 of 2017 is preferred by claimants.
4.
The facts relevant for disposal of these appeals are set out as
under:
(a) The motor vehicle accident involving the deceased viz.,
Neelam Chandra Sekhar occurred at about 9.00 A.M. on 18.04.2015
while he was travelling on motorcycle bearing No.AP04 AW 5852
towards Rapur. When he reached Anampalli Forest check post, the
offending vehicle viz., Tata Spacio bearing No.AP04 AY 3727, coming
in opposite direction at high speed in rash and negligent manner,
collided with the motorcycle, on which deceased was riding, on
account of which he sustained bleeding injuries and got shifted to
Government Hospital, Rajampet. On the advice of doctors, he was
HCJ & CGR, J.
M.A.C.M.A. Nos.48 & 2724 of 2017
shifted to SVRR Hospital, Tirupati, for better treatment, where
deceased succumbed due to injuries after five days.
(b) Initially, on 20.06.2015, the incident came to be reported to
Chitvel Police Station, Kadapa District, who registered Crime No.36
of 2015 for the offence under Section 337 IPC. Ex.A1 is the certified
copy of F.I.R. Later, as deceased succumbed due to the injuries,
altered FIR came to be registered for the offence under Sections 307
and 304-A IPC. Ex.A6 is the certified copy of altered F.I.R. Later, the
police have laid charge-sheet against the driver of offending Tata
Spacio vehicle.
(c) The deceased was aged about 29 years and was a driver,
stated to have had driving licence issued by Kuwait Government,
where he worked for some time. The deceased claimed to be earning
about Rs.20,000/- per month besides Rs.5,000/- per month, for
overtime job at the time of occurrence of accident. Accordingly, wife
and mother of deceased filed the claim seeking compensation of
Rs.55,00,000/-.
5.
The 1st respondent, driver-cum-owner of Tata Spacio vehicle,
remained ex parte and the 2nd respondent Insurer of the said vehicle,
contested the claim.
HCJ & CGR, J.
M.A.C.M.A. Nos.48 & 2724 of 2017
6.
In the counter-affidavit filed by Insurer, it has been disputed that
the accident had occurred solely on account rash driving of driver of
Tata Spacio, since, it was a case of head on collision, according to
Insurer, even the deceased also contributed to the occurrence. That
apart, age, earnings and the occupation of deceased have also been
severely disputed.
7.
Considering the respective pleadings, the Tribunal has framed
the following issues:
“1. Whether the accident occurred due to rash and
negligent driving by the driver of the Tata Spacio bearing
No.AP04 AY 3727 resulting the death of the deceased by
name Neelam Chandra Sekhar on 18.04.2015?
2.
Whether
the
petitioners
are
entitled
to
compensation, if so, to what amount and from whom?
3. To what relief?”
8.
In support of the claim, PWs.1 to 3 were examined and Exs.A1
to A11 were marked.
Likewise, on behalf of Insurer, RW.1 was
examined and Exs.B1 and B2 were marked.
9.
On appreciation of both oral and documentary evidence, the
Tribunal ultimately concluded that the driver of offending vehicle Tata
Spacio was solely responsible for causing accident and that the
deceased died due to injuries sustained in the accident.
HCJ & CGR, J.
M.A.C.M.A. Nos.48 & 2724 of 2017
10.
Insofar as second issue was concerned, the Tribunal has
considered the age of deceased as 29 years based on Ex.A7
passport. The income came to be assessed as Rs.12,000/- per
month and after granting future prospects at the rate of 50% and after
deducting 1/3rd towards personal expenses, applying multiplier of 17,
has determined the compensation for loss of dependency.
The
Tribunal also awarded Rs.1,00,000/- towards loss of consortium;
Rs.25,000/- towards funeral expenses and Rs.10,000/- towards
transport charges, in total, awarded Rs.25,83,000/- along with
interest at the rate of 9% p.a. from the date of petition till payment.
11.
Aggrieved by the same, the Insurer had preferred M.A.C.M.A.
No.48 of 2017 questioning the liability aspect. The claimants have
also preferred M.A.C.M.A.No.2724 of 2017, dissatisfied with the
quantum of compensation so determined.
12.
Heard Mr.Srinivasa Rao Vutla, learned counsel for Insurer and
none appeared for claimants.
13.
The following points arise for our consideration:
“1. Whether the Tribunal was right in holding that there was no
contributory negligence on the part of the deceased and
thereby, fixing entire liability on the Insurer alone and whether
HCJ & CGR, J.
M.A.C.M.A. Nos.48 & 2724 of 2017
the Tribunal has awarded just and fair compensation to the
claimants in the light of the submissions advanced by the
learned counsel for the parties?
2. To what relief?”
14.
Learned counsel for the Insurer mainly contended that since
the accident had occurred because of head on collision by both
motorcycle as well as Tata Spacio, the Tribunal ought to have held
both drivers of respective vehicles were equally responsible, and
therefore, was a clear case of contributory negligence. Hence, the
Tribunal ought not to have fixed entire liability on the Insurer. Except
for aforesaid ground, no other ground has been urged.
15.
We have gone through the material on record. The occurrence
of accident on 18.04.2015 has not been disputed, however, the
manner in which accident has occurred is in issue. As per the
claimants version, the accident occurred because of rash and
negligent driving of driver of offending vehicle Tata Spacio, whereas,
as per the Insurer, both deceased and as well as driver of Tata Spacio
were equally responsible for occurrence of accident, as it was a head
on collision. Ex.A1 is certified copy of FIR, Ex.A2 is certified copy of
charge-sheet and Ex.A6 is altered FIR. In order to prove their claim,
the claimants have relied on Exs.A1, A2 and A6, which suggested that
HCJ & CGR, J.
M.A.C.M.A. Nos.48 & 2724 of 2017
the driver of offending vehicle Tata Spacio was responsible for the
accident, besides the same, evidence of PW.2, eyewitness to the
incident, also supported the case of claimants. Whereas, the Insurer
sought to rely on Ex.B2 certified copy of judgment in C.C.No.222 of
2015 on the file of Judicial Magistrate of First Class, Rajampet, by
which, the Court has acquitted the driver of offending Tata Spacio
vehicle.
16.
The Tribunal on appreciation of aforesaid evidence adduced on
either side, has come to conclusion that the accident had occurred
because of negligence of driver of offending Tata Spacio vehicle. The
Tribunal also held that merely because the criminal case ended in
acquittal on account of the main eyewitnesses, including PW.2 herein,
turning hostile, the same by itself would not be a valid ground to
disbelieve the evidence of PW.2 herein. We may also add here the
degree of proof required to be established in criminal case is that of
beyond reasonable doubt and whereas, in the present case, it only
requires to be tested on the touch stone of preponderance of
probabilities. We, therefore, do not see any infirmity in the reasoning
adopted by the Tribunal.
HCJ & CGR, J.
M.A.C.M.A. Nos.48 & 2724 of 2017
17.
It is also to be noted that in order to establish the contributory
negligence on the part of deceased, the only other material and
reliable witness was the driver of offending Tata Spacio vehicle, who
never came to be examined. Therefore, we do not find any substance
in the contention of the learned counsel for the Insurer to hold that
even the deceased was negligent and contributed to the accident. As
no other point has been argued by the Insurer, the appeal filed by the
Insurer deserves to be dismissed.
18.
In the appeal filed by the claimants, the claimants have mainly
urged two issues – firstly, that the income of deceased ought to have
been considered as Rs.25,000/- per month, as he worked as driver
at Kuwait for a considerable length of time and even possessed
licence issued by the Kuwait Government, and, secondly, that
considering the age of deceased as 29 years, proper multiplier of 19
ought to have been applied.
19.
The claimants have sought to rely on Ex.A9 driving licence
issued by Kuwait Government and Ex.A10 employment contract,
coupled with the evidence of PW.3, to contend that the deceased was
earning Rs.25,000/- per month at the time of accident. The Tribunal,
upon appreciation of evidence, has come to conclusion that even if
HCJ & CGR, J.
M.A.C.M.A. Nos.48 & 2724 of 2017
deceased worked as driver at Kuwait, at some point of time and had
contract to work in future, considering nature of work and the
remuneration as payable to driver within the country, income of
Rs.12,000/- per month would be reasonable. We really do not find
any infirmity with such reasoning requiring indulgence. Further, the
age of deceased since is not disputed, the proper multiplier would be
“17” in view of judgment of the Hon’ble Apex Court in Sarla Verma v.
Delhi Transport Corporation1. Therefore, both the grounds urged
by the claimants have no merit.
20.
Accordingly, both the appeals are dismissed confirming the
award, dated 08.08.2016, in M.V.O.P.No.315 of 2015, passed by the
Chairman, Motor Accident Claims Tribunal-cum-IV Additional District
Judge, Kadapa. No costs.
As a sequel, miscellaneous petitions pending consideration, if
any, in these appeals shall stand closed.
LISA GILL, CJ
CHALLA GUNARANJAN, J.
cs
(2009) 6 SCC 121
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review