Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
AGARTALA
MAC App. 62 of 2023
National Insurance Company Limited,
Represented by its Divisional Manager (In Charge),
Agartala Division, 42, Akhaura Road, P.O.: H.P.O.
Agartala, P.S.: West Agartala, Dist: West Tripura,
PIN: 799001
(Insurer of TR-01-AS-0265, Maruti Suzuki Swift)
…………..Appellant
VERSUS
1.
Shri Tapas Debnath,
Son of late Hiralal Debnath,
……………….Claimant/Respondent No.1
(son of the deceased)
2.
Shri Ranjan Debnath,
Son of late Hiralal Debnath,
……………….Claimant/Respondent No.2
(son of the deceased)
3.
Smt. Rani Debnath,
Daughter of late Hiralal Debnath,
……………….Claimant/Respondent No.3
(daughter of the deceased)
All the 3 above are residents of villageNetaji Subhas Palli, Aralia,
P.S.: East Agartala, District: West Tripura,
PIN: 799004.
4.
Shri Shayan Chakma,
Son of Shri Sujit Chakma
resident of Shyamali Bazar, Kunjaban
P.S.: NCC, District: West Tripura,
PIN: 799006.
…………(Owner of TR-01-AS-0265,
Maruti Suzuki Swift)
For Appellant(s)
: Mr. Samrat Kar Bhowmik, Sr. Advocate.
Mr. J. Das, Advocate.
For Respondent(s)
Date of hearing and delivery
of judgment and order
Whether fit for reporting
: Mr. Kundan Pandey, Advocate.
: 12.01.2024
: No
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE T. AMARNATH GOUD
JUDGMENT & ORDER (ORAL)
This is an appeal under Section 173 of the Motor Vehicles Act,
1988 against the award dated 10.04.2023 passed by the learned Member,
Motor Accident Claims Tribunal, Tribunal No.4, West Tripura, Agartala in case
No. TS (MAC) 23 of 2021.
[2]
Brief facts of the case is that on 22.12.2019 at around 7.30 a.m.
while the
deceased Sudha Debnath was going towards Mathchowmuhani
market, through Shibnagar College Road the alleged accident was occurred as
suddenly when she came in front of the Bandhan Wedding Hall at around 7.30
a.m. vehicle bearing No. TR-01-AS-0265 came with high speed in rash and
negligent manner and dashed the victim Sudha Debnath. Due to the accident
the deceased fell on the road and was admitted at GBP Hospital and during
the treatment, she died at the hospital. The deceased Sudha Debnath, as
mentioned in the claim petition, was an employee of Ma Tripureswari
Mechanical Workshop, House Assistant and she was also engaged running a
Tiffin House. It was stated that she was earning Rs.25,000/- per month. After
filing of the claim petition notices were served upon the opposite parties. Both
the opposite parties No.1 and 2 (owner of the offending vehicle and the
insurer of the vehicle respectively) submitted written statement before the
tribunal and challenged the claim petition.
[3]
The O.P. No.1, owner of the offending vehicle has contested the
suit by filing written statement and apart from denying all the allegations has
contended that he is the owner of the offending vehicle and that at the time of
accident the driver drove the vehicle having valid driving licence and that the
vehicle was insured with the O.P. No.2, the National Insurance Co. Ltd. (the
appellant herein). Therefore, O.P. No.1, urged for fixing the liability on his
insurer to pay the compensation, if any.
The O.P. No. 2, the insurance company through their written
statement have denied all the allegations and thereby put the claimant
petitioners as well as the O.P. No.1 in strict proof of their respective claims.
[4]
With a view to decide the claim of the claimant petitioners
following issues were framed by the Motor Accident Claims Tribunal, West
Tripura, Agartala:
“I S S U E S
(1) Whether Sudha Debnath died in a vehicular accident occurred
on 22.12.2020 at about 7.30 a.m. at Shibnagar College Road,
Agartala near Bandhan Bieybari under East Agartala P.S. West
Tripura District due to rash and negligent driving of vehicle
bearing No. TR-01-AS-0265 (Maruti Suzuki Swift) by its driver?
(2)
Whether
representatives
the
of
claimant
the
petitioners
deceased,
are
being
the
entitled
legal
to
get
compensation, if so, upto what extent and who shall be liable to
pay the same ?”
[5]
Learned
Tribunal
on
consideration
of
all
the
facts
and
circumstances and on perusal of material evidence available on record,
observed in the following manner:
“O R D E R
13.
(i)
In the result, claim is awarded in following terms :Claimant
petitioners
are
entitled
to
get
the
award
of
Rs.24,41,500/- (Rupees twenty four lakhs forty one thousand five
hundred) only along with 9% simple interest per annum from the
date of the petition i.e. w.e.f. 28.01.2021 till the date of realization
thereof from the O.P. No.2 the National Insurance Co. Ltd.
(ii) 40% of the award of all the claimants be invested by
purchasing separate Fixed Deposit Certificates from Nationalised
Bank for a period of five years with auto renewal facility and the
claimant petitioners shall open savings account in the same bank.
No loan or advance or pre-mature withdrawal shall be allowed
without prior sanction of this Tribunal. The interest accrued on the
fixed deposit certificates shall be directly transmitted to the
individual savings accounts by the concerned bank. The concerned
bank shall retain the original fixed deposit certificates and the
copies of the certificates to be handed to all the claimant
petitioners.
The
claimant
petitioners
are
directed
to
submit
photocopies of their bank pass book.
(iii) The O.P. No.2 National Insurance Co. Ltd. shall deposit the
amount so ordered along with interest thereon within one month
to this Tribunal from the date of the order.
(iv) Copy of this order so awarded to be served upon the parties
not later than 15 days from the date of this award.
(v) The case stands disposed on contest……..”
[6]
Aggrieved by the award delivered on 10.04.2023, the appellant
herein has approached this Court seeking following reliefs:
a) Admit the appeal;
b) Call for the records of case No. T.S.(MAC) 23 of 2021 from the Court of learned
Motor Accident Claims Tribunal, Court No.4, West Tripura, Agartala.
c) Stay the operation of the impugned award dated 10.04.2023 passed in T.S.(MAC) 23
of 2021.
d) After hearing the parties be kind enough to set aside/quash/modify the impugned
award appealed against.
[7]
Heard Mr. Samrat Kar Bhowmik, learned senior counsel appearing
along with Mr. J. Das, learned counsel for the appellant insurance company.
Also heard Mr. Kundan Pandey, learned counsel representing the claimantrespondents. Perused the record.
[8]
Mr. Samrat Kar Bhowmik, learned senior counsel appearing for the
appellant-insurance company submits that without any documentary evidence
and only on the basis of pleadings, learned Tribunal wrongly computed the
earning of the deceased to be Rs.25,000/- per month and passed an award of
Rs.24,41,500/-. He further contends that learned Tribunal failed to appreciate
that since the deceased was 60 years old, 10% of income should not have
been added as future prospect. He also submits that the 9% per annum
simple interest as fixed by the learned Tribunal on the awarded amount is
much higher than the prevailing bank interest. He, therefore, urges before
this Court that the compensation as awarded by the learned Tribunal to the
claimant-respondents is liable to be set aside.
[9]
On the contrary, Mr. Kundan Pandey, learned counsel representing
the claimant-respondents prays before this Court that the award passed by
the Tribunal should not be interfered with and the instant appeal filed by the
appellant insurance company be dismissed.
[10]
Having
perused
the
entire
record
and
upon
hearing
the
submissions advanced by the learned counsel appearing for the parties, this
Court is of the view that in the absence of documentary proof adduced by the
claimant-respondents on the income of the deceased, learned tribunal fixed
the income of the deceased as Rs.25,000/- per month. This Court is of the
view that in the absence of documentary proof of income of the deceased, the
principle as laid down in
Ramachandrappa v. Royal Sundaram Alliance
Insurance Co. Ltd., be followed by fixing a notional income @ Rs.10,000/per month.
[11]
On perusal of record, it is revealed that at the time of death, the
deceased was 60 years old. As such, 10% of the income which has been
added by the Tribunal for future prospect should be deleted.
Except the above discussed two heads (i.e. reduction of income
and deletion of added of 10% of income as future prospect), insofar as, other
heads calculated by the Tribunal are concerned, the same shall remain
unaltered.
[12]
This Court in all the similarly situated matters is fixing 7.5%
interest to maintain uniformity while comparing the bank rate of interest
which is also much less. Thus, this Court is of the view that ends of justice
would be met if the rate of interest fixed by the learned tribunal be reduced
from 9% per annum to 7.5%. per annum.
[13]
Now in terms of the present appeal, the total compensation to be
awarded to the claimants herein is re-calculated which stands as under:
(i) Income per month = Rs.10,000/- only.
(ii)One fourth deduction to be contributed for her personal expenses
(10,000 – 2,500) = Rs.7,500/(iii) Compensation after applying multiplier of 9 (Rs.7,500 X 12 X 9 =
Rs.8,10,000/-.
(iv) Loss of consortium = Rs.40,000/ X 4 = Rs.1,60,000/-,
(v) Loss of estate = Rs.15,000/(vi) Funeral expenses = Rs.15,000/[Pranay Sethi case has been followed in loss of estate, loss of
consortium and funeral expenses, which should be enhanced at the rate
of 10% in every 3 years. Thus, the figure stands (Rs.15,000/- +
Rs.15,000/- + Rs.1,60,000/- = Rs. 1,90,000/-) + (10% of 1,90,000/-)
= Rs.2,09,000/-].
(vii) Transportation cost = Rs. 5,000/- (A lump sum amount is awarded
as no document was submitted in this respect);
(viii) Total compensation (Rs.8,10,000 + Rs.2,09,000 + Rs.5,000) =
Rs.10,24,000/-.
Thus, total compensation stands at Rs.10,24,000/- (Ten Lakh
Twenty-Four Thousand only). Accordingly, the compensation is reduced
from Rs.24,41,500/- to Rs.10,24,000/-.
Consequently, the total compensation entitled by the claimants would
be Rs.10,24,000/- (Ten Lakh Twenty-Four Thousand only) along with
7.5% simple interest per annum from the date of presentation of the claim
petition till the date of actual payment.
[14]
In view of the above, the instant appeal is allowed to the extent
as indicated above. Thus, the appellant insurance company is liable to pay the
total amount as awarded to the claimants in TS (MAC) 23 of 2021. The
amount to be deposited within one month from today on the file of the Motor
Accidents Claims Tribunal, Tribunal No.4, West Tripura, Agartala and on
depositing the same, the claimants may file appropriate application to the
satisfaction of the Court and withdraw the amount as per law.
As a sequel miscellaneous application(s) pending if any, shall
stand closed.
Draw the decree accordingly. Send down LCR.
JUDGE
Sabyasachi. G.
SABYASACHI
GHOSH
GHOSH
Date: 2024.01.18 17:30:19 +05'30'
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review