Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
2024:MLHC:665
Serial No. 01
Supplementary List
HIGH COURT OF MEGHALAYA
AT SHILLONG
WP(C) No. 328 of 2022
Date of Decision: 26.07.2024
1.SMTI NAPHIBANMER LASO
W/o Shri. S. Kharbuli
Resident of Mawlai Mawkynroh,
Shillong, East Khasi Hills District,
Meghalaya
2.SHRI CYPRIAN DKHAR
S/o Shri. J. Nonglang
Resident of Rynjah Lapalang,
Shillong, East Khasi Hills District,
Meghalaya
:::Petitioners
-Vs1.Khasi Hills Autonomous District
Council (KHADC), East Khasi Hills
District, Meghalaya 793002 represented
by the Secretary (Executive Committee),
KHADC
2.The State of Meghalaya
Represented by its Secretary to the Government
of Meghalaya District Council Affairs Department,
Shillong – 793001
3.The Registrar (Judicial Service) High Court of
Meghalaya, Shillong- 793001, East Khasi Hills
District, Meghalaya
2024:MLHC:665
4.Smti. Vyblue of Rest Mawlieh
Magistrate First Class, Subordinate District
Council Court, Nongstoin, West Khasi
Hills District, Meghalaya
5.Smti. Eblincy Lyngdoh Mawnai
Magistrate First Class, Subordinate
District Council Court, Mawkyrwat,
South West Khasi Hills District,
Meghalaya
6.Smti. Kerphidalin Warjri
Magistrate First Class, Subordinate
District Council Court, Nongpoh,
Ri Bhoi District, Meghalaya
:::Respondents
Coram:
Hon’ble Mr. Justice H. S. Thangkhiew, Judge
Appearance:
For the Petitioner(s)
:
Ms. P. Chettri, Adv.
Ms. N. Kharshemlang, Adv.
For the Respondent(s)
:
Dr. N. Mozika, Sr. Adv. with
Mr. M.L. Nongpiur, Adv. (For R 1)
Mr. N.D. Chullai, AAG with
Ms. Z.E. Nongkynrih,GA (For R 2&3)
Mr. K.C. Gautam, Adv. (For R 4,5&6)
i)
Whether approved for reporting in
Law journals etc.:
ii)
Whether approved for publication
in press:
Yes/No
Yes/No
2024:MLHC:665
JUDGMENT AND ORDER
1.
The petitioners by the instant writ petition are before this
Court praying for quashing the selection process by which the
respondents Nos. 4, 5 and 6, have been appointed as Magistrate First
Class, Subordinate District Council Court (KHADC) on the ground that
the appointment was made over and above the number of vacancies
advertised.
2.
The brief facts of the case are that the respondent No. 1, by
an advertisement dated 06.11.2019, had called for applications for
filling up of 3(three) vacant posts of Magistrate First Class, Subordinate
District Council Court (KHADC) and on the basis of the written
examination conducted, 6(six) candidates had qualified for the
interview. After the interview, in the final select list dated 11.01.2021,
3(three) candidates were declared selected and 3(three) candidates i.e.
respondents Nos. 4, 5 & 6 were placed in the waiting list. Thereafter, the
respondent No. 1, on 19.08.2020, sought approval from the respondent
No. 3, for filling up the remaining vacant posts from the waiting list as a
special condition, as it was not conducive to conduct fresh examinations
because of the situation in the State and country, and in view of the fact
2024:MLHC:665
that there were many pending cases that required speedy trial. The
respondent No. 3, then approved the said appointments and the
respondent No. 2 also by a notification dated 04.02.2022, was pleased to
approve the said appointments, and the respondents Nos. 4, 5 & 6, were
then conferred powers by the Governor of Meghalaya in exercise of
powers under sub-paragraph (1) of Paragraph - 5 of the Sixth Schedule
to the Constitution of India. The respondents Nos. 4, 5 & 6 thereafter,
were issued appointment orders and joined their respective posts, which
is now under challenge.
3.
Ms. P. Chettri, learned counsel for the petitioners, has
submitted that 3 posts had already been filled up by the respondent No.
1, by appointing the candidates who secured the highest marks in the
exam, but on the request of the respondent No. 1, on the ground that
some posts were still lying vacant and that the appointment be made on
a special consideration from the waiting list, the respondent No. 3,
without verifying the facts had approved the said appointments. She
further submits that the respondent No. 2, also approved the
appointments without holding any fresh exams. The reasons given by
the respondents she submits that, due to the COVID pandemic the
appointments were done, is incorrect as no COVID restrictions were
2024:MLHC:665
imposed and all public offices were functioning smoothly. She further
submits that the other reasons given that there were earlier 5(five) posts
and 1(one) more post was in the process of being sanctioned, cannot be
a ground for the additional appointments, as the respondent No. 1 had
by the advertisement advertised only 3(three) vacant posts. On the point
of special consideration, it is submitted that though the respondent No.
1, have not framed any recruitment rules till date, however, in cases of
public employment there cannot be any special consideration.
4.
It has also been contended that there was no fresh
advertisement for the other posts and that the respondent No. 1, having
filled the vacancies over the number of advertised posts, cannot take a
stand that there were a larger number of posts, which she submits is
impermissible in law. Reliance has been placed in the case of Arup Das
& Ors. vs. State of Assam & Ors. (2012) 5 SCC 559, to support this
argument. It is then submitted that the waiting list prepared does not
furnish a source of recruitment and mere inclusion of a candidate’s
name in the select list, does not confer any right to be appointed, even if
some of the vacancies remain unfilled. The action of the respondents
she argues, in giving direct recruitment to respondents Nos. 4, 5 & 6,
amounts to filling up of future vacancies and that the instant case, is not
2024:MLHC:665
one wherein a selected candidate did not join and the waiting list taken
recourse to. In support of this argument, the learned counsel has relied
upon the case of Gujarat State Dy. Executive Engineers’ Association
vs. State of Gujarat & Ors., 1994 Supp (2) SCC 591. The learned
counsel has also cited the following judgments.
(i)
Rakhi Ray & Ors. vs. High Court of Delhi, 2010 (2)
SCC 637
(ii)
Judgment dated 27.06.2022, passed in LPASW No.
186/2018 (High Court of Jammu & Kashmir and
Ladakh)
(iii)
Judgment dated 19.05.2023, passed in Civil Appeal
No. 3062 of 2023 (State of Karnataka vs. Smt.
Bharathi S.)
(iv)
Judgment dated 05.02.2021, passed in Civil Appeal
No. 104 of 2021 (Gajanan Babulal Bansode & Ors.
vs. State of Maharashtra & Ors.)
(v)
Judgment dated 05.10.2018, passed in Writ Petition
(L) No. 1064 of 2017 (Apurba Kumar & Ors. vs.
The Institute of Banking Personnel Selection &
Ors.) Bombay High Court
(vi)
Judgment dated 08.03.2022, passed in Civil Writ
Petition (Original Application) No. 4729/2019
(Roshan Lal vs. H.P. Power Corporation Limited &
Ors.) High Court of Himachal Pradesh
2024:MLHC:665
5.
The learned counsel in closing her arguments has
submitted that the action of the respondent No. 1, is violative of Articles
14 and 16 of the Constitution of India and has encroached upon the right
of the petitioners and other advocates, who could have participated if a
new advertisement had been issued. The fact that the respondents Nos.
4, 5 & 6, have served for 2 years, she submits cannot be an excuse as
they have been illegally appointed and cannot claim equity. She lastly
submits that without any recruitment rules, the respondent No. 1, has no
power or authority to directly recruit the respondents Nos. 4, 5 & 6,
from the waiting list. She therefore, prays that the appointments of the
respondents Nos. 4, 5 & 6 be quashed and the respondent No. 1, be
directed to issue fresh advertisement for 3(three) vacancies in the posts
of Magistrate First Class, Subordinate District Council Court
(KHADC).
6.
Dr. N. Mozika, learned Senior counsel assisted by Mr. M.L.
Nongpiur, learned counsel for the respondent No. 1, submits that in the
District Council Courts, KHADC, over a period of time till August
2021, a total of 9(nine) Judicial posts were sanctioned, i.e. 1(one) Post
of Judge, 2(two) Posts of Additional Judges, and 6(six) posts of
2024:MLHC:665
Magistrate First Class. It is submitted that, as 2(two) of the Magistrate
First Class were promoted to the post of Additional Judges, the working
strength in the year 2019 was, 1 Judge, 2 Additional Judges and 1
Magistrate First Class, with the remaining 5 posts of Magistrate First
Class lying vacant. In 2019 he submits, the Executive Committee
KHADC decided to fill up only 3 posts of Magistrate First Class out of
the 5 vacant posts on the understanding that, as 1 more post of
Magistrate First Class would be sanctioned soon, 3 vacancies then
would be advertised together, and as such only 3 posts were advertised
on 06.11.2019. The proposed 1 post of Magistrate First Class he
submits, was thereafter sanctioned vide letter dated 19.08.2021.
7.
The learned Senior counsel then submits that on the
conclusion of the selection process, 6(six) candidates were qualified and
placed in the select list and after obtaining approval from the Governor
of Meghalaya and the High Court, 3 candidates securing the highest
marks were given appointment, whereas the remaining 3 were placed in
the waiting list. It is submitted that in the meantime, considering the
huge pendency of cases in the District Council Courts and the need for
strengthening the system and to meet the demand for constitution of
outlying benches of the Subordinate District Council Courts in 3
2024:MLHC:665
Administrative Districts i.e. West Khasi Hills, Ri-Bhoi and South West
Khasi Hills, and also considering the prevailing COVID-19 situation,
which was then at its peak, the respondent No. 1 took a decision that it
was not conducive to conduct fresh examinations for filling up the 3
vacant posts, and therefore decided that the 3 remaining vacant posts be
filled up from the 3 wait listed candidates in the select list dated
11.01.2021. As such he submits, this policy decision was taken by the
respondent No. 1 in view of the prevailing circumstances, wherein there
was a pressing need to appoint new Magistrates, coupled with the fact
that holding of fresh examinations would be a time consuming process.
Thereafter, he submits, as the select list had already been extended till
31.03.2022, approvals were sought from the High Court as a special
consideration in view of the prevailing situation, which was received on
27.10.2021, and also from the Governor of the State of Meghalaya for
approval, and for conferment of powers as provided under Paragraph
5(1) of the Sixth Schedule which was then duly accorded.
8.
Accordingly, he submits office orders were then issued on
28.02.2022 and 04.03.2022, appointing the respondents No. 4 5 & 6, as
Magistrate First Class, and the said respondents thereafter, joined their
respective posts and are discharging their duties satisfactorily till today.
2024:MLHC:665
The learned Senior counsel then reiterates his submissions that the
entire exercise of filling the existing and anticipated vacancies, was due
to the exceptional circumstances and emergent situation prevailing then,
and were made pursuant to a considered policy decision of the
Executive Committee, KHADC. It is further submitted that the
appointments from the waiting list were made to the existing and
anticipatory vacancies and not to future vacancies, inasmuch as, 2(two)
posts were existing and 1(one) post was an anticipated vacancy, as the
process for creation and sanction of the said additional post had already
been undertaken. It has been stressed by the Senior counsel that the
appointments were thus made as a special consideration for the reasons
afore stated. The respondents Nos. 4, 5 & 6, he contends are otherwise
fully qualified for the posts and it is not the case of the petitioners, that
the respondents Nos. 4, 5 & 6, are not qualified and it is also not the
case of the petitioners, that there were any irregularities in the
examination or interview process, and in fact the only case put up by the
petitioners, is that 3(three) posts were advertised, whereas 6(six)
appointments have been given, from the same selection process. It is
also been contended that the appointments were granted following the
due process and after approvals had been obtained from the High Court
2024:MLHC:665
and after conferment of powers under Paragraph - 5(1) of the Sixth
Schedule to the Constitution of India, by the Governor of Meghalaya.
9.
The learned Senior counsel then submits that the
respondents No. 4, 5 & 6, as on date have been discharging their duties
for about 2 years and have gained valuable experience, and as such if
their appointments are invalidated at this stage, the same shall be against
public interest. The learned Senior counsel in support of his arguments
has placed reliance on the following decisions, wherein the Supreme
Court, has held that the State can deviate from the advertisement and
make appointments in exceptional circumstances, and that unseating the
selected candidates who have served for some time, would be contrary
to public interest. The cases are:-
10.
i)
Prem Singh & Ors. vs. Haryana State Electricity Board &
Ors. (1996) 4 SCC 319
ii)
Sivanandan CT & Ors. vs. High Court of Kerala & Ors.
iii)
Vivek Kaisth & Ors. vs. State of Himachal Pradesh & Ors.
On behalf of the respondents No. 2 and 3, Mr. N.D.
Chullai, learned AAG with Ms. Z.E. Nongkynrih, learned GA has
endorsed the submissions made by the learned Senior counsel on behalf
2024:MLHC:665
of the respondent No. 1, and further submits it was true that at that point
of time, in view of the pandemic, it was not conducive to conduct a
fresh examination to fill up the 3(three) vacant posts. As such, he
submits the State respondents accorded the approval for appointment of
the wait listed candidates. He further submits that the KHADC is an
autonomous body, and the State Government does not question its
competence in the conduct of its duties and functions.
11.
The learned AAG has further submitted that the petitioners
had taken part in the same selection process, but had not qualified,
whereas the respondents No. 4, 5 and 6 were successful in the selection
process. The fact that the petitioners had participated in the selection
process, he submits has not been disclosed by the petitioners
themselves, but the same has been revealed by the additional affidavit
filed on behalf of the respondent No. 1. He therefore contends that, the
petitioners herein, are also guilty of suppression of facts and on this
ground alone, the writ petition deserves to be dismissed. He finally
submits that, it is not the case of the petitioners that the appointments
given to the respondents No. 4, 5 and 6, was by way of favoritism,
nepotism or anything done by them to gain appointment illegally,
inasmuch as, they had participated in the selection process, and were
2024:MLHC:665
successful, though initially placed in the waiting list. The learned AAG
has also reiterated the submissions that unseating the respondents No. 4,
5 and 6 at this stage, would not be in public interest.
12.
Mr. K.C. Gautam, learned counsel for the respondents No.
4, 5 and 6 while adopting the submissions made by the counsels on
behalf of the other respondents, submits that the writ petition suffers
from delay and laches on part of the petitioners, inasmuch as, the
petitioners waited for over 6(six) months from the date of issuance of
appointment letters to the private respondents before approaching this
Court. He further submits that the petitioners could have immediately
approached this Court, and craved leave to file other documents at the
later stage, but they chose not to do so, and in the meantime, the
answering respondents had assumed office and started discharging the
judicial functions including hearing of cases and passing of orders. The
learned counsel has also placed reliance on the same cases, cited by the
learned Senior counsel on behalf of the respondent No. 1, and submitted
that after the lapse of over 2(two) years, it would be contrary to public
interest to unseat the answering respondents.
13.
Having heard the learned counsel for the parties, as
submitted, the only question before this Court is whether the actions of
2024:MLHC:665
the respondent No. 1, in affording appointments to candidates over and
above the advertised vacancies, is justifiable or whether the said
decision is visited with arbitrariness and illegality.
14.
Before addressing the case at hand, it is noteworthy to keep
in mind that the District Council Courts have been set up under the
mandate of Paragraph – 4 of the Sixth Schedule to the Constitution of
India, wherein the District Councils have been invested with powers to
constitute courts for the trial of suits and cases between the parties who
belong to the Scheduled Tribe; and these judicial officers who are then
appointed into such courts are conferred with powers under Paragraph –
5(1) of the Sixth Schedule by the Governor. In matters of appointment
of such judicial officers, the District Council is the appointing authority,
and as has been pointed out by the learned counsel for the petitioner, the
recruitment rules have not yet been published, but as apprised to this
Court, the same are awaiting approval by the Governor. As such, these
Courts occupy a very special place in the system of administration of
justice in these hills.
15.
In the normal course of recruitment in public employment,
as per practice and procedure, once the advertised vacancies as
published have been filled up, there is no question of recourse being
2024:MLHC:665
taken to fill up further vacant posts, from the same selection process,
and in this regard, heavy reliance has been placed by the writ petitioner
on the case of Arup Das & Ors. vs. State of Assam (supra), wherein it
has been held that an authority cannot make any selection/appointment
beyond the number of posts advertised, even if there were a larger
number of posts available, than those advertised. It is also settled law
that a select list cannot be treated as a reserve list for the purposes of
issuance of appointment, so that vacancies can be filled up by taking the
names from the list, as and when required, and that further no authority
or Government can fill up vacancies for the future. Accordingly, against
this backdrop, this Court is to examine the decision and action of the
respondent No. 1, in appointing the respondents No. 4, 5 and 6, against
the posts, which had not been advertised by the advertisement dated
06.11.2019.
16.
As noted from the discussions made herein above, the
reasons given by the respondent No. 1, for the appointments is
threefold, first is that the holding of fresh examinations for 3(three)
posts was not feasible and conducive, due to the COVID pandemic in
2021, which was at its peak, secondly, due to the demand, benches of
the District Council Courts were to be commissioned in three outlying
2024:MLHC:665
districts namely, West Khasi Hills, South West Khasi Hills and Ri-Bhoi
District, and thirdly, due to the need for speedy trials of cases. To this
end, as submitted, a considered policy decision had been taken by the
respondent No. 1, under what has been termed as exceptional
circumstances, in an emergent situation.
17.
The most important factor to be considered therefore, is
whether
under
these
circumstances,
the
deviation
from
the
advertisement was permissible. In the case of Arup Das & Ors. vs.
State of Assam & Ors. (supra), the Supreme Court while discussing this
issue in Para – 20 thereof, had held as follows.
“20. Even the decision in Prem Singh case which had been
strongly relied upon by Mr Joydeep Gupta in support of his
claim that the State had a right to deviate from the
advertisement published by it, has to be considered in the light of
the circumstances in which the same was made. While holding
that if the requisition and advertisement are for a certain
number of posts only, the State cannot make more appointments
than the number of posts, this Court went on to hold that the
State could deviate from the advertisement and make
appointments in posts falling vacant thereafter in exceptional
cases or in an emergent situation, and, that too, by taking a
policy decision in that behalf.”
2024:MLHC:665
18.
In the case of Prem Singh & Ors. vs. Haryana State
Electricity Board & Ors.(supra), which has also been discussed, in the
above noted case, at Para – 25, the Supreme Court has with regard to
clear and anticipated vacancies, but not to future vacancies, and also
with regard to exceptional circumstances, has held as follows.
“25. From the above discussion of the case-law it becomes clear
that the selection process by way of requisition and
advertisement can be started for clear vacancies and also for
anticipated vacancies but not for future vacancies. If the
requisition and advertisement are for certain number of posts
only the State cannot make more appointments than the number
of posts advertised, even though it might have prepared a select
list of more candidates. The State can deviate from the
advertisement and make appointments on posts falling vacant
thereafter in exceptional circumstances only or in an emergent
situation and that too by taking a policy decision in that behalf.
Even when filling up of more posts than advertised is challenged
the court may not, while exercising its extraordinary
jurisdiction, invalidate the excess appointments and may mould
the relief in such a manner as to strike a just balance between
the interest of the State and the interest of persons seeking
public employment. What relief should be granted in such cases
would depend upon the facts and circumstances of each case.”
2024:MLHC:665
19.
Further, in the case of Vivek Kaisth & Anr. vs. State of
Himachal Pradesh & Ors.(supra), with regard to unseating judicial
officers, who have already served in Para – 44 and 45, the Supreme
Court has held as follows.
“44. What is also important for our consideration at this stage is
that the appellants in the present case have been working as
judicial officers now for nearly 10 years. They are now Civil
Judge (Senior Division). These judicial officers now have a rich
experience of 10 years of judicial service behind them.
Therefore, unseating the present appellants from their posts
would not be in public interest. Ordinarily, these factors as we
have referred
above,
would not
matter,
once
the
very
appointment is held to be wrong. But we also cannot fail to
consider that the appellants were appointed from the list of
candidates who had successfully passed the written examination
and viva voce and they were in the merit list. Secondly, it is
nobody’s case that the appellants have been appointed by way of
favouritism, nepotism or due to any act which can even remotely
be called as “blameworthy”. Finally, they have now been
working as Judges for ten years. There is hence a special equity
which leans in favour of the appellants.
45. In a recent Constitution Bench decision of this Court
in Sivanandan C.T. v. High Court of Kerala though the finding
arrived at by this Court was that the Rules of the game were
changed by the High Court of Kerala by prescribing minimum
2024:MLHC:665
marks for the viva voce, which were not existing in the Rules
and therefore in essence the appointment itself was in violation
of the Rules, yet considering that those persons who had secured
appointments under this selection have now been working for
more than 6 years it was held that it would not be in public
interest to unseat them. It was stated in SCC para 55 as under: “55. The question which now arises before the Court is in
regard to the relief which can be granted to the petitioners. The
final list of successful candidates was issued on 6-3-2017. The
candidates who have been selected have been working as District
and Sessions Judges for about six years. In the meantime, all
the petitioners who are before the Court have not functioned in
judicial office. At this lapse of time, it may be difficult to direct
either the unseating of the candidates who have performed their
duties. Unseating them at this stage would be contrary to public
interest since they have gained experience as judicial officers in
the service of the State of Kerala. While the grievance of the
petitioners is that if the aggregate of marks in the written
examination and viva-voce were taken into account, they would
rank higher than three candidates who are respondents to these
proceedings, equally, we cannot lose sight of the fact that all the
selected candidates are otherwise qualified for judicial office
and have been working over a length of time. Unseating them
would, besides being harsh, result in a situation where the
higher judiciary would lose the services of duly qualified
2024:MLHC:665
candidates who have gained experience over the last six years in
the post of District Judge.”
And therefore, one of the directions in the said case was
as under: (Sivanandan C.T. case, SCC para 57)
“57. … 57.6. In terms of relief, we hold that it would be
contrary to the public interest to direct the induction of the
petitioners into the Higher Judicial Service after the lapse of
more than six years. Candidates who have been selected nearly
six years ago cannot be unseated. They were all qualified and
have been serving the district judiciary of the State. Unseating
them at this stage would be contrary to public interest. To induct
the petitioners would be to bring in new candidates in preference
to those who are holding judicial office for a length of time. To
deprive the State and its citizens of the benefit of these
experienced judicial officers at a senior position would not be in
public interest.”
The case at hand is on a similar footing if not better than
the petitioners in the above case.”
20.
Similarly, in the case of Sivanandan CT & Ors. vs. High
Court of Kerala & Ors.(supra), at Para – 53, it has been held as
follows.
2024:MLHC:665
“53. The question which now arises before the Court is in
regard to the relief which can be granted to the
petitioners. The final list of successful candidates was
issued on 6 March 2017. The candidates who have been
selected have been working as District and Sessions
Judges for about six years. In the meantime, all the
petitioners who are before the Court have not functioned
in judicial office. At this lapse of time, it may be difficult
to direct either the unseating of the candidates who have
performed their duties. Unseating them at this stage
would be contrary to public interest since they have
gained experience as judicial officers in the service of the
State of Kerala. While the grievance of the petitioners is
that if the aggregate of marks in the written examination
and viva-voce were taken into account, they would rank
higher than three candidates who are respondents to
these proceedings, equally, we cannot lose sight of the
fact that all the selected candidates are otherwise
qualified for judicial office and have been working over a
length of time. Unseating them would, besides being
harsh, result in a situation where the higher judiciary
would lose the services of duly qualified candidates who
have gained experience over the last six years in the post
of District Judge.”
2024:MLHC:665
21.
In the case of Gujarat State Dy. Executive Engineers’
Association vs. State of Gujarat & Ors. reported in 1994 Supp (2) SSC
591, which has been relied by the petitioner, with regard to the waiting
list not being a source of recruitment, at Para – 11 thereof however, it
has been held as follows.
“11. The entire appointment of direct recruits, therefore,
from the waiting list was not proper. But these persons
have been appointed and are working now at least for five
years. It would, therefore, be unjust and harsh to quash
their selection at this stage. Therefore, while refraining
from quashing the appointment made in pursuance of the
direction issued by the High Court, we are of the opinion
that the waiting list for one year cannot furnish source of
recruitment for future years, except in very exceptional
cases. It is, however, necessary to add that non-holding of
examination at the instance of the Government could not
result in reducing the quota of direct recruits to be worked
out on the principle for determination of such vacancies.
Therefore, if vacancies had collected between 1983 and
1993 due to interim orders passed by the courts, and they
have not been taken into account when the examination
for 1993 was held then it would be expedient to direct the
Government to work out the same immediately and send
the requisition to the Commission for holding selection for
if the next examination is going to be held within one year
2024:MLHC:665
from today. We may clarify that it is nobody's case that the
quota rule has broken. Therefore the direction is being
issued to protect the quota of direct recruits during 1983
to 1993 in the peculiar facts of the present case.”
[Emphasis supplied]
22.
From an examination of the above noted decisions, what
emerges is that such deviations are permissible when exceptional
circumstances are prevalent, or the same is resorted to meet an emergent
situation. Further, it is also clear that, such appointments would be
permissible for clear vacancies and anticipated vacancies, but not future
vacancies. In the case at hand, by applying the above conditions and
contingencies, it can safely be held that, the deviation from the
advertisement was caused by the events as narrated earlier, for which a
considered policy decision, was taken to address the situation and as
such, the same calls for no interference. On the aspect of the vacancies,
for which appointments were made from the waiting list, the same were
against two existing vacancies, and one was against an anticipated
vacancy, which was under the process of being sanctioned and was
thereafter sanctioned vide letter dated 19.08.2021, and as such, the
appointments were not made against future vacancies.
2024:MLHC:665
23.
The other decisions cited by the learned counsel for the
petitioner being of limited application, to the facts of the present case,
and on a different footing, are not discussed or elaborated upon.
24.
Apart from the discussions made herein above, another
factor that deserves consideration is the fact that the respondents No. 4,
5 and 6, are qualified candidates who have come through a selection
process, and have been discharging their duties for over 2(two) years
now, and unseating them at this stage, will surely not be in public
interest. Coupled with this is also the fact that, the petitioners though not
disclosing in the writ petition, are unsuccessful candidates who did not
even clear the written examination, and by displacing the respondents
No. 4, 5 and 6, would not mean that they would be in contention or
qualified to be appointed against the said posts. It is also to be noted
that, there has been no allegation of any favoritism or nepotism or that
the selection process was vitiated in any manner to render the selection
invalid, but the only challenge is that there was a deviation from the
advertisement.
25.
As such, in the considered view of this Court, the
appointment of the respondents No. 4, 5 and 6, in the circumstances
aforestated, which was made due to compelling circumstances and on
2024:MLHC:665
the basis of a policy decision, and also in consideration of the fact that
these officers are presently manning positions in outlying benches of the
District Council Courts, which are special in nature for the past 2(two)
years, their appointments are upheld and the writ petition accordingly
dismissed.
26.
No order as to costs.
Judge
THABAH
Date: 2024.07.26 15:26:48 IST
Powered by TCPDF (www.tcpdf.org)
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review