The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
12. Once a competent civil court has declared the petitioner to be the legal heir of the deceased government servant and the said declaration continues to hold the field, the respondents are bound to accord due weight and effect to the same. In the absence of any material to show that the aforesaid judgment of discharge, has been stayed, set aside, or otherwise rendered inoperative by any competent court, and in the light of the judgment of the civil court, the respondents cannot ignore their legal effect or insist upon production of a marriage certificate as a condition precedent for processing the claim of the petitioner. Consequently, the claim of the petitioner for service and retiral benefits, as well as her claim for appointment on compassionate grounds, deserves to be considered on its own merits in accordance with the applicable rules and policy, without insisting upon the production of a marriage certificate.
13. Since the respondents have admittedly not yet considered the petitioner's claim for release of the service and retiral benefits accruing on account of the death of her husband, who died in harness, as well as her claim for appointment on compassionate grounds, this Court deems it appropriate to dispose of the present writ petition in the following terms :(a) The respondents are directed to consider the petitioner's claim for release of all admissible service and retiral benefits, including family pension and other consequential benefits, strictly in accordance with the applicable rules. (b) The respondents shall also consider the petitioner's claim for appointment on compassionate grounds in accordance with the policy governing the field, taking into consideration the decree issued by the civil court and without insisting upon the production of a marriage certificate, in view of the observations made hereinabove. (c) The aforesaid exercise shall be completed and appropriate orders shall be passed by the competent authority within a period of six weeks from the date of receipt of a copy of this judgment. Needless to observe, if any other document, not inconsistent with the observations made hereinabove and otherwise permissible under the applicable rules, is required for processing the petitioner's claims, the petitioner shall furnish the same and extend full cooperation to the …
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JAMMU & KASHMIR AND LADAKH
AT JAMMU
Case No: WP(C) No. 3122/2025
Reserved on: 07.07.2026
Pronounced on: 17.07.2026
Uploaded on:17.07.2026
Whether the operative part or full
Judgment is pronounced :Full
Neelam Devi, age 35 years
W/O Late Surinder Kumar
D/O Bachan Lal,
R/O Ghagwal, Tehsil Ghagwal,
District Samba.
..…Petitioner(s)…..
Through:
Mr. Jagpaul Singh, Advocate
v/s
1. Union of India through its Secretary,
Ministry of Home Affairs,
New Delhi.
2. Director General of Indo-Tibetan
Border Police (ITBP), Headquarters
Block-IV, CGO Complex, Lodhi
Road, New Delhi-110 003.
3. Deputy Inspector General, Shimla,
Indo
Tibetan
Border
Police
(ITBP).P.O. Taradevi,
Shimal H.P.-171 010.
…. Respondent(s)….
Through:
Mr. Vishal Sharma, DSG( (Sr. Adv.) with Mr.
Karan Sharma, CGSC
CORAM: HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE RAJNESH OSWAL, JUDGE.
JUDGMENT
1. The petitioner, claiming herself to be the legally wedded wife of late
Constable (GD) Surinder Kumar of the Indo-Tibetan Border Police
WP(C) No. 3122/2025
(ITBP), has filed the present writ petition seeking the following
reliefs :a. Mandamus commanding the respondents to release all the
service benefits in favour of the petitioner, accruing to her
on account of death of her husband who died in harness, as
respondents have miserably failed to release the same in
favour of the petitioner.
b. Mandamus commanding the respondents to appoint her on
compassionate grounds in respondent department, as she is
fully covered by the compassionate appointment policy of
the government.
c. Any other order or direction which this Hon’ble Court
deems fit and proper may kindly be issued in favour of the
petitioner and against the respondents.”
2. The case of the petitioner is that her marriage with late Surinder
Kumar was solemnized on 08.03.2019. Unfortunately, he died in
harness on 26.05.2019 after allegedly committing suicide by
consuming a poisonous substance. It is contended by the petitioner
that, following the death of her husband, she was blamed by his
family members for having abetted the commission of his suicide.
Consequently, FIR No. 0170 dated 20.09.2020 came to be
registered against her under Section 306 of the IPC in Police
Station, Rajbagh, Kathua. Upon completion of the investigation, a
challan was presented before the Court of the learned Principal
Sessions Judge, Kathua. It is further averred that, vide judgment
dated 26.04.2022, the learned Principal Sessions Judge, Kathua
discharged the petitioner, holding that the prosecution had
miserably failed to make out even a prima facie case of abetment of
suicide against her. It is further contended that the prosecution did
not assail the said judgment. However, the petitioner's mother-in-
WP(C) No. 3122/2025
law preferred revision petition being Crl. R No. 21/2022, titled
Kunti Devi v. Neelam Devi and another, before this Court,
challenging the said judgment. The revision petition came to be
dismissed vide judgment dated 18.04.2024.
3. It is submitted that, immediately after the demise of her husband,
the petitioner applied to the respondents for the release of family
pension and other retiral benefits. She also sought appointment on
compassionate grounds. However, the respondents failed to process
her claim on the ground that criminal proceedings arising out of the
FIR registered under Section 306 IPC were pending against her. It is
contended that the petitioner stands discharged of all the allegations
alleged against her and she apprised the respondents by filing a
representation that she stood exonerated by the Court of law and
requested them to settle the service benefits of her deceased
husband and to appoint her on compassionate grounds . The
petitioner also contends that she filed a suit before the Court of the
learned JMIC, Hiranagar, seeking a declaration that she is the legal
heir of the deceased Surinder Kumar. The said suit came to be
decreed in her favour vide judgment dated 01.09.2022, whereby she
was declared to be the legal heir of the deceased-Surinder Kumar. It
was further held that she is entitled to inherit his property and all
claims in accordance with her share under law.
4. The respondents, while resisting the writ petition, have pleaded in
their objections that the petitioner's name did not find mention in the
service records of the deceased employee. According to the
WP(C) No. 3122/2025
respondents, the petitioner was repeatedly requested to furnish a
valid marriage certificate, a succession certificate, and the final
decision in revision petition being Crl.R No. 21/2022. However, she
failed to furnish the requisite documents. Therefore, the respondents
contend that they cannot be held responsible for the nonconsideration of her case, as the same was occasioned by the
petitioner's failure to provide the requisite documents. It has further
been pleaded that in view of Rule 54(11-C) the CCS (Pension)
Rules, 1972, the claim for family pension could not be processed
during the pendency of the criminal proceedings.
5. Heard learned counsel for the parties and perused the record.
6. The petitioner seeks twofold relief: first, a direction to the
respondents to release all service and retiral benefits payable to her
following the death of her husband, who died in harness; and
second, a direction to the respondents for her appointment on
compassionate grounds, asserting her eligibility under the relevant
Government policy.
7. It would be apt to reproduce Rule 54(11-C) of the CCS (Pension)
Rules as under:“11-C (a) If a person, who in the event of death of a
Government servant while in service, is eligible to receive family
pension under this rule, is charged with the offence of murdering
the Government servant or for abetting in the commission of such
an offence, the claim of such a person, including other eligible
member or members of the family to receive the family pension,
shall remain suspended till the conclusion of the criminal
proceedings instituted against him.
(b) If on the conclusion of the criminal proceedings
referred to in clause (a), the person concerned –
WP(C) No. 3122/2025
(i) is convicted for the murder or abetting in the murder of the
Government servant, such a person shall be debarred from receiving the
family pension which shall be payable to other eligible member of the
family, from the date of death of the Government servant,
(ii) is acquitted of the charge of murder or abetting in the murder of
the Government servant, the family pension shall be payable to such a
person from the date of death of the Government servant.
8. The aforesaid rules provides that where a person otherwise entitled
to family pension is charged with the offence of murdering the
Government servant or abetting such offence, payment of family
pension shall remain suspended till the conclusion of the criminal
proceedings. The Rule itself, however, further provides that where
such person is acquitted, family pension shall become payable from
the date of death of the Government servant. The embargo
contemplated under Rule 54(11-C) of CCS Pension Rules,
therefore, is not permanent but only temporary and continues only
till the criminal proceedings attain finality. In the present case, it is
not disputed before this Court that the petitioner was discharged by
the learned Principal Sessions Judge, Kathua vide judgment dated
26.04.2022 and that the said acquittal has been affirmed by the coordinate Bench of Court vide judgment dated 18.04.2024.
Consequently, the statutory embargo contained in Rule 54(11-C)
ceased to operate from the date the acquittal attained finality.
9. The respondents, in their response, have submitted that the
petitioner was requested to furnish a valid marriage certificate, a
succession certificate duly issued by the competent court of law,
and a copy of the final decision rendered in revision petition being
Crl. R No. 21/2022. However, according to the respondents, the
petitioner has failed to furnish the said documents.
WP(C) No. 3122/2025
10.It appears from the record that the petitioner has placed on record a
copy of the death certificate, the marriage card, the judgment dated
26.04.2022 passed by the learned Principal Sessions Judge, Kathua
in Case No. 59/2021, titled UT of J&K through Police Station,
Rajbagh v. Neelam Devi, the judgment dated 18.04.2024 passed in
Crl.R No. 21/2022, whereby the revision petition preferred by the
petitioner's mother-in-law was dismissed by a co-ordinate Bench of
this Court and the judgment and decree dated 01.09.2022 passed by
the Court of learned Munsiff/JMIC, Hiranagar, whereby the
petitioner was declared to be the legal heir of deceased Surinder
Kumar, son of Bishan Dass, resident of Chann Ranga, Tehsil
Hiranagar and was also held entitled to inherit his estate and other
lawful claims in accordance with her share under law.
11.Although the respondents have insisted upon the production of a
marriage certificate, the record reveals that the petitioner was
prosecuted for the alleged commission of an offence under Section
306 IPC on the accusation that she had abetted the suicide of her
husband, Surinder Kumar. However, she was discharged by the
learned Principal Sessions Judge, Kathua, vide judgment dated
26.04.2022, and the said order of discharge was upheld by a
Coordinate Bench of this Court vide judgment dated 18.04.2024.
Moreover, the petitioner has been declared to be the legal heir of the
deceased government servant by a competent civil court. In these
circumstances, the respondents cannot insist upon the production of
a marriage certificate as a precondition for considering her claim.
WP(C) No. 3122/2025
12.Once a competent civil court has declared the petitioner to be the
legal heir of the deceased government servant and the said
declaration continues to hold the field, the respondents are bound to
accord due weight and effect to the same. In the absence of any
material to show that the aforesaid judgment of discharge, has been
stayed, set aside, or otherwise rendered inoperative by any
competent court, and in the light of the judgment of the civil court,
the respondents cannot ignore their legal effect or insist upon
production of a marriage certificate as a condition precedent for
processing the claim of the petitioner. Consequently, the claim of
the petitioner for service and retiral benefits, as well as her claim for
appointment on compassionate grounds, deserves to be considered
on its own merits in accordance with the applicable rules and policy,
without insisting upon the production of a marriage certificate.
13.Since the respondents have admittedly not yet considered the
petitioner's claim for release of the service and retiral benefits
accruing on account of the death of her husband, who died in
harness, as well as her claim for appointment on compassionate
grounds, this Court deems it appropriate to dispose of the present
writ petition in the following terms :(a)
The respondents are directed to consider the petitioner's claim
for release of all admissible service and retiral benefits,
including family pension and other consequential benefits,
strictly in accordance with the applicable rules.
WP(C) No. 3122/2025
(b)
The respondents shall also consider the petitioner's claim for
appointment on compassionate grounds in accordance with
the policy governing the field, taking into consideration the
decree issued by the civil court and without insisting upon the
production of a marriage certificate, in view of the
observations made hereinabove.
(c)
The aforesaid exercise shall be completed and appropriate
orders shall be passed by the competent authority within a
period of six weeks from the date of receipt of a copy of this
judgment. Needless to observe, if any other document, not
inconsistent with the observations made hereinabove and
otherwise permissible under the applicable rules, is required
for processing the petitioner's claims, the petitioner shall
furnish the same and extend full cooperation to the
respondents. The decision so taken shall be communicated to
the petitioner forthwith.
14.The writ petition stands disposed of in the above terms along with
all connected applications.
(Rajnesh Oswal)
Judge
Jammu
17.07.2026
Madan Verma-Secy
Whether order is speaking? Yes.
Whether order is reportable? No.
WP(C) No. 3122/2025
MADAN LAL VERMA
2026.07.17 13:22
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this document
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review