The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
10. For the aforesaid reasons, instant application is found without any merits and is accordingly dismissed, as a consequence whereof, accompanying Mac App No.08/2023 as well shall stand dismissed along with connected CMs.
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
S. No. 27
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JAMMU & KASHMIR AND LADAKH
AT SRINAGAR
CM No.1422/2023 in Mac App No.08/2023
Date of Pronouncement: 02.02.2026
Uploaded on:13.02.2026
…Petitioner/Appellant(s)
NAZIR AHMAD BHAT
Through: Mr. Sami Lone, Advocate vice
Mr. Syed Sajad Geelani, Advocate.
Vs.
BAJAJ ALLIANZ INSURANCE COMPANY LTD & ...Respondent(s)
ANR.
Through: Mr. Sheikh Manzoor, Advocate for R 2
Mr. Imtiyaz Ahmad, Advocate with
Ms. Bushra, Advocate for R 1
CORAM:
HON’BLE MR JUSTICE JAVED IQBAL WANI, JUDGE
O R D E R (ORAL)
02.02.2026
CM No.1422/2023
1.
Through
the
medium
of
instant
application
filed
by
the
appellant/applicant herein, condonation of 837 days is being sought for filing
the appeal against the award dated 31.08.2020 (for short ‘the impugned
award’) passed by the Motor Accident Claims Tribunal, Kupwara, (for short
‘the Tribunal’) in claim petition titled as “Mohammad Amin Mir Vs. Bajaj
Allianz General Insurance company and Ors.,”
2.
Facts emerging from the record would reveal that the respondent/non-
applicant 1 herein had maintained the aforesaid claim petition before the
Tribunal seeking compensation therein for the death of one Yaser Amin Mir
S/o respondent 2 herein caused in the vehicular accident on 18.03.2011 by
vehicle bearing No. JK09-3645 (TATA SUMO). In the said claim petition,
the claimant respondent 2 have had impleaded the Insurance Company
respondent/non-applicant 1 herein as respondent, as also the owner and
driver of the said offending vehicle as respondents 2 and 3. The aforesaid
respondent 3 therein the claim petition being the appellant/applicant herein
and also the respondent/non-applicant 1 herein contested the claim petition
after filing objections thereto, whereafter the Tribunal framed issues on the
pleadings of the parties, in furtherance whereof the Tribunal passed the
award holding the claimant/non-applicant 2 herein entitled to the
compensation of Rs.5,95,000/- along with interest @ 7.5% payable jointly
and severally by the owner and driver of the offending vehicle providing
further that in the event of failure to pay the said amount of compensation
along with interest within the stipulated period, the amount of interest had to
be paid @ 9%.
3.
The appellant/applicant 1 herein being both the owner and driver of
the offending vehicle while maintaining the instant application has sought
condonation of delay as the following grounds: a) That the Id. tribunal has passed the impugned award as against the facts and
law and without application of judicial mind hence the same is liable to be set
aside.
b) That the Ld. tribunal has erred in passing the impugned award against the
appellant on the ground that the offending vehicle at the relevant time was
driven by Appellant without having effective and valid license in breach of the
terms of the Insurance policy on the date of accident. The matter of fact is that
the Appellant at the time of accident was having the Valid and effective license
bearing No: 1207/R/08 issued on 15.04.2008 by ARTO. Rajouri and renewed
from time to time by the competent authority like ARTO Sopore for plying
Medium Goods Vehicle and Medium Passenger Motor Vehicle. So the
offending vehicle bearing registration No. JK09-3645 was plying with proper
documents and also the driver of the vehicle was having the valid and
effective license on the date of accident.
c) That the Ld. Tribunal has examined the witness namely Subash Chander
(Junior Assistant ARTO Rajouri) produced by the Respondent No.1 and in his
statement the witness has deposed that the Licenses No: 1207/ARTOR/08
dated 28.06.2008 is in the name of Swarn Singh and is valid for LMV/Scooter
and has stated that the license is not in the name of the Nazir Ahmad Bhat
(Appellant) and on his cross examination by the counsel of the Appellant the
witness has deposed that there is a separate record for issuance of license
and further that there is a separate record for LMV, PSV and HV and he has
come in the court along with the record maintained for issuance of license
which pertains to LMV only and he has further deposed that the license which
he has seen today relates to MPMV and MGV and he was not asked for the
production of the said record. That despite the statement of the witness that
there is a separate record for MPMV and MGV and he has only verified the
licenses Issued for LMV under the aforementioned registration number and
not the License of the Appellant issued for MPMV and MGV and without
examining the record of the MPMV and MGV license the Ld. Tribunal has
passed the impugned award in violation of the facts of the case and in
contradiction to the evidence on record as such the Impugned award deserves
to be set aside by this Hon'ble Court.
d) That the alleged accident in which the driver of the offending vehicle hit the
deceased namely Yaser Amin Wani resulting the death of him. The fact that
the offending vehicle was insured on the date of the accident and the driver
was having the valid and effective license was brought into the notice of the
Ld. tribunal by appellant in its written statement to the claim petition That
despite specific pleadings of the appellant and its arguments in support of the
said pleadings and in view of the established legal position that the
adjudicating tribunal has to analyze evidence and pleading to ascertain
whether the vehicle owner was aware that the driving license of the driver was
fake, before absolving the liability of the insurer. The said position was settled
by the Hon'ble Apex Court in case titled Ram Chandra Singh vs. Rajaram &
ors., Civil Appeal No. 8145 of 2018 decided on 14.08.2018 and the Ld.
Tribunal without analysing the said fact and without any evidence and enquiry
in the matter has declared the license of the Driver as ineffective as such the
award impugned is bad in law as such deserves to be set aside by this
Hon'ble Court.
e) That the Appellant has the license in his possession issued by the competent
authority in the year 2008 and the license was also renewed from time to time
by the officers of the transport department and the Appellant has not an iota of
doubt that the license is fake or not genuine as he has been engaged as driver
for plying vehicles on the basis of the said license and no where he was
confronted the issue that such license is not genuine even during its renewal
before various competent authorities of the state and for that purpose he
produced the said license before the Tribunal and the Ld. Tribunal has erred in
law by holding the license of the Appellant as not genuine without calling for
the record of the MPMV and MGV licenses issued by the department and
without providing the opportunity of being heard to the Appellate during
COVID-19 Period when the access to courts was restricted and in the
particular facts of the case the Hon'ble Apex Court in case titled NIRMALA
KOTHARI VERSUS UNITED INDIA INSURANCE CO. LTD. (CIVIL APPEAL
NOS. 1999-2000 OF 2020 (ARISING OUT OF SPECIAL LEAVE PETITION
(C) NOS. 14739-14740 OF 2018) has held as under:
"While hiring a driver the employer is expected to verify if the driver has a
driving licence. If the driver produces a licence which on the face of it
looks genuine, the employer is not expected to further investigate into the
authenticity of the licence unless there is cause to believe otherwise. If the
employer finds the driver to be competent to drive the vehicle and has
satisfied himself that the driver has a driving licence there would be no
breach of Section 149(2)(a)(ii) and the Insurance Company would be
liable under the policy. It would be unreasonable to place such a high
onus on the insured to make enquiries with RTOs all over the country to
ascertain the veracity of the driving licence. However, if the Insurance
Company is able to prove that the owner/insured was aware or had notice
that the licence was fake or invalid and still permitted the person to drive,
the insurance company would no longer continue to be liable. 12. On
facts, in the instant case, the Appellant/Complainant had employed the
Driver, Dharmendra Singh as driver after checking his driving licence. The
driving licence was purported to have been issued by the licencing
authority, Sheikh Sarai, Delhi, however, the same could not be verified as
the concerned officer of the licencing authority deposed that the record of
the licence was not available with them. It is not the 10 contention of the
Respondent/ Insurance Company that the Appellant/complainant is guilty
of willful negligence while employing the driver. The driver had been
driving competently and there for the Appellant/Complainant to doubt the
veracity of the driver's licence. In view of above facts and circumstances,
the impugned judgment is not liable to be sustained and is hereby set
aside. The appeals accordingly stand allowed. The respondent/ Insurance
Company is held liable to indemnify the appellant....
f) That it is a settled position of law that Insurance Company cannot be permitted
to avoid its liability on the ground that the person driving the vehicle at the time
of the accident was not duly licenced as held by the Hon'ble Apex Court in the
case of United India Insurance Co. Ltd. vs. Lehru & Ors. in which a two Judge
Bench of the court has taken the view that the Insurance Company cannot be
permitted to avoid its liability on the ground that the person driving the vehicle
at the time of the accident was not duly licenced. It was further held that the
willful breach of the conditions of the policy should be established. The law
with this respect has been discussed in detail in the case of Pepsu RTC vs.
National Insurance Co. (SCC pp. 223-24, para10) 1 (2003) 3 SCC 338: the
relevant paragraph from the Judgment: is reproduced herein
"In a claim for compensation, it is certainly open to the insurer under
Section 149(2)(a)(ii) to take a defence that the driver of the vehicle
involved in the accident was not duly licensed. Once such a defence is
taken, the onus is on the insurer. But even after it is proved that the
licence possessed by the driver was a fake one, whether there is liability
on the insurer is the moot question. As far as the owner of the vehicle is
concerned, when he hires a driver, he has to check whether the driver has
a valid driving licence. Thereafter he has to satisfy himself as to the
competence of the driver. If satisfied in that regard also, it can be said that
the owner had taken reasonable care in employing a person who is
qualified and competent to drive the vehicle. The owner cannot be
expected to go beyond that, to the extent of verifying the genuineness of
the driving licence with the licensing authority before hiring the services of
the driver. However, the situation would be different if at the time of
insurance of the vehicle or thereafter the insurance company requires the
owner of the vehicle to have the licence duly verified from the licensing
authority or if the attention of the owner of the vehicle is otherwise invited
to the allegation that the licence issued to the driver employed by him is a
fake one and yet the owner does not take appropriate action for
verification of the matter regarding the genuineness of the licence from the
licensing authority. That is what is explained in Swaran Singh's case
(supra). If despite such information with the owner that the licence
possessed by his driver is fake, no action is taken by the insured for
appropriate verification, then the insured will be at fault and, in such
circumstances, the insurance company is not liable for the compensation."
It has been further held in the case of National Insurance Co. Ltd. vs.
Swaran Singh & Ors.3 (SCC pp.341, para 110) that, "110. (iii)... Mere
absence, fake or invalid driving licence or disqualification of the driver for
driving at the relevant time, are not in themselves defences available to
the insurer against either the insured or the third parties. To avoid its
liability towards the insured, the insurer has to prove that the insured was
guilty of negligence and failed to exercise reasonable care in the matter of
fulfilling the condition of the policy regarding use of vehicles by a duly
licenced driver or one who was not disqualified to drive at the relevant
time."
That the Ld. Tribunal has not given any consideration to the pleadings and
the arguments of the appellant and the precedents set by the Apec court
and passed the impugned award against settled principles of law as such
needs to be set aside by this Hon'ble Court.
g) That primarily it is liability of the insurer of offending vehicle respondent no.1
under the provisions of Motor Vehicle Act to pay the compensation to the
victims of the accident caused by vehicle and in case insurance company
established that offending vehicle was plying in breach of the terms of
insurance policy, in that event insurer can seek indemnification of the liability
from owner. As the offending vehicle was insured on the date of the accident,
so insurance company is liable to pay the claimant at the first instance, but the
Ld. tribunal has failed to appreciate the provisions of law and the guidelines
laid down by the Apex Court in passing the impugned award which merits to
be set aside against the appellant.
4.
Objections to the application have been filed by respondent/non-
applicant 1 herein wherein the application is being opposed on the premise
that the delay sought to be condoned by the appellant/applicant herein has
not been explained so much so, no sufficient cause as well has been
expressed in the application.
Heard counsel for the parties and perused the record.
5.
Perusal of the aforesaid grounds urged by the appellant/applicant
herein in the instant application reveals that the fundamental ground for
seeking condonation of delay is that the appellant/applicant herein came to
know about the award only in the month of February 2023 upon receiving
notice from the Tribunal qua the execution of the award whereafter an
application is stated to have been filed for obtaining the certified copy of the
award and furnished on 07.02.2023 as the award had been passed during
COVID-19 period and that the counsel who had been engaged by the
appellant/applicant herein for contesting the claim petition did not inform
the appellant/applicant herein about the passing of the award and that as
such there has been no deliberate delay caused by the appellant/applicant
herein in maintaining the application.
6.
Perusal of record available on the file in general and impugned award
would manifestly tend to show that indeed the appellant/applicant herein had
engaged the counsel before the Tribunal in contesting the claim petition,
however, no material worth the name has been produced or placed on record
by the appellant/applicant herein in support of the plea that the counsel did
not inform the appellant/applicant herein about the passing of the award. The
aforesaid plea thus, under these circumstances, cannot but be said to be
vague, ambiguous inasmuch as a figment of imagination.
7.
Insofar as the law of limitation is concerned, it is settled position that
the decisive factor in condonation of delay is not the length of delay but
sufficiency of satisfactory explanation. It is equally beaten position of law,
that law of limitation may harshly affect a particular period but it has to be
applied with all its rigor when the statute so prescribes and the Courts have
no power to extend the period of limitation on equitable grounds and the
discretion vested in the Court in extending the period of limitation has to be
exercised in a proper and judicious manner.
8.
It is also significant to mention here that an appeal filed under Motor
Vehicles Act against an award of the Tribunal is aimed at providing a cheap
and speedy remedy and that justice oriented approach has to be adopted by
the Courts in such matters only if the Court is of the view that appeal has
been filed within a reasonable period of time without taking a lenient
approach against the person who seeks extension of time /condonation of
delay who has been casual or non-diligent in the matter.
9.
As has been noticed in the preceding paras, the grounds/pleas urged
by the appellant/applicant herein for seeking condonation of delay on a plain
reading are cryptic besides being vague and ambiguous thus, not warranting
indulgence and in exercise of discretion by this Court.
10.
For the aforesaid reasons, instant application is found without any
merits and is accordingly dismissed, as a consequence whereof,
accompanying Mac App No.08/2023 as well shall stand dismissed along
with connected CMs.
(JAVED IQBAL WANI)
JUDGE
SRINAGAR
02.02.2026
Ishaq
Whether the order is speaking ?
Yes/No
Whether approved for reporting ?
Yes/No
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review