Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
APHC010559742024
IN THE HIGH COURT OF ANDHRA PRADESH
AT AMARAVATI
(Special Original Jurisdiction)
[3332]
FRIDAY,THE TWENTY SEVENTH DAY OF FEBRUARY
TWO THOUSAND AND TWENTY SIX
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE SRI JUSTICE RAVI CHEEMALAPATI
CIVIL REVISION PETITION NO: 3145/2024
Between:
1. NAGIREDDY TULASI KATYAYINI, W/O. SRINIVASA RAO, AGED
ABOUT 48 YEARS, OCC BUSINESS, R/O. D.NO.5-75/1/1, PLOT
NO.36, MUBARAK COLONY, NEAR MASEED,
YANDADA,
VISHAKHAPATNAM DISTRICT.
...PETITIONER
AND
1. BATHINA SUJATHA, w/o Bathina Venkata Srinivasa Rao, Aged
about 54 years, Occ Housewife, R/o Jagayyapeta, Krishna District.
...RESPONDENT
Petition under Article 227 of the Constitution of India, praying that in
the circumstances stated in the grounds filed herein, the High Court may
be pleased to set aside the order dated 13.11.2024 made in I.A.No.1236
of 2024 in O.S.No.85 of 2020 pending on the file of The Principal Junior
Civil Judge, Bhimunipatnam, Vishakhapatnam District by allowing the
Civil Revision Petition and pass
IA NO: 1 OF 2024
Petition under Section 151 CPC praying that in the circumstances
stated in the affidavit filed in support of the petition, the High Court may
be pleased to grant stay of all further proceedings in I.A.No.1236 of 2024
in O.S.No.85 of 2020 O.S.No.85 of 2020 pending on the file of The
Principal Junior Civil Judge, Bhimunipatnam, Vishakhapatnam District,
pending disposal of the above CRP and pass
Counsel for the Petitioner:
1. A K KISHORE REDDY
Counsel for the Respondent:
1. P VIVEK
The Court made the following:
ORDER:
Assailing the correctness and legality of the order dated 13.11.2024
passed by the Principal Junior Civil Judge, Bhimunipatnam in
I.A.No.1236 of 2024 in O.S.No.85 of 2020 dated 13.11.2024, the present
Civil Revision Petition is filed.
2.
The petitioner herein is the plaintiff and respondent herein is the
defendant in the above said suit filed for recovery of money.
3.
The respondent/defendant filed I.A.No.1236 of 2024 under Order
VIII Rule 1(3)(B) and Section 151 of CPC read with Section 65B of Indian
Evidence Act, 1872, duly praying the Court to receive the documents
mentioned in the said petition. The same was opposed by the petitioner/
plaintiff by filing counter denying the allegations inter alia contending that
the respondent/defendant did not plead about the said documents in the
written statement and the same cannot be received at a belated stage.
4.
After hearing the parties, the Court below, by order dated
13.11.2024, allowed the said application subject to payment of costs of
Rs.500/-. Aggrieved by the said order, the present Civil Revision Petition
is filed.
5.
Heard Sri A.K.Kishore Reddy, learned counsel for the petitioner
and Sri P.Vivek, learned counsel for the respondents.
6.
Learned counsel for the petitioner in elaboration to what has been
stated in the counter and the grounds of the revision petition contended
that the Court below failed to look into the aspect that the
respondent/defendant did not plead anything regarding the documents
now sought to be received in the written statement. He further contended
that the Court below erroneously allowed the said application by
observing that the relevancy and admissibility of the documents would be
considered at the time of judgment and the same is contrary to law. He
further submitted that once the documents are received, the rights of the
petitioner/plaintiff would be affected, as such, prayed to allow the Civil
Revision Petition and dismiss I.A.No.1236 of 2024.
7.
On the other hand, Sri P.Vivek, learned counsel for the
respondent/defendant submitted that the Court below cannot test the
relevancy and admissibility of the documents at the stage of receiving.
He further submitted that such objections can be raised at the stage of
marking the documents. He further submitted that the Court below has
rightly allowed the said application and needs no interference of this
Court and the revision is liable to be dismissed, accordingly, prayed to
dismiss the Revision Petition.
8.
Perused the record and considered the submissions made by the
learned counsel for the parties.
9.
The contention advanced by the learned counsel for the petitioner
is that under Order XVIII Rule 17 of CPC, the defendant has to produce
the documents upon which he relies along with the written statement and
the documents sought to be produced were not referred to in the written
statement, therefore, the same cannot be looked into. However, sub rule
(3) of the said provision confers discretion upon the Court to permit the
defendant to produce documents at a later stage if sufficient cause is
shown. Further, the contention advanced by the learned counsel for the
petitioner/plaintiff is that the Court below is erroneously observed that
admissibility and relevancy of documents must be looked into at the time
of judgment and by virtue of the said observation, if the documents
sought to be produced by the respondent/defendant were taken on
record, the rights of the petitioner/plaintiff would be affected.
10.
In support of his contention, learned counsel for the petitioner
relied on Para 10 & 16 of the judgement of the Hon’ble Apex Court in
K.K.Velusamy vs. N.Palaanisamy1, which are extracted hereunder for
quick reference:
10. The respondent contended that section 151 cannot be used for reopening evidence or for recalling witnesses. We are not able to accept
the said submission as an absolute proposition. We however agree
that section 151 of the Code cannot be routinely invoked for reopening
evidence or recalling witnesses. The scope of section 151 has been
explained by this Court in several decisions (See : Padam Sen vs. State
of UP-AIR 1961 SC 218; Manoharlal Chopra vs. Seth Hiralal - AIR 1962
SC 527; Arjun Singh vs. Mohindra Kumar - AIR 1964 SC 993; Ram
Chand and Sons Sugar Mills (P) Ltd. vs. Kanhay Lal - AIR 1966 SC
1899; Nain Singh vs. Koonwarjee - 1970 (1) SCC 732; The Newabganj
Sugar Mills Co.Ltd. vs. Union of India - AIR 1976 SC 1152; Jaipur
Mineral Development Syndicate vs. Commissioner of Income Tax, New
Delhi - AIR 1977 SC 1348; National Institute of Mental Health & Neuro
Sciences vs. C Parameshwara - 2005 (2) SCC 256; and Vinod Seth vs.
Devinder Bajaj - 2010 (8) SCC 1). We may summarize them as follows:
(a) Section 151 is not a substantive provision which creates
or confers any power or jurisdiction on courts. It merely
recognizes the discretionary power inherent in every court as
a necessary corollary for rendering justice in accordance with
law, to do what is `right' and undo what is `wrong', that is, to
do all things necessary to secure the ends of justice and
prevent abuse of its process.
(b) As the provisions of the Code are not exhaustive, section
151 recognizes and confirms that if the Code does not
expressly or impliedly cover any particular procedural aspect,
the inherent power can be used to deal with such situation or
aspect, if the ends of justice warrant it. The breadth of such
power is co-extensive with the need to exercise such power
on the facts and circumstances.
(c) A Court has no power to do that which is prohibited by law
or the Code, by purported exercise of its inherent powers. If
the Code contains provisions dealing with a particular topic or
aspect, and such provisions either expressly or necessary
implication exhaust the scope of the power of the court or the
jurisdiction that may exercised in relation to that matter, the
inherent power cannot be invoked in order to cut across the
powers conferred by the Code or a manner inconsistent with
such provisions. In other words the court cannot make use of
the special provisions of Section 151 of the Code, where the
remedy or procedure is provided in the Code.
Civil Appeal Nos.2795 & 2796 of 2011
(d) The inherent powers of the court being complementary to
the powers specifically conferred, a court is free to exercise
them for the purposes mentioned in Section 151 of the Code
when the matter is not covered by any specific provision in
the Code and the exercise of those powers would not in any
way be in conflict with what has been expressly provided in
the Code or be against the intention of the Legislature.
(e) While exercising the inherent power, the court will be
doubly cautious, as there is no legislative guidance to deal
with the procedural situation and the exercise of power
depends upon the discretion and wisdom of the court, and the
facts and circumstances of the case. The absence of an
express provision in the code and the recognition and saving
of the inherent power of a court, should not however be
treated as a carte blanche to grant any relief.
(f) The power under section 151 will have to be used with
circumspection and care, only where it is absolutely
necessary, when there is no provision in the Code governing
the matter, when the bona fides of the applicant cannot be
doubted, when such exercise is to meet the ends of justice
and to prevent abuse of process of court.
16. We may add a word of caution. The power under section 151 or
Order 18 Rule 17 of the Code is not intended to be used routinely,
merely for the asking. If so used, it will defeat the very purpose of
various amendments to the Code to expedite trials. But where the
application is found to be bona fide and where the additional evidence,
oral or documentary, will assist the court to clarify the evidence on the
issues and will assist in rendering justice, and the court is satisfied that
non-production earlier was for valid and sufficient reasons, the court
may exercise its discretion to recall the witnesses or permit the fresh
evidence. But if it does so, it should ensure that the process does not
become a protracting tactic. The court should firstly award appropriate
costs to the other party to compensate for the delay. Secondly the court
should take up and complete the case within a fixed time schedule so
that the delay is avoided. Thirdly if the application is found to be
mischievous, or frivolous, or to cover up negligence or lacunae, it
should be rejected with heavy costs. If the application is allowed and the
evidence is permitted and ultimately the court finds that evidence was
not genuine or relevant and did not warrant the reopening of the case
recalling the witnesses, it can be made a ground for awarding
exemplary costs apart from ordering prosecution if it involves fabrication
of evidence. If the party had an opportunity to produce such evidence
earlier but did not do so or if the evidence already led is clear and
unambiguous, or if it comes to the conclusion that the object of the
application is merely to protract the proceedings, the court should reject
the application. If the evidence sought to be produced is an electronic
record, the court may also listen to the recording before granting or
rejecting the application.
11.
No doubt, the principle laid down in the aforesaid judgment is well
settled. However, the said judgment is not helpful to the petitioner in the
facts and circumstances of the present case. As held by the Hon’ble
Apex Court, the power under Section 151 of the Code of Civil Procedure
or under Order XVIII Rule 17 CPC is not intended to be exercised
routinely or merely for the asking.
12.
There is some force in the contention advanced by the learned
counsel for the respondents that the question of relevancy or
admissibility of the documents cannot be looked into at the time of
receiving the documents. The settled principle is that the Court may
receive the documents on record, subject to proof and admissibility, and
the objections regarding their admissibility can be considered at
appropriate stage when the documents are sought to be marked in
evidence. In support of his contention, learned counsel for the
respondent relied on the judgment in G.Sudhaker Reddy vs.
M.Pullaiah2.
13.
No doubt the observation made by the trial Court insofar as
admissible or inadmissible, relevant or irrelevant aspect at the time of
delivering the judgement is erroneous and the Court cannot decide the
said aspect at the time of marking the document. As held in
2015 SCC Online Hyd 62
R.V.E.Venkatachala Gounder v. Arulmigu Viswesaraswami,3, there is
a clear distinction between receiving a document on record and marking
the document as an exhibit in evidence. While considering the said issue,
the Court relied upon the judgment of the Hon’ble Supreme Court in
R.V.E.Venkatachala Gounder case, wherein it was held that objections
relating to the admissibility must be taken at the time of marking of the
document, and if such objections are not raised at that stage, the party
may not be permitted to raise them subsequently at a later stage,
including in appeal or revision.
14.
In view of the above settled legal position, the Court below is
required to consider the objections relating to admissibility at the stage
when the documents are sought to be marked in evidence.
15.
In the said view of the facts and circumstances of the case and the
judgements referred supra, the Civil Revision Petition is partly allowed.
The Court below is directed to follow procedure laid down while
considering the documents which now sought to be relied by the
defendant. There shall be no order as to costs.
AIR 2003 SC 4548
As a sequel, miscellaneous applications, pending if any, shall
stand closed.
_____________________________
JUSTICE RAVI CHEEMALAPATI
th
Date: 27 February, 2026
RKS
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review