Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
[ 3303 I
IN THE HIGH COURT FOR THE STATE OF TELANGANA
AT HYDERABAD
THURSDAY, THE TWELFTH DAY OF FEBRUARY
TWO THOUSAND AND TWENTY SIX
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE SRI JUSTICE J SREENIVAS RAO
q?lMlNAL REVISION CASE NO: 23 07 0F 2010
I
;
I
:
I
Criminal Revision Case filed under Section 397 and 401 of Cr.PC against
the Judgment dated 16-08-2010 made in Crl.A.No.86 of 2008 on the file 5f tfre
Court of the Principal Sessions Judge at Nalgonda preferred against the Order
dated 14-05'2008 made in Case No.CS1/1852-of 2OO7 on the fil6 of the Court of
the District Collector, Nalgonda District.
I
I
:
;
.
Between:
Nagilla Krishna [\4urthy, S/oVishwanatham, Occ: Business, R/o Puligilla Village,
Valigonda ftlandal, Nalgonda District.
... Petitioner /Accused
AND
THE STATE OF AP through rep. by its Public Prosecutor, High Court of A.P., at
..Respondent
A. NO: 2 OF 2O1
MP. NO: 3463
Petition under Section 482 of Cr.P.C praying that in the circumstances stated in
the affidavit filed in support of the petition, the High Court may be pleased to stay all
further proceedings in pursuant to the orders orders dt. 16-08-2010 in Crl.A.No.B6 of
2008 on the file of the Prl.Sessions Judge at Nalgonda, in confirming the order dt.
14-05-2008 in Case No. CS1/185212007 on the file of District Collector, Nalgonda,
pending disposal of the Crlrc.
counsel for the Petitioner : sri Naren Rudra, counsel representing
Sri Harender Prasad
Counsel for the Respondent : Sri M Vivekananda Reddy, Assistant
Public Prosecutor
The Court made the following: ORDER
HIG]II
FOR THE STATE OF.TELANGAN AAT
ITYDERABAD
THE TIONOURABLE SRI JUSTICE J.SREENIVAS RAO
C:RIMINAL
SION CASE No.23O7 of 20LO
Date: 12.02.2o26
Between:
Nagilla Krir;hna Murthy
Petitioner/Accused
AND
The State of A.P. rep. by its
Public Pror;ecutor and another.
...Respondents
:ORDER:
This Criminal Revision Case has been filed by the
petitioner/accused invoking the provisions of Sections 397 and
401 of the Code of Crirninal Procedure, 1973 (for short 'Cr.P.C.')
aggrieved 'cy the orders dated 16.08.201O passed by the learned
Principal Siessions Judge, Khammam, in Criminal Appeal No.117
of 2OO9 confirming the order dated 06.10.2009 in M.C. No.94 of
2OO9, passed by the District Collector, Khammam, whereby and
where under the stocks belonging to the petitioner were
confiscate<l in exercise of powers under Section 6-A of the
Essential Oommodities Act, 1955 (for shortthe E.C. Act').
2.
Brief facts of the case:
2.lThattheTahasildar,Valigonda,submittedareportunder
Section 6-A of the E.C. Act, 1955 against the
proprietor of M/s
Hanuman BMRM, Puligilla (V), Valigonda (M)'
wherein it was
reported, that on receipt of credible information
regarding illegal
storage and business of PDS rice by M/s
Hanuman SMRM
Puligilla,healongwithTahasildar'Bhongir'DT(CS)'Bhongirand
the mill on
(Proc.), Bhongir, have cond'ucted raiding over
RI
lS.l2.2ooTandnoticedthatalorrybearingNo.APgU|44with
rice bags load and the rice bags are being unloaded
from the lorry'
at the time of inspection by the complainant, 172
containing 50 Kgs. rice found in the lorr], the
stitched FCI labelled bags and the details
bags each
bags were machine
printed on the bags are
thericedrawnfromthelotNo.6forthecropyear2ooT-o8of
KanyakaParameswariPBRI,Kunur,NalgondaDistrictandthe
centreisSwC,Wangapally,andtheremainingTSbagswere
unloadedandricewasremovedfromthebagsandtheFCl
labelled empty bags were kept at the side of
the rice mill, and on
noticing the inspection team, the unloading was
stopped, and on
questionedtheownerSriNagillaKrishnaMurthyS/o
Vishwanatham,whoreachedthemill,toprod.ucetherecordsor
documents etc., he failed to produce the records
\
and satisfactory
reply and beg;ged pardon and agreed that PDS rice was diverted to
the mill.
2.2 It was also reported that as the rice was drawn from SWC
Wangapally, the inspecting team enquired about the departure of
lorry from S\VC, Wangapally, and found that the said vehicle left
the SWC Godown Wangapally at 3-00 PM on L7.12.2OO7 and
supposed to deliver the stocks at the IMG point, Mothkur, instead
of proceeding to Mothkur, the vehicle was diverted to Puligilla
village of V:rligonda Mandal by the Vehicle owner Sri Nagilla
Krishna Murthy, who is also the mill owner, with an intention to
divert the PDS rice into black market, who also admitted the
diversion of PDS rice. Since no records or permissions were
produced by the mill owner, the complainant seized the physical
stocks available in the mill premises under cover of panchanama
and handed over the stocks to M / s Mathyagiri Laxminarsimha
Swamy PBRM and the lorry bearing No. AP 9 U 144 to Station
House Officer, Valigonda, for safe custody and also filed a criminal
case against the petitioner and requested to take action U/s 6-A of
the E.C. Act.
3.
The
District
Collector, Nalgonda, in
Case
No.CS1/ l8l;2l2OO7 after hearing the parties, exercising the
\.-"
powers conferred under Section 6-A of the E.C. Act, passed the
following order:
"1. lOOo/o value of the seized PDS rice. (Rs.25,O00/-)
2. 5Oo/o value of seized paddy and rice stocks available
in the mitl (stocks left in the mill, after releasing the
paddy stocks pertains to farmers) (Rs.3,50,OOO/-).
3. 1OO% value of the Bank guarantee furnished by the
vehicle owner for interim release of seized vehicle.
(Rs.65,00O l).
4. SOVI value of the Bank guarantee furnished by the
stage-t contractor at the time of entering agreement
with the Civil Supplies Corporation. (Rs.6 ,25,OOO l-),.
The District Manager, APSCSC Ltd., Nalgonda is
directed to remit PDS rice confiscation amount by
disposing the PDS rice through PDS and also to remit
the 50% value of the bank guarantee furnished by the
stage-I transport contractor by withdrawing from the
bank.
The District Supply officer, Nalgonda, is directed to
remit the lOO% value of the bank guarantee furnished
by the vehicle owner by withdrawing from the bank'
The Tahasildar, Valigonda is directed to recover the
5O%o value of seized paddy and rice stocks available in
the mill from the rice mill 0wner and release the rice
mill.
The confiscation amount has to be remitted under "MH
1456 Civil Suplies, 8oo other Receipts, 81 Other items. (DDo
CODE 1901 23Ol 0O1) and the original challans to be sent to the
office of the District Supply officer, Nalgonda, immediately."
Confiscation of 1BO.OO Qtls. of rice and 20 Qtls. of broken rice
pertaining to the respondent No.2 in favour of the Government.
2. Corrfiscation of 3O% of the rice and broken rice pertaining
to the petitioner to the Government and remainingTOoh of rice and
broken rice shall be released to the petitioner."
4.
Aggri,:ved by the above said order, the petitioner filed
Criminal Appeal No.86 of 2008 before the learned Principal
Sessions Judge at Nalgonda, and the learned Sessions Judge
dismissed the appeal and conlirmed the orders passed by the
learned District Collector. Aggrieved by the same, the present
Criminal Revision Case has been filed.
5.
Heard Mr.Naren Rudra, learned counsel, representing
Mr.Harender Prasad, learned counsel for the petitioner and
Mr.M.Vive<ananda Reddy, learned Assistant Public Prosecutor.
I
6.
Learned counsel for the petitioner submitted that the issue
raised in this criminal revision case is squarely covered by the
order pasrsed by the erstwhile High Court of Andhra Pradesh at
t
Hyderabad in Sri Sai Traders and another v. The Assistant
Supply Officer, Circle I, Viiayawada and othersr.
T.
Learned Assistant Public Prosecutor has not opposed the
submission made by the learned counsel for petitioner.
g.
Taking into consideration the submissions made by the
respective parties and in view of the principle laid down by the
erstwhile High Court of Andhra Pradesh in Sri Sai Traders
(supral, the impugned judgment passed by the learned Principal
Sessions Judge, Nalgonda in Criminal Appeal No.86 of 2OO8,
confirming the order passed by the District Collector, Nalgonda, in
cape No.CS I /t852/2007, dated 14.05.2008, is hereby set aside.
9.
Accordingly, Criminal Revision Case is allou'ed.
Miscellaneous applications, pending if any, shall stand
closed.
SD/- N.CHANDRA SEKHAR RAO
DEPUTY REGISTRAR
LGuob) + AUP 1 ,)6
//TRUE COPY//
SECTION OFFICER
To
i
E
'1. The Principal Sessions Judge at Nalgonda
2. The District Collector, Nalgonda District
3. Two CCs to the Public Prosecutor, High Court for the State of Telangana at
HYderabad (OUT)
4. One CC to SRI HARENDER PRASAD, Advocate [OPUC]
5. Two CD Copies
ADK/PSL
Along with a copy of order dated 22-06-2006 in WP.Nos.4797 and I1572 of 2006-
l
HIGH COTJRT
DATED i 1UAZI2026
1 tiE
r)
'!t
ORDER
GRLRC.|No.2307 of 2010
ALLOVVING THE CRLRC
*
!\,R
/1.l?fi
t
THE HON'BLE SRI JUSTICE C.V.'RAMULU
+ W.P.Nos.4797 and 11572 of 2006
%Dated 22-6'2006
W.P.No.4797 OF 2006
# Between
M/s. Sri SaiTraders, rep.by its Proprietor
Smt.Duddu Bata Tripura Sundari & another " ' Petitioners
And
The Assistant SuPPIY Officer,
Circle-|, Viiayawada Krishna Distrct & another "'
lOounsel lor the Petitioners: SHBI V'H'V'R'R'
^Counsel for Respondents:
<GIST
> HEAD NOTE:
Respondents
SWAMY
G'P' FOR CIVIL SUPPLIES
Y\ '\
THE HON'BLE SRIJUSTICE C.V. RAMULU
Thursday. 22lrd June. 2006
W.P.Nos.4797 and 11572 of 2006
W.P.No.4797 of 20108
Between
[//S. S]i Sai Trader,:, rep.by its Proprietor
Smt.Duddu Bala Tripura Sundari & another... petitioners
And
The Assistant Suppty Officer,
Circle-|, Vilayawada Krishna Distrct & another ... Respondents
ffi
.I-HE
HON'BLE SRIJUSTICE C.V. RAMULU
W.P.Nos.4797 and 11572 of 2006
COMMON ORDERI
ln these two Wril Petitions, common questions of fact and law arise for
consideration;thererfore, they are being disposed of by this common Order.
ln both these cases, the rice held by the petitioners was seized by conducting
panchanamas on the allegation that the said rice is meant for Public Distribution
System (PDS) anrl it was black marketed; therefore, invoked the provisions of
Section 6A of the Essential Commodities Act,1955 (for short'the Act').The Writ
Petitions are filed saeking to declare the action of the respondents in seizing the rice
and initiating the prcceedings under Section 6A of the Act as arbitrary and illegal.
Detailed counter alfidavits have been filed by respondents 1 and 4 in W.P.No.4797
of 2006 denying the allegations made by the petitioners and suppoding the
impugned action of the respondents.
Heard both sides.
Admittedly, the rice was taken out of the Essential Comrnodities Acf by way of an
Order passed by the tr/inistry of Consumer Affairs, Food and Public Distribution,
Government of lnrlia, New Delhi in G.S.R.104(E), dated 15'2-2002, is'sued in
exercise of the powers conferred by Section 3 of the Act. However, the learned
Government Pleader submitted that nothing in the said Order dated 15-2-2002 shall
affecl the operation ol the Public Distribution System (Controt) &der, 20O1 issued by
the Central Government and Orders of the State Government issued in pursuance
thereof. Thus, according to the learned Govemment Pleader, the rice is though taken
I
t
:,
1E.., .
rc*;,
Efuts::,':
from the list of essential comrnodities, but the rice distributed under Public
Distribution System has not been exempted from the application of the Act. Clause 6
of the said Order reads as under:
"6. Nothing contained in this Order shall affect the operation of the Public
Distribution System (Control) Order,2001 issued by the Central Government and
'
orders of the State Governments issued in pu.rsuance thereof.n
Whereas, learned counsel for petitioners strenuously contended that once the rice is
taken out of the Act, the only course left over lor the respondents is to invoke either
criminal proceedings or any other provision of law applicable in this regard. lt is also
their contention that in pursuance of the Central Govemment's Order dated '15-2-
2002, Government ol Andhra Pradesh issued a Governmental Order in
G.O.Ms.No.79, dated 29-6-2005 rescinding the Andhra Pradesh Paddy and Rice
(Requisitioning of Stocks) Order,1966.Therefore, absolutely, there is no restriction
on movement of rice in the State of Andhra Pradesh. ln fact, the notification issued
under Section 3 of the Act, rescinding the Andhra Pradesh Paddy and Rice
(Requisitioning of Stocks) Order,19ffi issued in G.O.MsNo.2721, Food ard
Agriculture (CS.|V) Department, dated 29-6-1966, is subject to the following
conditions:
"Provided that such rescission shall not affect:4,.
the previous operation of the said order on anything duly done or
suffered thereunder;
b.
by any right, privilege, obligation or liability acquired, accrued or
incurred under the said order;or
c.
any penahy, forfeiture or punishment incurred in respect of any offence
committed against the said order; and
d.
any investigation, legal proceeding or remedy in res@t of any such
rigfit, privitege, obtigation, tiabiltty, penatty, {orleiture or gmishment
as aforesaid, and any such investigation, legal proceeding, on
remedy may be instituted, continued or enforced any such
penalty, forfeiture or punishment may be imposed as if the
relevant said order has not been rescinded."
From a reading of the above, it would indicate that absolutely there is no restriction
on movement ol rice in the State of Andhra Pradesh and the authorities were
supposed to take action against those cases of violation under the Andhra Pradesh
Paddy and Rice (Requisitioning of Stocts) Or:der,1966, but not by invoking the
provisions ol Section 64 of the Act. Admittedly, in these two cases, the seizure was
effected after 29-6-2005 i.e. much after rescinding the Andhra Pradesh Paddy and
Rice (Requisitioning of Stocks) Order,1966. Therefore, there is no scope for invoking
Section 6A of the Act against the seized goods of the petitioners. Whereas, learned
counsel for the petitioners contended that Clause 6 ol the Central Govemmenfs
Order dated 15-2-2:002 must be interpreted strictly to carry out the object of
amendment. Further, tre Commissioner of Civil Supplies issued a clarification in this
regard by his Proceedings dated 12-8-2A02,which reads as under:
'With r,sference to letter cited, it is clarified that rice millers who indulge in
purchase of rice like Food For Work rice, aclion has to be laken under Criminal
Procedure Corle as there is no licensing system.
ln so firr as the Fair Price Shop Deaters are concerned, they are governed
by the conditions of the authorization issued under the Andhra Pradesh State PDS
Control Order,2001."
According to the pel.itioners, even assuming tl"lat they have purchased or have cOme
into possession of rice meant for'Food For Work' or'pubtic distribution system'the
only action to be tirken in ttris regqrd is to initiate criminal proceedings. Leamed
Government Pleader stated that the above clarification dated 12-B-20O2 at the most
exempts the 'Food For Work' rice from invoking the provisions of Section 6A of the
Act; but, insofar as fair price shop dealers are concerned, they are governed by the
condittons of authorization issued under the A.P. State Fublic Distrihrtton System
Control Order,2001 . Assuming that the Fair Price Shop dealers are governed by the
conditions of authorization; but, in these cases, the petitioners are not fair price shop
dealers. Therefore, it has to be seen whether under the A.P. State Public Distribution
System Control Order,2001 any action can be taken against the petitioners by
invoking the provis,ons of Section 6A of tre Act or any other provisions of the said
Act dealing wih such contingencies. Learned Government Pleader submitted that
sub-clauses (16) and (20) of Clause 2 of the A.P. State Public Distribution System
Control Order,2001 defines 'scheduled commodity' and 'public distribution system'
as under:
"(16) 'sctreduled Commodity' means any commodity specified in the
schedule to the Order, which is supplied by the State Government or to any
authorized fair price shop or establishment for issue to the Consumers.
(20) 'Public Distributbn System' means th€ system ,or distribution ol
essential commodities 10 the ration card holders through the fair price shops, such
as rice, wheat, sugar, edible oils, kerosene and such other commodities as ar€
notitied by the Central Government under clause (a) of Section 2 ol the Act.'
Further, Clause 16 of the said fuer contemplates power to enter premises, inspect,
search and seize stocks ol essential commodities, ask questions, require production
of doc{ments eb. The said Clause reads as under:
"16. Power to enter Premisas, lnspect, Searcfi and seize stocks of
Schsduled Commodit'Es, Ask questions requlre Productlon ot Dodments'
etc.,:.
(i) Any Ofiicsr or person aulhorized by the Government or by thg
Collector or by the appointing Authority or any Officer ol the Revenue
lnspector/Checking lnspector/Food lnspector (Civil Supplie6), Dy.Tahsildar
(Civil SuppliesyDy.Tahsildar (Revenue) or any Gazetted Olficer ol Vigilance and
Enforcement Oeparlment, Andhra Pradesh, Hyderabad, may at all reasonaHe
times inspect any stocks of scheduled commodities, supdy documents or
books, accounts or other documsnts pertaining to dealirE in scheduled
commodities and may lor the purpose ol such insPctions. ln case ot
weighment of Scheduled commodities, the Assistant Legal Metrology Oflicer
appointed by the Weighs and Measures Department is also competent to
inspect the Fair Price Shop premises
a.
enler the premises of any establishment or shop provkled that in
exercising the pof,er ol entry, due regard shall be pall by such
olfrcer or person to the social and reli(.lious customs o, the
occupants ol the premises.
b.
to summon and enquire any person with the relevant and necessary
queslions.
c
require the production ol any document and take or cause to be taken
extracts from or copies ol such documents: and
d.
take or cause to be taken the weight or me.$ure of th€ schedulsd
commodities found in the premises.
(ii) Every person when so required by such officer or person under suF
chuse (i) shall allow access to premises' answer all questbns to lhe best of his
knowledge and beliel, produce the documents in his possession and allow extracb
from or copies of any scheduled commodities found in the premises, to be taken'
(iii) Such Otficer, may in the course of such inspection search lor ard seize
any commodit/ in respect of which he has reasons to betieve that any provision
mada by his order has begn or is being contravened.
(iv) The provisions of Section 100 of the Code o, Criminat procedure,1g73
relating to search and seizure shall so far as may b€, apply to search and seizure
under this Order."
Ric€, ot c,ourse, is one of the scteduled cornmodities, though not an essential
commodity, under tre Control Orders. Clause i 6 of the said Order contemplates that
an Oflicer not belov, the rank of a Revenue lnspector may at all reasonable times
inspect any slocks cf scheduled commodities and the concerned person, may lor he
purpose of such inspection, supply documents or books, accounts or olher
documents pertaining to dealing in scheduled commodilies and. Further, when the
Officer so requires, such person under sub-clause (i) shall allow access to the
premises, answer a I questions to the best ol his knowledge and beliel, produce tre
documents in his possession and allow extracb from or copies of any scheduled
commodities found in the premises, to be taken. Such Officer may, in the course of
suct inspection, search for and seize any commodity in respect of which he has
reason to believe that any provision made by this Order has been violated or is
contravened and the pmvisions of Section 100 Cr.p.C. relating to search and
seizure shall be ap,tlicable to search and seizure under this Order. ln the entire the
A.P. State Public l)istibution System Control Order,2ool, a contingency of this
nalure is not contemptated. However, learned Governmenl pleader submitted that
enter the premises ,)f any establishment or shop as provicted under Clause 16 ol the
Control Order,200l means even the premises ol tha petition€rs and seizing stocks.
Learned Govemment Pleader has advanced yet another argument saying that since
clause 6 of the C{)ntrat Government's Order dated 1S-2-2O02 states that nothing
contained in that order shall affect the public Distribution system rice and the very
Order i.e. A.P. State Public Disribution System Control Order,2ool is made under
section 3 of the Ac1, il must be deemed that the loodgrains seized by the respondenl
authorities are es3ential commodities; therefore, the authorities are correct in
invoking the provisions of Section 6A of the Act.
I am of the c,)nsidered opinion that the purpose ol Clause 6 of the Order dated
,/-
-; 15-2-2002 is thal the Slale Government may have cohlrol over the rice required lor
public distribulion system as contemplated under Public Distribution System
(Control) *der2001 ard nothing more fian that. 8y Order dated 15-2-2002, in lacl.,
the rice has been taken out ol the Control Order as an essential commodity. ln he
entre Control Order,2001, there is no conlingency visualized of this nature.
Therelore, the Commissioner of Civit Supplies through his Proceedings dated 12-82002 as noliced above, has righfly clarified that against rice millers, who indulge in
purchase o, rice like 'food for work' rice, cnminal action has to be taken, as there is
no licensing system, lnsofar as fair price shop dealers are concerned, they are
governed by the conditions of authorization issued under the A.P. State Public
Distribution system conrol order,2001 .
According b the respondents, it is the public distribution system rice, which is
found to be lransported and/or in the possession of the peti{on€rs; therefor€, they
are at liberty to invoke the cdminal proceedings even against public distdbulion
system rice when il is diverted elsewhere with the connivance of the fair price shop
dealers. But that ibelf does not permit the respondents to invoke the provisions of
the Essential Commodities Act. As per Clause l6 of the Control Order,2001 rice is
only a scheduled commodity, but not an essenlial commodity to invoke the
provisions of the Act. Therelore, the impugned action of the respondenb in invoking
the provisions ol Section 6A o{ the Acl and seizing the rice of the petitioners is
wilhout any authority of law and as such, insofar as invoking the provisions of
Seclion 6A of the Act is concerned, it is arbitrary and illegal. May be, seizure is
iustilied since pr'ma ,acie it is the contention ol lhe respondents that lhe rice seized
is meant for public distribulion system and it cannot be permitted to do away with the
welfare scheme meant for the card holders. As such, the auftorities are directed to
take appropriate action as per law.
For all he above reasons, he Writ Petitions are allowed holding that he
respondents have no power to initiate proceedings under Section 6A of he Act
insofar as the stocks of rice seized lrom the possession of the pelitioners is
concemed. No order as to cosls.
22-6-2006
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review