Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
VS,J
C.M.A.No.1371 of 2017
APHC011391002016
IN THE HIGH COURT OF ANDHRA PRADESH
AT AMARAVATI
(Special Original Jurisdiction)
[3333]
WEDNESDAY,THE TWENTY EIGHTH DAY OF JANUARY
TWO THOUSAND AND TWENTY SIX
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE SMT JUSTICE V.SUJATHA
CIVIL MISCELLANEOUS APPEAL NO: 1371/2017
Between:
1. NATIONAL INSURANCE COMPANY LTD.,, VIJAYAWADA
...APPELLANT
AND
1. SMT SHAIK NURJAHAN, GUNTUR
2. SHAIK MAIMUNNISA, VIJAYAWADA
3. SHAIK RIJWANA, VIJAYAWADA
4. SHAIK KASIM SAIDA, VIJAYAWADA
5. SHAIK SAIDA, VIJAYAWADA
6. L NAGARJUNA, VIJAYAWADA
...RESPONDENT(S):
Appeal Under Section_____against ordersto set aside the order in WC
NO. 1 of 2014 on the file of the Court of the Commissioner for Employees
Compensation & Asst. Commissioner of Labour, at Guntur, dated 30th April,
2016, and pass
IA NO: 1 OF 2016(CMAMP 1319 OF 2016
VS,J
C.M.A.No.1371 of 2017
Petition under Section 151 CPC praying that in the circumstances stated
in the affidavit filed in support of the petition, the High Court may be pleased to
condone the delay of 54 days in preferring the appeal against the order and
decree in WC No. 1 of 2014 on the file of the Court of the Commissioner for
Employees' Compensation & Asst. Commissioner of Labour,a t Guntur, dated
30th April, 2016 and pass
IA NO: 2 OF 2016(CMAMP 1338 OF 2016
Petition under Section 151 CPC praying that in the circumstances stated
in the affidavit filed in support of the petition, the High Court may be pleased
grant stay of operation of the decee and order in WC No.1/2014 on the file of
the Court of the Commissioner for Employees Compensation & Asst.
Commissioner of Labour, at Guntur, dated 30th April, 2016 pending disposal
of the main CMA
IA NO: 1 OF 2017(CMAMP 1069 OF 2017
Petition under Section 151 CPC praying that in the circumstances stated
in the affidavit filed in support of the petition, the High Court may be pleased
vacate the interim order dated 26.08.2016 passed in CMAMP No.1338/2016
in CMASR No.30080/2016
Counsel for the Appellant:
1. A JAYANTHI
Counsel for the Respondent(S):
1. MARELLA RADHA
The Court made the following:
VS,J
C.M.A.No.1371 of 2017
JUDGMENT:
This Civil Miscellaneous Appeal is filed under Section 30 of the
Workmen?s Compensation Act, 1923, by the appellant/3rd opposite party
challenging the order dated 30.04.2016 passed on the file of the Court of the
Commissioner for Employees? Compensation and Assistant Commissioner of
Labour, Guntur in W.C.Case No.1 of 2014, whereby the Court below awarded
a compensation of Rs.5,77,552/- to respondent Nos.1 to 4/applicants against
the claim of Rs.6,00,000/-.
2.
Brief facts of the case are as under:
(a)
For the sake of convenience, the parties will hereinafter be
referred to as they are arrayed before the Court below. The applicant, being
the wife of late Shaik Saida Vali (hereinafter referred to as >deceased
workman?), filed a case before the Court below claiming compensation of
Rs.6,00,000/- for the death of her husband in an accident that took place on
20.07.2012, while he was driving the lorry bearing No.AP-27-W-3168. The 1st
opposite party is the owner of the lorry bearing No.AP-27-W-3168 and is the
father of the deceased. The 2nd opposite party is the policy holder of the lorry
bearing No.AP-27-W-3168. The 3rd opposite party is the insurer of the vehicle
bearing No.AP-27-W-3168.
VS,J
C.M.A.No.1371 of 2017
(b)
On 20.07.2012, at about wee hours, while the subject vehicle was
proceeding from Tirupathi to Rajupalem, at Padarupalli village of Nellore
district, the driver of the vehicle, drove the same in a rash, negligent manner
and having lost control over the same, hit a stationed lorry, as a result of
which, the deceased workman sustained injuries and died on the spot. The
said incident was reported to Nellore V town Police station and accordingly, a
case was registered in Crime No.292 of 2012 under Sections 304-A, 337 of
the Indian Penal Code. It was contended by the applicant before the Court
below that the deceased workman was earning Rs.3,000/- per month in
addition to a batta of Rs.100/- per day and that he is aged about 27 years.
(c)
The 1st opposite party filed a counter stating that the deceased
workman worked as a driver for the lorry bearing No.AP-27-W-3168 and that
he died during the course of employment. The 3rd opposite party filed a
counter denying all the averments of the applicant and contended that the
deceased and the 1st opposite party have no employee-employer relationship
established. It was further contended that the subject lorry was driven by
cleaner but not by the deceased.
(d)
After considering the submissions of either side, the Court below
framed the following points for consideration:
VS,J
C.M.A.No.1371 of 2017
1. Whether the deceased was a workman as per the provisions of
the Act and he died during the course of employment? Or not, under
Opposite Party-1.
2. What is apparent age of the deceased?
3. What is the wage of the deceased?
4. Whether the deceased was entitled without Driving License to
compensation in this claim?
5. Amount of compensation payable to the deceased?
(e)
During the course of trial, on behalf of the applicants, A.Ws-1 and
2 were examined and got marked Exs.A1 to A6. On behalf of the 3rd opposite
party, R.Ws.1 to 3 were examined and got marked Exs.B1 to B5.
(f)
The Court below, having considered the claim of the respondent
Nos.1 to 4/applicants, awarded a sum of Rs.5,77,552/- to the respondent
Nos.1 to 4/applicants and held that the 1st and 3rd opposite parties are jointly
and severally liable to pay the compensation to the applicants.
3.
party
Heard M/s A. Jayanthi, learned counsel for the appellant/3rd opposite
and
Smt.
Marella
Radha,
learned
counsel
for
the
respondents/applicants.
4.
During the course of arguments, learned counsel for the appellant
argued that at the time of accident, the deceased was sleeping on the top of
the cabin while the subject lorry was being driven by its cleaner
unauthorizedly. She further contended that the person who was driving the
subject lorry does not possess any valid driving license and the same has
VS,J
C.M.A.No.1371 of 2017
been corroborated by the evidence of R.Ws.1 to 3. It is the further contention
of learned counsel for the appellant that the Court below has erred in making
the appellant jointly and severally liable along with the 1st opposite party.
Hence, requested this Court to allow this appeal.
5.
On
the
other
hand,
learned
counsel
appearing
for
the
respondents/claimants has supported the order passed by Court below in all
aspects and contended that the employee-employer relationship between the
deceased and the 1st opposite party, though they are father and son, was well
established before the Court below as under Section 2(1)(n) of the Workmen?s
Compensation Act, 1923.
She further contended that though the person
driving the subject lorry is not in possession of a valid driving license, the fact
that the deceased died in the course of employment is sufficient for the
insurer to indemnify the employer. As such, she requested this Court to
dismiss this appeal as it is devoid of merits.
6.
Perused the material available on record. It is the case of the claimants
that the deceased, who is a driver of the lorry bearing No.AP-27-W-3168,
which belongs to the 1st opposite party and insured by the 3rd opposite party,
died on 20.07.2012, in an accident that occurred while the said vehicle was
proceeding from Tirupati to Rajupalem. In general, a father engaging his son
as an employee in a vehicle owned by the father is not prohibited in law nor it
can be said that such a situation is not normally possible. It is natural that a
VS,J
C.M.A.No.1371 of 2017
father engages his children as an employee. Thus, the relationship between
the deceased and the 1st opposite party, who is the father of the deceased is
well established and the same need not be doubted.
7.
The Court below, relying on the inquest report (Ex.A2) and postmortem
report (Ex.A3), considered the age of the deceased as 27 and in the absence
of any documentary proof, the minimum wage of the deceased, who was
working as driver,
was considered
as Rs.5397.75/-
and the total
compensation payable to the claimants was computed to Rs.5,77,552/-. The
compensation awarded by the Court below is not at all in dispute by either of
the parties, but the main ground on which the appellant – insurance company
filed this appeal is that the liability of paying compensation to the claimants
ought not to have been imposed on it. It is the case of the appellant that at the
time of accident, the subject vehicle was being driven by the cleaner of the
vehicle, who holds no valid driving license and not by the deceased; that the
deceased was sleeping on the top at the time of accident and that he did not
die during the course of his employment.
8.
Under similar circumstances, in a Judgment of the Hon?ble Supreme
Court of India in MST. Param Pal Singh through Father … Appellant
Versus national Insurance Co. & Anr… Respondents, Civil Appeal
No.9084 of 2012 @ SLP(C) No.16063 of 2007, decided on 14.12.2012, at
paragraphs No.27 and 28 it was held as follows:-
VS,J
C.M.A.No.1371 of 2017
<27. Applying the various principles laid down in the above decisions to the
facts of this case, we can validly conclude that there was CAUSAL
CONNECTION to the death of the deceased with that of his employment as a
truck driver. We cannot lose sight of the fact that a 45 years old driver meets
with his unexpected death, may be due to heart failure while driving the
vehicle from Delhi to a distant place called Nimiaghat near Jharkhand which
is about 1152 kms. away from Delhi, would have definitely undergone grave
strain and stress due to such long distance driving. The deceased being a
professional heavy vehicle driver when undertakes the job of such driving as
his regular avocation it can be safely held that such constant driving of heavy
vehicle, being dependant solely upon his physical and mental resources &
endurance, there was every reason to assume that the vocation of driving
was a material contributory factor if not the sole cause that accelerated his
unexpected death to occur which in all fairness should be held to be an
untoward mishap in his life span. Such an >untoward mishap? can therefore be
reasonably described as an >accident? as having been caused solely
attributable to the nature of employment indulged in with his employer which
was in the course of such employer?s trade or business.
28. Having regard to the evidence placed on record there was no scope to
hold that the deceased was simply travelling in the vehicle and that there was
no obligation for him to undertake the work of driving. On the other hand, the
evidence as stood established proved the fact that the deceased was actually
driving the truck and that in the course of such driving activity as he felt
uncomfortable he safely parked the vehicle on the side of the road near a
hotel soon whereafter he breathed his last. In such circumstances, we are
convinced that the conclusion of the Commissioner of Workmen?s
Compensation that the death of the deceased was in an accident arising out
of and in the course of his employment with the second respondent was
perfectly justified and the conclusion to the contrary reached by the learned
Judge of the High Court in the order impugned in this appeal deserves to be
set aside. The appeal stands allowed. The order impugned is set aside. The
order of the Commissioner for Workmen?s Compensation shall stand restored
and there shall be no order as to costs=.
9.
Undisputedly, whether the person driving the subject vehicle at the time
of accident is holding a valid driving license or not, would not be of any
relevance in determining the liability arising on account of the death of another
workman. Time and again, Courts have held that a workman, who sustained
injuries or had died in the course of employment would give rise to award of
compensation and once a valid policy exists, the insurer has to indemnify the
employer. The manner in which the vehicle was used or the question as to
VS,J
C.M.A.No.1371 of 2017
whether driver had a license would be of little relevance in this regard.
Admittedly, the deceased was on duty, but has died unfortunately by falling
down in an accident that took place on the fateful day.
10.
The Tribunal, considering the evidence adduced by the claimants and
as well as exhibits relied on by them, has rightly awarded the said amounts
and held that in all, the claimants would be entitled for a compensation of
Rs.5,77,552/-, which is just and proper and cannot be said to be excessive or
on higher side. Further, this Court finds no fault on the part of the Court below
in fixing the liability on the appellant herein.
11.
Accordingly, this appeal is dismissed. There shall be no order as to
costs.
Consequently, miscellaneous applications, pending, if any, shall also
stand closed.
___________________
JUSTICE V. SUJATHA
Date:28.01.2026.
Gss
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review