Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
IN THE HIGH COURT OF SIKKIM : GANGTOK
(Civil Extra-ordinary Jurisdiction)
WP (C) No. 03 of 2019
Mr. Naresh Kumar Rai
S/o Shri Kharga Bahadur Rai
Resident of Bozogari, Pangthang,
Post Office Gangtok and
Police Station Sadar Thana at Gangtok.
…
Petitioner
Versus
1.
State of Sikkim,
Through Chief Secretary,
Government of Sikkim, Gangtok.
2.
Secretary
Department of Personnel, Administrative Reforms Training
& Public Grievances, Government of Sikkim,
Gangtok.
… Respondents
BEFORE
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE ARUP KUMAR GOSWAMI, CJ.
For the Petitioner
:
Mr. A. Moulik, Senior Advocate with Mr. Ranjit
Prasad,Advocate.
For the Respondents
:
Mr. Vivek Kohli, Advocate General, Sikkim.
Date of hearing
:
01.09.2020
Date of judgment
:
14.09.2020
JUDGMENT
By filing this Writ Petition under Article 226 of the Constitution of
India, the petitioner has prayed for quashing the Order dated 28.09.2018
(Annexure-P5) and for a direction to issue fresh order for promotion. The
petitioner has also prayed for compensation for being subjected to mental
trauma and humiliation.
2.
The case of the petitioner, as presented in the writ petition, is that in
pursuance
of
a
Notification
dated
17.06.2005
(Annexure
P-1),
the
respondent no.1 had issued a common Order dated 26.09.2018, whereby
WP(C) No.03 of 2019
(Naresh Kumar Rai vs. State of Sikkim & Anr.)
the petitioner was promoted on officiating basis along with 193 Group-D
employees serving in various Government Departments to the post of Lower
Division Clerk (LDC). Pursuant to the aforesaid order, the petitioner had
joined
the
post
on
27.09.2018.
However,
by
another
Order
dated
28.09.2018, the officiating promotion order of the petitioner was withdrawn
without assigning any reason and without issuing any show cause notice to
the petitioner and he was brought back to the post of Cook.
3.
It is pleaded that he was promoted on officiating basis after he had
served for more than 20 years in the post of Cook in Sikkim Armed Police
and he had the requisite qualification for being promoted. There were other
Cooks who were also promoted on officiating basis by the said Order dated
26.09.2018 but the promotion order was withdrawn only in respect of the
petitioner.
4.
The respondents no.1 and 2 had filed a counter affidavit, wherein it
is stated that the petitioner was appointed as a Cook in the Sikkim Armed
Police vide Order dated 13.11.1998 under the post of Follower in the GroupD cadre in Sikkim Police and the service of the petitioner is governed by
Sikkim Armed Police Force (Recruitment, Promotion and other Conditions of
Service) Rules, 1989 (for short, the Rules of 1989). Copy of the appointment
order of the petitioner was annexed with the affidavit. At the relevant time,
the petitioner was working as a Cook in Sikkim Armed Police, Pangthang and
the officiating promotion order of the petitioner to the post of LDC was
erroneously and inadvertently issued. The said officiating promotion order
was issued under Sikkim Sub-ordinate (Ministerial and Executive) Service
Rules, 1984 (for short, the Rules of 1984). When a joint representation was
received from the Follower (Cook) of Police Department, respondents reverified the documents of the petitioner whereupon it was realized that the
petitioner was appointed under Sikkim Police cadre and not under any civil
post. In the said officiating promotion order, the petitioner was erroneously
WP(C) No.03 of 2019
(Naresh Kumar Rai vs. State of Sikkim & Anr.)
shown as Office Attendant while he was, in fact, a Cook under Sikkim Armed
Police. An Assured Career Progression Scheme (ACPS) and a Modified
Assured Career Progression Scheme (ACPS) were issued under revised Office
Memorandum dated 18.08.2018, extending the same to the Follower of
Sikkim Police. That apart, a Notification dated 21.01.2019 was issued
notifying uniform promotion avenues for the Follower under Sikkim Police
service.
5.
A rejoinder affidavit was filed by the petitioner stating that that the
officiating promotion was given to all Government servants in Group-D
working in various departments and the persons who were appointed along
with the petitioner vide Order dated 13.11.1998 were not considered for
promotion because they did not possess the basic educational qualification of
Class-X pass. It is also stated that neither in the Order dated 13.11.1998 nor
in the Rules of 1989, the post of Cook is termed as Follower and that the
Rules of 1989 do not cover promotion of Office Attendant/Cook and the post
of Office Attendant/ Cook does not fall under the Rules of 1989.
6.
Mr. A. Moulik, learned Senior Counsel for the petitioner, has
submitted that while the other Cooks, who were promoted on officiating
basis, have been allowed to continue, the petitioner had been singled out
and
discriminatorily
treated
by
the
respondents
by
withdrawing
his
officiating promotion order. Drawing attention of the Court to Rule 28 of the
Rules of 1989, which is under the heading “Residuary matters”, the learned
Senior Counsel points out that as there is no provision for promotion of Cook
in the Rules of 1989, provision for promotion, etc., are to be regulated by
the rules and orders issued by the Government from time to time, which are
applicable to the corresponding rank of the Sikkim Police Force.
He has
submitted that by the Notification dated 17.06.2005, in exercise of powers
conferred under Rule 10 of the Rules of 1984, the Government of Sikkim had
relaxed the provision of Schedule-II, under item Grade-IV of the said Rules,
WP(C) No.03 of 2019
(Naresh Kumar Rai vs. State of Sikkim & Anr.)
to promote Group-D employees possessing educational qualification of ClassX pass on seniority-cum-merit basis as well as Daftaries and Barkhandas on
seniority-cum-merit basis and it is on the basis of the aforesaid Notification,
as the petitioner is a Group-D employee having the requisite qualification of
Class-X pass, he was given the officiating promotion. It is contended by him
that the respondents acted illegally and arbitrarily in withdrawing his
officiating promotion without assigning any reason and without issuing any
show-cause notice and, therefore, the order cannot withstand the scrutiny of
law for being in violation of principles of natural justice. Relying on
paragraph 10 of the counter affidavit filed by the respondent nos.1 and 2, he
submits that it is admitted by the respondents that the post held by the
petitioner is a civil post and, therefore, even though he is working in Sikkim
Armed Police, he could be promoted on officiating basis as LDC. It is also the
contention of Mr. Moulik that there must be scope for promotion in a service
rule and in this connection, he placed reliance on the judgments of the
Hon‟ble Supreme Court in the cases of O. Z. Hussain (Dr) vs. Union of India,
reported in 1990 Supp SCC 688 and State of Tripura and Others vs. K.K.
Roy, reported in (2004) 9 SCC 65.
7.
Mr. Vivek Kohli, learned Advocate General, Sikkim, abiding by the
stand taken in the affidavit, has submitted that officiating promotion order of
the petitioner was erroneously issued and, therefore, the same was rectified
immediately within a period of 2 (two) days. He submits that under Section
2(c) of the Sikkim Armed Police Force Act, 1981 (for short, Act of 1981), the
term „Follower‟ is defined and it includes any person appointed to do the
work of Cook, Cobbler, etc. He has submitted that no material is placed by
the petitioner to demonstrate that the Cooks, whose names appeared in the
Order dated 26.09.2018, were also working in the Sikkim Armed Police. He
has submitted that the petitioner was appointed as a Cook in Sikkim Armed
Police and therefore, there is no manner of doubt that the Rules of 1989
WP(C) No.03 of 2019
(Naresh Kumar Rai vs. State of Sikkim & Anr.)
applies to the petitioner. Under the Rules of 1989, there is no post of LDC or
Office Attendant. The Notification dated 17.06.2005 is in respect of the Rules
of 1984 only and the same is not applicable to the members of the Sikkim
Armed Police. It is submitted by him that reliance placed on Rule 28 of the
Rules of 1989 by Mr. Moulik is misconceived as there is no pleading
whatsoever that recourse was taken to Rule 28 while promoting the
petitioner on officiating basis and besides, it was only because of
misconception of facts that the petitioner had been given officiating
promotion. Officiating promotion does not confer any right on the petitioner
and that when petitioner in the Writ Petition has failed to show how he could
have been promoted to a cadre post under the Rules of 1984, it cannot now
be urged by the petitioner that he had been denied the opportunity to show
cause and that there has been violation of principles of natural justice, he
contends. He has placed reliance on the decision of the Hon‟ble Supreme
Court in the case of Gopal Singh vs. State Cadre Forest Officers Assn. &
Ors., reported in (2007) 9 SCC 369.
8.
I have considered the submissions of the learned counsel for the
parties and have perused the materials on record.
9.
The appointment order of the petitioner dated 13.11.1998 goes to
show that the petitioner was appointed as a Cook in the Sikkim Armed
Police. At the very outset, it will be appropriate to take note of Section 2(c)
of the Act of 1981. It defines „Follower‟, which includes a Cook. Therefore,
the contention of Mr. Moulik that the term „Follower‟ is nowhere defined is
not correct. Rules of 1989 was framed under the Act of 1981 and the post of
Cook is mentioned in Schedule-I, reference to which is made in Rules 4 and
5 relating to “Composition of strength of the Force” and “Scale of Pay and
Allowances” ,respectively. In Schedule-I, there is no reference to any post of
Office Attendant or LDC. There is no escape from the conclusion that Rules
of 1989 applies to the petitioner.
WP(C) No.03 of 2019
(Naresh Kumar Rai vs. State of Sikkim & Anr.)
10.
Rule 2(j) of the Rules of 1984 defines „Service‟ to mean Sikkim Sub-
ordinate (Ministerial and Executive) Service comprising of posts mentioned
in Schedule-I for any of the departments and offices under the Government.
A careful perusal of the above definition goes to show that posts mentioned
in the Schedule-I of Rules of 1984 in any of the Departments and offices
under the Government would come within the ambit of service under the
Rules of 1984. Schedule-I of the Rules of 1984 lists posts under the
headings „Ministerial‟ and „Executive‟ and it does not include any post of
Cook.
11.
When the Rules of 1984 were framed, post of LDC was to be filled by
direct recruitment through Open Competitive Examination. Subsequently,
the Rule was amended by Notification dated 29.12.2001, providing for direct
recruitment to the aforesaid post through Open Competitive Examination to
the extent of 85%, promotion to the extent of 5% on the basis of meritcum-seniority from amongst Group-D employees holding grade-I post and
promotion to the extent of 10% through Limited Department Competitive
Examination
from
amongst
Group-D
employees
having
educational
qualification of Class-X examination pass with minimum speed of 15 words
per minute in typing. By Notification dated 17.06.2005, in exercise of powers
conferred under Rule 10 of the Rules of 1984, the requirement of
Departmental Competitive Examination in respect of Group-D employees
was relaxed and Group-D employees along with Daftaries and Barkhandas
were to be promoted on the basis of seniority-cum-merit by Departmental
Promotion Committee.
12.
At this juncture, it is to be placed on record that none of the parties
had thrown any light on who are the Group-D employees. However, it is an
admitted position that the petitioner is a Group-D employee. While the post
of Cook is mentioned in Schedule-I of Rules of 1989, method of recruitment
WP(C) No.03 of 2019
(Naresh Kumar Rai vs. State of Sikkim & Anr.)
and other eligibility conditions, which are mentioned in Schedule-II in terms
of Rule 6, are, however, not indicated.
13.
With regard to the submission of Mr. Moulik that Rule 28 of the
Rules of 1989 was taken recourse to while promoting the petitioner on
officiating basis, no factual foundation was laid and in fact, there is no
reference to the Rules of 1989 in the pleadings on behalf of the petitioner at
all. The contention advanced by Mr. Moulik that as the petitioner was ClassX pass, he was promoted on officiating basis in aid of the Notification dated
17.06.2005 is devoid of any merit because of the reason that the said
Notification is applicable to the employees holding posts which are covered
under Rules of 1984 and the petitioner could not have been promoted to a
non-existent post of LDC in Sikkim Armed Police on the strength of
Notification 17.06.2005.
14.
Though not part of the pleadings, the learned Senior Counsel has
placed a copy of Sikkim Police Force (Recruitment, Promotion and Seniority)
Rules, 1981, for short, Rules of 1981 which was deemed to have come into
force on and from 01.04.1974. The aforesaid Rule was framed under proviso
to Article 309 of the Constitution of India. The Rules of 1989, which was
framed in exercise of powers conferred under Section 27 of the Act of 1981,
was to come into force from the date of publication of Official Gazette and
the same was published in the Sikkim Government Gazette (Extra-Ordinary)
on 24.02.1990. Annexure-R5 is a notification dated 26.04.2013 amending
the Sikkim Police Force (Recruitment, Promotion and Seniority) Rules, 2000,
for short, the Rules of 2000. Notification dated 17.11.2017 is also a
Notification amending the Rules of 2000. Mr. Moulik had placed the Rules of
2000. No arguments are advanced by the learned counsel of the parties on
the aforesaid Rules and I have referred to the above Rules only to make the
narration complete and will not dilate on these Rules any further.
WP(C) No.03 of 2019
(Naresh Kumar Rai vs. State of Sikkim & Anr.)
15.
It is not disputed by the petitioner that he was wrongly shown as an
Office Attendant though he was a Cook in the Order dated 26.09.2018.
There is no pleading in the Writ Petition that Cooks, who were promoted on
officiating basis, are employees of Sikkim Armed Police. It was also argued
by Mr. Moulik that one Nar Bahadur Pradhan at Sl. No.20 of the Order dated
26.09.2018 was posted at the Police Headquarter, Gangtok and, therefore, it
is not that none has been promoted and posted in the Police Department.
There is no pleading regarding Nar Bahadur Pradhan and it is difficult to
hazard a guess in absence of any pleading the status of Nar Bahadur
Pradhan and it is also equally difficult to predicate whether Police
Headquarter and Sikkim Armed Police stand on the same footing.
16.
Though pleading in a Writ Petition has to be liberally construed, it is
axiomatic that some foundational facts have to be brought on record in order
to substantiate a plea that the petitioner is discriminated while granting
benefit to similarly situated persons.
17.
Though the petitioner has stated that he had joined on the very
same date on the issuance of the Order dated 26.09.2018, it is not
understood in which post he had joined as there is no post of LDC under the
Rules of 1989.
18.
Contention of Mr. Moulik that in paragraph 10 of the counter
affidavit, it is admitted that post held by the petitioner is a civil post, is
factually incorrect. What was mentioned in paragraph 10 is that the post of
Office Attendant which was mistakenly considered to be the post held by the
petitioner is a civil post. It is also categorically indicated therein that the
petitioner was appointed as Cook in the Group-D cadre of Sikkim Armed
Police. The petitioner, being a member of Sikkim Armed Police governed by
the Rules of 1989, could not have been promoted on officiating basis to a
civil post falling under Rules of 1984.
WP(C) No.03 of 2019
(Naresh Kumar Rai vs. State of Sikkim & Anr.)
19.
In Gopal Singh (supra), the question as to whether a person holding
the post of Assistant Mill Manager under the cadre of A&N Islands Forest
Department would be entitled to have consideration for promotion to the
post of Deputy Conservator of Forests which was an encadred post of Indian
Forest Service, was answered in the negative on the ground, amongst
others, that the post of Assistant Mill Manager was outside the Indian Forest
Service (Recruitment) Rules, 1966 and Indian Forest Service (Appointment
by Promotion) Regulations, 1966.
20.
In Sohan Lal Gupta vs. Asha Devi Gupta, reported in (2003) 7 SCC
492, the Hon‟ble Supreme Court observed that the principles of natural
justice cannot be put in a straight-jacket formula. In a given case the party
should not only be required to show that he did not have a proper notice
resulting in violation of principles of natural justice but also to show that he
was seriously prejudiced thereby. In Karnataka SRTC vs. S.G Kotturappa,
reported in (2005) 3 SCC 409, the Hon‟ble Supreme Court observed that
principles of natural justice cannot be applied in vacuum and the same are
not required to be complied with when it will lead to an empty formality.
21.
Lord Wilberforce in Malloch vs. Aberdeen Corpn., reported in (1971)
2 All ER 1278 (HL) had observed that”………. A breach of procedure …..cannot
give [rise to] a remedy in the courts, unless behind it there is something of
substance which have been lost by the failure. The Court does not act in
vain.”
Brandon L. J. opined in Cinnamond vs. British Airports Authority,
reported in (1980) 2 All ER 368 (CA) as follows: “ …… no one can complain
of not being given an opportunity to make representations if such an
opportunity would have availed him nothing.”
The above observations were quoted with approval by the Hon‟ble
Supreme Court in Dharampal Satyapal Ltd. vs. Deputy Commissioner of
Central Excise, Gauhati and Others, reported in (2015) 8 SCC 519.
WP(C) No.03 of 2019
(Naresh Kumar Rai vs. State of Sikkim & Anr.)
22.
Thus, even if it is found by the Court that there is violation of
principles of natural justice, it may not be necessary to strike down the
action and refer the matter back to the authorities to take a fresh decision
after complying with the procedural requirement in those cases when nongrant of hearing has not caused any prejudice to the person against whom
the action is taken. As a corollary, it follows that every violation of a facet of
natural justice may not lead to the conclusion that the order passed is null
and void. The validity of the order has to be decided on the touchstone of
prejudice.
23.
However, it is not open for the administrative authority to dispense
with the requirement of principles of natural justice by itself deciding that no
prejudice is caused to the person against whom the action is contemplated.
Whether opportunity of hearing will serve the purpose or not has to be
considered at a later stage and this aspect cannot be presumed by the
authority. It is now well established that the Courts are empowered to
consider as to whether any purpose will be served in remanding the case
keeping in mind whether any prejudice is caused to the person against
whom action is taken.
24.
In the proceeding before this Court, which was instituted after five
months of passing of the impugned order, the petitioner has failed to, even,
prima facie, show how the impugned order dated 28.09.2018 suffers from a
material defect qua the plea taken by the respondents that his officiating
promotion order was issued on misconception of fact as also how he is
prejudiced because of not being given an opportunity to show cause .
25.
In the facts and circumstances of the case, I am of the considered
opinion that it will be futile and an empty formality to set aside the order
dated 28.09.2018 on the ground of violation of principles of natural justice.
WP(C) No.03 of 2019
(Naresh Kumar Rai vs. State of Sikkim & Anr.)
26.
In view of what has been discussed above, I find no merit in this
Writ Petition and accordingly, the same is dismissed.
27.
However, before parting with the records, it will be appropriate to
record that Mr. Moulik had made submissions with regard to entitlement of a
Government servant for promotion during his service career. In O. Z.
Hussain (Dr) and K.K. Roy(supra), Hon‟ble Supreme Court has laid down
that promotion is a normal incidence of service. However, in absence of
appropriate pleadings and lack of clarity on the Rules placed before the
Court, in order not to cause prejudice to either of the parties, I have not
dealt with or deliberated upon this aspect of the matter. Fact remains the
petitioner had not earned any promotion for last 20 years. Accordingly, while
dismissing this petition, I grant liberty to the petitioner to ventilate his
grievances, if any, on the issue of promotional avenue, in an appropriate
manner and in an appropriate proceeding.
28.
No cost.
Chief Justice
Avi/
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review