Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
CRM-M-68801--2025 (O&M)
IN THE HIGH
H
COURT OF PUNJAB
JAB A
AND HARYANA AT
CHANDIGARH
ARH
(242)
CRM-M-68801-2025 (O&M)
M)
Date of decision : 16.02.2026
NARESH KUMA
UMAR
... Petitioner
oner
Versus
STATE OF PUNJAB
PUNJ
...Respondent
dent
CORAM: HON'BLE
HON
MRS. JUSTICE MANIS
ANISHA BATRA
Present:
Mr.. Vivek
V
Salathia, Advocate for
or the petitioner
Mr. Roshandeep
R
Singh, AAG, Punjab
****
MANISHA BATR
BATRA, J. (ORAL)
1.
The instant one is the second petition filed by the petitioner under
nder
Section 483 of Bharatiya
Bh
Nagarik Surakshaa Sanh
Sanhita, 2023 (for short “BNSS”))
for grant of regular
regul bail in case arising out
ut of FIR No.52 dated 29.03.2024
registered under
nder Sections
S
392, 342, 506, 120B
20B aand 395 of IPC (Sections 451,
452, 411 of IPC added
a
later on and Section 25 of Arms Act deleted later on)
n) at
Police Station
on Ajnala,
Ajn
Amritsar. The first petition
etition bearing CRM-M-43906-2024
was dismissed
ed as w
withdrawn vide order datedd 24.0
24.09.2024.
2.
The aforementioned
a
FIR was register
egistered on the basis of a complaint
int
filed by the complainant
comp
Surinderpal Sehgal
gal all
alleging that in the morning
g of
29.03.2024, he had
ha taken out his scooter from
om hi
his house and parked it outside.
side.
He was going towards
tow
his house after bringing
ging tthe keys when he was caught
ught
hold of by three
hree youths
y
who were having their
eir fac
faces covered. They pulled him
AMIT SHARMA
2026.02.17 13:53
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this order/judgment.
CRM-M-68801--2025 (O&M)
inside his house,
ouse, bolted the main door and
nd sta
started demanding keys off the
almirahs from
m him
him. They closed the mouthh of hi
his wife Veena with a tape and
tied his limbs.
bs. One
On of them pointed a pistol towa
towards him and threatened to kill
them, if they
y resi
resisted. They had broken the
he loc
lock of the almirahs kept in
n the
house, took out cash
c
amounting to Rs.15-16
16 la
lakhs and gold jewellery kept
therein and after ransacking the entire house,
use, le
left while extending threats
ts to
them. After registration
regist
of FIR, investigationn proc
proceedings were initiated.
3.
As per
p the further allegations,
ns, du
during investigation, a secret
ecret
information was received that the accusedd Paw
Pawan Sharma, Gurpreet Singh,
ingh,
Ashok Kumar
ar and Naresh Kumar i.e. the present
esent ppetitioner were involved in
n the
occurrence. They were nominated as accused.
cused. The petitioner and the co-accused were
re arre
arrested on 02.04.2024 and recov
recovery of total cash amount
nt of
Rs.11,70,000/- out
ou of looted money had been
en eff
effected from them in pursuance
ance
of the disclosure
losure statements suffered by them
them.
Investigation now stands
tands
completed and th
the petitioner alongwith the co-accused is facing triall for
commission of aforementioned
afo
offences.
4.
It is argued
a
by learned counsell for tthe petitioner that he has been
falsely implicated
icated in this case. He was nott name
named in the FIR. No specificc act
had been attributed
ributed to him. The recovery planted
anted uupon him jointly alongwith
h the
co-accused is false one and in fact no recovery
ery ha
has been effected at his instance.
ance.
The trial will
ill take
tak considerable time to conclu
conclude since only 04 out off 23
prosecution witne
witnesses have been examined so fa
far. He has clean antecedents.
ents.
The co-accused
sed A
Amarjit Kaur, Ashok, Monika
ika Sha
Sharma, Gurpreet Singh @ Gopi,
opi,
Amarjit Kaurr @ P
Preet Ali have already been exten
extended benefit of bail. On parity,
arity,
AMIT SHARMA
2026.02.17 13:53
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this order/judgment.
CRM-M-68801--2025 (O&M)
he too deserves
ves to be extended the same benefit.
nefit. It is, therefore, argued thatt the
petition deserves
erves to
t be allowed.
5.
Learn State counsel while placing
Learned
lacing reliance on custody certificate
icate
has argued that taking
t
into consideration the gravity of the allegationss as
levelled against
inst th
the petitioner, he does not deserve
eserve to be extended benefit of bail.
It is, therefore,
re, stressed
stre
that the petition doess not ddeserve to be allowed.
6.
This Court
C
has heard the rival submis
ubmissions made by learned counsel
unsel
for both the parties at considerable length.
7.
The petitioner alongwith the co-accu
accused is alleged to have hatched
ched
a conspiracy and iin pursuance thereof alleged
ed to have committed dacoity att the
house of thee complainant.
com
The petitioner’s incar
incarceration is for a period of 01
year 10 months
nths aand 03 days as on date. It is w
well-settled law that the Court,
ourt,
while considering
dering an application for grant off bail, has to keep certain factors
rs in
mind such ass whether
whet
there is a prima facie case oor reasonable ground to believe
lieve
that the accused
used h
has committed the offence, circum
circumstances which are peculiar
iar to
the accused,, likeli
likelihood of the offence beingg repea
repeated, the nature and gravity
ty of
the accusation,
n, severity
sev
of the punishment inn the eevent of conviction, the danger
nger
of the accused
sed absconding
a
or fleeing if relea
released on bail, and reasonable
able
apprehension
n of th
the witnesses being threatened,
ned, et
etc. However, at the same time,
the period of incarceration
inc
is also a relevant
vant ffactor to be considered while
hile
deciding whether
ether bail should be granted to an acc
accused charged with an offence.
ence.
The Hon’blee Ape
Apex Court has observed in a cat
catena of cases that an accused
used
cannot be kept in
i custody for an indefinite
inite pperiod of time, and the bail
application can be considered on its own merits
erits eeven if it is filed repeatedly.
ly. It
AMIT SHARMA
2026.02.17 13:53
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this order/judgment.
CRM-M-68801--2025 (O&M)
has also been
n held that every day spent in custod
custody can provide a new cause
se of
action for filing
ling a bail application under certain
rtain ci
circumstances. This principle
le is
a part of the broad
broader approach emphasizing that la
law prefers bail over jail, aiming
ming
to balance the
he rights
righ of the accused with the requi
requirements of the criminal justice
stice
system. Reliance
iance iin this regard can be placed
ed on the observations made by
y the
Hon’ble Apex
x Court
Co
in Mohd. Muslim @ Huss
Hussain v. State (NCT of Delhi),
hi),
2023 SCC OnLi
nLine SC 352, wherein itt was observed that the jails are
overcrowded
d and their
t
living conditions are,, more often than not, appalling.. The
danger of unjusti
unjustified imprisonment is that
at inm
inmates are more likely to
o be
hardened rather
ther th
than reformed. Reliance cann also be placed upon Manmandal
dal
and Another v. S
State of West Bengal, Special
ial L
Leave Petition (Criminal) No.
8656 of 2023 dec
decided on 14.09.2023 and Rabdi
abdi Prakash v. State of Odisha,
ha,
2023 SCC OnLin
nLine SC 110, wherein bail was
as gr
granted to the accused who had
been incarcerated
erated for a period of almost two
wo to three years and the trial was
likely to take
ke co
considerable time. By observing
erving that prolonged incarceration
ation
generally militates
ilitates against the most preciouss funda
fundamental right guaranteed under
nder
Article 21 off the C
Constitution.
8.
On analyzing
an
the peculiar facts
ts and circumstances of the present
esent
case in the light of
o the aforementioned principle
nciples of law, it transpires thatt the
petitioner has
as suffered
suff
prolonged incarceration
tion fo
for over a period of 01 year, 10
months and 03 days.
da
The trial is not likely
ly to bbe concluded in near future
re as
only 04 outt of 24
2 prosecution witnesses have been examined so far. The
continued detentio
etention of the petitioner is not likely to serve any fruitful purpose;
pose;
AMIT SHARMA
2026.02.17 13:53
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this order/judgment.
CRM-M-68801--2025 (O&M)
there is nothing
ing on record to show that if released
leased on bail, the petitioner will
ll not
participate in
n the trial
t
or will abscond.
9.
In view
vie of the above discussion,
n, this Court is of the opinion that
hat a
case is madee out ffor grant of bail to the petitioner
itioner at this stage. Accordingly,, the
petition is allowed
llowed and the petitioner is ordered
ered to be released on bail subject
ct to
his furnishing
g pers
personal as well as surety bonds
nds to the satisfaction of the learned
rned
trial Court/Chief
hief Judicial
J
Magistrate/Duty Magistr
agistrate concerned.
10.
In the event of there being anyy FIR
FIR/complaint lodged againstt the
petitioner, itt shall be open to the respondent-State
State to seek redressal by filing
g an
application seeking
seekin cancellation of bail.
11.
It is, however, clarified that thee obse
observations made above shalll not
be construed
d as an expression of opinion of this C
Court on the merits of the case
and shall nott influ
influence the outcome of the trial
ial in aany manner.
12.
Since the main petition has been all
allowed, pending application,
n, if
any, is rendered
ered in
infructuous.
(MA
(MANISHA BATRA)
JUDGE
16.02.2026
Amit Sharma
AMIT SHARMA
2026.02.17 13:53
I attest to the accuracy and
integrity of this order/judgment.
Whether speaking/reasoned:- Yes
Yes/No
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review