Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
2026:CGHC:7077
NAFR
HIGH COURT OF CHHATTISGARH AT BILASPUR
CRA No. 1651 of 2019
1 - Nastik Dewar S/o Shri Kolta Dewar Aged About 30 Years
2 - Dilwala @ Banda Dewar S/o Shri Kolta Dewar Aged About 25 Years
3 - Kaliram Dewar S/o Shri Ghasiram Dewar Aged About 23 Years
4 - Bhokalu Dewar S/o Shri Fagu Dewar Aged About 24 Years
5 - Gainda Dewar S/o Shri Sahdev Dewar Aged About 20 Years
6 - Ajeet Dewar S/o Shri Kolta Dewar Aged About 20 Years
7 - Bhaira Dewar S/o Shri Ghasiram Dewar Aged About 30 Years
8 - Bihari Dewar S/o Shri Kolta Dewar Aged About 22 Years
9 - Sadhu Dewar S/o Shri Ghasiram Dewar Aged About 40 Years
10 - Kushal Das S/o Shri Tiharu Das Aged About 22 Years
11 - Dindayal @ Deendayal S/o Shri Kolta Dewar Aged About 37 Years
12 - Kolta Dewar S/o Shri Tikra Dewar Aged About 55 Years
All are R/o Ward No.11 Dabrapara Bagbahra, Thana – Bagbahra, Distt.Mahasamund (C.G.)
... Appellants
versus
State of Chhattisgarh Through The District Magistrate Mahasamund,
District Mahasamund, Chhattisgarh
... Respondent
___________________________________________________________
For Appellants
: Mr. Sunil Sahu, Advocate
For State/Respondent : Dr. Surendra Kumar Dewangan, Panel Lawyer
___________________________________________________________
ASHUTOSH
MISHRA
Digitally signed
by ASHUTOSH
MISHRA
Hon'ble Shri Justice Arvind Kumar Verma
Judgment on Board
09/02/2026
1. This appeal has been preferred by the appellants/accused being
aggrieved with the judgment of conviction and order of sentence
dated 07/11/2019 passed by the Sessions Judge, Mahasamund,
District Mahasamund, C.G. in S.T. No.57/2017, whereby the trial
Court has convicted and sentenced the appellants as under :
Conviction
Sentence
Under Section 147 of Indian Penal Code RI for 06 Months
Under Section 323 read with Section 149 RI for 06 Months
of Indian Penal Code (for causing injury
to Sushil Dewar)
Under Section 323 read with Section 149 RI for 06 Months
of Indian Penal Code (for causing injury
to Punaram Dewar)
Under Section 323 read with Section 149 RI for 06 Months
of Indian Penal Code (for causing injury
to Abbu Dewar)
2. The prosecution story in brief is that on 24-08-2016 at 10:00 am,
outside the premises of Bagbahara Railway Station under the
jurisdiction of Police Station Bagbahara, the complainant Sushil
Dewar along with his family members Poonamram, Abbu, Sushil,
Jaikumar, Tarzan (Koto), Khilanga and Sanju were loading their
pigs in the cart, at the same time the accused Deen Dewar, Nastik,
Bihari, Ajit, Hathi, Kushal, Bhaira, Sadhu, Genda, Bully,
Narayan, Bhoklu and Kolta came there together and started
abusing him by saying, "Why are you taking away our pigs?"
They surrounded them and started beating them with sticks. Due
to which Sushil got injured in his left hand and head, Poonamram
in his back, Jaikumar in his left hand and right leg, Abbu in his
head and Sonia in her left cheek. A report of this incident was
lodged by the complainant Sushil at Bagbahara police station on
24-08-2016, on the basis of which a crime No. 167/2016 was
registered against the accused.
3. The prosecution's further case is that all the injured were given
medical treatment, the investigating officer himself and through
the Patwari got a map of the spot prepared, sticks, rods etc. used
in the incident were seized, blood stained clothes were seized, the
seized property was examined by FSL, all the accused were
arrested, after completing the proceedings with all the witnesses, a
charge sheet was filed against all the 12 accused under sections
147, 148, 294, 506, 323, 307/149 of the Indian Penal Code in the
Court
of
Judicial
Magistrate
First
Class,
Mahasamund
(Chhattisgarh), from where the case was committed for trial.
4. The accused have denied the charges against them and stated in
their defence that they are innocent and have been falsely
implicated. No evidence has been presented in their defence
5. In order to prove the guilt the prosecution has examined as many
as 24 witnesses and exhibited 32 documents. The learned trial
Court after appreciating the evidence and documents available on
record convicted and sentenced the present appellants as
mentioned in para 1 of this judgment. Hence this appeal.
6.
Learned counsel appearing for the appellants submits that he is not
pressing this appeal on merits and confining the arguments to the
quantum of sentence only.
He would next contend that the
sentence awarded to the appellants is R.I. for 06 months and out
of that the appellants Nastik Devar, Dilwala Devar, Kaliram
Devar, Bhoklu Devar, Gainda Devar have suffered 15 days of jail
sentence during trial and Appellants Ajit Devar, Bhaira Devar,
Bihari Devar, Sadhu Devar, Kushal Das, Deendayal have suffered
jail sentence of 21 days during trial and Appellant Kolta Devar
has suffered jail sentence of one day thereafter they were in jail
from the date of judgment i.e. on 07/11/2019 and subsequently
were granted bail by this Court on 21/11/2019. He would next
contend that since the incident is of the year 2016 and near about
10 years have elapsed, therefore, it is prayed that the sentence
awarded to appellants be reduced to the period already undergone
by them.
7.
On the other hand, learned State Counsel opposing the prayer of
learned counsel for appellants, would submit that the trial Court has
rightly convicted and sentenced the appellants and therefore, the
impugned judgment does not call for any interference.
8.
I have heard learned counsel for the parties and perused the record of
the trial Court including the impugned judgment with utmost
circumspection.
9.
Perusal of the statements of of PW-1 Rekhabai, PW-2 Sushil
Markam, PW-3 Buggi Bai, PW-4 Tarjan @ Koto, PW-5 Punaram,
PW-6 Abbu, PW-7 Jaykumar, PW-8 Soniyabai and PW-9 Sanju @
Dhaniram, who are the injured and eye-witnesses of the incident
would show that they have consistently deposed that the appellants
formed an unlawful assembly and, in prosecution of their common
object, assaulted the injured persons by means of lathi, danda and iron
rod. Their presence at the place of occurrence is natural; their version
is consistent on material particulars; and nothing substantial has been
elicited in cross-examination to discredit their testimony.
10. The prompt First Information Report lodged by PW-2 Sushil Markam
is proved by Ex.P-16, which lends assurance to the prosecution case.
The place of occurrence stands established by the spot map Ex.P-04.
The seizure of bamboo stick and iron rod at the instance of the
accused persons is proved by Ex.P-01 and Ex.P-02. The seizure of
blood-stained clothes and other articles and their deposit in the
Forensic Science Laboratory are duly proved by Ex.P-14 and Ex.P15. The arrest of the accused persons is established by arrest memos
Ex.P-26, Ex.P-27 and Ex.P-28, and the merg/intimation and related
documents have also been brought on record as part of the
prosecution exhibits.
11. The medical evidence fully corroborates the ocular version. The
injuries sustained by the injured persons were examined by Dr.
Yogendra Chandrakar (PW-22) and Dr. L.S. Prasad (PW-20). The
injury reports Ex.P-22, Ex.P-23 and Ex.P-24, along with subsequent
opinion Ex.P-25, establish that the injuries were simple in nature and
caused by hard and blunt object, consistent with the weapons alleged
and seized.
12. The entire investigation, including preparation of spot map, seizure
proceedings, arrest of accused persons, recording of statements and
filing of charge-sheet, has been duly proved by ASI Shobharam
Bervanshi (PW-24), whose testimony substantiates the procedural
aspects of the prosecution case.
13. Thus, the ocular testimony of PW-1 to PW-9 stands firmly
corroborated by the medical evidence (Ex.P-22 to Ex.P-25), the FIR
(Ex.P-16), the spot map (Ex.P-04), the seizure memos (Ex.P-01,
Ex.P-02, Ex.P-14 and Ex.P-15), and the arrest memos (Ex.P-26 to
Ex.P-28). The chain of evidence is complete and consistent.
Accordingly, the conviction of the appellants under the aforesaid
offences i.e. under Section 147 and Section 323 read with Section 149
(Three Counts) of Indian Penal Code is maintained.
14. As regards the quantum of sentence, considering the nature of the
incident, the absence of intention or knowledge to cause death, the
fact that the appellants are first offenders having no previous criminal
antecedents, that the occurrence was sudden, and further keeping in
view that more than nine years have elapsed since the date of
occurrence as the incident was of the year 2016 and further taking
into account that the appellants have already remained in custody for
about one month, this Court is of the view that the ends of justice
would be met if the sentences imposed upon the appellants for all the
aforesaid offences, namely Sections 147 and Section 323 read with
Section 149 (Three counts) of Indian Penal Code, are confined to the
period already undergone by them. It is ordered accordingly.
15. Consequently, this appeal stands allowed in part to the extent
indicated herein-above.
16.
Appellants are on bail. Their bail bonds shall remain operative for a
period of 06 months in view of Section 437A of CrPC (now Section
481 of Bhartiya Nagrik Suraksha Sanhita, 2023).
17.
The lower court record along with a copy of this judgment be sent
back immediately to the trial court concerned for compliance and
necessary action.
SD/(Arvind Kumar Verma)
Judge
ashu
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review