Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
2026:CGHC:5740
NAFR
HIGH COURT OF CHHATTISGARH AT BILASPUR
Reserved on 29-01-2026
Delivered on 02-02-2026
MCRCA No. 1701 of 2025
Narayan Sahu S/o Hariram Sahu Aged About 45 Years R/o Village- Hicha, Ward No.
11, District Mahasamund C.G.
... Applicant.
versus
State of Chhattisgarh Through A C B (E O W), Raipur C.G.
... Respondent(s)
For applicant.
:
Mr. Gagan Tiwari, Advocate.
For Respondent(s) State
:
Mr. Sourabh Kumar Pande, Dy. Advocate General
Hon'ble Shri Justice Narendra Kumar Vyas
CAV ORDER
1.
This is the first bail application filed under Section 482 of the Bharatiya
Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita, 2023 for grant of anticipatory bail to the
applicant who apprehends his arrest in connection with Crime No.
03/2024 registered at Police Station- Anti Corruption Bureau/ Economic
Offence Wing Chhattisgarh, Raipur, District- Raipur (C.G.) for the
offence punishable under Sections 420, 120-B and 384 of IPC and
Sections 7, 7-A and 12 of the Prevention of Corruption Act, 1988.
Initially the applicant had moved an application under Section 482 of
BSNN 2023 for grant of anticipatory bail before the learned trial Court
and learned trial Court vide its order dated 29-8-2024 has dismissed
the same.
2.
On 19.12.2025, learned State counsel has submitted before this Court
that warrant of arrest has been issued against the applicant, as such
the instant anticipatory bail application is liable to be dismissed on this
count alone. On 07.01.2026, learned counsel for the applicant would
submit that before issuance of warrant of arrest, no summons have
been issued to the accused as he was not named in the FIR, as such,
the procedure adopted by the prosecution is illegal and would submit
that he may be allowed to produce the copy of the order-sheet of the
trial Court.
3.
This Court has directed the applicant to substantiate his submission to
place on record relevant order sheets or record for perusal of the
Court. Thereafter, the matter was taken up on 16.01.2026 and on
16.01.2026, learned counsel for the applicant prayed for time to comply
with the earlier order dated 07.01.2026 passed by this Court, therefore,
the matter was taken up on 29.01.2026 and on 29.01.2026 the learned
counsel for the applicant would submit that he is unable to place on
record the documents and would pray for hearing the matter finally on
the basis of the material placed on record. On his submission, the bail
application is heard finally.
4.
The case of the prosecution, in brief, is that on 11.01.2024, one Mr.
Sandeep Ahuja, Deputy Director, Directorate of Enforcement, Raipur
through Mr. Farhan Qureshi, Deputy Superintendent of Police lodged a
complaint before the Director General of Police Anti Corruption Bureau
& Economic Offences Wing, Chhattisgarh pertaining to predicate
offence discovered during money laundering in investigation File No.
ECIR/RPZO/09/2022 was done under Section 66(2) of the Prevention
of Money Laundering Act, 2002 (for short “the PMLA”). Thereafter, an
offence bearing FIR No. 03/2024 has been registered on 17.01.2024 at
Police Station ACB/EOW Raipur (C.G.) against 35 accused persons
namely Smt. Saumya Chaurasiya, Sameer Bisnoi, Smt. Ranu Sahu,
Sandeep Kumar Nayak, Shivshankar Nag, Suryakant Tiwari, Manish
Upadhyay, Roshan Kumar Singh, Nikhil Chandrakar, Rahul Singh,
Parekh Kurre, Moinuddin Qureshi, Virendra Jaiswal, Rajnikant Tiwari,
Hemant Jaiswal, Joginder Singh, Nawneet Tiwari, Deepesh Taunk,
Devendra Dadsena, Rahul Mishra, Ramgopal Agrawal, Devendra
Singh Yadav, Shishupal Sori, Rampratap Singh, Vinod Tiwari, Amarjeet
Bhagat, Chandradeo Prasad Rai, Brashpat Singh, Idrish Gandhi,
Gulab
Kamro,
Shri
U.D.
Minj,
Sunil
Kumar
Agrawal,
Jai,
Chandraparakash Jaiswal, Laxmikant Tiwari & others.
5.
Immediately after registration of the FIR, the Police have duly
investigated the matter. However, from the investigation done so far it
is revealed that confidential verification was done in the Bureau Police
Station EOW/ACB Raipur, in relation to the report of letter number
ECIR/RPZO/09/2022/801 dated 11.01.2024 shared by Shri Sandeep
Ahuja, Deputy Director, Enforcement Directorate, Zonal Office, Raipur.
During the investigation of the case, it was found that Mr. Suryakant
Tiwari S/o. Late Mr. Shashibhushan Tiwari, used his political
domination influence Chhattisgarh State Government officials viz Smt.
Saumya Chaurasia, the then Deputy Secretary, Chief Minister's Office,
Chhattisgarh Government, Mr. Sameer Vishnoi, (IAS), Mineral
Department. A criminal conspiracy was hatched under the protection of
political personalities along with officials Smt. Ranu Sahu, the then
Collector Korba and other associates. By working as a syndicate with
Mr. Sameer Vishnoi, the then Director, Directorate of Mines and
Minerals, Government of Chhattisgarh, on 15.07.2020, an order was
passed to issue mineral DO and transport permit through manual
method instead of online, the reason assigned being error in the online
system. In the coal rich areas of the state like Raigarh, Korba,
Surajpur, District Mineral Officers made illegal recovery of Rs 25 per
tonne from coal transporters on the basis of the above, manual DO and
permit related orders were issued from the Mineral Directorate.
Investigation of the Enforcement Directorate and information received
from sources revealed that illegal levy of approximately Rs. 540 crore
has been collected by the above syndicate between July 2020 and
June 2022. On the basis of the report received from the Enforcement
Directorate, its confidential verification and source information, in
relation to the above incident was done in the Bureau and Crime
Number-03/2024 Section 420, 120 B, 384 IPC and 7, 7A and 12 of the
Act 1988 as amended Act 2018 was registered.
6.
From the case diary and the material so collected by the ACB/EOW,
the role of the accused- Narayan Sahu is that during investigation, it
was found that accused -Narayan Sahu was not merely the driver of
accused Suryakant Tiwari, but his most trusted confidant, who
remained continuously associated with him in his illegal activities. The
close proximity between them is evident from the fact that the wife and
children of Narayan Sahu have been residing along with the mother of
accused Suryakant Tiwari in his flat, clearly demonstrating a
relationship of exceptional personal trust and confidence rather than
that of an ordinary employer-driver exists.
7.
Further, analysis of the diaries seized by the Income Tax Department
reveals that approximately Rs. 13 crore of illegal cash was collected by
accused- Narayan Sahu on behalf of the coal syndicate run by
Suryakant Tiwari and that accused -Narayan Sahu, on the instructions
of Suryakant Tiwari, delivered approximately Rs. 7.5 crore in cash from
the proceeds of crime to co-accused Soumya Chaurasia, Sameer
Vishnoi,
Jaiprakash
Maurya,
Vinod
Tiwari,
Devendra
Yadav,
Rampratap Singh and others. The said diaries contain numerous
entries where both "cash received from Narayan" and "cash given to
Narayan" have been recorded, clearly indicating that he was
functioning as a key cash handler in the illegal coal levy network.
8.
To substantiate the above facts, the non-applicant/State has filed
copies of the statement recorded under Section 161 of the Cr.P.C. of
Roshan Kumar Singh, the statement of Ishwar Sidar recorded under
Section 164 of the Cr.P.C., memorandum of accused Manish Upadhyay
and the permanent arrest warrant of the applicant issued by the
learned special Judge, Prevention of Corruption Act and First
Additional Sessions Judge, Raipur (CG) which are collectively annexed
as Annexure-NA-1.
9.
Learned counsel for the applicant would submit that the applicant is
innocent and has been falsely implicated in the crime in question. He
would further submit that the allegations leveled in the F.I.R. do not
constitute any offence under Sections 420, 120-B, 384 of IPC and
Sections 7, 7A and 12 of P.C Act. The report has been lodged with
malafide intention just to rope the present applicant in a false case. The
applicant was working as a driver of Suryakant Tiwari, and therefore
his name has been mentioned as an accused in the present offence.
However, the applicant was appointed on a collector-rate/ad-hoc basis
during the year 2020-21, and thereafter he discontinued his association
with Suryakant Tiwari. Furthermore, the alleged offence pertains to the
period of 2020-21 to June 2022, whereas the applicant had already left
the service of Suryakant Tiwari in the year 2020-21, prior to the period
of the alleged offence. Hence, there is no question of the applicant's
involvement in the said offence and even he is not named in the FIR.
10.
He would further submit that even if aforesaid allegations are taken at
face value, the essential ingredients of the offences alleged are not
made out against the applicant. There is no element of deception
attributable to the applicant. As per the allegation he acted only on the
directions of his employer, without any independent intention to
deceive or induce delivery of property. The allegation that the applicant
collected money and handed it over to Suryakant Tiwari does not
disclose the offence of extortion, as there was no wrongful gain to the
applicant himself, nor did he benefit in any manner and there is no
material and substantial evidence that shows applicant has extort
illegal levy money.
11.
Furthermore, the allegations under Sections 7 and 7A of the Prevention
of Corruption Act are not made out against the applicant, as per the
allegation he acted solely in the capacity of an employee of Suryakant
Tiwari, merely handing over money on instructions. He did not obtain,
accept, or attempt to obtain any undue advantage for himself, nor did
he influence or induce any public servant to act dishonestly. There is
no evidence of mens rea or independent intent, and mere facilitation or
execution of instructions cannot constitute an offence under these
Sections. Accordingly, the applicant's role is peripheral and the
essential ingredients of Sections 7 and 7A PC Act are absent. He
would further submit that the applicant's role as reflected from the FIR
and letter dated 29.08.2025, is merely that of an employee acting
under the instructions of the Suryakant Tiwari, without criminal intent.
Hence, the offences alleged under any independent Sections 420, 384,
467, 468, IPC along with offence under Section 7, 7A and 12 of PC Act
does not attract.
12.
Further contention of the learned counsel for the applicant is that the
allegations under Sections 7 and 7A of the Prevention of Corruption Act
are not made out against the applicant, as per the allegation he acted
solely in the capacity of an employee of Suryakant Tiwari, merely
handing over money on instructions. He did not obtain, accept, or
attempt to obtain any undue advantage for himself, nor did he influence
or induce any public servant to act dishonestly. There is no evidence of
mens rea or independent intent and mere facilitation or execution of
instructions cannot constitute an offence under these sections.
Accordingly, the applicant's role is peripheral, and the essential
ingredients of Sections 7 and 7A PC Act are absent. Accordingly, the
applicant's role, as reflected from the FIR and letter dated 29.08.2025,
is merely that of an employee acting under the instructions of the
Suryakant Tiwari, without criminal intent. Hence, the offences alleged
under any independent Sections 420, 384, 467, 468, IPC along with
offence under Sections 7, 7A and 12 of PC Act does not attract. Thus,
the implication of the applicant appears to be solely on account of his
past association as a driver, without any material indicating conscious
participation in the alleged offence.
13.
He would further submit that the applicant has been made an accused
in the present case solely on the basis of the statements of co-accused
persons. It is submitted that under the provisions of the Indian
Evidence Act, such statements are not admissible in evidence against
any other accused and cannot be relied upon for the purpose of
prosecution. Therefore, in absence of any independent or corroborative
material linking the applicant with the alleged offence, the prosecution
case against the applicant is unsustainable in law. To substantiate his
submission he would refer to the judgment of Hon’ble Supreme Court
in the case of Kashmira Singh v. State of M.P., reported in AIR 1952
SC 159.
14.
He would further submit that it is well settled provisions of law that the
statements recorded under Sections 161 & 164 of the Cr.P.C. are not
admissible in law. He would further submit that the statement of coaccused person is an extremely weak piece of evidence and cannot be
treated as substantive evidence as against the other co-accused
persons as held by Hon’ble the Supreme Court in case of Prem
Prakash Vs. ED [SLP (Crl.) No. 5416 of 2024,
decided on
28.08.2024], Haricharan Kurmi Vs. State of Bihar [AIR 1964 SC
1184], Sanjay Jain Vs. ED [2024 SCC OnLine SC 656]. He would
further submit
that in the present case, there is also no evidence
showing any physical manifestation of agreement between the
applicant and other co-accused for committing the alleged crime for
making out a case of criminal conspiracy under Section 120-B of the
IPC. It is well settled that there must be cogent evidence to show that
the co-accused are acting as per a common agreement or a common
design. A reference in this regard may be made to the decision of the
Hon'ble Apex Court in case of Ram Sharan Chaturvedi v. State of
M.P., (2022) 16 SCC 166.
15.
He would further submit that there is no apprehension of violation of
the triple test by the applicant, therefore, the applicant is entitled to get
anticipatory bail as it is well settled law that mere apprehension of
influencing witnesses or tampering with evidence can never be a
ground to decline bail to any accused, unless there is cogent
supporting material as held by Hon’ble the Supreme Court in case of P.
Chidambaram Vs. CBI [2020 13 SCC 337], Manish Sisodia Vs. ED
& CBI [(2024) SCC OnLine SC 1920], Manish Sisodia Vs. CBI & ED
[(2023) SCC OnLine SC 1393].
16.
He would further submit that the co-accused persons namely Ranu
Sahu, Suryakant Tiwarii, Sameer Vishnoi and Saumya Chaurasiya
have already been granted bail by the Hon’ble Supreme Court vide
order dated 29-5-2025 passed in SLP (Cri) No. 15941 of 2024,
therefore, the present applicant may be granted anticipatory bail on the
ground of parity. He would further submit that the applicant is ready
and willing to furnish adequate surety and shall abide by all the
directions which may be imposed by this Court, therefore, the benefit of
anticipatory bail should be extended to the present applicant. In
support of his arguments he has relied upon the judgment of Hon’ble
Supreme Court in the case of Srikant Upadhyay and others vs. State
of Bihar and others, reported in (2024) 12 SCC 382, Deepankar
Vishwas vs. State of Madhya Pradesh through PS Omti, reported
in 2025 SCC Online MP 6145, State of Madhya Pradesh vs.
Pradeep Sharma, reported in (2014) 2 SCC 171.
17.
On the other hand, Dr. Saurabh Kumar Pande, Deputy Advocate
General for the ACB/EOW opposing the submissions made by learned
counsel for the applicant, referring to the FIR and the case diary would
submit that the applicant is involved in the economical offence which is
not only heinous offence but also against the economy of the nation.
He would further submit that in view of the above material, the
investigation clearly establishes that accused-Narayan Sahu was
actively and knowingly involved in the collection, movement and
distribution of illegal cash arising out of the coal syndicate's illegal coal
levy collections and directly participated in the acquisition, transfer and
use of the proceeds of crime.
18.
He would further submit that after the allegations were found prima
facie proven, the challan was presented before the Hon'ble Court
against the accused and co-accused persons. The present applicant
has been absconding for about
last two years, has not joined the
investigation despite repeated opportunities, and a Permanent Arrest
Warrant has been issued against him by the Court of the learned
Special Judge, Prevention of Corruption Act and First Additional
Sessions Judge, Raipur (C.G.). After the arrest of the applicant, an
appropriate supplementary charge-sheet will be presented.
19.
He would further submit that in view of the above, it is clear that the
present applicant is involved in the aforesaid crime. The investigation in
the matter is continuing, as in the present case a huge amount of
public money is involved and money laundering has also taken place
from the illegal levy on coal transportation by officials of the State
Government in connivance and conspiracy with other accused
persons. He would further submit that the applicant has not made out
any of the ground in which the instant bail anticipatory bail application
of the present applicant under Section 482 of the Bhartiya Nagrik
Suraksha Sahita, 2023 can be allowed. It is further submitted that there
is a strong prima facie case against the present applicant/accused.
Looking to the conspiracy and crime committed by the applicant in
connivance with the other co-accused, the instant application deserves
to be rejected.
20.
I have heard learned counsel for the parties and perused the case
diary with utmost circumspection.
21.
From perusal of the record of the case and also considering the fact
that the arrest warrant has been issued against the applicant and he
was absconded from the proceedings. Learned State counsel has
submitted that the proceedings under Section 82 of the Cr.P.C. or
Section 84 of Bhartiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita for proclamation of
person absconding will be initiated shortly as he is absconded and
warrant of arrest has been issued by the learned trial Court. The
applicant has also not disputed that the warrant of arrest has been
issued against the applicant, therefore, the present anticipatory bail
application until the warrant of arrest is not cancelled by invoking
Section 70(2) of the Cr.P.C. or Section 72 of the Cr.P.C., is liable to be
dismissed on this count alone as held Hon’ble the Supreme Court in
case of Srikant Upadhyay & others Vs. State of Bihar and another
[(2024) 12 SCC 382] wherein it has been held in paragraphs 25 & 30
as under:“25. The meaning of the term “absconded” has been dealt by us
hereinbefore. We found that its etymological and original sense
is that the accused is hiding himself. What is required as proof
for absconding is the evidence to the effect that the person
concerned was knowing that he was wanted and also about
pendency of warrant of arrest. A detailed discussion is not
warranted in this case to understand that the appellants were
actually absconding. It is not in dispute that they were served
with the “summons”. The fact that bailable warrants were issued
against them on 12.04.2022 is also not disputed, as the
appellants themselves have produced the order whereunder
bailable warrants were issued against them. We have already
referred to Section 70 (2), Cr. PC which would reveal the
position that once a warrant is issued it would remain in force
until it is cancelled by the Court which issued it or until its
execution. There is no case for the appellants that either of
such events had occurred in this case to make the warrants
unenforceable. They also got no case that their application was
interfered with by a higher Court. That apart, it is a fact that the
appellants themselves on 23.08.2022, moved a bail-cumsurrender application before the Trial Court but withdrew the
same fearing arrest. It is also relevant to note that in the case
on hand even while contending that they were before a Court,
the appellants got no case that in terms of the provisions under
Section 438 (1-B), Cr. PC an order for their presence before the
Court was ordered either suo motu by the Court or on an
application by the public prosecutor. When that be the
circumstance, the appellants cannot be allowed to contend that
they were not hiding or concealing themselves from arrest or
that they were not knowing that they were wanted in a Court of
law.
30. We have already held that the power to grant anticipatory
bail is an extraordinary power. Though in many cases it was
held that bail is said to be a rule, it cannot, by any stretch of
imagination, be said that anticipatory bail is the rule. It cannot
be the rule and the question of its grant should be left to the
cautious and judicious discretion by the Court depending on the
facts and circumstances of each case. While called upon to
exercise the said power, the Court concerned has to be very
cautious as the grant of interim protection or protection to the
accused in serious cases may lead to miscarriage of justice and
may hamper the investigation to a great extent as it may
sometimes lead to tampering or distraction of the evidence. We
shall not be understood to have held that the Court shall not
pass an interim protection pending consideration of such
application as the Section is destined to safeguard the freedom
of an individual against unwarranted arrest and we say that
such orders shall be passed in eminently fit cases. At any rate,
when warrant of arrest or proclamation is issued, the applicant
is not entitled to invoke the extraordinary power. Certainly, this
will not deprive the power of the Court to grant pre-arrest bail in
extreme, exceptional cases in the interest of justice. But then,
person(s) continuously, defying orders and keep absconding is
not entitled to such grant”
22.
From perusal of the record, it is quite vivid that the prosecution has
collected the material against the applicant that he has collected
money illegally form coal transporters. Thus, from perusal of FIR and
the material available in the case diary, involvement of the applicant in
commission of offence under Sections 420, 120-B, 384 of IPC read
with Sections 7, 7A & 12 of the PC Act, which is economic offence, is
prima facie reflected. Hon’ble the Supreme Court while considering the
gravity of economic offence in case of P. Chidambaram Vs.
Directorate of Enforcement, [(2019) 9 SCC 24] has held that the
economic offence is a serious offence and need to be visited with
different approach in the matter of bail.
23.
Again Hon’ble the Supreme Court in case of Ramesh Bhavan Rathod
Vs. Vishanbhai Hirabhai Makwana (Koli) & another [(2021) 6 SCC
230] has held that for declining bail application, the Court should
consider whether there is any prima facie or reasonable ground to
believe that the accused had committed the offence; nature and gravity
of the accusation; severity of the punishment in the event of conviction;
danger of the accused absconding or fleeing, if released on bail or
reasonable apprehension of the witnesses being influenced. From
submission made by the parties, it is quite vivid that prima facie these
conditions are available on record.
24.
Further submission of learned counsel for the applicant is that the
applicant is entitled to claim parity as other accused persons have
been granted bail by Hon’ble the Supreme Court, deserves to be
rejected as other accused who remained in the custody for about two
years and have been granted bail by Hon’ble the Supreme Court
whereas in the present case, the applicant has been absconding for
the last two years whereas in the present case, the
applicant is
absconding for more than two years and warrant of arrest has also
been issued against the applicant. Considering the FIR and other
material placed on record, it prima facie shows involvement of the
applicant in crime in question and issuance of warrant of arrest against
him. As such, I am of the view that it is not a fit case where benefit of
Section 482 of BSNN should be extended to the applicant.
25.
Accordingly, the instant bail application filed under Section 482 of the
Bhartiya Nagrik Suraksha Sanhita, 2023 is liable to be and is hereby
rejected.
Sd/-
RAVVA
SATYANARAYANA
RAJU
RAVVA
SATYANARAYANA
RAJU
Date: 2026.02.02
15:23:41 +0530
Raju
(Narendra Kumar Vyas)
Judge
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review