Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
[ 3488 J
IN THE HIGH COURT FOR THE STATE OF
AT HYDERABAD
TELANGANA
TUESDAY, THE TWENTY FIRST DATOF JULY
TWO THOUSAND AND TWENTY SIX
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE THE CHIEF JUSTICE SRI
APARESH KUMAR SINGH
AND
THE HONOURABLE SRI JUSTICE G.M. MOHIUDDIN
WRIT APP EA L NO: 606 O F 2026
writ Appear under crause 15 0f the Letters patent Appear preferred
the order daled 27-04'2026 passed in wp No 31400
Against
of 2o24on the fire of the High
Co u rt.
Between:
Nakka Sandhya Rani, W9,
Swamy, Aged about 55 years
J:lll"twara
Occ: Advocate Fyo HNo.1-2-336/5
Geethanigr, 'diaOip"t
i";; ;;gr";
Jangaon District
...APPELLANT/RESPONDENT IN W.P
AND
.)
The State of__Telangana, Rep^by its Secretary to Government
Legal Affairs
Legislative Affairs and Justice Setretariat nyOeTaOaJISOOOO+
The Collector and District l\,4agisti.ate, Jangaon District
The Principal District Judge, Jangaon
Varikota Ramgopal, S/o : Late Meenaiah, Age 66 years,
Occ: Advocate
Rlio Plot No145/1381F O pp: IOC Pump Siddipet
Road Vikas
Nagar Jangaon
Town and District
...RESPONDENTS
l.A. NO: 2 oF 2026
Petition under section 151 cpc praying that in the
affidavit fired in support of the petition, the High court
circumstances stated in the
may be preased to suspend
the operation of the .lu(lgment passed in wpNo314o0 o1 2024 dated
27 -04-2026
pending disposal of th,3 yyp11 Appeat.
Counsel for the Appeilant: SRt M. SURNDER RAO, REPRESENTTNG
SRI SRINIVASA RAO MADIRAJU
Counsel for the Respondent No.1: SRI D. SURENDER KUMAR,
AGP FOR LAW LEGISLATIVE AFFAIRS
Counsel for the Respondent No.2: Gp FOR REVENUE
Counsel for the Respondent No.4: SRI C.M.R. VELU
The Court made the following: ORDER
IN THE HIGTI OOT]RT FOR THE STATE OF'TEITANGAITA
AT TIYDERABAI)
THE HOITBI,E TTIECHIEF JUSTICE SRI APARESTH I{I'MAR SINGH
AND
THE HON'BLE SRI WSTICE G.M.MOHIUDDIil
WRIT APPEAL IYo.6O6 of 2o26
DATE.TI .O7.20/26
Between:
Nakka Sandhya Rani
....Appellant
And
The State of Telangana, Rep. by its
Secretary to Government, Legal Affairs,
Legislative Affairs and Justice, and 3 others
....Respondents
JUDGMENT
Heard- Mr. M. Surender Rao, learned Senior Counsel
representing Mr. Srinivasa Rao Madiraju, learned counsel for the
appellant; Mr. D. Surender Kumar, learned Assistant Government
Pleader for Law and Legislative Affairs Department appearing for
respondent No.l; and Mr. C.M.R. Ve1u, learned counsel appearing for
respondent No.4 and perused the record.
2.
This writ appeal is preferred under Clause 15 of the Letters
Patent, against the order dated 27.O4.2026 passed by the learned
Single judge in W.P.No.314OO of 2024. By the said order, the learned
Single Judge disposed of the writ petition fi1ed by respondent No. 4
herern (the original writ petitioner), with a direction to the ofhcial
respondents to reconsider the process of appointment to the post of
Goverhmtsnt Pleader, Principal District Court, Jangaon, strictly in
accordance with lau and G.O.Ms.No. 187, after affording a fair and
reasonable opportunitv to al1 eligible candidates, including the writ
petitioner and the appellant herern.
Factual matrix
3.
The Governrnent of Telangana, uide G.O.Rt.Nos.353 and 354,
dated 26.06.2024, rliscontinued the services of all Law Officers
functioning in the Crurts subordinate to the High Court, including
the rvrit petitioner. who was then serving as an Assistant
(iovernment Plead,:r. Simultaneously, the Government directed the
District Collectors to make in-charge arrangements and to furnish
fresh panels ol t:1i51ib1e Advocates for regular appointments in
accordance rn'ith the e pplicable procedure.
4.
Pursuant thereto, the District Collector, Jangaon, requested
the Principal Drstrict Judge, Jangaon, to furnish a panel of eligible
Advocates for appointTlent as Law Officers. Accordingly, the Principai
District Judge invitcd applications from eligible Advocates and, after
completing the process, fon','arded a panel to tbe Dislrict Collector cn
3O.Og.2024 for appoil-rtment to the post of Government Pleader for
the Principal Distri<:t ()ourt, Jangaon. The writ petitioner's name was
include<i at S1. No.ll in the said panel, which was thereafter
forwarded bv t he District Collector to the Ciovernme nt for
consideration
report from the
verification
Upon receipt of the antecedent
was noticed that certain
it
Warangal'
Police
of
5.
'
adverse br pending
had
panel
the
in
candidates included
Commissioner
as the writ petitioner is
antecedents' Insofar
complaint
h1e of
concerned' a private
stated to
in C'C'No'257 9 of 2022 was
Judge' Jangaon'
the Principal Junior Civil
District
be pending on the
In view thereof' the
requested the
dated 07 'iro '2024 '
Coilector' by proceedings
to furnish a fresh/revised
Principal District Judge
Consequently,
forwarded
the Principal District Judge
the name of the writ
O8.1O.2O24, wherein
on
and
a revised panel
petitioner was omitted
Smt' Nakka
the name of the appellant'
included.
Sandhya Rani' was
thereafter forwarded
The revised panel was
Coliector to the Government
panel'
by the District
on ll'l}'2o24'
issued
panel, the Government
revised
the
uPon
Acting
the appeilant as
appointing
.2025,
.Og
dated
6.
G.O.Rt.No.565,
for
Government Pleader
Pursuant
has
.
the Principai District Court'
assumed charge
thereto, the appellant
duties as Government
been discharging her
Aggrieved by the exclusion
Jangaon
on 19 .O9.2O25 ard
Pleader ever since.
of his name from the
revised Panel,
challenging the
W'P No 314OO of 2024 '
instituted
petitioner
the writ
the hrst panel and
1n disregarding
action
of the resPondents
the
cancelling or superseding
without
panel
prepanng a revised
appeilant'
the writ petition' the
of
pendency
the
earlier Pan ei. During
having been appointed as Governmer:t Pleader, was impleaded as
respondent No.4 by order dated 25.11'2025 passed in I'A No'2 of
2025. Thewrit petitLoner also filed I.A. No.1 of 2025 seeking interim
suspension of G.C).Rt.No 565, dated 15.09.2025; however, no interim
order was granted
.
Upon hearing the parties, the learned Single Judge, by the
8.
impugned order, partly allowed the writ petition and inter alia
directed the off.cial respondents to reconsider the process of
appointment to 1,h€ post of Government Pleader for the Principal
District Court, Jangaon, in accordance with lavr, G'O'Ms No 187,
daled. 06.12.200t), zrnd the applicable constitutional principles, after
affording an opport rnity to all eligible candidates, including the writ
petitioner and tht: aPPellant.
g.
Aggrieved thereby, the present writ appeal has been preferred
by the appellant.
Submissions on behalf of appellant
10. Learned St:nior Counsel appearing for the appellant, assailed
the impugned orrlel and has advanced the following submissions:
i) That the appointment of Law Officers is governed by the
executive instructions contained in G.O.Ms.No.187, Law
Departmerrt, dated 06. 12.2OOO, which do not possess statutory
force but are merely administrative guidelines. A writ of
mandamus cannot be issued to enforce such executive
instructions. Reliance was placed upon the Full Bench
decision of this Court in S. Nagender u. Gowrnnnnt o:f
Andhra Pradesh and ot tersl to contend that the learned
Single Judge failed to follow the binding precedent while
entertaining and allowing the writ petition.
ii)
That mere inclusion of the writ petitioner's name in the first
panel did not confer upon him any vested or enforceable right
to appointment. Under Instruction 5(a) of G.O.Ms.No.187, the
Government is empowered either to appoint one among the
empanelled candidates or to call for a fresh panel. The
decision to seek a revised panei fails within the executive
domain of the Government and cannot be subjected to judicial
review unless shown to be arbitrary, mala fide or actuated by
extraneous considerations. In the present case, the decision
was founded upon the antecedent verihcation report disclosing
adverse antecedents, which constituted a valid and rational
basis for seeking a fresh panel.
iii) That the State, being the principal litigant, possesses the
prerogalive as well as the constitutional obligation to appoint
the most suitable counsel to represent its interests before the
Courts. Such executive decisions are entitled to judicial
----' 1zoool + ALD 2ro
deference and ought not to be interfered with unless they are
shown to tre arbitrary or vitiated by malct 75des' The writ
petitioner LLas neither pleaded nor established any such
inllrmitv in 1.he decision-making process.
ir) That the writ petitioner neither questioned the antecedent
verification report which formed the basis lor his exclusion
from.the re'rised panel nor challenged G.O.Rt.No 565, dated
15.09.202.5, u.hereby the appellant came to be appointed as
Government Pleader. In the absence of a challenge to the finai
appointment order, no relief affecting the appellant's
appointment could have been gralted, irnd the learned Single
Judge erred in issuing directions which, in effect, unsettle the
appellant's a tp,:intment.
v) That although t:laborate submissions were adrranced on behalf
ol the appclltLnt , the learned Single Judge neither recorded nor
consideredthesamewhiledisposingofthewritpetition,
justice' It was also
thereb.v violaling the principles of natural
pointed out t ha t the impugned order erroneo usly
name of the counsel appearing for respondent
records the
No 4 as Sri K'
Laxmaiah,ur--]e].eas,infact,theappellantwasrepresentedby
Mr. M. Surender Rao, learned Senior Counsel'
vi) That the u rit pi tition u'as instituted in the year 2024' u'hereas
rhe appellanr u'as appointed as Government Pleader by
G.O.Rt.No.565 dated 15.09.2025. Though aware of the said
appointment, the writ petitioner neither amended the writ
petition nor challenged the appointment order, but merely
sought impleadment of the appellant and filed an interlocutory
application seeking suspension of the appointment of the
appellant. The appellant assumed charge on 19.09.2025 and.
has been discharging her duties continuously for more than
nine months. In such circumstances, interference at this
belated stage, after valuable rights have accrued in favour of
the appellant, is inequitable and barred by the doctrine of
delay and laches.
vii) That the learned Single Judge directed reconsideration of the
process of appointment to the post of Government pleader
despite the post already having been frlled by the appellant.
Such a direction is incapable of implementation unless the
appellant's appointment is first set aside. Any reconsideration
resulting in the selection of the writ petitioner would
necessarily entail termination of the appellant's appointment,
which carnot be undertaken without foliowing due process of
law and affording her an opportunity of hearing. Therefore, the
relief granted is illusory, unworkable and incapable of practical
implementation.
viii)
That althoulih the appellant was
impleaded as respondent No
by order da'ec 25'1 l '2025' the
writ pedtioner failed to amend
either the plt:adrngs or the
prayer in the writ petition to
dated 15.09.2025. The
specifically challenge G'O'Rt'No'565
to consideration of the first
relief claim(ld remained confined
could not have granted
panel lt rvas r;ontended that the Court
pleadings or effectively nullihed
relief beyond the scope of the
the appelleLnt s appointment in the
absetrce of a specihc
challenge to tlle appointment order'
ix) That the lt:arne d Single Judge erred
in drawing an adverse
inferencelnerelybecausetherevisedpatrelwasprepared
panel' Once the antecedent
within a sfrort span after the first
verification r(:ports were received'
the auth'rrities were under
an obligatr':n to act promptly The
preparation of the revised
panel be--w(ren 30 'Og 2024 and OaJO
2024 reflected
administra[iveefl-lciencyandabonafdeexerciseofpowerto
candidates
ensure that onlv suitabie
could not, by itself' be construed
as arbitrar'r or mala fide'
the respondent
Submissions on behalf of
11.
for
Per contra' lt'arned counsel
were recommended' and
No'4 (writ petitionerl
respondent No'4 advanced
the
follorving submis srons:
the
i) That the action ol the ofhcial respondents; in discarding
ilrst panel alrd preparing a revised pzlnel $ ithin an unusually
short span of lime, without formally cancelling or superseding
the earlier panel and without affording any notice or
opportunity to the writ petitioner, is arbitr;ry, unfair and
violative of Article 14 of the Constitution of India. The first
panel had been prepared after due consultation between tJle
District Collector and the Principal District Judge in
accordance wit]l G.O.Ms.No. 187, dated 06.12.2OOO, and after
considering the merit and suitability of the eiigible candidates.
The subsequent preparation of a revised panel, without
adhering to any transparent procedure, vitiates the decisionmaking process.
ir) That the inclusion of the writ petitioner's name in the first
panel gave rise to a legitimate expectation that his candidature
would be fairly considered for appointment. The exclusion of
his name from the revised panel, without assigning any
reasons and without affording him an opportunity of hearing,
defeated such iegitimate expectation and was contrary to the
principles of fairness and natural justice. It was further
submitted that every State action must satisfy the test of
fairness, reasonableness and non-arbitrariness.
iii)
That the antecedent verification report pertaining to the writ
petitioner was already available when the first panel
prepared and forwarded to the Govemment. Despite
was
being
i0
aware of the 1>endency of a private complairLt against the writ
petitioner, tht: authorities consciously incltrded his name in
the first panel, thereby indicating that the said circumstance
was not treated as a disqualification at that stage The
subsequent exclusion of the writ petitioner on the very same
matenal, ',t'ithout any fresh development or changed
circumstant;e, is arbitrary, inconsistent and indicative of a
colourable exercise of Power'
iv) That the .r'rr t petition was clearly maintainable as the
challenge was directed against arbitrary Stare action' Though
G.O.Ms.No., 8'7 contains executive instructions, the exercise of
power thereundcr is nevertheless amenable to judicial review
where it is shown to be arbitrary, unreasonable or violative of
Article i4 o{ tL,e Constitution. The power of the Government to
call for a fresh panel is not absolute or unfettered and cannot
beexercisedinamannerthatdefeatsthelegitimaterightofan
eligible candirlate to fair, transparent and non arbitrary
consideratio -r.
12, We have [a]ierl note of the respective contelltions urged
and
perused the mater.al on record'
Consideration bY this Court
13. The principrll question that arises for consideration is the
nature and enforcreabilitv of G.O.Ms.No.l87, Law (L) Department,
dated 06.12.2000, titled "The Andhra Pradesh Law Officers
(Appointment and Conditions of Seruice) Instructions, 200O". A platn
reading of the said Government Order shows that it contains
execulive instructions regulating the appointment and conditions of
service of Law Offrcers. Admittedly, the said instructions have not
been framed in exercise of the rule-making power under the proviso
to Article 309 of the Constitution of India and, therefore, do not
possess statutory force.
14. The legal position in this regard is no longer res integra. A FulL
Bench of this Court it S. Iilagender (supra 1) while dealing with the
self-same G.O.Ms.No.187 dated 06.|2.2OOO authoritatively held that
executive instructions or guidelines governing appointments of Law
Officers are directory in nature and cannot be enforced by issuance
of a writ of mandamus. The Fuli Bench therein has observed as
under:
57. ...1t is no doubt true that lnuing framed the Rules or issued
instructions or guidelines bg the State Gouemment, it is not
open to tlrc Stote Gouemment to totallg disregard the
instructions or guidelines and the same mag haue to be followed
as far as possible and an endeauour to be made in tlqe said
direction. Bg that itself it does not mean that these
rules/ guidelines/ instruction s are mandatory in nature and can
be enforced bg utag of a Wit Petition bg issuonce of either a
tuit of mandamus or specifted positiue directions in tltb
regard... .
The aforesaid declaration of law is binding upon this Court.
Consequently, the learned Single Judge could not have proceeded
on
1.2
the premise that. every procedural requirement contained
in
G.O.Ms.No.187 $ras enforceable as of right'
15. Further, ln.st-uction 5(4) of G O Ms'No' 187 expressly
empo\vers thc' Govt:rrLment, upon receipt of
a panel forwarded by the
District Collcctor, e ther to appoint one among the
empanelled
Instruction
candidates or to cilll for a fresh panel' Correspondingly'
a fresh panel whenever
5(5) obligates the L)istrict Collector to submit
so called upon ThlLs, the power to seek a fresh
panel is itself
traceable to the exetlutive instructlons governlng
the apPointment
process. At the silrr e time, it cannot be denied
that even while
exercising powers lLn'ier executive instructions'
the State is expected
to act fairly, reasora5lv and free from arbitrariness
woulcl, therelbre, h3 rtot for enforcement
Judicial review
of the exectttive instructions
per se, blut to exat-"rine whether the decision-making
vitiated bY arbitrttrirre ss, mala fides, irrationaiity
constitutional guaralltees. The scope
strict
cannot be enlargecl trl compel
instruction as though it u'ere
16.
or violation of
compiiance with every executive
a statutory mandate'
does
namc in a select I st or panel
inclusion of a candidate's
not confer upon such candidate
right to appointment' In Shankorsan
Hon'ble Supreme
Dash rt. llnion oJ India2' trre
'irooila scc +z
1S
of judicial review' however'
lt is equally u'':11 settled that mere
an.v t'ested or rnc e f':asible
process
Court held that even
the inclusion of a candidate in a select list does not create any right
to appointment and that the appointing authority retains the
discretion whether or not to fill the vacancies, subject to the
requirement that such discretion is exercised fairly a-nd not
arbitrarily. The sa.id principle applies with greater force in the case of
appointments of Government Pleaders and other l"aw Officers, which
are essentia-lly professional engagements.
L7. The writ petitioner's name was included in the frrst panel;
however, the Government, in exercise of the discretion conferred
under Instruction 5(4) of G.O.Ms.No.187, chose to call for a fresh
panel instead of making an appointment therefrom. The Government
was under no legal obligation to make an appointment from the first
panel merely because the writ petitioner's name was included
therein. Much emphasis was placed by the learned Single Judge on
the fact that the first panel was not formally superseded or cancelled
before a fresh panel was calied for. In our considered opinion, such
omission, by itself, does not vitiate the subsequent process. Neither
G.O.Ms.No. 187 nor any other provision brought to our notice
mandates the issuance of a formai order cancelling or superseding
the earlier panel before the Government exercises its power to call for
a fresh panel. The very exercise of the power under Instruction 5(4)
to seek a fresh palel necessarily implies that the Govemment had
decided not to proceed with the earlier panel.
18. It is to be notcd that the appointment of Government Pleaders
and other Law Ofhcers stands on a distinct footing from
appointments to civiL posts. A Law Officer represents the State before
Courts and acts as ils legal representative. Tire relationship between
the Government zLntl its Law Officers is essentiallY that of a ciient
and its counsel, though imbued with a pubiic element.
Consr:quentlv, the Government is entitled to appoinl such counsel as
it considers suitable and in whom it reposes confidt:nce to effectiveiy
represent its intert:sts before the Courts. The choice of a Lau' Officer
is, therefore, preCominantlv an executive function. Unless the
decision-making prccess is shown to be arbitrary, mala fide,
irrational or rn vio. ation of any constitutional or stEttutory mandate,
the scope of judicial r:vieu. in such matters remains limited.
19. In the prese nt case, the Government, upo1l receipt of the
antecedent verificilti,ln reports, exercised its discretion under
Instruction 5(a) of G.O.Ms.No.187 and ca1led for a fresh panel The
record discloses that a private complaint in C C No 2579 of 2022
was pending againsrt the u''rit petitioner at the relevant
point of time'
Whether such ant:ct:dent ultimately rendered the writ
unsuitable is a matt(ir falling r,r,ithin the domain of the
petitioner
appointing
authority. The Goi'el nment was entitled to take the antecedent
verillcation report iIt [c consideration while assessing the suitability of
the candidates, anrl :.his Court would not ortlinariJy substitute its
own assessment for that of the competent authority in the absence of
arbitrariness, mala fides or extraneous considerations.
20. A significant aspect of the present case is that, during the
pendency of the writ petition, the Government issued G.O.Rt.No.565,
dated 15.09.2025, appornting the appellant as the Government
Pleader for the Principal District Court, Jangaon. The appellant
thereafter assumed charge on 19.O9.2025 and has been discharging
her duties pursuant to the said appointment. Although the appellant
was impleaded as respondent No.4 by order dated 25.7L.2025, the
writ petitioner neither amended the pleadings nor the relief sought in
the writ petition so as to specifically challenge the validity of
G.O.Rt.No.565, dated 15.09.2025. The writ petitioner merely filed an
interlocutory application seeking suspension of the said G.O, which
was not granted. The substantive relief in the writ petition continued
to be confined to a declaration that the respondents had acted
illegally in not considering the l-rrst panel and a consequential
direction to consider the first panel for appointment.
21. The relief sought in the underlying writ petition reads as
foliows:
to issue a Writ of mandamus nafure of Wit of Mandamus
decLaring tLLe inaction of the Respondents in not consideing
first ponel of Aduocates to be appointed as Latu Olficers in
uaious Courts ot Jangaon Distict and consideing other
panels uithout ang notice to the Bar Association against its
ualid cancellation or return uhich is creating conJlicts and_
affecting our professional lift, as illegal and uiolatiue of Article
21 of Constih.ttion of India and con sequentlA direct the
respondents tc consider the
first panel of aduocates
post of GP irarjs such other ord.er or ord.ers as this for rc
Hon,ble
Court maa Lleem fit aid. proper in the ciratm_stances
oJ. the
CASC.
Thus, there \.as rro specific challenge to the appell,rnt,s
under G.O.Rt.No.565. Nevertheless, the directiorrs
learned Single Judge. necessarily have a
issued by the
bearing up,)n the appellant,s
appointmenr, whic;h had already been made
tluring the pendency of
the i.r.rit petition. [n the absence of a substantive
appolntment ord{rr and
appointment
challenge to the
an appropriate prayer seekrng its
invalidation, the earned Single Judge ought
to have exercised
.
greater restrainr in issuing directions which
have the effect of
unsetthng an appoint:nent that had alreadv been
made.
22. Another circunstance of significance is
that
the writ
petitioner's exclusic,n from the revised panel
\,r,as preceded by the
antecedent verificatiorr report received from
the Commissioner of
Police, Warangal, re_.erring to the pendency
of C.C. No.2579 of 2022
on the file of rhe principal Junior Civil Judge,
petitioner neither disputed the correctness
Jangaon. The writ
of the said report nor
challenged its consr<ler.ation bv the appointing authority;
contention was that r he pending proceeding was a pri.rate
complaint
and not a police case. lVhether such antecedent ultimately
the v"'rit petitioner unr;u tabre for appointment is not toi
determine, as t he assr_,ssment
his only
renclered
this court to
of suitability- for appointment as
Government pleader pr-imarily falls within
the domain of the
appointing authority' Therefore, it was open to the Government to
take the antecedent verification report into consideration while
assessing the suitabitity of the candidates, and the writ petitioner's
failure to challenge either the report or its consideration assumes
signihcance while examining the Iegality of the decision-making
process.
2g. The appellant has also contended that the learned Single
Judge failed to consider the submissions advanced on -her behalf'
The record discloses that the appellant frled a counter-afhdavit and
was represented by Mr. M. Surender Rao, learned Senior Counsel'
Although the impugned order records that the counsel appearing for
respondent No.4 was heard, a perusal thereof does not reflect any
discussion of the submissions advanced on behalf of the appellant. It
is also noticed that the impugned order erroneously records the
name of the counsel appearing for respondent No'4 as Sri K'
Laxmaiah, whereas the appellant was represented by Mr' M'
Surender Rao, Iearned Senior Counsel. While an incorrect recording
of the name of the counsel, by itself, may not be determinative, the
absence of any discussion on the substantial contentions urged on
behalf of the appeilant assumes significance and lends credence to
the grievance that the said contentions were not adequately
considered by the learned Single Judge. Such omission has a bearing
on the fairness of the adjudicatory process ald is a relevant
circumstance while examining the sustainability of the impugned
order.
24. Moreover, thc vrrit petition was instituted in the year 2024.
During its pende nc y', the appellant was appointed as Government
Pleader uide G.O.Rt.No.565 dated 15.09.2025 and assumed charge
on 19.09.2025. Despite being fully aware of the said appointment,
the rvrit petitione r neither challenged the appointment order nor
amended the relief ;ought in the writ petition, btLt merely hled an
implead petition, r',hich was allowed on 25.1 1.2025, and art
apphcation seeking suspension of the appointment, which was not
granted. By the timt: the learned Single Judge disposed of the writ
petition on 27 .O4..2J26, the appellant had beerr functioning as
Government Pleadr-'r ior over seven months.
25. It is u-ell se1 tl('d that a w'rit of mandamus is a discretionary
remedy, and reliel- tLnder Article 226 mav be declined where the
petitioner approaches. the Court after undue de1ay, particularly w'hen
third-party rights lLare intervened and crystallized. In the facts of the
present case, the writ petitioner cannot be permitted to indirectly
unsetlle the appellrn s appointment at such a belated stage without
specifically challengir g the appointment order'
26. It is also appcsire to note that the direction issued by the
learned Single .Jucige lt:; "reconsider the process oJ appointment" is
incapablc of effectiv: implementation. The post of Governmcnt
t9
Pleader is a single post and had already been filled by the
appointment of the appellant, who assumed charge on 19.O9.2025.
Any reconsideration of the appointment process would necessar y
have a bearing on the appellant,s subsisting appointment. If such
reconsideration were to result in the selection of the writ petitioner, it
wouid inevitably require the appellant's appointment to be displaced;
conversely, if the appellant were again found suitable, the exercise
would serve no practical purpose. In either event, the-appellant,s
appointment could not have been unsettled in the absence of a
specific challenge to G.O.Rt.No.565, dated lS.Og.2O2S, by which she
was appointed. Therefore, the direction issued by the learned Single
Judge travels beyond the scope of the relief sought in the writ
petition and is incapable of being effectively worked out in the
absence of a challenge to the appellant,s appointment.
27. In the present case the writ petitioner impleaded the appellant
bv filing I.A. No.2 of 2025, which was allowed on 25. 11.2025.
However, he neither amended the pleadings nor the relief sought to
challenge G.O.Rt.No.565, dated IS.O9.2O2S, whereby the appellant
was appointed as Government pleader. The relief continued to be
confined to consideration of the hrst panel. Mere impleadment of the
appellant did not enlarge the scope of the writ petition or dispense
with the necessity of specifically challenging the appointment order.
It is well settled that a Court ordinarily cannot grant relief beyond
the pleadings or the prayers sought. Consequently, the directions
)o
issued by the learrled Single Judge, which have the effect of
unsettling the appellant's appointment, could not have been
granted
in the absence of a specific challenge to G O'Rt No'565'
28. The learned Single Judge inferred arbitrariness from the short
interv'al betu'cen t hc {lrst panel dated 30 09 '2024 and the revised
panel dated O}JO .2'024 . We are unabie to conclrr with the said
finding. The record discloses that, upon receipt of the antecedent
verification report frcm the Commissioner of Police indicating adverse
antecedents agatn st certain candidates, including the writ petitioner'
the District Coilecr,or promptly sought a revised panel on 07 1O '2024 '
u,hich was furnished on Oa-rc.2024 and forwarded to the
Government on ll .|J.2024. Mere expedition in administrative action
cannot,byitself,gi',zerisetoaninferenceofarbitrariness'lnthe
absence of any nraterial establishing mala ftdes, extraneous
considerations or atruse of power, the prompt action taken by the
authorities to
,in iure
that only suitable t:andidates were
recommend.ed for,lpcointment as Law Officers cannot be faulted'
Conclusion
29, For [hc fore,]oing reasons, this Court is of the considered view
that the impugnetl order passed by the learned Sir.gle Judge suffers
from errors of law ar:d of approach warranting interlerence in appeai.
The learned Sing. e ..ludge failed to appreciate the true nature of
G.O.Ms.No.187, the limited scope of judicial review in matters
relating to appointment of Law Officers, the absence of any vested
right in favour of the writ petitioner, and the fact that the appellant's
appointment had neither been specihcally challenged nor could it
have been unsettled in the manner directed. Consequently, the
impugned order dated 27.04.2026 in W.P. No. 31400 ol 2024 cannot
be sustained and is liable to be set aside.
30. Accordingly, the Writ Appeal is allowed. The order dated
27.04.2026 in W.P. No. 31400 of 2024 passed by the learned Single
Judge is hereby set aside.
As a sequel, miscellaneous petitions, pending if any, stand
closed. No costs
SD/. M.RAMANA KRISHNA
OINT REGISTRAR
//TRUE COPY//
ECTION OFFICER
To
1. The Secretary to Government Legal Affairs Legislative Affairs and Justrce
Secretariat , The State of Telangana, Hyderabad - 500004
2. The Collector and District l/agistrate, Jangaon District
3. The Principai District Judge, Jangaon
4. One CC to Sri Srinivasa Rao Madiraju, Advocate [OPUC]
5. Two CCs to GP for Law Legislative Affairs, High Court for the State of
Telangana, at Hyderabad [OUT]
6. Two CCs to the GP for Revenue, High Court for the State of Telangana, at
Hyderabad[OUT]
7. One CC to Sri C.Ml.R. Velu, Advocate[OPUC]
8. Two CD Copies
TJ
TKS
tu4
HIGH COURT
DATED: 2110712026
..r,' R klE 5r4
JUDGMENT
,/'ro
t
-)
o
L,
WA.No.606 of 2026
lt
I JLlr
't .5 pIITC\1
ALLOWING THE WRIT APPEAL
WITHOUT COSTS
Pf^Q
+\24
v
z
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review