Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
S/L 4-5
29.06.2026
Court No.9
Swd
IN THE High COURT AT CALCUTTA
CIVIL APPELLATE JURISDICTION
APPELLATE SIDE
FMA 279 of 2026
With
IA NO: CAN/2/2026, CAN/3/2026
National Ins. Co. Ltd.
Vs.
Smt. Pushpa Diger & Ors.
With
COT 37 of 2026
Smt. Pushpa Diger & Ors.
Vs.
National Insurance Company Ltd. & Anr.
Mr. Deb Narayan Ray.
… for the Appellant/Insurance Co.
Mr. Amit Ranjan Ray.
… for the Respondent/Claimant.
1. The learned Advocates for the parties are present.
2. Heard learned Advocates.
3. The appellant before this Court was an opposite
party in a case under Section 166 of the Motor
Vehicles Act, 1988 and is aggrieved by the
judgment and award dated 5th June, 2025 passed
by the learned Additional District and Sessions
Judge, Fast Track, 2nd Court, Purba Bardhaman,
in M.A.C Case No.27 of 2018/143 of 2018.
4. The claimants/respondent Nos.1 to 4 being also
aggrieved by the judgment and award passed by
the
learned
Trial
Judge
has
filed
a
cross
objection.
5. The case of the claimants/appellants before the
learned Trial Court may be summed up thus:
On the fateful date and time the victim was
proceeding
with
his
bi-cycle
along
the
Shyamsundar Road towards Kisen Bazar and
while he reached near Kishen Bazar, at that time
the offending Vehicle bearing No. WB 38Q/7105
coming from the same direction, with high speed,
rash and negligent manner dashed the victim
from behind, resulting the victim fell down on the
ground and sustained severe bleeding injuries on
all over the body and he was removed to
Burdwan
Medical
College
and
Hospital
for
treatment and ultimately, the victim succumbed
to the injuries after a while at 12.10 p.m. on that
day.
Rash, reckless and negligent driving on the part
of the driver of the said vehicle No.WB 38Q/7105
was the sole cause of the pathetic accident. The
victim was the sole earning member of his family
and he used to maintain the petitioners and the
petitioners were solely dependent upon him and
due to sudden demise the petitioners/claimants
have suffered a great loss besides suffering from
pain and mental agony.
6. Pursuant to filing of this case, notice was issued
upon the opposite party. Opposite party vehicle
owner did not contest the case. However, the
opposite
party
National
Insurance
Co.
Ltd.
contested the case by filing written statement.
Issues were framed and evidence was adduced.
7. Learned
Trial
Judge
upon
considering
the
evidence and upon hearing the learned Advocates
was pleased to dispose of the claim application by
observing and directing as follows:“Hence it is,
ORDERED
that the instant M.A.C is allowed on contest
against the Opposite party No. 2, the National
Insurance Company Ltd. and exparte against the
Opposite party No.1, without costs. The claimants
do get an award of Rs.05,98,000/- along with the
interest mentioned above from the Opposite party
No. 2, Insurance Company.
The Opposite party No. 2, National Insurance
Company Ltd is directed to pay the aforesaid
amount of compensation by way of issuing four (4)
account payee cheques, out of which, one cheque
to be issued amounting to Rs. 2,80,000/- in the
name of petitioner 1. Smt. Pushpa Diger, and three
separate
A/C
Payee
cheques
amounting
to
Rs.1,06,000/- each in the name of petitioner No. 2.
Smt Madhumita Diger, 3. Sri Pabitra Diger & 4.
Smt. Kalpana Diger, through this Tribunal together
with interest within three months (90 days) from
the date of this order.
Let a copy of this, Judgment be supplied to the O.P
2, Insurance Company, free of costs for carrying
out the directions embodied in the Judgment, but if
there the petitioners fail to pay the additional
Deficit Court Fees as directed aforesaid, the copy
of the Judgment should not be handed over to the
Insurance Company Concerned and the cheques
issued by the Insurance Company shall not be
handed over to the petitioners.
Let a copy of this Judgment be supplied to the O.P
2, Insurance Company, free of costs for carrying
out the directions embodied in the Judgment, the
copy of the Judgment should not be handed over
to the Insurance Company Concerned if the Court
fees are not sufficiently paid and the cheques
issued by the Insurance Company shall not be
handed over to the petitioners.”
8. The
appellant
National
Insurance
Company
Limited being aggrieved by the judgment and
award passed by the learned Trial Judge has
come up with the instant appeal.
9. The claimants/respondent Nos.1 to 4 being also
aggrieved by the quantum of compensation
awarded by the learned Trial Judge have filed a
cross objection.
10. Heard learned Advocates. Perused the evidence,
adduced and materials on record.
11. Learned advocate for the appellant submits that
there is delay of 28 days in logging the FIR and
thus
the
case
of
the claimant
is
doubtful.
Learned Advocate further submits that this
vehicle is involved in several accidents and there
is every possibility that the vehicle is being
implanted.
12. Learned advocate also submits that the learned
Trial
Judge
without
documents have
considering
taken
into
relevant
consideration
monthly income of Rs.6,000/-.
13. Learned advocate for the claimants/respondent
No.1 to 4 submits that the learned Trial Judge
did not commit any error in coming to the finding
of
rash
and
negligent
driving
by
the
offending vehicle.
However,
learned
Advocate
submits that the learned Trial Judge erred in not
taking into
consideration
personal
expenses
deduction as one-fourth and proceeded on the
basis of personal expenses deduction as onethird. Learned Advocate further submits that the
learned Trial Judge erred in not awarding future
prospect at the rate of 10% per annum, in view of
the decision of the Hon’ble Supreme Court in the
case of National Insurance Company Limited
Vs. Pranay Sethi & Ors. reported in 2017 (4)
T.A.C 673 (S.C).
14. Learned
Advocate also
submits
that
the
compensation awarded should be enhanced. It is
submitted by the learned Advocate that the
married
daughters
are
also
legal
representatives and thus the personal deduction
expenses in respect of married daughters should
also be taken into consideration and one-fourth
shall be deducted as personal expenses.
15. Learned Advocate relies upon the decision of the
Hon’ble Supreme Court in the case of National
Insurance Company Ltd. Vs. Birender reported
in AIR 2020 SC 434 and the decision of the
Hon’ble Supreme Court in the case of Sarla
Verma (Smt.) Vs. Delhi Transport Corporation
& Anr. reported in (2009) 3 WBLR (SC) 700.
16. Upon
hearing
the
learned
Advocates
and
considering the facts of the case this Court is of
the view that with the regard to the first
submission of the learned Advocate for the
appellant that delay of 28 days in lodging the FIR
make the case of the claimant doubtful, it is
decided in different judicial pronouncements that
mere delay in lodging the FIR is not fatal.
17. It is observed in different cases that in Indian
Society, families of the injured person rushes to
hospital and not to police station. Hence, it
cannot be said that delay in 28 days in lodging
the FIR is fatal.
18. With regard to the submission of the learned
Advocate that the vehicle involved is implicated in
several
cases
and
several
claim
cases
are
pending, this Court does not find any such
pleading in the written statement before the
learned Trial Court. No inquiry conducted in this
regard by the Insurance Company by issuing
notice to the driver and the vehicle owner. The
vehicle owner and the driver were also not
examined by the Insurance Company. Thus, the
plea that the vehicle is implanted cannot be
sustained at this stage.
19. With regard to the monthly income of Rs.6,000/the claimants in their claim petition have stated
that the income of the victim was Rs.6,000/-.
Although, no document was filed in this regard
but from the cross examination of PW 1 nothing
can be shaken that the victim was a vegetable
vendor. Considering the nature of the occupation
it is not unusual for a vegetable vendor to
earnRs.6,000/- per month.
20. Thus, this court does not find any error of the
learned Trial Judge to proceed on the basis of
monthly income of Rs.6,000/-. With regard to the
submission of the learned Advocate for the
claimants/respondents Nos.1 to 4, relying upon
the decisions, it appears that in the case of
National
Insurance
Birender (Supra)
Company
Ltd.
Vs.
the Hon’ble Supreme Court
observed as follows:
“15. It is thus settled by now that the legal
representatives of the deceased have a right to
apply for compensation. Having said that, it must
necessarily follow that even the major married and
earning
sons
representatives
of
the
have
deceased
a
right
to
being
apply
legal
for
compensation and it would be the bounden duty of
the
Tribunal
to
consider
the
application
irrespective of the fact whether the concerned legal
representative
was
fully
dependant
on
the
deceased and not to limit the claim towards
conventional heads only. The evidence on record in
the present case would suggest that the claimants
were working as agricultural labourers on contract
basis and were earning meagre income between
Rs.1,00,000/ and Rs.1,50,000/ per annum. In
that sense, they were largely dependant on the
earning of their mother and in fact, were staying
with her, who met with an accident at the young
age of 48 years.
16. The next issue is about the deduction of the
amount receivable by the legal representatives of
the deceased under the 2006 Rules from the
compensation amount determined by the Tribunal
in terms of the decision of threeJudge Bench of
this Court in Shashi Sharma (supra). This Court,
after analysing the relevant rules, opined as
follows: “23. Reverting back to Rule 5, subrule (1)
provides
for
the
period
during
which
the
dependants of the deceased employee may receive
financial assistance equivalent to the pay and
other allowances that was last drawn by the
deceased employee in the normal course without
raising a specific claim. Subrule (2) provides that
the family shall be eligible to receive family
pension as per the normal Rules only after the
period during which they would receive the
financial assistance in terms of subrule (1). Subrule (3) guarantees the family of a deceased
government employee of a government residence
in occupation for a period of one year from the
date of death of the employee, upon payment of
normal rent/licence fee. By virtue of sub rule (4),
an ex gratia assistance of Rs 25,000 is provided to
the family of the deceased employee to meet the
immediate needs on the loss of the bread earner.
Subrule (5) clarifies that house rent allowance
shall not be a part of allowance for the purposes of
calculation of assistance.”
21. In the case of Sarla Verma (Smt.) Vs. Delhi
Transport Corporation & Anr. (Supra) the
Hon’ble Supreme Court observed as follows:
“49. As an earning member, the deceased would
have spent more on himself than the other
members of the family apart from the fact that he
would
have
incurred
travelling/transportation
expenditure
and
other
on
needs.
Therefore we are of the view that interest of justice
would be met if one-fifth is deducted as the
personal and living expenses of the deceased.
After such deduction, the contribution to the family
(dependants)
is
determined
as
Rs.57,658/-
per annum. The multiplier will be 15 having regard
to the age of the deceased at the time of death (38
years). Therefore the total loss of dependency
would be Rs.57,658 x 15 = Rs.8,64,870/-.”
22. In
the
case
of
National
Insurance
Company Limited Vs. Pranay Sethi & Ors.
(Supra) the Hon’ble Supreme Court observed as
follows:
“39. Before we proceed to analyse the principle for
addition of future prospects, we think it seemly to
clear the maze which is vividly reflectible from
Sarla Verma, Reshma Kumari, Rajesh and Munna
Lal Jain. Three aspects need to be clarified. The
first one pertains to deduction towards personal
and living expenses. In paragraphs 30, 31 and 32,
Sarla Verma lays down:-
“30. Though in some cases the deduction to
be
made
towards
personal
and living
expenses is calculated on the basis of units
indicated in Trilok Chandra4, the general
practice
is
deductions.
to
apply
Having
standardised
considered
several
subsequent decisions of this (2003) 3 SLR
(R) 601 Court, we are of the view that where
the deceased was married, the deduction
towards personal and living expenses of the
deceased,
should
be
one-third
(1/3rd)
where the number of dependent family
members is 2 to 3, one-fourth (1/4th) where
the number of dependent family members is
4 to 6, and one-fifth (1/5th) where the
number
of
dependent
family
members
exceeds six.”
23. Upon considering the judicial decisions relied
upon, it appears that the Hon’ble Supreme Court
in the case of National Insurance Company
Ltd. Vs. Birender (Supra) has decided the issue
with regard to legal representative as to who are
entitled to maintain a claim petition. It is well
settled that the legal representatives of the victim
are entitled to maintain a claim petition before
the tribunal.
24. However, from the decisions relied upon, nowhere
it provides that the married daughter is the
dependent of a victim. As the said decisions are
only with regard to the legal representatives and
not with regard to who are the dependents. The
said
decision
Maintaining a
cannot
claim
apply
in
this
case.
petition
by
the
legal
representative is one aspect and claiming of
personal deduction on the basis of maintenance
of dependents is another aspect. Just become,
the legal representatives are entitled to maintain
a claim petition does not give rise to the inference
for all the legal representatives, the personal
deduction will be taken into consideration on the
basis of the number.
25. It is only those representatives who are fully
dependent upon the victim should be taken
into consideration for the purpose of personal
deduction. In case of married daughter, unless a
specific case is pleaded with evidence, it would
not
be
reasonable
married daughter
as
to
a
consider
the
dependent
while
computing compensation and fixing the personal
deduction.
26. Thus, this Court does not find any error with
regard
to
taking
third personal
into
expenses
consideration
one-
to
the
compute
compensation. However, with regard to the future
prospects, this Court finds that the learned Trial
Judge ought to have taken into consideration
10% future prospects considering the age of the
victim and the occupation.
27. Learned
Trial
Judge further
ought
to
have
considered the issue of consortium to the mother.
However, instead of going into the arithmetical
calculation, this Court is of the view that it would
be just and reasonable to enhance compensation
to
the
extent
of
Rs.6,50,000/-
to
the
claimants/respondent No.1 to 4.
28. Hence, this appeal FMA 279 of 2026 with COT
37 of 2026 stands disposed. Judgment and
award dated 5th June, 2025 passed by the
learned Additional District and Sessions Judge,
Fast Track, 2nd Court, Purba Bardhaman, in
M.A.C Case No.27 of 2018/143 of 2018 stands
modified
to
the
extent
that
the
claimants Respondent No.1 to 4 are entitled to
compensation
of
Rs.6,50,000/-
from
the
appellant National Insurance Company Limited
along with interest at the rate of 6% per annum
from the date of filing of the claim case till today.
29. The
appellant
Company Limited
Registrar
National
shall
General,
deposit
High
Insurance
before
Court,
the
Calcutta
Rs.6,50,000/- along with interest at the rate of
6% per annum within eight weeks from the date
of communication of this order. In the event the
compensation awarded by the learned Trial Court
is already deposited the balance amount should
be deposited within eight weeks.
30. The Respondent No. 1 to 4 claimant will be
entitled to withdraw the compensation upon
compliance of all necessary formalities. As the
compensation awarded by the learned Trial Court
is enhanced, the claimants respondent Nos.1 to
4 shall pay the deficit court fee on the enhanced
compensation within four weeks from the date of
communication of this order.
31. Urgent Photostat certified copies of this order, if
applied for, be supplied to the parties upon
compliance of all necessary formalities.
(BISWAROOP CHOWDHURY, J.)
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review