Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
IN THE HIGH COURT AT CALCUTTA
Civil Appellate Jurisdiction
Appellate Side
Present:
The Hon’ble Justice Biswaroop Chowdhury
F.M.A. 288 of 2024
National Insurance Co. Ltd.
VERSUS
Sandhya Keora And Ors.
With
COT 22 of 2023
Sandhya Keora And Anr.
VERSUS
National Insurance Co. Ltd. & Anr.
For the appellant:
Mr. Sanjay Paul, Adv.
For the respondents/claimants:
Mr. Subhankar Mondal, Adv.
Last Heard on: February 04, 2026
Judgment on: February 19, 2026
Biswaroop Chowdhury, J:
The Appellant before this Court was an opposite party in a case under
Section 166 of the Motor Vehicles Act 1988 and is aggrieved by the Judgment
and Award dated 26-08-2022 passed by Learned Additional District Judge 2nd
Court Asansol Paschim Bardhaman in MAC Case No-52 of 2016. The
respondent no-1/claimants also being aggrieved by the Judgment and Award
passed by the Learned Trial Judge has filed a cross objection.
The case of the respondent no-1/claimant before Learned Trial Court
may be summed up thus:
On 28/06/2015 at about 17.35 hrs, the victim Suresh Keora was going
towards Kulti side from his working place i.e. Kumarpur of Asansol through
G.T. Road by riding his Motor Cycle bearing No-WB/44C-0921, in his left side
of the road with moderate speed. When he reached near New Road of
Neamatpur, under P.S. Kulti at that time, another Motor Cycle bearing NoWB/38J-9128, which was also proceeding in a same direction dashed the side
Motor Cycle, from its’ back rashly and negligently, with high speed. As a result
of such accident the victim fell down by the side of the road from the Motor
Cycle and sustained multiple grievous bleeding injuries all over the body and
head as evident from P.M. report. Soon after the accident the nearby persons
have arranged to sent the victim to Astha Hospital Asansol for better treatment.
Due to non-availability of the expert doctor the victim was shifted to
Vivekananda Hospital Private Limited, Durgapur where the victim succumbed
to his above injuries on 02/07/2015.
Thereafter the P.M. examination was done by the Autopsy surgeon S.D.
Hospital Durgapur vide NTS. P.S. UD case No. 294/2015 dt. 03/07/2015.
The victim had no fault at all for this accident and it actually took place
due to the fault of the driver of the Motor Cycle no-WB-/38J-9128.
The victim was very energetic person having good and sound physique.
The victim was a permanent employee of Bharat Sanchar Nigam Limited (A
Govt. of India Enterprise) as a Regular Mazdoor. The victim would have bright
future in his service carreer if he would have been alive. Due to such accident
the claimants/petitioners have suffered irreparable loss, which cannot be
compensated by way of money but the amount claimed will help them to
survive.
Pursuant to filing of the claim case notice was issued upon the opposite
parties. Opposite Party National Insurance Company contested the case by
filing written statements. Opposite Party vehicle owner although filed written
statement but did not contest the case. ISSUES were framed and evidence was
adduced. Learned Trial Court upon perusing the evidence and hearing the
Learned Advocates was pleased to dispose of the claim case by observing and
directing as follows:
Hence it is ORDERED that the MAC case No. 52 of 2016. (15 of 16) CIS
Regd. No. 86 of 2016 be and the same is allowed on contest without any cost
against the OP no. 2./National Insurance Company Ltd. and ex-parte against
the O.P., No. 1 the owner of the offending vehicle being No. WB/38-J-9128.
The claimant do get an award of Rs. 22, 59, 616- (Twenty Two Lakh Fifty
Nine Thousand Six Hundred Sixteen only) in this proceeding subject to deposit
of deficit Court fee.
The OP no-2 National Insurance Company Ltd. the Insurer of the
offending vehicle being No. WB/38J-9128 is directed to pay the compensation
of Rs. 22,59,616/- (Twenty Two Lakhs Fifty Nine Thousand Six Hundred
Sixteen only) to the claimant/wife i.e. petitioner no. 1 and her daughter i.e.
petitioner no. 2 by two account payee cheques of Rs. 11,49,808/- to the
petitioner no. 1 being the spouse of the deceased and Rs. 11,09,808/- to the
petitioner no. 2 being the daughter of the deceased through the Tribunal within
two months hereof with the interest at the rate of 6% per annum on the
amount of compensation from the date of filing of application till realization in
full subject to deposit of deficit court fees.’
The Appellant National Insurance Co. Ltd. being aggrieved by the
Judgment and Award passed by the Learned Trial Court has come up with the
instant appeal. The respondent no-1 and 2/claimants also being aggrieved by
the Judgment and Award passed by the Learned Trial Judge has filed a cross
objection.
Learned Advocate for the appellant submits that the FIR was lodged after
26 days from the date of accident which makes the case of the claimant
doubtful. Learned Advocate further submits that the driver of the motor cycle
was not having valid driving license thus the award ought not to have been
passed against the Insurance Company. Learned Advocate also submits that
Award cannot be sustained.
Learned Advocate for the respondent no-1, and 2/claimants submits that
the delay in lodging FIR is explained Learned Advocate further submits that the
driver of the motor cycle was holding driving license to drive light Motor Vehicle
Non Transport WEF 26/04/2013. Learned Advocate also submits that the
Learned Trial Court erred in not awarding future prospects to the extent of
15%, thus the compensation awarded should be enhanced.
With regard to the first submission of the Learned Advocate for the
appellant that there was delay in lodging the FIR it appears that the accident
took place on 28-06-2015, and pursuant to the accident the victim was
admitted to hospital where the victim died on 02/07/2015. The FIR was lodged
on 21-07-2015. The FIR maker in the FIR itself has stated that due to the
treatment of her father in hospital till his death and thereafter for the purpose
of completing the rituals there was delay in lodging the FIR. It is held in
different Judicial pronouncements that in Indian Society after accidents
members of the family rushes towards hospital and not for lodging FIR. In the
instant case the victim after accident was admitted to hospital where he died
after three days. Pursuant to the death on 2/07/2015 the FIR was lodged on
21/07/2015. It is quite natural that when a near relation is lost in road
accident the members of the family will be in a state of depression and it takes
time to recover partially from the depression to resume normal work and then
lodge FIR along with compensation claim case. Moreover on the death of a
member, to complete the rituals it takes about 10 to 12 days and this period
being the mourning period. Thus mere delay in FIR is not fatal in a claim case.
In the instant case as the FIR maker/claimant has explained the grounds of
delay in the FIR and the delay should not be viewed with suspicion.
With regard to the second argument of the Learned Advocate for the
appellant that the driver of offending vehicle being WB-38J-9128 was permitted
to drive LMV (Non Transport) and not Motor Cycle and hence there was
violation of policy for which Insurance Company is not liable to pay
compensation, it is settled that when there is violation of policy condition the
Insurance Company upon payment of the compensation may recover the same
in accordance with law. However to recover the compensation the Insurance
Company has to follow certain procedures by conducting enquiry and giving
the vehicle owner an opportunity of being heard.
In the case of National Insurance Co. Ltd. VS Lizasa Bibi and Anr. FMA.
1003 of 2025 (Calcutta High Court) it was observed as follows:
“In the event the violation of policy condition appears at the time of
argument when the case is at the verge of disposal and there was no scope for
the Insurance Company to make preliminary enquiry and give the vehicle owner
an opportunity of being heard the Learned Tribunal after it arrives at a finding
that there was breach of policy condition shall after directing payment by the
Insurance Company to the claimant issue show cause upon the Insured/vehicle
owner as to „why the compensation amount directed to be paid shall not be
recovered.‟ Copy of the Award shall also be enclosed with the notice.
Upon hearing the vehicle owner/insured with regard to violation of policy
condition if the tribunal/Court comes to the conclusion that there was violation of
policy condition which was not bona fide and without sufficient explanation, the
Court/Tribunal will order recovery of amount directed to be Paid by Insurance
Company.
In the normal course where vehicle owners receives notice of claim case
they ordinarily do not appear in Court on the ground that Insurance Company
will settle the claim. However if subsequent allegation is made in the written
statement about violation of policy condition and additional issue in this regard
is framed, and evidence adduced by the Insurance Company further notice in
this regard should be issued upon vehicle owner to meet the allegation. In the
event the Court/Tribunal is of the view that notice to be issued after considering
the evidence adduced in this regard Learned Tribunal may issue notice after
evidence. In any event prior to directing recovery after payment notice in this
regard must be issued specifically and the vehicle owner should be given an
opportunity of being heard.
In the instant case the vehicle owner/insured was not put to notice with
regard to violation of policy condition for the purpose of pay and recovery. Thus
no order with regard to recovery can be directed without the Appellant Insurance
Company causing enquiry and giving the vehicle owner/insured an opportunity
of being heard. Thus the Appellant National Insurance Company Limited is
granted liberty to cause service of notice upon the vehicle owner/insured
annexing copy of the order of trial Court and this order and upon hearing him
with regard to violation of policy condition and recovery of compensation amount
awarded. Upon hearing the insured respondent no-2 Subrata Nath the Appellant
National Insurance Company Limited will decide whether to proceed against the
said respondent for recovery. In the event recovery proceedings is instituted
parties will be entitled to take relevant points involved to enable the
Court/Tribunal to arrive at a just decision.”
In the case of Reliance General Insurance Company Ltd. VS Niyati
Kumar and ors reported in 2025 SCC Online Cal 8886 it was observed as
follows:
“Thus it is well settled that in order to absolve from liability of paying
compensation and to obtain an order of pay and recovery it is mandatory for the
Insurer to prove breach of the condition of Insurance Policy.
Although all Insurance Companies are not „State‟ within the meaning of
Article 12 of the Constitution of India but the fact that third party Motor
Insurance Law is a beneficial Legislation and it has a public aspect and its object
is to protect the public (third parties) from financial losses due to accidents
caused by a motorist by ensuring that victims are compensated. On one hand,
and also to protect the vehicle owners from bearing huge burden of compensation
in case of accidents where the insurance policy condition is complied with on the
other hand. Thus considering the public aspect of Motor Insurance Claims
Insurance Companies have responsibilities to ensure that genuine accident
claims are settled without delay and the vehicle owner who has not violated the
terms of policy is not unnecessarily harassed.
In the event the Insurance Company has reasons to believe that policy
conditions were violated it should conduct an enquiry issue notice upon the
vehicle owner and give him an opportunity of being heard. Where the Insurance
Company is satisfied after enquiry that conditions of policy were not violated the
allegations of violation of policy, namely the vehicle was driven without permit or
without valid driving license should not be raised in Court.
However upon Enquiry if the Insurance Company finds that there was
violation of terms of policy such findings should be recorded by Insurance
Company and necessary evidence should be adduced in Court. In such a case
the Enquiry Report should also be filed in Court, apart from adducing evidence.
A vehicle owner after getting his vehicle insured proceeds with the
assumption that Insurance Company will settle the compensation claim in case
of accidents thus the vehicle owners ordinarily do not appear in Court to contest
claim cases. Thus in the event there is allegation of violation of condition of Policy
the vehicle owners should be given an opportunity of being heard before such
allegation being made in Court and before being examined in Court as witness.
Upon such enquiry being made the Insurance Company can decide as to whether
policy violation was minor or major and whether to condone such violation or
recover the amount of compensation paid.
In the instant case the Appellant Insurance Company has merely alleged
that the vehicle was driven without permit on the ground permit was not seized
by Police Authority but no steps were taken to conduct an enquiry and to
examine officers of Regional Transport Authority as witness with regard to permit
of the vehicle.”
In the instant case although Investigator from the Insurance Company
conducted investigation and collected driving license and documents of the
offending vehicle but the opposite party Insurance Company on the said
documents did not come to a finding that there is a violation of policy condition
and neither made prayer before Court for framing such issue of violation of
policy condition and adduce evidence in this regard by examining necessary
witnesses.
Neither
did
the
Insurance
Company
issue
notice
to
the
insured/vehicle owner, to seek explanation from the said owner and ascertain
as to whether the act of the vehicle owner/insured is deliberate or bona-fide.
Moreover the opposite party Insurance Company did not examine officials of
the Motor Vehicles Authority who would have been in a position to state as to
whether motor cycle can be driven with LMV license, nor the vehicle owner is
examined. Thus in the facts and circumstances it cannot be held that there
was violation of policy condition. Hence the Learned Trial Judge rightly allowed
the claim case and granted compensation, by issuing direction upon Insurance
Company and by not directing recovery.
Now with regard to the quantum of compensation it appears that the
Learned Trial Judge considered the Net Salary by deducting GPF, profession
Tax GSLIS MOU Bank and others. However the income to be considered for the
purpose of computing compensation is the income which remains after
deducting Income Tax and Profession Tax.
In the instant case Learned Trial Court considered the monthly income to
be Rs. 34,340/-. Although profession tax is uniformly deducted Rs. 150/- per
month, the income tax deduction in different months varies; In one month
deduction is 409, another it is 410, and there is no Income Tax Return
document, thus average Income Tax deduction is considered as Rs. 500/- per
month. Thus deduction on account of Income Tax and profession Tax comes to
Rs. 650/- per month. Thus the monthly income after deduction of tax comes to
Rs. 33,690/-. The annual income comes to Rs. 4,04,280/-. Hence it would be
reasonable to proceed by considering yearly income to be Rs. 400,000/-. 15%
future prospect taken into consideration the income comes to Rs. 4,60,000/-.
1/3rd being deducted on account of personal expenditure the income comes to
Rs. 3,06,667/-. Thus the annual dependency loss comes to Rs. 3,06,667/-. As
the victim was 52 years of age multiplier to be applied is 11. The total
dependency loss comes to Rs. 33,73,337/- Further the claimants are entitled
to general damages of Rs. 70,000/-. Thus Rs. 34,43,337/- is the total
compensation which comes by arithmetical calculation. However this Court is
of the view that compensation of Rs. 34,00,000/- is just and reasonable.
Hence FMA-No-288 of 2024 along with COT. 22 of 2023 stands disposed.
Judgment and Award dated 26-08-2022 passed by Learned Additional District
Judge 2nd Court Asansal Paschim Bardhaman in MAC Case No. 52 of 2016
stands modified to the extent that the respondents no. 1, and 2/claimants are
entitled to Rs. 34,00,000/- from the Appellant National Insurance Company
Ltd. The Appellant Insurance Company shall deposit Rs. 34,00,000/- before
the Registrar General High Court Calcutta along with interest @6% per annum
from the date of filing of claim case till today. Such deposit shall be made
within 8 weeks from the date of communication of the order. In the event
amount directed by Learned Trial Court is already deposited balance amount
shall be deposited.
The claimants/respondents are entitled to withdraw the awarded sum
along with accrued interest if any upon compliance of necessary formalities.
Urgent photostat certified copy of this order, if applied for, should be
made available to the parties upon compliance with the requisite formalities.
(Biswaroop Chowdhury, J.)
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review