Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
2026:HHC:41814
IN THE HIGH COURT OF HIMACHAL PRADESH AT SHIMLA
Cr.W.P No. 73 of 2026
Decided on : 28.09.2026
Namveer Singh alias Badal
…Petitioner
Versus
State of Himachal Pradesh and another
…Respondents
Coram
The Hon’ble Mr. Justice G.S. Sandhawalia, Chief Justice.
The Hon’ble Mr. Justice Bipin C. Negi, Judge.
Whether approved for reporting?1
For the petitioner
: M/s Vijender Katoch and Kapil
Sharma, Advocates.
For the respondents
: Mr. Sidharth Jalta, Deputy Advocate
General.
G.S. Sandhawalia, Chief Justice (Oral)
Challenge in the present petition is to the detention
order dated 18.07.2026 (Annexure P-1), whereby the petitioner
was detained for a period of three months under Section 3(1)
read with Section 5 of the Prevention of Illicit Traffic in Narcotic
Drugs and Psychotropic Substances Act, 1988 (for short ‘the PIT
NDPS Act’).
2.
The reason as such for the detention was that there
were two FIRs registered against the petitioner under the NDPS
Act. The details of the said FIRs are as under:i.
In FIR No. 161/2024, dated 19.10.2024, at Police Station
Indora, Police District Nurpur, H.P., under Section 21 of
1Whether reporters of the local papers may be allowed to see the judgment?
2026:HHC:41814
the
Narcotic Drugs and Psychotropic Substances Act,
1985, wherein approximately 7.23 grams of heroin/chitta
were recovered from him;
ii.
In FIR No. 188/2025, dated 14.11.2025, at Police Station
Indora, Police District Nurpur, H.P., under Sections 21
and 29 of
the
Narcotic
Substances Act, 1985,
Drugs
and
Psychotropic
wherein approximately 9.42
grams of heroin/chitta were recovered from him.
3.
Counsel for the petitioner has pointed out that the
last FIR No. 188/2025 in question was dated 14.11.2025. Even
as per the reply of the State, the proposal against the detenue
was only made on 06.05.2026. Admittedly, he had been released
on bail vide order dated 20.12.2025 (Annexure P-4), in the said
FIR. It is thus submitted that the issue of proximate and live link
as such, would come into play and the benefit of the quashing of
the said order would have to be given effect.
4.
Similarly, it is pointed out that a specific averment
was made that a representation was made against his detention
on 20.08.2026 (Annexure P-2), whereby various pleas as such,
were raised including the fact of live link and the source report
dated 04.05.2026 on the basis of which the proposal was given.
The said source report is bereft of any particulars whatsoever, as
it disclosed no dates, no names of alleged purchasers, no
quantifies, no transactions and no seizures and was not backed
by any FIR or recovery and merely pendency of two FIRs as
2026:HHC:41814
such, would not make it a fit case for detention.
5.
It is submitted that in spite of the directions issued by
this Court while issuing notice on 09.09.2026, the representation
of the petitioner still has not been decided. Reference is also
made to the reply filed by the State regarding the contents of
Para-4, whereby the stand taken is that the detention would still
be sustainable and there is mention that the non-decision as
such, does not invalidates the detention.
6.
On the other hand, counsel for the State has laid a
lot of emphasis on the background of the petitioner and his family
to contend that his brother and mother were also involved in 5
cases of ND&PS Act. The father of the petitioner was involved in
12 cases and recently has been convicted in FIR No. 28/2023,
dated 21.02.2023 and the appeal against the said conviction is
still pending in the Court and was also convicted in two other
FIRs. He further pointed out that the mother of the petitioner was
also placed under preventive detention for a period of three
months vide detention order dated 03.05.2025. He thus submitted
that the petitioner and his family members are involved in drug
peddling and the detention order dated 18.07.2026 was rightly
passed and is not liable to be quashed.
7.
In similar circumstances, regarding the issue of non-
decision of the representation in Cr.W.P. No. 68 of 2026, titled
2026:HHC:41814
Vicky Kumar Vs. State of Himachal Pradesh and another,
decided on 31.08.2026, we had quashed the detention order
since in spite of the directions issued by this Court while issuing
notice, a month had gone by and the representation had not been
decided. The reasons given in the said judgment reads as under:“6.
We are of the considered opinion that there is a
gross violation of Article 22 (5) of the Constitution of India
in the present case. The mandate provided under the
Constitution does not seem to be taken very seriously and
very casually, regarding the personal liberty of an
individual. Article 22(5) provides that from the moment a
person is detained, an opportunity has to be given to him
to make a representation against the order and he has to
be communicated the grounds or which the order has been
made. The law is clear on this aspect that the person, who
passes the order as such, has to firstly examine whether
his order is justified and whether the representation makes
out a case to revoke the order of detention and set the
person at liberty.
7.
Reliance can be placed upon the five-Judge Bench,
judgment passed by the Hon’ble Apex Court in Kamlesh
Kumar Ishwardas Patel versus Union of India and
others, (1995) 4 SCC 51. The purpose of making the
representation has been highlighted time and again,
keeping in mind the golden principle, as such enshrined in
Articles 14, 21 and 22 of the Constitution of India which are
stated to be the golden triangle, on which the rights of the
citizens of this Country as such rest. The State is under
legal obligation to decide the said representation more so,
keeping in view the fact that earlier two FIRs, as noticed
above, were of the year 2019 and 2020, after a period of
six years and under the third FIR, which has been lodged
only 118 grams of charas has been recovered and bail was
2026:HHC:41814
granted in the said FIR on 19.03.2026. The detention order
as such does not depict whether the bail had been granted
and only talks out earlier two FIRs, in which the petitioner
was involved.
8.
The Apex Court in a recent case, i.e. SLP (Cr.)
No.8439 of 2026 titled as Alfiya. A versus State of
Kerala and others, decided on 28.07.2026, has set aside
the detention order on the ground of the right of
representation and consideration and the fact that there
was a delay and also took into account the fact that
representation had been placed before the Advisory Board.
It was noticed that if the representation is pending before
the Advisory Board and that the opinion of the Advisory
Board can not substitute the independent consideration
required by the authority to revoke the detention. Apart
from the fact that there was delay of 34 days, to the
consideration made and the Hon’ble Apex Court came into
the conclusion that there was violation of Article 22(5) of
the Constitution of India. Relevant paragraphs 18 to 22,
are read, as under:“18.
In the present case, the order of detention
was made by the Detaining Authority in exercise of
the power conferred upon an officer specially
empowered under Section 3(1) of the PITNDPS Act.
The detenu was informed that he could make
representations to the State Government, the
Advisory Board and the Central Government. He
was not separately informed that he was entitled to
make a representation to the officer who had made
the order of detention in exercise of the specially
conferred statutory power. The omission is evident
from the detention order itself. The fact that the
detenu
nevertheless
addressed
one
of
his
representations to the Detaining Authority cannot
cure the failure to inform him of that constitutional
right. The obligation was upon the authority to
2026:HHC:41814
communicate the right and could not depend upon
whether the detenu independently became aware of
it.
19.
The matter does not rest with the failure to
inform the detenu his right. The representation
addressed to the Detaining Authority was submitted
on 13.02.2026. The case was thereafter referred to
the Advisory Board on 16.02.2026. The Advisory
Board submitted its report only on 13.03.2026.
Neither the order of confirmation not the counter
affidavit filed before this Court discloses any
separate
consideration
representation
by
the
or
decision
Detaining
upon
the
Authority
in
exercise of its statutory power. On the contrary, the
case of the respondents is that the representation
was examined together with the opinion of the
Advisory
Board
and
the
other
connected
documents. This sequence indicates that the
representation was kept pending until the Advisory
Board had rendered its opinion and was thereafter
dealt with as part of the governmental exercise of
confirmation. The consideration of a representation
under Article 22(5) and the examination undertaken
by the Advisory Board are distinct constitutional
processes. The opinion of the Advisory Board
cannot substitute the independent consideration
required from an authority competent to revoke the
detention. This principle stands recognized by this
Court in Gracy versus State of Kerala and K.M.
Abdulla Kunhi versus Union of India. The record in
the present case does not disclose the distinct and
independent
decision
which
the
constitutional
guarantee required.
20.
There is also an unexplained delay in
dealing with the representation. Even if the order of
confirmation dated 19.03.2026 is treated as the first
2026:HHC:41814
decision upon the representation dated 13.02.2026,
a period of 34 days had elapsed before such
consideration. A further period of eight days elapsed
before the rejection was communicated to the
detenu on 27.03.2026. No separate order deciding
the representation has been placed before us. Nor
has any satisfactory or day-to-day explanation been
furnished for the time taken either to consider the
representation or to communicate the decision. The
general statement that the representation was
examined together with the opinion of the Advisory
Board does not explain the delay. It instead
reinforces the conclusion that the representation
was not treated as an independent constitutional
process requiring immediate attention.
21.
We accordingly hold that the safeguards
attaching to the right of the detenu to make a
representation against his detention were not
observed. The detenu was not informed of his right
to represent to the Detaining Authority who had
made the order. The record does not disclose any
independent decision upon the representation by
the Detaining Authority in exercise of his own
statutory power. The consideration disclosed by the
respondents was undertaken only as part of the
subsequent confirmation exercise, and even that
consideration was attended by an unexplained
delay. These infirmities violate Article 22 (5) of the
Constitution and are sufficient to render the
continued detention of the detenue illegal. 22. The
infirmities noted above are not mere technical or
procedural irregularities capable of being cured by
substantial
compliance.
They
concern
the
enforcement of the constitutional right guaranteed
by Article 22(5) to a person detained without trial.
Once
a
mandatory
constitutional
safeguard
2026:HHC:41814
governing preventive detention is found to have
been violated, the continued detention cannot be
sustained. The High Court did not examine whether
the representation submitted by the detenu received
the independent and expeditious consideration
required by Article 22(5) of the Constitution. Since
that issue bears directly upon the legality of the
continued detention, the judgment of the High Court
cannot be sustained.”
9.
Leaned counsel has also supplied the order passed
in Criminal Appeal No.2189 of 2026, titled as Sunil
Kumar Gupta alias Sunil Chain versus Union of India &
others, decided 27.04.2026, wherein, it was held that it is
a duty imposed on the government to consider the
representation of the detenu at the earliest point of time
and not though forwarded by Government. The competent
authority to the State Relevant part of the judgment, is
reads, as under:“The facts referred to above would
clearly show
that the detenu’s representation was not sent to the
State Government immediately, and that it was
rejected belatedly. A duty is imposed on the
concerned
Government
to
consider
the
representation of the detenu at the earliest point of
time. In the present case, the detaining authority did
not forward the representation to the
State
Government immediately, though it had actually
been sent to the detaining authority by the prison
authority at the earliest point of time. The State
Government on its part has approved the detention
order and only thereafter,considered the detenu’s
representation. The representation of the detenu
made to the State Government has nothing do do
with either the detaining authority or even the
Advisory Board. Unfortunately, the aforesaid action
of
considering
the
representation
was
not
2026:HHC:41814
forthcoming at the earliest point of time. This would
vitiate both the detention order and its subsequent
approval. In such view of the matter, both the
detention order and its subsequent approval shall
stand quashed. Accordingly, the impugned order
passed by the High Court is set aside. The
appellant shall be released forthwith. The appeal
stands allowed, accordingly, pending application(s)
if any, shall stand disposed of.”
10.
Keeping in view of the above, we are of the
considered opinion that on account of aforesaid reasons,
detention order, dated 08.06.2026 (Annexure P-1), and all
consequential orders are not liable to be sustained and the
same are quashed and set-aside. ”
8.
Counsel for the petitioner has placed reliance upon
another judgment of the Apex Court in passed in Criminal
Appeal No. 2189/2026, titled Sunil Kumar Gupta alias Sunil
Chain Vs. Union of India and others, decided on 27.04.2026,
wherein also, on account of the non-decision as such, by the
State, it is held that it is the duty of the concerned Government to
consider the representation of the detenue at the earliest point of
time and the inaction on the part of the Government would vitiate
both the detention order and its subsequent approval. In such
circumstances, the detention order and the subsequent approval
dated 27.04.2026 had been quashed in the said case. The said
aspect would squarely cover the case of the present petitioner.
9.
Similarly, the issue of live link factor would have also
to be taken into consideration considering that period of more
2026:HHC:41814
than 7 months had gone by, since the release of petitioner on bail
in an earlier FIR. The Hon’ble Apex Court in Sama Aruna vs.
State of Telangana, (2018) 12 SCC 150, has held that a preventive
detention order passed was without examining the existence of a
live and proximate link between the alleged events and the order of
detention would amount to punishment of a crime, passed without a
trial, and that the exceptional powers of preventive detention cannot
be permitted to devolve into a draconian and arbitrary exercise of
the State authority. It has also been held that the two FIRs
registered against the detenue were capable of being dealt with in
the ordinary course of criminal law. The relevant portion reads as
under:“17. We are, therefore, satisfied that the aforesaid
detention order was passed on grounds which are stale
and which could not have been considered as relevant
for arriving at the subjective satisfaction that the detenu
must be detained. The detention order must be based
on a reasonable prognosis of the future behavior of a
person based on his past conduct in light of the
surrounding circumstances. The live and proximate link
that must exist between the past conduct of a person
and the imperative need to detain him must be taken to
have been snapped in this case. A detention order
which is founded on stale incidents, must be regarded
as an order of punishment for a crime, passed without a
trial, though purporting to be an order of preventive
detention.
The
essential
concept
of
preventive
detention is that the detention of a person is not to
2026:HHC:41814
punish him for something he has done but to prevent
him from doing it. See G. Reddeiah v. Government of
Andhra Pradesh and Anr.2 , and P.U. Iqbal v. Union of
India.
18 to 21 x--------x----------x-----------x-------------x
22. We are of the view, that the detention order in this
case is vitiated by taking into account incidents so far
back in the past as would have no bearing on the
immediate need to detain him without a trial. The
satisfaction of the authority is not in respect of the thing
in regard to which it is required to be satisfied. Incidents
which are stale, cease to have relevance to the subject
matter of the enquiry and must be treated as
extraneous to the scope and purpose of the statute.
23. In this case, we find the authority has come to a
conclusion
so
unreasonable
that
no
reasonable
authority could ever reach. A detaining authority must
be taken to know both, the purpose and the procedure
of law. It is no answer to say that the authority was
satisfied. In T.A. Abdul Rahman v. State of Kerela and
Ors., this Court observed, where the authority takes into
account stale incidents which have gone by to seed it
would be safe to infer that the satisfaction of the
authority is not a genuine one.
24 & 25 x--------x----------x-----------x-------------x
26. The influence of the stale incidents in the detention
order is too pernicious to be ignored, and the order
must therefore go; both on account of being vitiated due
to malice in law and for taking into account matters
which ought not to have been taken into account.”
10.
Reliance can also be placed upon the judgments of the
Apex Court in Mallada K. Sri Ram Vs. State of Telangana and
2026:HHC:41814
Others, (2023) 13 SCC 537, Ameena Begum Vs. The State of
Telangana (2023) 9 SCC 587 and Rekha Vs. State of Tamil Nadu
(2011) 5 SCC 244.
11.
Resultantly, the present petition is allowed and the
detention order dated 18.07.2026 (Annexure P-1) is quashed.
The petitioner be set free forthwith, if not required in any other
case. Pending miscellaneous application(s), if any, also stand
disposed of accordingly.
(G.S. Sandhawalia)
Chief Justice
(Bipin C. Negi)
Judge
September 28, 2026
(Shivank Thakur)
Digitally
signed by
SHIVANK
SHIVANK THAKUR
THAKUR Date:
2026.09.29
17:34:39
+0530
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review