The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
12. The Supreme Court in the matter of J. Balaji Singh reported in 2017 (14) SCC 207 held thus at paras 15 & 16 : “15. Now coming to the facts of the case, we are of the considered opinion that once the first appellate court allowed the application under Order XLI Rule 27 of the Code and took on record the additional evidence, it rightly set aside the judgment/decree of the trial court giving liberty to the parties to lead additional evidence in support of their case which, in turn, enabled the trial court to decide the civil suit afresh on merits in the light of the entire evidence. The first appellate court was, therefore, justified in taking recourse to powers conferred on the appellate court under Order XLI Rule 23A for remanding the case to the trial court. We find no fault in exercise of such power by the first appellate court. 16…...The reason is that once the first appellate Court formed an opinion to remand the case, it was required to give reasons in support of the remand order as to why the remand is called for in the case. Indeed, the remand was made only to enable the trial court to decide the case on merits. Therefore, there was no need to discuss much a less record findings on several issues on merits. It was totally uncalled for.”
13. In the present matter, while remanding the matter the learned first appellate Court has not expressed its opinion on the merits of the matter. In fact, the learned first appellate Court after considering all the aspects of the matter has rightly allowed the application under Order XLI Rule 27 of the CPC and also given a direction for fresh adjudication. The Trial Court was directed to permit the appellant/defendant to file its pleadings and also grant liberty to the respondent/plaintiff to amend the plaint, if necessary, particularly explaining the circumstances under which the fact of the earlier suit was not disclosed. The Trial Court was further directed to frame appropriate issues, including the issue relating to res judicata, afford opportunity to both parties to lead their respective evidence and thereafter decide the suit afresh on merits in accordance with law. Thus, in the considered view of this Court, the appellate Court has rightly remanded the matter to the trial Court, which does not call for any interference.
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
2026:CGHC:12013
Digitally
signed by
JYOTI
SHARMA
JYOTI
SHARMA Date:
2026.03.17
10:23:07
+0530
NAFR
HIGH COURT OF CHHATTISGARH AT BILASPUR
MA No. 111 of 2022
Nanku Ram Sahu S/o Late Sumer Sahu Aged About 90 Years R/o
Village - Bori, Tahsil - Bori, District - Durg Chhattisgarh
... Appellant(s)
versus
State Of Chhattisgarh Through The Collector, Durg District - Durg
Chhattisgarh
... Respondent(s)
For Appellant
: Mr. Vidhya Bhusan Soni, Advocate
For Respondent/ State
: Mr. Lekhram Dhruv, P.L.
Hon'ble Shri Bibhu Datta Guru, J
Judgment on Board
13.03.2026
1.
By the present appeal under Order 43 Rule 1(u) of the Code of
Civil
Procedure,
(for
brevity
‘the
CPC’),
the
appellant/plaintiff is challenging the impugned judgment and
decree dated 22.11.2022 passed by the learned VIth
Additional District Judge, Durg, C.G. in Regular Civil Appeal
No.57/2022 (State of C.G. Vs. Nanku Ram Sahu), whereby
the judgment and decree passed by the learned XI Civil
Judge, Class- II in Civil Suit No. 94A/2015 dated 16/03/2022
(Nanku Ram Vs. State of C.G.) has been set-aside and the
matter has been remanded for retrial and fresh adjudication
as per points mentioned in para 22 of the judgment rendered
by the appellate court.
2.
For the sake of convenience, the parties would be referred as
per their status before the learned trial Court.
3.
The plaintiff preferred the suit seeking declaration of title and
permanent injunction pleading inter alia that the plaintiff’s
father, Late Sumer Sahu, was in possession of certain
agricultural lands situated at Village Bori, Tehsil Dhamdha,
District Durg, bearing old Khasra Nos. 1929, 1950 and 2028,
which were later renumbered as Khasra Nos. 527 and 559.
Subsequently, parts of the said lands were further
renumbered as Khasra Nos. 796, 797 and 802. The plaintiff
submits that he remained in possession of the said lands
along with his father and, after the death of his father, has
continued to cultivate the same. It is further pleaded that
though the authorities had earlier initiated encroachment
proceedings against the plaintiff and imposed monetary
penalties, the plaintiff was never dispossessed from the suit
land. According to the plaintiff, he has been in continuous
possession and cultivation of the suit land for more than 50
years and, therefore, has perfected his title over the same by
way of adverse possession. It is further stated that despite
service of legal notice dated 18.06.2014 upon the defendant,
no action was taken to record the land in the plaintiff’s name,
hence the present suit has been filed.
4.
The defendant/State has not filed any written statement
before the trial Court and it was proceeded ex parte.
5.
The Trial Court, after framing the issues on appreciation of the
oral and documentary evidence, held that the plaintiff Nanku
Ram proved that he had been in continuous possession and
cultivation of the suit land bearing Khasra Nos. 796, 797 and
802 for more than 50 years. The plaintiff examined himself
and another witness, Shivnath Deshmukh, who supported the
plaintiff’s claim of long and continuous possession over the
suit land. The documents produced by the plaintiff, including
revenue records, renumbering slips, maps and khasra
panchshalas of different years, also indicated the possession
of the plaintiff over the suit property. The Court further noted
that the defendant did not contest the suit and was proceeded
ex parte, and therefore the evidence adduced by the plaintiff
remained unrebutted. On the basis of the material on record,
the Trial Court held that the plaintiff had established
continuous and hostile possession over the suit land for more
than the statutory period and had perfected his title by way of
adverse possession. Consequently, the suit was decreed and
the plaintiff was declared owner of the suit land, and the
defendant was permanently restrained from interfering with
the plaintiff’s possession.
6.
Aggrieved
by
the
said
judgment
and
decree,
the
defendant/State preferred Civil Appeal before the learned first
Appellate Court and also filed an application under Order XLI
Rule 27 of the CPC. The learned First Appellate Court, after
examining the record and the additional documents produced
by the appellant, allowed the application filed under Order 41
Rule 27 of the Code of Civil Procedure and took the said
documents on record. On consideration of the material
available, the Court found that the respondent/ plaintiff had
earlier filed Civil Suit No. 1A/2011 against the State which was
dismissed
on
06.07.2013
and
the
appeal
preferred
thereagainst was also dismissed on 17.07.2014. However,
while filing the present suit for declaration of title and
permanent injunction on 20.08.2014, the respondent had
suppressed the fact of the earlier litigation.
7.
The Appellate Court further observed that the Trial Court had
neither framed nor decided the issue relating to the bar of res
judicata under Section 11 of the Code of Civil Procedure and
had proceeded to decide the suit ex parte without proper
adjudication of the controversy. Holding that the Trial Court
failed to properly appreciate the facts and law and had
committed legal as well as factual errors, the Appellate Court
set aside the judgment and decree dated 16.03.2022 and
remanded the matter to the Trial Court for fresh adjudication.
The Trial Court was directed to permit the appellant to file its
pleadings and also granted liberty to the respondent to amend
the
plaint,
if
necessary,
particularly
explaining
the
circumstances under which the fact of the earlier suit was not
disclosed. The Trial Court was further directed to frame
appropriate issues, including the issue relating to the bar of
res judicata, afford opportunity to both parties to lead
evidence, and thereafter decide the suit afresh in accordance
with law.
8.
Learned counsel submits that the Appellate court failed to
exercise the jurisdiction properly, as in the event, the Trial
Court had omitted to frame or decide any material issue,
particularly the issue relating to res judicata, the proper
course available to the Appellate Court was to invoke the
provisions of Order 41 Rule 25 CPC by framing the necessary
issue and referring the same to the Trial Court for
determination, instead of remanding the entire matter for fresh
trial. Learned counsel submits that the Appellate Court has
thus committed a jurisdictional error in remanding the suit as a
whole. It is also argued that the respondent/defendant had not
appeared before the Trial Court despite service of notice and
had not filed any written statement; therefore, the Trial Court
rightly proceeded ex parte and decided the suit on the basis of
the evidence adduced by the plaintiff. It is further contended
that the finding of the Appellate Court regarding the
applicability of the principle of res judicata is also erroneous,
as the earlier suit filed by the respondent was for mesne
profits and not for declaration of title or permanent injunction.
Hence, the impugned judgment of remand deserves to be set
aside. In support of his contention, he placed reliance upon
the decision rendered by this Court in the matter of Anish
Fulara Vs. Devcharan reported in 2014 (2) CGLJ 2.
9.
I have heard learned counsel for the parties, perused the
material available on record.
10.
The learned First Appellate Court, by the impugned judgment,
first allowed the application filed by the appellant under Order
XLI Rule 27 of the Code of Civil Procedure and took the
additional documents on record. Upon perusal of the said
documents,
the
Appellate
Court
found
that
the
respondent/plaintiff had earlier filed a suit against the State
which had already been adjudicated, but the said fact was not
disclosed in the present suit filed for declaration of title and
permanent injunction. Observing that there was suppression
of the material fact relating to the earlier litigation and that the
Trial Court had not considered or framed any issue regarding
the bar of res judicata, the First Appellate Court set aside the
judgment
and
decree
passed
by
the
Trial
Court.
Consequently, the matter was remanded to the Trial Court
with a direction to permit the parties to file their pleadings,
allow amendment to the plaintiff, if necessary, frame
appropriate issues including the issue of res judicata, afford
opportunity to both sides to lead evidence and thereafter
decide the suit afresh in accordance with law.
11.
It is the trite law that once the appellate Court decides to
remand the matter, it is not required for it to adjudicate on
merits involved in dispute. In fact, discussion and finding on
issues involved in matter, after the appellate Court coming to
conclusion that the matter needed to be remanded, is
uncalled for.
12.
The Supreme Court in the matter of J. Balaji Singh reported
in 2017 (14) SCC 207 held thus at paras 15 & 16 :
“15. Now coming to the facts of the case,
we are of the considered opinion that once the
first appellate court allowed the application
under Order XLI Rule 27 of the Code and took
on record the additional evidence, it rightly set
aside the judgment/decree of the trial court
giving liberty to the parties to lead additional
evidence in support of their case which, in turn,
enabled the trial court to decide the civil suit
afresh on merits in the light of the entire
evidence. The first appellate court was,
therefore, justified in taking recourse to powers
conferred on the appellate court under Order
XLI Rule 23A for remanding the case to the trial
court. We find no fault in exercise of such
power by the first appellate court.
16…...The reason is that once the first
appellate Court formed an opinion to remand
the case, it was required to give reasons in
support of the remand order as to why the
remand is called for in the case. Indeed, the
remand was made only to enable the trial court
to decide the case on merits. Therefore, there
was no need to discuss much a less record
findings on several issues on merits. It was
totally uncalled for.”
13.
In the present matter, while remanding the matter the learned
first appellate Court has not expressed its opinion on the
merits of the matter. In fact, the learned first appellate Court
after considering all the aspects of the matter has rightly
allowed the application under Order XLI Rule 27 of the CPC
and also given a direction for fresh adjudication. The Trial
Court was directed to permit the appellant/defendant to file its
pleadings and also grant liberty to the respondent/plaintiff to
amend the plaint, if necessary, particularly explaining the
circumstances under which the fact of the earlier suit was not
disclosed. The Trial Court was further directed to frame
appropriate issues, including the issue relating to res judicata,
afford opportunity to both parties to lead their respective
evidence and thereafter decide the suit afresh on merits in
accordance with law. Thus, in the considered view of this
Court, the appellate Court has rightly remanded the matter to
the trial Court, which does not call for any interference.
14.
As an upshot, the second appeal is dismissed, and the
judgment impugned passed by the appellate Court dated
21.11.2022 is hereby affirmed.
15.
Both the parties are directed to appear before the concerned
learned trial Court on 22-4-2026.
SD/(Bibhu Datta Guru)
Judge
Jyoti
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review