Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Page No.# 1/16
GAHC010240972018
2026:GAU-AS:15195
THE GAUHATI HIGH COURT
(HIGH COURT OF ASSAM, NAGALAND, MIZORAM AND ARUNACHAL PRADESH)
Case No. : MACApp./933/2018
NATIONAL INSURANCE COMPANY LIMITED
SUBSIDIARY OF GENERAL INSURANCE CORPORATION OF INDIA,
REGISTERED HEAD OFFICE AT 3, MIDDLETON STREET, CALCUTTA700071, REPRESENTED BY THE DEPUTY MANAGER, GAUHATI REGIONAL
OFFICE, BHANGAGARH, GUWAHATI 781005
VERSUS
SMTI. DALIMI KALITA AND 4 ORS
W/O LATE BIREN KALITA,
RESIDENT OF VILLAGE KHANAMUKH, PO GAUHATI UNIVERSITY, PS
JALUKBARI, GUWAHATI, DIST KAMRUP M ASSAM , 781014
2:SRI KANKAN KALITA
S/O LATE BIREN KALITA
RESIDENT OF VILLAGE KHANAMUKH
PO GAUHATI UNIVERSITY
PS JALUKBARI
GUWAHATI
DIST KAMRUP M ASSAM
781014. TO BE REPRESENTED BY RESPONDENT NO. 1
3:SMTI. THANESWARI KALITA
W/O LATE THANESWAR KALITA
RESIDENT OF VILLAGE KHANAMUKH
PO GAUHATI UNIVERSITY
PS JALUKBARI
GUWAHATI
DIST KAMRUP M ASSAM
781014
Page No.# 2/16
4:SRI BHASKAR CHOUDHURY
S/O NARENDRA NATH CHOUDHURY
EAST GOSALA PO MALIGAON
PS JALUKBARI
DIST KAMRUP ASSAM
781011. OWNER
5:MD. HIKMAT KHAN
S/O LATE NOROSAN ALI
VILLAGE SATRA KANARA
PO SATRAKANARO BAZAR
PS BAGHBAR
DIST BARPETA
ASSAM
781308
DRIVE
Advocate for the Petitioner
: MS. R D MOZUMDAR, MR. S P SHARMA,MS. C MOZUMDAR
Advocate for the Respondent : MR. S RAHMAN (R1-R3), MRS. M SAIKIA (R-1,2,3),MR. M U
MAHMUD (R-1,2,3),MR. Z IQBAL (R1-R3),MR. S MUKTAR
:::BEFORE:::
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE KARDAK ETE
Date on which judgment is reserved
: N/A
Date of pronouncement of judgment
: 08.10.2026
Whether the pronouncement is of
the operative of the judgment?
: No
Whether the full judgment has been
pronounced?
: Yes
Page No.# 3/16
JUDGMENT & ORDER (ORAL)
Heard Ms. R. D. Mozumdar, learned counsel for the appellant. Also heard
Mr. M. U. Mahmud, learned counsel for respondent Nos.1, 2 & 3. None appears
for respondent Nos. 4 and 5, despite service of notice. It is also noticed that
respondent Nos. 4 and 5 did not appear before the learned Tribunal to contest
the claim.
2.
This appeal has been preferred against the judgment and award dated
26.07.2018, passed by the learned Member, Motor Accident Claims Tribunal No.
3, Kamrup (M), Guwahati, in MAC Case No. 794/2016, whereby the learned
Tribunal has awarded a sum of Rs. 14,80,000/- (Rupees fourteen lakh eighty
thousand) only as compensation to the respondent Nos. 1, 2 & 3/claimants on
account of the death of Biren Kalita in a motor vehicle accident, with a direction
to the appellant-National Insurance Company Limited to pay 50% of the
awarded amount along with interest at the rate of 7.5% per annum from the
date of filing of the claim petition till realization, and the remaining 50% to be
paid by the owner of the offending vehicle, with liberty to the appellantinsurance company to recover the amount so paid from the owner of the
vehicle.
3.
The case of the claimants, in brief, is that on 06.03.2016 at about 10:30
a.m., Biren Kalita was travelling as a pillion rider on a motorcycle bearing
registration No. AS-01-BV-2330 from Jalukbari towards Azara. When the
motorcycle reached near Azara Fish Market on NH-37, a Tata Magic bearing
registration No. AS-25-AC-0427, coming from the same direction, was being
driven in a rash and negligent manner and dashed the motorcycle from behind.
Page No.# 4/16
As a result of the accident, Biren Kalita sustained grievous injuries and was
immediately shifted to Narayana Hospital for treatment. However, he succumbed
to his injuries on 09.03.2016 while undergoing treatment. Thereafter, his postmortem examination was conducted at Gauhati Medical College and Hospital. In
connection with the accident, Azara P.S. Case No. 107/2016 was registered and
upon investigation, charge-sheet was laid against the driver of the offending
vehicle.
4.
The respondent Nos. 1, 2 and 3, being the wife, minor son and mother of
the deceased, respectively, instituted the claim proceeding under Section 166 of
the Motor Vehicles Act, 1988, seeking compensation on account of the death of
Biren Kalita. It was stated that at the time of the accident, the deceased was
aged about 45 years and was earning approximately Rs. 12,000/- per month
from his employment at STD Bricks Industry, Azara, and was the sole bread
earner of the family. The offending Tata Magic was stated to be insured with the
appellant-National Insurance Company Limited.
5.
The owner and driver of the offending vehicle, arrayed as opposite party
Nos. 1 and 2 before the learned Tribunal, did not contest the proceeding and
the case proceeded ex parte against them. However, the appellant contested
the claim by filing its written statement. The learned Tribunal, upon
consideration of the evidence and materials on record, allowed the claim
petition and awarded compensation of Rs. 14,80,000/- with interest at the rate
of 7.5% per annum, directing the appellant-insurance company to pay 50% of
the awarded amount and the owner of the offending vehicle to bear the
remaining 50%, with liberty to the appellant-insurance company to recover the
amount paid by it from the owner under the principle of pay and recovery.
Aggrieved thereby, the present appeal has been preferred by the insurance
Page No.# 5/16
company.
6.
Ms. R. D. Mozumdar, learned counsel for the appellant, submits that the
learned Tribunal, having arrived at a categorical finding that there was a
violation of the terms and conditions of the insurance policy on account of the
offending vehicle being plied without a valid route permit, could not have
directed the appellant-insurance company to pay 50% of the awarded
compensation and thereafter recover the same from the owner of the vehicle.
Once a breach of the policy condition stood established, the liability to satisfy
the award could not have been fastened upon the appellant, even to the extent
of 50%, and the direction for pay and recovery is therefore unsustainable in law.
7.
Learned counsel further submits that the owner of the offending vehicle
had violated the policy condition by allowing the vehicle to be operated without
a valid route permit and therefore, the entire liability to pay the compensation
ought to have been fastened upon the owner of the vehicle. The learned
Tribunal has erred in directing the appellant to bear 50% of the compensation
despite having found violation of the policy condition. However, she submits that
in the event this Court is of the view that the appellant is required to satisfy
50% of the awarded amount, the appellant may be permitted to pay the said
amount to the claimants and recover the same from the owner of the offending
vehicle in accordance with the principle laid down by the Hon'ble Supreme Court
in Oriental Insurance Co. Ltd. v. Shri Nanjappan & Ors., reported in
(2004) 13 SCC 224. In the said decision, the Hon'ble Supreme Court, while
directing the insurer to satisfy the awarded amount, permitted the insurer to
recover the amount so paid from the insured through the executing court,
without requiring the insurer to institute a separate suit.
8.
Ms. Mozumdar, learned counsel for the appellant, further submits that a
Page No.# 6/16
similar course was adopted by this Court in MACApp. No. 986/2018
(Oriental Insurance Co. Ltd. Vs. Smt Rekha Moni Phukan & Ors.),
wherein, while permitting the insurer to satisfy the award, liberty was granted to
recover the amount from the owner/insured in accordance with the law laid
down by the Hon’ble Supreme Court in Nanjappan (supra). She submits that in
the said case, this Court, having found a clear violation of the policy conditions,
did not fasten the ultimate liability upon the insurer and while directing the
appellant-insurance company to deposit the awarded amount, granted liberty to
recover the same from the owner/insured, with a further direction to the
learned Tribunal to issue notice to the insured owner and require him to furnish
security for the amount to be paid by the insurer. Therefore, she submits that in
the event this Court upholds the direction requiring the appellant to satisfy 50%
of the awarded compensation, the appellant may likewise be granted liberty to
recover the amount so paid from the owner of the offending vehicle in
accordance with law.
9.
Learned counsel for the appellant also challenges the quantum of
compensation assessed by the learned Tribunal. She submits that in the
absence of cogent proof regarding the income of the deceased, the learned
Tribunal ought not to have assessed his monthly income at Rs. 8,000/- per
month. The learned Tribunal erred in adding 25% towards future prospects,
whereas, the appropriate addition ought to have been 10%. Learned counsel
also submits that having regard to the number of dependants, the learned
Tribunal ought to have deducted 1/3 of the income towards the personal and
living expenses of the deceased instead of 1/4. Learned counsel further submits
that the learned Tribunal has also erroneously awarded a sum of Rs. 1,50,000/towards medical expenditure, although the bills on record establish expenditure
Page No.# 7/16
of only Rs. 84,000/-. Therefore, she submits that the impugned judgment and
award, particularly to the extent of fastening 50% of the liability upon the
appellant-insurance company in respect of the award of Rs. 14,80,000/- along
with interest at the rate of 7.5% per annum, is contrary to law and the settled
principles governing the liability of an insurer in cases of breach of policy
conditions.
10.
Mr. M. U. Mahmud, learned counsel for respondent Nos. 1, 2 & 3, submits
that the direction issued by the learned Tribunal requiring the appellantinsurance company to satisfy 50% of the awarded compensation ought not to
be interfered with, particularly having regard to the beneficial object of the
Motor Vehicles Act and the settled principle that the interest of the claimants
should not be prejudiced on account of a dispute between the insurer and the
owner of the offending vehicle. He submits that even where a breach of the
terms and conditions of the policy is alleged, the insurer may be directed to
satisfy the award in the first instance and thereafter recover the amount from
the owner in accordance with law.
11.
Learned counsel for the respondents has relied upon the judgment of the
Hon'ble Supreme Court in Sunita & Ors. v. United India Insurance Co. Ltd.
& Ors., reported in 2025 0 Supreme(SC) 1085, to contend that even in a
case where the Insurance Company disputes its liability on the ground of
violation of the policy conditions or non-coverage of the risk, the principle of
“pay and recover” can be invoked so as to protect the interest of the third-party
claimants. He submits that in the said case, in spite of the Insurance Company's
plea that the offending vehicle was being used without a valid permit,
registration and fitness certificate and that the driver was not holding a valid
licence, the Hon'ble Supreme Court directed the Insurance Company to
Page No.# 8/16
indemnify the compensation amount awarded by the Tribunal and permitted it
to recover the same from the owner of the offending vehicle.
12.
Mr. Mahmud, learned counsel, has further placed reliance upon the
judgment of the Hon'ble Supreme Court in Reliance General Insurance
Company Ltd. v. Om Parkash & Ors., reported in 2026 LiveLaw (SC) 742,
to submit that the owner of the vehicle has a duty to ensure that the driver
possesses a valid driving licence and where there is a breach of the policy
condition on account of the owner permitting an unlicensed driver to operate
the vehicle, the ultimate burden of satisfying the award may be placed upon the
owner and driver. Learned counsel submits that even in such circumstances, the
principle of “pay and recover” has been recognized, thereby ensuring that the
claimants receive the awarded compensation without being required to litigate
the dispute between the insurer and the insured. Therefore, he submits that if
the appellant-insurance company is required to satisfy 50% of the awarded
compensation in terms of the impugned judgment and award, the same may
appropriately be followed by recovery from the owner in accordance with law.
Thus, he submits that the direction of the learned Tribunal requiring the
appellant-insurance company to satisfy 50% of the awarded compensation, with
liberty to recover the amount from the owner of the offending vehicle, does not
call for interference and as such, the present appeal is liable to be dismissed.
13.
Considered the submissions of learned counsel for the parties and also
perused the materials available on record, including the impugned judgment
and award dated 26.07.2018, passed by the learned Member, Motor Accident
Claims Tribunal No. 3, Kamrup (M), Guwahati, in MAC Case No. 794/2016.
14. The respondent Nos. 1, 2 and 3, being the wife, minor son and mother of
the deceased Biren Kalita, respectively, have filed a claim petition claiming
Page No.# 9/16
compensation on account of his death in the motor vehicle accident. The case of
the claimants was that on 06.03.2016, while the deceased was travelling as a
pillion rider on a motorcycle bearing registration No. AS-01-BV-2330, a Tata
Magic bearing registration No. AS-25-AC-0427, coming from the same direction,
dashed the motorcycle from behind due to rash and negligent driving of its
driver. As a result, the deceased sustained grievous injuries and subsequently
succumbed to the same on 09.03.2016 while undergoing treatment at Narayana
Hospital.
15. In support of their claim, claimant No. 1, Dalimi Kalita, examined herself
as PW-1. She had deposed that the deceased was her husband and at the time
of the accident, he was aged about 45 years and was earning approximately Rs.
12,000/- per month from his employment at STD Bricks Industry, Azara. She
further deposed regarding the manner of occurrence and the treatment
undergone by the deceased following the accident. She produced the accident
information report, medical documents, post-mortem report, certified copy of
the FIR, charge-sheet and other documents, including the salary certificate,
which were exhibited before the learned Tribunal. The claimants also examined
PW-2, Md. Rashid Ahmed, who claimed to be an eye-witness to the occurrence.
He deposed that the Tata Magic bearing registration No. AS-25-AC-0427 was
being driven in a rash and negligent manner and dashed the motorcycle bearing
registration No. AS-01-BV-2330 from behind, resulting in serious injuries to the
deceased.
16.
On the other hand, the appellant-insurance company examined DW-1,
Debajit Barkakati, its investigator. He deposed regarding the verification of the
driving licence of the driver of the offending vehicle and the route permit of the
vehicle. According to his evidence, the driving licence of the driver, Hikmat
Page No.# 10/16
Khan, was valid only up to 10.01.2012 and the route permit of the offending
vehicle had also expired prior to the date of the accident. He accordingly
deposed that the offending vehicle was being driven without a valid driving
licence and permit at the relevant time, resulting in violation of the terms and
conditions of the insurance policy. However, in his cross-examination, he
admitted that the insurance policy covered the offending vehicle at the relevant
time and no document had been produced to show that the owner of the
vehicle had been informed by the insurance company about the alleged
invalidity of the driver's licence.
17. Upon consideration of the evidence and materials on record, the learned
Tribunal held that the accident had occurred due to the rash and negligent
driving of the driver of the offending Tata Magic and the vehicle was insured
with the appellant-insurance company. However, the learned Tribunal found that
the driver did not possess a valid driving licence at the relevant time and the
offending vehicle did not have a valid route permit. While holding that there was
violation of the policy conditions, the learned Tribunal nevertheless directed the
appellant-insurance company to bear 50% of the awarded compensation and
the owner of the vehicle to bear the remaining 50%, with liberty to the
appellant to recover the amount paid by it from the owner under the principle of
pay and recovery.
18.
As regards the quantum of compensation, the learned Tribunal did not
accept the claimed income of Rs. 12,000/- per month for want of satisfactory
proof. However, considering the age of the deceased to be 45 years, the learned
Tribunal assessed his monthly income at Rs. 8,000/- and added 25% towards
future prospects. After deducting 1/4 towards his personal and living expenses,
the loss of dependency was assessed at Rs. 12,60,000/-. The learned Tribunal
Page No.# 11/16
further awarded amounts under the heads of loss of consortium, loss of estate,
funeral expenditure and medical expenditure, and arrived at a total
compensation of Rs. 14,80,000/-, with interest at the rate of 7.5% per annum
from the date of filing of the claim petition till realization.
19. Upon consideration of the facts obtaining on record, this Court finds that
there is no serious dispute with regard to the factum of the accident, the
involvement of the offending vehicle bearing registration No. AS-25-AC-0427,
the death of Biren Kalita as a consequence of the injuries sustained in the said
accident, and the fact that the offending vehicle was insured with the appellantinsurance company at the relevant time. The learned Tribunal, on the basis of
the evidence of PW-2, the eye-witness, as well as the materials relating to the
criminal proceedings, has recorded a finding that the accident occurred due to
rash and negligent driving of the driver of the offending vehicle. The said finding
has not been seriously assailed before this Court and accordingly, the same calls
for no interference.
20.
The issue which arises for consideration is as to whether, in view of the
finding recorded by the learned Tribunal regarding the absence of a valid route
permit and driving licence, the appellant-insurance company could have been
directed to satisfy 50% of the awarded compensation with liberty to recover the
same from the owner. From the evidence of DW-1, Debajit Barkakati, the
investigator of the appellant-insurance company, it appears that upon
verification, the driving licence of the driver, Hikmat Khan, was found to have
been valid only up to 10.01.2012, whereas the accident occurred on
06.03.2016. It has also come in evidence that the route permit of the offending
vehicle had expired prior to the date of the accident. Thus, the finding of the
learned Tribunal regarding breach of the policy conditions is supported by the
Page No.# 12/16
evidence on record.
21.
However, the learned Tribunal has also noticed that the appellant-
insurance company did not produce any material to establish that the owner of
the offending vehicle had been informed about the alleged invalidity of the
driving licence of the driver. The said aspect assumes significance while
considering the liability of the insurer towards the third-party claimants. In any
event, having regard to the beneficial object of the Motor Vehicles Act and the
fact that the claimants are third parties to the contract of insurance, this Court is
of the view that the interest of the claimants ought not to be prejudiced on
account of the dispute between the insurer and the owner regarding the breach
of the policy conditions.
22. In Nanjappan (supra), the Hon'ble Supreme Court, while considering the
liability of the insurer vis-à-vis the insured, directed the insurer to satisfy the
awarded compensation in favour of the claimants and permitted the insurer to
recover the amount so paid from the insured. The Hon'ble Supreme Court
further clarified that for the purpose of such recovery, the insurer would not be
required to institute a separate suit and could initiate appropriate proceedings
before the executing court.
23. The aforesaid principle has also been reiterated in the recent judgment of
the Hon'ble Supreme Court in the case of Sunita (supra) wherein, despite the
plea of the insurer regarding violation of the policy conditions, the Hon'ble
Supreme Court held that the principle of “pay and recover” ought to be invoked
and directed the insurer to indemnify the compensation awarded by the Tribunal
and recover the same from the owner of the offending vehicle.
24.
In the present case also, therefore, having regard to the circumstances
Page No.# 13/16
noticed hereinabove and the fact that the claimants are third parties, this Court
is of the view that the direction of the learned Tribunal requiring the appellantinsurance company to satisfy 50% of the awarded compensation cannot be said
to be wholly unjustified. However, the appellant-insurance company would be
entitled to recover the amount so paid from the persons liable therefor, in
accordance with law. Such direction for pay and recovery is also in consonance
with the principle laid down by the Hon'ble Supreme Court in Nanjappan
(supra). Accordingly, the appellant-insurance company shall be entitled to
recover the amount paid by it from respondent Nos. 4, the owner, in accordance
with law.
25.
The next question which arises for consideration is with regard to the
quantum of compensation. The learned Tribunal, though did not accept the
claimed monthly income of Rs. 12,000/- for want of satisfactory proof, assessed
the monthly income of the deceased at Rs.8,000/- and added 25% towards
future prospects. Having regard to the age of the deceased, i.e. 45 years, the
addition of 25% towards future prospects does not call for interference. Thus,
the monthly income of the deceased, after addition of 25% towards future
prospects, would be Rs. 10,000/-.
26.
The learned Tribunal, however, deducted 1/4 th of the income towards
personal and living expenses of the deceased on the premise that there were
three dependants. The said deduction requires modification. The deceased left
behind his wife, minor son and mother, i.e. three dependants. Accordingly,
having regard to the number of dependants, 1/3 rd of the income ought to be
deducted towards his personal and living expenses. Thus, from the monthly
income of Rs. 10,000/-, 1/3 rd, i.e. approximately Rs. 3,333/-, is liable to be
Page No.# 14/16
deducted, leaving a monthly contribution of Rs. 6,667/- towards the family.
27. Accordingly, the loss of dependency is calculated as follows:
Particulars
Amount
Monthly income after 25% future prospects
Rs.10,000/-
Deduction towards personal expenses (1/3rd)
Rs.3,333/-
Monthly contribution to the family
Rs.6,667/-
Annual contribution
Rs.6,667 × 12
Multiplier
Rs.11,20,056/-
Loss of dependency
28. The learned Tribunal had further awarded a sum of Rs. 1,50,000/- towards
medical expenditure. However, from the record of the learned Tribunal, it
appears that the medical expenditure bill produced before the learned Tribunal
establishes an expenditure of Rs. 84,155/-. Accordingly, the amount awarded
under the head of medical expenditure is liable to be reduced from Rs.
1,50,000/- to Rs. 84,155/-.
29. Consequently, the compensation payable to the claimants is calculated as
under:
Sl. No.
Heads of claim
Amount
Loss of dependency
Rs.11,20,056/-
Loss of consortium
Rs.40,000/-
Page No.# 15/16
Loss of estate
Rs.15,000/-
Funeral expenditure
Rs.15,000/-
Medical expenditure
Rs.84,155/-
Total
Rs.12,74,211/-
30. Thus, the total compensation payable to the claimants/ respondent Nos. 1,
2 and 3 is determined at
Rs. 12,74,211/- (Rupees twelve lakh seventy four
thousand two hundred eleven) only, instead of Rs. 14,80,000/- awarded by the
learned Tribunal. The said amount shall carry interest at the rate of 7.5% per
annum from the date of filing of the claim petition till realization, as directed by
the learned Tribunal.
31. In view of the foregoing discussion, the appellant-insurance company shall
be liable to satisfy 50% of the aforesaid compensation amount, i.e. Rs.
6,37,105.50/-, together with proportionate interest thereon. The remaining 50%
shall be payable by the owner of the offending vehicle. However, the appellantinsurance company shall be at liberty to recover the amount paid by it from
respondent Nos. 4, the owner, in accordance with law and the principle laid
down by the Hon'ble Supreme Court in Nanjappan (supra).
32. Accordingly, the impugned judgment and award dated 26.07.2018, passed
by the learned Member, Motor Accident Claims Tribunal No. 3, Kamrup (M),
Guwahati, in MAC Case No. 794/2016, stands modified to the extent indicated
hereinabove. The appellant-National Insurance Company Ltd. shall deposit its
50% share of the compensation, along with proportionate interest, before the
Page No.# 16/16
learned Tribunal within a period of 4 (four) weeks from the date of receipt of a
certified copy of this judgment. Upon such deposit, the learned Tribunal shall
disburse the amount to the claimants upon proper verification and identification.
33. The appellant-insurance company shall be entitled to recover the amount
so deposited and paid to the claimants from respondent Nos. 4, the owner, in
accordance with law. For the purpose of such recovery, the appellant shall not
be required to institute a separate suit and may avail the remedy available
before the executing court in terms of the principle laid down by the Hon'ble
Supreme Court in Nanjappan (supra).
34. With the aforesaid modification in the quantum of compensation and the
liability of the appellant-insurance company, the appeal stands partly allowed
and disposed of.
35. The statutory deposit, if any, shall be returned.
36. The Registry to send back the records to the learned Tribunal forthwith.
JUDGE
Comparing Assistant
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review