Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Digitally
signed
by
SHAYNA
KADRI
2026:CGHC:760
NAFR
HIGH COURT OF CHHATTISGARH AT BILASPUR
WPS No. 9516 of 2023
1 - Nahid Parveen Wd/o Late Suhail Ahmed Aged About 48 Years R/o
Behind Ankur Tent House, Old Bus Stand, Korba, District- Korba, Cg
Presently Residing At- Behind Madina Masjid, Korba, Tehsil And Police
Station- Korba,, District : Korba, Chhattisgarh
... Petitioner(s)
versus
1 - South Eastern Coal Fields Through Managing Director, Bilaspur,
District : Bilaspur, Chhattisgarh
2 - General Manager Secl Dipka, Tehsil- Katghora,, District : Korba,
Chhattisgarh
3 - Personnel Manager Secl Dipka, Tehsil- Katghora,, District : Korba,
Chhattisgarh
4 - Smt. Taj B R/o In Front Of Petrol Pump, Mudpar, Secl, Tehsil And
District- Korba, Cg
... Respondent(s)
(Cause-title is taken from Case Information System)
For Petitioner
:
Mr. Saket Pandey, Advocate
For Resp. No. 1 to 3
:
Mr. Aditya Tiwari, Advocate appearing on
behalf of Mr. Shailendra Dubey
SB- Hon'ble Shri Justice Amitendra Kishore Prasad
Order on Board
06/01/2026
1.
The petitioner has filed this writ petition seeking following reliefs :-
“10.1. That, the Hon'ble Court may kindly call for
records pertaining to service records of the
petitioners husband.
10.2. That the Hon'ble Court may kindly direct the
respondents to provide compassionate
appointment to the petitioner with granting
monetary and retiral benefits, with interest.
10.3. That, any other relief, which this Hon'ble Court
may deemed just and fit in facts and
circumstances of the case.”
2.
The facts of the case, in brief, are that the husband of the
petitioner, Late Shri Suhail Ahmed, was employed with the
respondent authorities on the post of Dumper Operator.
Unfortunately, he died during the course of service on 11.10.2012.
The death of the deceased employee is evidenced by a death
certificate, which has been placed on record by the petitioner.
After the death of her husband, when the petitioner approached
the respondent authorities for release of retiral dues and other
service benefits, she was informed that the same could not be
processed in the absence of a succession certificate in her favour.
Consequently, to establish her legal status and entitlement, the
petitioner was constrained to institute a civil suit before the
competent civil court. The learned Court below, after due
consideration, decreed the suit in favour of the petitioner by
judgment and decree dated 15.11.2019. Pursuant thereto, a
succession certificate was ultimately issued in favour of the
petitioner on 19.01.2022, wherein she was declared to be the
lawful heir of the deceased employee in the capacity of his widow.
After obtaining the succession certificate, the petitioner submitted
repeated representations to the respondent authorities seeking
release
of
retiral
dues
of
her
deceased
husband
and
consideration of her case for compassionate appointment. Such
representations, along with certified copies of the succession
certificate, were submitted on several occasions, namely on
02.12.2019, 24.01.2022, 27.04.2022, 27.06.2022 and 17.04.2023.
Despite these repeated efforts, no final decision was taken by the
respondents, nor were any benefits released in favour of the
petitioner.
The petitioner further states that the respondent
authorities merely informed her that her case had been forwarded
to higher authorities for consideration; however, even thereafter,
no concrete action was taken. It is also the case of the petitioner
that her husband died at Apollo Hospital, Bilaspur, and the
hospital did not provide certain documents, and further, the
petitioner being the second wife of the deceased employee, the
private respondent has not been cooperating by providing the
identity documents of the deceased. On account of these alleged
deficiencies, the respondent authorities have rejected or kept
pending the claim of the petitioner, citing lack of documents.
Aggrieved by the inaction and refusal of the respondents to grant
retiral dues and compassionate appointment despite issuance of
a succession certificate in her favour, the petitioner has
approached this Court by filing the present petition.
3.
Learned counsel for the petitioner submits that the impugned
inaction on the part of the respondents in not releasing the retiral
dues, monetary benefits and in not considering the case of the
petitioner for compassionate appointment is wholly arbitrary,
illegal and contrary to the facts and circumstances of the case. It
is contended that despite the death of the employee and the clear
entitlement of the petitioner, the respondents have failed to
discharge their statutory and constitutional obligations.
It is
further submitted that earlier the respondents had withheld the
benefits on the ground that the petitioner did not possess a
succession certificate. However, even after the petitioner obtained
the succession certificate from the competent Court and the same
was duly produced before the respondents, the retiral dues,
monetary benefits and the benefit of compassionate appointment
have still not been granted to her. Such conduct of the
respondents, according to learned counsel, is unjustified and
reflects total non-application of mind.
Learned counsel also
submits that as per the relevant rules, policies and provisions
governing compassionate appointment and release of retiral
benefits, the petitioner is legally entitled to the said benefits. There
exists no legal impediment or bar for granting compassionate
appointment and monetary benefits in favour of the petitioner, and
the continued denial thereof is contrary to the settled principles of
law. Lastly, learned counsel submits that the petitioner, being a
widow, is surviving under acute financial distress and hardship.
She has been compelled to run from pillar to post for release of
the retiral dues and other benefits. Despite issuance of the
required certificates and even after a decree having been passed
in her favour, the respondents have failed to provide her lawful
dues, thereby depriving her of her legitimate rights and causing
grave injustice.
4.
Learned counsel appearing for the respondents No. 1 to 3/SECL,
while opposing the submissions advanced on behalf of the
petitioner, submits that the petition is misconceived and not
maintainable in the present form. It is contended that there exists
a serious and bona fide dispute with regard to the entitlement of
the petitioner to claim retiral dues, monetary benefits and
compassionate appointment.
Learned counsel further submits
that the petitioner claims herself to be the widow of the deceased
employee; however, as per the service records and information
available with the respondents, the petitioner is the second wife of
the deceased employee. The marital status of the petitioner and
the validity of her claim as a legally wedded spouse are under
dispute, and therefore, the respondents cannot be compelled to
release the retiral dues or grant compassionate appointment
without proper adjudication of such disputed questions of fact. It
is also submitted that compassionate appointment is not a matter
of right and can be granted only in accordance with the applicable
rules and policies. In the present case, due to the dispute
regarding the legal status and entitlement of the petitioner, the
respondents are justified in withholding the benefits till the matter
is finally resolved by a competent authority or court of law.
Learned counsel lastly submits that the respondents have not
acted arbitrarily or illegally, but have acted strictly in accordance
with law and the governing service rules. Until the issue of
entitlement of the petitioner is conclusively determined, no
direction can be issued to the respondents for release of retiral
dues or for grant of compassionate appointment, and therefore,
the petition deserves to be dismissed.
5.
At this stage, learned counsel for the petitioner submits that the
objection raised regarding the marital status of the petitioner is
wholly untenable and misconceived. It is contended that in the
petitioner’s community, second marriage is permissible under the
relevant personal law and statutory provisions, and therefore, the
petitioner cannot be denied her legitimate rights merely on the
ground that she is the second wife of the deceased employee.
Learned counsel further submits that the petitioner has already
obtained a succession certificate in her favour in Succession
Case No. 8/13 from the competent Court, which conclusively
recognizes her entitlement to the estate and dues of the deceased
employee. It is further pointed out that the said succession
certificate was challenged by the other party in appeal; however,
the said appeal has also been dismissed, and as such, the
succession certificate has attained finality. It is thus submitted
that once the succession certificate stands affirmed and there is
no subsisting dispute with regard to the entitlement of the
petitioner, the respondents have no justification to withhold the
retiral dues or to deny consideration of the petitioner’s case for
compassionate appointment. The continued inaction on the part of
the respondents is arbitrary, illegal and contrary to law. Learned
counsel lastly submits that in view of the settled legal position and
the final adjudication of the petitioner’s entitlement, the petitioner
is entitled to compassionate appointment as well as release of all
retiral and monetary dues in respect of her deceased husband,
and therefore, appropriate directions may be issued to the
respondents to grant the same.
6.
I have heard learned counsel for the parties and have also
perused the documents enclosed along with the writ petition.
7.
Having heard learned counsel for the parties at length and upon
perusal of the pleadings as well as the documents placed on
record, this Court finds that the undisputed fact is that the
husband of the petitioner, Late Shri Suhail Ahmed, was working
as a Dumper Operator under the respondent authorities and died
in harness on 11.10.2012. After his death, the petitioner
approached the respondents for release of retiral dues and
consideration of her case for compassionate appointment, which
was initially withheld on the ground of absence of a succession
certificate.
8.
From the material available on record, it is evident that the
petitioner thereafter approached the competent civil Court and
succeeded in obtaining a judgment and decree dated 15.11.2019,
pursuant to which a succession certificate was issued in her
favour on 19.01.2022 in Succession Case No. 8/13, declaring her
to be the lawful heir of the deceased employee. It is also not in
dispute that the said succession certificate was challenged by the
other party in appeal, which appeal has already been dismissed,
and thus, the succession certificate has attained finality.
9.
The objection raised by the respondents with regard to the
petitioner being the second wife of the deceased employee
cannot be accepted at this stage to indefinitely deny consideration
of her claim. Once a competent civil Court has adjudicated the
issue of entitlement and issued a succession certificate in favour
of the petitioner, and the same has attained finality, the
respondents are duty-bound to consider the petitioner’s claim in
light of the said succession certificate. The respondents cannot sit
over the matter endlessly on the pretext of alleged disputes,
particularly when such disputes stand resolved by a judicial
determination. At the same time, this Court is conscious of the
settled legal position that compassionate appointment is not a
matter of right and is required to be considered strictly in
accordance with the applicable rules and policies. However, the
respondents are under an obligation to take a reasoned decision
on the claim of the petitioner for compassionate appointment and
release of other service and retiral dues, instead of keeping the
matter pending indefinitely.
10.
Considering the aforesaid aspects of the matter, this Court deems
it appropriate to dispose of the petition with a direction.
Accordingly, respondents No. 1 to 3 are directed to consider the
case of the petitioner in light of the succession certificate issued in
her favour and to pass an appropriate order in respect of grant of
compassionate appointment as well as other service and retiral
dues payable on account of the deceased employee. The
aforesaid exercise shall be completed expeditiously, preferably
within a period of 60 days from the date of receipt of a copy of this
order.
11.
With the aforesaid observation and direction, the writ petition
stands disposed of.
No order as to costs.
Sd/(Amitendra Kishore Prasad)
Shayna
JUDGE
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review