Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Page 1
CGHC010366292023
{WPS No.8771/2023}
2026:CGHC:28149
AFR
HIGH COURT OF CHHATTISGARH AT BILASPUR
WPS No. 8771 of 2023
Narendra Kumar Rautkar S/o Shri Bareek Rao Rautkar Aged About 56 Years,
R/o Anand Vihar Colony, Ward No.9, Behind Collector Colony, Kawardha,
District : Kawardha (Kabirdham), Chhattisgarh
... Petitioner.
Versus
1. State Of Chhattisgarh Through The Secretary, Department Of Panchayat And
Rural Development, Mahanadi Bhawan, Mantralaya, Atal Nagar, Naya Raipur,
District : Raipur, Chhattisgarh.
2. Collector Kabirdham, District Kabirdham, Chhattisgarh
3. Chief Executive Officer Zila Panchayat Kabirdham, District Kabirdham,
Chhattisgarh
4. Chief Executive Officer, Janpad Panchayat Bodla, District Kabirdham,
Chhattisgarh
... Respondents.
(cause title downloaded from CIS Periphery)
For Petitioner
:
Mr. Ramesh Nayak, Advocate.
For Res No.1 & 2
:
Mr. Siddharth Sharma with Mr. Ashutosh Shukla,
for State
For Res No.4
Panel Lawyers.
:
Mr. Sangharsh Pandey with Mr. Shrijan Pandey,
Advocates.
For Res No.3
:
None though notice has been served.
(Hon’ble Shri Justice Naresh Kumar Chandravanshi)
Order on Board
08/07/2026
Page 2
{WPS No.8771/2023}
1) By way of this writ petition under Article 226 of the Constitution of India,
the petitioner challenges the order dated 07.08.2023 (Annexure-P/17)
issued by the Chief Executive Officer, Jila Panchayat Kabirdham (Respondent
No.3), by which the departmental enquiry report (Annexure-P/16) was
accepted, finding the petitioner guilty of bypassing statutory rules to propose
the unauthorized and illegal absorption/regularization of 5 daily wage
employees. Subsequently, an order for the recovery of Rs.13,77,869/(Rupees Thirteen Lakh Seventy-Seven Thousand Eight Hundred Sixty-Nine
only) was passed against the petitioner, which is amount of salaries and
arrears disbursed to the said 5 employees. Pursuant to this direction, the
Chief Executive Officer, Janpad Panchayat Bodla, District Kabirdham
(Respondent No. 4) ordered the petitioner to deposit the aforesaid amount
vide order dated 29.08.2023 (Annexure-P/18). Hence, the petitioner seeks
following relief:"10.1 That, this Hon'ble Court may kindly be pleased to
direct the respondents to call the entire records of the case
for kind perusal of the Hon'ble Court.
10.2 That, the Hon'ble Court may kindly be pleased to set
aside the impugned order dated 07/08/2023 (ANNEXURE
P-17) passed by respondent no. 3.
10.3 That, the Hon'ble Court may kindly be pleased to set
aside the impugned memo dated 29/08/2023 (ANNEXURE
P-18) passed by respondent no. 4.
10.4 That the Hon'ble Court may kindly be pleased to grant
any other relief as Hon'ble Court may deem fit & proper in
the circumstances of the case."
2) The factual background of the case is that the petitioner was initially
appointed as a Clerk on a temporary basis in the office of Janpad
Page 3
{WPS No.8771/2023}
Panchayat Bodla vide order dated 26.03.1992. On 07.12.2004, he was
promoted to the post of Assistant Grade-II, and on 24.07.2017, he was
promoted to the post of Accountant in Janpad Panchayat Bodla. On
28.08.2018, a meeting of the General Administrative Committee of
Janpad Panchayat Bodla was held, wherein a regularization order for 5
daily-wage employees was passed. However, one Kaleshwar Sahu
submitted a complaint alleging that irregularities had been committed
in Janpad Panchayat Bodla with regard to these 5 daily-wage
employees and that the regularization order was passed without
following the due process of law.
2.1) Consequent to the said complaint, a show-cause notice (AnnexureP/7) was issued to the petitioner on 31.07.2021 regarding the
unauthorized
absorption/regularization
of
the
said
daily-wage
employees, which was replied to by the petitioner on 08.08.2021
(Annexure-P/8)
denying
the
allegations
levelled
against
him.
Subsequently, vide order dated 19.08.2021 (Annexure-P/9), the
Collector, District Kabirdham suspended the petitioner on account of
alleged negligence in work and financial irregularities. A charge-sheet
was served upon him on 28.08.2021 (Annexure-P/10). The petitioner
submitted his reply (Annexure-P/11) on 13.09.2021, denying the
charges levelled against him. However, the Collector, Kabirdham
(Respondent No. 2) found the reply of the petitioner unsatisfactory and
passed an order (Annexure-P/12) on 16.09.2021 initiating a
Departmental Enquiry against the petitioner. Vide order dated
Page 4
03.03.2022
(Annexure-P/13),
the
{WPS No.8771/2023}
Chief
Executive
Officer,
Jila
Panchayat Kabirdham revoked the suspension of the petitioner on the
basis of application submitted by him and posted him at the office of
Janpad Panchayat Bodla until further orders.
2.2) On 21.04.2023, the Enquiry Officer vide Annexure-P/14 sought an
explanation from the petitioner in respect of the charges leveled, which
was replied to by the petitioner on 27.04.2023 vide Annexure-P/15. On
the same day i.e. 27.04.2023, the Enquiry Officer submitted the
enquiry report to the Collector, Kabirdham vide Annexure-P/16. Based
on the said enquiry report, the Chief Executive Officer, Jila Panchayat
Kabirdham (Respondent No. 3) passed the order dated 07.08.2023
(Annexure-P/17), inflicting the penalty of recovery of Rs. 13,77,869/-,
which is equivalent to the arrears and salaries disbursed to the 5 dailywage employees. Consequently, a recovery order dated 29.08.2023
(Annexure-P/18) was passed by the Chief Executive Officer, Janpad
Panchayat, Bodla (Respondent No. 4), directing the petitioner to
deposit Rs.13,77,869/-1 with Janpad Panchayat Bodla. Hence, this
petition.
3) Learned counsel for the petitioner submits that the suspension order dated
19.08.2021 (Annexure-P/9) and the enquiry order dated 16.09.2021
(Annexure-P/12) against the petitioner were passed by the Collector,
Kabirdham. Even the charge-sheet was issued under the signature of the
Collector, Kabirdham, and the enquiry report was likewise submitted to him
by the Enquiry Officer. However, since the petitioner is an employee of
Wrongly mentioned as Rs.1,33,77,869 in the order dated 29.08.2023 (Annexure-P/8)
Page 5
{WPS No.8771/2023}
Janpad Panchayat Bodla, as per the Appendix to Rule 2(c) of the
Chhattisgarh Panchayat Services (Discipline and Appeal) Rules, 1999
(henceforth "Rules, 1999"), the Chief Executive Officer, Janpad Panchayat
Bodla was the competent Disciplinary Authority. In the present case, no such
order was passed by the competent Disciplinary Authority against the
petitioner, instead, he was merely appointed as the Presenting Officer by the
Collector, Kabirdham vide Annexure-P/12. Thus, the alleged Departmental
Enquiry initiated against the petitioner stands contrary to the law and
procedure prescribed under the Rules, 1999.
3.1) Learned counsel further submits that neither any departmental witness
was examined nor any document was exhibited by the Presenting
Officer/Enquiry Officer during the course of the enquiry. Immediately upon
receiving the explanation from the petitioner, the enquiry report was
prepared and sent to the Collector, Kabirdham vide Annexure-P/16. Thus,
the mandatory procedure prescribed under Rules 7 and 8 of the Rules, 1999
has completely been bypassed by the Respondent Authorities.
3.2) Learned counsel also submits that though the petitioner has been
inflicted with a penalty to deposit Rs.13,77,869/- by order dated 07.08.2023
(Annexure-P/17), no specific charge was levelled against him in this regard.
Moreover, Respondent No.3 - the Chief Executive Officer, Jila Panchayat
Kabirdham imposed the said penalty after obtaining approval from the
Collector, Kabirdham. Since Respondent No.3 was also not the Disciplinary
Authority of the petitioner, the penalty imposed is a direct violation of the
provisions and procedure prescribed in the Rules, 1999. He lastly submits
that since the entire Departmental Enquiry conducted against the petitioner
Page 6
{WPS No.8771/2023}
is against the law and established procedure, the order dated 07.08.2023
(Annexure-P/17) and the subsequent recovery order dated 29.08.2023
(Annexure-P/18) passed by Respondents No. 3 and 4, respectively, are liable
to be set aside.
4) None appeared for Respondent No. 3, despite notice having been duly
served.
5) Learned counsel for Respondents No.1 and 2 (State) and Respondent No. 4
have filed their return, which appears to be similar in stance. Learned
counsel for Respondents No.1, 2, and 4 jointly submit that after receiving a
complaint against the petitioner, a preliminary enquiry was conducted,
wherein it was reported that the petitioner had made a proposal for the
regularization of 5 daily-wage employees to Class-III and Class IV (Peon)
posts in Janpad Panchayat Bodla in violation of various rules. Following the
said enquiry report, an explanation was sought from him, which was
subsequently placed before a 3-Member Committee. The Committee, after
examining the issue along with the explanation submitted by the petitioner,
arrived at the conclusion that the petitioner not only made the proposal for
regularization of those 5 employees but also managed to get the
regularization order passed by the Chief Executive Officer merely in
anticipation of approval from the prescribed Authority, which has not been
approved to date.
5.1) It is further submitted that as the aforesaid proposal was made by the
petitioner without obtaining approval from the Higher Authority, therefore,
he was served with a charge-sheet and a Departmental Enquiry was
conducted against him, wherein he was found guilty of misconduct and
Page 7
{WPS No.8771/2023}
financial loss to the Government vide Annexure-P/16. The said report was
accepted by the Chief Executive Officer, Jila Panchayat Kabirdham, and
finally, the penalty was inflicted upon the petitioner vide Annexure-P/17,
directing him to deposit Rs. 13,77,869/-. Therefore, they contend that the
proceedings are just and proper.
5.2) Learned counsel for Respondent No. 4, while referring to Rule 6 of the
Rules, 1999, also submits that since the Chief Executive Officer, Jila
Panchayat Kabirdham, and the Collector, Kabirdham are higher/superior
Authorities, they were fully entitled to pass order of Departmental Enquiry
and impose the penalty. In view of these submissions, the learned counsel for
the respondents prays for the dismissal of the writ petition.
6) Heard the learned counsel for the parties and perused the documents placed
on record with the writ petition.
7) Perusal of the record shows that the petitioner was initially appointed as a
Clerk on a temporary basis at Janpad Panchayat Bodla on 26.03.1992, and
was later promoted to Assistant Grade-II on 07.12.2004. At the relevant
time, he was promoted and posted as an Accountant, which is a Class-III
post. On 28.08.2018, the General Administrative Committee of Janpad
Panchayat Bodla passed an order regularizing 5 daily-wage employees, after
which a complaint was received from one Kaleshwar Sahu alleging that the
regularization had been done without following due process. Subsequently, a
show-cause notice was issued to the petitioner on 31.07.2021. Though
petitioner has denied the allegations, the Collector of District Kabirdham
suspended him on 19.08.2021 on grounds of alleged negligence and
financial irregularities.
Page 8
{WPS No.8771/2023}
8) Thereafter, a charge-sheet was served on the petitioner on 28.08.2021 under
the signature of the Collector, Kabirdham. The petitioner replied to the same
vide Annexure-P/11, which was found unsatisfactory. Consequent thereto,
the Collector ordered a Departmental Enquiry on 16.09.2021 vide AnnexureP/12 and appointed an Enquiry Officer and a Presenting Officer to carry out
further proceedings. Subsequently, the Enquiry Officer submitted the Enquiry
Report to the Collector vide Annexure-P/16 on 27.04.2023. On the basis of
approval by the Collector, Kabirdham, the Chief Executive Officer, Jila
Panchayat Kabirdham issued an order dated 07.08.2023 (Annexure-P/17),
inflicting a penalty for the recovery of Rs. 13,77,869/-, which is the amount
of arrears and salaries disbursed to the said 5 daily-wage employees. This
resulted in a final recovery direction issued by the Chief Executive Officer of
Janpad Panchayat Bodla on 29.08.2023 (Annexure-P/18), ordering the
petitioner to deposit the said amount. Thus it is explicit that the entire
Departmental Enquiry was conducted under the supervision and orders of
the Collector Kabirdham right from its inception until the imposition of the
penalty.
9) Undisputedly, the petitioner was a Class-III category employee of Janpad
Panchayat Bodla, District Kabirdham.
10) A perusal of the Appendix to Rule 2(c) of the Rules, 1999 makes it apparent
that the Collector, Kabirdham was not the Disciplinary Authority of the
petitioner. Instead, as per the Appendix to Rule 2(c), the Chief Executive
Officer, Janpad Panchayat Bodla is designated as the Disciplinary Authority
of the petitioner. In this regard, it would be appropriate to reproduce Rule
2(c) and its Appendix, which read as follows:
Page 9
{WPS No.8771/2023}
"2. Definitions.(a)
***
***
***
(b)
***
***
***
(c)
"Disciplinary Authority" in relation to the imposition of
penalty on a member of the Panchayat Service means the
authority declared to be the disciplinary authority under
the Appendix appended to these rules;"
***
APPENDIX
S.
No.
Class
of
Panchayats
Class of
Service
(1)
(2)
(3)
1.
2.
Zila
Panchayat/
Janpad
Panchayat
Zila
Panchayat/
Class III
and IV
Disciplinary
Authority
(4)
Chief Executive
Officer
General
Administration
Committee.
Kind
of
penalty
referred to in rule 5
which
may
be
imposed
(5)
Minor Penalty
Major Penalty
Appellate
Authority
(6)
General
Administratio
n Committee.
General body
Class II
General
Administration
Committee.
Minor Penalty
General body
Janpad
Panchayat
3.
Zila
Panchayat
Class II
General body
Major Penalty
Divisional
Commissioner
4.
Janpad
Panchayat
Class II
General body
Major Penalty
District
Collector
5.
Gram
Panchayat
Class IV
Secretary
Minor Penalty
Gram
Panchayat
-
-
General
Administration
Committee.
Major Penalty
General body
-
-
General
Administration
Committee.
Minor Penalty
General body
-
-
General body
Major Penalty
Sub Divisional
Officer
(Revenue)
Class III
Page 10
{WPS No.8771/2023}
11) Bare perusal of the aforesaid provision and Appendix makes it clear that the
Chief Executive Officer, Janpad Panchayat Bodla was the Disciplinary
Authority of the petitioner. However, he did not initiate or conduct the
Departmental Enquiry against the petitioner, rather vide Annexure-P/12
dated 16.09.2021, the Collector, Kabirdham appointed him as the Presenting
Officer in the Departmental Enquiry proceedings. This order passed by the
Collector, Kabirdham runs completely contrary to the Rules, 1999.
12) Further, pursuant to the said Departmental Enquiry, the petitioner has been
inflicted with a minor penalty of recovery of Rs.13,77,869/-, which is said to
be equivalent to the salary and arrears paid to those 5 daily-wage employees
who were regularized allegedly against the rules. However, no specific
charge was levelled against the petitioner in this regard, instead, it appears
only a vague charge was levelled that he had caused financial loss to the
State. It is well-settled law that an order imposing recovery or punishment is
legally unsustainable if it is passed without explicitly framing a specific
charge of causing financial loss to the Government against the concerned
employee.
13) In the case of Union of India and others Vs. Chattar (2009) 12 SCC 78, while
considering a case of minor penalty, the Hon'ble Supreme Court, referencing
established precedents, reiterated that even in a domestic enquiry, the charge
must be clear, definite, and specific, as it would be difficult for any
delinquent employee to meet vague charges. The evidence adduced should
not be perfunctory, and even if the delinquent employee does not raise a
defense or protest against the vagueness of the charges, it does not save the
enquiry from being vitiated. This is because fair play in action is a mandatory
Page 11
{WPS No.8771/2023}
prerequisite, particularly in respect of an order involving adverse or penal
consequences. It has been also reiterated that it is impermissible to hold an
enquiry on a vague charge, as it deprives the delinquent employee of an
opportunity to make an effective defense since they may not be aware of the
exact nature of the allegations to put up a proper rebuttal.
14) In the present case, a perusal of the enquiry report appended as AnnexureP/16 reveals that the Enquiry Officer merely received the petitioner's
explanation vide Annexure-P/15, wherein the petitioner has not accepted his
guilt in clear terms, rather he has denied charges levelled against him.
15) Here it would be appropriate to go through the Rule 7 of the Rules, 1999,
where the procedure has been prescribed for imposing a major penalty,
which reads as under:
"7. Procedure for imposing major penalties.
(1)No order, imposing on a member of the Panchayat
Service, any of the penalties specified in clauses (iv) to
(via) of Rule 5 shall be passed except after a formal
inquiry is held as far as may be, in the manner
hereinafter provided.
(2)When an order for formal inquiry has been made, the
disciplinary authority shall frame Definite charges on
the basis of allegations and shall communicate such
charges, alongwith the statement of the allegations, to
the member of the Panchayat Service and also require
him to submit, within such time as may be specified a
written statement of defence and also to state whether
he desires to be heard in person.
(3)The person against whom inquiry is to be held shall,
for the purpose of preparing to defence, be permitted to
inspect and take extracts from such records as he may
Page 12
{WPS No.8771/2023}
specify :Provided that such permission may be refused if,
for reasons to be recorded in writing, in the opinion of
the Enquiry' Officer such records are not relevant for the
purpose or it is against the public interest to allow his
access thereto.
(4)On receipt of the written statement of defence or if
any such statement is not received within the time
specified, the disciplinary authority may himself enquire
into such of the charges as are not admitted or appoint
an Enquiry Officer to hold the inquiry and forward to
him his report and, if advised, his recommendation
alongwith all the inquiry papers.
(5)The disciplinary authority may nominate any person
to present the case in support of the charges before the
Enquiry Officer. The member of the Panchayat Service
may present his case with the assistance of any other
Panchayat
Servant
of
State
Government
Servant
approved by the Enquiry Officer but may not engage a
legal practitioner for the purpose, unless the person
nominated by the disciplinary authority as aforesaid is a
legal practitioner or unless the disciplinary authority
having regard to the circumstances of the case so
permits.
(6)If the servant of the Panchayat Service desires to be
heard in person, he shall be so heard. If he so desires or
if the disciplinary authority so directs, an oral enquiry
shall be held by the Enquiry Officer. At such inquiry,
evidence shall be heard as to such of the allegations as
are not admitted and the person charged shall be
entitled to cross examine the witness, to give evidence
in person, to produce documentary evidence, if any and
to have such witness called as he may wish :Provided
that the Enquiry Officer may, for reasons to be recorded
in writing, refuse to call a witness.
Page 13
{WPS No.8771/2023}
(7)At the conclusion of the inquiry, the Enquiry Officer
shall prepare a report of the inquiry, recording his
findings on each of the charges together with reasons
therefor.
(8)The proceedings conducted against the persons
charged shall contain a sufficient record of :(i)the charges framed against such person and the
statement of allegations;
(ii)the written statement of defence if any;
(iii)the oral evidence taken in the course of the inquiry;
(iv)the documentary evidence considered in the course
of the inquiry;
(v)the orders, if any, made by the Enquiry Officer or the
disciplinary authority, as the case may be, with regard to
the inquiry;
(vi)a report setting out the findings on each charge and
the reasons therefor.
(9)The Enquiry Officer, if he is other than the
disciplinary authority, shall submit the records of the
proceedings mentioned in clause (8) above to the
disciplinary authority without recommendation relating
to the penalty to be imposed. The disciplinary authority
shall consider the record of the enquiry and its findings
on each charge, having regard to the findings on the
charges and the record (if the proceedings) if he is of
the opinion that any of the penalties specified in clauses
(iv) to (vii) of Rule 5 should be imposed, it shall furnish
to the person charged a copy of the report of the
Enquiry Officer, and where the disciplinary authority is
not the Enquiry Officer a statement of its findings
together with brief reasons for disagreement, if any, with
the findings of the Enquiry Officer.
Page 14
(10)The
disciplinary
{WPS No.8771/2023}
authority
shall
consider
the
representation, it any, made by the person charged in
response to the notice and determine the penalty, if any,
should be imposed and shall pass appropriate order on
the case.
(11)The orders passed by the disciplinary authority shall
be communicated lo the member of the Panchayat
Service, who shall also be supplied with a copy of the
report of the Enquiry Officer and where disciplinary
authority is not the Enquiry Officer, a statement of its
findings
together
with
the
brief
reasons
for
disagreement, if tiny, with the findings of the Enquiry
Officer, unless they have already been supplied to the
person charged."
16) It is explicit from the above text that under Rule 7, a major penalty requires
issuing definite charges to the employee for a written defense before holding
an inquiry. The employee has the right to inspect records, present evidence,
and cross-examine witnesses during a hearing. The Enquiry Officer then
submits a findings report to the disciplinary authority, who must share it with
the employee, consider their final representation, and issue a reasoned
decision. The non-obstante clause under Rule 8(1)(b) stipulates that even for
imposing a minor penalty, the procedure prescribed in sub-rules (1) to (11)
of Rule 7 must be followed. The aforesaid rule reads as follows:
"8. Procedure for imposing minor penalties(1) No order imposing any of the penalties specified in clauses
(i) to (iii) of Rule 5 shall be passed except after :(a)the person charged is informed in writing of the proposal to
take action against him and of the allegations on which such
action is proposed to be taken and is given an opportunity to
make any representation which he may wish to make; and
Page 15
{WPS No.8771/2023}
(b) such representation, if any, is taken into consideration by the
disciplinary authority;
Notwithstanding anything contained in clause (b) of subrule (1), if in a case it is proposed after considering the
representation, if made by the Panchayat Servant, under clause
(b) of that sub-rule to withhold increments of pay or stagnation
allowance, and such with holding of increment of pay or
stagnation allowance is likely to affect adversely the amount of
pension payable to the Panchayat Servant or to withhold
increment of pay or stagnation allowance, for a period
exceeding three years or to withhold increments of pay or
stagnation allowance, with commutative effect for any period,
an enquiry shall be held in the manner laid down in sub-rules
(1) to (11) of Rule 7, before making any order imposing on the
Panchayat Servant any such penalty."
17) However, in the present case, no Departmental witnesses were examined, nor
were any documents allegedly prepared by the petitioner exhibited or proved
during the course of the enquiry. Furthermore, neither the charges, the
charge-sheet, nor the enquiry report mentions which specific rule or rules
were violated by the petitioner while making the proposal for the
regularization of the said employee.
18) It is well-settled law that unless charges are expressly accepted, the employer
cannot establish misconduct based on mere documentary evidence alone.
The Department must examine witnesses to prove the contents of those
documents, as the delinquent employee has the right to cross-examine all
departmental witnesses.
19) The Hon'ble Supreme Court in the case of State of Uttaranchal and Others
Vs. Kharak Singh {(2008) 8 SCC 2236}, while considering its various
judgments has held in Para 15 as Under:-
Page 16
{WPS No.8771/2023}
"15) From the above decisions, the following
principles would emerge:
i) The enquiries must be conducted bona fide and
care must be taken to see that the enquiries do not
become empty formalities.
ii) ***
***
***
iii) In an enquiry, the employer/department should
take steps first to lead evidence against the
workman/delinquent charged, give an opportunity
to him to cross-examine the witnesses of the
employer. Only thereafter, the workman/delinquent
be asked whether he wants to lead any evidence and
asked to give any explanation about the evidence
led against him.
iv)
On receipt of the enquiry report, before
proceeding further, it is incumbent
of
on
the
part
the disciplinary/punishing authority to supply a
copy of the enquiry report and all connected
materials relied on by the enquiry officer to enable
him to offer his views, if any. "
20) Recently, the Hon'ble Supreme Court in Jai Prakash Saini Vs. Managing
Director, UP Cooperative Federation Ltd. {2026 SCC OnLine SC 505}, has
made following observation in Para 17 which reads thus:"17. From the decisions of this Court in Sur Enamel
(supra) and Kharak Singh (supra), followed in Chamoli
District Cooperative (supra), which deals with similar
service rules as are applicable here, it is now settled that
unless the charged employee accepts his guilt in clear
terms, an enquiry on the charges drawn against him
would have to be held. In the enquiry, the employer
/department would have to take steps first to lead
Page 17
{WPS No.8771/2023}
evidence against the workmen / delinquent charged and
give an opportunity to him to cross examine
those
witnesses. Only thereafter, the workmen / delinquent
shall be asked whether he wants to lead any evidence
and/ or submit an explanation about the evidence led
against him. Even in a case based solely on documentary
evidence, unless the relied upon documents are admitted
by the charged employee, a witness would have to be
examined to prove those documents and when so
examined, the witness would have to be tendered for
cross-examination."
21) In light of the aforesaid principles and considering the observations made in
the preceding paragraphs, the petitioner (delinquent employee) had not
accepted his guilt in clear terms, but had rather denied it. Despite this, the
Department neither examined any witnesses nor exhibited any documents,
and failed to prove which specific rule or rules were violated by the
petitioner while making the alleged proposal for regularization. Instead,
immediately upon receiving the explanation (Annexure-P/15) from the
petitioner, the Enquiry Officer prepared the enquiry report on the very same
day i.e. 27.04.2023 and forwarded it to the Collector, District Kabirdham.
Thus, it is clear that the Departmental Enquiry was conducted against the
petitioner without following due procedure of law, and the same was done in
total violation of the principles of natural justice.
22) Apart from the above, learned counsel for the respondents referred to Rule 6
of the Rules, 1999 to argue that the Chief Executive Officer, Jila Panchayat
Kabirdham, and the Collector, Kabirdham were Higher/Superior Authorities
and were therefore entitled to order a Departmental Enquiry and impose a
penalty.
Page 18
{WPS No.8771/2023}
23) Before addressing this contention and determining the competency of the
Collector, Kabirdham, and the Chief Executive Officer, Zila Panchayat
Kabirdham, it is necessary to examine the enabling statutory framework. For
this purpose, Rule 6 of the Rules of 1999 is reproduced below:
"6. Authority to impose penalties.
- Subject to the provisions of these rules, the disciplinary
authority or any authority to whom such authority is
subordinate, may impose any of the penalties specified in
Rule 5 on any servant of the Panchayat Service to the
extent shown against in the Appendix appended to these
rules."
24) The argument made by counsel for the respondents is contradicted by a
reading of Rule 6 and the statutory Appendix. Rule 6 explicitly states that a
subordinate or superior authority may only impose penalties "to the extent
shown against in the Appendix appended to these rules." A perusal of the
Appendix clarifies that for Class-III employees of a Janpad Panchayat, the
Chief Executive Officer of that specific Janpad Panchayat is designated as the
competent Disciplinary Authority for minor penalties, whereas the General
Administration Committee is vested with the jurisdiction for major penalties.
Neither Rule 6 nor the Appendix provides a blanket authorization for higher
administrative authorities, such as the Collector or the Chief Executive
Officer of the Zila Panchayat, to completely usurp the original jurisdiction of
the designated Disciplinary Authority, particularly regarding the issuance of a
show-cause notice, the initiation of a Departmental Enquiry, or the issuance
of a charge-sheet. Under Rule 6 of the Rules of 1999, Superior Authority is
only empowered to impose the specific penalties enumerated in Rule 5 of the
Page 19
{WPS No.8771/2023}
Rules 1999. Hence, the contention made by the learned counsel for the
respondents is misconceived and legally untenable.
25) Furthermore, in the considered opinion of this Court, a superior authority to
whom the original disciplinary authority is subordinate may step in only
under exceptional exigencies, such as when the post of the designated
Disciplinary Authority is vacant or the official is otherwise unavailable. To
permit higher/superior authorities to routinely usurp this power in ordinary
circumstances would invite administrative chaos and result in conflicting,
inconsistent orders across parallel authorities, thereby defeating the certainty
of the statutory framework.
26) Moreover, the Appendix, read along with Rule 2(c) of the Rules of 1999,
specifically provides that the Chief Executive Officer of the Janpad Panchayat
will be the Disciplinary Authority for Class-III and Class-IV employees.
Therefore, the Collector or the Chief Executive Officer of the Jila Panchayat
cannot usurp the whole power of the Chief Executive Officer, Janpad
Panchayat under the garb of Rule 6 of the Rules of 1999. Even otherwise,
Rule 6 only delegates power to the superior officer in respect of the penalty
itself and not in respect of holding the disciplinary proceedings. Therefore,
on this count as well, the contention raised by the respondents that the
Collector, Kabirdham has the competence to order a disciplinary enquiry and
issue charges is unsustainable.
27) In view of the discussion made here-in-above, in the considered opinion of
this Court, both the impugned order dated 07.08.2023 (Annexure-P/17)
passed
by
Respondent
No.3
and
the
order
dated
29.08.2023
Page 20
{WPS No.8771/2023}
(Annexure-P/18) passed by Respondent No.4 suffer from perversity and
illegality, and hence deserve to be, and are hereby, set aside.
28) Accordingly, the Writ Petition is allowed.
29) However, liberty is reserved to the Respondent/Authority to conduct a fresh
Departmental Enquiry in accordance with the rules and law, if so advised.
30) Pending applications, if any, stand disposed of.
Sd/(Naresh Kumar Chandravanshi)
Judge
Ajay
Digitally
signed by AJAY
KUMAR DWIVEDI
Date:
2026.07.14
10:21:53 +0530
Page 21
{WPS No.8771/2023}
Head Note
Unless a delinquent employee accepts his guilt in clear and unambiguous
terms, the employer/department cannot establish misconduct based
solely on documentary evidence. The employer/department is legally
required to hold a proper enquiry, call witnesses to prove the contents of
disputed documents, and tender those witnesses for cross-examination.
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review