The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
11. This Court is therefore of the considered view that the petitioner’s case is to be looked at afresh, and though the benefit of the Office Memorandum dated 24.11.1988 may not be strictly applicable, as the case will be governed by the earlier Office Memorandum, the respondents are however directed to consider the case for payment of a reasonable amount as ex-gratia payment, taking into account the peculiar circumstances of the case, and the fact that the case was never referred, or any steps taken for grant of ex-gratia payment from the year 1990 itself. The entire exercise should be completed within a period of 4(four) months from the date of this order.
12. With the above directions, this writ petition stands closed and is accordingly disposed of. Meghalaya
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Serial No. 31
Regular List
HIGH COURT OF MEGHALAYA
AT SHILLONG
WP(C) No. 170 of 2021
Date of Decision: 16.03.2023
Vs.
Smti Nanda Maya Gurung
Union of India & Ors.
Coram:
Hon’ble Mr. Justice H. S. Thangkhiew, Judge
Appearance:
For the Petitioner(s)
:
Mr. Philemon Nongbri, Adv. with
Mr. E. Lalsangluaia, Adv.
For the Respondent(s)
:
Dr. N. Mozika, DSG with
Ms. S. Rumthao, Adv. (For R 1,3-6)
Ms. Z.E. Nongkynrih, GA (For R 2&7)
i)
Whether approved for reporting in
Law journals etc.:
ii)
Whether approved for publication
in press:
Yes/No
Yes/No
JUDGMENT AND ORDER (ORAL)
1.
The petitioner before this Court is stated to be the wife of
the Head Constable, Jiwan Gurung of the 142 Bn. BSF, who was killed
while on duty at Pulvama, Jammu & Kashmir. The respondent No. 6,
thereafter granted cash equivalent to leave salary for 11 days unutilized
earned leave to the petitioner and subsequently the petitioner also
received an amount of Rs. 1,25,000/- (Rupees One Lakh Twenty Five
Thousand only) which was sanctioned by the Government of Jammu &
Kashmir as ex-gratia relief. Another amount of Rs. 20,000/- (Rupees
Twenty Thousand only) from the benevolent fund of the BSF was also
sanctioned to the next of kin. The case of the writ petitioner is that apart
from the payments that have been made, no other ex-gratia amount or
any other entitlements were accorded to the petitioner in spite of the
existence of the executive orders and policy decisions with regard to the
Special Benefits extended in such cases. Hence the writ petition.
2.
Mr. Philemon Nongbri, learned counsel for the petitioner
submits that the Government of India in the Ministry of Personnel, Public
Grievances & Pension, Department of Pension & Pensioner’s Welfare
had vide Office Memorandum dated 11.09.1998, extended the Special
Benefits in cases of death and disability in service and provision for
payment
of
ex-gratia
lumpsum
compensation,
as
per
the
recommendation of the Fifty Pay Central Pay Commission. The only
prayer in the writ petition he submits, is that whatever entitlement the
petitioner is eligible for, should be extended to her. He further submits
that it was only after a representation in 2007, that the ‘Normal Family
Pension’ was changed to ‘Extraordinary Pension’ and that too only in the
year 2009, and Liberalized Pension was granted only after filing of the
instant writ petition.
3.
The learned counsel has then drawn the attention of this
Court to the Office Memorandum dated 11.09.1998, which deals with
the Special Benefits in cases of death and disability in service. It is further
submitted that by way of the said Office Memorandum dated 11.09.1998,
reference had been made to another Office Memorandum dated
25.05.1990, whereby the Scheme for ex-gratia lumpsum compensation
to the families of Central Government employees killed in incidents of
terrorist violence in Punjab, had been extended to Jammu & Kashmir. He
therefore prays that as no steps were taken by the respondents, to accord
the ex-gratia payment, this Court pass directions for compliance of the
Office Memorandum dated 25.05.1990.
4.
Dr. N. Mozika, learned DSG assisted by Ms. S. Rumthao,
learned counsel for the respondent No. 1, 3 to 6 submits that the Office
Memorandum dated 11.09.1998, will not be applicable to the case of the
petitioner as the petitioner was killed in November, 1990, before the
issuance of the said Office Memorandum. It is also submitted by the
learned DSG that the applicability of the Office Memorandums, whether
11.09.1998 or 25.05.1990, is questionable as the same speaks about
lumpsum compensation to the families of Central Government
employees killed in incidents of terrorist violence, whereas the writ
petitioner’s husband was a Head Constable in the BSF. Referring to the
affidavit filed on behalf of the respondent No. 1, 3 to 6, the learned DSG
submits that the Office Memorandum dated 25.05.1990, which is in
continuation of the earlier Office Memorandum dated 24.11.1988,
speaks of continuation of the existing procedures which are adopted by
different Departments, which are on the case to case basis, and further
that the families of the deceased Government employees be given a
minimum of Rs. 50,000/- (Rupees Fifty Thousand only) as lumpsum
payment.
5.
I have heard the learned counsel for the parties.
6.
Shorn of the other details, the only point to be decided is
whether the petitioner herein has been accorded ex-gratia payment under
any Scheme by the respondents due to the loss of her husband in a
terrorist attack in Jammu & Kashmir. When the matter was initially
brought before this Court and on examination of the Office
Memorandum dated 11.09.1998, wherein reference had been made to the
D.O. letter dated 25.05.1990, this Court was not in in position to discern
or to examine the eligibility of the writ petitioner, inasmuch as, the said
D.O. letter was not before this Court. The same has however, been
brought on record by an additional affidavit filed by the respondents
along with the other connected documents.
7.
A perusal of the Office Memorandum dated 11.09.1998
reflects that there are specific instructions with regard the Special
Benefits to be given to Central Government employees who have died in
various circumstances; and in cases of death occurring due to action
against militants or extremists, the amount has been fixed at Rs.
7,50,000/- (Rupees Seven Lakhs Fifty Thousand only), However, as
submitted by the learned DSG, the said Office Memorandum will have
no application to the case of the petitioner, as the death had occurred
much earlier before the issuance of the same. It is relevant therefore to
examine the D.O. letter dated 25.05.1990 which has been referred in the
Office Memorandum dated 24.11.1988, to ascertain as to what
entitlements the petitioner is eligible for.
8.
However, before coming to the D.O. letter dated 25.05.1990
which only extends the instructions/policy of Punjab to Jammu &
Kashmir, the D.O. letter dated 24.11.1988 which contains the policy is
to be examined. The same for the sake of convenience is reproduced
hereinbelow:“D.O. No. 46/1/88-P&PWF(F)
24.11.88
Dear
Subject: Compensation to the families of Central Govt.
employees killed in incidents of terrorist violence
in Punjab.
******
There is no provision at present for granting any
lump sum compensation to the families of Central Govt.
employees killed in incidents due to terrorist violence in
Punjab. The question whether any provision in this behalf
needs to be made on the lines or orders issued by the Govt.
of Punjab was recently considered by the Committee of
Secretaries. It was observed that various Departments are
following different schemes for compensating their
employees. In some Departments compensation under the
Workmens’ Compensation Act is being paid. In other
Departments also some ex-gratia grant is being made on a
case by case basis. In the light of this it was decided by the
Committee of Secretaries that there was no need for issue
of any instructions to give ex-gratia grant to Central Govt.
employees killed in terrorist violence on the pattern of the
Punjab Government and that the existing procedure
followed by different Department could be continued. The
Committee, however, felt that the Departments could
ensure that the amount paid to the families of deceased
govt. servants may be a minimum of Rs.50,000/- in such
cases. In computing this amount payments ordinarily
made in case of death not attributable to service such as
Death Gratuity under the Ordinary Pension Rules,
CGEIS, Deposit Linked Insurance Scheme in G.P.F. etc.,
should not be taken into account but any other item which
is payable in case of death attributable to service should
be included as a part of the total amount of Rs.50,000/- to
be paid to the families of the deceased govt. servants in
such cases.
2.
It is requested that each individual case for grant of
compensation to families of Central Govt. employees
killed in terrorist violence in Punjab arising in your
Ministry and the offices thereunder may be processed in
the light of the above mentioned decision of the Committee
of Secretaries. It is also requested that all such cases may
be referred to the Department of Pension and Pensioners’
Welfare for prior clearance to ensure consistency in
approach in deciding the quantum of compensation in
such cases.
With regards,
Yours sincerely,
Sd/(A.C. Tiwari)”
9.
A perusal of the above quoted D.O. letter shows that the
respondents at that point of time, felt that there was no necessity for
issuance of any instructions for grant of ex-gratia to the Central
Government employees killed in terrorist violence, and that the existence
of the procedures followed by different Departments should be
continued, and further that the Departments were to ensure that the
amount was to be minimum of Rs. 50,000/- (Rupees Fifty Thousand
only). The above D.O. letter was extended to the State of Jammu &
Kashmir by the D.O. dated 25.05.1990 and reads as follows:“GOVERNMENT OF INDIA
DEPARTMENT OF PENSION AND PENSIONERS’
MINISTRY OF PERSONNEL PUBLIC GRIEVANCES AND
PENSIONS, NEW DELHI
S.K. PARTHASARATHY
ADDL SECRETARY
WELFARE
D.O. No. 46/1/88-P&PW(K)
25 MAY 1990
Kindly refer to Confidential D.O. letter No. 46/1/88-P7PW
(F) dated 24th November, 1988 issued by my predecessor – Shri
A.C. Tiwari (copy enclosed for ready reference) regarding exgratia grant to the families in respect of Central Government
employees killed in incidence of terrorist violence in Punjab.
2.
It has since been decided to extend the provisions of the
above mentioned instructions to the families of Central
Government employees killed in terrorist violence in Jammu &
Kashmir. It is requested that each individual case for grant of
compensation to the families in respect of Central Government
employees killed in terrorist violence in Jammu & Kashmir
arising in your Ministry and the offices there under may be
processed accordingly and referred to the Department of
Pension & Pensioners’ Welfare as per the present practice.
Yours Sincerely,
(S.K. PARTHASARATHY)”
10.
On examination of the materials that have been placed
before this Court, there is nothing to show that the respondents had taken
any steps in pursuance to the above D.O. letters to process payment of
any ex-gratia grant to the deceased employee. The fact that the pension
of the petitioner comes under the Department under the Ministry of
Personnel, Public Grievances & Pension, Department of Pension &
Pensioner’s Welfare is not disputed. There are no reasons therefore, to
justify as to why the case of the husband of the writ petitioner was never
processed in accordance with the policy in place.
11.
This Court is therefore of the considered view that the
petitioner’s case is to be looked at afresh, and though the benefit of the
Office Memorandum dated 24.11.1988 may not be strictly applicable, as
the case will be governed by the earlier Office Memorandum, the
respondents are however directed to consider the case for payment of a
reasonable amount as ex-gratia payment, taking into account the peculiar
circumstances of the case, and the fact that the case was never referred,
or any steps taken for grant of ex-gratia payment from the year 1990
itself. The entire exercise should be completed within a period of 4(four)
months from the date of this order.
12.
With the above directions, this writ petition stands closed
and is accordingly disposed of.
JUDGE
Meghalaya
16.03.2023
“V. Lyndem-PS”
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review