Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
2025:MLHC:198
Serial No. 01
Regular List
HIGH COURT OF MEGHALAYA
AT SHILLONG
W.P.(Crl.) No. 5 of 2022
Date of Decision: 24.03.2025
Shri. Nabam Tai
S/o (L) H. Nagam Tagam
R/o Itanagar, Bapung, P.S. Daimukh
Dist. Daimukh, Arunachal Pradesh
..…Petitioner
–Versus–
1. The State of Meghalaya represented by the Secretary,
Political Department, Government of Meghalaya.
2. The Secretary to the Government of Meghalaya, Shillong.
3. The Home Secretary, Department of Jail and Prison,
Government of Meghalaya
4. The Director General of Police, Department of Jail and Prison,
Government of Meghalaya
5. The Inspector General of Prisons and Correctional Home,
Meghalaya, Shillong.
6. The Superintendent, District Prison and Correctional Home,
Shillong
..…Respondents
Coram:
Hon’ble Mr. Justice W. Diengdoh, Judge
Appearance:
For the Petitioner/Appellant(s) : Mr. B. Deb, Adv.
For the Respondent(s)
: Mr. N.D. Chullai, AAG with
Ms. R. Colney, GA
2025:MLHC:198
i)
Whether approved for reporting in
Law journals etc.:
ii)
Whether approved for publication
in press:
Yes/No
Yes/No
JUDGMENT
1.
The genesis of this instant petition preferred under Article 226 of
the Constitution of India read with Section 482 of the Code of Criminal
Procedure, 1973 dates back to the year 2005, to the effect that on
12.12.2005 at about 1:15 pm or so, some persons hired a Tourist Taxi,
bearing registration No. ML-05-D-5296 driven by Gaytam Gurung.
2.
Since the said Tourist Taxi did not return home, the owner
reported the matter to the President of the Shillong Greater Tourist Taxi
Association, who in turn lodged an FIR dated 15.12.2005 with the
Officer In-charge, Shillong Sadar Police Station. The same was
registered as Shillong Sadar P.S. Case No. 194(12) of 2005 under Section
382/302/201/34 IPC.
3.
On investigation launched, the petitioner herein along with four
other accused persons were arrested and eventually made to stand trial
for the offences under the IPC, including murder, that is, under Section
302 IPC.
4.
In course of trial, the learned Sessions Judge, Shillong has
examined a number of witnesses and brought on record certain material
exhibits produced by the prosecution and vide judgment and order dated
05.03.2008, had convicted the petitioner herein as well as one Jatin
Rabha for having committed the offence of murder and theft. Upon
2025:MLHC:198
conviction for the offences under Section 302, 382 and 201 IPC, they
were accordingly sentenced to undergo imprisonment for varying
periods and more specifically, to undergo imprisonment for life as regard
the offence under Section 302 IPC. However, all the sentences are to run
concurrently, reads the sentence. A fine of ₹ 1000/- was also imposed.
5.
It may also be pointed out that out of a total of five accused
persons, three of them, viz; Chandra Singh Chetri, Namgil Dorjee and
Rahul Pegoo were let off by the Trial Court on benefit of doubt given to
them.
6.
The petitioner has sought relief of remission of sentence,
primarily on the ground that he has completed more than 14 years of
imprisonment as provided under Section 432 read with Section 433A of
the Code of Criminal Procedure (Cr.P.C.) 1973. To this effect, an
application dated 14.08.2020 was filed by the petitioner with a prayer for
remission of his sentence. Again, on 05.12.2020 another application was
filed before the relevant authority through his brother Akil Tam. Since
there was no response to the said applications, the petitioner had filed
another application on 02.08.2021.
7.
Finding no answer to his petition dated 14.08.2020, the petitioner
sent a reminder dated 21.07.2022 to the concerned authority and the said
authority being unresponsive, the petitioner was compelled to approach
this Court by way of a writ petition being W.P.(Crl.) No. 4 of 2022 inter
alia, with a prayer for direction to the authorities to release the petitioner
by remitting the rest of his sentence.
8.
It was only in course of the proceedings of the said writ petition
2025:MLHC:198
before this Court that on the filing of the counter affidavit by the relevant
respondents, the petitioner came to know of the order dated 23.09.2022
passed by the Secretary to the Government of Meghalaya, Department of
Prisons & Correctional Services whereby his petition seeking remission
was rejected, the same being based on the opinion of the learned District
Judge, Shillong, who, vide opinion dated 14.07.2022 has opined that the
remission should not be considered as the manner in which the crime was
committed was brutal in nature and that the petitioner has the potential
to repeat the crime and secondly, that the crime was committed by a
syndicate who are still on the run.
9.
Thus being highly aggrieved and dissatisfied with the said opinion
dated 14.07.2022 and the effective order dated 23.09.2022, the petitioner
has now approached this Court with this instant petition with a prayer to
set aside and quash the same and to direct release of the petitioner by
remitting the rest of his sentence.
10.
Heard Mr. B. Deb learned counsel for the petitioner who has
submitted that firstly, the learned District Judge has failed to appreciate
the main ingredients required to be considered in a case of prayer for
remission of sentence, since nothing has been reflected in his opinion as
to the (i) antecedents of the petitioner (ii) his conduct in prison and (iii)
the likelihood of him committing a crime, if released.
11.
It is the submission of the learned counsel that the petitioner is
now in custody for about 19 years and during such time, there is no
complaint whatsoever as far as his character and conduct is concerned.
In fact, during his period of imprisonment, he has undergone a certificate
course in handicraft and candle making and was given a certificate by the
2025:MLHC:198
WISE Social Service Centre, St Mary’s Convent, Shillong in this respect.
He was also recognised in his efforts to help his fellow inmates in many
areas for which the Meghalaya State Legal Services Authority has also
recommended that he be appointed as one of the Para Legal Volunteers.
This was conveyed vide the relevant letter dated 18.08.2015. It is
noteworthy to say that he has also completed a course in theology and as
such, is well prepared to be reintegrated in society if granted remission
of sentence, further submits the learned counsel.
12.
What the learned District Judge has opined is only to the manner
in which the said crime was committed, that it was brutal in nature and
also that the crime was committed by a syndicate who is still on the run.
This, according to the learned counsel are not relevant factors to be
considered as admittedly, the petitioner has been convicted for the crime
committed. There is however, no evidence or materials on record to
indicate that there is a syndicate involved in the commitment of the
crime.
13.
The learned counsel has further submitted that the relevant
Government authority has failed to exercise its mind to the facts of the
case of prayer for remission by the petitioner and has simply relied on
the opinion of the learned District Judge that the petition of the petitioner
cannot be allowed since the crime was committed by a syndicate who is
still on the run.
14.
In support of his case, the learned counsel has cited the case of
Ram Chander v. State of Chattisgarh & Anr., reported in 2022 SCC
Online SC 500, particularly para 9(vi), (vii), (viii), (x), 12, 14, 15, 17, 18,
21 & 30.
2025:MLHC:198
15.
Mr. N.D. Chullai, learned AAG along with Ms. R. Colney, GA
appearing for the State respondent has opposed the prayer made in this
petition and has submitted that a perusal of the records pertaining to the
case of the petitioner would reveal that it is not a fit case for grant of
remission of sentence as far as the petitioner is concerned.
16.
The learned AAG has admitted that an application dated
14.08.2020 was indeed filed before the competent authority with a prayer
for remission of the rest of the sentence of the petitioner. On receipt of
such application, the opinion of the learned District Judge was sought for
and on his opinion dated 14.07.2022, the Secretary to the Government of
Meghalaya, Department of Prisons & Correctional Services vide
communication dated 23.09.2022 has passed the order rejecting the
prayer made by the petitioner.
17.
It is the submission of the learned AAG that the learned District
Judge has rightly given his opinion inasmuch as from the evidence on
record, it is seen that the victim who was brutally murdered by the
petitioner herein along with the other co-accused, Jatin Rabha was
committed in a manner which was indeed horrific. Further, the learned
District Judge has also observed that there is a syndicate at work when
the said murder was committed and the members of such syndicate are
on the run. This only indicates that if released on remission of sentence,
the petitioner most likely will repeat such kind of offences. Hence, the
opinion given is found acceptable and the resultant order of rejection of
the related application cannot be faulted, submits the learned AAG.
18.
In support of his case, the learned AAG has cited the case of Rajo
alias Rajwa alias Rajendra Mandal v. State of Bihar & Ors., reported in
2025:MLHC:198
2023 SCC Online SC 1068, para 11, 12, 14 and 22. The case of Laxman
Naskar (Life Convict) v. State of W.B. & Anr., (2000) 7 SCC 626, para
3 as well as the case of Bilkis Yakub Rasool v. Union of India & Ors.,
(2024) 5 SCC 481, para 124, 168, 169 and 170.
19.
It is the contention of the learned AAG that under the
circumstances, reiterating the opinion made by the learned District
Judge, the petitioner is not eligible for grant of remission of his sentence
and is to serve the same till the end of his natural life.
20.
The learned AAG has also referred to the Notification dated
31.01.2025 issued by the Secretary to the Government of Meghalaya,
Department of Prisons & Correctional Services by which the
Government of Meghalaya has notified “The Remission Policy, 2025”
wherein is found the details of the manner and mode of how remission
and pre-mature release of convicts is to be considered. This was done
keeping in mind the relevant directions of the Hon’ble Supreme Court
passed in Suo Moto Writ Petition (Criminal) No. 4 of 2021, titled In Re
Policy Strategy for Grant of Bail, wherein all the States are directed to
frame/modify their policies for grant of remission or additional remission
under Section 473 of the Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita, 2023 or
Section 432 of the Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973, the same is
therefore applicable to the case of the petitioner hererin, further submits
the learned AAG.
21.
Chapter XXXII of the Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973 is
headlined as “Execution, Suspension, Remission and Commutation of
Sentences”. It contains about 24 Sections starting from Section 413 to
435. Part E of the same deals with matters relating to the issue of
2025:MLHC:198
remission of sentence and runs through Section 432 to Section 435.
22.
The fact that this part dealing with remission of sentence is found
in the Code only exhibits the intent of the lawmakers to adopt and apply
the principles of reformation in the criminal jurisprudence of the
Country. Even in a case of conviction for murder, the scope of
reformation is extended, where more often than not, a sentence for
commission of murder carries with it a term of life imprisonment.
23.
In this respect, it would be but proper to look at the relevant
provisions under the Code which provides for the same. Section 432, 433
and 433A being such provisions. To be more precise, relevant to the case
in hand, section 432 (1) (2), 433(b) and 433A are reproduced herein as
follows:
“432. Power to suspend or remit sentences.–(1) When any
person has been sentenced to punishment for an offence, the
appropriate Government may, at any time, without conditions or
upon any conditions which the person sentenced accepts, suspend
the execution of his sentence or remit the whole or any part of the
punishment to which he has been sentenced.
(2) Whenever an application is made to the appropriate
Government for the suspension or remission of a sentence, the
appropriate Government may require the presiding Judge of the
Court before or by which the conviction was had or confirmed, to
state his opinion as to whether the application should be granted
or refused, together with his reasons for such opinion and also to
forward with the statement of such opinion a certified copy of the
record of the trial or of such record thereof as exists.
433. …
b) a sentence of imprisonment for life, for imprisonment for
a term not exceeding fourteen years or for fine;
[433A. Restriction on powers of remission or commutation in
certain cases.–Notwithstanding anything contained in section
432, where a sentence of imprisonment for life is imposed on
2025:MLHC:198
conviction of a person for an offence for which death is one of the
punishments provided by laws, or where a sentence of
imprisonment for life, such person shall not be released from
prison unless he had served at least fourteen years of
imprisonment.]”
24.
Facts as indicated above would show that the petitioner had gone
through the proper process seeking remission of his life sentence to be
remitted for the remaining part of his sentence, inter alia, on the ground
that he has completed more than 14 years of imprisonment. In fact, as on
date, he has crossed 19 years of imprisonment.
25.
Apparently, when the petition of the petitioner was placed before
the relevant State authority, it is presumed that due process was followed
and the opinion of the Presiding Judge of the court before or by which
the conviction was confirmed was sought for in this regard.
26.
The learned District Judge who has rendered such opinion as was
found in the impugned communication dated 14.07.2022 has referred to
the findings of the then learned Trial Judge to say that the manner in
which the crime was committed was brutal and gruesome which is
disturbing, also that there is a possibility that the crime may be repeated
if released on remission and finally that the crime was committed by a
syndicate which is still on the run.
27.
At the outset, what is noticed is that the impugned opinion, dated
14.07.2022 was passed by the learned District Judge, East Khasi Hills in
connection with Sessions Case No. 10 of 2006 under Section
302/382/201 IPC. The Secretary to the Government of Meghalaya,
Department of Prisons & Correctional Services vide his communication
dated 23.09.2022 issued upon the Inspector General of Prisons &
2025:MLHC:198
Correctional Services, Meghalaya while conveying the rejection of the
prayer for remission of sentence on behalf of the two convicts, the
petitioner being one of them, has quoted the opinion of the learned
District Judge (supra) in so doing.
28.
As noticed, what is mandated under Section 432 of the Code is
that the opinion of the presiding judge of the court who had passed the
sentence was required to be obtained. It can only mean the Sessions
Judge, since a criminal case is always taken up by the Sessions Judge in
a sessions triable cases such as the one in question. Even if the judge who
had passed the sentence is no longer available as in the present case, it
would be but proper for the opinion to be sought for or to be given by the
succeeding Sessions Judge of the concerned court. The fact that the
opinion was given by the District Judge, Shillong who has not stated that
he has done so in his capacity as the Sessions Judge, would, in the
considered opinion of this Court render any such opinion given as not
tenable in law. Therefore, the relevant authority while passing the
impugned order dated 23.09.2022 (supra) could not have relied on the
opinion of the District Judge, such impugned order passed was on a
wrong premise.
29.
Be that as it may, another aspect of the matter to be considered
when a case of application for remission of sentence is made is that
certain factors are to be taken into account, which factors form part of
the several guidelines issued by the Supreme Court in related cases, some
of which are found at para 6 of the case of Laxman Naskar (Life Convict)
v. State of W. B. & Anr., reported in (2000) 7 SCC 626, duly reproduced
herein below as:
2025:MLHC:198
“6. This Court also issued certain guidelines as to the basis on
which a convict can be released prematurely and they are as under:
“(i) Whether the offence is an individual act of crime without
affecting the society at large.
(ii) Whether there is any chance of future recurrence of
committing crime.
(iii) Whether the convict lost his potentiality in committing
crime.
(iv) Whether there is any fruitful purpose of confining this
convict any more.
(v) Socio-economic condition of the convict’s family.”
30.
In this regard, it would have been convenient for the relevant
authority to seek the report of the prison authorities to study the case of
the applicant/convict within the parameters of the abovementioned
guidelines. However, there is nothing on record that such a report has
been sought for or that the learned District Judge has taken such
guidelines into consideration while giving his opinion (supra). Instead,
the opinion of the learned District Judge has reflected only the
observations made based on the judgment of the Trial Court passed in
the case, that too, only on the observations that the crime committed was
done so in a brutal manner and furthermore, that there appears to be a
syndicate at work which is still at large, meaning that the
applicant/convict is also part of such syndicate, when no such
observations or findings was ever made by the learned Trial Judge who
has passed the initial judgment. This part of the observation being taken
cognizance of by the relevant authority while considering the petition for
remission has further caused prejudice to the petitioner’s cause.
31.
Even if one study the proposition of law propounded in the many
authorities cited by the parties herein, what is observed in these
judgments is that there is a common pattern of principles set out
2025:MLHC:198
whenever a case of remission of sentence is under examination by the
authorities concerned.
32.
Some of the principles and factors relevant in this regard would
be:
i)
Grant of remission is statutorya) Section 432 Cr.P.C.
b) Bilkis Yakub Rasool v. Union of India & Ors., (2024) 5
SCC 481, para 169
c) Ram Chander v. State of Chhattisgarh and Anr., 2022
SCC Online SC 500, para 21
ii)
Opinion of the presiding judge of the convicting court is
requireda) Section 432(2) Cr.P.C.
b) Ram Chander v. State of Chhattisgarh & Anr., 2022 SCC
Online SC 500, para 21(supra)
c) Bilkis Yakub Rasool v. Union of India & Ors., (2024) 5
SCC 481, para 169 (supra)
iii)
Power of remission cannot be exercised arbitrarily, must
conform to factors that govern the grant of remissiona) Ram Chander v. State of Chhattisgarh & Anr., 2022 SCC
Online SC 500, para 9(viii),
b) Laxman Naskar (Life Convict) v. State of W.B. & Anr.,
(2000) 7 SCC 626, para 6
c) Bilkis Yakub Rasool v. Union of India & Ors., (2024) 5
SCC 481, para 170 (supra)
33.
It must be noted that the Notification dated 31.01.2025, notifying
the State “Remission Policy, 2025” may not be applicable to the case of
2025:MLHC:198
the petitioner herein as the cause of action of this case dates back to the
year 2022 or so, nevertheless, even if an observation of the details of the
said policy of 2025 is made herein, it may be pointed out that the policy
has conformed with the relevant stated statutory provisions and the
methodology adopted when dealing with an application for grant of
remission, includes forwarding of such application by the Superintendent
of Prison to the Department of Prisons & Correctional Services, which
in turn, after scrutinizing as to its correctness and eligibility of the
candidate, will seek the opinion of the Presiding Officer of the
Convicting Court or the Confirming Court who shall render his opinion
with reasons. Thereafter, the matter being placed before the Sentence
Review Committee for the final decision of whether remission is to be
granted or not and the same to be conveyed to the convict in question.
34.
Coming back to the facts and circumstances of this case in hand,
what has been observed hereinabove, is that the authorities concerned
has failed to seek the relevant report of the Superintendent of the Prison
wherein the petitioner was interned and as a result, while seeking the
opinion of the learned District Judge, he has also failed to give his
opinion based on the factors which ought to have been considered, some
of which are found stipulated by the Hon’ble Supreme Court as was done
in the case of Laxman Naskar (supra). This, in turn, has resulted in the
final decision rendered by the authority concerned to reject the prayer of
the petitioner. The premise relied upon is therefore unfounded.
35.
In view of the above observations, this Court holds that the said
impugned opinion and order have been passed without any application
of mind and law and therefore, the case of the petitioner for grant of
2025:MLHC:198
remission is required to be reviewed.
36.
The operation of the impugned order dated 23.09.2022 of the
Secretary to the Government of Meghalaya, Department of Prisons &
Correctional Services as well as the opinion dated 14.07.2022 of the
learned District Judge, East Khasi Hills, Shillong are hereby set aside
and quashed.
37.
Without the necessity of the petitioner having to file a fresh
application, the concerned authorities would take up the same from the
records and reconsider the same following due procedure. This exercise
is preferably to be completed within 45(forty five) days from the date of
communication of this order to the Secretary to the Government of
Meghalaya, Department of Prisons & Correctional Services.
38.
Petition disposed of. No costs.
Judge
TIPRILYNTI KHARKONGOR
Date: 2025.03.24 16:59:20
PDT
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review