Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
AGARTALA
MAC App. No.81 of 2024
1.
Smt. Smriti Deb
W/O Shri Badal Deb,
Of Ranjit Nagar,
P.O-Ram Nagar, P.S.-West Agartala,
Agartala, West Tripura District.
2.
Shri Badal Deb,
S/O Lt. Bhanu Deb,
Of Ranjit Nagar,
P.O-Ram Nagar, P.S.-West Agartala,
Agartala, West Tripura District.
------ Appellants
Versus
1.
Sri Sagar Das
S/O Shri Subal Das,
Of Capital Complex,
Qtr. No.II/A, P.O. Kunjaban,
P.S.-N.C.C., Agartala, Tripura(W).
M-9862580100.
(Owner of vehicle No.TR01-U-5504,
(Motorcycle, Hunk).
2.
The Branch Manager,
National Insurance Company Ltd.,
Agartala, Division, Akhaura Road,
Agartala, Tripura (W), 799001.
(Insurer of vehicle No.TR01-U-5504),
(Motorcycle, Hunk).
3.
Shri Sujan Das,
S/O Shri Subal Das,
Of Capital Complex,
Qtr. No.II/A, P.O. Kunjaban,
P.S.-N.C.C., Agartala, Tripura (W)
(Rider of vehicle No.TR01-U-5504, (Motorcycle, Hunk)
------ Respondents
along with
MAC App. No.82 of 2024
National Insurance Company Ltd.
Represented by its Divisional Manager (In Charge),
Agartala Division, 42-Akhaura Road,
P.O: H.P.O. Agartala, P.S: West Agartala,
Dist: West Tripura, Pin: 799001.
(Insurer of the motor cycle Bearing Registration No.TR-01-U-5504)
------ Appellant
Versus
1. Smt. Smriti Deb
W/O Shri Badal Deb,
Of Ranjitnagar,
P.S.-West Agartala,
Dist: West Tripura. Pin: 799001.
------ Claimant/Respondent No.1.
2. Shri Badal Deb,
S/O Lt. Bhanu Deb,
Of Ranjitnagar,
P.S.-West Tripura,
Dist: West Tripura. Pin: 799001.
------ Claimant/Respondent No.2.
3. Sri Sagar Das,
S/O Sri Subal Das
Of Capital Complex, Quarter No: II/A, P.O: Kunjaban,
P.S: NCC, Dist: West Tripura, Pin: 799006.
------ Owner of motor cycle No.TR-01-U-5504).
4. Sri Sujan Das,
S/O Sri Subal Das
Of Capital Complex, Quarter No:II/A, P.O: Kunjaban,
P.S: NCC, Dist: West Tripura, Pin: 799006.
------ (Rider of motor cycle No.TR-01-U-5504).
In MAC App. No.81 of 2024
For Appellant(s)
:
Mr. Samar Das, Adv.
For Respondent(s)
:
Mr. H. K. Bhowmik, Adv.
In MAC App. No.82 of 2024
For Appellant(s)
:
For Respondent(s)
:
Mr. N. Debnath, Adv,
Mr. E. L. Darlong, Adv.
Mr. H. K. Bhowmik, Adv.
Date of hearing &
delivery of
Judgment & Order
:
30.11.2024
Whether fit for
reporting
:
YES
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE BISWAJIT PALIT
Judgment & Order
Both the appeals have filed under Section 173 of M.V.
Act challenging the judgment and award dated 18.01.2024
delivered by Learned Member, MAC Tribunal No.4, West Tripura
in connection with case No.TS(MAC) No.46 of 2022. Since both
the appeals have arisen out of a common judgment, so by this
common judgment both the appeals are disposed of for the sake
of convenience.
2.
Heard
Learned
Counsel
Mr.
Samar
Das
for
the
claimant petitioners also heard Learned Counsel, Mr. H.K.
Bhowmik for the owner and rider of the alleged offending
motor bike and also heard Learned Counsel for the Insurance
Company, Mr. N. Debnath along with Learned Counsel Mr. E.
L. Darlong in both the cases.
3.
In MAC App. No.81 of 2024, the appeal has been
preferred by the claimant-petitioners for enhancement of the
award of compensation and in MAC App. No.82 of 2024, the
Insurance
Company
has
preferred
the
appeal
for
setting
aside/quashing the impugned award dated 18.01.2024.
4.
Learned Counsel, Mr. Samar Das for the claimant-
petitioners in course of hearing of argument submitted that the
Learned Tribunal below rightly and reasonably allowed the claim
petition filed by the appellant-claimant petitioners but at the
time of determination of compensation, Learned Tribunal below
failed to determine the amount of compensation properly for
which the claimant-petitioners have preferred this appeal for
enhancement of the amount of compensation.
5.
Learned Counsel, Mr. H. K. Bhowmik representing the
owner-cum-rider of the alleged offending motor bike first of all
submitted that before the Learned Tribunal below, the claimantpetitioners did not submit the relevant prosecution papers like
FIR, C/S for marking exhibits but the Learned Tribunal below on
the basis of documents available with the connected Misc
case(AIR) decided the case without marking of any exhibits of
the documents and delivered the judgment/award. Learned
Counsel further submitted that although the Learned Tribunal
below came to the observation that for deciding a motor accident
claim case, it is not necessary for the Learned Tribunal below to
rely upon the evidence recorded in Criminal case that where the
accident took place rather the MAC Tribunal on the basis of
evidence on record can decide any claim case in merit. Learned
Counsel,
Mr.
Bhowmik
further
submitted
that
before
the
Tribunal, the O.P.-owner and rider of the motor bike never
admitted the fact of accident and they totally denied the
involvement of the alleged offending motor bike with the alleged
accident and furthermore, the claimant petitioners i.e. the
appellants totally failed to establish that the offending motor bike
of the alleged O.P. owner was involved with the accident because
in this regard, no independent witness was produced by the
petitioners before the Learned Tribunal below. Furthermore, he
also referred the evidence of the petitioners recorded before the
Learned Tribunal below before delivering the judgment and
referring the same, specifically the cross-examination part, he
drawn the attention of the Court that the claimant-petitioners
failed to discredit the evidence of the O.P.-owner regarding his
defence. Even during cross-examination by the InsuranceCompany before the Learned Tribunal below, it was clearly
established that the alleged offending bike of the O.P.-owner was
not involved with the accident. Finally Learned Counsel, Mr. H. K.
Bhowmik fairly submitted that the Learned Tribunal below rightly
ignored the principle of ‘Pay and Recovery’ and fastened the
liability
of
payment
of
compensation
upon
the
Insurance
Company.
6.
On the other hand, Learned Counsel for the appellant-
Insurance Company in MAC App. No.82 of 2024 submitted that
the judgment and award of the Learned Tribunal below suffers
from various infirmities for which the interference of the Court is
required and he urged for setting aside the award delivered by
the Learned Tribunal below. Learned Counsel further submitted
that Learned Tribunal below came to the observation that at the
time of accident, the rider of the bike had no driving licence as
he was minor and furthermore, the Learned Tribunal below at
the time of delivery of judgment wrongly fastened the liability of
payment compensation upon the Insurance Company without
applying the principle of ‘Pay and Recovery’. In support of his
contention, Learned Counsel referred few citations which will be
discussed later on and in summing up, Learned Counsel for the
appellant-Insurance Company submitted that in absence of
cogent evidence on record as observed by Learned Tribunal
below that the rider had driven the bike beyond the knowledge
of the owner of the bike was not correct and in view of the
principle of law laid down by the Hon’bel Apex Court, the owner
cannot escape from the liability of payment of compensation of
the alleged accident to the claimant-petitioners. So, Learned
Counsel urged for allowing the appeal and also for setting aside
the judgment and award of the Learned Tribunal below.
7.
I have heard detailed argument of Learned Counsels of
the rival parties and perused the judgment of the Learned
Tribunal below.
Admittedly, the claimant-petitioners Smt. Smriti Deb and
Shri Badal Deb filed one claim petition before the Learned
Tribunal
below
under
Section
of
M.V.
Act
seeking
compensation due to the death of their son Bipratik Deb and
accordingly the case was registered as T.S.(MAC) No.46 of 2022.
8.
The gist of the claim petition of the claimant petitioners,
in short, is that on 08.12.2020, the victim Bipratik Deb (since
dead) as pillion rider of the motor bike bearing No.TR-01-U-5504
which was being driven by his friend Sujan Das were proceeding
towards his maternal uncle’s home at Gurkhabasti and on
reaching near Shani Temple at Bholagiri Tri Junction, suddenly
the rider had lost control over the bike and dashed against an
electrical pole resulting which the victim fell down on the road
and sustained multiple injuries on his person. Immediately he
was taken to G.B.P. Hospital where the attending doctor declared
him as dead.
It was also the plea of the claimant-petitioners that the
accident occurred due to rash and negligent driving of the rider
of the motor bike and according to them, the deceased was 16
years old at the time of death and a student of Class X of Sri
Krishna Mission School who used to earn Rs.15,000/- per month
by doing private tuition.
9.
The case was contested by the owner of the alleged
offending motor bike as well as by the Insurance Company. The
owner Shri Sagar Das and the alleged rider of the vehicle, Shri
Sujan Das, filed joint written statement totally denied the fact of
accident and also denied the fact of riding of bike by Shri Sujan
Das along with Bipratik(since dead) on 08.12.2020 with motor
bike bearing No.TR-01-U-5504 and finally prayed for dismissal of
the claim petition.
The Insurance Company also appeared and denied the
assertions of the claimant-petitioners and also took the plea that
the claim petition was subjected to strict proof by the claimants.
10.
Upon the pleadings of the parties, Learned Tribunal
below framed the following issues:
1. Whether Bipratik Deb died in a vehicular accident
occurred on 08.12.2020 at about 6.30 a.m. at Bholagiri
Tri Junction area under NCC P.S. West Tripura District
due to rash and negligent driving of vehicle bearing
No.TR-01-U-5504 (motor bike) by its rider?
2. Whether the claimant petitioners being the legal
heirs
of
the
deceased,
are
entitled
to
get
compensation, if so, upto what extent and who shall be
liable to pay the same?
To determine the points, the claimant side examined five
witnesses and relied upon some documents which were marked
as Exhibits.
On the other hand, the O.P.-owner examined himself
and also exhibited some documents.
11.
For the sake of convenience, the name of the witnesses
of the claimant-petitioners and their exhibits and the witness of
the OP and exhibits are mentioned hereinbelow:
Petitioner witnesses:
1. Smt. Pinki Deb (PW1)
2. Sri Badal Deb (PW2)
3. Sri Biswajit Das (PW3)
4. Sri Amlan Biswas (PW4)
5. Sri Sudip Biswas (PW5)
Petitioner exhibits:
1) Death certificate of deceased – Exbt.1;
2) Birth certificate of deceased – Exbt.2;
3) Report card of school of deceased – Exbt.3 to 3/1;
4) Certificates of co-curriculum of deceased – Exbt.4
to 4/4;
5) Ration card – Exbt.5.
Opposite Party witness:
Sri Sagar Das (OPW1)
Opposite party exhibits:
1. Registration certificate of the offending vehicle –
Ext.A;
2. Insurance policy of the vehicle – Exbt.B;
3. Driving licence of the owner – Exbt.C;
4. Tax token of the vehicle – Ext.D;
5. Pollution certificate of the vehicle – Ext.E.
12.
Finally on conclusion of evidence on record, Learned
Tribunal below delivered the judgment on 18.01.2024. The
operative portion of the judgment/Award runs as follows:
11. In the result, claim is awarded in following terms:(i) Claimant petitioners are entitled to get the
award of Rs. 7,40,000/- (Rupees seven lakhs
fourty thousand) only along with 9% simple
interest per annum in equal share from the date of
the petition i.e. w.e.f. 15.02.2022 till the date of
realization thereof from the O.P. No.2 the National
Insurance Co. Ltd.
(ii) 40% of the awarded amount be invested by
purchasing separate Fixed Deposit Certificates
from Nationalised Bank for a period of five years
with auto renewal facility and the claimant
petitioners shall open savings account in the same
bank. No loan or advance or pre-mature
withdrawal shall be allowed without prior sanction
of this Tribunal. The interest accrued on the fixed
deposit certificates shall be directly transmitted to
the individual savings accounts by the concerned
bank. The concerned bank shall retain the original
fixed deposit certificates and the copies of the
certificates to be handed to all the claimant
petitioners. The claimant petitioners are directed to
submit photocopies of their bank pass book.
(iii) The O.P. No.2 the National Insurance Co. Ltd.
shall deposit the amount so ordered along with
interest thereon within one month to this Tribunal
from the date of the order.
(iv) Copy of this order so awarded to be served
upon the parties not later than 15 days from the
date of this award.
(v) The case stands disposed on contest.
(vi) Enter the result.
13.
In course of hearing of argument, Learned Counsel for
the alleged owner and the rider of the bike submitted that before
the Learned Tribunal below the claimant petitioners have failed
to prove the involvement of the alleged offending motor bike
with the alleged accident and also failed to prove that the rider of
the bike was responsible for the alleged accident on that day.
Learned Counsel referring the evidence on record tried to draw
the attention of the Court that the Learned Tribunal below
without appreciating the evidence on record properly delivered
the judgment/Award.
14.
Now for the sake of convenience, I would like to discuss
hereinbelow the synopsis of the evidence on record. As already
stated the claimant petitioners have adduced five witnesses.
15.
PW-1, Smt. Smriti Deb deposed that her son met with
an accident on 08.12.2020 at about 6:30 am near Bholagiri Tri
Junction area under NCC P.S. due to rash and negligent driving
of the bike bearing No.TR-01-U-5504 and after the accident, her
husband lodged a complaint to O/C, NCC P.S. and accordingly,
N.C.C. P.S. case No.179 of 2020 under Section 279/304(A) of
IPC was registered. She further stated that at the time of
accident, her son was a student of Class-X in Sri Krishna Mission
School and was aged about 16 years and he used to earn
Rs.15,000/- per month and also stated that the deceased
Bipratik was their only son and they were dependent upon the
income of their son and relied upon the exhibited documents.
During cross-examination by the Insurance Company,
she stated that her husband is a Government employee serving
as a Pump Operator under the P.W.D Department. During crossexamination by the alleged owner and rider of the bike, she
stated that she did not witness the accident and her husband
also did not witness the accident. She did not submit any income
proof of her deceased son and admitted that her son was a
student.
16.
PW-2, Badal Deb is the husband of PW-1 and the father
of the deceased Bipratik Deb. He also in his examination-in-chief
in affidavit asserted the same submissions made by his wife.
During cross-examination by Insurance Company, he
stated that he is a Government employee serving as a Pump
Operator under PWD Department. During cross-examination by
the alleged owner and rider of the bike, he stated that he did not
witness the accident and also stated that he has not submitted
any income proof of his deceased son and his son was a student.
Nothing more came out relevant.
17.
PW-3, Biswajit Das only deposed that Bipratik Deb
expired on 08.12.2020 due to a bike accident and he was a
student of Sri Krishna Mission School and the deceased used to
render private tuition to his daughter and for that he used to pay
Rs.3000/- per month to him.
During cross-examination by O.P.No.2 i.e. the Insurance
Company, he stated that his daughter Priyanka was a student of
Maharani Tulsibati School at the time of accident and he was
earning Rs.15,000/- to Rs.20,000/- per month. He further stated
that his daughter was aged about 16 years and the deceased
was also 16 years. During cross-examination by the alleged
owner and rider of the bike, he stated that he has not witnessed
the occurrence of accident nor submitted any school certificate of
his daughter being a student of Class VIII and he know the
father of the deceased.
18.
PW-4, Amlan Biswas was also deposed in the same
manner like PW-3 and also stated that his son Auyosh Biswas
undergone private tuition to said Bipratik Deb (deceased) and for
that he used to pay Rs.3000/- per month.
During cross-examination by the Insurance Company, he
stated that he is earning Rs.15,000-Rs.20,000/- per month and
also stated that the deceased was 16 years old. During cross-
examination by the alleged owner and rider of the bike, he
stated that he did not witness the occurrence of accident nor
submitted any school certificate of his son Auyosh Biswas being a
student of Class IV and he knew the father of deceased Bipratik
Deb namely Badal Deb.
19.
PW-5, Sudip Biswas also deposed in the same manner
like PW-4 and stated that his daughter Priyanka Biswas, a
student of Class-VIII took private tuition from said deceased
Bipratik Deb and for that he used to pay Rs.3000/- per month to
him as honorarium.
During cross-examination by the Insurance Company, he
stated that he was earning Rs.15,000/- to Rs.20,000/- per
month and deceased was 16years old. During cross-examination
by OP Nos.1 and 3, he did not witness the occurrence of the
accident and he did not submit any school certificate of his
daughter being a student of Class-IV and he knew Badal Deb,
the father of deceased Bipratik Deb.
20.
As already stated, the O.P.-owner examined himself as
OPW-1/DW-1. In his examination-in-chief by way of affidavit, he
stated that he is the registered owner of the vehicle/bike bearing
No.TR-01-U-5504(Hunk). OP No.3 is his younger brother and he
has been falsely implicated in the case without any cause of
action and he was not the rider of the motor bike (Hunk) on the
alleged day of accident i.e. on 08.12.2020 at about 6:30 am
near Bholagiri Tri Junction area under N.C.C. P.S. He further
stated that he himself and O.P. No.3 i.e. the rider filed joint
written statement before the Learned Tribunal below and totally
denied the allegation that his brother Sujan Das was the rider of
the offending bike on the day of accident. He further stated that
on the alleged day of accident on 08.12.2020 at about 6:30 am
his motor cycle bearing No.TR-01-U-5504 was not driven to any
road nor it was involved in any road traffic accident and also no
road traffic accident occurred due to rash and negligent driving
of the motor bike either by him or by his younger brother. But he
stated that on the basis of Suo Moto complaint lodged by police
of GB Top under N.C.C. P.S. a case was registered on
11.12.2020 vide N.C.C. P.S. case No.179 of 2020 under Section
279/304(A) of IPC against his brother Sujan Das and later on
police submitted charge-sheet against his brother vide N.C.C.
P.S. case No.49 of 2021 dated 12.07.2021 and further stated
that at the time of alleged accident, his brother was minor and
he
was
prosecuted
before
the
Juvenile
Justice
Board
in
connection with Juvenile case No.5 of 2021 and by order dated
19.05.2022 passed by the Board, his brother was acquitted from
the charge. Also stated that at the time of accident, his vehicle
was duly insured with the O.P. No.2 and he had valid driving
licence and also mentioned the policy number of the alleged
offending motor bike and also mentioned his driving licence
bearing
No.TR-01-20130086227
which
was
valid
w.e.f
18.11.2013 to 26.12.2034 and denied the allegation of the
petitioners. He also relied upon some documents which were
marked as Exhibits A to E.
During cross-examination by the claimants, he totally
denied the suggestions made by the claimants but during crossexamination by the Insurance Company, he stated that on
08.12.2020 i.e. on the date of accident his brother was minor
and also admitted that his brother being a minor had no driving
licence. Further admitted that his brother on receiving summons
appeared before the Juvenile Justice Board but he do not know
deceased Bipratik Deb and also stated that he never heard the
fact that his brother Sujan Das had driven his motor bike and the
pillion rider was Bipratik Deb and volunteered that the keys of
the motor bike remained under his custody. Again stated that his
brother never took the keys and the motor bike without his
consent. He also heard the fact from anyone that his minor
brother in his absence had took away the motor bike.
These are the synopsis of the evidence on record.
21.
Learned Tribunal below at the time of determination of
issue No.1 came to the observation that on the alleged day, the
bike was driven by Sujan Das when he was minor but the
offending motor bike had valid Insurance Policy (Ext.-B) and the
driving licence of Sagar Das i.e. the owner of the motor bike was
marked as Ext.-C. But the Learned Tribunal below came to the
observation that there was no breach of conditions of the policy
by the owner. So, ‘Pay and Recovery’ principle would not be
applicable in this case. So, Learned Tribunal below at the time of
delivery of judgment/award fastened the liability of payment of
compensation upon the Insurance Company.
22.
As already stated, in course of hearing of argument,
Learned Counsel for the Insurance Company relied upon few
citations.
Hon’ble the Supreme Court of India in Jawahar Singh
v. Bala Jain & Ors. dated 09.05.2011 reported in (2011) 6
SCC 425 wherein in para Nos.5, 7, 8, 10, 11, 12, 14, 15 and 16
observed as under:
“5. The Delhi High Court held that Jatin was a minor
on the date of the accident and was riding the
motorcycle in violation of the provisions of the Motor
Vehicles Act, 1988, and the Rules framed thereunder.
The High Court also relied on the evidence of PW 8,
who has deposed in clear and in no uncertain terms
that the accident had occurred due to the rash and
negligent driving of the motorcycle by Jatin. No
suggestion was given to the said witness (PW 8) that
the accident did not take place on account of rash
and negligent driving on the part of Jatin. Such
deposition went unchallenged and became final. It is
against the said order of the learned Single Judge of
the Delhi High Court and the order dated 26-9-2008
dismissing Review Application No.333 of 2008, that
the present special leave petition has been filed.
7. Mr. Tyagi submitted that the Petitioner, Jawahar
Singh, had no liability in regard to the incident, as
would be evident from his deposition as R1W4, in
which he admitted that he was the owner of the
motorcycle in question and that on 18-7-2004 at 1.00
p.m., while he was at his residence, he received a
telephonic message indicating that his nephew, Jatin,
had met with an accident. In his deposition, he stated
that the key of the motorcycle was on the dining
table of his house and without his knowledge and
consent, Jatin took the keys of the motorcycle and
was, thereafter, involved in the accident. It was
submitted that despite the same, the Motor Accident
Claims Tribunal also held him to be responsible for
the death of the victim in the accident and while a
sum of Rs.8,35,067/- with interest @7% from the
date of institution of the petition till the date of
realization was awarded in favour of the claimants,
the Insurance Company, which was directed to pay
the said amount in the first instance, was given the
right to recover the same from the Petitioner. He
submitted that it was in view of such wrong approach
to the problem that the judgment and order of the
High Court impugned in the special leave petition was
liable to be set aside.
8. On the other hand, it was urged by the learned
counsel for the respondents, that the orders of the
Tribunal and the High Court did not call for any
interference, since the factum of rash and negligent
driving by Jatin had been duly proved from the
evidence of PW 8 and there was nothing at all to
show that the deceased had in any way contributed
to the accident by his negligence or that the
petitioner had taken sufficient precaution to see that
his motorcycle was not misused by any third party.
10. On behalf of Respondent No.6, National
Insurance Company Ltd., it was sought to be urged
that at the time of the accident, the motorcycle was
being driven in breach of the terms and conditions of
the Insurance Policy and, accordingly, the Insurance
Company could not be held liable for making payment
of the compensation awarded by the Motor Accident
Claims Tribunal. Apart from the fact that Jatin, who
was riding the motorcycle, did not have a valid
driving licence, it had also been established that he
was a minor at the time of the accident and
consequently the Insurance Company had been
rightly relieved of the liability of payment of
compensation to the claimants and such liability had
been correctly fixed on the owner of the motorcycle,
Jawahar Singh.
11. It has been well settled that if it is not possible
for an awardee to recover the compensation awarded
against the driver of the vehicle, the liability to make
payment of the compensation awarded fell on the
owner of the vehicle. It was submitted that in this
case since the person riding the motorcycle at the
time of accident was a minor, the responsibility for
paying the compensation awarded fell on the owner
of the motorcycle. In fact, in Ishwar Chandra v.
Oriental Insurance Co. Ltd. :(2007) 3 AD (SC) 753, it
was held by this Court that in case the driver of the
vehicle did not have a licence at all, the liability to
make payment of compensation fell on the owner
since it was his obligation to take adequate care to
see that the driver had an appropriate licence to
drive the vehicle.
12. Before the Tribunal reliance was also placed on
the decision in National Insurance Co. Ltd. Vs. Gh.
Mohd. Wani :2004 ACJ 1424 (J&K) and National
Insurance Co. Ltd. v. Gadigewwa :2005 ACJ 40(Kant),
wherein it was held that if the driver of the offending
bike did not have a valid driving licence, then the
Insurance Company after paying the compensation
amount would be entitled to recover the same from
the owner of the vehicle. It was submitted that no
interference was called for with the judgment and
order of the High Court impugned in the special leave
petition.
14. We cannot shut our eyes to the fact that it was
Jatin, who came from behind on the motorcycle and
hit the scooter of the deceased from behind. The
responsibility in causing the accident was, therefore,
found to be solely that of Jatin. However, since Jatin
was a minor and it was the responsibility of the
petitioner to ensure that his motorcycle was not
misused and that too by a minor who had no licence
to drive the same, the Motor Accident Claims Tribunal
quite rightly saddled the liability for payment of
compensation on the petitioner and, accordingly,
directed the Insurance Company to pay the awarded
amount to the awardees and, thereafter, to recover
the same from the petitioner. The said question has
been duly considered by the Tribunal and was
correctly decided. The High Court rightly chose not to
interfere with the same.
15. Without going into the merits of the case, we are
of the view that the story of Jatin, who was a minor,
walking into the house of the Petitioner and taking
the keys of the motorcycle without any intimation to
the petitioner, appears to be highly improbable and
far-fetched. It is difficult to accept the defence of the
petitioner that the keys of the motorcycle were taken
by Jatin without his knowledge. Having regard to the
aforesaid facts, we are not inclined to accept the case
of contributory negligence on the part of the
deceased, attempted to be made out on behalf of the
petitioner.
16. Accordingly, since the notice on the special leave
petition was confined to the question of contributory
negligence, if any, on the part of the deceased, we
see no reason to interfere with the award of the
Motor Accident Claims Tribunal, as confirmed by the
High Court. The special leave petitions are,
accordingly, dismissed, but without any order as to
costs.”
Referring the aforesaid citation and also referring the
evidence on record of the present case, Learned Counsel for the
Insurance Company has drawn the attention of the Court that
from the evidence on record, it is clear that there was breach of
condition of the policy by the owner. So, the observation of
Learned Tribunal that he (owner) had no knowledge about the
taking of keys by his brother without his consent cannot be
accepted rather from the facts and circumstances of the case,
the ‘Pay and Recovery’ principle should be applied in the given
case which the Learned Tribunal below failed to consider at the
time of delivery of judgment/award.
23.
Learned Counsel for the Insurance Company further
relied upon two more citations.
In Sri Pramod Kumar Agrawal & Anr v. Mushtari
Begum & Ors. dated 18.08.2004 reported in (2004) 8 SCC
667 wherein in para No.12, Hon’ble the Apex Court observed as
under:
“12. Therefore, while upholding the judgment of the
High Court we direct in terms of what has been
stated in Baljit Kaur case :(2004) 2 SCC 1 that the
insurer shall pay the quantum of compensation fixed
by the Tribunal, about which there was no dispute
raised, to the respondents-claimants within three
months from today. For the purpose of recovering the
same from the owner the insurer shall not be
required to file a suit. It may initiate a proceeding
before the Executing Court concerned as if the
dispute between the insurer and the owner was the
subject matter of determination before the Tribunal
and the issue is decided against the owner and in
favour of the insurer. Before release of the amount to
the claimants, owner of the vehicle i.e. Appellant 1
shall furnish security for the entire amount which the
insurer will pay to the claimants. The offending
vehicle shall be attached, as a part of the security. If
necessity arises, the Executing Court shall take
assistance of the Regional Transport Authority
concerned.
The
Executing
Court
shall
pass
appropriate orders in accordance with law as to the
manner in which the owner of the vehicle i.e.
Appellant 1 shall make payment to the insurer. In
case there is any default, it shall be open to the
Executing Court to direct realization by disposal of
the securities to be furnished or from any other
property or properties of the owner of the vehicle,
the insured (Appellant 1).”
Further, the Bombay High Court in Bajaj Allianz
General Insurance Co. Ltd. v. Sangita wd/o Bhagwan
Raut and Ors. dated 21.07.2014 reported in 2015 (1)
Mh.L.J. wherein in para No.15 also observed as under:
“15. However, some modification is required in the
impugned directions as the learned Member in F.A.
No. 1043/11 has not categorically made it clear that
the Insurance Company need not file a separate
execution proceeding against the owner and that the
learned Members in both cases have not taken into
account the directions issued in the case of Pramod
Kumar Agrawal and Others vs. Mushtari Begum and
Others reported in III (2005 ACC 357 (SC) wherein
the Hon’ble Apex Court has issued several directions,
one of which is that before release of the amount to
the claimants, the owner of the vehicle shall furnish
security for the entire amount which the insurer will
pay to the claimants. Said directions should have
been issued in both the cases and, therefore, to this
extent only, there is a need to modify the impugned
orders.”
Referring the said citations, Learned Counsel drawn the
attention of the Court that the mode of recovery of amount by
the Insurance Company in the event of ‘Pay and Recovery’ policy
and drawn the attention of the Court that the Learned Tribunal
below ought to have consider that there was clear violation of
the terms and conditions of the policy by the O.P.-owner of the
alleged offending motor bike. But the Learned Tribunal below
without appreciating the evidence on record came to the
observation that principle of ‘Pay and Recovery’ would not be
applied in the given case which is misconceived and cannot be
accepted in the eye of law and urged for taking notes of the
aforesaid citations in deciding the case.
24.
In this regard, Hon’ble the Supreme Court of India in
Shamanna
&
Anr.
Insurance
Company
V.
Divisional
Limited
&
Manager,
Ors.
dated
Oriental
08.08.2018
reported in (2018) 9 SCC 650 wherein in para Nos.5, 6, 7 and
8 have been framed the modalities to be followed in case of ‘Pay
and Recovery’:
“5. In the case of third-party risks, as per the
decision in National Insurance Co. Ltd. v. Swaran
Singh:(2004) 3 SCC 297, the insurer had to indemnify
the compensation amount payable to the third-party
and the insurance company may recover the same
from the insured. Doctrine of "pay and recover" was
considered by the Supreme Court in Swaran Singh
case(supra) wherein the Supreme Court examined
the liability of the insurance company in cases of
breach of policy condition due to disqualifications of
the driver or invalid driving licence of the driver and
held that in case of third-party risks, the insurer has
to indemnify the compensation amount to the thirdparty and the insurance company may recover the
same from the insured. Elaborately considering the
insurer's contractual liability as well as statutory
liability vis-à-vis the claims of third parties, the
Supreme Court issued detailed guidelines as to how
and in what circumstances, "pay and recover" can be
ordered. In para 110, the Supreme Court summarised
its conclusions as under: (SCC pp. 341-42)
"110. The summary of our findings to the various
issues as raised in these petitions is as follows:
(1) Chapter XI of the Motor Vehicles Act, 1988
providing compulsory insurance of vehicles
against third-party risks is a social welfare
legislation to extend relief by compensation to
victims of accidents caused by use of motor
vehicles.
The
provisions
of
compulsory
insurance coverage of all vehicles are with this
paramount object and the provisions of the Act
have to be so interpreted as to effectuate the
said object.
(ii) An insurer is entitled to raise a defence in a
claim petition filed under Section 163-A or
Section 166 of the Motor Vehicles Act, 1988,
inter alia, in terms of Section 149(2)(a)(ii) of
the said Act.
(iii) The breach of policy condition e.g.
disqualification of the driver or invalid driving
licence of the driver, as contained in subsection (2)(a)(ii) of Section 149, has to be
proved to have been committed by the insured
for avoiding liability by the insurer. Mere
absence, fake or invalid driving licence or
disqualification of the driver for driving at the
relevant time, are not in themselves defences
available to the insurer against either the
insured or the third parties. To avoid its liability
towards the insured, the insurer has to prove
that the insured was guilty of negligence and
failed to exercise reasonable care in the matter
of fulfilling the condition of the policy regarding
use of vehicles by a duly licensed driver or one
who was not disqualified to drive at the
relevant time.
(iv) Insurance companies, however, with a
view to avoid their liability must not only
establish the available defence(s) raised in the
said proceedings but must also establish
"breach" on the part of the owner of the
vehicle; the burden of proof wherefor would be
on them.
(v) The court cannot lay down any criteria as to
how the said burden would be discharged,
inasmuch as the same would depend upon the
facts and circumstances of each case.
(vi) Even where the insurer is able to prove
breach on the part of the insured concerning
the policy condition regarding holding of a valid
licence by the driver or his qualification to drive
during the relevant period, the insurer would
not be allowed to avoid its liability towards the
insured unless the said breach or breaches on
the condition of driving licence is/are so
fundamental as are found to have contributed
to the cause of the accident. The Tribunals in
interpreting the policy conditions would apply
"the rule of main purpose" and the concept of
"fundamental breach" to allow defences
available to the insurer under Section 149(2) of
the Act.
(vii) The question, as to whether the owner has
taken reasonable care to find out as to whether
the driving licence produced by the driver (a
fake one or otherwise), does not fulfil the
requirements of law or not will have to be
determined in each case.
(viii) If a vehicle at the time of accident was
driven by a person having a learner's licence,
the insurance companies would be liable to
satisfy the decree.
(ix) The Claims Tribunal constituted under
Section 165 read with Section 168 is
empowered to adjudicate all claims in respect
of the accidents involving death or of bodily
injury or damage to property of third-party
arising in use of motor vehicle. The said power
of the Tribunal is not restricted to decide the
claims inter se between claimant or claimants
on one side and insured, insurer and driver on
the other. In the course of adjudicating the
claim for compensation and to decide the
availability of defence or defences to the
insurer, the Tribunal has necessarily the power
and jurisdiction to decide disputes inter se
between the insurer and the insured. The
decision rendered on the claims and disputes
inter se between the insurer and insured in the
course
of
adjudication
of
claim
for
compensation by the claimants and the award
made thereon is enforceable and executable in
the same manner as provided in Section 174 of
the Act for enforcement and execution of the
award in favour of the claimants.
(x) Where on adjudication of the claim under
the Act the Tribunal arrives at a conclusion that
the insurer has satisfactorily proved its defence
in accordance with the provisions of Section
149(2)
read
with
sub-section
(7),
as
interpreted by this Court above, the Tribunal
can direct that the insurer is liable to be
reimbursed
by
the
insured
for
the
compensation and other amounts which it has
been compelled to pay to the third-party under
the award of the Tribunal. Such determination
a claim by the Tribunal will be enforceable and
the money found due to the insurer from the
insured will be recoverable on a certificate
issue by the Tribunal to the Collector in the
same manner under Section 174 of the Act as
arrears of land revenue. The certificate will be
issued for the recovery as arrears of land
revenue only if, as required by sub-section (3)
of Section 168 of the Act the insured fails to
deposit the amount awarded in favour of the
insurer within thirty days from date of
announcement of the award by the Tribunal.
(xi) The provisions contained in sub-section (4)
with the proviso thereunder and sub-section
(5) which are intended to cover specified
contingencies mentioned therein to enable the
insurer to recover the amount paid under the
contract of insurance on behalf of the insured
can be taken recourse to by the Tribunal and be
extended to claims and defences of the insurer
against the insured by relegating them to the
remedy before regular court in cases where on
given facts circumstances adjudication of their
claims inter se might delay adjudication of the
claims of the victims." (emphasis supplied)
6. As per the decision in Swaran Singh case (supra),
onus is always upon the insurance company to prove
that the driver had no valid driving licence and that
there was breach of policy conditions. Where the
driver did not posses the valid driving licence and
there are breach of policy conditions, "pay and
recover" can be ordered in case of third-party risks.
The Tribunal is required to consider "as to whether
the owner has taken reasonable care to find out as to
whether the driving licence produced by the driver...
does not fulfil the requirements of law or not will
have to be determined in each case".
7. The Supreme Court considered the decision of
Swaran Singh case (supra) in subsequent decision in
National Insurance Co. Ltd. v. Laxmi Narain Dhut
:(2007) 3 SCC 700, wherein this Court held that: (SCC
p. 705, para 5)
"5. The decision in Swaran Singh case(supra) has
no application to cases other than third-party
risks and in case of third-party risks the insurer
has to indemnify the amount and if so advised, to
recover the same from the insured."
8. The same principle was reiterated in Premkumari
v. Prahlad Dev:(2008) 3 SCC 193.”
25.
Here in the case at hand, there is no dispute on record in
respect of the death of the deceased Bipratik Deb on the alleged
day.
The
O.P.-owner
although
totally
denied
the
fact
of
involvement of his vehicle with the alleged accident and also
denied the fact of involvement of his younger brother being a
rider of the bike, but admitted that his brother had no valid
licence as he was minor. At the same time, the OP-owner also
admitted that a police case was registered and police laid
charge-sheet against his brother and since he was minor i.e.
children in conflict with law so he was enquired by the Juvenile
Justice Board, Agartala although he was acquitted on benefit of
doubt from the said case.
26.
Regarding filing of charge-sheet and also regarding
facing of enquiry, Learned Counsel Mr. Bhowmik in course of
hearing of argument failed to show any cogent grounds to
disbelieve the said fact. On the other hand, to substantiate the
claim
petition,
as already
stated,
the respondent-claimant
petitioners have adduced oral/documentary evidence on record
but by the evidence, they could not specifically say as to how
and when the accident took place and who was the actual rider
of the vehicle and also they failed to explain clearly as to rash
and negligent driving of the bike by the rider for which the
accident occurred. Even no relevant prosecution papers were
exhibited by the claimant petitioners. Although the Learned
Tribunal below relied upon the papers of the connected Misc.
case
i.e.
the
detailed
accident
report
and
came
to
the
observation that the offending motor bike was driven by the
rider Shri Sujan Das due to his negligent driving, the accident
occurred but also came to the observation that the rider was
minor on that relevant point of time and he had no driving
licence. Although the owner of the bike has exhibited his driving
licence which was marked as Ext.-C. It is also the settled
position of law that the strict principles of evidences recorded in
criminal trial are inapplicable in MACT claim cases. Since the fact
of police case and filing of charge-sheet by the investigating
officer against the rider of the motor bike has not been rebutted
by the owner of the motor bike. So, the plea taken by the owner
of the motor bike that his bike was not involved with the
accident on the alleged day and his brother was not the rider of
the offending motor bike and he did not ply the motor bike on
that relevant point of time cannot be accepted in limini. But from
the evidence on record as discussed above, it appears that the
Learned Tribunal below at the time of delivery of judgment failed
to appreciate the principles of law laid down by the Hon’ble Apex
Court in different cases and also failed to appreciate the
evidence on record properly and ignoring the principles of law
laid down by the Hon’ble Apex court decided the claim petition in
favour of the claim peititoners. More so, the documents of the
connected accident information case were also not marked as
Exhibits in this case although it cannot be said that in absence of
marking of those documents, no judgment can be delivered.
Now, from the facts and circumstances of the case and
the evidence on record and in view of the aforesaid principles of
law laid down by the Hon’ble Apex Court in the aforenoted cases,
it appears to this Court that the entire case needs to be
reexamined by the Learned Tribunal below for which the
judgment delivered by Learned Tribunal below at this stage
cannot be sustained in the eye of law.
27.
In the result, the judgment and award dated 18.01.2024
delivered by Learned Tribunal below in connection with case No.
TS(MAC) No.46 of 2022 is hereby set aside and both the appeals
are disposed of accordingly with the observation that the matter
be remanded back to the Learned Tribunal below with a direction
to afford opportunity to the contesting Opposite parties to file
their additional written statements, if any, and thereafter, to
frame issues afresh, if required, and after taking fresh both oral
and documentary evidences on record of both the sides, the
Learned Tribunal below shall deliver a fresh judgment in
accordance with law in view of the principles of law laid down by
the Hon’ble Apex Court without being biased by the observation
of this Court and shall complete the entire exercise within a
period of 6(six) months from the date of receipt of the copy of
this judgment. It is expected that for early disposal of the case,
the contesting parties shall cooperate with the Learned Tribunal
below time to time and Learned Tribunal below after appreciating
the
evidence
on
record
afresh
shall
pass
a
detail
and
comprehensive judgment. Both the parties are accordingly asked
to appear before the Learned Tribunal below on 16.12.2024.
Send down the LCR along with a copy of this judgment.
Pending applications(s), if any, also stands disposed of.
JUDGE
SABYASACHI
SABYASACHI
BHATTACHARJEE
BHATTACHARJEE Date: 2024.12.02 16:00:31
+05'30'
Deepshikha
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review