Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
-1-
"
!
%
&
#
#
"$
#
&
'
' (
)*
'
))
+
!"# # "
$
Digitally
signed by
SHIVALEELA
DATTATRAYA
UDAGI
Location:
HIGH COURT
OF
KARNATAKA
%
&
'
(
(
!)! '#
)
(
*!)!
#
$
%
(
&
'+
-2-
(
(
%,)
(
#"
' #
((
% &
# !&
# !%
(
(
!
!'% &
! )
&
%!&
(
",% &% &
* #
(
.
-,
(
''!
'!'
*
(
(
/
012 34515167 12 8194: ;7:4<
4=5167 ! ) 68
#
56 >;?20 504 3<6=44:17@2 ?@?1725 504 345151674< ?==;24:
6' #
#"
# !
# ! <4@1254<4: BC
68847=42 3;7120?B94 ;7:4<
%=&
!
?<1217@
06<?3;<
4=5167
3<424759C 347:17@ 67 504 8194 68
#
<42367:475
<42367:475
691=4
<1A4
5?5167 86< 504
4=5167 ",% &%A& ''!% & -,
!'% & <4?: D150
4221672 ;:@4 215517@ ?5
6;5
%!& 68
::15167?9
#
125<1=5 ?7:
06<?3;<
04 8?=5;?9 A?5<1E 68 504 =?24 12 50?5 504
96:@4:
=6A39?175
B486<4
6 ' * 3691=4 ?994@17@ 50?5 204 12 504 <421:475
-3-
4A?7;<; F199?@4
06<?3;<
?9;G ?7: 204 0?: #
=019:<47
74 C4?< 3<16< 56 504 17=1:475
?==;24:
6 ' 0?: 215;?54: 17 8<675 68 04< 06;24 ?5
4A?7;<;
F199?@4
?7:
;24:
504 06;24 68
F1215
04<
06;24
6==?2167?99C ?7: 4E3<4224: 50?5 04 8499 17 96F4 D150 04<
=6A39?17?75
<4H4=54:
3<6362?9
50<4?5474: 04< ?7: =67517;4: 56 F1215 04< 06;24
2566: 50;2 67 '- #,
017@2
# ! ?5 ?B6;5 #' ## 3 A D047 204
D?2 ?9674 17 04< 06;24 ?==;24:
6 ' 4754<4: 504 06;24
?7: =6AA1554: 86<=1B94 24E;?9 1754<=6;<24 67 04< ?7:
861254: 9184 50<4?5 56 04< 765 56 :12=9624 504 2?A4 56
?7C674
367 2;=0 50<4?5 67 504 2;B24>;475 :?C ?926 04
F12154: ?7: 0?: 24E;?9 ?=5 D150 04< ?7: 67=4 ?@?17 861254:
9184 50<4?5 56 04<
?54<
2?A4 56 04< 0;2B?7:
#) ## ? A
?==;24:
504 =6A39?17?75 1786<A4: 504
2 2;=0 67
#,
# ! ?5 ?B6;5
504 0;2B?7: 68 504 F1=51A F12154: 504 06;24 68
6 ' ?7: 47>;1<4: ?7: ?:F124: 01A 765 56 17:;9@4
17 2;=0 ?=5 ?7: 765 56 F1215 012 06;24 ?7: =?A4 B?=G
6D4F4<
67 504 2?A4 :?C ?5 ?B6;5 #
## ? A
-4-
?==;24:
6 ' ?7: 504 345151674< 1 4 ?==;24:
=?A4 56
504 06;24 68 =6A39?17?75 * F1=51A ?7: ?B;24: 04< ?7: 04<
0;2B?7: 17 81950C 9?7@;?@4 ?7: ?926 6;5<?@4: 04< A6:425C
2 2;=0 67
=6A39?175
! #,
?@?1725
<42367:475
=6A39?175
6' #
# ! 504 <42367:475
?==;24:
62 '
691=4
B4
<4@1254<4:
6' *
(
=?A4
?7:
96:@4: 504
B486<4
25<47@50
68 2?1:
<1A4
# ! 86< 504 ?86<4A4751674: 68847=42 ?@?1725 504
345151674< ?7: ?76504<
;B24>;4759C <42367:475
6' *
3691=4 ?854< =67:;=517@ ?7 17F4251@?5167 9?1: =0?<@4*20445
?@?1725 504 345151674< ?7: ?76504< 86< 504 ?86<4A4751674:
68847=42 BC ?<<?C17@ 504 345151674< ?2 ?==;24:
67 504 <4=4135 68 504 =0?<@4*20445 504 94?<74:
?@125<?54
566G =6@71I?7=4 68 504 68847=42
345151674<
3<484<<4:
?7:
@@<14F4: BC 504 2?A4
34515167
>;?20
3<6=44:17@2 ?@?1725 01A
#
4?<: 504 94?<74: =6;7249 86< 504 345151674< 26
?926 504 94?<74:
1@0
6;<5
6F4<7A475
94?:4< 86<
-5-
<42367:475
6 '* 5?54
<42367:475
#,
423154
24<F1=4
7651=4
204 <4A?174: ?B2475
3?<5 8<6A ;<@17@ 24F4<?9 =6754751672 94?<74:
=6;7249 86< 504 345151674< 3<1A?<19C =6754754: 50?5 504
345151674< * ?==;24:
D?2 741504< 3?<51=13?54: 17 504
17=1:475 76< 3<42475 ?5 504 2=474 68 6==;<<47=4 ?2 67
#,
# ! ?2 ?994@4: 17 504 =6A39?175
504 345151674< D?2 ?5
6*6<:17?56< 68
47@?9;<; 217=4 04 12 D6<G17@ ?2 ?
?205<650?7?
?<120?: ?5
2;B25?751?54 504 2?1: ?234=5 204 39?=4:
=4<5181=?54
?205650?7?
==6<:17@ 56 04<
122;4:
BC
?<120?:
?5547:?7=4
30656@<?302 ?7: 504
47@?9;<;
774E;<4*
6*6<:17?56<
<4@1254<
8665?@42 ?967@ D150 504 347
:<1F4
C 39?=17@ <491?7=4 67 504 2?A4 204 2;BA152 50?5 ?
8?924
=6A39?175
0?2
B447
345151674< ?==;24:
:;4
861254:
369151=?9
F47@4?7=4 217=4 04 12 ?88191?54: D150
?@?1725
<1F?9<C
?7:
0?<?51C?
?7?5?
?<5C ?7: 67 6504< 0?7: 504 =6A39?17?75 12 504 D6<G4< 68
-6-
?5167?9
67@<422
?<5C
==6<:17@9C 204 3<?C2 56 ?996D
504 34515167
#!
94?<74:
1@0
6;<5
6F4<7A475
94?:4< F404A4759C 633624: 504 34515167 ?7: 2;BA1554:
50?5 3<424759C =0?<@4*20445 0?2 B447 8194: ?7:
'# ?<4 504 4C4D157422 56 504 17=1:475
- 56
04C 0?F4 =94?<9C
25?54: 504 3<4247=4 68 5012 345151674< 67 504 ?994@4: 2365
68 17=1:475 67
#,
# ! ?7: 504
?<4 39?=4: ?@?1725 5012 345151674<
A?54<1?92
==6<:17@9C
3<?C2 56
:12A122 504 34515167
#"
0?F4 @1F47 AC ?7E16;2 =6721:4<?5167 B650 67
504 2;BA122167 A?:4 BC 504 94?<74: =6;7249 86< 504
<4234=51F4 3?<5142 ?7: ?926 34<;24: 504 =0?<@4*20445
A?54<1?92
#-
2 =6;9: B4 2447 8<6A 504 =6A39?175
3<1A?<C ?994@?5167 A?:4 ?@?1725 ?==;24:
6 ' 50?5 04
=6AA1554: 24E;?9 1754<=6;<24 D150 504 F1=51A*=6A39?17?75
67 24F4<?9 6==?21672 BC 8612517@ 9184 50<4?5 56 04< 217=4
-7-
012 06;24 12 215;?54: 17 8<675 68 04< 06;24
04<4?854< 504
2?1: 17=1:475 D?2 1786<A4: BC 504 F1=51A 56 04< 0;2B?7:
2 2;=0 04< 0;2B?7: >;4251674: 504 2?A4 D150 ?==;24:
6'
04<4?854< ?==;24:
6 ' ?967@ D150 5012 345151674<
F12154: 504 06;24 ?7: A?70?7:94: 504 F1=51A ?7: 04<
0;2B?7: BC ?B;217@ 504A 17 81950C 9?7@;?@4
504 25?54A475 68
2 - 56
7 34<;2?9 68
'# D06 ?<4 =9?1A2 56 B4
4C4D15742242 56 504 17=1:475
3?<51=13?54: 17 504 17=1:475
5012 345151674< 0?: ?926
6D4F4< 94?<74: =6;7249 86<
504 345151674< 39?=4: =4<5181=?54 122;4: BC 674 6@420 504
6*6<:17?56< 68
#, #
?205<650?7?
?<120?: ?5
?7@?96<4 :?54:
# ! D01=0 <4F4?92 50?5 504 345151674< B417@ 504
6*6<:17?56< D6<G17@ 17 504 2?1:
?<120?: D?2 3<42475 ?5
?7@?96<4
8<6A
'- #,
# !
#,
# !
?5547:?7=4 <4@1254< ?926 :12=96242 50?5 504 345151674< D?2
17 504
?<120?: 67 50624 :?C2
8665?@42 :?54:
50?5
' #,
345151674<
?7@?96<4 67 50?5 :?C
# ! ?7:
D?2
?5
4F4<5049422
#,
# ! ?926 :431=52
?205<650?7?
?<120?:
04 3<4247=4 68 504 345151674< 17
-8-
8665?@42 ?<4 39?=4: ?967@ D150 504 347 :<1F4 ?7:
504 6504< :6=;A4752 ?<4 765 24<16;29C :123;54: BC 504
94?<74:
1@0
6;<5
6F4<7A475
94?:4<
7 =?<48;9 68
50424 :6=;A4752 15 12 6BF16;2 50?5 504 345151674< =?7765
B4 3<42475 ?5 5D6 39?=42 ?5 ? 51A4 1 4
#, # !
6<46F4< 504 ?994@?51672 A?:4 ?@?1725 504 345151674< ?<4
6A71B;2 ?994@?51672 4F47 17 504 =6A39?175 ?7: ?926 17 504
25?54A4752 68 ?994@4: 4C4D157422 56 504 17=1:475
25?54A475 68 504 ?994@4: 4C4D157422 <4=6<:4: ?854< 9?324
68 ! :?C2 8<6A 504 :?54 68 <4@125<?5167 68 (
504<4 12 ? :49?C 68
<42367:475
6==;<<4: 67 '- #,
! #,
# !
::15167?99C
:?C2 17 96:@17@ 504 =6A39?175 BC
==6<:17@ 56 04< 504 81<25 17=1:475 D?2
# ! ?7: 504 =6A39?175 D?2 96:@4: 67
7 2;=0 =1<=;A25?7=42 ? :6;B5 ?<1242 17 504
F4<2167 68 504 =6A39?17?75 ?7: ?926 17 504 25?54A4752 68
?994@4: 4C4D157422
#)
5 12 76D D499 245594: 50?5 =67517;?5167 68 504
=<1A17?9 3<6=44:17@2 ?@?1725 ?7C 34<267 67 504 B?212 68 ?
8<1F696;2 6< F4E?516;2 =6A39?175 12 26A45017@ F4<C 24<16;2
-9-
0?5 D6;9: 5?<7120 504 1A?@4 68 504 34<267 ?@?1725 D06A
8?924 8<1F696;2 ?7: F4E?516;2 ?994@?51672 ?<4 94F494:
67JB94
34E
6;<5 17 504 =?24 68
<436<54: 17
049: 50?5 D0474F4< ?7 ?==;24: =6A42 B486<4 504
17F6G17@ 41504< 504 1704<475 36D4<2 ;7:4<
<
6< 4E5<?6<:17?<C H;<12:1=5167 ;7:4<
=672515;5167
@45
(
6<
6;<5
4=5167 ,)
<51=94
" 68
=<1A17?9 3<6=44:17@2
>;?204: 4224751?99C 67 504 @<6;7: 50?5 2;=0 3<6=44:17@2
?<4 A?7184259C 8<1F696;2 6< F4E?516;2 6< 172515;54: D150 504
;954<16< A651F4 86< D<4?G17@ F47@4?7=4
=1<=;A25?7=4
6;<5 6D42 ? :;5C 56 966G 1756 504 (
=?<4 ?7: ? 915594 A6<4 =96249C
(
D150
5 D199 765 B4 H;25 476;@0 86<
6;<5 56 966G 1756 504 ?F4<A4752 A?:4 17 504
=6A39?175
D04504<
?9674
86<
3;<3624
?2=4<5?1717@
504 74=422?<C 17@<4:14752 56 =672515;54
?994@4: 68847=4 ?<4 :12=9624: 6< 765
5047 17 2;=0
7 504 6504< 0?7:
6;<5 6D42 ? :;5C 56 966G 1756 A?7C 6504< ?5547:17@
=1<=;A25?7=4 4A4<@17@ 8<6A 504 <4=6<: 68 504 =?24 6F4<
- 10 -
?7: ?B6F4 504 ?F4<A4752 ?7: 18 744: B4 D150 :;4 =?<4
?7: =1<=;A234=5167 5<C 56 <4?: 17 B45D447 504 91742
6;<5 D0194 4E4<=1217@ 152 H;<12:1=5167 ;7:4<
<
6<
<51=94
" 68
4=5167 ,)
672515;5167 744: 765 <425<1=5 152498
679C 56 504 25?@4 68 ? =?24 B;5 12 4A36D4<4: 56 5?G4 1756
?
=6;75
6F4<?99
=1<=;A25?7=42
94?:17@
17151?5167 <4@125<?5167 68 504 =?24 ?2 D499 ?2 504 A?54<1?92
=6994=54: 17 504 =6;<24 68 17F4251@?5167
#
339C17@ 504 2?1: 3<17=13942 56 504 8?=52 ?7:
=1<=;A25?7=42 68 504 =?24
50?5 504 (
?A 68 504 =6721:4<4: F14D
<4@1254<4: ?@?1725 504 345151674< ?==;24:
B?24: 67 504 =6A39?175 12 8<1F696;2
F4E?516;2 ?7: 504
2?A4 12 <4@1254<4: D150 ?7 ;954<16< A651F4
04 4751<4
?994@?5167 A?:4 17 504 =0?<@4 20445 A?54<1?92 67 152 8?=4
F?9;4 ?926 :642 765 =672515;54 ?7C 68847=42 17 504 =0?<@4
20445 ?@?1725 504 345151674<
F14D
47=4
17 AC =6721:4<4:
504 =67517;?5167 68 504 3<6=44:17@2 ?@?1725 504
345151674< ?==;24:
==6<:17@9C
12 ?B;24 68 3<6=422 68
3<6=44: 56 3?22 504 86996D17@
6;<5
- 11 -
%?&
04 34515167 12
%B&
3<6=44:17@2
345151674< ?==;24:
?<1217@ 6;5 68
BC 504
?@?1725
<1A4
6' #
06<?3;< 691=4
!
!'% &
#"
# ! <4@1254<4:
%!&
-,
(
''!
'!'
* #
04<4BC >;?204:
,*
'
#
)
#
'
# !
5?5167 86< 504 68847=4
3;7120?B94 ;7:4< ",% &%A&
% &
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review