Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
GAHC010251742023
2026:GAU-AS:7368
IN THE GAUHATI HIGH COURT
HIGH COURT OF ASSAM, NAGALAND, MIZORAM & ARUNACHAL PRADESH)
CRP(IO)/412/2023
Nareswar Deka,
S/o-Late Lalit Deka,
R/o- Vill.-Konwarpara, Mouza-Rangamati,
P.O.-Mangaldai,
P.S.- Mangaldai, Dist.-Darrang, Assam,
Pin-784125.
-Versus-
…..Petitioner
Mukut Kalita,
S/o-Late Khargeswar Kalita,
R/o- Vill.-Konwarpara, Mouza-Rangamati,
P.O.-Mangaldai,
P.S.- Mangaldai, Dist.-Darrang, Assam,
Pin-784125.
……Respondent
For Petitioner
Mr. A.R. Shome, Advocate.
For Respondent
1.
2.
Date of Hearing
Date of Judgment
:
:
Mr. D.Mazumder, Senior Advocate.
Mr. D.Mazumdar, Advocate.
30.01.2026.
25.05.2026.
BEFORE
CRP(IO)/412/2023
Page 1
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE MRIDUL KUMAR KALITA
JUDGMENT AND ORDER
[1]
Heard Mr. A. R. Shome, the learned counsel for the petitioner.
Also heard Mr. D. Mazumder, the learned senior counsel,
assisted by Mr. D. Mazumdar, the learned counsel for the
respondent.
[2]
This application under Article 227 of the Constitution of India
has been filed by the petitioner, namely, Sri Nareswar Deka,
impugning the order dated 16.08.2023, passed by the Court
of learned Civil Judge Darrang, Mangaldoi in Misc. (J) Case
No.98/2022, arising out of Title Suit No. 01/2021, whereby,
the prayer for amendment of plaint made by the present
petitioner was rejected.
[3]
The facts relevant for consideration of the instant revision
petition, in brief, are that the present petitioner, as plaintiff,
has filed a Title Suit bearing No. 01/2021 before the Court of
learned
Civil
Judge
Darrang,
Mangaldoi,
praying
for
declaration of his right, title and interest over the suit land, as
well as for eviction of the present respondent therefrom and
recovery of khas possession. The relief of cancellation of
agreement and permanent injunction against the present
respondent has also been made therein. During the pendency
of the suit, the present petitioner had filed an application
under Order 6 Rule 17 of the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908,
CRP(IO)/412/2023
Page 2
seeking amendment of the plaint on the ground that the
applicant came to know from the present respondent that he
has got the patta in the name of the present petitioner
cancelled by the ADC Revenue.
[4]
It is further stated by the petitioner that on becoming
apprehensive, when he enquired in the office of the Circle
Officer, Mangaldai Revenue Circle regarding the matter, he
came to know that by Order No. DRC-25/2020/35, dated
12.01.2021, of the Additional Deputy Commissioner and Order
dated 27.01.2021, of the Circle Officer, Mangaldai Revenue
Circle, he came to know that the periodic patta No. 214 of
village Konwarpara, Mouza-Rangamati, which was in the name
of the present petitioner, has been cancelled. Accordingly, he
prayed for amendment of the plaint for including the said
facts therein.
[5]
Mr. A. R. Shome, the learned counsel for the petitioner, has
submitted that, after coming to know about the fact of
cancellation of patta in the name of present petitioner, he
issued notice under Section 80 of the Code of Civil Procedure,
1908, to the revenue authorities, however, no response was
received from them. As such, the petitioner filed an
application under Order 6 Rule 17 of the Code of Civil
Procedure, 1908 for amendment of the plaint and impleading
the government officials as party in the pending suit, so as to
prevent multiplicity of suit. He submits that, since the fact of
cancellation of patta came to the knowledge of the present
CRP(IO)/412/2023
Page 3
petitioner only after institution of the suit, the amendments
sought for by the present petitioner ought to have been
allowed by the trial court.
[6]
The learned counsel for the petitioner submits that, the patta
in the name of present petitioner was illegally cancelled by the
revenue authorities and as such, the amendments sought for
by the present petitioner is necessary to decide the real
controversy between the parties. He submits that, the
amendments sought for shall not change the nature and
character of the suit and it will only prevent multiplicity of the
proceedings. Hence, the amendments ought to have been
allowed. However, by not doing so, the trial court has failed to
exercise the jurisdiction which was vested in it.
[7]
The learned counsel for the petitioner further submits that,
the suit is presently pending at the stage of filing of evidence
on affidavit by the present petitioner / plaintiff and he is yet to
file his evidence on affidavit. Hence, he submits that the trial
is also not yet commenced. He also submits that, even if the
amendment which has been sought for is allowed, the
respondent shall not suffer any prejudice, as he would get a
chance to file additional written statement in response to the
amendment made by the petitioner in his plaint. As such, he
submits that, the impugned order is liable to be set aside and
the amendment sought for by the petitioner may be allowed.
[8]
In support of his submission, the learned counsel for the
petitioner has cited following rulings:-
CRP(IO)/412/2023
Page 4
i.“Baldev Singh and Ors. Vs. Manohar
Singh and Anr.” reported in “AIR 2006 SC
2832;”
ii. “Sanjida Choudhury And Ors. Vs.
Kukoi Chetia And Ors.” reported in“(2023)
3 GLR 323;”
iii. “Secretary to The Government of
Nagaland
And
Anr.
Vs.
Lhousakhotuo
Vumero And Anr.” reported in “(2026) 1GLR
504.”
[9]
On the other hand, Mr. D. Mazumder, the learned senior
counsel, appearing for the respondent, has submitted that,
the trial court had rightly rejected the prayer for amendment
of the plaint considering the facts and circumstances of the
case. He submits that, the petitioner had taken an advance
amount of Rs.15,00,000/- (Rupees Fifteen Lakhs only) from
the present respondent by executing an agreement to sell the
suit land in favour of the present respondent. The possession
of the suit land is, accordingly, with the present respondent.
[10]
He further submits that, the petitioner has suppressed
material facts in his application under Order 6 Rule 17 of the
Code of Civil Procedure, 1908. He submits that, the petitioner
was well aware about the proceeding before the revenue
authorities for cancellation of patta, as he was given notice of
the said proceeding. However, he suppressed these facts from
CRP(IO)/412/2023
Page 5
the trial court in his application seeking amendment of the
plaint.
[11]
The learned Senior Counsel for the respondent submits that,
the bar under Order 6 Rule 17 of the Code of Civil Procedure,
1908 regarding allowing of the amendment once the trial
commenced has been rightly considered by the trial court.
[12]
He submits that, in the instant case, issues were framed and
the case is fixed at the stage of evidence of PWs. He submits
that, it is a settled legal proposition that trial in a civil suit
commences on framing of the issues.
[13]
The learned senior counsel for the respondent also submits
that, in the proposed amendment, the relief is sought for
against the revenue authorities and the cause of action is also
different, i.e., the cancellation of patta. Hence, if the proposed
amendment is allowed, it will change the nature and character
of the pending suit between the parties. He, therefore,
submits that, trial court has rightly rejected the prayer for
amendment of the plaint.
[14]
The learned senior counsel for the respondent also submits
that, since the petitioner was aware of the proceeding before
the revenue authorities regarding cancellation of the patta,
there was also lack of diligence on the part of the petitioner in
seeking the proposed amendment and these aspects were
rightly considered by the trial court while rejecting the prayer
for amendment. Hence, he submits that, the present revision
CRP(IO)/412/2023
Page 6
petition filed by the applicant/petitioner is liable to be
dismissed.
[15]
In support of his submission, learned senior counsel for the
respondent has cited following rulings:i.
“Basavaraj Vs. Indira And Others”
reported in “(2024) 3 SCC 705”.
[16]
I have considered the submissions made by learned counsel
for both sides and have gone through the materials on record.
I have also gone through the rulings cited by learned counsel
for both sides in support of their respective submissions.
[17]
If we go through the impugned order of the trial court, by
which the prayer for amendment of the plaint by the present
petitioner was rejected, it appears that the trial court
dismissed the prayer mainly for two reasons. Firstly, the trial
court was of the opinion that the trial has already commenced
and the petitioner failed to show that in spite of due diligence
he
could
not
have
raised
the
matter
before
the
commencement of trial, and secondly, that the proposed
amendment will bring a new cause of action in the pending
suit.
[18]
Rule 17 of Order 6 of the Code of Civil Procedure is quoted
herein belowfor the sake of convenience.
“17. Amendment of pleadings.—The court
may at any stage of the proceedings allow
either party to alter or amend his pleading in
such manner and on such terms as may be
CRP(IO)/412/2023
Page 7
just, and all such amendments shall be made as
may be necessary for the purpose of
determining the real questions in controversy
between the parties:
Provided that no application for amendment
shall be allowed after the trial has commenced,
unless the court comes to the conclusion that in
spite of due diligence, the party could not have
raised the matter before the commencement of
trial.”
[19]
In the case of “Mohinder Kumar Mehra Vs. Roop Rani Mehra
And Others,” reported in“(2018)2 SCC 132”, the Supreme
Court of India, while considering the bar of amending the
pleadings subsequent to commencement of trial, has observed
as follows:“14. By Amendment Act 46 of 1999, with a
view to shortage litigation and speed of the trial of
the civil suits, Rule 17 of Order 6 was omitted,
which provision was restored by Amendment Act
22 of 2002 with a rider in the shape of the proviso
limiting
the
power
of
amendment
to
a
considerable extent. The object of newly inserted
Rule 17 is to control filing of application for
amending
the
commencement
pleading
subsequent
of
Not
trial.
to
permitting
amendment subsequent to commencement of the
trial is with the object that when evidence is led
on pleadings in a case, no new case be allowed to
set up by amendments. The proviso, however,
contains an exception by reserving right of the
Court
to
grant
amendment
even
after
commencement of the trial, when it is shown that
in spite of diligence, the said pleas could not be
CRP(IO)/412/2023
Page 8
taken earlier. The object for adding proviso is to
curtail delay and expedite adjudication of the
cases.”
[20]
Thus, if in a civil suit, trial has commenced, the bar provided
in the proviso to Order 6 Rule 17 of the Code of Civil
Procedure, 1908 would be applicable. However, there is a
rider to the said fact, i.e., if the petitioner is able to show that
in spite of due diligence, the pleas sought to be incorporated
by way of amendment could not be taken earlier, the said bar
is not applicable. Further, if the trial has not commenced, the
bar provided in the proviso to Order 6 Rule 17 is also not
applicable.
[21]
As to when the trial commences in a civil suit, the question
was answered succinctly by the Apex Court in the case of
“Mohinder Kumar Mehra Vs. Roop Rani Mehra And Others,”
reported in “(2018)2SCC 132”, as follows:“17 [Ed.: Para 17 corrected vide Official Corrigendum
No. F.3/Ed.B.J./104/2017 dated 7-2-2018.] . Although
Order 6 Rule 17 permits amendment in the pleadings
“at any stage of the proceedings”, but a limitation has
been engrafted by means of proviso to the effect that
no application for amendment shall be allowed after
the trial is commenced. Reserving the court's
jurisdiction to order for permitting the party to amend
pleading on being satisfied that in spite of due
diligence the parties could not have raised the matter
before the commencement of trial. In a suit when trial
commences? Order 18 CPC deals with “hearing of the
CRP(IO)/412/2023
Page 9
suit and examination of witnesses”. Issues are framed
under Order 14. At the first hearing of the suit, the
court after reading the plaint and written statement
and after examination under Rule 1 of Order 14 is to
frame issues. Order 15 deals with “disposal of the suit
at the first hearing”, when it appears that the parties
are not in issue of any question of law or a fact. After
issues are framed and case is fixed for hearing and
the party having right to begin is to produce his
evidence, the trial of suit commences.
18. This
Court
in Vidyabai v. Padmalatha [Vidyabai v. Padmalatha,
(2009) 2 SCC 409 : (2009) 1 SCC (Civ) 563] held that
filing of an affidavit in lieu of examination-in-chief of
the witnesses amounts to commencement of
proceedings. In para 11 of the judgment, the
following has been held: (SCC p. 413)
“11. From the order passed by the learned trial Judge,
it is evident that the respondents had not been able to
fulfil the said precondition. The question, therefore,
which arises for consideration is as to whether the trial
had commenced or not. In our opinion, it did. The
date on which the issues are framed is the date of first
hearing. Provisions of the Code of Civil Procedure
envisage taking of various steps at different stages of
the proceeding. Filing of an affidavit in lieu of
examination-in-chief of the witness, in our opinion,
would amount to “commencement of proceeding”.”
[22]
Thus, from the observations of the Apex Court in the
aforesaid judgment, it is clear that after issues are framed and
case is fixed for hearing and the party having right to begin is
to produce his evidence, the suit commences. It also appears
that filing of an affidavit in lieu of examination chief of the
witness would also amount to commencement of the
CRP(IO)/412/2023
Page 10
proceeding. In the instant case, however, it appears that
though the issues have been framed and the case was fixed
on six consecutive dates for filing of the examination-in-chief
by the plaintiff, i.e., on 26.04.2022, 27.05.2022, 29.06.2022,
02.08.2022,
19.09.2022
and 06.12.2022,
however,
the
petitioner instead of filing his evidence on affidavit on
06.12.2022 had filed the amendment petition on 06.12.2022.
Thus, in the instant case, the petitioner has yet to file his
evidence on affidavit, as such the trial cannot be said to have
commenced within the meaning of the word as used in
proviso to under Order 6 Rule 17 of the Code of Civil
Procedure, 1908.
[23]
The purpose of not allowing the amendment of plaint
subsequent to the commencement of trial, i.e., when the
evidence is led on pleadings in a case, is that no new case is
allowed to be set up by way of amendments, as same may be
prejudicial to the other side. However, as in the instant case,
strictly speaking, the evidence on affidavit by the plaintiff’s
side is yet to be filed, therefore, for the purpose of deciding
the question as to whether proviso to Order 6 Rule 17 of the
Code of Civil Procedure, 1908 would be applicable or not, this
court is of considered opinion that the trial may not be
regarded as having been commenced in the instant case,
therefore, said bar may not be applicable.
[24]
Further, all amendments are to be allowed, which, are
necessary for determining the real question in controversy
CRP(IO)/412/2023
Page 11
provided it does not cause injustice or prejudice to the other
side. This appears to be mandatory requirement as it is
apparent from the use of word “shall” in the later part of
Order 6 Rule 17 of the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908. Further,
the prayer for amendment is also required to be allowed to
avoid multiplicity of proceedings provided that proposed the
amendment does not result in injustice.
[25]
In the instant case, though belatedly the petitioner has sought
for amendment in his plaint, however, by allowing the same,
the multiplicity of the proceedings may be avoided. Whether
after amendment he has a good case or not is to be decided
in the trial. However, for the limited purpose of deciding the
question as to whether the amendment is required to be
allowed or not, this court is of considered opinion that since
the amendments sought to be incorporated are also
connected with the suit land and it would certainly avoid
multiplicity of proceedings. Same is required to be allowed.
However, since much delay has been caused in seeking
amendment of the plaint by the petitioner, a cost of Rs 5000/(Rupees Five Thousand only) is imposed on him.
[26]
The petitioner shall file the amended plaint before the trial
court on or before 31st of July, 2026 subject to payment of
cost of Rs. 5000/- to the respondent. The payment of cost
imposed hereby shall be condition precedent for acceptance
of amended plaint by the trial court.
CRP(IO)/412/2023
Page 12
[27]
It is also clarified that no further date shall be granted by the
trial court to submit the amended plaint. If any lapse occurs
on the part of the petitioner, it shall be deemed that his
prayer for filing amended plaint is rejected. After filing of the
amended plaint, the trial court shall grant scope to the
respondent/defendant to file written statement against the
amended plaint and proceed with the trial accordingly.
[28]
This revision petition is, accordingly, disposed of.
JUDGE
Comparing Assistant
signed
Munmu Digitally
by Munmun
Boruah
n
Date: 2026.05.27
Boruah 14:03:01 +05'30'
CRP(IO)/412/2023
Page 13
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review