Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
2026:CGHC:3143
NAFR
HIGH COURT OF CHHATTISGARH AT BILASPUR
WPS No. 5914 of 2023
Dhanlal Kurre S/o Ishwar Kurre, Aged 45 Years, R/o Village - Bhainsamuda,
Patwai Halka Number - 09, Tahsil - Navagarh, District - Bemetara (C.G.)
--- Petitioner(s)
versus
1 - Naveen Kumar Kurre S/o Roop Kumar Kurre R/o Village Bhainsamuda,
Patwari Halka Number - 09, Tahsil - Navagarh, District - Bemetara (C.G.)
2 - State Of Chhattisgarh Through Secretary Department Of Revenue and
Disaster Management, Mantralaya, Mahanadi Bhawan, Nawa Raipur Atal
Nagar, Raipur (C.G.)
3- Commissioner Durg Division, Durg, District - Durg (C.G.)
4-Collector Bemetara, District - Bemetara (C.G.)
5 - Sub-Divisional Officer (R) Navagarh, Tahsil - Navagarh, District Bemetara
(C.G.)
6 - Tahsildar Navagarh, Tahsil - Navagarh, District - Bemetara (C.G.)
Digitally signed
by SHYNA AJAY
cn=SHYNA
SHYNA DN:
AJAY,
o=PERSONAL,
AJAY
st=Chhattisgarh,
c=IN
--- Respondent(s)
WPS No. 8704 of 2023
Naveen Kumar Kurre S/o Roop Kumar Kurre, Aged About 24 Years R/o
Village Bhaisamuda, P.H. No. 9, Tahsil Nawagarh, District Bemetara (C.G.)
---Petitioner(s)
Versus
1 - The Board Of Revenue Bilaspur, Circuit Court, Raipur (C.G.)
2 - Commissioner Durg Division District Durg (C.G.)
3 - Sub Divisional Officer (R) Nawagarh, District Bemetara (C.G.)
4 - Tahsildar / Naib Tahsildar Nawagarh District Bemetara (C.G.)
5 - Dhan Lal Kurre S/o Ishwar Kurre Aged About 26 Years R/o Village
Bhaisamuda, P.H. No. 9, Tahsil Nawagarh, District Bemetara (C.G.)
--- Respondent(s)
For Petitioner/
Respondent-Dhanlal :
Kurre
Ms. Anu Mishra, Advocate on behalf of Mr. Malay
Shrivastava, Advocate
For Petitioner/
Respondent –
Naveen
Kumar Kurre
Mr. Bharat Rajput, Advocate
For Respondent/
:
Ms. Vartika Shrivastava, Panel Lawyer
State
SB: Hon’ble Mr. Justice Amitendra Kishore Prasad
Order on Board
19/01/2026
1. Since the issues raised in both these captioned petitions are the same
and the impugned order dated 26.7.2023 passed by the Chhattisgarh
Board of Revenue, Bilaspur, Circuit Court, Raipur, also being the
same, they are taken up analogously for hearing and are being
disposed of by this common order.
2. By the impugned order 26.7.2023, the Board of Revenue has
set-
aside/quashed the order dated 10.8.2021 passed by the Tehsildar;
Navagarh; the order dated 8.11.2021 passed by SDO (R), Navagarh,
District
Bemetara;
and
the
order
15.3.2022
passed
by
the
Commissioner, Durg Division. Further, the Tehsildar, Nawagarh has
been directed to initiate fresh proceedings for appointment to the post
of Kotwar from amongst eligible candidates and after following the due
process of law, appoint a new Kotwar. In both the present petitions, the
respective petitioners have challenged the aforesaid order. While
seeking to set-aside the order dated 26.7.2023, they have further
prayed for consequential relief in their favour.
3. The facts germane for disposal of these petitions are that the father of
Dhanlal Kurre and grandfather of petitioner - Naveen Kumar Kurre
namely Ishwar Das was Kotwar of Village Bhainsamuda. Owing to his
advanced age and ill health, he was unable to perform his duties and
as such, moved an application tendering his resignation for
consideration by the authority.
As Naveen Kumar Kurre (grandson)
had gained some experience in discharging duties of a Kotwar by
working alongside his grandfather, he filed an application for
appointment to the post of Kotwar under Section 230 of the CG Land
Revenue Code, 1959 (in short “the Code”) before the Tehsildar,
Navagarh. The Tehsildar invited objections and a Character Certificate
in respect of Naveen Kumar Kurre was also obtained from the Police
Station Nawagarh. Subsequently, petitioner -Dhanlal Kurre, son of ex.Kotwar Ishwar Das, also moved an application for appointment as
Kotwar, asserting his claim as the son of ex.-Kotwar. The applications
moved by both the parties i.e. the son and grandson of late Ishwar Das
were considered and the Tehsildar passed an order dated 10.8.2021 in
favour of Dhanlal Kurre, son of ex.-Kotwar for appointment to the post
of Kotwar. Ultimately, petitioner -Dhanlal Kurre was appointed as the
Permanent Kotwar in accordance with Section 230 of the Code. He
was further granted the service land previously held by ex.-Kotwar Ishwar Das along with other prescribed remuneration. Aggrieved by
the aforesaid order 10.8.2021, petitioner- Naveen Kumar Kurre,
grandson of the ex-Kotwar, preferred an appeal before the concerned
SDO stating that the appointment of petitioner- Dhanlal Kurre was not
in accordance with law. Petitioner -Naveen Kumar Kurre contended
that
he
possessed
relevant
experience,
having
assisted
grandfather (Ishwar Das) in discharging the duties of Kotwar.
his
Upon
consideration of the record, the concerned SDO observed that the
Gram Panchayat had passed a resolution in favour of Naveen Kumar
Kurre. Furthermore, the concerned SHO had issued a Character
Certificate confirming that he had no criminal antecedents. Conversely,
no such verification or character certificate was available on record in
respect of petitioner – Dhanlal Kurre. Furthermore, Naveen Kumar
Kurre has studied up to Class VIII whereas Dhanlal Kurre has passed
only V standard. Upon finding that the Tehsildar has committed an
error of law in the appointment process, the SDO allowed the appeal
vide order dated 8.11.2021. Consequently, the concerned SDO setaside the order dated 10.8.2021 passed by the Tehsildar and held that
Naveen Kumar Kurre was the more suitable candidate for the post of
Kotwar. Aggrieved by the said order of the SDO, petitioner Dhanlal
Kurre (son of ex-Kotwar) preferred an appeal under Section 44(2) of
the Code before the Commissioner, Durg Division, Durg, stating that
the order dated 8.11.2021 passed by the concerned SDO is not in
accordance with law. He contended that as the son of Ex- Kotwar, he
(Dhanlal Kurre) is the primary heir and that preference should have
been given to him over grandson- Naveen Kumar Kurre, who should
not have been considered for appointment. It was further stated that
although a character certificate had not been requisitioned for him, his
maturity and experience at 45 years of age far outweighed that of 24
year old grandson i.e. Naveen Kumar Kurre. Petitioner - Dhanlal Kurre
(son) maintained that the Tehsilder had correctly exercised its
discretion by appointing him, who possessed the requisite experience,
over the grandson.
The concerned Commissioner, after considering
the entire aspects of the matter, observed that in the appointment of a
Kotwar, primary preference must be accorded to the son of ex-Kotwar.
Consequently, the Commissioner held that the Naib Tehsidar,
Navagarh has correctly passed the order dated 10.8.2021 in favour of
Dhanlal Kurre, son of Ex-Kotwar, finding no illegality or infirmity
warranting interference. The Commissioner further observed that the
order dated 8.11.2021 passed by the concerned Sub Division Officer
(R) is not a speaking order and was, therefore, not legally sustainable.
Accordingly, while setting aside the order of the concerned SDO( R ),
the Commissioner, vide order dated 15.3.2022,
restored and
confirmed the order dated 10.8.2021 passed by the concerned
Tehsildar in favour of Dhanlal Kurre, son of ex-Kotwar. Against the
said order dated 15.3.2022 passed by the Commissioner, Durg
Division, petitioner- Naveen Kumar Kurre preferred a Revenue
Revision. Upon considering the Revision Petition filed by petitioner
Naveen Kumar Kurre, the Board of Revenue concluded that for the
appointment of a Kotwar, the proposal issued by the Gram Panchayat
must be duly examined before an eligible candidate is appointed as
Kotwar. Pursuant to Rule 4(2) (1) of the Kotwari Rules, preference
shall be given to the near legal heirs; however, such preference is only
applicable when all other qualifications are equal. In the present
matter, son and grand son of ex-Kotwar are aspirants. Consequently,
the Commissioner should have directed the concerned Tehsildar to
complete the entire appointment process and pass a fresh order
strictly in accordance with law. It was further observed that while a
proposal was sought for one candidate; no such proposal was
obtained for the other due to Covid-19 pandemic. Since the
applications of both the parties must be considered on their respective
merits, the Tehsildar was directed to reconsider the rival claims in
accordance with law. Upon completion of the entire process as per the
prescribed procedure and after providing both the parties an
opportunity to be heard, the Tehsildar was further directed to pass a
fresh order regarding the appointment of Kotwar.
4. Learned counsel for the petitioners submit that both the parties hold
respective orders in their favour. Learned counsel for petitionerDhanlal Kurre submits that the Tehsildar, Navagarh as well as the
Commissioner have passed orders in his favour, holding that the
appointment process is in accordance with law and the son of exKotwar must be granted preference over the grandson. Furthermore,
in light of his age, experience and other supporting materials, it was
held that Dhanlal Kurre is the most suitable candidate for the subject
post. Accordingly, the Naib Tehsildar rightly appointed Dhanlal Kurre as
Kotwar, whereas, the order passed by the SDO (R) in favour of
Naveen Kumar Kurre (grandson) is not in accordance with law. He
further submits that instead of passing an order in favour of either
party, the Board of Revenue sought to balance the respective claims
by remanding the matter to the concerned Tehsildar. Further, the
Board directed a re-examination of the case and issuance of a fresh,
appropriate order after evaluating the merits and the specific
favourable factors available to each aspirant.
5. Similarly, learned counsel for petitioner -Naveen Kumar Kurre, who
has filed WPS No.8704/2023, submits that the SDO has passed a
well-reasoned order in favour of the petitioner. He submits that the
order dated 8.11.2021 passed by the concerned SDO, which set-aside
the order dated 10.8.2021 passed by the Tehsildar in respect of
appointment of Dhanlal Kurre, should have been upheld. However, the
Commissioner has not considered
all these grounds and instead
confirmed the order passed by the Tehsildar. He further submits that
the Board of Revenue, rather than passing an order on merits in favour
of either party, remanded the matter to the concerned Tehsildar. He
lastly submits that the concerned authority ignored the relevant
documents and the proposal submitted in favour of grandson (Naveen
Kumar Kurre) and illegally appointed petitioner Dhanlal Kurre, solely
on the basis of preference.
6. I have heard learned counsel for the parties and also perused the
documents annexed with the petition with utmost circumspection.
7. For the sake of brevity, Section 230 of the Code is reproduced below :
230. Appointment of kotwars and their duties.(1) For each village or group of villages, there shall be
appointed, in accordance with rules made under Section
258, one or more kotwars for the performance of such
duties as may be prescribed :
Provided that in the Madhya Bharat region the duties of
kotwars under this section shall be performed by the
Police Chowkidars who shall, on the coming into force of
this Code, be deemed to be kotwars under this section,
and be subject in all respects to the control of Revenue
Officers.
(2) Every person who at the coming into force of this
Code holds the post of a village watchman in the Bhopal
and Sironj regions or of a chowkidar in the Vindhya
Pradesh region shall be deemed to be a kotwar under this
section.
8. From a bare perusal of the record, it is quite vivid that both the parties
are near relatives; petitioner- Dhanlal Kurre is the son of Ex-Kotwar,
while petitioner -Naveen Kumare Kurre is the grandson. For the
appointment of Kotwar, the preference is general accorded to the son
of ex-Kotwar. In the present case, Dhanlal Kurre, son of ex-Kotwar is a
middle aged man about 45 years, whereas the grandson is aged about
24 years. Regarding educational qualifications, Dhanlal Kurre (son)
has passed V standard, whereas, Naveen Kumar Kurre (grandson)
has passed VIII standard. Upon reviewing the applications, the
concerned Naib Tehsildar evaluated the merits of the case and after
considering the entire aspect of the matter, issued an order in favour of
Dhanlal Kurre. In making the appointment, the Tehsildar held that the
son possessed a preferential right as the direct descendant of exKotwar and consequently, rejected the grandson’s application after due
consideration.
9. So far as the relation of the parties is concerned, in the absence of a
son, the preferential right would naturally shift to the grandson. When
the son is available, the grandson can only be given preference if the
son is found inelligible for the appointment of Kotwar. There is nothing
on record to show any disqualifying factor against Dhanlal Kurre (son),
which would debar him from being appointed as Kotwar.
10. The role of a Kotwar is more of a community service than a strictly
official duty.
In a village setting, the Kotwar is responsible for
identifying residents and maintaining records for each household,
which is a task often better suited to the old generation due to their
deep rooted knowledge of the community, as compared to younger
individual such as a grandson. Furthermore, sons hold a preferential
right to the post previously held by their father. As there are no adverse
remarks on record against Dhanlal Kurre, son of ex-Kotwar, the
Tehsildar and the Commissioner correctly evaluated the merits of the
case in great detail. Consequently, the Commissioner has rightly
upheld the order passed by the Tehsildar.
11. For the foregoing, I am the view that the present case squarely falls
within the supervisory jurisdiction of this Court under Article 227 of
the Constitution of India. Unless grave misconduct is evident in the
appointment of a Kotwar, the order cannot be challenged on cursory or
superficial grounds asserting that a grandson should be appointed
over a son. When competing rights are concerned, experience is a
primary consideration.
In the opinion of this Court, the son in the
present case possesses greater experience than the grandson.
Therefore, the Tehsildar rightly exercised his power under Section 230
of the Code and passed the order dated 10.8.2021, which was further
confirmed by the detailed order dated 15.3.2022 passed by the
Commissioner.
12. Moreover, the Board of Revenue ought to have decided the case on
merits in favour of either party. Instead, the Board of Revenue
remanded the matter to the concerned Tehsildar, effectively opening
the door for further unnecessary litigation, which this Court deems
unwarranted.
13. Consequently, while dismissing the petition filed by Naveen Kumar
Kurre i.e. WPS No.8704/2023, the petition filed by Dhanlal Kurre i.e.
WPS No.5914/2023 is hereby allowed. The order
dated 10.8.2021
passed by the Naib Tehsildar, Navagarah in favour Dhanlal Kurre,
which was subsequently confirmed by the Commissioner, Durg
Division, Durg, vide order dated 15.3.2022, is hereby restored.
14. In view of the above, the impugned order dated 26.7.2023 passed by
the Chhattisgarh Board of Revenue, Circuit Court, Raipur and the
order dated 08.11.2021 passed by the SDO (R), Navagarh, District
Bemetara (CG) are hereby quashed.
15. Resultantly, WPS No.5914/2023 is allowed and WPS No.8704/2023 is
dismissed.
Sd/(Amitendra Kishore Prasad)
Judge
Shyna Ajay
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review