Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
[ 3378 I
IN THE HIGH COURT FOR THE STATE OF TELANGANA
AT HYDERABAD
THURSDAY, THE TWELFTH DAY OF MARCH
TWO THOUSAND AND TWENTY SIX
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE SRI JUSTICE P.SAM KOSHY
Between:
Narsi Reddy Komatireddy s/o. K.papi Reddy Aged about 61 years, occ.
Business, R/o. Villa No.6, Legend chimes, Gandipet Road, Kokapet, Ranga
Reddy District-500075.
...APPLICANT
AND
1. Mr. susai Manickam chellappa, s/o.Susai Manikam Aged about 70 years,
occ.Retd., Govt, Employee R/o. plot No.443lA3, Road No.2, Film irlagar
Jubilee Hills, Hyderabad-500096.
2. Mr. K.Manohar Reddy, s/o. Late K. samba Reddy Aged about 75 years,
occ.Business R/o 3-43-14s, Krishna puri colony- west Marredpally,
Secunderabad-500026, Telangana.
:
I
I
3. M/s Designhaaus Projects LLP., a Limited Partnership Firm Registered under
the Provisions of the LLP Act, 2008 having lts office at Plot No.8g, Road No.g
Jubilee Hills, Hyderabad Represented by its Designated Partner Mr.Rajeev
Kumar Sharma, S/o.late Deonandan Sharma.
4. M/s.Navanaani Ventures LLP, a Limited Partnership Firm Registered under
the Provisions of the LLP Act, 2008 having lts office at Plot No.7B, Jubilee
Hills Hyderabad, represented by its Designated Partner Mr.Gadde Venkat
Navden, S/o.Sri Buchi Babu.
5. M/s.Tattvam Project LLP., a Limited Liability Partnership Firm, bearing
No.ACB-5451, registered under the provisions of the LLp Act, 200g,
(PAN.AAUFT7615A) having its registered office at Plot No.Bg, Road No.9,
Jubilee Hills, Hyderabad, Telangana - 500033, represented by its Designated
Partner Mr.Rajeev Kumar Sharma.
...RESPONDENTS
i
i
I
i
i
Arbitration Applicafion under Sub-sections (5 & 6) of Section 11 of the
Arbitration and (lonciliation Act, 1996 Rl/w para (3Xi)(c) of scheme
for Appointment
of Arbitrators, 2006 praying that this court may be pleased to appoint an arbitrator
for the purpose of adjudication of the disputes that have arisen between the
Applicant and the Respondents in respect of the MoUs dated 1110412022,
0910712022 and 1Ot1112022 and 2BtO2t20Z3.
Counsel for the, Petitioner:
_S-ri
y. Shreyas Reddy representing
M/s. lndus Law Firm
Counsel for the Respondent No. 1: Sri. Jakkula Sridhar
Counsel for the. Respondents 3 to 5: Sri Amancharla V. Gopal Rao
The Court madr: the foilowing: ORDER
IN THE HTGH COURT FOR THE STATE OF TELANGANA
AT HYDERABAD
THE HONOURABLE SRI J USTTCE
M KOSHY
ARBITRATION APPLI CATION No.222 of 2024
DATE: 12.03.2026
Between:
Narsi Reddy Komatireddy,
S/o. K.Papi Reddy.
Petitioner
AND
Mr. Susai Manickam Chellappa,
S/o.Susai Manikam and 4 others.
Respondents
ORDER:
The instant Arbitration Application under Section I I (5) & (6) of
the Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996 (for short the 'Act') has been
filed by the applicant praying the Coun to appoint an Arbitrator for the
purpose of adjudication of the disputes that have arisen between the
applicant and the respondents in respect of the Memorandum of
Understanding (for short 'N{OU') dated I I .04.2022, 09.07 .2022,
10. 1 I .2022 and 28.02.2023.
!--t
Page 2 of8
2.
Hea.rd Mr. Y.Shreyas Reddy, learned counsel representing
M/s. lndur; Law Firm lor the applicant; and Mr. Gopal Rao Amancharla
V., leame<l counsel for respondent Nos.3 to 5
3.
It is the case of the applicant that the respondent No. I is in
possession of the land admeasuring 5 acres 00 guntas situated at survey
Nos./A/l , 4, and 4AA in Alijapur Village, falling within the jurisdiction
of Manikonda Municipality, Gandipet Mandal, Ranga Reddy District.
Respondent No.l offered to sell the said property to the applicant flor a
total con:;ideration of Rs.90,00,00,000/-. Accordingly first MoU was
executed on 11.04.2022 and the applicant commenced initial work.
However, due to delays in obtaining No Objection Certificates (for short
'NOC') f:om the authorities concemed, the applicant could not complete
the contr,lct within the timeline stipulated in the first MoU leading to
executror
ol' second and third MoUs between the applicant and
respondent No.l. Finally, after regular follow-ups and negotiations with
the authorities concemed, the applicant was able to obtain NOC.
4. It is the further case of the applicant that subsequently the
applicant and respondent No.l including the respondent Nos.2, 3, and 4
Page 3 of8
mutually agreed to jointly develop the said propefty and entered into an
fourth MoU dated 28.02.2023 outlining the work to be completed by
15.05.2023. Pursuant to the said MoU dated 28.02.2A23 the applicant
paid Rs.10,00,00,000/- which was duly acknowledged by respondent
No.1 and the remaining balance of Rs.24,00,00,000/- was to be paid by
agreement holders including applicant and respondent No.2 to
respondent No.l .
5.
It is the further case of the applicant that on t3.04.2023 the
respondent No.l issued a notice stating cancellation of the three MoUs
without any reference to the fourth MoU. According to the applicant, in
the said notice respondent No.l undertook to repay a sum of
Rs.15,00,04,0001-. However, only Rs.4,95,04,000/- was paid and the rest
of the amount was withheld. tt is further said that on 09.05.2023, the
respondent No.l issued another letter stating that respondent No.3
approached respondent No.1 dernanding Rs.10,00,00,000/- which
according to respondent No.l was lent by the applicant.
6.
The applicant contended that the respondent No.l has no right
whatsoever to retain the aforementioned amounts or to cancel the three
Page 4 of8
MoUs. Ttre applicant also contended that since the foufth MoU contains
an arbitralion clause i.e. clause 10, he had invoked the same. However,
durintg the pendency of the proceedings before the concerned Court, the
responderrt No.l had entered into a new Development Agreement-cum-
General l)ower of Attorney dated 28.06.2023, which was executed in
favour of respondent No.5. The respondent No.l also executed a deed of
simple mortgage, dated 29.02.2024 in the favour of HMDA in order to
obtain construction permissions.
7.
[t was the contention of the applicant that although notice was
issued to the respondents, none of them appeared which resulted in
initiation of arbitration proceeding with the help of a former Judge of the
Andhra F'radesh High Court as Arbitrator. However, the respondents did
not respond to the notice issued by the Arbitrator as well. Therefore, the
applicant was leflt with no other option but to approach this Court
seeking the appointment of an Arbitrator to resolve the inter se disputes
between the parlies herein
8.
Orr the other hand, the respondents submit that the MoUs relied
upon by the applicant were validly terminated. It is further contended
Page 5 of8
that the amounts received from the applicant were dealt with strictly in
accordance with the agreements entered into between the parties, and
that no amount is illegally retained. tt is further contended that the
invocation of arbitration clause by the applicant is untenable, as the
disputes raised are not arbitrable.
9.
Having gone through the pleadings in detail, contentions put forth
on either side, and on perusal of records, undisputedly there is an
arbitration clause in the MoU to resolve the dispute by way of
arbitration. tt would be trite at this juncture to take note of the arbitration
clause which is reflected in the MoU dated 28.02.2023. For ready
reference, the arbitration clause i.e. clause l0 of the MoU dated
28.02.2023 is reproduced hereunder, viz.,
"10. If any dispute or difference arises out of or in conncctitm wilh
this Memorandum of Understanding or validiy,. inlerprctcttion.
implementalion or alleged breach of any of the provisions o-f this
Memorandtmt of Underslanding or unylhing done or omilted lo bc
done pursuant to this MOIJ shall us.far as pos.sible be rcsolved b.t'
mutual consultation or negoliations. If the parlies fail to rcach any'
settlcment by mutual consultation or negotiation v'ithin 30 du1's aJter
commencement of the negoliations or such longer period as lhe
parties moy agree in u,riting, then in that event lhe same shall be
Page 6 of8
re.f:rred .for seillement hr- arbitration as per the provisions of
Artiitration utul ('<tnciliution Act. I996. "
A plain reading of the aforesaid clause makes it amply clear that
any dispute arising out of or relating to the MoU, has to be resolved by
way of nr:gotiations and still if the dispute stands unresolved, the same
has to be referred to arbitration in accordance with the provisions of the
Act.
10. Thr: respondents have also not disputed the fact so far as the MoU
being enlered into between the parties. Alt the objections that the
respondents have can be raised before the Arbitrator, which the
Arbitrator is expected to take note of, and decide the same after hearing
both the sides in accordance with law. MoreoveE the arbitration
proceedings would be confined only between the parties who have
entered irrto the Motjs dated 11.04.2022, 09.07.2022, and l0.ll .2022
and shall uot extend to any other parties. If the event of inclusion of the
additiona; parties becomes necessary, the same shall be considered and
decided by the Arbitrator in accordance with law.
Page 7 of8
11. In the given factual circumstances of the case, this Court is
inclined to appoint an arbitrator who shall in tum decide the grievance
and the claims raised by the applicant. In the course of the deliberation,
leamed counsel for the parties accepted the suggestion of Hon'ble Sri
Justice P.Naveen Rao, former judge of this High Court to be appointed as
an Arbitrator and adjudicate the claim raised by the applicant.
Accordingly, this Court appoints Hon'ble Sri Justice P.Naveen Rao,
former Judge of this High Court (#3001, My Home Bhooja, Block-A,
Plot Nos.22-24 & 3t-33, Rayadurgam, Ranga Reddy District, Mobile
No.8374012311) to act as an Arbitrator and to pass appropriate award in
terms of the provisions of the Act. The venue of the arbitration shall be
decided mutually by the parties subject to the consultation and
agreement of the learned Arbitrator. The fees of the learned Arbitrator
also be decided mutually by the parties again in consultation and
agreeffrent with the leamed Arbitrator and the arbitration proceedings
shatl be governed in accordance with the provisions of the Act-
12.
Accordingly, the instant Arbitration Apptication stands a[[owed.
I
I
I
.-!
Page 8 of8
13. As a sequel, miscellaneous petitions pending if any, shall stand
closed. However, there shall be no order as to costs.
SD/- K.SRINIVASA RAO
OINT REGISTRAR
//TRUE COPY"
OFFICER
To,
for the state of
court
1.
r' sri Justice P. Naveen Rao, former Judge of High
Plot Nos. 22-24 & 31-33,
Bhooja, block-A,
i"r*g"i*, (#3001, My Home
District, Mobile No. 8374012311) (By Special
nrGirr#r, R"ng" ieddy_Copy
of affidavit and material papers)
iy6;;;"r) (Along with a
2. One CC to M/s lndus Law Firm, Advocate IOPUC]
3. One CC to Sri Jakkula Sridhar, Advocate IOPUC]
4. One CC to sriAmancharla v. Gopal Rao, Advocate [oPUC]
5. Two CD CoPies
L
HIGH COURT
DATED: 121031202G
THE S
\
.:4;..
o
()
ORDER
3 0
ARBAPPL. [.lo .222 of 2024
ALLOWING THE
ARBITRATION APPLICATION
?o
*
t{ Afl
2[2[
*
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review