Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
-1-
WA No. 2107 of 2025
C/W WA No.1861 of 2026
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA AT BENGALURU
DATED THIS THE 17TH DAY OF SEPTEMBER, 2026
PRESENT
THE HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE D K SINGH
AND
THE HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE H.SHANTHI BHUSHAN
WRIT APPEAL NO. 2107 OF 2025 (LR)
C/W
WRIT APPEAL NO. 1861 OF 2026 (LR)
W.A.NO.2107/2025
BETWEEN:
1.
Digitally
signed by
VASANTHA
KUMARY B K
Location:
HIGH
COURT OF
KARNATAKA
NAMMA WHITEFIELD RWA
FEDERATION TRUST
REPRESENTED BY ITS PRESIDENT
MR. ANIRUDHAN SANDEEP
C/O S.V. MILAN APARTMENTS
NO.1352, SWAMI VIVEKANANDA ROAD
UPKAR LAYOUT, WHITEFIELD
BENGALURU-560 066
…APPELLANT
(BY SRI AKANKSH ASHOK, ADVOCATE)
AND:
1.
THE STATE OF KARNATAKA
REPRESENTED BY ITS
PRINCIPAL SECRETARY
REVENUE DEPARTMENT
VIDHANA SOUDHA
BENGALURU-560 001
2.
THE CHAIRMAN
LAND TRIBUNAL
(DELETED V/O
DATED 07.07.2026)
®
-2-
WA No. 2107 of 2025
C/W WA No.1861 of 2026
H B MUNIVENKATAPPA
S/O LATE S BOYANNA
SINCE DEAD
REPRESENTED BY HIS LRS
3.
SMT. SHAKUNTALA
ADULT
4.
SRI D M PADMANABHA
ADULT
5.
SMT. PREMANKUMARI
ADULT
6.
SRI M MOHANSUNDAR
ADULT
7.
SRI M RAJASHEKAR
ADULT
8.
DR. M CHANDRASHEKARA
R3 TO R8 ARE
REPRESENTED BY THEIR GPA HOLDER
SRI M MOHANSUNDAR
ALL RESIDING AT NO.314
"DWARAKA", INNER CIRCLE
WHITE FIELD, NEAR K.R.PURAM
BENGALURU SOUTH TALUK
(R4-R8 ARE LRS OF DECEASED R3 V/O DATED 07.07.2026)
…RESPONDENTS
(BY SRI KIRAN V RON, AAG FOR
SRI M N SUDEV HEGDE, AGA FOR R1;
SRI MANMOHAN P N, ADVOCATE FOR R4, R5, R6 & R8;
SRI K N PHANINDRA, SENIOR ADVOCATE FOR
SRI ABHINAY S, ADVOCATE FOR R7;
R2 DELETED VIDE ORDER DATED 07.07.2026)
-3-
WA No. 2107 of 2025
C/W WA No.1861 of 2026
THIS WRIT APPEAL IS FILED UNDER SECTION 4 OF THE
KARNATAKA HIGH COURT ACT PRAYING TO SET ASIDE THE
IMPUGNED ORDER DATED 19.11.2025 PASSED IN W.P.
NO.26097/2018 AND CONSEQUENTLY ALLOW THE RELIEFS
PRAYED FOR IN W.P.NO.26097/2018.
IN W.A.NO.1861/2026:
BETWEEN:
1.
THE STATE OF KARNATAKA
REPRESENTED BY ITS
PRINCIPAL SECRETARY
REVENUE DEPARTMENT
VIDHANA SOUDHA
DR. AMBEDKAR VEEDHI
BENGALURU-560 001
…APPELLANT
(BY SRI KIRAN V RON, AAG FOR
SRI M N SUDEV HEGDE, AGA)
AND:
H B MUNIVENKATAPPA
S/O LATE BOYANNA
SINCE DEAD BY HIS LRS
1.
SMT. A SHAKUNTALA
2.
SRI D M PADMANABHA
3.
SMT. PREMANKUMARI
4.
SRI M MOHANSUNDAR
5.
SRI M RAJASHEKAR
6.
DR. M CHANDRASHEKARA
REPRESENTED BY GPA HOLDER
SRI M MOHANASUNDAR
-4-
WA No. 2107 of 2025
C/W WA No.1861 of 2026
ALL ARE RESIDING AT NO.314
"DWARAKA", INNER CIRCLE
WHITE FIELD, NEAR K.R. PURAM
BANGALORE SOUTH TALUK
7.
THE CHAIRMAN LAND TRIBUNAL,
BENGALURU SOUTH TALUK
BENGALURU-560 009
8.
NAMMA WHITEFIELD RESIDENTS
WELFARE ASSOCIATION FEDERATION
C/O S V MILAN APARTMENTS, NO.1352
SWAMI VIVEKANANDA ROAD
UPKAR LAYOUT, WHITEFIELD
BENGALURU-560 066
REPRESENTED BY ITS PRESIDENT
…RESPONDENTS
(BY SRI MANMOHAN P N, ADVOCATE FOR R2 TO R5;
SRI K N PHANINDRA, SENIOR ADVOCATE FOR
SRI ABHINAY S, ADVOCATE FOR R6;
SMT. SHIVANI SHETTY, ADVOCATE FOR R8)
THIS WRIT APPEAL IS FILED UNDER SECTION 4 OF THE
KARNATAKA HIGH COURT ACT PRAYING TO SET ASIDE THE
IMPUGNED
ORDER
DATED
19.11.2025
PASSED
BY
THE
LEARNED SINGLE JUDGE IN WRIT PETITION NO. 26097/2018
BY ALLOWING THIS APPEAL.
THESE APPEALS HAVING BEEN HEARD AND RESERVED
FOR
JUDGMENT
PRONOUNCEMENT
ON
14.08.2026,
THIS
DAY,
COMING
HON'BLE
D K SINGH PRONOUNCED THE FOLLOWING:
MR.
ON
FOR
JUSTICE
-5-
WA No. 2107 of 2025
C/W WA No.1861 of 2026
CORAM:
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE D K SINGH
and
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE H.SHANTHI BHUSHAN
CAV JUDGMENT
(PER: HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE D K SINGH)
PREFACE:
1.
The
present
intra-court
appeals
have
been
filed
impugning the judgment and order dated 19.11.2025 passed
by the learned Single Judge in W.P.No.26097/2018, whereby
the order dated 27.12.1980 passed by the Land Tribunal,
Bengaluru South Taluk, in Case No.LRF.5063/79-80 was upheld
and the writ petition came to be dismissed. W.A.No.2107/2025
has been filed by Namma Whitefield RWA Federation Trust and
W.A.No.1861/2026 has been filed by the State of Karnataka
(hereinafter referred to as 'the State').
FACTS OF THE CASE:
2.
The land in Sy.No.54 (old Sy.No.15), measuring 11 acres
20 guntas, situated at Pattandur Agrahara Village, Bengaluru
South Taluk originally belonged to one Muniswamappa of
Hoskote, who sold the property to another Muniswappa of
Ulsoor vide registered Sale Deed dated 06.06.1918 who in turn
-6-
WA No. 2107 of 2025
C/W WA No.1861 of 2026
sold the property in favour of Sri H.T.Thimmareddy vide
registered Sale Deed dated 10.11.1927. On 18.10.1931 an
extent of 20 Guntas of land in Sy.No.54 was acquired by the
Government of Mysore (now Government of Karnataka) for the
purpose of a bore well for water supply to Whitefield Village
wherein the land was shown as dry land. On 07.11.1947 the
legal heirs of Sri. H.T.Thimmareddy sold 11 Acres 20 Guntas of
land
in
Sy.No.54
in
favor
of
Captain
Armugam
Pillai
Thyagarajan who in turn sold the property in favor of
Sri.H.B.Munivenkatappa
vide
registered
Sale
Deed
dated
26.12.1960.
3.
The Mysore (Personal and Miscellaneous) Inams Abolition
Act, 1954 (hereinafter referred to as ‘the Inams Abolition Act’)
came into force on 19.03.1955, and the said land in Sy.No.54
came to be vested in the state government. Sri. H.B.
Munivenkatappa made an application under the provisions of
the Inams Abolition Act before the Land Tribunal, Bangalore for
re-grant of the said land. On 27.12.1980 the Land Tribunal
granted occupancy rights of land in Sy.No.54, measuring 11
Acres 20 Guntas, situated at Pattandur Agrahara Village,
-7-
WA No. 2107 of 2025
C/W WA No.1861 of 2026
K.R.Puram
Hobli,
Bengaluru
in
favor
of
Sri.
H.B.
Munivenkatappa after collecting necessary premium amount.
4.
An eviction notice dated 11.06.1979 was issued by the
then Tahsildar to Sri. H.B. Munivenkatappa. The said notice was
challenged by Sri. H.B. Munivenkatappa in W.P.No.7908/1979,
which came to be allowed in the year 1987 and the notice
dated 11.06.1979 was quashed. Being aggrieved, the State
filed appeal in W.A.No.381/1988 against the judgment and
order passed in W.P.No.7908/1979, which also came to be
dismissed vide order dated 01.03.1988.
5.
Thereafter,
Sri.H.B.Munivenkatappa
(original
plaintiff)
filed O.S.No.394/1993 seeking a declaration that he is the
absolute owner of the land in Sy.No.54 by virtue of the
registered sale deed and that the land is a 'Hiduvali' land and
not a tank bed and also sought for permanent injunction
restraining
the
State
from
interfering
with
the
peaceful
possession and enjoyment. The said suit came to be decreed in
favor of legal heirs of late Sri H.B.Munivenkatappa vide order
dated 24.01.1995 holding that they are the owners of the
subject land and the land is a ‘hinduvali land’ and not a tank
bed. The State preferred appeal in R.A.No.38/2004 which came
-8-
WA No. 2107 of 2025
C/W WA No.1861 of 2026
to be dismissed vide order dated 26.10.2004. The State
thereafter filed appeal in R.S.A.No.2166/2006 which was
allowed vide order dated 08.03.2007 and remanded the matter
back to the lower appellate court to consider the case afresh.
R.A.No.38/2004 filed by the State once again came to be
dismissed vide order dated 17.12.2008 however, liberty was
given to the State to challenge the legality of the order passed
by the Land Tribunal.
6.
The State filed R.S.A.No.142/2009 before this Court
challenging the judgment and decree dated 17.12.2008 which
came to be dismissed vide order dated 24.11.2016. The State
thereafter
filed
S.L.P.(C)No.10357/2018
challenging
the
judgment and order dated 24.11.2016 and the same came to
be dismissed by the Supreme Court both on delay and merits.
A Review Petition (C) No.129/2019 filed by the State also came
to be dismissed by the Supreme Court vide order dated
12.02.2019. W.P.No.24122/2018 & connected matter (PIL) filed
by the Pattandur Agrahara Residential Welfare Associations
federation in respect of the subject land also came to be
dismissed vide order dated 24.04.2019.
-9-
WA No. 2107 of 2025
C/W WA No.1861 of 2026
7.
The State has filed the present W.P.No.26097/2018
challenging the order dated 27.12.1980 passed by the Land
Tribunal
in
LRF
No.5063/79-80
which also
came
to
be
dismissed vide order dated 19.11.2025. The present intra-Court
appeals have been filed impugning the order dated 19.11.2025
FINDINGS OF THE
W.P.NO.26097/2018:
8.
LEARNED
SINGLE
JUDGE
IN
The learned Single Judge has held that the validity and
genuineness of the Land Tribunal order dated 27.12.1980 and
the nature of the subject land had already been considered in
the earlier proceedings.
9.
The learned Single Judge has noted that the Division
Bench of this Court in RSA No.2166/2006 and connected
matters, had considered three important issues, viz.:
“i) Whether the suit schedule land which is
“kere angala” could have been granted to
Inamdar at all?
ii) Whether it could have been granted to a
person who has purchased the schedule
land after the schedule land vested with
the Government?
iii) Whether any such grant at all?”
- 10 -
WA No. 2107 of 2025
C/W WA No.1861 of 2026
10.
The learned Single Judge further noted that the Division
Bench, after taking all the relevant facts and material,
remanded the matter to find out whether an application in Form
No.7 under the provisions of the Inams Abolition Act was filed
by Sri. H.B. Munivenkatappa; whether an inquiry was held by
the Land Tribunal; whether an order was passed by the land
tribunal.
11.
The learned Single Judge has noted that on remand, the
lower appellate Court found that there was an entry in the
register evidencing the fact that application was filed by
Sri.H.B.Munivenkatappa
before
the
Deputy
Commissioner,
Inams Abolition. The lower appellate court has come to a
conclusion that the Land Tribunal held an enquiry and passed
the order dated 27.12.1980 re-granting the subject land in
favour of Sri.H.B.Munivenkatappa. The learned Single Judge
also noted that the revenue records did not establish that
Sy.No.54 was a tank bed as the two water bodies recorded in
the village were situated in Sy.Nos.85 and 124 and not in
Sy.No.54.
- 11 -
WA No. 2107 of 2025
C/W WA No.1861 of 2026
12.
The learned Single Judge further noted that the sale
transactions in respect of the subject land took place from the
year 1918 and that the survey records did not mention the
existence of a water tank or tank bed in Sy.No.54. It was
further held that the very issues sought to be raised by the
State had already been considered in the earlier proceedings,
which culminated in RSA No.142/2009 and the dismissal of the
SLP (C) No.10357/2018 by the Supreme Court.
13.
The learned Single Judge therefore held that the writ
petition was barred by the principles of res judicata. It was also
held that the State could not be permitted to reopen the matter
after such prolonged litigation. The challenge to the 1980 order
was raised nearly 38 years after the order was passed by the
land tribunal and nearly 20 years after the decree was passed
by the lower appellate court. It was held that entertaining the
writ
petition
would
effectively
give
the
State
a
second
opportunity to agitate the same issue. The learned Single Judge
further held that the State is equally bound by the principles
governing delay and laches. The petition was accordingly
dismissed.
- 12 -
WA No. 2107 of 2025
C/W WA No.1861 of 2026
SUBMISSIONS ON BEHALF
PRIVATE RESPONDENTS:
14.
OF
THE
LANDOWNERS/
Sri. K.N. Phaneendra, Senior Counsel assisted by Sri.
Abhinay S. learned counsel, Sri. Manmohan P.N., learned
counsel, Smt. Shivani Shetty, learned counsel appearing for the
private respondents contend that the writ appeal is wholly
devoid of merit and is liable to be dismissed. It is submitted
that the subject land bearing Sy.No.54 measuring 11 Acres 20
Guntas of Pattandur Agrahara Village was granted in favour of
Sri H.B. Munivenkatappa by the Land Tribunal vide order dated
27.12.1980, pursuant to which he was the owner of land.
15.
It is further submitted that in O.S.No.394/1993, the Civil
Court declared Sri H.B. Munivenkatappa to be the absolute
owner of the subject property, and held that the land was a
Hiduvali land and not a tank bed, and granted injunction
against the State from any interference with his possession.
The said judgment was affirmed in R.A.No.38/2004, thereafter
in RSA No.142/2009, and the Special Leave Petition filed by the
State before the Supreme Court was dismissed both on delay
and merits, followed by dismissal of the review petition. The
learned Senior Counsel therefore submits that the State
cannot, after
having unsuccessfully
challenged the same
- 13 -
WA No. 2107 of 2025
C/W WA No.1861 of 2026
subject matter in several proceedings, once again question the
jurisdiction of the Land Tribunal. It is submitted that the issue
regarding the nature of the land, the validity and existence of
the Land Tribunal's order and the State's challenge thereto had
already been directly and substantially considered in the earlier
proceedings and, therefore, the subsequent writ petition is
barred by principles of res judicata as well as constructive res
judicata.
16.
The learned Senior Counsel further submits that the
State, having admitted in its written statement the existence of
the Land Tribunal's order and the sale deeds relating to the
subject land, cannot now take a contrary stand and contend
that no such order exists. The findings recorded by the
appellate court in R.A.No.38/2004, after examination of the
relevant records, including the Land Tribunal register, survey
records and sketch, conclusively establish that the subject land
was a Hiduvali land and not a tank bed. The said findings were
thereafter affirmed by this Court as well as the Supreme Court.
17.
The learned Senior Counsel further submits that the
challenge to the Land Tribunal's order is barred by delay and
laches. The writ petition was instituted nearly 38 years after
- 14 -
WA No. 2107 of 2025
C/W WA No.1861 of 2026
the order of the Land Tribunal and, even if the date of the
liberty
granted
by
the
appellate
court
is
taken
into
consideration, there remains a delay of about 20 years. Such
extraordinary delay, according to the respondents, disentitles
the State from invoking the discretionary jurisdiction of this
Court.
SUBMISSIONS ON BEHALF OF THE STATE:
18.
Sri. Kiran V. Ron, AAG assisted by Sri. Sudev Hegde, AGA
appearing for the State would submit that the present
proceedings arise out of the challenge to the alleged order
dated 27.12.1980 passed by the Land Tribunal, Bengaluru, in
LRF No.5063/1979-80. It is submitted that the very existence
and legality of the said order is disputed by the State.
19.
It is submitted that the proceedings in O.S.No.394/1993
and the subsequent appeals proceeded on the assumption that
the alleged Land Tribunal order dated 27.12.1980 was a valid
and
existing
order.
The
Regular
Appellate
Court,
while
dismissing the appeal, had expressly reserved liberty to the
State to challenge the legality of the Land Tribunal order before
this Court. The said liberty was not interfered with in the
subsequent proceedings.
- 15 -
WA No. 2107 of 2025
C/W WA No.1861 of 2026
20.
The principal contention of the State is that, even
assuming the alleged order dated 27.12.1980 to be in
existence, the Land Tribunal had no jurisdiction to grant the
subject land, as the land in Sy.No.54 of Pattandur Agrahara
Village is a Sarkari kere/tank bed. The land, being Jodi Inam
land governed by the Inams Abolition Act, 1954, was incapable
of being granted in view of Section 9 of the said Act.
Consequently, the alleged order of the Land Tribunal, having
been passed without jurisdiction and contrary to the statutory
prohibition, is a nullity.
21.
It is further submitted that the alleged order is itself
fraudulent and non-existent. The document produced as the
order dated 27.12.1980 describes the subject property as
Sarkari kere, but does not bear the signatures of the Chairman
or the Members of the Land Tribunal. It is also submitted that
the original of the alleged order has never been produced
before any Court and thus, the document relied upon by the
respondents is not a genuine order of the Land Tribunal.
22.
It is further submitted that the principles of res judicata
cannot validate a fraudulent or non-existent order, particularly
- 16 -
WA No. 2107 of 2025
C/W WA No.1861 of 2026
when the issue of fraud and the legality of the Land Tribunal
order were not finally adjudicated in the earlier proceedings
and liberty had expressly been reserved to the State. The State
accordingly submits that the learned Single Judge erred in
dismissing the writ petition without examining the merits of the
challenge.
23.
It is also submitted that the State invokes the doctrine of
public trust and the principle of parens patriae, stating that
protection of public tanks and water bodies is a matter of public
interest and that a public water body cannot be permitted to be
converted into private property on the basis of an allegedly
fraudulent or jurisdictionally void order. It therefore seeks
setting aside of the order of the learned Single Judge and
allowing of the writ appeal.
SUBMISSIONS ON BEHALF OF NAMMA WHITEFIELD RWA
FEDERATION:
24.
Sri. Akanksh Ashok learned counsel appearing for the
appellant– Namma Whitefield RWA Federation would submit
that the learned Single Judge erred in dismissing the writ
petition on the grounds of delay and res judicata without
examining the fundamental question regarding the existence
- 17 -
WA No. 2107 of 2025
C/W WA No.1861 of 2026
and
validity
of
the
alleged
Land
Tribunal
order
dated
27.12.1980. It is submitted that, even assuming the order
exists, the Tribunal had no jurisdiction to grant occupancy
rights over Sy.No.54, which is classified as a tank bed/Sarkari
kere, in view of Section 9 of the Inams Abolition Act.
25.
It is submitted that the Tippan, Settlement Register,
Pakka Books and village map, as well as the reports of various
committees constituted for protection of lakes in Bengaluru,
consistently identify the subject land as a tank. Mere cultivation
during dry periods cannot alter the legal character of a tank
bed.
26.
It is further submitted that the earlier proceedings did not
finally determine the jurisdiction of the Tribunal to grant tankbed land or the allegation of fraud. The liberty reserved in the
earlier proceedings to challenge the legality of the Tribunal's
order was not disturbed, and therefore, the principle of res
judicata cannot operate against an issue which was not
adjudicated on merits.
27.
The
learned
counsel
also
submitted
that
an
order
obtained by fraud or passed without jurisdiction is a nullity, and
- 18 -
WA No. 2107 of 2025
C/W WA No.1861 of 2026
therefore cannot be sustained merely on the ground of delay. It
is also submitted that the matter concerns the protection of a
public water body and, therefore, the principles of public trust,
parens patriae and the constitutional obligation to protect the
environment are attracted.
POINTS FOR CONSIDERATION:
28.
Having heard both the parties, the following points arise
for consideration:
i. Whether the learned Single Judge was
justified in holding that the challenge to the
order dated 27.12.1980 passed by the Land
Tribunal in LRF No.5063/79-80 could not be
reopened
in
the
present
proceedings,
particularly when the State contends that the
said order was without jurisdiction in respect of
the subject land?
ii. Whether the liberty granted by the lower
appellate Court on 17.12.2008 enabled the
State to maintain the writ petition filed on
18.06.2018
challenging
27.12.1980,
notwithstanding
delay and laches?
the
order
the
dated
prolonged
- 19 -
WA No. 2107 of 2025
C/W WA No.1861 of 2026
ANALYSIS AND FINDINGS:
29.
Re. Point No.1: The challenge of the State to the order
dated 27.12.1980 proceeds principally on the premise that the
Land Tribunal had no jurisdiction to grant occupancy rights in
respect of the subject land, which, according to the State, was
a Sarkari Kere/tank bed. The State would therefore contend
that the order of the Land Tribunal is a nullity and that the
question of its validity was not conclusively adjudicated in the
earlier proceedings.
30.
In order to examine this contention, it is necessary to
take note of the course of litigation which preceded the filing of
the present writ petition.
31.
The order of the Land Tribunal came to be passed on
27.12.1980 in LRF No.5063/79-80 granting occupancy rights in
favor of Sri. H.B. Munivenkatappa. The then Tahsildar issued
eviction notice dated 11.06.1979 to H.B. Munivenkatappa
asking him to vacate, as the subject land is a tank bed. Thus,
Sri H.B. Munivenkatappa instituted O.S.No.394/1993, seeking a
declaration of his title over Sy.No.54, specifically contending
that the subject land was ‘Hiduvali’ land and not a tank bed.
The suit came to be decreed on 24.01.1995, declaring the legal
- 20 -
WA No. 2107 of 2025
C/W WA No.1861 of 2026
heirs of late H.B. Munivenkatappa to be the owners of the
subject property and holding the land to be a Hiduvali land and
not a tank bed.
32.
The State filed appeal in R.A.No.38/2004 which came to
be dismissed and thereafter the State filed appeal before this
Court in R.S.A.No.2166/2006 and vide order dated 08.03.2007,
the matter was remanded for fresh consideration. The remand
was not confined merely to the nature of the land. This Court
directed examination as to whether the application in Form
No.7 had been filed by Sri H.B. Munivenkatappa, whether an
enquiry had been conducted by the Land Tribunal and whether
an order had in fact been passed by the Tribunal.
33.
Upon such remand, the lower appellate Court examined
the relevant documents and found an entry in the register
evidencing the filing of the application in Form No.7 under the
provisions of the Inams Abolition Act. It further recorded a
finding that an enquiry had been conducted by the Land
Tribunal and that the order dated 27.12.1980 had been passed
granting the subject land in favour of Sri H.B. Munivenkatappa.
- 21 -
WA No. 2107 of 2025
C/W WA No.1861 of 2026
34.
The lower appellate Court also considered the revenue
and survey records and found that they did not establish
Sy.No.54 to be a tank bed. In particular, it was noted that the
water bodies recorded in the village were situated in Sy.Nos.85
and 124 and not in Sy.No.54.
35.
The
lower
appellate
Court
once
again
dismissed
R.A.No.38/2004 vide order dated 17.12.2008 granting the
State a liberty to challenge the order dated 27.12.1980 passed
by the land tribunal. The State challenged the said judgment in
R.S.A.No.142/2009, which came to be dismissed by this Court
vide order dated 24.11.2016. The State thereafter approached
the Supreme Court in SLP (C) No. 10357/2018 which came to
be dismissed, followed by dismissal of the review petition vide
order dated 12.02.2019. Thus, the record does not disclose a
circumstance where the State is seeking to challenge an order
which had previously never been the subject matter of judicial
scrutiny. On the contrary, the existence of the Land Tribunal
proceedings, the passing of the order dated 27.12.1980 and
the nature of the subject property were all matters which arose
for consideration in the earlier proceedings. Following the
- 22 -
WA No. 2107 of 2025
C/W WA No.1861 of 2026
remand by this Court, the lower appellate Court specifically
examined the records and findings on these aspects.
36.
The State contends that the earlier proceedings cannot
operate as a bar because the order dated 27.12.1980 is alleged
to be fraudulent, non-existent and without jurisdiction. It is
further contended that, being a tank bed, the subject land
could not have been granted by the Land Tribunal and that a
jurisdictionally void order does not acquire validity merely by
passage of time. However, that very factual premise had been
placed in issue in O.S.No.394/1993 and was also considered in
the subsequent appellate proceedings. The Civil Court, on
24.01.1995, held the land to be Hiduvali land and not a tank
bed. More importantly, after the remand by this Court, the
lower appellate Court once again examined the relevant survey
and revenue records and recorded its findings. Therefore, the
State cannot, in the present case, proceed on the assumption
that the subject land was conclusively established to be a tank
bed and, on that basis alone, contend that the Tribunal acted
without jurisdiction.
37.
The principle of finality of litigation applies with equal
force to the State. In the case of DARYAO AND OTHERS vs
- 23 -
WA No. 2107 of 2025
C/W WA No.1861 of 2026
STATE OF U.P. AND ANOTHER [AIR 1961 SC 1457] the
Constitution
Bench
of
Supreme
Court
recognised
the
applicability of the principles of res judicata to proceedings
under Article 226. In the case of FORWARD CONSTRUCTION
CO.
AND
OTHERS
vs
PRABHAT
MANDAL
(REGD.),
ANDHERI AND OTHERS [(1986) 1 SCC 100], the Supreme
Court reiterated the applicability of the principles of res judicata
and constructive res judicata to subsequent proceedings and
emphasised the need to prevent repeated litigation on matters
which have already been adjudicated.
38.
The present case is also distinguishable from a situation
where a party discovers, for the first time, that an order relied
upon against it was fabricated or that the authority which
passed it had demonstrably lacked jurisdiction. In the case on
hand, the State itself was litigating party and was fully aware of
the Land Tribunal order and the dispute concerning the nature
of the subject land. After the remand, the lower appellate Court
examined the relevant material and recorded its findings. Those
findings were thereafter challenged before this Court in RSA
No.142/2009 and the matter was carried further to the
Supreme Court.
- 24 -
WA No. 2107 of 2025
C/W WA No.1861 of 2026
39.
Consequently, the State cannot convert the plea of
jurisdictional error into an independent means of reopening the
entire
dispute
after
having
participated
in
the
earlier
proceedings and exhausted its appellate remedies. It is also
relevant to note that the lower appellate Court's finding was not
based
solely
upon
the
Land
Tribunal
order.
The
Court
considered the historical revenue records, as well as the
longstanding sale transactions concerning the property. The
land in question has been the subject matter of registered
transactions commencing from 1918, and that an extent of 20
guntas was acquired by the Government on 18.10.1931 for a
borewell, where the land was shown as ‘dry land’ in the gazette
notification published for the acquisition of 20 guntas in the
Sy.No.54. These facts were part of the records considered in
the earlier litigation and cannot now be disregarded while
examining the State's jurisdictional objection.
40.
We, therefore, find that the State has not demonstrated
any circumstance which would justify treating the order dated
27.12.1980 as an order wholly outside the jurisdiction of the
Land Tribunal so as to permit the entire matter to be reopened
- 25 -
WA No. 2107 of 2025
C/W WA No.1861 of 2026
in the present proceedings. The learned Single Judge was
justified in taking note of the earlier adjudication and rejecting
to permit a fresh challenge to the same subject matter.
41.
This conclusion is also consistent with the broader
principle that a party cannot be permitted to repeatedly
challenge the same adjudication by changing the formulation of
the ground of challenge in successive proceedings. The State
having
already
questioned
the
rights
of
Sri
H.B.
Munivenkatappa and the nature of the subject land, and having
pursued the matter through successive appellate stages, cannot
now seek a fresh adjudication merely by characterising the
same issue as one relating to jurisdiction.
42.
Re. Point No.2: While disposing of R.A.No.38/2004 vide
order dated 17.12.2008, the lower appellate Court granted
liberty to the State to challenge the legality of the order dated
27.12.1980 passed by the Land Tribunal. The State places
reliance upon this liberty to contend that the writ petition filed
by it was maintainable.
43.
We are unable to accept the submission that the said
liberty, by itself, entitled the State to approach this Court at
- 26 -
WA No. 2107 of 2025
C/W WA No.1861 of 2026
any point of time thereafter. The liberty granted by the lower
appellate Court has to be understood in the context in which it
was granted. It enabled the State to avail an appropriate
remedy against the order of the Land Tribunal; it did not
exempt the State from the settled principles governing the
exercise of extraordinary jurisdiction under Article 226 of the
Constitution, including the requirement that such jurisdiction
must be invoked within a reasonable time.
44.
The R.S.A.No.142/2009 assumes significance. The State
challenged the judgment and order dated 17.12.2008 before
this Court in R.S.A.No.142/2009 wherein the land tribunal’s
order dated 27.12.1980 was not specifically assailed. The
liberty granted in R.A.No.38/2004 although was available to the
State, was not exercised in the proceedings initiated by it
before this Court. Despite the liberty having been granted on
17.12.2008, the State invoked the writ jurisdiction of this Court
only on 18.06.2018. Thus, there was a delay of approximately
nine and a half years from the date on which the liberty was
granted. The challenge has been instituted nearly 38 years
from the date of passing of order by the land tribunal. The
learned Single Judge has noted both these aspects while
- 27 -
WA No. 2107 of 2025
C/W WA No.1861 of 2026
rejecting to entertain the writ petition. The mere availability of
a liberty granted by the appellate Court cannot be construed as
a continuing permission to keep the matter open indefinitely.
Once a party is granted liberty to pursue a particular remedy,
such remedy must nevertheless be pursued with reasonable
time. The passage of several years, particularly where the
rights of the opposite party have been the subject matter of
repeated adjudication, cannot be disregarded.
45.
The principle is well settled that though no fixed period of
limitation
is
prescribed
for
invoking
Article
226,
the
extraordinary jurisdiction of the High Court is discretionary and
may be rejected where the petitioner is guilty of unreasonable
delay and laches. In the case of STATE OF MADHYA
PRADESH AND ANOTHER vs BHAILAL BHAI AND OTHERS,
[AIR 1964 SC 1006], the Constitution Bench of Supreme
Court held that the High Court may refuse the relief under
Article 226 where the delay is unreasonable. This principle has
subsequently been reiterated in the case of STATE OF M.P.
AND
OTHERS
vs
NANDLAL
JAISWAL
AND
OTHERS
[(1986) 4 SCC 566], wherein the Supreme Court made it
clear that the State is not immune from the doctrine of delay
- 28 -
WA No. 2107 of 2025
C/W WA No.1861 of 2026
and laches. Likewise, in the case of KARNATAKA POWER
CORPN. LTD. vs K. THANGAPPAN AND ANOTHER [(2006)
SCC
322],
the
Supreme
Court
reiterated
that
the
discretionary jurisdiction under Article 226 is not ordinarily
exercised in favor of a party which has slept over its rights for
an unreasonable length of time.
46.
We are also unable to accept the submission that the
liberty granted by the lower appellate Court nullified the effect
of the subsequent proceedings in R.S.A.No.142/2009. The
State itself chose to challenge the judgment dated 17.12.2008
before this Court in R.S.A.No.142/2009. Having not pursued
the liberty, it cannot treat the same as an independent and
unlimited source of right to reopen the matter years later.
47.
The fact that the appellant is the State does not make the
principle of delay and laches inapplicable. On the contrary,
where the State seeks to unsettle rights which have been the
subject matter of litigation for decades, the requirement of
diligence assumes greater significance. The subsequent plea of
the State that the Land Tribunal order is fraudulent or nonexistent also does not furnish a satisfactory explanation for the
- 29 -
WA No. 2107 of 2025
C/W WA No.1861 of 2026
delay. The existence and legality of the order had already been
challenged in the earlier proceedings, and after remand the
lower appellate Court examined the relevant material and
recorded its findings. The State thereafter pursued its appellate
remedies. The plea of fraud, therefore, cannot be used as a
device to overcome the consequences of prolonged inaction.
48.
We are consequently of the considered view that the
liberty granted on 17.12.2008 did not confer an unrestricted
right upon the State to challenge the order dated 27.12.1980
after a delay of nearly nine and a half years. The writ petition
was filed after the parties had already undergone prolonged
litigation concerning the very same land and the very same
order. The learned Single Judge was, therefore, justified in
rejecting the exercise of discretionary jurisdiction of this Court
on the ground of delay and laches.
CONCLUSION:
49.
In view of the above discussion, we are of the considered
view that the learned Single Judge was justified in rejecting to
entertain the challenge to the order dated 27.12.1980 passed
by the Land Tribunal in LRF No.5063/79-80. The subject matter
- 30 -
WA No. 2107 of 2025
C/W WA No.1861 of 2026
had
already
been
considered
in
the
earlier
proceedings
culminating in the judgment and order dated 13.04.2018
passed by Supreme Court in SLP (C) No.10357/2018. The
liberty granted by the lower appellate Court on 17.12.2008 did
not confer an unrestricted right upon the State to challenge the
Land Tribunal order at any point of time. The State, having
invoked successive remedies and having failed to obtain a
reversal of the findings concerning the subject land, cannot be
permitted to reopen the same matter through a belated writ
petition. The writ petition filed on 18.06.2018, nearly 38 years
after passing of the order by the Land Tribunal and about nine
and a half years after the liberty granted by the lower appellate
Court, suffers from gross and unexplained delay and laches.
50.
We are, therefore, of the considered view that the learned
Single Judge was justified in dismissing W.P.No.26097/2018.
We find no ground warranting an interference in the present
intra-court appeals. The judgment and order dated 19.11.2025
passed by the learned Single Judge in W.P.No.26097/2018 is
affirmed. Accordingly, the writ appeals W.A.No.2107/2025 and
W.A.No.1861/2026 are dismissed.
- 31 -
WA No. 2107 of 2025
C/W WA No.1861 of 2026
51.
Pending interlocutory applications, if any, do not survive
for consideration and accordingly stand disposed of.
Sd/(D K SINGH)
JUDGE
Sd/(H.SHANTHI BHUSHAN)
JUDGE
BKV
CT:SN
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review