Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
IN THE HIGH COURT OF ORISSA AT CUTTACK
CRLREV No.661 of 2023
Nalini Kanta Nayak
….
Petitioner
Mr. Tanmaya Kumar Mohanty, Advocate
-VersusPrasanna Kumar
….
Opposite Party
Mr. Amit Prasad Bose, Advocate
CORAM:
JUSTICE R.K. PATTANAIK
DATE OF HEARING: 09.12.2025
DATE OF JUDGMENT:23.03.2026
1. Instant revision filed under Section 401 read with Section
397 Cr.P.C. is at the behest of the petitioner assailing the
impugned judgment dated 2nd May, 2022 as at Annexure-2
passed in connection 1CC Case No.1190 of 2015 (T.R.
No.137 of 2019) confirmed in Criminal Appeal No.19 of
2022 by judgment dated 4th November, 2023 i.e. Annexure-2
passed by the learned 3rd Additional Sessions Judge,
Bhubaneswar for having convicted him for an offence
punishable under Section 138 of the NI Act followed by a
sentence and to pay compensation of Rs.30 lac in terms of
Section 357(3) Cr.P.C. with a default sentence on the
grounds inter alia that the order of conviction cannot be
sustained in law and hence, liable to be interfered with and
set aside in the interest of justice.
2. The opposite party filed the complaint in 1CC Case
No.1190 of 2015 alleging therein that the petitioner though a
power of attorney holder managed to sell away his property
and in that connection, when it was protested, as such
authorization was only to look after the property and not for
any other purposes and for having received the consideration
money of Rs.40 lac issued a cheque of Rs.20 lac dated 24 th
February, 2015, it could not be encashed and returned back
dishonoured with an intimation and endorsement that the
account has insufficient fund received on 3rd March, 2015
and thereafter, despite notice to the latter to pay back the
cheque amount within fifteen days, the same was not
responded.
3. A copy of the complaint is at Annexure-1. On the basis of
such complaint, the opposite party alleged that the petitioner
should be criminally prosecuted for dishonour of cheque in
failing to discharge the liability arising out of the alleged
transaction. Considering the evidence received only from the
side of the opposite party, the learned J.M.F.C., Bhubaneswar
reached at a conclusion that the case under Section 138 of the
NI Act is established and sentenced the petitioner thereunder
and also directed him to pay compensation. The petitioner
being aggrieved of filed the appeal before the learned court
below, but was dismissed vide Annexure-2 confirming the
order of conviction and sentence awarded against him. Such
confirmation of conviction order is presently under challenge
by the petitioner on the premise that there has been no any
debt or liability for him to discharge and that apart, a civil
suit is pending before the court of learned Civil Judge (Senior
Division), Bhubaneswar in respect of the property involved,
wherein, the opposite party is seeking a declaration to the
effect that the Power of Attorney dated 17th January, 2014 to
create a 3rd party interest without passing any consideration
to be bad in law and to grant permanent injunction against the
petitioner and purchaser, namely, defendant No.2 and their
agents from interfering in its peaceful possession over the
same with such other reliefs sought for and in that view of
the matter, any such conviction and sentence under Section
138 of the NI Act could not have been directed by the learned
courts below, hence, the same is liable to be quashed.
4. Heard Mr. Mohanty, learned counsel for the petitioner and
Mr. Bose, learned counsel for the opposite party.
5. Perused the LCR.
6. According to Mr. Mohanty, learned counsel for the
petitioner, the order of conviction and sentence is not legally
tenable in absence of any liability from being discharged with
and that apart, the alleged cheque was issued for the purpose
of security but it was misutilized by the opposite party. It is
also submitted that the opposite party having instituted the
suit in C.S. No.2239 of 2015 pending disposal in the court of
leaned Civil Judge (Senior Division), Bhubaneswar, wherein,
there is a status quo order in IA No.281 of 2015, the
petitioner is unable to get back the money from the buyer
further to hand it over to the opposite party and in that
connection, the cheque in question was issued as a security
and
the
same
stood
dishonoured
and
under
such
circumstances, the impugned order of conviction and
sentence vide Annexure-1 cannot be justified so also the
decision of the learned court below in appeal at Annexure-2.
7. On the contrary, Mr. Bose, learned counsel for the
opposite party would submit that the learned courts below did
not commit any error or illegality in reaching at a conclusion
that the petitioner is guilty of dishonour of cheque drawn and
issued by him to the opposite party and upon its presentation
before the Bank failed to be enchased for an amount of Rs.20
lac which is a part of consideration money said to have been
received from the buyer, namely, Debasmita Mishra. The
further submission is that for the alleged default and when
there was a liability to discharge and in that connection, the
alleged cheque was issued by the petitioner, in absence of
any rebuttal evidence, the learned courts below left with no
option but to hold that he has committed an offence
punishable under Section 138 of the NI Act.
8.
In reply to the above, Mr. Mohanty, learned counsel for
the petitioner would submit that the opposite party executed a
General Power of Attorney dated 17th January, 2014 in
respect of the plot in favour of the petitioner, for which, the
latter handed over a security cheque for an amount of Rs.20
lac and assured to pay the consideration amount after selling
of the same and thereafter, as against the transaction, the civil
suit was filed challenging the Power of Attorney executed
and in such view of the matter, no case under Section 138 of
the NI Act is made out but the learned courts below reached
at a conclusion to the contrary.
9. A copy of the plaint in C.S. No.2239 of 2015 is in the LCR
and it reveals that the opposite party has instituted it against
the petitioner and buyer with a declaratory relief sought for
therein with injunction and as earlier stated, it is in respect of
the Power of Attorney executed on 17th January, 2014 to be
declared as bad in law against creation of a 3rd party interest
without passing of consideration directly to him.
10. As far as issuance of cheque and receipt of the same by
the opposite party, it is not denied by the petitioner, however,
the claim is that the same was handed over as a security. The
opposite party proved the presentation of cheque in the Bank
with a deposit slip as Ext.4 and intimation regarding its
dishonour with a return memo i.e. Ext.5. The original cheque
has been marked as Ext.3 from the side of the opposite party.
The signature of the petitioner on the alleged cheque has
been marked as Ext-3/1. The issuance of the cheque or for
that matter, signature of the petitioner thereon has not been
disputed. The Power of Attorney executed in favour as the
petitioner was proved as Ext.2. The sale deed in question in
favour of buyer is marked as Ext.1. The claim of the opposite
party is that the Power of Attorney was managed by the
petitioner, who was authorized only to look after the property
without any such rights for its disposal, hence, the suit. The
opposite party has filed the suit challenging the General
Power of Attorney and for a declaration that the same is not
valid without passing of consideration money in his favour.
The fact of execution of sale deed is not in denial. As earlier
stated, that the drawal of the cheque by the petitioner has not
been disputed either. The only ground is that the cheque
dated 24th February, 2015 was drawn and issued to the
opposite party as a security. But, the record reveals that such
a plea was never advanced from the side of the petitioner
even in response to the pleader notice i.e. Ext.6 said to have
been duly received by him proved vide Exts.6, 7 and 8. No
any evidence was adduced from the petitioner with such a
plea that the cheque i.e. Ext.3 had not been received in
discharge of any liability but was merely a security deposit
and therefore, the cheque having been issued and not
honoured by the Bank for insufficient found, any such notice
thereafter without a response received from the drawer,
according to the Court, a presumption would arise to the
effect that an offence under Section 138 of the NI Act has
been committed. In fact, a reverse presumption is to apply for
the drawer of the cheque to prove and establish that there was
no any lawful debt or liability to discharge with and in that
connection, the cheque in question had been issued. In
absence of any evidence from the side of the petitioner and
when the opposite party and two other witnesses withstood
cross-examination, it has to be concluded that a case under
Section 138 of the NI Act is made out. When issuance of
cheque has been admitted by the petitioner but claimed to be
for a different purpose and not towards discharge of any
liability and its dishonour is corroborated by Ext.5 and nonpayment of the amount despite a pleader notice as per Ext.6,
the Court is left with no other choice except to confirm view
expressed by the learned courts below.
11. The contention of Mr. Mohanty, learned counsel for the
petitioner is that the fate of the criminal action is to depend
on the result in the suit and the learned court below under the
circumstances leading to the execution of the sale deed which
was within the knowledge of the opposite party though
denied to have executed the Power of Attorney on the terms
agreed upon, the order of conviction for the offence under
Section 138 of the NI Act and sentence, as has been directed,
is to prejudice him and hence, it has to be interfered with.
The further contention is that the order of conviction is likely
to influence the findings of the civil court and therefore, it
ought to have been taken judicial notice of at least by the
learned court below. Mr. Bose, learned counsel for the
opposite party, on the other hand, submits that a criminal
action shall lie irrespective of the pendency of the suit
between the parties involving the buyer with any such relief
sought for therein. According to the Court, a case under
Section 138 of the NI Act for the dishonour of cheque either
as a part of consideration money or speculatively an amount
received by the power of attorney holder can be entertained,
even if, a civil suit is pending between the parties which has a
bearing vis-à-vis validity of the sale.
12. A criminal action is an independent remedy and can be
pursued simultaneously even during and in continuation of a
civil litigation between the parties as both serve distinct
purpose. When a cheque is issued in connection with a
transaction which is an outcome of a dispute between the real
owner and the power attorney holder and it has been in
respect of a liability for the latter having received part or full
of the consideration money, a presumption of existence of
debt would arise in view of Sections 118 and 139 of the NI
Act and that it was issued for a legally enforceable liability
and in that case, the burden shifts on the drawer to rebut such
presumption. The sale deed is not void ab initio. The
challenge at the instance of the opposite party is to the Power
of Attorney executed by him in favour of the petitioner, who
allegedly without any such authorization said to have
disposed of the property to a 3rd party. So, to say, the sale
deed is a voidable one at the instance of the opposite party
and hence, to be declared as void. In such view of the matter,
if the sale is merely voidable, the purchaser or for that matter,
the power of attorney holder having received a part of the
consideration money as an existing liability to pay back the
cheque amount and when it is dishonoured, a cause of action
would certainly arise for a criminal prosecution under
Section 138 of the NI Act.
13. If ultimately the sale deed in question is found to be
invalid, the underline debt may cease to exist and in such a
situation, it could lead to acquittal of the drawer of the
cheque for any such offence under Section 138 of the NI Act.
While a case under Section 138 of the NI Act can proceed
pending disposal of the suit but if the civil court decides that
the sale is void with a decree therein holding that the
petitioner had limited rights in dealing with the property, it
would automatically lead to closure of the criminal action.
The above aspect of the matter cannot be entirely brushed
aside as has been rightly flagged and highlighted upon by Mr.
Mohanty, learned counsel for the petitioner.
14. At the same time, when according to the opposite party,
an amount of Rs.40 lac was received by the petitioner but in
return, the alleged cheque was issued and the same could not
be honoured by the Bank for insufficiency of fund and since,
the plea of the petitioner regarding the cheque that it was
issued as a security was not proved by any evidence, the
inevitable conclusion would be that for the debt, it was drawn
by him, he being the power of attorney holder. Under the
above circumstances, it has to be held by the Court that the
petitioner in consequence of a liability to discharge and
having issued the alleged cheque was under obligation to pay
back the amount to the opposite party and having failed so,
he is liable under Section 138 of the NI Act.
15. But, according to the Court, it is indeed a genuine
concern on the part of the petitioner, who is up against an
order of conviction when the fate of the sale deed is
dependent on the result of the suit challenging the legality of
the Power of Attorney executed in his favour by the opposite
party. It may be said that a criminal action on the anvil of a
civil suit pending between the parties affecting the validity of
a sale would involve complex considerations. It is not that a
court is to decline any such action under Section 138 of the
NI Act solely for the reason that such a suit is pending
disposal. However, the concern is that in the event, the suit is
decreed in favour of the opposite party, the sale deed would
become invalid or unworkable and in such a situation, the
opposite party cannot have any demand against the petitioner
on the basis of the alleged cheque. In that case, the buyer
may demand the money back either from the opposite party
or petitioner being the power of attorney holder and allegedly
for having received the consideration money either in part or
full. If the suit is dismissed, it would result in validation of
the sale executed in respect of the property and in such
eventuality, the petitioner shall have to be held having the
liability to honour the cheque having received the
consideration money from the buyer. If the suit is decreed
and the sale becomes invalid, it would result in an
irreversible consequence since the petitioner has already been
found guilty under Section 138 of the NI Act. Though, the
Court is of the view that the criminal prosecution is valid on
the basis of the complaint filed and for the petitioner having
miserably failed to establish the plea that the alleged cheque
was issued towards security but at the same time, the
conclusion is that the order of conviction and sentence if not
modified would have an adverse consequence of irreversible
nature and could further lead to legal complications.
16. In the peculiar facts and circumstances of the case
discussed hereinabove, the Court is of the view that the order
of conviction under Section 138 of the NI Act is to be upheld
however with modification as to the sentence and
compensation awarded against the petitioner. It would be just
and proper, if the petitioner is awarded fine of Rs.20,000/and direction for him to pay a compensation of Rs.22 lac in
terms of Section 357(3) Cr.P.C. with a default sentence
against the cheque amount of Rs.20 lac to be kept in a fixed
deposit in the name of Registrar, Civil Courts, Bhubaneswar
with any Nationalized Bank renewable from time to time
payable to the opposite party subject to outcome in the suit.
17. Hence, it is ordered.
18. In the result, the revision stands disposed of. As a
necessary corollary, the order of conviction in 1CC Case
No.1190 of 2015 (T.R. No.137 of 2019) confirmed in
Criminal Appeal No.19 of 2022 vide Annexure-2 by the
learned 3rd Additional Sessions Judge, Bhubaneswar is
hereby modified to the extent as aforesaid directing the
petitioner to pay a fine of Rs.20,000/- and compensation of
Rs.22 lac, with a default sentence of three months SI, to be
deposited in terms of the order of the learned J.M.F.C.,
Bhubaneswar and if not deposited within a period of next
three months, it shall be realized according to law. It is
further directed that the release of the compensation
deposited before the court below, in terms of the direction as
above, shall be subject to the result in C.S. No.2239 of 2015.
(R.K. Pattanaik)
Judge
Tuddu
Digitally Signed
Signed by: THAKURDAS TUDU
Designation: Sr. Stenographer
Reason: Authentication
Location: OHC,CTC
Date: 30-Mar-2026 10:29:01
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review