Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
2024:MLHC:1109
Serial No.09
Regular List
HIGH COURT OF MEGHALAYA
AT SHILLONG
Crl. Petn.No. 106 of 2023
Shri. Nagen Chandra Boro Vs.
S/o Late Mislu Ram Boro
R/o Fatashil ambari,
Brindaban path, Pin-781025
P.S- FatashilAmbari, Guwahati781025, Assam.
Date of Hearing : 03.12.2024
Date of Decision: 03.12.2024
1.State of Meghalaya represented
by the Secretary, Government of
Meghalaya, Home (Police)
Department, East Khasi Hills
District, Meghalaya.
2. The Executive Engineer,
Guwahati Central Division,
Central Public Works Department
C.P.W.D, Mamunimaidam,
Guwahati -781021, Assam.
3. The Assistant Engineer, Tura
Central Sub-Division 1, Central
Public Works Department CPWD,
Tura, Meghalaya.
4. The Area General Manager
(Civil) Food Corporation of
India (FCI), Lumjingshai Rd,
Mawlai Nongmali, Shillong,
793008, Meghalaya.
5. The Manager, Food Corporation
of India (FCI), West Garo Hills,
Tura, Meghalaya.
2024:MLHC:1109
6. The Deputy Commissioner,
West Garo Hills, NH51, Akonggre,
Tura, 794001, Meghalaya.
7. Dr.(Mrs) Elsie Mathew N.Sangma
D/o Mrs. Regina N. Sangma,
R/o Nazing Bazar, West Garo Hills,
Tura, 794001, Meghalaya.
::::PETITIONER.
::::RESPONDENTS.
Coram:
Hon’ble Mr. Justice B. Bhattacharjee, Judge
Appearance:
For the Petitioner(s)
:
Mr. M. Smith, Adv.
For the Respondent(s)
:
Mr. S. A. Sheikh, GA. (R: 1 & 6).
Dr. N. Mozika, Sr. Adv. with
Ms. L.M.D. Marak, Adv.(R: 2 & 3)
Mr. M. K. Das, Adv. (R: 7).
None for (R: 4 & 5).
(JUDGMENT & ORDER)
This is an application under Section 482 Cr.P.C. seeking quashing of FIR
dated 21-07-2020 lodged by the respondent No. 7 before the Officer-inCharge of New Tura Police Station registered as Tura PS case No. 99
(07)
(G.R.
No.
of
2020)
under
Section
290/206/427/432/406/34 IPC and the charge-sheet No. 43/2023 under
Section 290/206/427/432/406 dated 25-09-2023 which was submitted
2024:MLHC:1109
during the course of the pendency of this petition and brought into record
by an additional affidavit dated 29-04-2024.
1.
Heard Mr. M. Smith, learned Counsel appearing for the petitioner
also Mr. S. A. Sheikh, learned GA appearing for the State-respondents
No. 1 & 6, Dr. N. Mozika, learned Senior Counsel assisted by Ms.
L.M.D. Marak, learned Counsel appearing for the respondents No. 2 & 3
and Mr. M. K. Das, learned Counsel appearing for the respondent No.7.
None appeared for the respondents No.4 & 5.
2.
The fact leading to the filing of the present case is that an FIR
dated 21-07-2020 was lodged before the Officer-in-Charge of New Tura
Police Station, Tura by the respondent No.7 alleging that a large-scale
construction work was being carried out in the rear portion of the Food
Corporation of India (FCI) Godown in Tura, involving mass mud filling
along with inferior construction of RCC retaining boundary wall carried
out by the Contractor, Engineer, Supervisor and the concerned Manager
of FCI under the protection of the implementing agency just above the
land of the respondent No.7 without any water outlet resulting in the
direct flow of rain water along with mud, sludge and filth into her
compound causing huge loss and damages to her property. On the basis
of the said FIR, the Tura PS case No. 99 (07) 2020 (G.R. No. 146 of
2020) under Section 290/206/427/432/406/34 IPC was registered and the
matter was investigated into. The petitioner filed this instant criminal
petition before this Court on 21-09-2023 seeking quashing of the
aforesaid FIR and the police case, however, a charge-sheet in the matter
was submitted on 25-09-2023 by the investigating authority which was
2024:MLHC:1109
brought into record of this Court by the petitioner vide additional
affidavit dated 29-04-2024.
3.
Mr. M. Smith, learned Counsel for the petitioner submitted that
the petitioner was neither the Engineer nor the Contractor appointed by
the respondent No.2 to execute any work on behalf of the department.
He submitted that the work for construction of storage Godown of 2500
MT capacity for FCI at Tura was allotted to one M/s. Shrolenson
Marbaniang, a registered Class I contractor firm, by the respondent No.2.
The said firm had authorised the petitioner, who was an employee of the
firm, to represent the firm relating to any kind of correspondence with
the department in executing the said work.
The learned Counsel
submitted that during the pendency of the said work, due to incessant
rainfall in the region, the retaining wall of the FCI Godown complex was
gradually sliding for which the respondent No.7 had raised an alarm and
the issue was taken up by the FCI authorities. An emergent meeting was
held on 13-07-2019 at the FCI Depot, Tura wherein several
recommendations were made for taking preventive measures in order to
avoid severe calamities. The learned Counsel further submitted that an
independent Technical Committee, which was constituted to look after
and assess the situation, vide its detailed report dated 20-04-2020 had
clearly stated that the sliding of the wall was caused due to incessant
rainfall and not because of fault or wrongdoing of any person. The
learned Counsel submitted that inspite of several difficulties the allotted
work was completed by taking into consideration the several
rectifications and safety measures recommended by the concerned
authorities from time to time. The learned Counsel submitted that the
construction work was completed on 12-02-2022 to the satisfaction of
2024:MLHC:1109
the concerned authority and payment for all the bills for the work has
been cleared by the department.
4.
It is further submitted by the learned Counsel for the petitioner
that there is no allegation of commission of any technical fault or illegal
omission on the part of the petitioner in the construction work resulting
in sliding of the retaining wall and as no case was made out in the FIR, a
final report No.240/22 dated 13-10-2022 was submitted by the
investigating authority before the Court of the Chief Judicial Magistrate,
Tura seeking discharge of one Shri. Jiten Gogai, who was an accused in
Tura PS Case No. 99 (07) 2020.
However, the respondent No.7 had
filed a protest petition against the said final report which was accepted
by the Court and by order dated 21-03-2023, a direction was made to the
Officer-in-Charge, Tura PS, to conduct further investigation in the case.
The learned Counsel submitted that it is only because of the order dated
21-03-2023, the investigating officer has submitted the impugned
charge-sheet No.43 of 2022 dated 25-09-2023 against the petitioner
without making any specific allegation against the petitioner.
The
learned Counsel submitted that even if the allegations made in the FIR
and the charge-sheet are accepted, no case is made out against the
petitioner and, hence, the petitioner cannot be made to face the trial. He
submitted that it would be an abuse of process of law if any trial is
allowed to proceed against the petitioner on the basis of the impugned
FIR and the charge-sheet and prayed for quashing of the entire
proceeding in connection with the Tura PS Case No. 99 (07) 2020.
5.
Mr. S. A. Sheikh, learned GA appearing for the State-respondents
No. 1 & 6, in his response, has drawn attention of this Court to the
charge-sheet and submitted that the petitioner has admitted to have taken
2024:MLHC:1109
care and supervised all the works of construction of storage Godown of
2500MT capacity of FCI, Tura. However, the learned GA has fairly
submitted that he has nothing more to add to what has been stated in the
charge-sheet.
6.
Dr. N. Mozika, learned Senior Counsel for the respondents No. 2
& 3 submitted that the contents of the FIR or the charge-sheet do not
make out a case for criminal prosecution. He submitted that the
allegations made by the respondent No.7, if accepted, may constitute a
case for seeking remedy under law of torts, but no criminal offence is
disclosed in the present case.
7.
Mr. M. K. Das, learned Counsel appearing for the respondent No.7
has vehemently opposed the submission made on behalf of the petitioner
and submitted that a case for criminal proceeding against the petitioner
has been clearly made out in the FIR and the charge-sheet. The learned
Counsel submitted that the allotment of the work for construction of FCI
Godown was made by the concerned department in the year 2012 and
since the year 2015 the respondent No.7 has raised her objection against
the construction work on the ground of public nuisance, apprehension of
danger and damages. The learned Counsel submitted that on 20-03-2015
and 12-07-2019, complaints were filed at the police station pertaining to
the mode and manner of the construction.
The then Deputy
Commissioner took cognizance of the matter and by letter dated 31-032015 had asked the contractor to sign a social agreement with the
complainant to take measures that rights of citizens are not affected. He
submitted that in spite of the said letter, the construction work was not
stopped and proceeded in a hazardous situation with danger of causing
loss of human life and damage to the property of the respondent No.7.
2024:MLHC:1109
By referring to the letter dated 12-07-2019, he submitted that the issue
was taken up again by the Deputy Commissioner who had visited the
place and assured to make good all damages and losses caused due to
unlawful construction at the FCI Godown, however, nothing was done.
The learned Counsel, relying on the averments made in the present
petition has submitted that petitioner is responsible for the construction
which resulted in danger and caused damage to the property of the
respondent No.7. He further submitted that the allegation made in the
FIR
disclosed
the
commission
of
offence
under
Section
290/206/427/432/406 IPC against all the persons who were responsible
for implementing and supervising the construction work. In support of
his argument, the learned Counsel has placed reliance on a decision of
the Apex Court reported in (2023) 4 SCC 338, State Versus M. Maridoss
and Another (paras 7 & 8) and submitted that the courts should not
thwart any investigation or criminal proceeding at the initial stage and no
interference should be made in judicial process, save in exceptional
cases, where non-interference would result in miscarriage of justice. He
contended that in the present matter, the FIR disclosed commission of
cognizable offence and the High Court is not required to conduct the
mini trial to determine merits of the allegation. According to the learned
counsel, the construction is yet to be concluded and debris are still lying
in the compound of the respondent No.7. The learned counsel submitted
that no case has been made out by the petitioner calling for any
interference at this stage and the criminal petition is liable to be
dismissed.
8.
The submissions made by the rival parties are duly noted by this
Court and also perused the materials on record.
2024:MLHC:1109
9.
There is no dispute to the fact that the petitioner was neither the
appointed contractor nor the supervising authority of the construction of
the storage Godown of 2500MT capacity for FCI, Tura. The contract for
construction of the said storage Godown was awarded to one Shri
Shrolenson Marbaniang who has not been made an accused in the matter.
The FIR dated 21-07-2020 also did not name the petitioner and no
specific allegation has been levelled against him. It appears from the
materials on record that the work was allotted in the year 2012 and the
same proceeded for a considerable period of time despite the objections
raised by the respondent No.7. There also exist two communications
dated 31-03-2015 and 19-07-2020, which are made parts of the FIR, by
the Deputy Commissioner concerning the boundary wall of the FCI
Godown, Tura, calling for early necessary action in the matter. Despite
the aforesaid communications, there is nothing on record to show that
the work of construction of the FCI Godown was ever sought to be
stopped by issuing necessary order to the concerned authority including
the petitioner. It is also not the case of the respondent No.7 that the
petitioner had carried on with the construction work in violation of the
prescribed norms and safety measures issued from time to time by the
Deputy Commissioner or any other administrative authority.
10. Perusal of materials on record reveals that a final report No.
240/22 dated 13-10-2022 was filed by the Investigating Officer (IO) in
connection with the Tura PS Case No. 99 (07) 2020 with a prayer for
discharging one Shri. Jiten Gogai, who was an accused in the matter.
The respondent No.7 had filed a protest petition against the final report
submitted by the IO and the learned Chief Judicial Magistrate vide order
dated 21-03-2023 did not accept the final report and directed the OfficerPage 8 of 11
2024:MLHC:1109
in-Charge, Tura PS to conduct further investigation in the matter. It is
only after the said order, the charge-sheet No.43/2023 dated 25-09-2023
was submitted by making the petitioner the sole-accused in the case.
There is no information available as to what happened to Shri. Jiten
Gogai, who was the original accused in the matter. The materials on
record does not reveal the reason for replacing Shri. Jiten Gogai by the
petitioner as the accused in the case.
11. The charge-sheet No.43/2023 dated 25-09-2023 does not speak of
commission of any offence by the petitioner. The relevant part of the
charge-sheet is extracted below: “During further course of investigation Shri. Nagen
Chandra Boro, s/o Lt. Mislu Ram Boro, permanent
residence of Brindaban Path, P.O/P.S: Fatasil Ambari,
Kamrup District, Assam appear at the Araimile P.S on
behalf of contractor Shri. Shrolenson Marbaniang on being
granted interim bail from the Hon’ble Court of Special
Judge, West Garo Hills Tura. He was arrested and released
on bail bond on being produced of 2 (two) sureties as per
the order passed by the Court of Special Judge, Tura. He
was examine and revealed that, he have taken care and
supervised all the works, construction of storage Godown
of 2500 MT capacity for FCI, Tura Nazing Bazar including
the construction of boundary retaining wall. Work order for
the construction was received on December 2012 and the
construction of works was started on next year 2013. In
between from 2 to 3 years have been gap and construction
awaited due to non- released of funds. The construction
have been completed and all the pending bills have been
already released on last year 2022. Further, he produces
the authorization letter for work construction of storage
Godown of 2500 MT capacity for FCI, Tura location,
Meghalaya to present him and act on behalf of proprietor
M/s Shrolenson Marbaniang relating to any kinds of
correspondence with the department, receiving instruction
from department, collection and receiving of letters, bills
2024:MLHC:1109
and cheques from the department addressing to the
Executive Engineer, Guwahati Central Division CPWD,
Bamunimaidan, Guwahati, Assam.”
The above part of the charge-sheet does not project any wrongdoings or
commission of offense on the part of the petitioner. Moreover, in the
entire charge-sheet, there is no details of any damage caused to the
property of the respondent No.7.
12.
It is also important to notice that although the respondent No.7 has
alleged damage and loss to her property caused by the construction work
of the Godown of FCI right from the year 2015 and an FIR to that effect
was lodged on 21-07-2020, it is clear from the materials on record that
the construction work for the Godown proceeded without any hindrance
from any authority including the investigating authority and was
completed on 12-02-2022. The progress of the construction work and its
completion even after the filing of the impugned FIR by the respondent
No.7 without any interference from any quarter would undoubtedly
indicate that no criminal offence was committed by the petitioner.
13. The case law cited by the learned Counsel for the respondent No.7
was in relation to an FIR which was lodged on 09-12-2022, the quashing
petition was filed on the very next date on 10-12-2021 and the order of
quashing of the proceeding was passed within four days i.e. on 14-122021. It is in the above situation; the Hon’ble Apex Court has held that
quashing of the proceeding without giving any reasonable time to the
investigating agency to investigate the allegation in the FIR was not
proper. The situation is in the present case is totally different as the
investigation has been completed.
The decision, as such, is not
applicable in the facts and situation of the present case.
2024:MLHC:1109
14.
In view of the discussions made above, the present criminal
petition succeeds. The impugned FIR dated 21-07-2020 and the chargesheet No. 43/2023 in Tura PS Case No. 99 (07) 2020 (G.R. No. 146 of
2020) under Section 290/206/427/432/406/34 IPC are set aside and
quashed.
JUDGE
Meghalaya
03.12.2024
“Biswarup-PS”
BHATTACHARJEE
Date: 2024.12.04 15:10:48 IST
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review